News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by jjmarr on Monday February 03, 2025 @12:58PM (#42920913)
> He was consistent and clear when he talked about his identity in California courtrooms as he tried to fight the charges on the grounds that he really was the man whose name he was accused of stealing. But Mr. Woods made other remarks that seemed to amplify the doubts. In court appearances, transcripts show, he would sometimes interrupt the judge, talk about historical figures or assert that he had tried to warn the F.B.I. in advance of the Sept. 11 attacks.

I wonder how many people are telling the truth about something, and aren't taken seriously because they're problematic about something else.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ty6853 on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:35PM (#42921276)
I was once dragged to a hospital by police because they were looking for a drug smuggler that was not me. They told hospital staff I was a druggie criminal with drugs up my ass, as I sat there in cuffs.

It is incredibly hard to overcome such accusation by someone in authority. Nurses cursed me, touched me without consent, and several doctors examined me. They ultimately found nothing, and noted no intoxication, but noted in my medical record that they think i am a smuggler anyway, with no explanation as to why.

I am now in medical debt for a non-existent 'overdose' bill that notes no intoxication...

I imagine as soon as some official person insists the identity isn't yours, just as multiple doctors wouldn't believe despite all evidence to contrary, they won't believe you.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by mobilene on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:42PM (#42921985)
Something similar happened to one of our sons. Unfortunately he has a history of drug use that landed him in legal trouble. The local police recognize him. He had a minor fender bender. The police tested him for alcohol there, clean. But then given history they detained him and took him to the nearest ER for a battery of drug tests -- for which the hospital billed our son, and for which our son is on the hook. It's bonkers.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by freedomben on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:57PM (#42922144)
That's despicable. What a clearly grotesque thing for a cop to be able to do, forcing people to involuntarily spend their own money to accomplish police business. If they want the tests, the least they should do is pay for them!

Mind if I ask what area he lived in?

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by earnestinger on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:23PM (#42924140)
Is this legal? Everything is done by the book?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ty6853 on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:26PM (#42924186)
Yes see Ashley Cervantes v US, nearly identical case to my circumstances and same people but even worse abuse. She lost as doctors were considered acting as non medical pseudo police for the purposes of challenging the care and considered purely medical actors when challenging the police search.

Catch 22 you lose. She was sent bill by same hospital. I contacted her lawyers for my own purposes, they said they'd given up these cases.

https://holdcbpaccountable.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/ce...

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by nickff on Monday February 03, 2025 @06:04PM (#42924633)
Here's the court's decision on the case:

https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.azd.985...

The result wasn't what you're describing. The plaintiff was suing in federal court, with a constitutional cause of action. The defendants argued, and the court decided that the plaintiff has a medical malpractice cause of action in state court, which is appropriate for her to pursue (at least before a federal court will rule in her favor).

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by cornholio on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:46PM (#42924411)
> doctors were considered acting as non medical pseudo police for the purposes of challenging the care

What does that mean? They are either providing the services on behalf of the police, so their pseudo employer needs to pay them, or they are medical professionals providing a care you did not consent to or requested, in which case they should charge the party that requested the services, again, the police.

In both cases, you were not the contractual beneficiary of the services, so you own nothing. The fact that your blood and orifices are involved is purely incidental, any evidence resulting from this unnecessary medical act can only be used against you, so you would have no reason to want it.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by mindslight on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:56PM (#42924542)
What are the actual legal theories by which they're trying (/succeeding) at enforcing these bills? Anybody can send anybody a bill for anything, that does not mean it is valid or legally enforceable.

In general I find discussions of this topic very frustrating because everybody stops short of visiting the if and how of the fraudulent bills actually having an effect. I can certainly believe there are corrupt or dubious ways they get collected on, but those mechanisms need to be focused on and then eliminated as an obvious first step of healthcare reform.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by throwway120385 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @09:53AM (#42933093)
Usually the hospital has you sign something during intake that says "I acknowledge that if the insurance fails to pay this bill then I am the final guarantor." And so without that signed documentation the detainee shouldn't be on the hook for the bill. So asking the hospital to present your signature on that document or escalating until someone can provide that or indicate that they don't have it should be enough. This is a situation where personal legal insurance might be beneficial because for about $30 a month you get a law office you can call and ask questions, for example about the legality of the local hospital's billing practices for detainees.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ty6853 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @11:17AM (#42934356)
Yes I refused to sign anything so they just send it to a carousel of debt collectors who give up with resistance but then resell it to someone else whom hasn't received a cease and desist yet, then I must start over fighting it. This happens roughly annually for several years now.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by fc417fc802 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @02:38PM (#42937483)
> resell it to someone else whom hasn't received a cease and desist yet

I wonder if you could sue them for that? Reselling a debt that they know is invalid.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by mindslight on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @12:58PM (#42936111)
The thing they have you sign is a single-party "consent" and not a two-party "contract", implying it's merely informing you about what they are able to do to you, rather than asking you to assent to a purportedly mutual agreement.

I cross out all that unilateral nonsense about being financially responsible (as well as other types of nonsense), and have never been balked at. Worst case is these days when they ask me to sign a contextless touchpad, and then they roll their eyes like it's some big imposition when I ask for a hard copy instead so I can "review".

So I don't think that paperwork is directly involved with how the medical industry has come to run on billing fraud shakedowns. Hence asking for actual mechanics / outcomes of what happens when people are "sent a bill" and don't do the implied thing of just paying it.

