Re:Who died and left the US $7B?
by pembrook on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:52AM
(#41784616)
If you need to pull out a library of texts and appeals to authority to rebuke OP…yet aren’t able to actually communicate a rebuttal yourself…I would argue your position is more of a religious one than one based on an understanding of the “real” world.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Who died and left the US $7B?
by kombookcha on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @06:07AM
(#41786161)
Damn, that guy is citing sources, must mean he's wrong and there is no need for you to examine any of the vibes-based assumptions you are making about the real world then.
The point is, there’s no way to evaluate if this commenter is wrong, since nobody is going to read 7 books to verify the validity of an internet comment.
It’s a classic logical fallacy; appeal to authority. There is no reason to believe any of these writers have a better understanding of how the world works than any other “authority” of the past like Karl Marx.
Just because someone says something in a book doesn’t make it true.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B?
by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:14PM
(#41790255)
He's not "citing sources." He's outsourcing his argument to textbooks. The point stands: if you want to refute an argument, do so yourself, possibly with reference to corroborating sources. Don't just say "you're wrong. Go read this stuff to figure out why" -- that's no way to have a discussion.
Re:Who died and left the US $7B?
by ChadNauseam on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:53PM
(#41792493)
The GP never said they were wrong because they gave sources, they said they didn't give any rebuttal at all and instead only cited sources that presumably contained a rebuttal. If they said "such and such author did a survey that found that only 5% of money held by rich people got to them via productive pursuits", that would be one thing, but they just said "such and such author says you're wrong"