News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bee_rider on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:41PM (#41772298)
Ukraine was not considered to be a near peer to Russia before the war. It seems likely that they thought they’d have a quick win. Possibly, whatever it is they are after, it isn’t worth the pariah status using nuclear weapons would produce. (Or maybe they still think they can get it done conventionally).
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by HKH2 on Monday October 07, 2024 @09:58PM (#41773113)
America lost the Vietnam war. Do you think Vietnam is America's near peer?

Also, if you're not sure what they're after: Russia has been systematically driving Ukraine forces out of the Donbas because the Donbas has been shelled indiscriminately by Ukrainian forces since 2014. You can argue there's more to it than that, but that's their perspective.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:26PM (#41773262)
That's their claimed perspective. Unfortunately Russia's current regime tends to lie a lot, and there's no reason to take anything it says at face value. "Indiscriminate shelling of the Donbas (by Ukrainian forces)" is one of its many talking points that lots of people like to repeat, but which no one seems to be able to substantiate. Meanwhile reports of shelling by Russian forces are quite ample.

In any case: No, that's not why they went into the Donbas, or why they're trying to hold onto it.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by HKH2 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:47AM (#41773931)
America is way better at controlling the narrative.

Right now, Kursk is supposedly considered a major success by the Ukrainians. Let's see how that pans out.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bee_rider on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:08PM (#41773164)
> America lost the Vietnam war. Do you think Vietnam is America's near peer?

I was responding to somebody who said Ukraine was Russian’s near-peer. I didn’t say they should be considered peers now, just that they certainly weren’t when the choice was made to go to war.

The Vietnam War was like 50 years ago. Who cares, sure, I don’t have any investment in whether or not the US and Vietnam were peers decades before I was born. Vietnam certainly has an impressive record.

> Also, if you're not sure what they're after: Russia has been systematically driving Ukraine forces out of the Donbas because the Donbas has been shelled indiscriminately by Ukrainian forces since 2014. You can argue there's more to it than that, but that's their perspective.

They also seem to be trying to get entrenched in Crimea, and IIRC brought up the idea of some promise that Ukraine wouldn’t ever going NATO, although don’t remember if that was a serious proposal or what.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by HKH2 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:39AM (#41773890)
> I didn’t say they should be considered peers now

You implied it.

> The Vietnam War was like 50 years ago. Who cares, sure, I don’t have any investment in whether or not the US and Vietnam were peers decades before I was born. Vietnam certainly has an impressive record.

America clearly wasn't using anywhere near all of the power it had. Neither is Russia now.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bigfudge on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:31AM (#41775001)
It seems like they are fairly close to their non-nuclear limits though. I guess they could fuel air bomb Kiev but that would likely change the calculus re nato involvement so is not obviously an aid to their cause.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:54AM (#41776321)
Neither is Russia now.

An entirely supported belief.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by bee_rider on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:08AM (#41776440)
>> I didn’t say they should be considered peers now

> You implied it.

No I didn’t. I left that unaddressed because I don’t care to argue it either way, or consider it relevant to my overall point.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by onepointsixC on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @10:04AM (#41777507)
Vietnam war was fought on the other side of the planet, an ocean away. Ukrainian war is fought on the border of Russia and has resulted in Russian territory being occupied by a foreign power for the first time since WW2. These are very different things.
Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by simiones on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:16AM (#41775636)
> They also seem to be trying to get entrenched in Crimea, and IIRC brought up the idea of some promise that Ukraine wouldn’t ever going NATO, although don’t remember if that was a serious proposal or what.

NATO explicitly added plans to offer membership to Ukraine and Georgia at the Bucharest summit, and has been conducting joint military excercises with Ukraine ever since, the last one happening ~1 year before the Russian war of aggression started. The current huge NATO support for Ukraine also proves the military closeness - to the point that many of the major victories NATO weaponry firing NATO rockets with NATO targeting details to targets identified by NATO intelligence, only with Ukrainian soldiers pushing the trigger.

Not to justify Russia's clear war of aggression in any way, just explaining that Ukraine absolutely was, and likely still is, moving towards NATO membership.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by aguaviva on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:10AM (#41776451)
NATO explicitly added plans to offer membership to Ukraine and Georgia at the Bucharest summit,

That's the complete opposite of what happened. The key outcome of the Bucharest summit is that Ukraine and Georgia were explicitly denied Membership Action Plans, which would have been the crucial step needed to move their application forward. Instead they got kicked downstairs to "aspirational" status, which they both complained loudly and bitterly about. This was very, very big news at the time.

So no, Ukraine was not "absolutely moving toward membership" as of that date. They might be moving in a different direction now, but if so that's a result of the invasion, not the 2008 summit.

Re:Is the Attack Helicopter Dead? by hajile on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:22AM (#41778346)
Russia never intended to take over Ukraine in 2022. 100-150k troops aren't enough to do that vs a country with that many people.

Their intent was a quick military action to either get an agreement from Zelensky not to join NATO and to give autonomy to the Donbas region or replace him with someone who would do those things. The lack of a troop recruiting and training pipeline until months into the war is especially damning evidence for this idea.

Putin was succeeding too. He had Zelensky's government at the table. The treaty was mostly signed, then Boris Johnson showed up and shut down the peace plan by promising lots of NATO equipment and support.

Ukraine was not considered a near-peer before the war because they are NOT a near-peer without our NATO equipment, our NATO intel organizations, our NATO operators on the ground, our NATO trainers, etc.