News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by Kapura on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:18PM (#41782799)
Pretty obscene that somebody could have so much wealth that $7,000,000,000 is just the tax bill. Also weird that it's framed as a "gift."
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by sushid on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:44PM (#41782987)
The article highlights that it’s not actually that hard for the ultra-wealthy to avoid a massive estate tax bill through proper tax planning and investment strategies. What’s striking here is that this individual wasn’t even the richest person to ever die, yet he paid the largest estate tax in history, likely by choice.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bluGill on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:04PM (#41789473)
> likely by choice.

There is an element of competitiveness there. Some rich want to be known as rich and so they can brag about paying the most taxes that in turns implies they have the most money. Others want to be quieter about their wealth and so don't want you to know they have it and wouldn't tell you how much taxes they pay.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by rootusrootus on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:05PM (#41792072)
If he were doing it competitively, I don't understand the strategy. His name was leaked, not announced, and since he is dead he cannot feel like he won the competition.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by deepsun on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @07:05PM (#41793746)
Sometimes rich could not find a way out of paying a large tax, so instead they pull at least some good from their bad situation, and make it a PR.

And it's a good thing that government is strong enough to be able to collect large taxes. Contrary to popular opinion, rich people are mostly OK paying large taxes, but only as long as all other rich pay their share as well. The grudges they hold are only about unfairness, not about amounts.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by somethoughts on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:11PM (#41783183)
Interestingly a lot of the larger philanthropic organizations are just as administration heavy as the US government and suffer from the same mission creep and the same obfuscated, bureaucratic decision making process, etc. Not to mention the leadership is often richly compensated (i.e. $1M in salary) and non-elected.

In fact we should probably celebrate gifts to the US government more than we do.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by jimcsharp on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:54PM (#41783410)
My hunch is that taxes are the most efficient 'charity', even with the bloat, and everyone's too busy sniffing farts in their corner to see it.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by enos_feedler on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:32PM (#41783593)
Not only that but it’s also the structure that enabled the riches in the first place. I don’t see why more people don’t do this.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by advael on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:00PM (#41783736)
Mostly because of a very successful propaganda campaign by people who sought to loot the post-war economic boom

Generally speaking, the sad truth of a complex economy is that coordination is hard, and there's usually a short-term privatized gain to be had by someone willing to poison the future and the commons. No amount of benefit to humanity overall or even the specific society such a person lives in will convince a person who simply doesn't care about anyone else. Fortunately for humanity, a very small minority of people actually operate like that. Unfortunately for humanity, some of them have managed to accumulate a lot of power

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by enos_feedler on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:31AM (#41784516)
Well said! I feel better already
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by mozman on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:31PM (#41783589)
No thanks, I’d rather keep more of my paycheck.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by schneems on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:36PM (#41783621)
The ultra rich don’t get paychecks. If you’re thinking in terms of “paychecks” you’re not who they are talking about when they say “tax the rich.”
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bialpio on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:57PM (#41784060)
100% this. This reminds me of what my SO says: if you have to work, you are not in the upper class. I don't think I agree with this statement fully (I personally think that top decile by income is already upper class), but I feel like I'm becoming more open to re-evaluating my opinion...
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bluGill on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:14PM (#41789580)
Most upper class work. They work different jobs, but they are generally not sitting around retired. They might or might not get a paycheck, but they are working. (if you own a restaurant you will probably pay yourself minimum wage when you do work - dishwashers start at double that - talk to your accountant but this is often the best legal way to handle your hours that are trackable) Steve Job's was famous for taking a salary of $1/year - he clearly was working and upper class.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by triceratops on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:26PM (#41790408)
But they don't have to work.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bluGill on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:44PM (#41790620)
Most middle class don't have to work either - they are just not willing to accept the lifestyle that forces. Even poor people could find enough savings by 30 to not work if they really want to live that lifestyle. (I don't blame anyone for not wanting to live like that)
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by triceratops on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:50PM (#41790704)
> they are just not willing to accept the lifestyle that forces

Jeez the pedantry around here.

Let me spell it out: Upper class people don't have to work to maintain their existing lifestyle. Steve Jobs could have continued wearing black turtlenecks and paying fines for parking his Mercedes in handicapped spots for the rest of his life, without doing a lick of work. That he didn't is a credit to his work ethic and passion for the work.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bialpio on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:41PM (#41792395)
Out of curiosity, how much money do you think is needed to survive ~55 years ("savings by 30" + life expectancy around 85ish = 55yrs) without working? Also, please spell out biggest assumptions you're making.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bluGill on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @06:35PM (#41793489)
Eat rice and beans $50/month. Live in a $200 tent with a warm sleeping bag replace every 10 years. every year you get $100 for clothing at goodwill (walmart for underware) No other possessions. don't get sick as you don't have health care, but you should on average live to 70 or so [5-10 years less than average with health care], assuming you are not unlucky. so about $70/ month.

I wouldn't want to live like that and I wouldn't wish it on even the most undeserable (life without parole prisoneers). you could do it. Some do it for a month or two in college as they see the world - but they go back to a more normal life and just fondly tell stories.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bialpio on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @07:32PM (#41793945)
You may want to revise the life expectancy estimate on a rice+beans diet, scurvy is a thing and based on my googling you would not get enough vit. C. I'm probably missing some other disease too, so "don't get sick" is probably also out the window on this diet.

One can of beans is ~400kcal and costs ~$1.30+tax in my closest QFC, so you need around $4 per day just for beans (3 cans). 5lb bag of rice (50 servings, 160kcal per serving) is $5.50, & you need 5 servings per day to reach 2000kcal, so +55¢. That's $135/mo just for rice and beans, and I have not checked if that satisfies daily protein intake needs.

Where will you set up your tent without getting arrested? Needs to be walkable from a Goodwill, otherwise you need transport once a year. How are you cooking the rice? Where are you getting the potable water from?

Decent sleeping bag is another $100.

Even your unserious response is underestimating the amount of money required.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bluGill on Thursday October 10, 2024 @07:57AM (#41797954)
Bags of dry beans are a lot cheaper than cans. there should be room for a few vegitables in the budget.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bialpio on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:39AM (#41800008)
Not if you have to pay to set up your tent legally, which you conveniently forgot to respond to. The only place I found so far that is free is BLM dispersed camping, but they allow only 14 consecutive days in 28 day period, and those places are far from civilization, so buying those beans is going to be a challenge.

