News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by HPsquared on Monday October 07, 2024 @04:38PM (#41770772)
Efficiency starts to matter in a near-peer conflict.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Retric on Monday October 07, 2024 @04:49PM (#41770889)
Near-peer conflicts have more meaningful targets which favors these kinds of expensive weapons platforms.

A drone that can do meaningful damage to a factory 500+ miles from a front line is either an easy target or it starts to look a lot like a missile with all the associated costs from that.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by torginus on Monday October 07, 2024 @05:24PM (#41771226)
I think it's more complex than that. The US made Switchblade drones which cost tens of thousands of dollars were outperformed with lightly modified FPVs with grenades, which came in under a thousand.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by SJC_Hacker on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:03PM (#41771537)
We don't know if they underperfomed so much as weren't cost effective. If the switchblade costing $10k results in a kill 80% of the time, while the $1k drone is 30% of the time, you just get 3 times as many $1k drones, average about the same kill rate, and save 70% to boot. Or spend the same amount and get about 3x the kill rate.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jandrewrogers on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:58PM (#41772008)
It is not just production cost, the average latency between target detection and target destruction has a large impact on battlefield dynamics. More precise weapons can destroy most of the capability of less precise weapons before they are ever used. Additionally, precision weapons typically have a much smaller logistical footprint, and logistics can make or break military campaigns.

Much of the US focus on precision terminal guidance is derived from this calculus in a straightforward way. It may be more expensive in a unit cost sense but significantly cheaper in terms of net expected effect on the battlefield. This "precision versus quantity" argument played out to greatly favor precision in Ukraine.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by SR2Z on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:26PM (#41772215)
> This "precision versus quantity" argument played out to greatly favor precision in Ukraine.

Yes, but the defining attribute of the Ukraine war seems to be CHEAP precision - the ability of drones to respond and attack car-sized targets in real time is what has turned this war into a slog.

The American-made stuff is great, but I've seen multiple examples of Ukrainian missile crews reacting contemptuously to the idea that they could use a Javelin/NLAW to take out an older Soviet piece of equipment; that kind of task seems to be reserved for Soviet-era weapons or (preferably) drones.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nine_k on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:51PM (#41773069)
OTOH the highly precise HIMARS played a crucial role many times. Regular artillery has to shoot dozens of shells before it hits the exact high-value target. This betrays the position of the cannon; if it's close enough it will be fired at. HIMARS is precise so it can pack up and leave before the projectiles even reach the target.

FPV drones are precise because they're remotely piloted by experienced pilots. This allows them to inflict large damage with small payloads applied at a critical point, Luke Skywalker-style.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by khuey on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:31AM (#41774114)
HIMARS is highly effective exactly because it's cheap precision. An air force capable of executing the missions that HIMARS can would cost Ukraine many many billions of dollars. HIMARS clocks in at $5M per truck and $200k per rocket.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by InDubioProRubio on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:40AM (#41775059)
FPV-drones can also be precise post-mortem. You record the flight as command-inputs in sim from start location.

Then you deploy the drone from some carrying vehicle, land and loiter, listening for a trigger. Trigger comes, the drone flies only gets a connection for a lineup if any and flies through the "line up" trajectory.

Pilot involvement can be optional.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nine_k on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:01PM (#41778843)
Should work as long as the drone's inertial and visual navigation stay adequate. (I suppose that GPS and the like gets constantly jammed near high-value targets.)
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by InDubioProRubio on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @03:49AM (#41785493)
In theory, you could do loitering mines that go back and forth, every trigger, resting and solar charging in between
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by SJC_Hacker on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:05PM (#41778885)
HIMARS is precise, but my understanding maybe 25% are actually getting through to their targets these days. But still until recently Ukraine didn't have anything of comparable capability
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nine_k on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:39PM (#41779201)
Much like 30% of Russian drones are not actually shot down but driven off course by EW these days.

Things progress at a ridiculous pace in a high-stakes environment like a war for existence.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by QuiteSocialized on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:12PM (#41779514)
"What is the Kelly Blue Book value of a 1989 Toyota Hilux?"
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nostrademons on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:18PM (#41772152)
The reason drones are kicking butt right now is because you get both precision and quantity. Advances in electronics, software, communication links, and sensor technology mean that you can make guidance systems as a hobbyist that would be a million dollar missile from a specialized defense contractor just 15 years ago.

You lose range, but urbanized warfare of the 21st century seems to be a very different battlefield calculus from the strategic bombing campaigns of WW2. The vast majority of engagements these days seem to be within easy drone range, probably because they can be produced in quantities that negate the "just destroy everything within 200 miles" strategy of WW2 carrier battle groups.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ethbr1 on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:15PM (#41773206)
Also small drones, which is to say smart grenades, are a counter to trench warfare.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nradov on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:45PM (#41773371)
The fact that recent engagements have been within easy drone range is an accident of geography. The same situation won't necessarily obtain in the Western Pacific. The quantity of drones you can produce won't matter if the launching platform can't survive long enough to get within range of the target.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ajb on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:10AM (#41773742)
Yeah, although given the number of TEU shipped from China to the US, I would not count out a significant number of drones having been prepositioned in US territory.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nostrademons on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:11PM (#41780135)
This gets complicated, because technology usually advances on multiple fronts at the same time. As others have mentioned, we've seen drones primarily used as an air-to-ground weapon in Ukraine because the airspace is not particularly contested. We have not yet seen them used in air-to-air combat.

There are multiple reasons to believe that drones' advantages over piloted aircraft are even greater than drones' advantages over tanks. Take the pilot away and the G-forces you can pull increase many-fold. Take the pilot away and you have no compunctions against sacrificing a drone for tactical advantage. Take the pilot away and you can field 10x or 100x as many aircraft, since pilot training is often the limiting factor in the growth of your airforce (see eg. Japanese WW2 experience from 1943 onwards, or the need for Top Gun in Vietnam). More aircraft can play airspace denial, since the presence of a bogey creates a kill zone in the area where they can bring their weapons to bear. Computer algorithms can play physics and geometry games where no matter where a piloted aircraft turns, there is always something waiting to shoot them down. Computers can run these simulations instantly, overwhelming the pilot's ability to react. The human becomes the weak link in the weapon system.

The equilibrium I see is drone designs with a range made to just out-range cheap weaponry like glide bombs and common anti-ship missiles, maybe 50-80 miles. For anything fancy (like the supersonic cruise missiles that the Russians have with 200-300 mile range), you want directed energy CIWS instead, but you need those anyway to defend against enemy drones. Then you pack these drones into shipping containers, and launch and retrieve them directly. A single container ship carries its own air force of roughly 10,000 drones, and makes the airspace around it out to ~100 miles completely inhospitable for foes. The convoy becomes its own aircraft carrier, just like the escort carriers of WW2, but the air wing follows the shipping containers and can be packed onto trucks or rail at its destination. Then you bring the convoy to where it needs to be, creating a no-go bubble around it at all times.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by wongarsu on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:36PM (#41772654)
> This "precision versus quantity" argument played out to greatly favor precision in Ukraine

With artillery that's certainly true. On the other hand, Ukraine moved from expensive Bayraktar drones in 2021 to primarily drones in the 1k-10k price range today. Cheaper weapon systems allow them to be deployed in more places. Getting 5000 drones for the price of 5 drones might be worse for logistics, but it also means some will always be where you need them, doing wonders for the latency between target detection and target destruction.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by zmgsabst on Monday October 07, 2024 @11:18PM (#41773535)
> Additionally, precision weapons typically have a much smaller logistical footprint, and logistics can make or break military campaigns.

Only if you exclude manufacturing.

> This "precision versus quantity" argument played out to greatly favor precision in Ukraine.

Until the allies of Ukraine fell behind on artillery manufacturing — allowing Russia to gain dominance and grind down the Ukrainian military.

That mass produced artillery out sustained precision munitions is a major lesson in Ukraine’s defeat.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:01AM (#41773711)
It's one thing to make a speculative assessment, or a prediction. But the use of the implied past tense in reference to a situation that has many variables and which in any case is far from decided is definitely quite pretentious.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by zmgsabst on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:30AM (#41776154)
I don’t think anybody serious questions the outcome of the Ukraine war — as evidenced by the international realignment caused by NATOs defeat, increases talk about Ukraine relinquishing ground, etc.

What event do you believe could change the outcome at this point?

And since Ukraine was defeated, we can discuss why: their inability to match artillery exchanges for most of the war.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:27AM (#41776579)
Since you not only "know" the outcome, but it apparently it's ancient history for you already - why are you asking?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by zmgsabst on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:37PM (#41783327)
You disagree — perhaps I’m wrong.

But that you responded with rhetoric rather than pointing out where I’m wrong suggests you don’t have an answer to what would change the outcome.

Not even his allies believe in the “Victory Plan” — and several started talking about calling Putin after reading it.

If you think I’m wrong, stop engaging in empty rhetoric and explain what you think will allow Ukraine to win… because nobody seems to know, not even Zelensky.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:11PM (#41784143)
Sorry, but I can't engage you on this. You have to understand that your original statement, in both content and tone, simply precludes any follow-up or debate. And then when this ws pointed out, you doubled down on the same weird, time-traveling, debate-terminating formulation.

So okay, fine: HN is a big place, and there's plenty of other people you can debate on this particular point if you want. I don't think we'll convince each other of anything anyway, which is also perfectly fine.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by throwaway2037 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @07:31AM (#41797777)

    > caused by NATOs defeat
To clarify: Is this a hypothetical statement or is there a specific NATO defeat that you have in mind? As I understand, Russia has not directly attacked any NATO states since the state of the Ukraine war. (Leave aside the sabotage of Nord Stream natural gas pipelines.)
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by lazide on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:58AM (#41774213)
Haha, since when is Ukraine even close to defeat?

Defeated enemies aren’t making regular incursions into the ‘victors’ land which the ‘victor’ can’t stop, or launching attacks agains the ‘victors’ capital.

This just reads like Russian delusion/cope.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by zmgsabst on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:28AM (#41776136)
What are you talking about?

Kursk was stopped after small gains and prior to any major captures — with Ukraine losing their best units. That loss has led to cities along the line of battle being captured, including the fortress city of Vuhledar.

There’s now increased talk of Ukraine giving up territory — which is their defeat.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by lazide on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:57AM (#41776356)
Oh talk.

[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian-occupied_territories....]

