Who uses raw abstract percents? Even the meme version is much more competent than that: https://preview.redd.it/o1lktd5no9t61.jpg?width=640&crop=sma...
What color is the ball?
People who are #1 respond immediately, just as if you asked them about a real object in front of them. #4/#5 will ask “what do you mean what’s the color? I can imagine it to be a certain color” - in their head the ball is just an abstract concept labelled “ball”, it doesn’t have a color by itself.
And so many things I read about aphantasia are spot-on aligned with my own experience, but put into a comparative context I hadn't really thought about until the word was more or less invented a decade ago, and the idea leaked out into the internet. The line about "weaker autobiographical memories" in this article really hit home for me. I take so many photos now - thank goodness for digital photography - and in the context of this topic, it's no wonder.
I've also struggled to remember dreams, all my life - and also thought the 'counting sheep' thing never made sense, at all.
The thing I never got with the "Close your eyes, can you visualize a Red Star" - is that I can "conceive" what a red-star is like but I can't even imagine what "visualizing" a red star would be - do people actually see the red star in their head in the same way that I'm hearing Hell's Bells in my head? Or are there people who can actually pick up the actual image in exactly the same way they hear a sound? (I'm presuming not)
There is zero difficulty in my mind distinguishing between the sound I hear and the sound in my "head" - but at least I have an ability to hear sounds.
On the flip side while I have absolutely no ability to view images in my head 99.9% of the time, about 0.1% of the time, usually just in the 5 or so minutes before I fall asleep - I do see thinks in my head - to the point of being fascinated by them - but in this case - I'm actually seeing things, even though I have no control over it. It's different from when I'm hearing things - because that is mentally hearing things, whereas when I'm seeing things as I fall asleep - it's not mental at all - I actually see them (albeit with my eyes closed). It's a real image - not a mental one.
You are the first person to have given me a sense of what it means to "visualize" if it means something similar to "hearing" a song in your head.
It's also different from the inner monologue, btw. That's identical to my ability to hear sounds. Clearly there. Clearly mental. Sometimes chatty to the point of being distracting - but there is no doubt whatsoever that it's a mental dialogue - nothing whatsoever like actual sounds.
The imagination spectrum applies to all senses, so we all have varying degrees of it. Some can visualize every sense very well, others only vague faint unclear versions, some a mix!
I can recall/imagine taste, smell, vision, hearing, touch (texture and temperature), body movement, spacial awareness, and maybe more.
I can vividly imagine doing a physical feat, all the imaginary senses and sensations. Same as hearing a song in my head or imagining a red star.
It follows that there are others who can't imagine the other senses. What super imaginary powers might someone else have that is equally beyond my own? I heard of a guy with synesthesia who imagined numbers as complex 3d shapes and he could multiply large numbers in his head by, lego style, combining the shapes. The mind is wild.
I think the initial stimulus can originate at any part of this circuit.
So I do not think there is much difference between external so-called real stimuli and internal ones.
it's all just vibrations, processing, and reverberations :)
I'm the same way and my impression is that, no, most people don't have an auditory imagination anywhere near that strong. I actually work hard to avoid songs that are notoriously catchy and annoying because I know I won't get the earworm out of my head if it gets in.
I basically always have a loop of music playing in my head. Which piece of song is stuck playing in a loop varies over time, but it's very rarely silence. Often, it will be a sort of jumble of a couple of different things. (Right now it's a line from some annoying meme song my daughter just sang and a bit of the bassline from Basement Jaxx's "Red Alert".)
I'll often wake up with a different song stuck in my head because there's music in my dreams too.
> about 0.1% of the time, usually just in the 5 or so minutes before I fall asleep - I do see thinks in my head - to the point of being fascinated by them - but in this case - I'm actually seeing things, even though I have no control over it.
This is called a "hypnagogic hallucination" and is pretty common for all people to experience.
I can't really see objects in my head, but music I can play perfectly like it's an iPod. Usually just gets stuck on one track all day, though.