Sorry, but with such an outrageously low estimate (US poverty line is $15k a year), you have to put in a bit more effort and show some receipts.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bluGill on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:10PM (#41789544)
Taxes are not and never will be because no two people have the same priorities. Even if my favorite charity is only 10% as efficient as the government in doing what I want, a donation to that charity does what the charity does. A donation to the government goes to military, welfare (social security, medicare...), roads, scientific research, and a long long list. If I want to put extra money into say Lymphoma research $10,000 to a really bad lymphoma charity will get $3000 to research (finding a lymphoma research charity that bad is left as an exercise for the reader - the ones I'm aware of are considerably better). The same $10000 to the government will add nothing to lymphoma research since the share of the budget going to that is a rounding error.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by wizzwizz4 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:59PM (#41790105)
But if you and a million other people, all with differing priorities, all agree to pay taxes…
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bluGill on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:45PM (#41790637)
Most of the right wing who is against taxes still agree to pay taxes on something. They disagree what taxes should go for and how much, but they generally agree some are needed.

Society is about the compromise. However that compromise makes nobody happy.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by schneems on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:32PM (#41783592)
> we should probably celebrate gifts to the US government more than we do.

I had the idea that we should put a donation box on tax forms. The 100 top donators get on the “US 100” list (like Forbes) but it’s based ONLY on how much you donate, not how much you claim to be worth.

It’s one thing to claim to be rich to a Forbes reporter, it’s another to have the (tax) receipts to back it up.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by internetter on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:51PM (#41783688)
This is sorta genius. I could totally see Musk and Bezos engulfed in an ever escalating leaderboard feud:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/kenrickcai/2021/09/28/elon-musk...

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by vanjajaja1 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:17PM (#41783821)
reminds me of the way dubai auctions off the 3 digit car license plates, then hotels do things like only letting low number license plates park out front
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by t0mas88 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @10:07AM (#41788149)
Brilliant move, then use the money to support those that are less well off. You can have the ultra-rich bragging about how much they paid, while those that need it most are benefitting. A real win-win.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by vanjajaja1 on Friday October 11, 2024 @03:57AM (#41807295)
yep, iirc on the huberman podcast on testosterone it even said that the competition that's decided by society has an impact on t-levels. societies that make prosocial / win-win games for men obv end up better off
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by dh2022 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:05PM (#41783764)
Billionaires flaunt their wealth via yachts, mansions, space rockets and super-PACs. Which to me seems way more fun than getting your name on a tax list…
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by safety1st on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:21PM (#41783848)
I think it's a great idea. It would generate good press for the donors and some billionaires care a lot about that. Guys like Buffett would do it. It's basically free money for the government.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:09PM (#41790204)
That's not flaunting it; that's just buying things you like because you have the money. Flaunting would definitely be getting your name on a list that you don't need to be on.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by freejazz on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @02:26PM (#41791074)
Gigantic luxury yachts of ever-increasing lengths are absolutely flaunting.

> Flaunting would definitely be getting your name on a list that you don't need to be on.

Oh, like a list of the largest yachts and their owners?

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by AmericanChopper on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:27AM (#41784500)
Most tremendously wealthy people don’t want to be known for being tremendously wealthy. Unless being known for being tremendously wealthy is a part of your wealth accumulating strategy, the attention it brings is almost entirely negative. Being tremendously wealthy without millions of people constantly chirping about clawing as much of it away from you as possible, or demanding an explanation from you every time you wipe your ass is a far better outcome, and most people who are savvy enough to become billionaires are savvy enough to figure that out pretty quickly.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by schneems on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @09:14PM (#41794578)
> Most […] don’t want to be known

But some do.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by M95D on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:31AM (#41785715)
Only the ones at the top of the list would be interested in donating and keep donating. If a rich person calculates that he could only reach the 57th place by donating a large part of his money, then he would have no incentive to donate. 57th place means nothing.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by schneems on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @10:52AM (#41788535)
The key though is that you don't know how much everyone else puts in. There's a psychological effect of seeing the amount and saying "That's it? I can do better than that." It's basically a silent auction.

> 57th place means nothing.

It means you're on the board and got one higher than 56th place. I'm a top 50 rails contributor, that means something to me and to others.

It's kinda like F1. Some teams are racing for the constructors championship. Some teams are racing for the midfield. All of them are racing for even a single point and to stay in the game.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by rootusrootus on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:10PM (#41792108)
> I had the idea that we should put a donation box on tax forms.

I don't believe it's on a tax form, but you can absolutely just donate money to the US. They make it very easy, just go to pay.gov.

https://fiscal.treasury.gov/public/gifts-to-government.html

I like your idea of adding a leaderboard.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by jrockway on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:03PM (#41783110)
Anyone can make a voluntary contribution to the United States Treasury: https://fiscal.treasury.gov/public/gifts-to-government.html
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by mynameishere on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:23PM (#41783254)
I always wondered if there was a way to effectively "burn" one's entire wealth, creating a small deflationary event that would increase the value of existing dollars. How could one do this? Donate to the Federal Reserve? Or would you literally have to cash everything out and burn it?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hollerith on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:27PM (#41783275)
According to my understanding, burning US dollar bills, donating to the Fed (if such a thing is possible) and donating to the Treasury are approximately equivalent in their effects.

