I also have a mortgage on my apartment and I also think it's a decent choice, especially considering that I'll have less income after retirement. But most people are only a couple of bad turns in life away of losing everything they own.
All in all, I'd say the way to think this article presents does hold up to mortgage as well.
This is new. Mortgages in the US traditionally took just the home as collateral. Thanks for the reminder that this is now a thing to look out for, as I may need to borrow one more time than I ever expected.
This is wild. In Canada not only do we all take interest rate risk every 5 years maximum as we can’t lock in for longer (which seems to make our whole society less robust), we can’t refinance early if rates drop without massive penalties eliminating any incentive to do so, but all of our mortgages are full recourse.
I can’t believe how much worse this seems, on a societal level, than the US.
Now that interest rates are higher than they were a couple of years ago, TD Canada Trust waived all my prepayment penalties. They were happy to let me prepay as much as I wanted.
It's incredible how one-sided the Canadian system is. Prepayment is acceptable as long as the bank benefits. Prepayment is not ok when the person taking out the loan benefits.
However the government often will not allow you to get the full reward and so while the numbers work out for everhone in a free market it doesn't happen. adjustable rate mortgages in the us are lower interest rate. Often in the us they are a better deal - we are just looking at one case where everyone in a fixed rate two years ago is better off than those with adjustable rates.
No doubt, but the upside is a populace not especially at risk to interest rates which is absolutely crushing and systemically risky currently.
> in particular the government assumes the credit risk on something like 85% of US mortgages.
In Canada, CMHC does something similar so I am not sure we get away with anything special that the Americans are not.
This worked out fine when interest rates dropped and I refi'd. I've refi'd many times whenever the interest rate dips :-/
Except in Saskatchewan and Alberta [1].
[1]: https://financialpost.com/personal-finance/mortgages-real-es...
And those do not have such nice terms either.
Unless you live in a no-recourse state, where they can't take everything else.
In AZ, CA, TX, WA, and a handful of other states, banks can't go after your other assets, just the house that's mortgaged.
The bigger impact, I believe, is that housing prices can go more crazy. People will take more risk if they know they can walk and leave the bank holding the bag, so there isn't that limiting factor on prices.
(Though I suspect, but obviously can't confirm, that the effect from non-recourse mortgage is absolutely dwarfed by other factors, especially out here on the west coast where we have very restrictive zoning policies, weaponized environmental policies inside urban areas, etc)
There is also a similar process, non-judicial foreclosure[0], which is similar to non-recourse in some ways, but not for tax purposes (e.g. cancelation of debt income).
[0]https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/how-foreclosure-work...
Yes, and they'll sell the house to cover the debt. But the amount they receive from selling the house in excess of the debt goes to you.
I.e. you'll get the equity portion.
It's in your mortgage contract. Worth reading.
And now you're homeless and with your equity you cannot acquire capital. Your credit is also tanked due to the default...
Remember, most people do not own multiple houses and having no stable address can really mess you up legally even.
I don’t feel convinced that having a mortgage debt is that much worse than not having one, if you lose your job and war and other bad things.
With a recourse mortgage, they can go through normal debt channels (including wage garnishment, etc).
Not necessarily so in the US. In several states (including the biggest ones like CA and TX), non-recourse mortgages are the default. In other states, sometimes non-recourse mortgages exist too.
E.g. right now I'm sitting on a 2.5% fixed 30 year non-recourse mortgage.
Specifically, I'm asking if the mortgage deals the poster above was discussing would help if the house is now worth less than the mortgage.
the point is there is alway risk and many different situations. depending on details there are different results.
You already are in "debt" by being alive. You have the huge liabilities of needing food and housing and maybe sometimes some healthcare, in order to stay alive.
By buying a perpetual source of one of those you aren't investing or expanding your liabilities-- just the opposite, you are hedging against and closing out your liability by prepaying for it. To take this idea further, this is why I think buying a little bit of stock in energy and agriculture companies is "risk free" because while they could go down if those things get cheaper, you would then win out as a consumer. You will need food and energy down the line anyway, so a modest investment in those closes out that hedge rather than expanding liability
The market needed a way to transfer this risk (risk of delivery) so prices went negative meaning you were paid to find a place for the oil.
It's really neat actually and shows how almost all of the financial system is really a big "risk transfer" mechanism.
The further you get from the initial purchase date the dollar will have a lower value, and in theory you should be making more money.
Plus, even tbills are returning over 5% and are state tax exempt.
But I agree that most debt is probably bad to have.
I always thought the snowball method was dumb but as time goes on I can see how it makes sense psychologically, even if not mathematically.