Another fun story. I did improv comedy for a few years. One of the warm up games we played was someone would start singing a song, then another person would tag you out and sing a different song. I was bad at this game. But I have a few simple things in my back pocket to "play". Somewhere over the rainbow is one of them. The last person was doing some sort of rap, and what came out from me was a rap version, until the crowd helped correct it. I just have no idea what it sounds like other than trying to memorize if it's a high pitch or a low pitch, etc.
Regarding the inner monologue, I do have one. And it feels similar to my ability to visualize. I can control it, give it emotion per say, (not sound for me), but it isn't as strong as a memory of a dream.
I can hum Jingle Bells (or 1000+ other songs, the Star Spangled Banner, Rudolf the Red Nosed Reindeer, any pop song from the last few decades, etc...). The experience of imagining the song is the same as humming it except I don't actually hum it.
It sounds like you're saying you can't hum a song or even remember one? Can't remember anyone's voice? Can't rememeber the sound of fireworks? Of cars going by?
I can’t hum songs anymore complicated than the “Happy Birthday” song (but if it plays, I’ll recognize it).
I can’t remember people’s voices in my head (but if I hear them speaking, I’ll recognize it is them).
The bang of a fireworks or a car going by is simple enough to recall. It is also generic. I might not remember the hum of the engine of a specific car, or be able to play back a specific fireworks display.
Explains why I had such difficulty singing my whole life. It must be way easier if you can just recall a song in your head and match its pitch!
Like the idea of a firework bang, being low intense vibrations, or a car horn being a high pitched short startling sound. Still can't really imagine it like I can picture things in my head, but I have an idea of the what the experience would be like.
Yes, that's a very good description of what the experience is like.
When you're auralizing(?) a song, you can choose which memory of the song you're listening to, and you can tap along with the beat, whistle along with the melody, sing along with the words, while being absolutely conscious of the fact that you're not actually hearing the song, right?
Visualizing something is the same, you can manipulate the image in your mind, rotate, choose different memories of the thing - or imagine new ways the thing could look, while being absolutely conscious of the fact that you're not actually seeing the thing in front of you.
When you said "red star", I imagined a red giant star, protuberances and sunspots and all, floating in space. Then someone else commented about a "five-pointed star", so I shifted my imaginary image to a stylized five-pointed red star icon instead. Same as you would imagine listening to one song, and then swapping to a completely different one with the same title.
To the rest of your comment, it's fascinating how it's all a spectrum. I can't visualize a star, can hear sounds but have no inner monologue.
If I put my hand a couple inches away from my face, in front of one eye only, I can still 'see' aspects of that hand with the uncovered eye.
Analogously, when I imagine a 'red star', it is visible in a different medium / realm (like my covered eye) than the rest of the things I see around me (with my uncovered eye). I can 'insist on' or 'overlay' the imagined image, like the red star situated in a particular spot on my desk, but I do not feel that they 'become the same visual stream', ever, such that I would think that the star could be physically present in the room.
I've recently been wondering about the fact that I am pretty sensitive to sounds and may have trouble concentrating in a very noisy environment (especially if the sounds are not constant/predictable.)
My hypothesis is that this inability to concentrate well in a noisy environment is a trait that mostly affects people who are more 'auditory'. Thoughts/experiences?
LLMs basically are examples of how humans visualize things. With a few differences. Humans have more fine grained control over the result and understanding of a query. LLMs have greater detail in the sense that the LLMs knows the location of every wrinkle on a face while our imagination delivers an approximation with detail only being rendered if we decide to focus on the details.
I often get really detailed mental imagery. Often unbidden, when daydreaming. My drawing skills are ok too.
When I partner with my brother it's almost telepathy. I can draw a single curved line and he'll correctly guess 'elephant' before any players have even put pencil to paper.
I can’t imagine/see mental images the same as having a real screen in front of me.
I can imagine a triangle. I can’t “see” it, it has no color and no brightness/darkness. Can’t really even describe the size. More like feeling around in a dark room. But the triangle is gone the instant I stop thinking about it. I wouldn’t be able to imagine a game of Tic Tac Toe.
Some people call this normal, some don’t. I have no idea.