What puts a lid on how much money the Fed creates is the desire to keep inflation to reasonable levels, preferably 2% per year. Your burning your cash allows the Fed to create more while adhering to their inflation target. Someone please correct me if I am wrong, but my understanding is that although the Fed decides how much money is created, the Fed is not allowed to keep or to spend newly-created money, but rather must give it to the Treasury (perhaps through some complicated or non-obvious mechanism) which makes it available for the government to spend.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by MobiusHorizons on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:34PM (#41783605)
At least one way they do this is to buy treasury bonds. It is not clear to me what happens to the interest though .
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by ckemere on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:47PM (#41783676)
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by sdenton4 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:07PM (#41783466)
In fact, dragons are important stabilizing influences in dungeon economics. The hoard of gold isn't inflationary until the adventurers liberate it and start buying wands and stuff.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by patwolf on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:29PM (#41783891)
Reminds me of something I read years ago about how Ultima Online would create "gold sinks", super expensive items that served no purpose other than help remove gold from the economy and prevent inflation.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by koolala on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:27PM (#41784228)
I guess the trick there is they don't spend it. The money leaves the virtual economy. IRL that's impossible.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by endgame on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:56AM (#41784626)
This is a problem with all kinds of virtual world economies. Players accumulate so much gold that some substitute becomes more useful. Diablo II had the Stone of Jordan, for example.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by willcipriano on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:51PM (#41783392)
A big part of modern monetary theory is taxing the newly printed money and putting it towards (wasteful) government programs to "burn it" in a sense.

Predictably, politicians who support MMT only did the printing part and skipped that bit once inflation started.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bialpio on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:01PM (#41784080)
That does not feel like burning the money, more like propping up the private sector (naively, government's deficit is going to be private sector's surplus if you don't actually reduce the amount of money in circulation).
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by VirusNewbie on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:53AM (#41784619)
How does that burn the money? If the government is spending the money, it's going to federal employees and purchasing good and services from the general economy.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by kelseyfrog on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:53AM (#41784901)
It helps to conceptualize the circuit of money as it flows from government(G) to the private sector(P) back to the government as G-P-G. The outlays(G-P) and receipts(P-G) can both be increased or decreased to affect aggregate demand. MMT's view is that inflation can be a result of aggregate demand outstripping economic capacity, though not the only one. Supply-side constraints, resource shortages, or structural bottlenecks can also lead to inflation.

MMT emphasizes that taxation (P-G) is not necessary to "fund" government spending. Instead, taxation primarily serves to control inflation and create a demand for the currency. Taxation creates a value for the currency since taxes are payable only in the government's currency.

When we hold the P-G-P view of government spending, we assume it operates like a household - that a government has to collect taxes before spending and this is viewed by MMTheorists as an antiquated perspective. The misconceptions of "The government as a household" were based on the gold standard or fixed exchange rate systems, which since 1971 no longer apply.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:20PM (#41792194)
Please everyone read this comment. Any disagreements should come with relevant references showing how it's wrong.

An additional point to add is the mechanism by which taxation controls inflation. Tax serves to suppress demand in the private sector, freeing up resources that can then be bought at non-inflated prices. This is why super wealthy people are irrelevant to a sovereign government's ability to spend; their marginal propensity to consume is too low to be seriously impacted by normal levels of taxation. It's also why tax has to be broad base to be useful.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by kelseyfrog on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @07:08PM (#41793772)
I will provide a set of example critiques to begin.

MMT alone may not provide sufficient guidance on how to adjust outlays and receipts to manage employment and inflation.

MMT may not be politically feasible. Politicians may not be navigate politically unpopular but economical necessary.

MMT may be domestically sound, but challenging to implement regarding international trade. It may result in devaluing compared to other currencies.

MMT may suggest that interest rates can be kept low indefinitely. It's unclear if this would result in excessive risk taking.

MMT may not be applicable to developing economies.

MMT may work in the short term to manage employment and demand but fail to cultivate long term economic development.

MMT's implication as having a larger governmental impact on investment may crowd out private sector investment.

MMT if implemented could be constrained by international investors. If international investors dislike a policy, it may have domestic implications.

MMT depends on having a government effective enough to implement it. If a government is too dysfunctional, MMT may fail in practice.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Thursday October 10, 2024 @02:31AM (#41796148)
> MMT alone may not provide sufficient guidance on how to adjust outlays and receipts to manage employment and inflation.

The primary policy prescription of MMT is the job guarantee, which explicitly addresses the question of how to manage employment and inflation. The job guarantee defines the value of the currency, with other spend floating relative to that, whilst simultaneously providing full employment. In any case, the current model is pretty broken in which fiddling with interest rates is assumed to have a direct casual link to both (and depressingly in opposite directions).

> MMT may not be politically feasible. Politicians may not be navigate politically unpopular but economical necessary.

Insomuch as descriptive MMT is what happens in most sovereign currency areas, this is just a problem of communication. You are right that getting the politics correct is both hard and important. I'm not sure the policies will in aggregate be very unpopular though once a non-made-up description of what limits spending is understood better by the population.

> MMT may be domestically sound, but challenging to implement regarding international trade. It may result in devaluing compared to other currencies.

A floating exchange rate is a feature not a bug. Current attempts to maintain a soft peg are deeply damaging domestically for many countries. In any case, countries that are confident in their monetary and fiscal policies and that have a sound economy seem to be more robust than those that try to maintain a soft peg (see Japan).

> MMT may suggest that interest rates can be kept low indefinitely. It's unclear if this would result in excessive risk taking.

Excessive risk taking needs dealing with at the political level with actual laws and regulations. Interest rate policy is a crap tool to deal with such problems.

> MMT may not be applicable to developing economies.

Why not? It explains what their actual constraints are and the risks of taking on foreign debt or pursuing an export led growth strategy etc.

> MMT may work in the short term to manage employment and demand but fail to cultivate long term economic development.

I'm not sure what this has to do with MMT. The post war period with much higher employment and stronger government intervention had much higher growth than the following monetarist/neoliberal era, so perhaps the status quo is the problematic position.

> MMT's implication as having a larger governmental impact on investment may crowd out private sector investment.

Far from crowding out, it crowds in in practice:

https://billmitchell.org/blog/?p=12022

Again, the historical evidence shows when governments stop spending, private investment collapses.

> MMT if implemented could be constrained by international investors. If international investors dislike a policy, it may have domestic implications.

What domestic implications? If you're thinking about direct foreign investment, this is problematic in its own right. It might increase domestic employment and potentially increase local skills, but it is also extractive and drains the nations' equity. This possibly has stronger implications for low income nations that don't have a good education base and well developed industries, but MMT at least makes clear where the trade-offs lie.

> MMT depends on having a government effective enough to implement it. If a government is too dysfunctional, MMT may fail in practice.