Looks like Russia has lost everything but a tiny portion they gained, at immense cost - including the near total collapse of their economy.

And are going to be locked in trench warfare on land they don’t control, with uncertain supply lines, with no air superiority - going into winter.

And is losing more and more control of the little they have left.

This is Russia’s Afghanistan writ large, and will lead to the total collapse of the Russian gov’t (and society) soon.

It’s already nearly destroyed an entire generation of Russian men - in the middle of an already epic demographic collapse.

Don’t get me wrong, this has wrought terrible damage to Ukraine too. But with Russia’s economy (previously) and population being 10x larger, this whole debacle is a huge embarrassment to Russia. Even bigger than the collapse of the USSR.

It would be like if the US went to invade Canada, and couldn’t even hold Ottawa.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by throwaway2037 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @07:35AM (#41797801)

    > including the near total collapse of their economy.
I am not here to shill for Russia, but this is certainly not true. The Russian economy has proven much more resilient than anyone expected since the start of coordinated global sanctions by the world's most developed economies. It is currently growing about 4% per year.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Thursday October 10, 2024 @08:23AM (#41798131)
You're not, but given that the IMF is saying 2.6 percent (current), 3.2 percent (projected) -- how does one obtain 4 percent for "current" growth (other than from Russian government figures)?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by throwaway2037 on Friday October 11, 2024 @03:11AM (#41807060)
This is my source: https://tradingeconomics.com/russia/gdp-growth-annual

Regardless, even if 2, 3, or 4%, none of those is "near total collapse of their economy".

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Friday October 11, 2024 @07:38AM (#41808553)
So Russian government figures, then.

Agreed that comment above yours was out to lunch, of course.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by meiraleal on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:48AM (#41776281)
Zelenski (which presidential term ended) complains every day that they can't properly fight with what they have. This looks like losing for me
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by lazide on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:55AM (#41776340)
That’s called fundraising.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by meiraleal on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:18AM (#41776500)
No, it is called a losers fundraising
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by torginus on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:24AM (#41774319)
Those FPV drones (either of the bombing or suicide variant) seem to be precise enough - there's plenty of footage of them hitting moving vehicles in weak spots like engines/hatches, individual soldiers etc.

As for AI features when the comms are jammed, Russian lancet drones, which have some autonomous capability, seem to be running on Nvidia Jetson boards, and those things cost like $200.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by dgroshev on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:58AM (#41776363)
Would you ever see footage of them not hitting weak spots?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by throwaway2037 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @07:28AM (#41797761)
It is a fair question, but I have seen plenty of footage where the first drone misses a weak spot. Sure, the explosion is intense, but the tank continues unabated. Then a second or third drone hits the weak spot for disablement.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by SJC_Hacker on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:54AM (#41778763)
I'm not just including precision, but ability to get through defenses - i.e. total battlefield effectiveness.

Precision in terms of "circular error probability" isn't the biggest issue now. Its the EW environment.

My point was if system A gets through defenses 30% of the time, but is 10x cheaper than system B which gets through 80% of the time. System A is generally the better choice, except for some very specific circumstances, very high value targets with limited strike opportunity.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by rolandog on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:52PM (#41771967)
Another thing commonly left out of these napkin math scenarios is cyber security risk... it may make sense to cut down on human resources, but you better make sure your drone fleet won't be commandeered by an adversarial nation-state's script kiddies. Cheaper to make, but perhaps also cheaper to have them turn on you.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by theelous3 on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:22PM (#41772555)
Considering we're looking at an adversarial nation state (famously full of script kiddies) which is absolutely hell-bent and motivated to tackle their drone problem, and not once has that state or its script kiddies commandeered a single drone - nevermind a fleet of them - (nor are the script kiddies even remotely in range?) I don't see this being a problem now or in the near future.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Eisenstein on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:39PM (#41772672)
It isn't a problem until it is one, and the it can be a huge problem. I don't know anyone who was ever made to look foolish saying 'it is improbable, but let's prepare for it anyway' whereas plenty of graves are filled with people who said 'that will never happen'.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by SJC_Hacker on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:19AM (#41778309)
Sadly generals, or at least the high command, tend to fight the last war, and tend to be fairly conservative.

WW2 was a classic example. Every nation except the US still had bolt-action rifles as the standard infantry weapon, on the belief that giving every infantryman semi-auto was a waste of ammo/too expensive/too heavy on logistics. Also motorization was not appreciated until late in the war, even in the German army - which despite all the attention devoted to the panzer/panzergrenadier divisions, was maybe 20% motorized at its peak. Mostly their soldiers marched from place to place, or used rail.

There is kinda a reason for this, that there are counter examples were new tech wasn't all it was hyped to be. And until something is battle tested, its hard to say how it would perform. Like early in the Vietnam war, US infantrymen may have been better off with the old M1 garand, because early models of the M16 tended to jam in combat conditions.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by theelous3 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:57PM (#41783070)
> It isn't a problem until it is one

> anyone who was ever made to look foolish saying[...]

These are common throwaway sayings people with no concept of resources and an overly active aversion to risk often use.

The reality of the situation is that nobody cares to invest in some insanely expensive and vulnerable platform to hijack drones, because 1. it will probably get taken out by a drone 2. it would cost orders of magnitude more than all of the drones and personnel it would take out.

Furthermore, nobody would care to truly protect against such a counter, because the drones cost absolutely nothing.

Saying "it's improbable but let's prepare anyway" isn't how the real world works. Look around you - the world is absolutely filled to the brim with problems, even ones quite probable, even ones inevitable, that nobody can or is willing to spare the resources to deal with. As a general rule, preparing for the improbable is a poor path to success, and worse still is preparing for the improbable, where the improbable event doesn't even impact you in any serious way.

Also, ofc you don't hear about those people. Nobody is reporting on the non-event or the people who prepared for the non-event. Pure selection bias.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Eisenstein on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @02:50AM (#41785196)
You are telling me that the US has made plans for invading or defending against every scenario imaginable[1], but they wouldn't bother considering the 'our drones are being hijacked and used against us' scenario? Just because you are overly confident doesn't make caution an extreme position.

[1] https://williamaarkin.files.wordpress.com/2012/02/arkins-con...

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by theelous3 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @05:59AM (#41797268)
I wasn't telling you that. There is a huge difference in preparing on a meta level for national and international level events, and actually investing in countering specific tactical scenarios. The tactical scenario we are talking about is mid-flight hijack and use of sub $1k drones, by a state, and by civilian script kiddies. It's not a "what if china sits it's navy on a contested Philippine island".
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by guappa on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:20AM (#41774060)
Yes, not a problem at all. It never has happened before. Oh wait!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93U.S._RQ-170_incid...

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by theelous3 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:51PM (#41783031)
Did you read that article? That drone was electronically taken out of the sky and rendered useless, it was not commandeered and used against the US.

Where did I claim nobody's ever taken out a drone with ewar? Plus this action presumably took an entire squadron with extremely powerful ewar apparatus - a complete waste of time on an 800e drone that will be replaced before the one you've dropped even hits the ground.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by guappa on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @03:45AM (#41785477)
Well Iran says they landed it, USA said they crashed it. I don't really know who's less believable between the 2.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by theelous3 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @05:52AM (#41797234)
Even if they landed it (meaning it landed its self due to loss of control) that doesn't fit your criteria, and says absolutely nothing about the topic at hand - battlefield uno reversing mini drones.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by thaumasiotes on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:17PM (#41772149)
> If the switchblade costing $10k results in a kill 80% of the time, while the $1k drone is 30% of the time, you just get 3 times as many $1k drones, average about the same kill rate, and save 70% to boot.

Sanity check: 80% success is an 80% success rate; 3 shots at 30% success is a 66% rate, which is much, much worse.

You need 5 cheap 30% drones to beat an 80% success rate, still a major savings at the prices you give, but 70% more than 3 drones.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by szvsw on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:33PM (#41772256)
Obviously this is just a binomial distribution, but another thing to consider I suppose would be if all trials are performed sequentially or simultaneously. If performed sequentially, on the one hand, you have a non-zero chance of not needing to expend the subsequent trials; on the other hand, it seems reasonable to think there might be a degraded (or increased!) probability for each sequential trial. If conducted simultaneous, similarly, it seems reasonable to think that that the individual chance of success is higher due to saturation of one form or another, but you are also guaranteed to expend all resources.

Point is just that it seems a little silly to try to reductively do these calculations - seems meaningless to try to compare without more information…

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by thaumasiotes on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:41PM (#41772296)
> but another thing to consider I suppose would be if all trials are performed sequentially or simultaneously.

Yes! That definitely came up while I was thinking about the problem.

I concluded that, in cases where you desire to eliminate (1) a particular target (2) under time constraints, only simultaneous attempts make sense. (And that this combination of needs is common.)

If instead your goal is to cause random deaths, you can ignore the simultaneous/sequential distinction, treat every drone as having a different target, and just say that 3 30% drones will get 0.9 kills for every 0.8 kills from 1 80% drone.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:56AM (#41774206)
Both 80% and 30% are imaginary numbers, nobody measured it, so all the math is pointless. I've read that it takes 10 to 15 FPV drones to finish off a "turtle tank".
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by OrigamiPastrami on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:17PM (#41771666)
Your analysis assumes collateral damage is irrelevant.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by phs318u on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:31PM (#41771804)
It’s not that collateral damage is irrelevant. It’s that the calculation as to whether collateral damage is “worth it” in the context of the specific goal/target is usually relative and calculated unemotionally. Some may say inhumanly.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hnbad on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:34AM (#41775023)
Of course it's also worth pointing out that this question hinges on the perceived cost of collateral damage.

For countries like the US which at least ostensibly claim to care about human life indiscriminately and to fight for "liberty and peace" and all that, there is a considerable cost to collateral damage, although of course that also depends on who the victims are and the cost can be higher for a Democrat leader than a Republican.

Putin's Russia infamously responded to a hostage crisis in Moscow by killing not only all hostage takers but also more than three times as many hostages and injuring most of the survivors. That alone should make it easy to extrapolate what the cost of collateral damage in Ukraine might be in Russia's calculations. Israel similarly seems to use a much lower cost than the US although in Palestine this is also shaped by the perception that anyone who isn't a militant or supports the militant is eventually going to turn out that way anyway (e.g. the child who died would have grown up to become a threat anyway).