What I didn't like about his take was that it also kind of also excluded getting into like $20,000-$40,000 of debt to go to a decent state school. That's a bad take; getting a degree (at least in a technical field) substantially increases your earning potential, and while $40,000 is a lot of money, it's not out of reach for virtually anyone working in tech or engineering or something adjacent, at least not in the US.
I guess my frustration with his perspective is that it felt extremely reductive; he acts like the only student loan debt you can get into is Harvard-level stuff, but I think that's just not true, and not even the average case. Most people don't get into Harvard, (I think) most people who go to college end up at a state or local university, and as such they're not getting into the obscene levels of debt that you'd get from these yuppie private schools, particularly if they state within state.
of course the degree matters. You pay about the same for art and engineering degrees but one will earn far more than the other.
You can easily get well into the 6 figures of debt even at state schools now. You'll find even rando state universities are hitting $30k+/year. Education costs have done exactly what you'd expect them to do when you convince people something is priceless and then give them unlimited and near unconditional loans to buy it.
I don't really see the point in this when you can instead attend English language programs in e.g. Europe or Asia and pay less for your entire education than you'd pay for a semester at rando state school in the US. Do a work-study program and you could graduate with a tidy chunk of change saved up, instead of graduating buried in enough debt to buy a house.
The ironic part is that this advice is even more pertinent for those coming from low income backgrounds, or from parents with limited education. But they're probably the people most unlikely to take advantage of such options, if not only because they probably just don't consider it.
That said, I'm a huge fan of European/UK universities. I do graduate school in the UK, it's a lot cheaper than a comparable program in a lot of American universities. I've been trying to get my considerably-younger brother in law to consider applying to European schools.
[1] https://catalog.sunyempire.edu/undergraduate/tuition-fees/#t...
[2] https://admissions.fsu.edu/first-year/finances/
ETA:
Sorry, I didn't see the "housing" part of your first sentence. That certainly does make the costs add up, particularly if you stay in the dorms, which I think are kind of a scam in most schools. I think to save money, a lot of people would benefit from trying to stay with their parents a bit longer instead of partaking in the dorms.
He acknowledges this. It's about the psychological effect of seeing your list of debts grow smaller. I think a big part of his audience are people who have historically been very bad with money, which is why some of his advice seems strange to people who are already financially responsible. People with a bunch of maxed out credit cards and loans on ATVs and crap.
If your loans have a minimum payment and a penalty for missing a payment above and beyond interest (which seems to be common for loans in the US), the snowball method gives you more flexibility. Paying off a loan completely eliminates that part of your monthly minimum payment.
If in 2 or 5 years your income decreases unexpectedly (layoff, etc.), but by that point you've completely eliminated 1 or more loans, you're more likely to be able to continue making minimum payments.
It’s not just a forced savings plan. That isn’t to say it’s for everyone, but it’s important to get the nuance.
(Also, it’s not really fair to say an “irrational” emotional attachment - that attachment can generate great joy and a sense of ownership, those are real things and not irrational even if they don’t make someone more money. It’s totally rational to optimize for things outside of money!)
PS: From context, I suspect you meant to say "illiquid asset".
I think it makes it worse.
I never understood that part. Barring actual damage that would necessarily affect its worth it's still the same house.
Or in other words: why should I care what others think my house is worth when I'm not selling, as I currently live there?
In my corner of the world banks are required to assume a 2,5-5 percentage point buffer when calculating mortgage eligibility - the upper bracket is for variable interest rate mortgages. An unlikely scenario, but keeps the risk of what you mentioned low.
What a house is worth is what someone else will pay you for it. There is no intrinsic worth to it.
It's value is only what people will pay for it.
For example, a relative of mine died some years ago. She had a house full of expensive furniture. You couldn't give that furniture away, even though it was in perfect condition. It had no value.
The average estate value, excluding land, houses, and cars, is about $900. I have friends who ran an estate liquidation service. You'd net something like 5 cents on the dollar.
This is one reason why I buy stuff at the thrift store. I bought a perfectly good chainsaw there for $10.
This is most of where its monetary value comes from (obviously not universally true, many properties have simply become investments), and its monetary value would probably only completely evaporate if the house were so degraded that it could not function as a shelter.
The monetary value of most houses is rooted in their ability fulfill a basic human need, as opposed to the monetary value of some other things, like gold or bitcoin, which are valuable primarily because of what they are worth to other people. Even if you disagree with using terms like 'worth' and 'value', you must agree that a house has utility that is not affected by its market price.
The market price is determined by how much people want it, of which utility is a large component.
If that is how you define it then by definition that is true. It is not the only possible definition though.