True, but then so do all political systems. MMT "failing" is also a strange concept given MMT describes the system since the fall of Bretton Woods. What's remarkable is how stable (notwithstanding the obvious "shocks") the system has been despite most governments operating as though they were still inside the Bretton Woods system.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by kelseyfrog on Thursday October 10, 2024 @02:36AM (#41796178)
Thank you. I learned a lot!
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by VirusNewbie on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:39AM (#41800001)
Disagreement? Literally nowhere in either of your comments did anyone actually explain how government spending is deflationary.

There is nothing to disagree with, no claims were made!

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Thursday October 10, 2024 @02:08PM (#41801530)
The comment was a response to burning money. What does that have to do with deflation?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by VirusNewbie on Thursday October 10, 2024 @02:57PM (#41802142)
Are you seriously asking what reducing the money supply has to do with deflation?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Thursday October 10, 2024 @03:31PM (#41802583)
Friedman was a charlatan and monetarism was trivially debunked when he came up with it. The 60 years since have not been any more kind to it. Don't confuse stocks with flows. The whole idea of money supply as a useful metric needs to be put to bed; one would have thought the 13 years post GFC would have made that apparent.

(Of course, the Austrians have a peculiar notion that inflation can by definition only be considered as such if it's associated with increased money supply. Another reason to ignore them completely)

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by VirusNewbie on Thursday October 10, 2024 @09:28PM (#41805246)
Huh. So if I understand correctly, if we halved the money supply tomorrow, the price of everything would stay the same?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by kelseyfrog on Thursday October 10, 2024 @09:32PM (#41805270)
How would you halve the money supply?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by VirusNewbie on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:25PM (#41805712)
it's a thought exercise. I'm asking if you think that would the consequences be?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Friday October 11, 2024 @02:12AM (#41806705)
Between 2008 and 2020 M2 pretty much doubled and prices barely moved anywhere. This was intentional policy for the purpose of increasing inflation which stayed doggedly around zero. What does this tell us? Pretty much nothing because money supply is a useless measure.

What would happen if we halved it? Dunno, but to achieve that, stuff has to happen, and depending on that stuff, you might get price changes. I expect if the gov engaged in QT to achieve it, very little would happen.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by VirusNewbie on Friday October 11, 2024 @02:25AM (#41806781)
>Between 2008 and 2020 M2 pretty much doubled and prices barely moved anywhere

Except Real estate prices more than doubled. Also the Dow went from ~11k to 32k . So almost triple.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Friday October 11, 2024 @04:16AM (#41807402)
And yet the price of a cabbage stayed exactly the same. Oh, we also had close to zero interest rates, might that have something to do with peoples' appetite for higher mortgages and shares over bonds?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by VirusNewbie on Friday October 11, 2024 @03:10PM (#41812516)
>Oh, we also had close to zero interest rates, might that have something to do with

YES! YES! YOU ARE CORRECT, THAT'S MY POINT. Lowering the interest rates is how you EXPAND THE MONEY SUPPLY.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Friday October 11, 2024 @04:45PM (#41813546)
But that doesn't suggest that the critical variable is money supply. It just suggests there's a correlation. There are plenty of ways of increasing the money supply that does nothing at all. Pursuade the fed to give me a trillion trillion dollars and I'll show you by not spending it (though I might spend a few mil for keeping it safe, but that's not going to do much).
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by VirusNewbie on Friday October 11, 2024 @10:19PM (#41815817)
If you literally buried the money then yes, you are correct but in effect that is basically destroying it.

But what would you do to not spend it? Put it in the bank? Buy bonds?

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Saturday October 12, 2024 @02:21AM (#41816900)
The point is that lots of monetary operations are consumption neutral, including buying bonds. The only thing that actually matters from a price perspective is when a real resource gets consumed. People having more money can push the price of real goods up for sure, but the marginal propensity to consume by individuals goes down with higher relative wealth.

There's another very important effect which is the spending on things that matter induces taxation (employment taxes to deliver the thing, sales taxes etc). This is a geometric series reducing the money supply on every transaction of real goods. What matters is the flow, not the stock.

https://new-wayland.com/blog/structural-deficits-are-deflati...

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by kelseyfrog on Friday October 11, 2024 @10:55AM (#41810033)
I don't think the thought exercise can exist in our reality then. Our reality requires a receipt for money supply to be halved.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by kelseyfrog on Thursday October 10, 2024 @03:03PM (#41802221)
Government spending being deflationary is not a claim MMT makes.

> and putting it towards (wasteful) government programs to "burn it" in a sense.

This claim isn't congruent with the idea of MMT.

One way to look at MMT is asking, does our government have to operate like it has a checking account, or can our economy act like an MMORPG economy?

For example, Blizzard has no obligation to collect coin before distributing coin. Blizzard thinks in terms of coin sources and coin sinks and adjusts source and sink policy in response to aggregate demand and player engagement goals.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by willcipriano on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @06:26AM (#41786279)
That's where the wasteful bit comes in.

If the taxed dollars ended up with say hurricane victims or other struggling Americans, those dollars would chase goods and services domestically driving up the price of those goods.

Now consider if instead you helped fund Israels socialized medicine program or paid off some of Ukraines debt or paid interest to Chinese creditors. Those dollars wouldn't have much effect when it comes to increasing the price of eggs in the US as they are being spent far away in another economy.

A similar effect could occur if the money ended with the wealthy folks, say wealthy owners of private defence contracting firms, as those dollars might chase building a super yacht (inadvertently employing some people but also consuming foreign made materials and labor) instead of trying to rent an apartment in Iowa. Less dollars chasing Iowa apartments, considering supply and demand, lower prices, lower CPI.

Take dollars from the middle class who will drive up the cost of the American dream and instead give them to people who will drive up the price of luxury goods.

It's never explained this clearly beacuse people would riot, but with this framework the choices of government in the last few decades or so suddenly makes more sense.

(I don't endorse MMT)

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:42PM (#41792406)
I'm yet to meet anyone that actually understands MMT and doesn't endorse it. You might be the first, but I doubt it. Which bit of MMT do you have trouble with?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by willcipriano on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:02AM (#41799572)
The political will only exists to do money printing part in practice. The rest is a pipe dream.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Thursday October 10, 2024 @02:10PM (#41801545)
So no, you don't understand it?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by willcipriano on Thursday October 10, 2024 @05:41PM (#41803868)
So, its implemented then?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Friday October 11, 2024 @02:21AM (#41806758)
"implemented"? What does that mean? MMT accurately describes the monetary operations and fiscal constraints of a sovereign government (i.e. with their own currency) and from which you can predict outcomes with a high degree of reliability.