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by littlestymaar on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:21PM (#41771712)
Collateral damage is much less relevant in symmetric conflicts. Nobody is using either a Switchblade or an FPV in the middle of civilian areas in Ukraine right now.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by sgc on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:59PM (#41772784)
Russia is using FPVs to kill civilians on their bicycles or buying fruit, and posting the videos on telegram to laugh about it. This happens every day, it is not a few isolated incidents. It is not boredom, but a chosen tactic.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by kspacewalk2 on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:59PM (#41773121)
Here's a great piece[0] about these Russian "human safari" tactics in Kherson, written by what seems to be the only Western journalist living in that city.

[0] https://kyivindependent.com/human-safari-kherson-civilians-h...

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by littlestymaar on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:57AM (#41774209)
I hadn't heard of that before, but it really isn't a counter argument to what I'm saying: when you're targeting civilians themselves, you don't have “collateral damage”.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by usrusr on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:07AM (#41774248)
"Look at how much pain we can inflict, you want to be friends with us, that's the only logical conclusion".

That seems to be the explicit strategy here, and I've come to believe that they genuinely think that this is how it should be, that there can't be a different world. Perhaps some linguistic quirk that makes the difference between friendship (that's not based on a power gradient) and allegiance (unite with the strongest, even when they're monsters, in particular when they're monsters) different to express and think about, perhaps it's a long term effect of socialist ideology having co-opted all concepts of friendship based on equality for a system that never was. But the pattern seems to go all the way through society, from the infamous prison hierarchies to imbalanced spousal relationships to the KGB state to the relationship between state power and its barons (who are commonly called oligarchs, but they are the exact opposite, powerless pawns on the political floor that are allowed to hold a fief until they aren't)

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by immibis on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:18PM (#41771675)
It is, or it's an advantage.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by pclmulqdq on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:27PM (#41772591)
Russian military doctrine favors collateral damage. I think part of the US's love of precision weapons comes from the fact that they media will go nuts if the US kills non-targets.

20 civilians dying in Iraq to a helicopter that thought their camera was a gun was a national embarrassment. For Russia, 100 civilians dying in a mass artillery bombardment is a normal workday.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by sgc on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:56PM (#41772767)
> For Russia, 100 civilians dying in a mass artillery bombardment is a normal workday.

More specifically, it is a success to them. They clearly use civilian casualty and the terror it brings as a tactic to dishearten their victims.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bluGill on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:20PM (#41772883)
they use it to hearten the folks back home. Civillian deaths mostly make civillians want to support the war and so is not a good idea. In turn this is why the us doesn't
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jajko on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:44AM (#41774693)
Last week I've seen russian military coming from 'official' TG channels boasting how they dropped grenades on civilians, Donetsk IIRC. Literally civilians driving in their cars or walking on pedestrian crossing with shopping bags, having grenades dropped on them, killing many including women. Sarajevo tactics all over again, just not serbs anymore (although both societies share a lot in common).

Also during beginning of the war there were videos of russian soldiers setting up machine gun posts next to bigger roads and literally gunning every single unsuspecting civilian car that came along... not much better behavior than hamas attack last year. Bucha, civilian mass graves with people having hands tied behind their back with wire and headshot found on territories won back from them.

Shows how depraved that society is that this doesn't even cause any upheaval, instead is something to boast about back home and to whole world. Now do a simple projection for next decades.

I know China is #1 topic for US right now, but China views US rather as a competitor. Russia views whole west and US specifically as existential threat to actively fight against (and it did in asymetric subversion warfare for past 2 decades). Not whole russian population, they don't give a fuck whether whole world burns as long as they can drink vodka into desperate oblivion, but all their rulers and that's all that matters there. Now how to tackle and survive that due to all the resources required from that land I don't know but future in that regard looks bleak.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hajile on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:57AM (#41778050)
https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/2024-02/two-year-u...

10k civilians killed and at least 6k are solidly inside territory Russia has controlled since the start of the war meaning that Ukraine -- not Russia -- has been responsible for the overwhelming majority of casualties.

There are evil people on both sides, but the casualty numbers speak very clearly for themselves.

This shouldn't be a surprise. I started sporadically following the war since 2014 and there were loads of videos where Ukrainian Nazi units would launch artillery and mortar attacks on 100% civilian areas just to hurt/kill people.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bitkrieg on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:58PM (#41773118)
What the US public opinion is and what the US government does are two different things. Americans are hilariously self-delusional in that regard. Just compare the civilian death tolls between the first two years of the invasion of Iraq and the first two years of the invasion of Ukraine.

For the last twenty years in the Middle East alone, the number of civilian deaths in which the US is either directly or indirectly involved is easily in the millions

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by pclmulqdq on Monday October 07, 2024 @11:27PM (#41773576)
Unless you're counting a lot of definitions of "indirect involvement" (eg including things Israel does on its own and any proxy wars the Saudis start), you're going to have a hard time counting to 1 million civilians with any authoritative sources. Most of the civilian deaths in the US's "war on terror" were to IEDs and other devices set up to kill Americans.

People who create studies suggesting those wars killed 5 million people include a lot of ludicrous definitions of "killed" to get numbers that big.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by rjurney on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:00AM (#41773701)
When you topple a foreign government, destroy all the infrastructure for pointless "shock and awe" and then send the ethnic majority but recently oppressed armed forces home... you bear responsibility for the millions of extra deaths that follow when traumatic civil war rocks the nation. You are the exact example of the delusional American he means.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by pclmulqdq on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:11AM (#41773750)
You are the exact kind of person to demonstrate why the US builds the best precision weapons in the world and doesn't kill civilians if at all possible. If you are going to blame every single death in a conflict, including indirect deaths (eg excess heart attacks) and deaths at the hands of the other party (WMDs laid by the other side), on the US, there's no reason to give you any more ammunition or make your argument seem rational.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by guappa on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:25AM (#41774086)
I mean, USA could stop doing wars everywhere in the world no?

It's not like iraq had tanks by the USA border, ready to roll in no?

It also didn't have any of the terrible weapons that USA claimed they had.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by pclmulqdq on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:59AM (#41774214)
When you are the world police and you stop "doing wars everywhere," everywhere starts doing wars with you (usually through your weaker/looser allies). Hence Ukraine, Hong Kong, the Mexican cartels, Iran's proxy wars, and let's not forget 9/11.

In all cases, the US has demonstrated a level of weakness on the foreign stage, and terrible people have come to exploit that. Like it or not, those little wars in Iraq were the long arm of the Pax Americana, which is ending now, to the tune of the first land war in Europe in quite some time. And one of the bloodiest conflicts in recent history.

This is what happens when you are a world-spanning empire. An empire, by the way, that Europe, India, China, and the rest of the civilized world has benefitted massively from in the form of free security and safe transport of goods. When there is no dominant empire, the world gets messy.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by guappa on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:03AM (#41774228)
This needs a very large "citation needed" banner.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by pclmulqdq on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:30AM (#41774344)
Ah yes, the "source?" argument. The classic cry of people who want to disagree but have nothing productive to add to the discussion.

I could point you to literally dozens of books on the Pax Americana and its decline (google is your friend) and America's de facto empire, as well as historical studies of the Pax Brittanica and the Pax Romana. Or Chinese histories that discuss the waves of peace and prosperity following the growth of major dynasties which end exactly the same way. I suspect you won't read any of them though, since nobody who asks for a source in an online discussion really wants a source (nobody ever asks for a source when they agree with you). They just want to claim that their counterpart is uninformed.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by lucubratory on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:16AM (#41774906)
This would be a fantastic copypasta for anytime someone requests you prove the outlandish claims you're making.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by pclmulqdq on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:11AM (#41776457)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning

You want to engage in a debate involving cited sources? What's good for the goose is good for the gander - write a response with a citation or two that rebuts a key point. Otherwise, asking for sources in online arguments is borderline trolling.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by LtWorf on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:11PM (#41780136)
You want people to "read the books", you better be prepared to say which books…
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hnbad on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:21AM (#41774941)
The problem with narrativized framings like "Pax Americana" is that they only work if you focus on internal peace. The "American" century began with World War 2 (arguably) and was defined by continuous proxy wars and assassinations. The US also didn't stand unchallenged at least until the decline of the Soviet Union (remember: the commies even won the "Space Race" before the goalposts moved to putting a man on the moon) but arguably that was also a crucial step in the rise of China as a direct challenger.

In the case of Pax Americana the framing is also dubious as it wasn't American dominance that kept the peace in Europe (on this side of the iron curtain) but arguably more the shared market and the necessity of cooperation to recover from the wounds of two world wars while facing the threat of annihilation in the conflict between the US and the Soviet Union.

Even in Europe this period was heavily defined by oppressive policing in both East and West Germany (culminating in the fall of the Berlin Wall in the East and the student protests and RAF terrorist attacks in the West), civil war in Northern Ireland (with terrorist attacks reaching deep into England at times), separatist movements in the Basque region, the excruciatingly slow death of fascism in Spain and Portugal, the violent suppression of striking miners in the UK, and the birth pains of neoliberalism and austerity.

The "pax" in these titles always only applies in a very narrow sense to the affluent in its imperial core, i.e. the American upper middle class of the 1950s or the British bourgeoisie of the colonial era. Even the Pax Romana is not a coherent description of life in the Roman Empire for the time frame it is often applied to and was defined by expansion (i.e. military conquest) not an absence of war.

If anything, the "prosperity" these terms often imply always only existed because of a hierarchical system of exploitation and the "peace" refers to the absence of serious challengers to disrupt this exploitation. The prosperity in Britain during the Pax Britannica specifically only existed due to the violent oppression of British colonies and the absence of powerful challengers to claim those colonies instead. Following the war economies of WW2, the 20th century saw a massive redistribution of wealth and public infrastructure to the financial elites, especially under Reagan in the US and Thatcher in the UK, while colonialism largely evolved from the crude brutal oppression of e.g. the British Raj to loans and privatization, aka "soft power" (promoting the production of worthless cash crops for international trade at low margins instead of vital food crops, making the economy dependent on imports to keep the local population fed, or exporting raw resources rather than building up local infrastructure to refine those resources into goods that can be sold at a higher price and thus having to import the finished goods at exorbitant prices).