I can imagine music too — and find it takes far less effort. (But can’t remember exactly what I imagined — more like just enjoying as it happens)
It looks roughly like the detail level of picture "C" in this picture: https://history.siggraph.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/2014... But with much less brightness/opacity/solidity than that, maybe 20x less (i.e., only 5% of the brightness/opacity/solidity of the tie fighter image - but same level of lack of detail)
You can improve this ability through practice. If you spend 10 minutes every day concentrating on visualizing that triangle with more detail & specificity, like an art student would, you'll gradually improve.
I have it, but could draw pretty well when younger (not practiced in decades). What I found, though, was that my style was very different depending on if I drew from a model or from memory.
People with aphantasia are absolutely crap though with drawing anything from memory, but they can draw if something is in front of them.
Mine are clearer than picture "C" though when I try to focus on something they tend to fade to black. Sometimes though I have dreams in HD where when I focus on something the details reveal themselves and everything is clear and sharp.
All I'm saying is plenty of people can play back songs in their head, or replay a conversation (or practice a future one) - it's why having a song stuck in your head is a universal experience - but not be able to internally "view" or "picture" objects with anywhere near similar fidelity, and therfore being good with sounds but bad with imagery is quite common, and not indicative of a condition (which is being called "aphantasia" here.)
I have very poor ability to imagine/remember music. Though curiously I'm good at "intros" (guessing songs from the first few notes); I couldn't hum you the first few notes of anything.
My visual imagination absolutely can have a time dimension just like my audio imagination. I can remember sequences of film from movies I have seen many times with high level of detail, and then if I so choose change what happens in that sequence to whatever I want.
I think it's more that as humans our audio fidelity in general is less detailed than our visual fidelity so it is easier for us to notice limitations in our ability to imagine visuals than in our ability to imagine audio.
(I don't mean to be dismissive; I do think this is an awesome topic to debate and talk about though, it's a great path for us to maybe understand qualia a bit deeper, if that's possible at all.)
Ask me about it while dreaming and it’s a full on 3D movie/VR experience.
Music too I can play that in my head no problem like my own radio (unless it has words then I can’t imagine it at all) - so I suck at karaoke. Even trying to sing with songs I can’t process it correctly unless it’s tonal sounds from the words.
For a neuroscience background we are certainly not all wired the same. You are correct though that aligning those descriptions and untangling social meanings and words from experience is tricky.
Uhhhhhhhh.......I don't think that's extreme at all. Isn't that normal?? I just asked several people today to close their eyes and imagine an apple (or anything else) and everyone just sees black.
If you could see objects with your eyes closed, I think that's called having a photographic memory? (Which is...rare?)
I can have very vivid mental imagery, I can imagine all sorts of fantastical things in detail in my mind on command. But that doesn't mean I don't see black when I close my eyes. It doesn't mean the mental imagery blocks what I can see normally with my eyes open. It is in your "mind's eye", so it is still triggering the vision parts of the brain, but almost like its on a different screen.
Similarly with imagining sound or music. I can almost perfectly recall some of my favorite music, I can compose a new piece (poorly) in my head based on music and sounds I have heard, but none of it will drown out an actual sound I hear around me.
That being said, if I am very mentally focused on some mental imagery it can still distract me from my real vision and or even sort of "replace it" without my closing my eyes. Sort of like the feeling you get when driving and zoning out thinking about something (but you are still safely driving).
If so do you see things in these dreams?
Either way, I've experienced a range, where my normal day to day experience is no sign whatsoever of seeing anything except maybe occasionally sub-second vague flashes, and the best I've experienced was as if I was looking straight at a real scene. So my day to day experience stands out very, very starkly against both my regular dreams and that one experience.
The frustrating part about that experience is that it suggests I can see things in the right frame of mind, but I don't know how to bring it out.
I suspect the mind is just like a body in the sense that the more you engage a particular muscle the easier it gets.
When I’m struggling with something I find it helpful to reframe statements into questions to activate creativity and clear any unconscious barriers that the mind is enforcing.
But when I close my eyes I describe it best as a black-and-orange static. I'll occasionally get residual images. Ask me to describe something in detail I struggle - but I can conceptually describe a space for example.
These are very different to what I "see" when I meditate for example, which is more dream-like (and I assume similar processes kicking in)
But maybe I have aphantasia and am totally wrong!