Also, have you ever talked to an attorney - especially asking them preemptive or against-the-status-quo questions? In my experience they generally tell you to just go with the flow. If they advise you to do anything else and it blows up, then they themselves could be on the hook.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by potato3732842 on Monday February 03, 2025 @06:48PM (#42925076)
It lives in one of those grey areas of "nobody has been murdered over it brutally enough to make national news so it persists" just like all the other abuse the police do. At least they don't suffocate people as much anymore...
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by wongarsu on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:25PM (#42924176)
It's pretty bizarre. Surely if spending money is free speech as per Citizens United, then the right to remain silent also includes the right not to spend money on an investigation against yourself.

Apart from all the other common sense reasons why this is absurd

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by 34679 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @10:03AM (#42933203)
Ah, but you not only have the right to remain silent- since a 2013 supreme Court ruling, you also have to know that you have the right to remain silent, and you have to say that you know and that you wish to remain silent.

https://reason.com/2013/06/17/supreme-court-rules-fifth-amen...

>In a 5-4 decision the Supreme Court ruled today that a potential defendant's silence can be used against him if he is being interviewed by police but is not arrested (and read his Miranda rights) and has not verbally invoked the protection of the Fifth Amendment.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by potato3732842 on Monday February 03, 2025 @06:46PM (#42925061)
What do you think the cops do all day?

Handing out civil infractions is basically the same thing but without the unnecessary extra party and steps.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by FireBeyond on Monday February 03, 2025 @03:29PM (#42922607)
One day I got a call at work from my (now previous) partner. "What's up?" "You need to come home, we need to talk."

I duly do.

"So I went to the doctor earlier today. Had an issue. They swabbed me and told me I have an STD. So they did a full STD and blood test, we'll see how that goes. In the meantime, who did you cheat on me with?"

"Uh, nobody."

Back and forth, arguing, etc. Me insisting I'll go get tested.

The doctor rings back the next day. "We reviewed and looked again under the scope, and you do not have an STD, just a yeast infection."

Relationship relief.

A month later, get a call from the clinic: "So about this bill for $290 for a full workup and testing, can you pay that today?"

No. Not a chance. You not only misread a test, but you also gave my girlfriend factually inaccurate information that you knew was going to be controversial. On the strength of that, you told her, "If it wasn't you, you really need to get fully tested if you don't know where he's been."

And then you want to send me the bill for the battery of tests you ordered because you misread a culture? No.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by giantg2 on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:14PM (#42924023)
Did they actually waive it then?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by thaumasiotes on Monday February 03, 2025 @09:40PM (#42927011)
Doesn't matter. It's not like they can make you pay.

I refused to pay for medical "services" I never asked for. They sent the debt to collections. Collections had no argument other than that they would really like it if I paid. My credit score was unaffected.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by gwd on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @06:52AM (#42931205)
This is what confuses me about so many of these "horror stories" about cancelling things like gym memberships or NYT subscriptions. You can't just say to someone "you owe me X because my policy says you do". You only owe someone something if you are legally or morally obliged to do so, and there are certainly lots of cases where (it seems to me) you are neither.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by OptionOfT on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:21PM (#42924127)
I'm surprised the police doesn't have to pay for them. It's not that the tests were medically necessary.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by potato3732842 on Monday February 03, 2025 @06:45PM (#42925055)
Nobody has gotten their life ruined enough over it to go postal in a hospital so it's in hospital's interests to keep playing along.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ty6853 on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:30PM (#42924222)
In my case they tried to bill the federal government first, they then denied the claim and put me as the guarantor instead.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by account-5 on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:45PM (#42924404)
I'm assuming you and the son of the other commenter are US citizens? Quite frankly the way the US operated on most things absolutely baffles me. In the UK were the same thing to happen to you the police would be paying the bill, but obviously we have the NHS so it actually pays. The NHS might be broken but I am thankful every time I hear an American health story!
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by DFHippie on Monday February 03, 2025 @08:19PM (#42926127)
I sometimes think the US exists as a cautionary tale. We suck so you don't have to!
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by cscurmudgeon on Monday February 03, 2025 @10:52PM (#42927664)
But somehow you can use us as the world’s ATM!

https://www.statista.com/statistics/275597/largers-donor-cou...

Imagine a fraction of that going back to citizens!

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ssalazar on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @12:10AM (#42928279)
You dont have to imagine! Thats less than a sixth of a percent of the entire US federal budget :)
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by eru on Monday February 03, 2025 @11:44PM (#42928080)
> Imagine a fraction of that going back to citizens!

You know that US citizens mostly donate to charities that help other US citizens?

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by mpweiher on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @03:19AM (#42929617)
Hmm...there are other countries on that list...who spend more relative to their GDP. So not exactly "the world's ATM".

And of course the rest of the world finances the US economy and US debt by virtue of the US dollar being both the currency of international trade and reserve currency. And it is reserve currency by virtue of being the currency of international trade.

That is a far, far greater monetary value than the aid given out.

Which you can also tell by what happens to you if you start to use another currency for trade. "Would you like some regime change to go with that?" Or how the US fights the Euro tooth and nail, including sabotage.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by mywacaday on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:09AM (#42931340)
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by eru on Monday February 03, 2025 @11:46PM (#42928093)
Well, the NHS might be better than what the US has, but that doesn't mean it's good.

So Britain as a whole spends roughly half (in terms of percentage of GDP) on healthcare as the US. That includes both public and private expenditure. At similar health outcomes.

