Re:What Happens in a Mind That Can't 'See' Mental Images
by rini17 on Saturday August 03, 2024 @07:41AM
(#41146020)
Low fidelity information transmission is not "ultimately futile" but instead something to build on. Or what do you measure it against?
Re:What Happens in a Mind That Can't 'See' Mental Images
by strogonoff on Saturday August 03, 2024 @08:30AM
(#41146266)
It is ultimately futile for the reasons outlined in the top-level comment. What one person experiences cannot be precisely conveyed to another person without round-tripping very lossy means of communication, such as language.
If you have an example of some existing means of lossless communication between two humans, bring it forth. If you believe it is a technical possibility, then be my guest—however, I do not see such a way (that would also maintain humans as a set of diverse individual conscious agents, so homogenizing society to reduce everyone to a shared baseline does not count).
Re:What Happens in a Mind That Can't 'See' Mental Images
by rini17 on Saturday August 03, 2024 @03:55PM
(#41148827)
Absolutely everything we have achieved as a civilization, depended on lossy communication between humans. And all experience is inherently subjective. Why is all that somehow ultimately futile and requires counterexample not to be? I don't get it. We don't have to totally understand each other to achieve something together.
Re:What Happens in a Mind That Can't 'See' Mental Images
by strogonoff on Sunday August 04, 2024 @04:25AM
(#41151957)
What is futile is to fully communicate experience. You seem to be talking about something else. Yes, individuals having or not having aphantasia, me being unable to communicate whether my blue feels the same as your blue, etc., does not prevent us from achieving certain goals together.
The key here is to remember that what makes us capable of sharing a world view and understanding each other is not just speaking the same language, there is also a degree of required shared cultural background—and it is not shared by all humans or even just speakers of a language.
In order to make sure a question about inner experience yields a useful answer at all from person on Earth who has a sufficiently different life from yours, you may first need to establish a common world view basis of sorts (unlikely to happen in, for example, a mass survey, but perhaps possible in a long-form discussion on an online forum).
Of course, even after all that, any comparison will still necessarily be very low fidelity.