In my world I prefer to sleep in a place where the rain doesn’t fall on me. Having a place with a roof over me is value to me. If this meaning of the word “value” does not work for you then simply we are talking different languages.
Perhaps try thinking about “how much would i need to pay to provide the same neccesity if I wouldn’t own this place”. Maybe that puts it into economic terms what we are talking here.
At least where I live, there would be a gulf between the estates of people who bought into the property market and those that rented their entire lives. Latter will have some furniture no one wants and scraps. The owners will have a $2m property and then investment property that get split up between their kids.
The marketplace valuation is just where individual suppliers' and demanders' valuations cross.
The individual valuations are the foundational reality, or the market wouldn't work.
Every time you buy, sell, or decline to sell or buy something, you are operating based on your own valuation. So there is nothing theoretical about it.
People find out it is true when they try to sell something.
> If you wouldn't sell your house for $1M, then it is worth $1M to you
If you're willing to pay $1M for it, then it's worth that to you.
(Sorry, deleted that phrase after getting distracted while making my comment. In my mind the edit was instant!)
> What a house is worth is what someone else will pay you for it. There is no intrinsic worth to it.
> People find out it is true when they try to sell something.
Of course there is intrinsic value. A buyer has to pay you what you want for your house.
You are setting the market price.
If someone wants it, thats what they will need to give you.
We often use the word “worth” to mean “what would be the best offer I might get. But you won’t sell it if it is “worth” more than that to you. Which “worth” is usually obvious from context.
Valuations happen on both sides of every trade, and most often both participants end up with surplus value. The seller getting more than their minimum price, the buyer paying less than their maximum price.
Even market makers commonly post prices with surplus relative to their neutral trade valuation, and typically move their price if their are no takers. They want a trade at X, but will try for as much surplus as they can before settling for X if they have to.
A buyer offers what he wants to pay for it. You negotiate until reaching an agreement. That is the market price.
I.e. The Law of Supply and Demand.
If you think the seller sets the market price, try selling your car for $10 million.
There are plenty of things which are valuable or bring value, but are never sold or bought.
Case in point: how much is the Sun worth according to you?
But do you doubt I value it because I am not buying or selling it?
I suppose near infinite, in that I would certainly sacrifice everything I have to protect it - given it represents the survival of all of us - which for me at least would be the apex of value.
It is worth noting that value can often be measured in currency, but not always. It is ultimately an ordering of everything, by kind and quantity.
In the end, even money is just another “thing” which we value on a gradient and relative to context (what we need to survive, we value a lot. To live Without stress, a lot, but less. More than that, even less, even if we are ambitious.)
Market value comes directly from each of our personal, “intrinsic” as another commenter called it, valuations. There is no market value where there are no personal valuations. But there can be personal valuations where there is no market.
Each of us still prioritizes what we have against what we want, and the costs to us of that, even if we were hermits. Each of spends our time, the ultimate resource, based on our relative values of things.
That is the source of all “value” or “worth”. Individual or (and before) collective.
Average home price since 1965: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ASPUS
Average Dow Jones index since 1919 [adjust scale to ~1965]: https://www.macrotrends.net/1319/dow-jones-100-year-historic...
So under-building in the future will be harder, as houses exist.
Of course, it's hard to know how population growth will work out in the future. And even harder to know how it'll work out in your neighborhood :D
The GP is pointing out a key advantage of buying your primary home vs. renting: you're not exposed to the risk of rising rents. Others have pointed out disadvantages, such as being exposed to the risk of rising property taxes and rising insurance costs. How those things balance out is going to depend a lot on where your home is.
Most people think: "I bought my house for $200,000 and sold it for $300,000, I made $100,000!!!!!" and neglect to do a proper accounting.
If I take a leveraged position on a stock via margin trading and the stock goes to $0 (or, more realistically, it dips in value enough that I get a margin call) then I owe the whole balance, not just what I put up as capital. This is true of literally any leverage. And on top of that, I pay a margin rate in the form of an interest payment based on the amount of money I have outstanding beyond my capital. Sounds familiar, right? Because it's exactly identical. The only difference between a mortgage and a margin interest payment is that a mortage is amoritized across the term and is a fixed period, whereas margin interest is indefinite and acts more like a HELOC (i.e., you only pay interest on the amount that you have outstanding... and that amount can vary over time).
I absolutely hate the idea that "paying X in interest means that's money you have to earn in addition to make it worthwhile". No, it's not. It's money you are paying to free up extra capital elsewhere that can be invested more efficiently. Unless you're spending well beyond your means (which, admittedly, some people do), then paying interest on a mortgage payment should mean making much much more elsewhere by investing money you would have spent on buying a house in cash.