Now Singapore spends roughly half of what Britain spends (in terms of percentage of GDP), and our population is no worse off for it.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by cma on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:19AM (#42930127)
You can also get cheap dental and haircuts in Mexico: what's Singapore's purchasing power parity compared to the UK? Maybe not an extreme difference since Singapore has has such a high GDP or even worse, but if it is more that can explain a lot even for advanced services.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by eru on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @08:46AM (#42932239)
Purchasing power parity depends a lot on what basket you compare.

Eg owning a car or cigarettes are very expensive here. But eating out starts much cheaper than in the UK. (There's no upper limit in either place, of course.)

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by supermatt on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @08:39AM (#42932161)
The GDP per capita in Singapore is roughly double that of the UK, so health spending per capita is similar. I cant find latest figures, but it seems it is somewhere around 20% higher spend in UK.

On the other hand, there are EU countries such as lithuania and estonia, that spend less than half per capita of Singapore, and are ranked with a higher healthcare index.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by eru on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @08:45AM (#42932226)
Depends on how you measure. Lots of health spending is labour costs, and our labour costs are higher. So percentage of GDP relatively closely tracks percentage of total working time.

Also perhaps our more enlightened policies are helping us achieve that higher per capita GDP?

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by supermatt on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @09:02AM (#42932436)
Well, im not measuring anything. Im just saying that the spend per capita is mostly equivalent for Singapore and UK.

No idea why you are equating enlightenment to per-capita GDP. I don’t quite understand that equation. Singapore may have a high per capita GDP, but that isn't resulting in a higher median individual incomes. Given the extremely high cost of living, the purchasing power of an average Singaporean is actually comparable to that of someone in the less affluent EU countries that have 1/4 of the GDP per capita and equivalent (or better!) healthcare. So while the GDP figure looks impressive, it doesn’t fully reflect the financial reality for most residents. Is that your "enlightened policies" at work?

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by jeeeb on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @10:48PM (#42943488)
> Also perhaps our more enlightened policies are helping us achieve that higher per capita GDP?

Singapore’s GDP per-capita is likely fairly inflated as it doesn’t correct for the effect of multinational tax planning by large corporations on the GDP statistics , unlike say Ireland.

See: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_gross_national_inco...

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by eru on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @12:23AM (#42944187)
Yes, though we are also doing pretty well in terms of eg wages, not just GDP.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by amiga386 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @09:04AM (#42932456)
You need to look at PPP-adjusted per-capita stats, and also accept that there are limitations in a simple measure of "health outcomes" (e.g. average life expectancy)

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/life-expectancy-vs-health...

What you can see though, is a cluster that vaguely fits "spend more, better life expectancy", with two outliers:

1. The USA, massively outspending every other country, but having same life expectancy as China spending a tenth of what it does

2. South Africa, spending roughly as much as Mexico or Columbia, but 10 years less life expectancy. I suspect it needs more targeted spending with its HIV crisis, rather than measuring average spend vs average life expectancy

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by myrmidon on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @09:43AM (#42932936)
Another thing to consider about South Africa is that wealth inequality is insanely high; it seems very plausible to me that most money is spent on like the rich 30% of population, and the majority of the country is basically on Namibian levels of care.

Public healthcare expenditure is also likely to be wasteful; governmental corruption and languishing infrastructure is a comparatively big problem there (compare power infrastructure, rail network, postal service), so the pure dollar value spent on healthcare is systematically off.

Thanks for the link btw-- I would not have expected such a clear trend in this, especially given how noisy metrics like life expectancy are; very interesting.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by randerson on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @09:25AM (#42932708)
South Africa's poor life expectancy is more a function of poverty, violence, and HIV, than anything to do with their healthcare system.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by eru on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @12:23AM (#42944177)
Interestingly, if you plot disposable income against healthcare spending, the US falls squarely on the trend line.

See https://www.econlib.org/is-the-us-an-outlier-on-health-care-... for a discussion.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ashoeafoot on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:53PM (#42924510)
There must be a whole bootleg health system by now in the shadows , that is single payer and non-hostile/helping. Wait till the debtdoctor passes then go to the real one in some back alley .
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by astrange on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:58PM (#42924569)
"Single payer" means the government pays it. Hard to do in a back alley.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Ajedi32 on Monday February 03, 2025 @09:43PM (#42927032)
Are you actually legally on the hook to pay? Or are they just going after you because they think they have a better chance of getting you to pay than the government?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by anon7000 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @03:17AM (#42929595)
This is why we need constitutional amendments to make the police better. I mean there’s shit like this, and then asset forfeiture (legalized theft). Shit like this should be non-partisan.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by hwillis on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @10:17AM (#42933381)
> After being chased by police for stealing clothing from a Walmart, Seacat barricaded himself in a house at 4219 South Alton Street in Greenwood Village, Colorado. By the time Seacat was finally extracted from the premises, the house had been destroyed by law enforcement in their efforts to flush him out. The homeowner—Leo Lech—filed a lawsuit against the municipality for compensation, but was ruled against by the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit; he appealed to the Supreme Court of the United States, but the court declined to hear the case.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrest_of_Robert_Seacat

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Ajedi32 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @11:21AM (#42934408)
That's a different situation, because at least there it could be argued the damage was ultimately Seacat's fault for engaging in a shoot out with law enforcement on someone else's private property; the police were just doing their job apprehending an armed suspect. With a drug test that comes back negative, the person being tested clearly isn't at fault.