So, yes, for you or I living in the imperial core - whether literally in the US or by extension in Europe - the "decline" and the rise of challengers is worrisome and can only be negative. But ultimately, especially to those living outside that core, the challengers are no worse or better than the status quo.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by pclmulqdq on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:07AM (#41776950)
Yes, I agree with you that the "peace" mostly applies to those in the fold, and the only people who enjoyed a real, enduring peace for the whole time are the middle and upper classes of the very core of the empire. Personally, I would suggest that much of NATO (but not all of it at all times) has had relative peace during this time. The borders of empires have always had belligerents that need "putting down" from the perspective of the empire, which means small proxy wars. However, the "peace" usually refers to wars between nation-states.

Much of Europe's economic policy benefits from the huge subisdy that the US covers them with its guns - a drain of 6-10% of GDP may otherwise apply to NATO countries that find themselves up against Putin (and in a hypothetical world - maybe against each other). The Marshall Plan is also a relatively visible indication of how intertwined Europe's post-WWII growth was done with America's involvement, and when you look at US foreign aid ("imperial economic stimulus"), a lot of it today goes to poorer European nations. I agree with you that the EU (post-iron-curtain project) has been, as you suggest, a solely European initiative driven more by European solidarity than US guns. However, it exists in the world of the petrodollar (not any more) and with the quiet reassurance that many of the leading nations in the EU are NATO members. As we have seen with Ukraine, sometimes that NATO membership matters.

Empires are always a lot looser than we think - the Roman empire was a great example of this, where the nation-state of Rome (in the modern idea) didn't extend beyond the Alps until the Caracalla years, where Roman citizenship was truly extended to the provinces (note: after the end of the pax Romana). Egypt and the levant were basically completely autonomous, much like the EU is today.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by guappa on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @05:39AM (#41775393)
What you call "policing" they call "exploiting". Every single country that has dared to vote too left wing has had CIA or USA army having something to say about it.

This happened in europe, south america, and middle east.

> I suspect you won't read any of them though

That's very unacademic of you to suspect I won't read "the books", which you didn't even bother to list.

I have read this book in the summer. Perhaps you want to give it a read and step out of your bubble? https://www.amazon.it/del-marcio-Occidente-Piergiorgio-Odifr...

> Pax Brittanica

That's now how you spell it.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:28PM (#41780307)
Look. You made the claim; you have the burden of proof. What can be claimed without evidence can be disbelieved without evidence.

But also, on an online forum, a post is written once, but read many times. When you say "look it up yourself", that doesn't tell one person to look it up, it tells 10 or 100. That's inefficient - the looking up is done multiple times rather than once.

And, I can google for why the earth is flat and find plenty of resources. The fact that I can find stuff on google that supports your position doesn't say much.

So, yeah. Maybe you could supply some resources that you think are solid, and why you think they are?

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jychang on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:38AM (#41774135)
> You are the exact kind of person to demonstrate why the US builds the best precision weapons in the world and doesn't kill civilians if at all possible.

Wait is that a good thing or a bad thing?

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by pclmulqdq on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:53AM (#41774185)
No value judgment, but he's a good demonstration of why the US does the thing he's accusing the US of not doing.

The US goes out of its way to minimize collateral damage because it gets accused of causing all collateral damage in the first place.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by rjurney on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:24AM (#41778368)
We took out tons of infrastructure in Iraq during shock and awe. Utilities were on the target list. We were about to occupy it. That was incredibly stupid. The infrastructure itself was not collateral damage, it was targeted. We have no occupation plan, it was that stupid. The destruction resulted in millions of extra deaths due to the impoverishment and destruction of Iraqi society. Yes, we bear responsibility for all those deaths. You break it, you own it. That's war.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by guappa on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:23AM (#41774073)
USA doesn't kill many civilians because Obama defined that "if you die in a drone attack you weren't a civilian".

https://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/opinion/2012-05-29/ana...

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hnbad on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:40AM (#41774669)
Specifically, the US considers anyone who is male and "of fighting age" not a civilian - and the "male" part is often optional.

This does somehow still result in a lower ratio of dead civilians than when applying the same definitions to Russia or Israel. This shouldn't be seen as a way to excuse the behavior of the US but rather as a way to recontextualize the actions of the latter two, whether you support or oppose their military operations.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by guappa on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:18AM (#41775654)
I don't think it helps anyone to separate what israel does from what USA does. Everything that israel does is authorized and aided by the USA. It'd all stop the very second the USA told them to stop.

Related reading. https://chomsky.info/20210512/

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by mcphage on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:03AM (#41776915)
> It'd all stop the very second the USA told them to stop.

What makes you think that? And which “the USA”, since Netanyahu has been in discussions with both Biden’s administration, and Trump.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by guappa on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @03:44AM (#41785473)
The fact that they'd have no weapons if not for USA?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by throwaway2037 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @07:47AM (#41797877)
That's not true. They buy weapons from a variety of nations. Also, they have a large domestic military industry to produce them.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hajile on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:52AM (#41777993)
People are really misinformed about the Ukraine war. Russia cares about civilian casualties more than Ukraine (see below) and the total civilian casualties (as reported by both Ukraine and Russia) is astronomically low for such a large-scale war.

> Since 24 February 2022, conflict-related violence in Ukraine has killed at least 10,582 civilians and injured 19,875 (30,457 total civilian casualties). This number includes 587 killed and 1,298 injured children (1,885 child casualties)

That's from the UN report Feb this year (the latest I know of).

They give a breakdown of civilian deaths by region. Nearly 6,000 of those civilian deaths are in places controlled by Russia since the first week of the war which means those civilians were almost certainly killed by Ukraine rather than Russia. Many of the remaining 4000 MAY have been in Russian-controlled areas, but it isn't as easy to determine.

Most wars have 5+ civilians killed for every soldier. This war with around 1M dead soldiers has the reverse with more like 100 soldiers killed for every civilian.

https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/2024-02/two-year-u...

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by sgc on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:52PM (#41772744)
Since they are ramping up to build switchblades in Ukraine [1], I would say they are a quiet success. They were just extremely overhyped before they got there.

[1] https://kyivindependent.com/us-company-aerovironment-plans-t...

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by fullspectrumdev on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:14AM (#41774888)
The 600 is significantly better than the 300 (which was provided in higher numbers).

Odds are there will be local adjustments made - different, more robust radio link and such to replace the fucking shit one that originally came with the switchblade.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by pletnes on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:43PM (#41779862)
I’m guessing they just don’t have camera links so they don’t make the best videos, i.e quiet sucess
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by sgc on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:59PM (#41780576)
They have camera links. I think it is US opsec requirements keeping the videos to a minimum.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by JohnBooty on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:32PM (#41772960)
I would think there are other advantages to large numbers of cheap drones too.

Trying to defend against 3x-10x as many enemies brings its own challenges, even if each one is less lethal.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by closewith on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:05PM (#41773150)
The reality is that Ukraine is producing 300,000+ drones per month, so the ratio is closer to 10,000:1 cheap drones to Switchblades.

No Western military is prepared for a ground war with hundreds of thousands of drone attacks per day, which is what near peer would mean now.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by throwaway2037 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @07:39AM (#41797827)
I think you make some excellent points here. Small nitpick: According to the Ukrainian gov't, they can currently produce half that amount: 150k per month. That is still an incredible number.

Ref: https://kyivindependent.com/deputy-minister-ukraine-can-prod...

I do think this war must be making any sufficiently advanced military rethink their ground game to include a lot of cheap FPV drones with attached explosives.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by closewith on Friday October 11, 2024 @05:04AM (#41807692)
While 150,000 per month was true in March, now Ukraine claims 4 MM per year, or ~333,000 per month.

https://thedefensepost.com/2024/10/03/ukraine-produce-millio...

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by torginus on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:43AM (#41774402)
I just wonder how much does professional image comes into play. I can't imagine US troops using drones which are basically a bunch of PCBs screwed together and mounted to a sheet of laser cut carbon fiber, even if those things are technically the most cost effective way to build a drone.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jajko on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:32AM (#41774634)
Switchblade 300 definitely underperformed and disappointed, many many reports from Ukraine frontline, they preferred using normal Mavic 3 drones instead.

Switchblade 600 is a bit better but still overpriced what civilian market can deliver at a fraction of a cost, in vast numbers, not blocked by various political negotiations etc.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by onepointsixC on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:33AM (#41777205)
What civilian market drone has the 8.5kg explosive payload of a Javelin warhead? Because that’s what the Switchblade 600 has.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by throwaway2037 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @07:46AM (#41797872)
I just confirmed from the Switchblade 600 website: It can carry 15kg of "munition". Ref: https://avinc.com/lms/switchblade-600
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by fullspectrumdev on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:10AM (#41774863)
Switchblade cost closer to 50k$, its payload was around 100 grams of explosive, and its range and success rate in the electronic warfare heavy environment of Ukraine are lower than a 300$ FPV that can carry 1.5kg of explosive.

Switchblade was designed for a different war entirely.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Retric on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:17PM (#41772146)
Lightly modified FPVs with grenades are a major concern for soldiers, but so are mortars and artillery shells etc. There’s a lot of low cost long range weapons vs infantry, but a drone with a grenade isn’t really effective vs tanks etc. A fleet of cheap drones just don’t do anything if bomber aircraft can simply fly higher than they can reach.

Leave the realm of mass production and you can build drones that would be, but they quickly start looking like existing systems because militaries have been working with drones since WWII.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bhickey on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:38PM (#41772285)
> but a drone with a grenade isn’t really effective vs tanks

You may be thinking of AP grenades, but broadly speaking this isn't true. UA has been dropping RKG-3 anti-tank grenades since early in the invasion. Any drone with a 3 pound lift capacity can knock out armor.

https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-cheap-grenades-expensive-tan...