All the information is there, not just a visual, so I don't think it'd be a viable test at all.
> indistinguishable from a real apple
This is like saying what you perceive in your head through the wall is exactly as real, vibrant and tangible as if that wall was actually replaced by a window. Most everybody can describe, or "picture," a familiar room in their head - even from long ago like walking through the house you grew up in - but it is not the same as saying it is indistinguishable from actually being in the room and your eyeballs actually looking at it.
My point is not "I can do this", but rather, "I'm close to that, and it's foolish to think the continuum ends where I am."
This is the line in the article that gets confusing for me. Like, are some people actually seeing an actual image of an apple, as if they were wearing VR goggles or something?
For example if asked to visualize a green banana, and you can only see vague, unclear, faint outlines of a banana, that's hypophantasia. If you cannot see an image at all, it's aphantasia. Some might see vivid details of the banana, like the matte skin and subtle green gradient, they fall under hyperphantasia. Others who lack the details but are still clear considered phantasia.
This also applies to all other senses, like being able to imagine a sound or smell.
It was cool. Sort of like a hazy projection over the visual field. Normally when I visualize something with my minds eye it is on a black background. When the visualization ends my visual field snaps back to reality.
The imaginary apple doesn't seem fully comparable to a real apple unless I'm in a very focused and compelling daydream, and even then real but not real at the same time, if that makes sense. But even now if I was to conjure an image of a faint, ethereal apple in front of this computer screen, I can do it easily.
The major difference is VR goggles are fully vivid, and remain so when I'm not willing them to be, and tangible in some sense I'm sure is indefinable with people to aphantasia. The VR goggles are real in the same way things that aren't dreams are real.
I don't personally have such a vivid visual imagination, but there are moments when it can feel like that — I won't know what I was physically looking at because I was so concentrated on a visual(-ish) mental image that obscured my awareness of the real world, to a degree.
Like the guy above, you should not be allowed to drive a vehicle.
> obscured my awareness of the real world
Yes - because these are the same symptoms as someone who drives drunk and kills someone - "didn't see anybody walking there" (= unable to tell what you're looking at) "just a little buzzed" (= obscured awareness of reality) "I don't know what happened" (same)
Just to clear some things up, in case anyone cares:
(1) It is largely voluntary, what I tried to describe. Just like choosing to focus on your phone or the kids in the back seat while driving is voluntary. All of those are, of course, bad things to do. A good driver controls themselves — imagination included.
I wouldn't especially trust a driver's reaction time in "deep concentration" mode whether or not they were making pictures in their head, so I guess I don't see (ha) a big distinction.
Though actually, for me I find it harder to do mental visualization when there's a lot of real eyball visuals going on, as when driving. I have an easier time with a static background. Perhaps other people are different.
(2) I find that day-dreaming is somewhat voluntary, too. It can happen on its own, but it can also be a choice, like choosing to meditate. I don't understand your point about how someone else's ability to interrupt you makes it non-voluntary.
(3) I didn't mean to say I "see images in front of me." They are actually distinctly not in front of me — not outside my body. They live in a different space, if you will.
Isn’t it distracting? Seeing stuff in front of you when you should be looking at the road?
Another fun thing is imagining things but not fully. The brain will fill in the spots but not throw you all the info at once. For example I didn't really think of the monsters nose, but now that I did, it has a huge nose piercing like a cow ring. This is great for creation because instead of creating with your foreground brain, you can create for free with your background brain. I'm pretty sure every person can do this (barring <0.01% population health issues).
I use this extensively when I code too. I can see the lines of code, to the degree I can read them, and I've not found a limit to how much code I can have in my head and visualize at a reading level. I can do this with every single line of code from an animated ray tracer I wrote in C back in '85. Any code that I personally felt proud to have created, given about 5 minutes to recall the details, I can write the code out from memory.
Beyond seeing the lines of code, I see functions and objects and data structures as geometric shapes, and their interactions vary between images of little machines, like airplanes, traveling between them to complex bridge structures like freeways with lot's of traffic.