That said, I think it does probably make sense for there to be some sort of financial incentive for police to not create more collateral damage than necessary. Like maybe the damages should come out of the department budget initially and then they could get a judge to decide how much of that was the suspect's fault and recover that amount from them, assuming they can pay? Policing is a social service and I don't think externalizing the costs of social services onto innocent bystanders is a good idea; it makes the agency less accountable for the monetary costs they incur if those costs aren't tracked as part of their budget, and it's bad PR.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by hwillis on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @12:17PM (#42935475)
> At 10:38 pm, SWAT entered the house and used a stun grenade to conceal their movements, but were driven back outside by gunshots (though criminalists would later establish that they were not fired upon). During the next 10.2 hours, a Lenco BearCat was driven through the front door, tear gas and 40 mm grenades were repeatedly launched inside, shots were fired upon the house, and explosives were detonated to destroy several exterior walls.

Whether or not police have any imperative to consider the impact of their actions, this situation was clear incompetence and reckless destruction. They're just as much doing their job by forcing drug tests on random people. The person may not have been on drugs, but all police would have to do is say they saw "erratic behavior".

> Like maybe the damages should come out of the department budget initially and then they could get a judge to decide how much of that was the suspect's fault and recover that amount from them, assuming they can pay?

This is just a different bad incentive; it incentivizes police to completely ignore situations or to find someone to hold accountable. Just extend the logic to the other expenses of an investigation- hourly pay, overtime, materials, forensics. Making a criminal pay for their own arrest is a terrible idea.

Police should pay for all the drug tests they demand, and for all the damages incurred in the process of investigating or arresting a suspect. Those things are not related to the crime itself, like a fine is. They are part of the cost of investigation and operation.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Ajedi32 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @12:43PM (#42935873)
> This is just a different bad incentive; it incentivizes police to completely ignore situations

If the societal cost of enforcement exceeds the societal cost of non-enforcement, then perhaps they should ignore the situation.

> or to find someone to hold accountable

This is why it would have to be decided by a judge as part of sentencing. If they're actually accountable then why shouldn't they be held to that?

> Just extend the logic to the other expenses of an investigation- hourly pay, overtime, materials, forensics. Making a criminal pay for their own arrest is a terrible idea.

I don't necessarily disagree, but just to play devil's advocate: why? It's their fault the public had to spend money on this, so why shouldn't they pay for it? (One argument I can think of is that for small crimes the cost of enforcement may greatly exceed the bounds of reasonable punishment for the offense, but what about when that's not the case?)

> Those things are not related to the crime itself

I'd argue exchanging gunfire with police is definitely a big part of the crime committed in this case. The shoplifting that started the encounter is practically irrelevant compared to that.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by fc417fc802 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @02:30PM (#42937386)
Broadly agree with you and would like to add that if in this particular case the department had expected to foot the bill for their destruction I imagine they would have readily found a slower but cheaper approach. They went with the fast, expedient, and above all exciting (for them) approach precisely because they knew they wouldn't be the ones paying for the aftermath.

> It's their fault the public had to spend money on this, so why shouldn't they pay for it?

How about transparency and uniform enforcement of the law? Fines should be formally codified, not implicit and variable depending on incidentals internal to that particular investigation. The legislature is always free to direct those proceeds wherever they would like.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by hwillis on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @01:43PM (#42953177)
> > or to find someone to hold accountable > This is why it would have to be decided by a judge as part of sentencing. If they're actually accountable then why shouldn't they be held to that?

I am more insinuating that it will lead to much more falsified evidence- something that is already a problem even while completely shielding them from consequences.

> why? It's their fault the public had to spend money on this, so why shouldn't they pay for it?

Because that isn't really accountability, practically speaking. The department funding is very distantly coupled to personal impact. When a division of a company does badly, they don't cut its funding as a form of incentive or punishment. Individual performance is done through the system of management and personal incentive. You don't want to fund the police based on how many crimes they solve- you do it based on how much crime exists. Likewise you shouldn't cut funding for bad policing- it's something that can also just be actively managed instead of simplified to a budgetary concern.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by xvokcarts on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @12:29PM (#42935646)
The same wiki article also describes the absurdness of the whole thing:

> At 10:38 pm, SWAT entered the house and used a stun grenade to conceal their movements [...] During the next 10.2 hours, a Lenco BearCat was driven through the front door, tear gas[1] and 40 mm grenades were repeatedly launched inside, shots were fired upon the house, and explosives were detonated to destroy several exterior walls.

Just amazing multiple people (the authorities) were present and none of them stopped to think "gee, that house is somebody's home".

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by fasa99 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @03:25PM (#42938096)
>I'm surprised the police doesn't have to pay for them. It's not that the tests were medically necessary. If only it were so simple. Medicine can be quite nasty politically at times, internally and externally, and these mandatory examinations are the currency of really screwing someone if that's what you want. Psych especially, part of the theme of the original catch-22 book.

