This is new. Mortgages in the US traditionally took just the home as collateral. Thanks for the reminder that this is now a thing to look out for, as I may need to borrow one more time than I ever expected.
This is wild. In Canada not only do we all take interest rate risk every 5 years maximum as we can’t lock in for longer (which seems to make our whole society less robust), we can’t refinance early if rates drop without massive penalties eliminating any incentive to do so, but all of our mortgages are full recourse.
I can’t believe how much worse this seems, on a societal level, than the US.
Now that interest rates are higher than they were a couple of years ago, TD Canada Trust waived all my prepayment penalties. They were happy to let me prepay as much as I wanted.
It's incredible how one-sided the Canadian system is. Prepayment is acceptable as long as the bank benefits. Prepayment is not ok when the person taking out the loan benefits.
However the government often will not allow you to get the full reward and so while the numbers work out for everhone in a free market it doesn't happen. adjustable rate mortgages in the us are lower interest rate. Often in the us they are a better deal - we are just looking at one case where everyone in a fixed rate two years ago is better off than those with adjustable rates.
No doubt, but the upside is a populace not especially at risk to interest rates which is absolutely crushing and systemically risky currently.
> in particular the government assumes the credit risk on something like 85% of US mortgages.
In Canada, CMHC does something similar so I am not sure we get away with anything special that the Americans are not.
This worked out fine when interest rates dropped and I refi'd. I've refi'd many times whenever the interest rate dips :-/
Except in Saskatchewan and Alberta [1].
[1]: https://financialpost.com/personal-finance/mortgages-real-es...
And those do not have such nice terms either.
Unless you live in a no-recourse state, where they can't take everything else.
In AZ, CA, TX, WA, and a handful of other states, banks can't go after your other assets, just the house that's mortgaged.
The bigger impact, I believe, is that housing prices can go more crazy. People will take more risk if they know they can walk and leave the bank holding the bag, so there isn't that limiting factor on prices.
(Though I suspect, but obviously can't confirm, that the effect from non-recourse mortgage is absolutely dwarfed by other factors, especially out here on the west coast where we have very restrictive zoning policies, weaponized environmental policies inside urban areas, etc)
There is also a similar process, non-judicial foreclosure[0], which is similar to non-recourse in some ways, but not for tax purposes (e.g. cancelation of debt income).
[0]https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/how-foreclosure-work...
Yes, and they'll sell the house to cover the debt. But the amount they receive from selling the house in excess of the debt goes to you.
I.e. you'll get the equity portion.
It's in your mortgage contract. Worth reading.
And now you're homeless and with your equity you cannot acquire capital. Your credit is also tanked due to the default...
Remember, most people do not own multiple houses and having no stable address can really mess you up legally even.
I don’t feel convinced that having a mortgage debt is that much worse than not having one, if you lose your job and war and other bad things.
With a recourse mortgage, they can go through normal debt channels (including wage garnishment, etc).
Not necessarily so in the US. In several states (including the biggest ones like CA and TX), non-recourse mortgages are the default. In other states, sometimes non-recourse mortgages exist too.
E.g. right now I'm sitting on a 2.5% fixed 30 year non-recourse mortgage.
Specifically, I'm asking if the mortgage deals the poster above was discussing would help if the house is now worth less than the mortgage.
the point is there is alway risk and many different situations. depending on details there are different results.
I also have a mortgage on my apartment and I also think it's a decent choice, especially considering that I'll have less income after retirement. But most people are only a couple of bad turns in life away of losing everything they own.
All in all, I'd say the way to think this article presents does hold up to mortgage as well.