Insomuch as "implemented" means using the policy prescriptions (specifically, the job guarantee), there are no countries doing that, but various real world experiments have touched on it.

Japan had done things differently (albeit from a different perspective of mainstream economics) and is a good test case for the MMT model, especially given how many bet against the yen (and lose), implying the mainstream models are struggling there.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by willcipriano on Friday October 11, 2024 @08:27AM (#41808892)
I said the political will does not exist (in several different ways) now you say:

> Insomuch as "implemented" means using the policy prescriptions (specifically, the job guarantee), there are no countries doing that, but various real world experiments have touched on it.

Something that you can't implement, doesn't work. In practice MMT is a smokescreen for politicians to print money for their friends.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Friday October 11, 2024 @08:38AM (#41808944)
The point is, you don't "implement" MMT. It's a useful framework for analysis regardless of what policies you choose. If we could get to the point of discussing monetary and fiscal operations from a sound basis, then we can start debating policies, but we're so far from that at the moment.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by willcipriano on Friday October 11, 2024 @09:36AM (#41809378)
I'd argue a less correct framework that you could actually sell to voters and politicians would be more successful by the virtue of its policy actually being implemented (not just the fun bits).

I can find you far more people who wish to abolish the fed and return to the gold standard than people who are willing to have the levels of taxation required to limit the inflation caused by funding the government with unsound money.

MMT's advocates policies would work if it wasn't for that pesky democracy and realities around campaign finance.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by hgomersall on Friday October 11, 2024 @09:54AM (#41809520)
Right, so I suggest now you're highlighting your lack of understanding. What do you mean by "unsound money"?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by willcipriano on Friday October 11, 2024 @10:04AM (#41809575)
I see no point in arguing further as what you suggest is entirely a pipe dream.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by ChadNauseam on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:49PM (#41792454)
Couldn't you just not spend or invest the money? I think putting it in a chest and burying it in an unmarked location would be equivalent to burning it.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by somethoughts on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @02:58AM (#41785236)
It'd be really interesting if you could allocate your donation to specific branches of the government (i.e. NSF, Pre-K, etc.).
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by FredPret on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:41PM (#41782968)
What's obscene is that you imply some draconian system to limit the posessions an individual can accumulate through a series of legal and mutually agreed-upon transactions.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by kinghajj on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:00PM (#41783092)
> For the transformation of money into capital, therefore, the owner of money must find the free worker available on the commodity-market; and this worker must be free in the double sense that as a free individual he can dispose of his labour-power as his own commodity, and that, on the other hand, he has no other commodity for sale, i.e. he is rid of them, he is free of all the objects needed for the realization of his labour power.

> Why this free worker confronts him in the sphere of circulation is a question which does not interest the owner of money, for he finds the labour-market in existence as a particular branch of the commodity-market. And for the present it interests us just as little. We confine ourselves to the fact theoretically, as he does practically. One thing, however, is clear: nature does not produce on the one hand owners of money or commodities, and on the other hand men possessing nothing but their own labour-power. This relation has no basis in natural history, nor does it have a social basis common to all periods of human history, It is clearly the result of a past historical development, the product of many economic revolutions, of the extinction of a whole series of older formations of social production.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by mmmpetrichor on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:48PM (#41783012)
It's draconian to have some upper limit on wealth? what if a small number of people managed to, legally, extract wealth to the point where we all became vassals? (Or is that what we've already gone very far towards?)
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bawolff on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:15PM (#41783208)
I think anti-trust laws are generally more effective at dealing with that than wealth limits. When capitalism is functioning well, what cones up must go down, and the main trick is to make sure the ultra-wealthy can't leverage their wealth to prevent anyone competiting with them.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by xpe on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:23PM (#41783257)
> When capitalism is functioning well, ...

I recommend this question as an interesting conversation starter at parties: Is it in the self-interest of the most successful capitalists to have a well-functioning capitalism?

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bawolff on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:31PM (#41783298)
Obviously not. Which is why we have antitrust laws. If it was in the self-interest of the most succesful capitalists, we wouldn't have to have laws about it.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by xpe on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @10:28AM (#41788298)
Right. Phrasing it as a question and waiting for the gears to turn can be a good strategy.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bawolff on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @11:29AM (#41788945)
I still don't really understand your point. I don't think anyone disagrees that monopolies and other anticompetitive behaviour is a thing that exists.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by xpe on Friday October 11, 2024 @09:40PM (#41815630)
> I don't think anyone disagrees that monopolies and other anticompetitive behaviour is a thing that exists.

There are people who never learned this or have essentially forgotten it. Some ideologies bury such truths.

Among business/tech circles, there is a fairly common disdain of regulation. People can conveniently forget that self-interest taken too far can destroy the conditions that make competition work.

It is one thing to criticize a powerful monopoly that isn’t you. It is another thing to say “Oh. Maybe what I’m doing is part of the problem.”

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by chgs on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:08PM (#41783469)
What goes up accumulates and is effectively removed from circulation, allowing money to be printed at a minion level while still struggling to avoid deflation.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by AdrianB1 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:52PM (#41783036)
No. But it is a slippery slope of having limits on people, from wealth to anything you can think of (random example: limit ownership to a single car). In the end if it is all legal, it is nobody else's business. If it is illegal, setting an upper limit is not the moral solution.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by recursive on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:59PM (#41783084)
> If it is illegal, setting an upper limit is not the moral solution.

Any particular reason you believe that?

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by AdrianB1 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @04:24PM (#41803174)
Yes, if something is illegal then you don't need to set limits, you send people to prison, don't pass Go, don't collect $200.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by fragmede on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:11PM (#41783176)
Where $1 billion is about 40,000 Honda Civics, I think most people would support limiting ownership of cars to 39,999. It doesn't even have to be a hard limit, just a luxury tax on cars that cost more than, say, $1 million, and on owning more than 40,000 cars. If you want a 40,001st car, your can do it but it means you're going to have to pay an extra fee that goes towards helping people with less.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by FredPret on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:41PM (#41783347)
Who cares what “most people would support”?