A lot of the laws are at first pass related to psych - "harm to self or others". That earns you a free non-voluntary trip to the hospital. The part where it gets nasty is when words get twisted, when ulterior motives exist, when the accuser possesses some authority - such that an "unsafe to self or others" argument is put forth. Situations where the person needs help, but perhaps won't seek it out on their own, thus the state must intervene. In this narrative, our police officers said, "harm to self, drugs in digestive tract, may rupture and cause death, not willing to seek medical care for fear of losing drug transport and/or prosecution, please treat so they don't rupture"

The victim of such a crime now has a choice - pay a bunch of money to the hospital to clear the bill, or pay a bunch of money to a lawyer to get the police to pony up responsibility. It's happened to me too along the lines of "the government made big mistake and caused problems for you, you can take ownership of the false accusations, or pay a bunch of money to a lawyer to have them wiped". Often in our society there's the suffering of being a victim, then the victim tax on top of that

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by prawn on Monday February 03, 2025 @07:48PM (#42925780)
I read the piece on your blog viewing your life story from various perspectives. This story about your son seems a good example of those facets for him; in this case, the hospital situation piling on top of existing challenges. What a scam. Best of luck to both of you.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by justinclift on Monday February 03, 2025 @09:50PM (#42927110)
"America! Fuck Yeah!"
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Egret on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @03:59PM (#42938587)
In medicine, for minor procedures such as blood tests or ECG, there is the notion of implied consent. Just holding out your arm for the blood test is implied consent. To refuse, you might say, I am of sound mind and I do not consent to this procedure. Or, you are performing this procedure without my consent and against my wishes. I'm not a lawyer,and not in the US, but this is how it generally operates for practical reasons. Written informed consent is required for more invasive or significant procedures.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by mlinhares on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:42PM (#42921343)
Being skeptical about authority figures is always a good thing, it always surprise me to see populations so deferent to them like americans are to law enforcement.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by nadermx on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:06PM (#42921606)
Law enforcement in the US has a license to kill with paid leave after. The fear that instills in an entire populace is chilling.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by cm2012 on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:23PM (#42921769)
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by pjc50 on Monday February 03, 2025 @03:37PM (#42922729)
Yes, because they assume that the license to kill with paid leave will be used against someone they don't like. It's a real "fix your hearts" situation. Watch this play out in the current fiasco with USAID.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ranger_danger on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @03:58PM (#42938571)
And I think in the vast majority of cases, it's only used against actual criminals. You only hear about these sensationalized cases because it's out of the ordinary and not at all common.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by redleggedfrog on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:30PM (#42921842)
1 in 5 Americans don't like the police.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by thatcat on Monday February 03, 2025 @03:39PM (#42922758)
Propaganda is effective
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by potato3732842 on Monday February 03, 2025 @06:55PM (#42925158)
What were the demographics and what exact questions were they asked?

Because I don't see any way to get those numbers unless you basically just survey old people.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by cm2012 on Monday February 03, 2025 @07:02PM (#42925233)
These numbers are consistent across many surveys and research. Consider the fact that you may be in an information bubble.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by lmm on Monday February 03, 2025 @07:44PM (#42925745)
> consistent across many surveys and research

Sure, but there's a huge systematic bias in how a lot of surveys and research are carried out. If everyone is sampling from e.g. people who answer a phone call, their results will be consistent but hugely biased.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by mlinhares on Monday February 03, 2025 @09:58PM (#42927196)
You haven't been to a sports even in the US right?

The general population in the US is very much in favor of law enforcement and the more "end of the world" news they consume the more they think there should be MORE law enforcement and they should have even more power.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by lmm on Monday February 03, 2025 @11:40PM (#42928049)
> You haven't been to a sports even in the US right?

I have, as it happens. But many people never do; the people who go to sports games might be a similar group to the people who answer phone calls, but they're not a representative sample of the whole population by any means.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by potato3732842 on Monday February 03, 2025 @06:52PM (#42925115)
Law enforcement literally everywhere has a license to kill. They dress it up with a bunch of process to keep it from getting used on a whim but that is literally the point of law enforcement, to kill you if you don't comply with the will of the state as enforced through them.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by asdasdsddd on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:10PM (#42921631)
This is also the attitude that makes every dumbass think they are above the law.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by mlinhares on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @10:31AM (#42933625)
The law and law enforcement employees are not the same.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by freehorse on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:15PM (#42921686)
For people from most places outside the US, I bet such stories from US's medical system sound totally crazy. It is crazy for a medical system to function like this charging somebody for being involuntarily treated, and even more for no medical cause.

What would have happened, to the hospital's part, if they had declared that you were not intoxicated and you should not have been brought to the hospital, and sent you on your way? Would the police have had to justify dragging you to the hospital, and pay for your examination? I suspect that going along with the police may have been the decision with the simplest and most profitable outcome for everybody (apart from you) and that the hospital side was incetivised to go along with police's story rather than against, but I am not sure how things there typically work in such cases.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by DebtDeflation on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:31PM (#42921855)
There was a highly publicized case a few years back where the police entered a hospital and ordered a nurse to draw a blood sample for an unconscious patient who had been in a car accident. They had no warrant and she refused per hospital policy (and law). The cops roughed her up pretty bad and arrested her.

https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/11/01/561337106...

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by FireBeyond on Monday February 03, 2025 @03:31PM (#42922634)
Also good to point out that the reason they -rushed- to the hospital to do this was that the person who had hit them was an off-duty cop who was drunk and had run a red light, and they were looking for something, anything, to pin on this guy instead as being responsible, rather than the cop.

Said unconscious patient later died, if I recall correctly, too.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Schiendelman on Monday February 03, 2025 @08:06PM (#42925973)
Abuse of state power is the one thing I think we should keep the death penalty for. Police who use their power like that should hang.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by saagarjha on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:27AM (#42930181)
You think we should combat abuse of state power…with a power that is really easy for the state to abuse?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by BeFlatXIII on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:06AM (#42931312)
It would only apply to agents of the state. Live by the sword and all that.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by red-iron-pine on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @10:40AM (#42933770)
so now the people wielding all the power are risking death? sounds like an even more powerful incentive to cover stuff up extra hard and shoot all witnesses, etc.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Schiendelman on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @11:21AM (#42934409)
This sounds a little "reductio ad absurdum" - "we can't stop anyone from doing anything".
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by BeFlatXIII on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @11:46AM (#42951239)
"You come at the king, you'd best not miss" and all.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Schiendelman on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @09:53AM (#42933092)
Take that to the next level. What are you worried about, and how would you combat it?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ty6853 on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:44PM (#42922001)
What they ended up doing was getting a warrant AFTER the fact, then the smartest of the doctors waited to sign his chart until after that. Right after I was served the warrant I was released, that was the culpability they needed to save their asses.

