If you need to pull out a library of texts and appeals to authority to rebuke OP…yet aren’t able to actually communicate a rebuttal yourself…I would argue your position is more of a religious one than one based on an understanding of the “real” world.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B?
by kombookcha on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @06:07AM
(#41786161)
Damn, that guy is citing sources, must mean he's wrong and there is no need for you to examine any of the vibes-based assumptions you are making about the real world then.
The point is, there’s no way to evaluate if this commenter is wrong, since nobody is going to read 7 books to verify the validity of an internet comment.
It’s a classic logical fallacy; appeal to authority. There is no reason to believe any of these writers have a better understanding of how the world works than any other “authority” of the past like Karl Marx.
Just because someone says something in a book doesn’t make it true.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B?
by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:14PM
(#41790255)
He's not "citing sources." He's outsourcing his argument to textbooks. The point stands: if you want to refute an argument, do so yourself, possibly with reference to corroborating sources. Don't just say "you're wrong. Go read this stuff to figure out why" -- that's no way to have a discussion.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B?
by ChadNauseam on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:53PM
(#41792493)
The GP never said they were wrong because they gave sources, they said they didn't give any rebuttal at all and instead only cited sources that presumably contained a rebuttal. If they said "such and such author did a survey that found that only 5% of money held by rich people got to them via productive pursuits", that would be one thing, but they just said "such and such author says you're wrong"
For detailed counter arguments, see Branko Milanović Global inequality: A New Approach for the Age of Globalization, James Kwak Economism: Bad Economics and the Rise of Inequality, Walt Bogdanich & Michael Forsythe When McKinsey Comes to Town: The Hidden Influence of the World's Most Powerful Consulting Firm, and many other books.