The logic you are using is flawed beyond all reasoning to be honest. People who are in a position to both pay back their mortgages AND invest heavily elsewhere are already rich.
As an example, if you sold a house 5 years into owning it, at current interest rates, you would only have paid down approximately 6% of the 30 year loan, so the 'leverage' of a 20% down loan would still be ~4.8:1.
> Unless you're spending well beyond your means (which, admittedly, some people do), then paying interest on a mortgage payment should mean making much much more elsewhere by investing money you would have spent on buying a house in cash.
There's no free lunch. Often, investments will get you a better return than your interest fees. Often they won't. And "much much more" is downright wrong.
No, it doesn't. Because the alternative was renting, which isn't free.
Even if you end up losing 50K on the home, all told, but if renting for the same number of years would've cost you 100K, you're ahead by 50K.
> rents have gone up a lot in the last two years
Where? In most places, rent is capped by the median income. Also, many people here are about middle income, so they are living in way above average homes. Yes, there, rents can really run away because you have higher income people, but middle class housing will barely budge.Meanwhile, Microsoft stock is about 10x over the last 10 years. Transaction costs are minimal. I can sell it on a moment's notice. I was paid dividends. No insurance costs, no property tax, no maintenance.
I just had to replace the roof on my house. Wow, that was a whopping bill. The roofer told me if I'd delayed another year, the bill would have been a lot higher, as he would charge $150 per sheet of plywood replaced. As it was, only one was water damaged bad enough.
Asphalt shingle roofs are lucky to get 20 years, cedar shingles are even worse.
I'm picky and it looks great.
https://www.google.com/search?sca_esv=d265e0c6ccb16526&q=col...
Not that expensive given the life of it. Mine is 15 years old and you couldn't tell it wasn't new.
If you manage to pick Microsoft in 2014, Apple in 2000, Tesla in 2015 and BTC in 2010, you are definitely way better off not buying a house but keep renting.
On QQQ it's 450%.
Most people might not do the proper accounting, but not in the direction you suggest.
Maybe they made 100K gross profit but after deducting all the expenses they only made $1000. Ok, was that bad? No, it's great because the comparison is to renting where they would've lost tens of thousands of dollars.
Do not compare your house to other investments, that's as apple to oranges as it gets.
Compare it to renting, since you have to live somewhere.
debt for productive activity in general makes sense if it isn't compounding (mortgages act like simple interest, btw, although it's complicated since you pay more interest at the start of the loan and so if you move within the first five years you've paid almost entirely interest on the home)
debt for consumption is always parasitic
that's why it's insane how hard it is to get a business loan and how easy it is to get a credit card: usurers want suckers, not shared risk on productive investments
Has there been a 20 year stretch of time in the US in which housing is broadly a depreciating asset?
Seems that land is definitely, and housing for the most part, an appreciating asset over time due to scarcity.
you are asking if real estate prices have fallen over a 20 year period in the US and the answer is not in the modern inflationary era:
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/QUSR628BIS
but that mixes land & housing prices together of course
prices have fallen over 10 year periods (sometimes dramatically) however, and the average length of ownership is 8 years, so timing can make a huge difference in outcomes of home ownership, particularly with the leverage involved.
The Great Depression started early for farmers...
https://ag.purdue.edu/commercialag/home/resource/2023/08/the...
And home insurance, too. But generally, yes: over the course of decades an American fixed-rate mortgage really is a wonderful thing.
There is also the possibility of deflation to worry about, although deflation comes with many other problems. I personally think that worrying about deflation is like worrying about a meteor, or the collapse of the local government: if it happens, so many other bad things will also happen that my mortgage will be the least of my concerns.
The author on paying down his mortgage:
> It just increased our independence, even if it made no sense on paper. So that's another element of debt that I think goes misunderstood. And a lot of that for both of those points is this idea that people don't make financial decisions on a spreadsheet. They don't make them in Excel. They make financial decisions at the dinner table. That's where they're talking about their goals and their own different personalities and their own unique fears and their own unique skills and whatnot. So that's why I kind of push people to say like, it's okay to make financial decisions that don't make any sense on paper if they work for you, if they check the boxes of your psychology and your goals that makes sense for you. And for me, extreme aversion, what looks like an irrational aversion today, and I would say is an irrational aversion to debt, is what works for me and what makes me happy, so that's why I've done it.
So my plan if I move is exactly what it sounds like: I sell the house and then buy a new one wherever I'm moving to. As long as I'm staying for like 5+ years at that location I think it's still worth it.