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Retric on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:02AM (#41773715)
Can a RKG-3 in the right situation knock out some armor, definitely. But they don’t seem to be that effective vs amor designed to deal with shaped charges such as you’d see with a peer adversary.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by scanny on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:05PM (#41780070)
Those shaped charges weren’t envisioned coming from directly above, especially precisely dropped on the engine or on hatches, hence the drones are hitting spots with little to no armour compared to the front and sides.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Retric on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @03:13PM (#41791574)
The Bofors RBS 56 BILL (1988), FGM-148 Javelin and similar missile systems exploited weak top armor long enough ago to result in changes to modern tank designs.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top-attack

The KF51 Panther revealed 2022 should represent the current state of the art. comprising a hard-kill element of extending the coverage of the ADS to the roof of the vehicle for protection against ATGMs and unguided anti-tank rockets launched from higher elevations, as well as a soft-kill element for protection against threats such as loitering munitions.[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panther_KF51

Obviously getting 100% accurate information on current tank armor isn’t realistic but at minimum these drones aren’t breaking new ground.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by onepointsixC on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:35PM (#41772265)
Switchblade 600’s have the same warhead as the Javelin. With 8.5kg of explosives, it’s an entirely different category of weapon than the drones you’re thinking of which had closer to 200g of explosives.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by torginus on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:41AM (#41774396)
There are drones with shaped charges.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by onepointsixC on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:16AM (#41777042)
You need mass on target to reliably kill heavily armored targets. A drone dropping grenades doesn’t have that payload capacity.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by throwaway2037 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @07:54AM (#41797925)
Can I ask a stupid question about shaped charges? I assume they only work on a very fast projectile, like a tank shell. Would they work from a (relatively) slow drone?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nradov on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:10PM (#41772834)
FPV drones can only work at short ranges (line of sight) or in permissive EW environments. So, not as relevant to a future conflict with China.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by 05 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:17AM (#41774559)
There are fiber optic FPV drones now with up to 10km range.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by m4rtink on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:47PM (#41773041)
While the regular Switchblade is essentially a glorified flying granade, many FPVs use RPG7 warhwads and are regularly used to take out tanks (possibly using multiple hits, but still).

Also there is a trend recently to see more and more AA FPVs taking down Russian recon drones, some flying up to 3 km high! This already had an interesting side effects of many such drones being covered by expletives or even fake Ukrainian markings - did not really help.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by wongarsu on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:25PM (#41772586)
Currently most air-defense systems heavily depend on rockets, so you can just send more of those cheap easy targets than the enemy air defense has loaded rockets.

Of course everyone sees this happening in Russia right now and is adapting their next generation, if they weren't already doing so. But that will only shift the sweet-spot for saturation attacks, not eliminating them

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nine_k on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:59PM (#41772786)
The Israel's "Iron Dome" is supposed to include lasers, and they did use lasers to shoot down incoming rockets. In a stationary setting, like a factory or a bridge, lasers can be hard to overload, with their fast targeting, straight-line shooting, and the cost of a shot measured in single dollars. Small / cheap / slow drones with 1-2 kg payload would be an easy target.

Tanks / APCs / IMVs / other armored devices that go close to the front line seem like having much more of an existential crisis.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bluGill on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:24PM (#41772913)
Tanks and the other things you list do much better when used by well trained troops in ways that the trainers tell you to. russia isn't doing that so they look bad but that is russia not the concept
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hajile on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:12AM (#41773758)
You're talking about a year ago. Today, Russia has the largest and most experienced infantry on the planet.

Ukraine tried NATO tactics in last year's offensive and got slaughtered. If they'd tried to bunch up even closer (as some NATO generals were pushing for), the losses would have been far worse inside of those kill boxes. It's not training. Tanks are trivial for spotter drones to find at which point they can die to stuff like drones dropping RPG shells onto the weak upper armor (even the most modern Abrams tanks can be penetrated easily) or even just calling in an artillery strike. The best case for either of these attacks is very often a mission kill and the worst case is a complete loss.

Tanks made to fight other tanks are a dead end. The future is pure infantry support. You want something with more armor than a Bradley so it can't be taken out without specialized weapons and with enough firepower to be a must-answer threat, so a bigger cannon than the one on the Bradley is needed. Rifled barrels should probably make an appearance again because they offer better accuracy and HESH rounds are great for infantry support and fortification busting. It also needs to haul troops because you can't afford an extra vehicle that can't hold troops. Merkava shows a path in that direction.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:31AM (#41775002)
Ukraine tried Ukrainian tactics two months ago and found no Russian army at all.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bluGill on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:55AM (#41776334)
Russia has some evperienced infantry but they have and are using a lot of untrain troops. Even their well train infantry is often still being use wrong for the training. Every military commentator who has credentials to believe they know something [as opposed to say me who doesn't] notes how poorly trained most russians are. This is not soviet war doctine which russia knows and worries nato, it is something new and not expected.

NATO tactics have never been used as those start with air power which ukraine doesn't have. NATO hasn't always given good advice but this isn't the way they would fight.

ukrane is using tanks as they are made to fight. That isn't fight other tanks if there is any other option. tanks in previous world wars were fighting tanks but not today. Russia is sometimes using tanks like that and there they do well.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hajile on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:34AM (#41777216)
The only military commentators saying Russian troops are untrained are pretty ignorant and biased. Russia certainly sent untrained troops in the early part of the war, but most of them were by mistake and got recalled quickly. Russia recognized the need to train their troops (they only sent 100k troops and planned on an early peace that Boris Johnson scuttled).

To buy training time, they hired Wagner. Wagner needed bodies, so they recruited untrained guys from prison to die for them (though some small percentage survived and are presumably still working for Wagner). After 6 months of this, the Russian training pipeline started pushing out troops at a steady pace and has been ever since.

This is in stark contrast to Ukraine where you get several videos every week from someone who was kidnapped off the streets and sent to die in the trenches 24-48 hours later. A couple guys on my dev team haven't left their homes in months (female family getting them stuff) because they are so afraid of getting shanghaied.

As to "used wrong for the training", everyone is training/preparing for the last war. Nobody is sure how to train for this war as the only part that has a historical analog is trench storming, but that was over 100 years ago and the tactics have changed.

Did ANYONE expect calvary to reappear? I don't think so, but Russian troops are dumping money into buying small motorcycles and dirt bikes so they can mount up and charge the enemy trenches.

The real issue for me is that Russia is working out how to fight the new style of war while we in the US are not. Russia is going to walk away from this war with a massive 1M+ army of seasoned veterans while we can barely muster around 70k of active infantry most of whom aren't veterans and NONE with combat experience in the new way of war.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:14AM (#41777611)
This is in stark contrast to Ukraine where you get several videos every week from someone who was kidnapped off the streets and sent to die in the trenches 24-48 hours later.

You mean "sent to training". It definitely seems strange to suggest that Russia has a smooth, efficient "training pipeline", while Ukrainians are brutally sent "to die in the trenches". As if their onboarding process is in any way different, or newly trained Russian soldiers aren't also being sent to die in trenches.

We all know what war entails, so there's no need for weird, emotionally manipulative language like this.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bluGill on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:50AM (#41777365)
Russia is still sending about 1000 troops to the front lines every day with a week or two of training. I guess that isn't completely untrained, but it is the next thing to and the death totals show that lack.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nine_k on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:36PM (#41773320)
Russian troops are definitely poorly prepared. Likely Saddam's troops were in a better shape in 1991, when the same tanks clashed in Kuwait: Abramses and Chieftains vs T-72s and T-80s. Then the Western tanks showed an overwhelming advantage. Now about a quarter of Abrams tanks in Ukraine were rendered inoperable, some of them plainly destroyed. Tanks did become more vulnerable to anti-tank weapons.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jandrewrogers on Monday October 07, 2024 @11:37PM (#41773614)
In fairness, the Abrams in the Ukraine are ancient export-version M1A1s. The current US standard is A2v4. Other than basic shape, the technology is completely different and several decades apart, the armor bears almost no relation. A lot of the old export Abrams had armor similar to the Israeli Merkava tanks, it didn’t have a lot of similarity to what the US used.

Something that gets lost in these discussions is that the US does continuous “Ship of Theseus” upgrades to their systems and they mostly don’t export the state-of-the-art. Abrams armor in US systems is regularly completely replaced with new tech but the details are classified and not exported.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by vasac on Monday October 07, 2024 @11:36PM (#41773613)
There were no T-80s in Iraq or Kuwait.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simiones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:07AM (#41775557)
The Iron Dome was easily overwhelmed with the ~200 ballistic rockets fired by Iran recently, many of which hit the military bases they were targeting. So it I think the point stands.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by onepointsixC on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:38AM (#41777246)
Iron Dome is for rockets like the one Hamas fires, not for short range and intermediate range ballistic missiles like what Iran fired. Those are very different things and have different requirements. You may as well be talking about body armor ineffectiveness against a tank shell.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nradov on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:07PM (#41772818)
That only works in areas like Europe and the Middle East where targets are relatively close. For drones to be relevant in the Pacific fight they'll have to be much larger, faster, and smarter; and thus more expensive.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by sidewndr46 on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:36PM (#41771846)
I live in the US. A near-peer conflict involves a nuclear exchange. The world will change in ways forever that none of us can ever foresee at that point.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by krisoft on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:47PM (#41771925)
> The world will change in ways forever that none of us can ever foresee at that point.

Nukes are not magic. Of course we can foresee many of the changes a nuclear exchange would bring. Especially on the “planning for war” level.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by marginalia_nu on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:21PM (#41772171)
Worth noting that Russia has nuclear weapons, yet elects not to use them against their near peer Ukraine.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by WillAdams on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:31PM (#41772246)
Worth noting that Ukraine had nuclear weapons and negotiated them away in exchange for a promise that Russia would not use nuclear weapons against them.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nostrademons on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:13PM (#41772514)
Worth also noting that the nuclear weapons that Ukraine had were useless. All modern (post-1960s) nukes except the UK's are equipped with PALs [1]. Without the launch codes, they are just very expensive hunks of lithium deuteride. The launch codes for Ukraine's nukes remained with the KGB/FSB in Moscow throughout the breakup of the Soviet Union. They had essentially zero negotiating leverage, and as a result got essentially zero out of the negotiation.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permissive_action_link

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by lamontcg on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:28PM (#41772600)
"This is the lockpicking lawyer, and what we have here today is the PAL from the reentry vehicle of a Russian R-36M ICBM..."
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:31PM (#41772618)
Without the launch codes they still had highly enriched weapons grade nuclear material. That’s the tough part. Making it go bang we figured out in the 1940s.

We also saw with DVD encryption that physical access to the device makes it tough to fully protect. Nuclear codes are protected significantly by “no one gets to tinker with the device without rapid lead poisoning”.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nostrademons on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:43PM (#41772701)
Enriching uranium is within the capability of a nation-state the size of Ukraine. If Iran and North Korea can do it, Ukraine certainly can. Hell, even today, in the midst of a war, they have 8 operational reactors at 3 power plants, plus 2 under construction, one damaged and recently repaired, 6 at the Zaporizhzhia power plant in contested territory, and 4 in the decommissioned Chernobyl plant.