The nursing board then used the warrants signed AFTER the nurses charts to shield nurses from my malpractice complaints. The board argued essentially nurses are performing a police search if told to execute a search, thus it's nonmedical search. However if you challenge the police, they argue it is medical care not a police search thus you can't challenge that angle either.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by snailmailstare on Monday February 03, 2025 @04:50PM (#42923700)
You should probably still try to sue each medical practitioner individually. Even in the 1980s, a doctor wouldn't interfere with something like preventing a mule from private lavatory use. If a new generation is dumb, there's only one recourse offered for fixing them.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ty6853 on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:20PM (#42924112)
Yes Ashley Cervantes, who was finger raped by doctors at the same hospital as me by the same CBP did that.

She lost as judges ruled doctors basically become deputized and are non medical unofficial police when directed to a warrantless search.

https://holdcbpaccountable.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/ce...

Lawyers involved told me they'd given up and wouldn't take my case. The trouble is it is medical when you challenge the police search, and nonmedical when you challenge the medical care. The judges and police created a catch 22.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by abtinf on Monday February 03, 2025 @06:27PM (#42924869)
You might consider contacting the Institute for Justice, which specializes in pro bono cases like yours.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by snailmailstare on Monday February 03, 2025 @06:10PM (#42924694)
Ah, wow, sometimes I forget why I won't even visit that 'country'.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by seethedeaduu on Monday February 03, 2025 @04:04PM (#42923104)
I live in a country in the EU where conversion therapy is illegal. One of my trans friends was involuntarily admitted to a psychiatric hospital, got emotionally and physically abused (no food, tied to bed), was forced into the male wing of the institute despite being legally a female and had "conversion therapy" performed on her against her will.

It's no secret that lgbt people and prisoners are being mistreated by medical professionals globally.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by unification_fan on Monday February 03, 2025 @03:03PM (#42922228)
How are people surprised that Luigi Mangione is considered a hero?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by BizarroLand on Monday February 03, 2025 @03:27PM (#42922574)
You should talk to a no fee lawyer or three. Financial & Emotional damages can help assuage the anger you have.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ty6853 on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:23PM (#42924145)
A stronger more egregious nearly identical case was lost against the same people a few years before so lawyers weren't interested.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by BizarroLand on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @12:48PM (#42935953)
Did you talk to more than 1 lawyer?

Also, try finding the lawyers that ran the previous case. They may be itching for round 2.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by cactusplant7374 on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:57PM (#42921502)
They can force you to pay when you don't consent to treatment?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by hansvm on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:18PM (#42921714)
They try. Success rates vary, but most people can't afford to fight it even when they're right.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by heavyset_go on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:24PM (#42921778)
Yes
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by rokhayakebe on Monday February 03, 2025 @07:37PM (#42925657)
Can you sue?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by debuggerpk on Monday February 03, 2025 @08:08PM (#42926005)
why didn't you sue?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by IncreasePosts on Monday February 03, 2025 @08:45PM (#42926415)
Because there's probably a lot more to the story, and all the details that have not been provided probably make OP look worse and the police/hospital staff look better.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by seethedeaduu on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @01:48AM (#42928935)
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by banga on Monday February 03, 2025 @08:58PM (#42926544)
Authority bias is very real, very problematic, and very well documented. As a consequence, those in authority must always be held to a high standard. Always doubt an assertion by authority unless accompanied with sufficient evidence.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by jb1991 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:43AM (#42930740)
Good Lord that’s terrible, what country did this happen in?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by BeFlatXIII on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:02AM (#42931282)
I hope you never pay it and shoot anyone who tries to collect that debt.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by fullstop on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @08:57AM (#42932365)
Wow, it's like if the movie Brazil was a documentary.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by bragr on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:31PM (#42921238)
I have a cousin who is paranoid schizophrenic. He makes all kinds of wild claims about all sorts of things: family abuse, screwed over by employers/landlords, beaten up by the police for no reason, the people living in the crawl space are poisoning him, etc, etc... Many of them are provably false e.g. those family members didn't live there at the time of the allegation, the body cam clearly shows him charging the police and then trying to grab their guns while they try to wrestle him into handcuffs, nobody in the crawl space, etc. The problem is that it'd take a full time detective to track down all his various claims. It's very sad that as a vulnerable person he probably is sometimes taken advantage of by people, but at the same time he's never been compliant with medicine and therapy for more than a couple months at a time, despite extensive support. It's kind of a no win situation.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by 542354234235 on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:50PM (#42921422)
It is a weird twist on the fairy tale. What if you had a medical condition that compelled you to cry “Wolf” all the time? Obviously the townsfolk can’t spend all their time responding to false wolf sightings, but there is no lessoned to be learned when The Boy actually believes he sees a wolf every day.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by gunian on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:20PM (#42921734)
the guy from that story was lucky they even responded once
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by asveikau on Monday February 03, 2025 @03:03PM (#42922230)
I have been close to multiple people who made similar paranoid allegations while psychotic. It is sometimes hard for people to understand the allegations are false or part of an illness. This can include judges and mental health professionals.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by RobotToaster on Monday February 03, 2025 @04:01PM (#42923049)
Shouldn't he be on a long acting injection?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by bragr on Monday February 03, 2025 @04:44PM (#42923624)
He was for a while. It was partially successful at controlling his issues, but after a while he stopped coming to the door when social services came around each month to give him his injection. Social Services doesn't have the ability to bust down your door and inject you against your will.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by skissane on Monday February 03, 2025 @09:06PM (#42926647)
Someone I know who has a psychotic illness was telling people “my dad is having an affair”. And people didn’t believe her because they just assumed it was another one of her delusions