I'm also a lucid dreamer. I can tell when I'm dreaming with a test: if I say "apple" with my hand held on front of me, palms up and an apple appears which I can then grasp and hold, then I'm dreaming. I'll often wake at that moment, but when I don't I start taking advantage and fly like Neo. Often I'll fly into something, and the jolt wakes me. I wake laughing too.
It's funny for me, because I can "visualize" something in a non-visual way. I can transform it and imagine it fitting together with another object, or whatever. However, this is entirely non-visual. I see zero of this in my visual field, it's purely a sensation of seeing it without actually seeing it.
I also have nearly zero dream recall. I know I do dream, because occasionally I will wake up in the right part of my sleep cycle to literally feel the dream dissipating. Sometimes I can remember parts of it as it dissipates, but most of the time I have no clue what I dream after the fact.
I can visualise things in my head exactly the same as someone with their eyeballs removed can see real things.
I think that's relatively objective.
And I say this with confidence.
And I don't confuse this state of mind with lucid dreaming: I had spontaneous lucid dreams a few times. They were not very vivid, just as my normal dreams (I dream in images, and they are maybe around 50% vivid).
So, there is definitely a way to experience variation of vividness of mental imagery, by a single observer.
It always makes me question if I’m dreaming or not - and often, it’s the last thought I remember before I actually drift off to sleep. All of this seems to happen during the span of 60 seconds max (judging from my heartbeats), but this has categorically been debunked when my wife once told me I was actually snoring for a couple of minutes.
As I drift off to sleep sometimes it's fun to shift the inner eye to observe the mind and watch images float across my "viewport".
I remember reading somewhere that consciousness is like a public relations manager. It makes sense that highly social creatures that will die if shunned by their tribe would have a complex system for explaining their actions in the most positive light possible.
I literally don't believe that aphantasia meaningfully "exists" given what we've learned about brains. I'm reminded of the great article I saw about how "Your mind is not a computer?" No one remembers "images" in the way a computer does, we (re)construct them via association.
So I think our brains "remember" enough to do what it needs to do and no more, and so called aphantasia people are perhaps doing what subjectively feels like less reconstruction based on what they read.
What it practically means? I have no idea. I’m absolutely worse at remembering things like clothes someone left the house in but that could also just be me paying less attention to things like that.
I also have mental images while dreaming, but not so clear, that persist for short periods as I'm aware I'm waking up.
The three experiences are nothing remotely alike.
Same on my end. As far as I'm concerned, I don't see an apple, but basically just in the sense that I'm not hallucinating—with my eyes open, there is no apple before me, and with my eyes closed, there is no apple on the insides of my eyelids, and I don't think that there is. I feel like I could answer questions about the appearance of my imagined apple, but I don't literally see it. But does that mean that I have aphantasia? Since this seems to be the main diagnostic instrument for a casual Googler, and since, as you say, there's no way for me to understand whether or not other people "really" see an apple, I have no idea.
(If people think that your point about never really knowing what other people are seeing is merely academic or philosophical, I'll mention that my mother went a long time before getting her amblyopia treated because she assumed that's what things looked like for everybody. Nothing in ordinary conversation told her, or anyone else, that her vision was different, and so no-one ever thought to test her for it.)
The same cannot be said of aphantasia, which is trivial to fake and almost as trivial to mask. Combine this with some social desirability bias, and you have a perfect recipe for a complete non-condition.
You are skeptical when people say they have an internal monologue. Those without internal monologue would be skeptical when you say you do have an internal monologue. Your confidence is also based on nothing more than your personal experience + bias.
PS I firmly doubt those "swapped colour experience" ideas make any sense at all. Probably the thing that is assumed to be flipped is just that part of the experience that only seems to exist as an absolute, yet is actually not defined at all beyond its relations to other experiences.
On internal monologue, I said the opposite. I'm skeptical when people say things like "I also don't have an internal monologue. I don't passively think thoughts. I have to actively think everything."[1] I have a reason for this beyond personal experience and bias: that it's easy to be shockingly wrong in this direction. For example, many people will think they can count 60 breaths without being distracted by thoughts, only to find it impossible when they try and pay close attention.