Physical access to a nuke does not let you disable the PAL. They are constructed so that they are embedded within the device, and cannot be disabled or altered without deconstructing significant parts of the warhead. (I suspect that the PAL is not actually a separate device that can be separated from the warhead, but a series of design choices for how the warhead is constructed that make it unable to fire without the input of a cryptographic code. But then, details on this are very highly classified for obvious reasons, so we'll never know for sure.)

The real reason they didn't and don't do this is because they don't want to end up an international pariah state like Iran and North Korea. It's very clear that the U.S. has a vested interest in nuclear non-proliferation; they were the ones who gave the PALs to all our adversaries in the first place, because in the game-theoretic calculus of MAD, a small number of enemies that you can bargain and reason with is better than a large number of nuclear states even if many of those states are on your side. We would not have supported Ukraine if they attempted to retain the nukes in the 1990s, and we wouldn't support them developing nukes now.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:10PM (#41772832)
> Enriching uranium is within the capability of a nation-state the size of Ukraine.

Sure. But standing up a program makes you an international pariah. “We’re keeping this” would have had a bit less uproar.

> Physical access to a nuke does not let you disable the PAL. They are constructed so that they are embedded within the device, and cannot be disabled or altered without deconstructing significant parts of the warhead.

People say this sort of thing, but it comes out that the US arsenal was set to 00000000 in fear that they couldn’t be used. I have… severe doubts on the uncrackable nature of Soviet nuclear cryptography.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:40AM (#41775061)
Ukraine is free to develop nukes for self-defence because it's attacked by nuclear country.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simiones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:22AM (#41775694)
No country in the world is free to develop nukes, for any reason. Some still do, of course, but it is expressly forbidden by international laws and agreements.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:46AM (#41776265)
Except Ukraine, because Ukraine invaded by nuclear country. Read the agreement, please.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:08AM (#41776439)
Quote from the agreement, please.

https://treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/Volume%203007/P...

Nothing in it says anything like "if broken, Ukraine can have a nuclear program".

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:53AM (#41776823)
Кожний Учасник цього Договору в порядку здійснення свого державного суверенітету має право вийти з Договору, якщо він вирішить, що пов'язані зі змістом цього Договору виняткові обставини поставили під загрозу найвищі інтереси його країни. Про такий вихід він повідомляє за три місяці всіх Учасників Договору і Раду Безпеки Організації Об'єднаних Націй. В такому повідомленні має міститися заява про виняткові обставини, які він розглядає як такі, що поставили під загрозу його найвищі інтереси.

Загроза силою чи її використання проти територіальної цілісності та недоторканності кордонів чи політичної незалежності України з боку будь-якої ядерної держави, так само, як і застосування економічного тиску, спрямованого на те, щоб підкорити своїм власним інтересам здійснення Україною прав, притаманних її суверенітету, розглядатимуться Україною як виняткові обставини, що поставили під загрозу її найвищі інтереси.

Цей Закон набирає чинності після надання Україні ядерними державами гарантій безпеки, оформлених шляхом підписання відповідного міжнародно-правового документа.

Machine translation (Gemma2):

Each Participant of this Treaty, in the exercise of its state sovereignty, has the right to withdraw from the Treaty if it determines that exceptional circumstances related to the content of this Treaty have threatened the supreme interests of its country. Such withdrawal shall be notified to all Participants of the Treaty and the Security Council of the United Nations three months in advance. The notification shall contain a statement on the exceptional circumstances which it considers to threaten its supreme interests.

Threat of force or its use against the territorial integrity and inviolability of borders or political independence of Ukraine by any nuclear state, as well as the application of economic pressure aimed at subjugating the exercise by Ukraine of rights inherent in its sovereignty to its own interests, shall be considered by Ukraine as exceptional circumstances that threaten its supreme interests.

This Act shall enter into force after Ukraine has received security assurances from nuclear states, formalized through the signing of a relevant international legal document.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:24AM (#41777107)
That's a separate agreement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_on_the_Prohibition_of_N....

It cannot be withdrawn mid-conflict:

https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/ihl-treaties/tpnw-2017/art...

> Such withdrawal shall only take effect 12 months after the date of the receipt of the notification of withdrawal by the Depositary. If, however, on the expiry of that 12-month period, the withdrawing State Party is a party to an armed conflict, the State Party shall continue to be bound by the obligations of this Treaty and of any additional protocols until it is no longer party to an armed conflict.

Ukraine also isn't a signatory to it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_parties_to_the_Treaty_...

Which specific agreement are you trying to quote from, because it's not the Budapest Memorandom?

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:21AM (#41777687)
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:57PM (#41780552)
OK, that one is the original 1968 treaty they acceded to after leavin the Soviet Union. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_on_the_Non-Proliferatio....

As with any treaty, it can be broken/withdrawn from.

The treaty does not establish a right/recourse to a nuclear weapons program to NPT members in Ukraine's scenario. Ukraine just, when agreeing to it, said they'd leave if they had to. They would be non-compliant with the treaty, as North Korea was/is.

The Budapest Memorandom was a separate agreement, predicated on acceptance of the NPT. Similarly, nothing in it says "you can have a nuclear weapons program in scenario x".

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @12:18AM (#41784465)
Ukraine can join NPT back in exchange for safety assurances. No need for sanctions.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:25PM (#41790393)
If Ukraine started a nuclear weapons program, they would be in violation of the NPT treaty. Sanctions and loss of Western support would be virtually guaranteed.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Thursday October 10, 2024 @12:34AM (#41795537)
Ukraine is not bound by NPT because we are attacked by nuclear country. See text of NPT signed by Ukraine.

Moreover, Ukraine is post-nuclear country. We had nuclear weapons and we know how to produce more.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Thursday October 10, 2024 @01:31AM (#41795839)
But you understand this part, right?

Sanctions and loss of Western support would be virtually guaranteed.

Talk about biting the hand that feeds.

Seriously, this whole nuclear idea you're onto, while no doubt well-intentioned, is infinitely untenable for a whole bunch of plainly obvious reasons.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:22AM (#41799791)
Ukraine may claim damages. Nuclear countries promised security assurances, then broke them. We have $1T in damages from war.

> Sanctions and loss of Western support would be virtually guaranteed.

This will be a good case to support the claims. Moreover, this support will be unnecessary for a nuclear country, because war will be ended very fast.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Thursday October 10, 2024 @04:29PM (#41803237)
Except it's just not going to happen. I don't believe in the stupid propaganda (that gets repeated here almost every week) that Ukraine was manipulated into this war, by Boris or anyone else. Ukraine is entirely independent and makes its own choices.

But the simple fact is, it doesn't have unlimited control over its destiny in this particular regard, and pretending otherwise won't change that fact. It is entirely dependent on Western help at this point -- its benefactors are 1000 percent against any further nuclear proliferation, and are infinitely more concerned about that issue than they are about the borders of Ukraine, or Ukraine's survival in any other sense. They have no interest in the inevitable and far wider confrontation with Russia that would ensue from such recklessness -- and they just aren't going to allow it.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:49PM (#41805895)
Yep, high dependency on Western help is a problem, which must be solved first.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Thursday October 10, 2024 @08:28AM (#41798153)
Ukraine is bound by the NPT until they exit it. That hasn’t happened so far.

Exiting it would lead to consequences from their allies, which they can’t afford.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Thursday October 10, 2024 @11:19AM (#41799765)
It's not so simple, because Ukraine will join NPT when we will have security assurances from nuclear countries. It found recently, that security assurances, given to Ukraine, either a) broken, b) fake, so Ukraine may claim that the essential step is not completed yet.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Thursday October 10, 2024 @01:54PM (#41801392)
Ukraine already joined the NPT, in the 1990s. That's a done deal.

Ukraine does not automatically leave the NPT just because Russia violated the Budapest Memorandum; such a mechanism linking the two does not exist. Ukraine would have to explicitly leave the NPT, which they will not do.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Thursday October 10, 2024 @02:50PM (#41802060)
It's not a deal. It's cheat to disarm Ukraine. It's stupid to play fair game with cheaters.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by onepointsixC on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:07AM (#41777531)
The US invaded Iraq, because of the phantom prospect of a nuclear proliferation. A state which was just created and gave up Crimea without a shot fired in 2014 was not about to fight to keep nukes which were not theirs in the 90’s. With the combined forces of the West and Russia breathing down their necks there was zero chance that they would be able to keep them.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @05:01PM (#41792565)
North Korea serves as a pretty clear counterexample.

Having nukes actually in-hand changes the calculus, a lot.

They'd have been sanctioned like crazy, but invaded? No one's taking the risk that they managed to arm a bomb.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bluGill on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:27PM (#41772924)
Ukrain could have replaced those part if they wanted. Not worth the effort IMHO but they could have.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bee_rider on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:46PM (#41772330)
The Bucharest memorandum contained the promises that:

- None of the countries (US, UK, and Russia) would threaten Ukraine’s territory

- If nuclear weapons were used against them, or they were threatened by nuclear weapons, the other signatories would “Seek immediate Security Council action to provide assistance”

Among other promises. So it seems like they’ve already had their promises violated.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by epolanski on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:26PM (#41772587)
Didn't china and France sign it too?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by nradov on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:52PM (#41773408)
China and France didn't formally sign the Budapest Memorandum. They made separate statements generally in support but aren't obligated to take any real action.

https://warontherocks.com/2015/06/the-budapest-memorandum-an...

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bee_rider on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:28PM (#41779678)
I can’t believe I mixed up Budapest and Bucharest :(
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by cjbgkagh on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:37PM (#41772280)
The old ‘Russia will not use nukes because they have not used nukes’ routine so people can feel safer about poking the bear. There is always a first time and I’m very thankful that it hasn’t happed yet.

To me a near peer implies that either side has a good chance of losing the war. It’s my opinion that Russia has not yet been at a real risk of losing this war and thus has not yet had a need to use nuclear weapons. I’m aware that the NAFO line is that Ukraine still has this in the bag - but I still don’t see a Ukrainian victory as a likely.