Then guess what we find out a few months later? Yep, her father really is having an affair, and her mother has just discovered it and is now filing for divorce over it

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by garciasn on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:56PM (#42921487)
This is how divorce goes now based on my experience. The legal system is not setup to handle these sorts of problems well and leaves the innocent to deal with the fall out of bad actors and lawyers who empower them.

This won’t be corrected until there are penalties for political, legal, and administrative professionals who don’t do their due diligence.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by kylebenzle on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:23PM (#42921766)
Yes! This is divorce in America right now, if one party is willing to make up a series of lies, no matter how unbelievable the court will just default to the one making the accusations because its too much work to even try to sort out truth from lie, thats why the lawyers call it, "Liars Court" because the biggest liar wins.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by giantg2 on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:22PM (#42924138)
Even many of the lawyers encourage it with stuff like suggesting filing baseless protection orders.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by latency-guy2 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @02:45AM (#42929359)
The standard for the judicial is not "the truth", its about what you can "prove".

Judicial cannot claim one party is lying or not, in fact it is impossible, given the fact its nearly always a "he said she said" deal (in this particular scenario). Quite literally, the judge was't there, lawyers weren't there either and they get a twisted version of truth no matter if they are prosecuting or defense.

It sucks, fully agreed, but there is no way around it. As long as the judgement is not too punitive is about the best you can hope for.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by CPLX on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @10:22AM (#42933457)
> The standard for the judicial is not "the truth", its about what you can "prove".

It's not though. Completely unprovable allegations by a single person have real consequences. That's just the way the system works.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by kylebenzle on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @02:41PM (#42937524)
Exactly, the lawyers will encourage their client to make a false claim, use it for leverage then drop the accusation with no recourse for the accused.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by giantg2 on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:21PM (#42924125)
This is in most small civil law areas and even summary criminal cases. They simply aren't important enough for the people in power to do their due diligence or give a shit. Nobody can force them to do their jobs either.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by thih9 on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:32PM (#42921247)
> or assert that he had tried to warn the F.B.I. in advance of the Sept. 11 attacks

That’s a very long shot but I now want someone to verify this claim too, in case he was also telling the truth.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by ykonstant on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:51PM (#42924477)
Imagine if some member of the bin Laden family was high on something and had rumors of their cousin's shenanigans and were spilling them out on some IRC channel or BBS or whatever, and that guy happened upon them and tried to alert the police, only to be dismissed as a lunatic and end up in prison for unrelated reasons while the disaster happened. That would be a true Kafkian nightmare.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by RobotToaster on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:30PM (#42921216)
Just because you're crazy doesn't mean you're wrong.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by mchannon on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:56PM (#42921486)
The contrapositive of which is just because you’re right does not mean you are not crazy.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by LoganDark on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:20PM (#42921732)
I was crazy once. Actually, maybe multiple times. Weirdly, whenever I'm not crazy I think I want to be crazy, and whenever I am crazy I just want it to stop. "I didn't ask for that crazy, I wanted a different crazy!!!"
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Alive-in-2025 on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:38PM (#42921947)
Can you explain. Like maybe you have a condition that causes some psychological challenges and then you get better and it goes away for a while? That would be horrible.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by LoganDark on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @01:16AM (#42928713)
I don't know if I have any actual condition. I probably have maybe 5 mental disorders but I don't think any of them cause actual crazy just on their own. Usually my crazy is induced by staying awake for unhealthy lengths of time. I think last time this happened I joked about being schizophrenic because I kept hearing things in silence and being incredibly agitated/panicked about it. I probably said the exact quote "I didn't want that schizophrenia I wanted a different schizophrenia!!!!" since sometimes I wonder what it would be like to actually be schizophrenic. (I wonder this about so many things, though generally people tell me that wondering this is not normal)
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by lylejantzi3rd on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:05PM (#42920990)
"I wonder how many people are telling the truth about something, and aren't taken seriously because they're problematic about something else."

Isn't that everybody now? Credibility is a strange thing in the age of social media.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by orwin on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:52PM (#42922101)
No, i don't think so. I have an older friend that is persuaded to have seen something most people don't believe in back in the 90s. He just won't claim it publicly, and don't talk about it all the time, it's not a core part of his personality. Even if some people make fun of him for it (i don't think it happen nowadays, but it might), they can, and probably will believe him on other subjects (he is a very precise and knowledgeable in electronics, and have really interesting philosophical point of views).
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by add-sub-mul-div on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:15PM (#42921097)
Evaluating things people say in the context of their general credibility and character is pretty evergreen.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by heavyset_go on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:28PM (#42921819)
This is just the system getting rid of (in their eyes) an undesirable. The truth doesn't really matter in these cases unless you have tens of thousands of dollars to hire a lawyer to plead your case.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by daseiner1 on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:08PM (#42921020)
“problematic” being a rather charitable term here, I think
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by drawkward on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:18PM (#42921123)
What word would you use?
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by contravariant on Monday February 03, 2025 @01:31PM (#42921228)
Sounds schizophrenic at this stage.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by daseiner1 on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:03PM (#42921570)
In contemporary parlance, “problematic” connotes to me that said individual expresses ideas, in their words, speech, or way of life, that are anathema to the dominant paradigm of thought/manners/civility, but does not necessarily imply anything about the mental health of the related individual.