Maybe the swapped color was a bad example. I just mean any direct comparison of qualia in different minds which is impossible to do, and therefore pointless to talk about.
[1] The first Reddit post I found searching for "no inner monologue"
Also, I think people who say they have no inner monologue think an inner monologue is like JD on Scrubs thinking to himself.
As for mental images, I have them all the time while dreaming, but I've only experienced them once in my life while fully awake, and profoundly clearer than any dream. I can remember what some of the images in a few dreams looked like, but once I start waking up, the visuals fade within 30 seconds or so of being aware.
It's certainly difficult to perfectly compare qualia in absolute terms across minds. It's less difficult to compare qualia within the same mind. And if one person reports they experience two things equivalently, and another person reports they experience two things incredibly differently... it's hard to claim the two people must be experiencing the world equivallently.
Some people hallucinate through drugs or mental illness, and find themselves unable to distinguish said hallucinations from reality. If only one of us sees the pink elephant tap dancing in the middle of the room... it's likely that one person is hallucinating.
Some people dream vividly, to the point where they can't always immediately discern if a memory was from when they were awake or when they were asleep. I have had such dreams. Others are able to identify specific diminished senses that they were able to use to immediately distinguish the dream from reality. I have had such dreams.
Some people are able to visualize scenes and describe them in far greater detail than I ever could from mere imagination, which helps back up their claims to being able to effectively vividly hallucinate/dream at-will in ways I've never accomplished.
> I could say I see it clearly or not at all depending on what you mean by seeing.
I can see an apple in reality.
I can see an apple in vivid dreams.
I could presumably see an apple if I ever hallucinated one.
I cannot in good conscious say I can "see" an apple through visualization alone without a great deal of effort to get an incredibly mediocre result that even a toddler's enthusiastic and proud parents would have qualms about pinning to the fridge.
Some people will be able to go into immediate detail about the color and texture of the apple they have a specific concrete memory of imagining years ago. Others, such as myself, will readily admit they completely forgot to even consider that the apple they're trying to imagine might have colors, even as they try to imagine it. Red? Green? A rainbow mac apple logo with a bite out of it? ...and you say this thing is supposed to have lighting from a direction and cast shadows?!? I can barely imagine a circle! Give me a break! And maybe some dice, so I can decide on a color to attempt to imagine! ...I think it's fairly safe to say that those two experiences are at least marginally different.
It would be unfathomable for me to have this experience and not acknowledge that my mind is simulating sound
God this is a tired argument. Your visual cortex is not special. Your red isn't any more different from my red than my "circular" is different from your "circular".
We literally can't know, and never will. The fact that you assert that assert otherwise (as far as I can tell) with such staunch confidence seems to be exactly the kind of thing OP is calling into question.
If you can close your eyes and get your mind to produce something like a photo of an apple, you know it. If you can't even remotely obtain anything like that you know that too.
"where did I leave my keys", "what would it look like if I moved that couch", and "how big is the room I can only see one wall of", are decent examples.
We could suppose that someone could see the entire spectrum inverted, but that causes other problems that we could test for. There are more hues between red and blue than there are between green and yellow. Instead of seeing brown (really dark yellow), they'd see dark blue.
And the even more interesting thing is that this nuance of reality extends to everything. The world as we perceive is only after extensive processing and filtering by our brain, driven by millennia of evolution. And it's very safe to say that our perception of the world has changed over those millennia and will continue to change in the future. So it seems essentially illogical to then assume that everybody at the current time shares the exact same 'experience' of perception.
Consider an enum type: we agree on labels (colour names) for different stimuli; as those stimuli combine they correspond to some other enum variant, and we interpret them as the same label. But we don't know, and I agree with the top-level comment that we can't know, whether our perception of the stimuli with that label is the same.
This is distinct from colourblindness, which is inability to distinguish stimuli for some of the enum variants, and so the labels get merged/boundaries between labels move. (Ok fine we also need a hashmap from stimuli to the enum..)
We agree to call the rose pink, and it's the same pink we see when we look at a colour card and agree it's the colour of the rose, but we don't know that what our brains reconstruct from the light when we look at 'pink'-labelled things is the same.