It’s right, or it isn’t.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by AdrianB1 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:10PM (#41789537)
"most people would support" is mob rule or tyranny of the majority. Not morally right. People have no right to tell you how many cars (or something else) you are allowed to own.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by fragmede on Thursday October 10, 2024 @04:08PM (#41802975)
how many slaves do you own, how much cocaine do you own, how many guns do you own? how many crocodiles or tigers can I keep as a pet? there are lots of limits on what I can own
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by mxkopy on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:03PM (#41783111)
You can make just about anything a slippery slope if you wanted to - “they’re putting limits on guns, what’s next, kitchen knives?”

Morally you should probably be spending more time figuring out how to get everyone their first car instead of worrying about your legal rights in owning your second.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by amatecha on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:11PM (#41783175)
Right? What's with all the volunteer billionaire-wealth advocates?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by fragmede on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:19PM (#41783231)
well, see, it's embarrassing to admit, but you see, I'm a billionaire. I mean, I'm not one right now, it's a temporary thing. Once I'm back on my feet, I'll have a billion dollars and then, see, I just couldn't have restrictions like that placed on me. I think everyone should be able to get that. So even though it's hurting me now that the rich don't get taxed more, it's just this temporary embarrassing thing where I'm not currently a billionaire.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by AuryGlenz on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @02:26AM (#41785073)
Just because something won’t affect people doesn’t mean they can’t be allowed to think it’s morally wrong.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by FredPret on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:43PM (#41783356)
Why yes, there are countries with limits on kitchen knives.

And if your focus is on providing that first car, then the system currently doing that en masse for billions of previously-poor people is called “capitalism” and your moral imperative is to speed it up, not slow it down.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by mxkopy on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @02:40AM (#41785143)
Capitalism only works when you have a middle class. Protecting billionaires’ abilities to hoard wealth is not in the interests of the middle class.

To be charitable I’ll point out that in general that’s not what you’re arguing for. There is a real sense in which personal freedom is essential to people making it out of poverty. Protecting one person’s and not another’s freedoms would defeat the point.

Here is the compromise. It should be easy for people to do things that billionaires would have no point doing (i.e. take out a business loan of $10K) and difficult for billionaires to do things that people would have difficulty doing (hoard the global supply of some good). That’s if your goal is to have an equitable society where everyone more or less is on the same difficulty level.

Approached this way there would not be a slippery slope because the delineation is quite clear. Moreover there’s no squashing of personal freedom, a billionaire is always free to do things a regular person is able to do. In fact the system we have now basically squashes the freedom of the average person because they are not free to do things (buy a house, have a chance in court) by virtue of not having money while other people have a ton.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by AdrianB1 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:17PM (#41789625)
"Capitalism only works when you have a middle class" - I never saw a scientific demonstration of this. It is always in the "everyone knows" fallacy class of statements pulled out of the landing gear.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by mxkopy on Thursday October 10, 2024 @01:07AM (#41795711)
Ok, argue for a smaller middle class all you want
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by AdrianB1 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:16PM (#41789611)
That is not even an argument. "shall not be infringed" means you cannot put the first limit, no concerns about more limits.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by BurningFrog on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:31PM (#41783299)
You don't become a vassal by someone else having a lot of wealth.

The feudal systems arose as a way to organize military defense locally in the absence of a strong central power like the Roman Empire.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by defrost on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:44PM (#41783360)
Feudal systems are better described as local organised threat of violence.

There are castle strongholds, control of choke points, a lower strata that are required to work the land and pay tithe upwards to the military heirarchy.

Feudal systems have existed in times and locations where there was little need for military defense against external forces, they persist in form as a polite, polished, chivalrous bikie club on horses, mafia with great houses.

Warrior nobility systems farm farmers.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by 082349872349872 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:21AM (#41784729)
> Warrior nobility systems farm farmers

A farm is a system with many living beings, but most of the benefits accrue to those we call the farmers.

A farmer farm is a called a fief (feudum in latin), so it's no surprise that under feudalism most of the benefits accrue to those who have control over heaps of feuda.

Would it be true that under capitalism most of the benefits accrue to those who have control over heaps of capital?

[to the original point: capitalism works very well when it allows people to trade and specialise in their comparative advantages; under what conditions might it work less well?]

EDIT:

> little need for military defense against external forces

I think they were also successful even where there was need, as long as those external forces were also based on a warrior class.

What Napoleon managed was to "scale" the nature of warfare; two poorly remembered quotes from a book one of his cavalry generals wrote:

— 10 mamluks could beat 30 french, but 100 to 100 was even, and 300 french could beat 1000 mamluks

— our troopers' horsemanship was pitiful, and their officers' not much better, yet with this cavalry we made the tour of Europe

I'd say both point to innovation in the use of mass over class.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by gradschoolfail on Friday October 11, 2024 @01:11AM (#41806370)
Morally speaking, is ((profit<->negative externality) <-> (speculation<->liquidity provision)) a tautology i could get any of u curious about?

It motivates a search for the mystical beast: Marxist financier (not the pastry?)

(Not to mention elucidates the boney/HF-inspired principle of intertwining* (wrt scaling — CENDEC, decentralizing by centralizing — marxist-financing-in-itself))

*https://archive.is/FxHSl

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40603483

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by 082349872349872 on Friday October 11, 2024 @02:15AM (#41806725)
Defo! (but not necessarily a tautology: there are models where it's false, it just happens to be true both for Marxists and for financiers — or have we some axioms which would make these models inconsistent?)

Note that 1984's Inner Party, despite not owning anything, benefits from everything; compare Plato's Guardians: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24069572 (or Номенклатура?)

On a straight CenFi note, even Cicero is more subtle than he'd appear by my contextless quote in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41796726 ; he may have enlisted Cato to frown upon usury, but I take http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%... as implying that he smiles upon clipping coupons: Sed ut pecuniae non quaerendae solum ratio est, verum etiam collocandae, quae perpetuos sumptus suppeditet...

[the distinction between ownership and benefit in both code and common law jurisdictions has its roots in roman law, but unless either of you are really interested I'm not going to delve in that graveyard]

EDIT: HF? Our Ford?