The goal is that by the time you reach retirement age, you have paid off the mortgage and own your home free and clear. Thus, you only have to pay the property taxes and have more financial security than someone who never built up equity because they always paid rent.
Furthermore, if you have children, that home is potentially a source of generational wealth. They can sell it after you pass and invest the proceeds, or live in it themselves if they want. Worst case, if you find you didn't save enough for retirement, you can tap into the home equity to keep food on the table, although this is not optimal.
In any case, if they move, then the price of the home they are selling will have gone up (or down) more or less the same as everyone else's, so it basically works out to a wash.
I suspect it has or will soon reach the point where the Kelly criterion says mathematically I'd be better off to self-insure - if I didn't have a bank loan.
It's not just insurance (which is likely also weather-related); after a fluke super-cold Winter we had, our natural gas companies incurred a huge wholesale market bill which they've passed on to customers. I have a family member who owns his house free and clear whose gas bill went up so much he could no longer afford to heat his house. The gas company still tried / is trying to assess a one-time very large retroactive fixed fee even though he turned off his gas.
My point, I guess, being even homeowners are not totally insulated from being screwed over by outside market forces.
Heh wait till you go to replace the property/damage. Unless you're doing yourself you'd absolutely crap on the floor once you see how high prices have got for this work.
Add to this the increasing incidence of weather/climate related damages to homes and the situation isn't looking good for many states.
Aside from what you've mentioned, the state can raise the efficiency standard to protect the environment, raise the cost of services, or make you pay to rebuild the street or sidewalk in front of your home. Then come the maintenance: new roof, new windows, new kitchen and so on.
If your country has good tenant rights, there are not so many reasons to buy. It's better to invest the money for a while.
I guess once the mortgage is paid off for whatever reason you’re welcome to not get insurance.
I had a not so fun experience with switching insurance providers at about the same time that my bank was about to make the insurance payment out of escrow.
The house I have is pretty old and the roof had some issues. I obviously was planning on fixing those, but it became a bit of a catch-22 problem; the insurance I was planning on using (cuz I had a discount from my employer) said that they wouldn't insure me until the roof was thoroughly fixed and/or replaced, but I couldn't fix the roof until the deal closed, and the mortgage company wouldn't close the deal until we had insurance. We were afraid we'd have to pay the insane insurance rates from the mortgage company.
Fortunately, after multiple days of shopping, I found one insurance company that agreed to insure me as long as I fixed the roof within 30 days of closing, which I did.
I thought this was only a problem in CA or FL. I wonder if this is nationwide or specific to states with disaster prone areas.
Insurance company profiteering is a disaster but that's a whole different topic.
But remember that rental properties are also insured. And the renter is paying for that insurance, it's just bundled in the rental price. So renters are also paying the wild insurance hikes.
And utilities like gas are generally directly paid by renters, so no difference.
This only works in places with fixed property tax. When I lived in Texas my property tax went up hand over fist every year as my property increased in value and automatic reassessments occurred. If your salary remains relatively stagnant and does not increase with cost of living (most salaries are subject to this) then you can certainly find yourself being subject to nuevo rent rates as a long time mortgage holder.
I do agree with you that different types of debt should be classified differently.
Rent has increased 30-50% where I live over the same time period. At least when my property tax increases, it's because I have an asset that has increased in value. If I am at some point forced to sell because I can no longer afford the property taxes, then I'll walk away with more money than if I had been paying rent for those same years.
Property taxes can force the same type of relocation that rent increases cause, but I think the typical outcome from someone being forced out by rising property taxes will be better than the person forced out by rising rents.
Critically, this also only works in places that offer fixed-rate mortgages. In my country (and most of Europe I believe) they are relatively expensive and the rate is fixed for only ~5 years (after which you either change to floating or update the rate). So basically nobody considers them long-term. Damn, I envy Americans.
For many, taking on debt in 2018 to buy a house for 200k would have paid off greatly by selling in 2022 for 500k. In an inflationary environment, you should grab as much cheap debt as possible.
I have a 30 year mortgage on my house with a 2.75% interest rate. That has effectively given myself "rent control"; outside of a potential rise of property taxes, my "rent" payment will not exceed a certain number of dollars. That means that if the housing prices rise rapidly, I'm covered.
If I had decided not to leverage several hundred thousands of dollars of debt, then yes I'd have more cash directly now, but I might have suffered the fate that lots of others faced with the recent spikes in rent that have happened due to COVID. I simply didn't have to worry about that.
Obviously there's different types of debt; some insanely high-interest loan you get from a payday loan place absolutely is a bad and will hurt your ability to stand volatility.