The key here is to remember that what makes us capable of sharing a world view and understanding each other is not just speaking the same language, there is also a degree of required shared cultural background—and it is not shared by all humans or even just speakers of a language.
In order to make sure a question about inner experience yields a useful answer at all from person on Earth who has a sufficiently different life from yours, you may first need to establish a common world view basis of sorts (unlikely to happen in, for example, a mass survey, but perhaps possible in a long-form discussion on an online forum).
Of course, even after all that, any comparison will still necessarily be very low fidelity.
If you have an example of some existing means of lossless communication between two humans, bring it forth. If you believe it is a technical possibility, then be my guest—however, I do not see such a way (that would also maintain humans as a set of diverse individual conscious agents, so homogenizing society to reduce everyone to a shared baseline does not count).
> However, such tests rely on introspection and self-reported experience, which made some neuroscientists doubt that aphantasia was real. Could reported differences in visual imagery be a language disconnect, given the ambiguity in how we describe our inner worlds? “It could be the case that we’re all actually experiencing the exact same apple, we’re just describing it differently,” said Rebecca Keogh, a research fellow in cognitive neuroscience...
The following ~8 paragraphs discuss the evidence for it beyond subjective reports.
So I have basis for comparison. The difference is sharp and unmistakable.
What is frustrating is that my one experience suggests it ought to be possible for me to train my ability to, but no attempts have succeeded (I've not made that many - it was an interesting experience, and I'd enjoy having it again, but it wasn't earthshattering enough to spend a lot of time on)
So these are be relative to what i see with my open eyes and hear with my ears. I think this is the only way you can measure.
(What i see vividly with eyes shut is more like something random a kalidescope.)
You could say that aphants just may not be trying enough - there are tests for that as well. But there is hope that in many people aphantasia is something that can be overcome, because it’s just a matter of a lack of a proper skill, or some sort of childhood trauma.
When you think of linguistics, and commonly misunderstood terms even though we have an objective way to convey the meaning (dictionaries, words) eg 'emigrate', how many more misunderstandings are possible when there is no objective access?
I can place symbols and move them, but I can't imagine a realistic flower; if I tried hard enough I could memorize a chess boards, but the pieces wouldn't have exact shapes as such, everything would be just a representation of a thing, not comparable to a visual memory of seeing the layout. In programmer speak, I think in nodes, graphs, connections. I can imagine people moving in a room to great detail, but not at all their faces or clothing.
I'm strongly spatial but not photographic at all. You're probably strongly tactile, and you learn a poem as if it was muscle memory of a movement.
I suspect it probably could be if they practiced, maybe picked up an artistic hobby or two, but if they're insist they're not visualizing presently then I'll believe them.
Psychologists and neuroscientists can tease these things apart.. in the article they talk about it. But aphantasia is only recently being understood so methods to quantify the degree will improve.
"Behind her eyes, it was completely black” "They reported actually seeing an apple, some vividly and some faintly"
This seems weird, but both of these describe my subjective experience of imagining an apple equally well.
From the article: "but somehow they cannot integrate this information in a subjective experience".
Consider a conversation with a blind person. Claiming they aren't having a subjective experience because they can't visually perceive you would be fundamentally biased. Clearly, one doesn't need visual input to engage in meaningful interaction or to have rich internal experiences.
Over time, it's become clear that people have a wide range of internal experiences. While individuals often try to compare their experiences to some imagined baseline, this baseline itself is subjective and variable. Many mistakenly assume that their own subjective experience is universal or "correct," failing to recognize the vast diversity of internal processes across different people.
Recognizing this diversity is crucial. It helps us understand that subjective experiences can vary greatly between individuals, yet all are equally valid. This broader understanding moves us away from judging others' internal experiences based on our own limited perspective, and towards appreciating the rich tapestry of human cognition and perception.
EDIT: It also reminds me of the "inner monologue". I'm skeptical when people confidently claim they have no inner monologue, as if it's as easy to verify as being right-handed or left-handed. In the context of meditation, it's common for people to confuse "having no thoughts" with "thinking nonstop" -- it's not an easy thing to understand about yourself, let alone claim how it relates to other people's subjective experience.