EDIT2: for an SAP advertorial, I like TLTF! pigs acorns etc.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by 082349872349872 on Friday October 11, 2024 @08:46AM (#41808999)
TIL; I was more familiar with a different product of Lorraine: https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSWv-gr...
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by FredPret on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:04PM (#41783758)
How can you not see that it's draconian?

You may think it's no biggy since the limit will be so high.

1. First of all, when party A contracts with party B, party C (that's you) does not have a moral right to dictate an upper limit on how many times they can do that or what the terms can be as long as the transaction is legal and A and B are willing participants.

Thus, either A or B can build up an arbitrary amount of wealth and you have exactly zero to say about it. Would you have similar concerns for people who have a disproportionate number of friends, or sex partners, or hit songs, or hell, even votes?

2. If there were to be an upper limit, what is the limit? Today it's a billion dollars. What if it's 100m next, then 10m, then 1m, then 100k? What happens after a couple of decades or centuries of inflation? I suspect you don't care about this because the limit seems far out of reach to you. And so it might be - for now.

3. If there was a limit, who will decide what it should be? What are their incentives? Do you really want a jury of your peers reviewing your financials and drawing lines through it?

4. If there was a limit, who will enforce it? And how? Hand over a check or you go to prison?

There's no way to implement this without an authoritarian regime that has unlimited power over its citizens.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by mystified5016 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:55PM (#41783056)
What's obscene is that you imply it's perfectly acceptable to hoard more wealth than your entire future family tree could use in several generations while we have hungry children, people living on streets, veterans dying sick, homeless, and alone.

Pretty obscene when all that money being siphoned out of the economy could be used to improve the world in any way, but is instead in some ludicrous dragon's hoard that was acquired through illegal and unethical means. Oh, and that by having enough money you no longer have to pay taxes because you can just pay to have tax laws rewritten, or pay for your previously illegal practices to be made legal, or pay a fraction of a fraction of a percent in fines for breaking laws you couldn't be bothered to pay to rewrite.

The real obscenity is hoarding wealth for absolutely no reason other than "big number go up" while people are dying of poverty or preventable illness they can't afford to treat.

Why do you think that some asshole you have never and will never meet having the biggest number is more important than dead children? Tell me, how many starving kids are worth a billion dollars? Is there a limit? Or does having the biggest number justify any number of deaths?

You are by definition a bad person.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by komali2 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:49PM (#41783018)
"Mutual" implies lack of coercion, which doesn't exist under capitalism, since the ownership class leverages significantly greater political power than the working class.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by HauntedDrum on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:45PM (#41782993)
lol, please elaborate
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by BriggyDwiggs42 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:23PM (#41783252)
“Draconian”
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by nomdep on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:23PM (#41783258)
If you think wealth is zero-sum game you are in the wrong forum: https://www.paulgraham.com/wealth.html

He/She could have made their money by inventing something that saved millions of lives, you know nothing.

What it's really obscene is how the government can collect that kind of money like is nothing and it squanders it in bureaucracy.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by yughnior on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:28PM (#41783287)
Peak HN. (I feel comfortable saying that considering the link to a pg article and “you are in the wrong forum”)

In the face of calling out someone else’s ignorance by saying we are all ignorant then going on to assume the thing you like is wonderful while assuming the thing you hate is terrible.

Classic. PG would be proud.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by nomdep on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:45PM (#41783663)
> Classic. PG would be proud.

That’s bad?

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by juunpp on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:28PM (#41783888)
Paul will share all his wealth with the boys. nomdep is on the top of his list, like the pup waiting to suck the mother's tit.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by nomdep on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:37PM (#41783941)
Wow, at the very top? I'd imagined I would be in the middle at most
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by juunpp on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:44PM (#41783982)
The link you shared is kind of deranged. I get where it comes from, but if that is basically your world view, a little getting out wouldn't hurt you.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bko on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:44PM (#41783363)
Why is that obscene? Presumably the person created something very valuable to the world. Sure there are zero-sum ways to generate wealth (e.g. suing people, theft, front running trades) but generally that kind of wealth comes from actually generating something that people value.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by FabHK on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:56PM (#41783418)
The word “Presumably” is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. That Econ101 justification is harder and harder to keep up as you learn more about both economics and the real world.

For detailed counter arguments, see Branko Milanović Global inequality: A New Approach for the Age of Globalization, James Kwak Economism: Bad Economics and the Rise of Inequality, Walt Bogdanich & Michael Forsythe When McKinsey Comes to Town: The Hidden Influence of the World's Most Powerful Consulting Firm, and many other books.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by pembrook on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:52AM (#41784616)
If you need to pull out a library of texts and appeals to authority to rebuke OP…yet aren’t able to actually communicate a rebuttal yourself…I would argue your position is more of a religious one than one based on an understanding of the “real” world.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by kombookcha on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @06:07AM (#41786161)
Damn, that guy is citing sources, must mean he's wrong and there is no need for you to examine any of the vibes-based assumptions you are making about the real world then.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by pembrook on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:14PM (#41790248)
The point is, there’s no way to evaluate if this commenter is wrong, since nobody is going to read 7 books to verify the validity of an internet comment.

It’s a classic logical fallacy; appeal to authority. There is no reason to believe any of these writers have a better understanding of how the world works than any other “authority” of the past like Karl Marx.

Just because someone says something in a book doesn’t make it true.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:14PM (#41790255)
He's not "citing sources." He's outsourcing his argument to textbooks. The point stands: if you want to refute an argument, do so yourself, possibly with reference to corroborating sources. Don't just say "you're wrong. Go read this stuff to figure out why" -- that's no way to have a discussion.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by ChadNauseam on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:53PM (#41792493)
The GP never said they were wrong because they gave sources, they said they didn't give any rebuttal at all and instead only cited sources that presumably contained a rebuttal. If they said "such and such author did a survey that found that only 5% of money held by rich people got to them via productive pursuits", that would be one thing, but they just said "such and such author says you're wrong"
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by intended on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:00AM (#41784410)
Hasn’t it largely been finance and inheritance related, until very recently when tech joined the scene ?