I assume this is why the gp post suggested ‘near peer’ implies nukes.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by kspacewalk2 on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:09PM (#41773171)
Both the US and the USSR lost major wars during the Cold War without resorting to nuking their opponent when they felt they were "at a real risk of losing a war". In Vietnam and Korea, the Soviet involvement was considerably more than the current Western involvement in countering the Ukraine invasion. Soviet pilots on Soviet planes killed Americans in American planes. Soviet operators of Soviet-made SAM sites shut down American planes as well.

The reality is that nuclear weapons are a deterrent against existential threats, and all else is a bluff. So it's not a risk of losing this war that will push Russia to commit such murder-suicide, but an existential threat to its own survival as a nation.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bigfudge on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:34AM (#41775019)
I mostly agree, but it does assume rational actors in charge. If the goal of conflict is to cement the position of a dictatorial elite, it’s not clear to me that ‘smaller scale’ nuclear exchanges are ruled out, especially if leaders are isolated, paranoid etc.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by kspacewalk2 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:34PM (#41779746)
Ever since the US made crystal clear that a nuclear strike against Ukraine will mean the US annihilating all Russian forces in Ukraine by conventional means, such small scale nuclear exchange is in fact ruled out. This will in effect invite Russia to simply swallow such a devastating blow, or else end it all. Russia is in fact ruled by rational actors, so it rationally backed off. Thus in effect proving its rationality and the emptiness of its "but what if we're insane" bluff. They're not insane.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simiones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:19AM (#41775667)
> The reality is that nuclear weapons are a deterrent against existential threats, and all else is a bluff. So it's not a risk of losing this war that will push Russia to commit such murder-suicide, but an existential threat to its own survival as a nation.

Note that there have been numerous documented cases of near nuclear launches, especially in the 60s and 70s, it is by no means a bluff or an idle risk.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by kspacewalk2 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:30PM (#41779713)
It is certainly a bluff. Accidents or misunderstandings aside, the only time the US chose to press the issue as it were was when it faced a serious threat to having its nuclear deterrent rendered completely ineffective (Cuban missile crisis). No one's launched nukes because of non-nuclear events in Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan or Cuba, and no one will seriously contemplate it over losing pieces of eastern Ukraine or Crimea. Even taking the war into Russia proper won't do the trick, murder-suicide is only on the table when the threat is existential.

The bluff does, however, work very well in slowing down and dissuading Western help to Ukraine by cultivating the "don't do X else nukes tomorrow" memes and propaganda talking points. Very effective foreign policy tool for a nuclear-armed fascist dictatorship, other will certainly take note for future invasions.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by onepointsixC on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:02AM (#41777488)
The Russians haven’t used nukes because they’ve been told under no uncertain terms what would happen if they did.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hajile on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:16AM (#41778269)
Are the French going to destroy their country and kill most of their people for Ukraine? The English? Germans? Anyone in Europe?

I can assure you that we in the US aren't going to commit global suicide over Ukraine.

Remember that we were all set to sign off on using UK/American missiles to hit targets in Russia. Then Putin said he'd view that as an attack by the UK/America and would use nukes. We immediately backtracked and said our policy wouldn't be changing (Biden seemed particularly unhappy about the announcement).

If you know about the whole no-nonsense, "strong leader" mentality in that region, this wouldn't be a mystery. Putin making fake red lines would severely damage him politically. Look at Ukraine. He said he'd invade if they tried joining NATO. We claimed they were and Putin invaded even though it has cost his country a fortune.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by onepointsixC on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:26PM (#41779663)
Funny thing about deterrence conversations in the west is that it’s so often characterized as a one way street. That the west can be deterred limitlessly and that others like Russia are impervious to deterrence. As if Putin were some fearless automaton with complete confidence. Because if anything spells confidence it’s having 4 out of 5 of your latest in service ICBM tests fail, including the most recent. Just how confident is Putin, having personally fostered such an endemically corrupt society, in his recently manufactured pits? Russia’s pursuit of a nuclear powered drone that would attempt to be a weapon of mass destruction by virtue of creating an irradiated tsunami reveals an intense fear of the credibility of their current deterrence.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by LtWorf on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:53PM (#41781153)
The french are actually trying to drag the rest of EU into war because they lost their colonies to russia.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @05:28PM (#41782001)
That's a caricature. These countries haven't been colonies for decades, and Russia's efforts to gain influence in these places isn't "colonial" either.

It's something else - a new game with different rules. You can decry/condemn it this influence-jockeying all want, but if you can't get past 19th/20th century idioms and imagery about how the world operates, you'll never get anywhere in your analysis.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by LtWorf on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:07PM (#41784120)
Ah yes, it's "territories" nowadays. It's completely the same besides the name!
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:42PM (#41784298)
No, they're called "countries" actually. I highly doubt you'd get very far with this "territory" label if you were to bring it up in a discussion with anyone actually from these places.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by LtWorf on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @04:23AM (#41785668)
Wait you're unaware that france has territories???? Please do some reading before doing the lecturing, it might be more pleasant for everyone involved.

I guess you're also completely unaware of the shenanigans they pull to avoid giving independence.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @11:12AM (#41788751)
Mais bien sur, but they aren't the places Russia has been trying to gain influence in.

I'm not lecturing about anything, and it seems you're jumping to a whole bunch of unwarranted conclusions here.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by keybored on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:28PM (#41779682)
Everyone is worried about the desperation nuke. Yet all nukes in history have been to teabag civilians once you’re already winning.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by keybored on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:37PM (#41779778)
Slightly more serious. There have been times where we’ve gotten close during the Cold War. You can’t trust people to not use nukes on account of it being suicidal. People can be irrational like that. And/or chains of command can be irrational.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Spooky23 on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:06PM (#41772477)
Given the decay of Russia and their forces, it’s questionable whether they would work.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:32PM (#41772625)
Even if 99% are non-functional it’s a significant threat.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by epolanski on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:32PM (#41772626)
No I don't think it is.

They have detonated more than 800 nukes in their history, ballistic ones from subs since 60 years ago, and have almost 2k warheads deployed.

Don't confuse the fact that they tend to start and conduct wars poorly, until cornered, with complete ineptitude.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by JohnBooty on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:56PM (#41773099)
Right, but when is the last time they detonated one? What is the current status of their stockpile and the infrastructure required to launch it and strike a target thousands of miles away?

Nuclear missiles have a lot of stuff that degrades over time. The plutonium. The conventional chemical explosives. The electronics. Were their nukes even designed to be serviced 25, 50 years in the future?

Russia went through quite a bit of economic difficulty in the waning years of communism and in the years after communism. The state of their other big expensive military toys (their navy, etc) and even their ability to equip their infantry on a personal level seems to be pretty far from ideal.

I'm not telling you that Russia doesn't have functional nukes, and it's certainly not a bluff that other nations can afford to call, but I think it's a very legitimate question.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by swagasaurus-rex on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:43AM (#41773911)
Safe to say they probably got more than one functional nuke, which is more than enough for concern.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by malfist on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:29PM (#41773283)
Sure, they might be inept now, but wait until they're desperate!
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by tomjen3 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:33AM (#41773863)
russia is completely corrupt. Nuke upkeep is expensive and is an obvious area for corruption (you will only know at the end of the world). There is zero reason that more than a handful has actually been maintained.

Not to mention that their recent launch was a bit - eh.

The Soviet Union was evil, but it was somewhat competent. The russian regime is not.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hollerith on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:35AM (#41774360)
I've never heard any expert in nuclear weapons suggest that Russian nukes don't work, especially the ones that have been modernized since the fall of the SU, which is all the ones attached to ICBMs and SLBMs. Until a few years ago, US nuke experts regularly inspected Russian nukes and Russian nuke delivery systems. If Russian nukes don't work, it seems likely that the inspectors would have been able to tell, e.g., through gamma-ray spectrography.

The ICBMs and SLBMs to "deliver" the nukes are more expensive and harder to develop them the nukes themselves, and Russia routinely tests those.

"harder to develop": London, not having had as much money to spend on nukes as the US and USSR had, gets its SLBMs (along with the launch tubes) from the US (whereas they make their own nukes and SLBM-carrying subs) and a few minutes of searching finds no signs of them ever developing an ICBM. (In fact, they might never have had ICBMs: they certainly don't now.)

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by rjsw on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:16AM (#41774907)
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hollerith on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:41AM (#41777270)
Thanks.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by jabl on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:56AM (#41774208)
OTOH current day Russia doesn't have the yoke of communism around their neck. Is the level of corruption worse than the economic inefficiency of communism? I don't know, possibly?

As for nukes, nuclear saber rattling seems to be one of the few remaining reasons the rest of the world gives a f*ck about whatever Putin and his cronies are saying. Without nukes, the West would have massively stepped up support for Ukraine, and the Russian army would be nothing but a breadcrumb of smoldering wrecks all the way to Siberia. So I'd think that Putin has a huge incentive to keep his nuclear deterrent functional, no matter how corrupt and inept the rest of his armed forces are.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:39AM (#41775050)
Yep, but thos ICBM's are developed by Ukraine and need regular (every 10 years) maintenance to be performed in Dnipro, Ukraine.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:35AM (#41777224)
That's not the case for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RS-28_Sarmat.

The one you describe - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R-36_(missile) - is being actively phased out.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:29AM (#41777777)
Quote from Wikipedia about Sarmat:

> Despite the Russian claims that the missile is on 'combat alert', since its 2022 flight test, it has experienced four failed tests, the most recent on 21 September 2024

We have the short opportunity window, when Satana stopped to work and Sarmat is not working yet.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:54AM (#41778014)
I think it'd be a pretty big mistake to interpret "it needs servicing every ten years" as "it stops working immediately after that", and similarly a mistake to think the Russians can't accomplish at least some of that maintenance themselves. One can run a car without oil changes for quite a while before the problems add up.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:13AM (#41778230)
Even one nuke is a big threat for a non-nuclear country, but Russia is not the only one with nukes, so number of well maintained nukes in service is important, if RF want to win a war with nukes. It will be pretty dumb for RF to strike FIRST with expired nukes.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:31AM (#41778463)
There's no winning a war with nukes.

Even if 1% are operational, they could devastate the US.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:09PM (#41778923)
War with imperial Japan was won with nukes.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:16PM (#41779543)
Because Japan had exactly zero nukes to send back at the US.

Russia has 2000. What percentage of them are you willing to gamble are working? Are 10% of them working? That's 200 US cities.