Disordered thinking of the quality you’ve described is indicative of a serious psychological unwellness that, as the other commenter suggested, suggests paranoid schizophrenia or a related form of psychosis. But I don’t intend to seriously engage in back-of-envelope psychologizing.

Prattling on about irrelevant history and insinuating 9/11 conspiracy theories in a courtroom not at all concerned with either of those items does harm credibility, and I think rightfully.

For reasons of both family and personal history I am genuinely sensitive to the phenomenon of the “deemed crazy” person being consigned to permanent non-consideration of their words and expressions, their concerns, but I also recognize that such legitimate unwellness poses genuine issues for the believability of anything they claim.

Putting my extended aside aside, I would phrase it as “how many people are telling the truth about something, but aren't taken seriously because they're severely psychologically disregulated generally.”

It’s not necessarily outrageous for me to assert that I warned the FBI about 9/11 in June 2000. It seriously harms my credibility if I decide to bring up this grievance when I’m speaking to a judge about my undeserved traffic ticket in October 2024.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Workaccount2 on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:19PM (#42921721)
I wonder the same but I also firmly believe it's a useless and unproductive thing to worry about.

I mean, I wonder how many gold coins are laying in the forest? Surely there are many, and you can find ample news stories of people locating them out there, but I can confidently tell you that if you assembled a team an combed the forest for a year, maybe you would find one object worthy of a news story. And definitely you would wasted thousands of man hours that could have produced far far far more than what the object is worth.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by fwip on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:24PM (#42921772)
Is it? There's a sibling comment to yours about somebody who went through this - seems like the rate is higher than the "gold coin in the woods."
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Workaccount2 on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:43PM (#42921993)
I'm surprised there is only one. There are thousands, perhaps tens of thousands of people who view posts on here.

If I searched ten thousand forests, I'd be hopeful for more than a single coin.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by robertlagrant on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @08:46AM (#42932243)
You seem to have switched what you're saying to "it's not many gold coins in one forest; it's at least one gold coin in many forests".

Or rather, you now seem to think it's pretty likely that lots of people have this happen to them.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Workaccount2 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @10:13AM (#42933312)
In absolute terms, it happens to many people.

In practical terms, it happens to virtually no one.

Hundreds of people win $10,000+ in the lottery every month. That is a lot of people. You can post a thread and will likely get comments from those who have won before.

But as a percentage of the population, virtually no one wins big in the lottery.

If you are foolish and think social media accurately portrays reality, you might quit your job to play the lottery full time - because hey, look at all the winners in the comments.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by Almondsetat on Monday February 03, 2025 @05:13PM (#42924009)
>I wonder how many people are telling the truth about something, and aren't taken seriously because they're problematic about something else.

(Un)fortunately, there is a quite famous experiment

>The Rosenhan experiment or Thud experiment was an experiment regarding the validity of psychiatric diagnosis. For the experiment, participants submitted themselves for evaluation at various psychiatric institutions and feigned hallucinations in order to be accepted, but acted normally from then onward. Each was diagnosed with a psychiatric disorder and given antipsychotic medication.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by gpt5 on Monday February 03, 2025 @06:40PM (#42924992)
"The meds are working"
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by debugnik on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @11:05AM (#42934180)
> For the experiment, participants submitted themselves for evaluation at various psychiatric institutions

How did anyone volunteer for this? Isn't there a risk of actually getting stuck at the asylum, or failing to clarify it was an experiment to have it removed from your records?

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by sixothree on Monday February 03, 2025 @06:56PM (#42925164)
Having grown up in the Deep South, I feel like every single person in the justice system from police to judge make decisions about you based on how you look and subconsciously decide to not believe facts or allow weak facts to have more weight. Nothing about this question seems outrageous to me whatsoever. And I think that’s the shocking part here.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by speakspokespok on Monday February 03, 2025 @07:20PM (#42925440)
The literal moral of "The boy who cries Wolf"? Liars are not believed even when they tell the truth.

... probably all of them.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by SecretDreams on Monday February 03, 2025 @09:11PM (#42926701)
> I wonder how many people are telling the truth about something, and aren't taken seriously because they're problematic about something else.

Likely a metric fuck ton. The perceived quality of one's character plays an outsized role in getting people to believe you. Serial killers figured that out a long time ago.

Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by saghm on Monday February 03, 2025 @10:37PM (#42927556)
I'm not sure that being "problematic" was the issue here; it sounds more like they might have thought he wasn't fully sane. I could imagine thinking that someone fully believed what they said about their identity in the same way they believed that they could have stopped 9/11 if people had listened to them beforehand. The issue isn't thinking they have bad takes or unsavory opinions, but that they have trouble distinguishing reality from delusions.
Re:He Went to Jail for Stealing Someone's Identity. But It W... by interludead on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @03:18AM (#42929607)
This is how these institutions work. If someone behaves erratically, holds unconventional beliefs or just doesn't present themselves in the "right" way, they can be dismissed entirely