Given the way everything is being made into its crappier form, it’s arguable that even tech isn’t “adding value” anymore.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by 6stringronin on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:01PM (#41783442)
I'm sure the value they created trickles down?
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by vkou on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:51PM (#41783395)
> Presumably the person created something very valuable to the world

Or they are a rent-seeker, or a straight-up thief that sucked a lot of value out of the world. (Or one of their ancestors did, etc, etc.)

Or they robbed Peter to create value for Paul, and took a share of the difference.

These are all tried and true mechanisms for wealth generation. Without any information, you shouldn't assume that their contributions were net-positive.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:17PM (#41790286)
Barring evidence to the contrary, some of us prefer to assume that people have good intentions.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by vkou on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @07:40PM (#41793998)
Here's some evidence to the contrary: Almost every family of old money has been built on one form of theft or other.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday October 10, 2024 @12:46AM (#41795603)
That's an assertion, not evidence.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by cipheredStones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:56PM (#41783420)
The article says that he made it by stock trading. It is, at best, difficult to articulate how that could be creating value rather than capturing it. Many of the world's billionaires made their money that way.

Doing something positive-sum is a way to become a billionaire, but many people are very handsomely paid to ensure that their clients are on the good side of zero-sum transactions.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by CityOfThrowaway on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:10PM (#41783489)
He did it through offering a _money management_ service to large institutions and wealthy individuals.

That money management service includes, amongst other things, picking stocks. But that's the tactical "what". The value-added element is that he preserved and grew that wealth instead. It turns out that is hard to do, and is indeed a positive sum service to customers. They get to relax _and_ make money. Great outcome.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by cipheredStones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:36PM (#41783618)
Yes, he was capturing value for his clients, and getting paid some of that. That isn't the same thing as doing something that increases the amount of wealth in the economy, which was my point.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by ipaddr on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:54PM (#41783704)
The entire point of the stock market is to get capital to companies to allow them to do things that may increase wealth (could be local, state, country or globally). Successfully doing this means the companies he supported did well.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by quesera on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @03:42PM (#41791848)
> The entire point of the stock market is to get capital to companies

Only if the shares are newly-issued, though.

Usually your counterparty is just someone with different cash flow needs, or who disagrees with you about the future. No benefit accrues to the company.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by whatshisface on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:11PM (#41783492)
Taking money away from mismanaged companies, and giving it to well-managed ones, is a net positive of stock trading. Another net positive of stock trading is making buyers and sellers available all day, for anything on the market. Yet another benefit of stock trading is to make it more difficult to manipulate the market - there's a reason why pump and dump scams only occur with assets that see very little attention (i.e. are low-volume).
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by cipheredStones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:31PM (#41783588)
> Taking money away from mismanaged companies, and giving it to well-managed ones, is a net positive of stock trading.

Where "well-managed" means "good at delivering money to its shareholders", which is at best obliquely related to a positive impact on the world. (Also, I'm skeptical that the stock price in itself makes that much of a difference to what the company is able to do.)

> Another net positive of stock trading is making buyers and sellers available all day, for anything on the market. Yet another benefit of stock trading is to make it more difficult to manipulate the market - there's a reason why pump and dump scams only occur with assets that see very little attention (i.e. are low-volume).

In other words, the benefit-to-the-world of stock trading is that it makes it easier to trade stocks? And both of these are the result of unprofitable trading as much as profitable trading, so they can't be the proof that the money comes from the value delivered!

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by glompers on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:44PM (#41783656)
Not GP, but if I recall correctly, "taking money away from mismanaged companies" only occurs if the companies choose to do another issuance of shares in the future to raise equity, or stock options in the future to compensate people, in which case they would have to issue shares at a lower valuation, or issue more stock options to provide a similar benefit, than if they were a desirable company.

But stock trading also penalizes well-managed companies in slow-growing or more mature industries by giving them a higher cost-of-capital, just as it would if they were poorly managed. It seems a haphazardly blunt instrument for allocating liquidity to value generation. It piles on where rewards seem ready to be reaped, and makes it harder for mature sectors to renew or reinvent themselves.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by dclowd9901 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:37PM (#41784279)
Does the quality of management of a company actually dictate its positivity to the world at large? Seems like a quite unrelated signal.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by whatshisface on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:19AM (#41784468)
The world's not all tobacco advertising and chemical spill coverups, there are also dishonest mechanics and dirty restaurant kitchens.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by FanaHOVA on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:19PM (#41783529)
Do you really think a single individual could make $7B of profits from stock trading? They'd need to be trading $30-100B. Point72 manages $35B and has almost 3,000 people on staff.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by Arch485 on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:01PM (#41789442)
Sure, but you could also toss that $30bn into SPY and make a killing.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by wisty on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:59PM (#41783432)
It's not real money. They aren't holding all the gold like a dragon. Or maybe they are, but that isn't hurting anyone, it's wealth not consumption. They consume the same number of calories as a poor person. They breathe the same amount of air. Maybe they have a few extra bedrooms, but their consumption could easily be less than a millionaire.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by kaibee on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @11:41AM (#41789143)
Idk man, I'm pretty sure I consume a lot fewer labor hours than a billionaire with a super-yacht. The thing to focus on is how many labor-hours someone is consuming. When a billionaire allocates ~20 people of labor-hours every day to maintaining that super-yacht, that means there's ~20 people fewer labor hours for services for everyone else. And building that super-yacht also consumed a lot of high-skill labor hours.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by bluGill on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:23PM (#41789683)
That means there are 20 MORE labor hours, not less. The typical person reading this is only working a couple hours to do anything related to the basics (you don't need nearly as large a house as you live in - even if you live in a tiny house)
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by wisty on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @05:16PM (#41792736)
As I said, it's consumption not wealth. A billionaire with a super-yacht is more obscene than a trillionaire who doesn't have one.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by Dalewyn on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:29PM (#41783575)
>Also weird that it's framed as a "gift."

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...

>The gift tax is a tax on the transfer of property by one individual to another while receiving nothing, or less than full value, in return. The tax applies whether or not the donor intends the transfer to be a gift.

Re:Who died and left the US $7B? by juunpp on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:16PM (#41783813)
Gift tax is a tax on gifts. It's not a tax that happens to be a gift.

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...