So, no. We are absolutely not going to follow your logic. There is too much chance that they have enough nukes working to make us infinitely regret a nuclear exchange.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by oneshtein on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @10:41AM (#41788418)
Yep, but Ukraine took the risk, invaded RF, and we are still alive.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by ceejayoz on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:35PM (#41780367)
That is a pretty clear edge case we can’t duplicate today.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bee_rider on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:41PM (#41772298)
Ukraine was not considered to be a near peer to Russia before the war. It seems likely that they thought they’d have a quick win. Possibly, whatever it is they are after, it isn’t worth the pariah status using nuclear weapons would produce. (Or maybe they still think they can get it done conventionally).
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by HKH2 on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:58PM (#41773113)
America lost the Vietnam war. Do you think Vietnam is America's near peer?

Also, if you're not sure what they're after: Russia has been systematically driving Ukraine forces out of the Donbas because the Donbas has been shelled indiscriminately by Ukrainian forces since 2014. You can argue there's more to it than that, but that's their perspective.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:26PM (#41773262)
That's their claimed perspective. Unfortunately Russia's current regime tends to lie a lot, and there's no reason to take anything it says at face value. "Indiscriminate shelling of the Donbas (by Ukrainian forces)" is one of its many talking points that lots of people like to repeat, but which no one seems to be able to substantiate. Meanwhile reports of shelling by Russian forces are quite ample.

In any case: No, that's not why they went into the Donbas, or why they're trying to hold onto it.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by HKH2 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:47AM (#41773931)
America is way better at controlling the narrative.

Right now, Kursk is supposedly considered a major success by the Ukrainians. Let's see how that pans out.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bee_rider on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:08PM (#41773164)
> America lost the Vietnam war. Do you think Vietnam is America's near peer?

I was responding to somebody who said Ukraine was Russian’s near-peer. I didn’t say they should be considered peers now, just that they certainly weren’t when the choice was made to go to war.

The Vietnam War was like 50 years ago. Who cares, sure, I don’t have any investment in whether or not the US and Vietnam were peers decades before I was born. Vietnam certainly has an impressive record.

> Also, if you're not sure what they're after: Russia has been systematically driving Ukraine forces out of the Donbas because the Donbas has been shelled indiscriminately by Ukrainian forces since 2014. You can argue there's more to it than that, but that's their perspective.

They also seem to be trying to get entrenched in Crimea, and IIRC brought up the idea of some promise that Ukraine wouldn’t ever going NATO, although don’t remember if that was a serious proposal or what.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by HKH2 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:39AM (#41773890)
> I didn’t say they should be considered peers now

You implied it.

> The Vietnam War was like 50 years ago. Who cares, sure, I don’t have any investment in whether or not the US and Vietnam were peers decades before I was born. Vietnam certainly has an impressive record.

America clearly wasn't using anywhere near all of the power it had. Neither is Russia now.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bigfudge on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:31AM (#41775001)
It seems like they are fairly close to their non-nuclear limits though. I guess they could fuel air bomb Kiev but that would likely change the calculus re nato involvement so is not obviously an aid to their cause.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:54AM (#41776321)
Neither is Russia now.

An entirely supported belief.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bee_rider on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:08AM (#41776440)
>> I didn’t say they should be considered peers now

> You implied it.

No I didn’t. I left that unaddressed because I don’t care to argue it either way, or consider it relevant to my overall point.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by onepointsixC on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:04AM (#41777507)
Vietnam war was fought on the other side of the planet, an ocean away. Ukrainian war is fought on the border of Russia and has resulted in Russian territory being occupied by a foreign power for the first time since WW2. These are very different things.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simiones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:16AM (#41775636)
> They also seem to be trying to get entrenched in Crimea, and IIRC brought up the idea of some promise that Ukraine wouldn’t ever going NATO, although don’t remember if that was a serious proposal or what.

NATO explicitly added plans to offer membership to Ukraine and Georgia at the Bucharest summit, and has been conducting joint military excercises with Ukraine ever since, the last one happening ~1 year before the Russian war of aggression started. The current huge NATO support for Ukraine also proves the military closeness - to the point that many of the major victories NATO weaponry firing NATO rockets with NATO targeting details to targets identified by NATO intelligence, only with Ukrainian soldiers pushing the trigger.

Not to justify Russia's clear war of aggression in any way, just explaining that Ukraine absolutely was, and likely still is, moving towards NATO membership.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:10AM (#41776451)
NATO explicitly added plans to offer membership to Ukraine and Georgia at the Bucharest summit,

That's the complete opposite of what happened. The key outcome of the Bucharest summit is that Ukraine and Georgia were explicitly denied Membership Action Plans, which would have been the crucial step needed to move their application forward. Instead they got kicked downstairs to "aspirational" status, which they both complained loudly and bitterly about. This was very, very big news at the time.

So no, Ukraine was not "absolutely moving toward membership" as of that date. They might be moving in a different direction now, but if so that's a result of the invasion, not the 2008 summit.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hajile on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:22AM (#41778346)
Russia never intended to take over Ukraine in 2022. 100-150k troops aren't enough to do that vs a country with that many people.

Their intent was a quick military action to either get an agreement from Zelensky not to join NATO and to give autonomy to the Donbas region or replace him with someone who would do those things. The lack of a troop recruiting and training pipeline until months into the war is especially damning evidence for this idea.

Putin was succeeding too. He had Zelensky's government at the table. The treaty was mostly signed, then Boris Johnson showed up and shut down the peace plan by promising lots of NATO equipment and support.

Ukraine was not considered a near-peer before the war because they are NOT a near-peer without our NATO equipment, our NATO intel organizations, our NATO operators on the ground, our NATO trainers, etc.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by HKH2 on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:46PM (#41773029)
Who are America's near peers then? Afghanistan? Vietnam?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by energy123 on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:04PM (#41772054)
> A near-peer conflict involves a nuclear exchange.

There are many steps on the escalation ladder before a nuclear exchange.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by Demiurge on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:10AM (#41773740)
How many steps would you guess are left between US and Russia?
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hnbad on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:58AM (#41775181)
Given that neither side has directly attacked the other yet? Almost all of them.

Using nuclear weapons against an opponent who has enough nuclear weapons to retaliate is a "flip over the chess board and stomp on the pieces" move. Presently the US isn't even playing against Russia, at best it's sitting behind Russia's opponent and whispering chess moves into their ear.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by energy123 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @05:51AM (#41775454)
There's also gradations of nuclear exchange, including a limited exchange (i.e. not against cities) that doesn't necessarily escalate to a strategic exchange. While obviously extremely dangerous and unpredictable, some think you can skirt that line successfully in a war.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by throwaway2037 on Thursday October 10, 2024 @08:01AM (#41797982)

    > gradations of nuclear exchange
This is the first time that I have seen this terminology. I tried to Google for it, but I cannot find any information about this idea. Are there any war college studies (US/Europe) that you can share?

Controversially, I don't think generals from either the US, nor Russia, would be willing to "pull the trigger" and launch a nuclear attack. Yes, I really think there would be a constitutional crisis where senior ministers and military leaders might stage an "instant" coup to prevent a nuclear attack.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by gertlex on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:45PM (#41771909)
Not sure that counts, as we're not using nuclear weapons in practice for current conflicts/engagements.

We have the whole other range of combat capabilities, and the distribution of those capabilities in our arsenal/armed forces seems guaranteed to change.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by sidewndr46 on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:48PM (#41771933)
Then it is just another proxy war, like the last half of the 20th century between major powers.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by JohnBooty on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:42PM (#41773008)

    A near-peer conflict involves a nuclear exchange
Respectfully, I think you're misunderstanding the term. The term is meant to represent the level of resources and weapons each combatant is bringing to the theater of conflict.

It does not mean that the two sides are necessarily using the most destructive possible weapons in their arsenals. A hypothetical US/China armed conflict over Taiwan (god forbid) would be "near-peer" even if neither side goes nuclear.

"Near-peer" is meant to distinguish that sort of conflict from, let's say, US vs. Taliban in Afghanistan where the two sides had vastly different levels of technology and capability.

Or maybe you're making the point that two nuclear states would be hard-pressed to fight an open war that did not devolve into a nuclear exchange. Which is a very valid concern. If that's your point, I apologize.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by andrewflnr on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:30PM (#41773291)
> Which is a very valid concern. If that's your point, I apologize.

It's a valid point to argue, but it does need to be argued, not assumed.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by lumost on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:57PM (#41773105)
This assumes that any party to a conflict chooses to use their nuclear arsenal. In WW2, both sides had chemical weapons but chose not to use them due to concerns of reciprocal strikes coupled with a perceived limited utility.

We could be entering a world where there is always a military alternative to nuclear weapons, leaving nukes in a state where their only utility is as a deterrent against another nuclear power using them.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by closewith on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:16PM (#41773214)
Or more importantly, refrained from use of chemical weapons against those who could retaliate in kind. Japan used chemical and biological weapons in China.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by preisschild on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:07AM (#41774515)
Not necessarily. Loosing a war is probably preferential to loosing your entire country, because mutually assured destruction using nukes is still a thing.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simiones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:25AM (#41775724)
There is no guarantee whatsoever that if Russia were to launch a nuke on Ukraine, the USA or any other country would launch one against Russia. If they launched one on the USA or a EU country, that would be a different matter.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by onepointsixC on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @09:44AM (#41777300)
The closest near peer to the US is China which strategically is significantly inferior to the US and would very much not like to get into a nuclear exchange. But conventionally it has more vessels than the USN, and with nearly all of them near China while the USN is all over the world, they have an advantage early in a Taiwan war. Conventional wars between nuclear powers can be fought and won.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by titanomachy on Monday October 07, 2024 @05:15PM (#41771148)
> near-peer

I prefer the Culture term “equiv-tech”

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by SJC_Hacker on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:04PM (#41771552)
Its not just tech but capability. You can give some random country F35s, that doesn't mean they are useful.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by pavlov on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:04PM (#41771546)
There’s something icky about discussing killing real people like it was fan fiction of a sci-fi franchise.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by AlbertCory on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:07PM (#41771565)
I guess you don't want to read anything by actual military people, then. Dehumanizing the enemy is a requirement for those folks.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simonh on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:52PM (#41771957)
That’s not the case. It happens, for sure. I know some hair raising army jokes, but plenty of military people recognise their opponents as people just the same.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by kergonath on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:29PM (#41771791)
It is also something that must be resisted, because that’s how you get war crimes and genocides.