News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I Think About Debt by francisofascii on Monday May 06, 2024 @10:56AM (#40275431)
People don't realize how risky housing is compared to other investments. It is risky because it is SO MUCH MONEY and it is not diversified at all. If your house loses half its value, that represents hundreds of thousands in losses. And don't think that can't happen. You buy a penny stock for $2K and lose half, no big deal compared to your house. BUT, we need housing, we need a stable school for our kids, or a comfortable place for our partner, etc. So we have to take this risk.
Re:How I Think About Debt by dehrmann on Monday May 06, 2024 @11:20AM (#40275704)
If you ask a financial advisor for advice on investing half your net worth on 5x leverage in an liquid asset with one customer and one location, they'd think you're crazy.
Re:How I Think About Debt by edmundsauto on Monday May 06, 2024 @12:00PM (#40276134)
But most of them would not think you’re crazy once it’s specified to real estate. This means either financial professionals are blind to the similarities or there is something critical missing from your description.
Re:How I Think About Debt by dehrmann on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @01:50AM (#40294761)
It's that people have an irrational emotional attachment to homes and financial advisors know they wouldn't be in business if they told prospective homeowner to put the money in an index fund. Where owning a home wins is it forces people to set aside income and put it in an asset rather than spend it, but there are other ways to do this.
Re:How I Think About Debt by edmundsauto on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @04:42PM (#40302541)
I think it’s a lot more nuanced than that. Leverage is great, being able to do what you want to your living space has value. It also locks in your housing costs. There are tax advantages.

It’s not just a forced savings plan. That isn’t to say it’s for everyone, but it’s important to get the nuance.

(Also, it’s not really fair to say an “irrational” emotional attachment - that attachment can generate great joy and a sense of ownership, those are real things and not irrational even if they don’t make someone more money. It’s totally rational to optimize for things outside of money!)

Re:How I Think About Debt by sokoloff on Monday May 06, 2024 @12:57PM (#40276730)
When that one customer is "your family", it's a little bit different, though.

PS: From context, I suspect you meant to say "illiquid asset".

Re:How I Think About Debt by dehrmann on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @12:06AM (#40282240)
> When that one customer is "your family", it's a little bit different, though.

I think it makes it worse.

Re:How I Think About Debt by sokoloff on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @03:19AM (#40283192)
How so? You control the customer’s buying decision and the product on offer is “living indoors”, something that you’re not going to easily decide to cut from your budget.
Re:How I Think About Debt by Tade0 on Monday May 06, 2024 @01:24PM (#40277046)
> If your house loses half its value, that represents hundreds of thousands in losses.

I never understood that part. Barring actual damage that would necessarily affect its worth it's still the same house.

Or in other words: why should I care what others think my house is worth when I'm not selling, as I currently live there?

Re:How I Think About Debt by Negitivefrags on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:22PM (#40278505)
You care if you have a mortgage and you live in a non-US country where interest rates can actually go up to price you out of it.
Re:How I Think About Debt by Tade0 on Monday May 06, 2024 @06:27PM (#40280224)
You mean a situation where I could not afford the installments and therefore would be forced to sell it?

In my corner of the world banks are required to assume a 2,5-5 percentage point buffer when calculating mortgage eligibility - the upper bracket is for variable interest rate mortgages. An unlikely scenario, but keeps the risk of what you mentioned low.

Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @02:37PM (#40277969)
> it's still the same house

What a house is worth is what someone else will pay you for it. There is no intrinsic worth to it.

Re:How I Think About Debt by schlauerfox on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:25PM (#40278541)
A house has intrinsic worth. It is a house, people live in it, it provides shelter by it's nature as a house. How many dollars it's worth to others is extrinsic, but it certainly has intrinsic value.
Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @04:08PM (#40278936)
> A house has intrinsic worth

It's value is only what people will pay for it.

For example, a relative of mine died some years ago. She had a house full of expensive furniture. You couldn't give that furniture away, even though it was in perfect condition. It had no value.

The average estate value, excluding land, houses, and cars, is about $900. I have friends who ran an estate liquidation service. You'd net something like 5 cents on the dollar.

This is one reason why I buy stuff at the thrift store. I bought a perfectly good chainsaw there for $10.

Re:How I Think About Debt by Vegenoid on Monday May 06, 2024 @05:49PM (#40279894)
You are thinking of worth and value only in the monetary sense, and the person you are responding to is referring to a house's ability to be valuable to individuals, even if nobody else will pay for it, because it provides them shelter, satisfying a basic necessity.

This is most of where its monetary value comes from (obviously not universally true, many properties have simply become investments), and its monetary value would probably only completely evaporate if the house were so degraded that it could not function as a shelter.

The monetary value of most houses is rooted in their ability fulfill a basic human need, as opposed to the monetary value of some other things, like gold or bitcoin, which are valuable primarily because of what they are worth to other people. Even if you disagree with using terms like 'worth' and 'value', you must agree that a house has utility that is not affected by its market price.

Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @11:21PM (#40282028)
> you must agree that a house has utility that is not affected by its market price

The market price is determined by how much people want it, of which utility is a large component.

Re:How I Think About Debt by Vegenoid on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @10:34AM (#40285985)
Agreed, but it is the utility that is the root of the value, and the relationship from utility as shelter -> market value is one way.
Re:How I Think About Debt by krisoft on Monday May 06, 2024 @06:14PM (#40280126)
> It's value is only what people will pay for it.

If that is how you define it then by definition that is true. It is not the only possible definition though.

In my world I prefer to sleep in a place where the rain doesn’t fall on me. Having a place with a roof over me is value to me. If this meaning of the word “value” does not work for you then simply we are talking different languages.

Perhaps try thinking about “how much would i need to pay to provide the same neccesity if I wouldn’t own this place”. Maybe that puts it into economic terms what we are talking here.

Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @08:53PM (#40281160)
The value of it to you is how much you're willing to pay for it. There really isn't much getting away from that.
Re:How I Think About Debt by prawn on Monday May 06, 2024 @09:18PM (#40281270)
That's furniture and not a house though. I'd guess that the average estate being that low value is not including outright-owned property/land. It's old people with a 20 year old car they've nursed through retirement, antiques that aren't in fashion, and bric a brac.

At least where I live, there would be a gulf between the estates of people who bought into the property market and those that rented their entire lives. Latter will have some furniture no one wants and scraps. The owners will have a $2m property and then investment property that get split up between their kids.

Re:How I Think About Debt by Nevermark on Monday May 06, 2024 @02:55PM (#40278181)
That isn't true.

The marketplace valuation is just where individual suppliers' and demanders' valuations cross.

The individual valuations are the foundational reality, or the market wouldn't work.

Every time you buy, sell, or decline to sell or buy something, you are operating based on your own valuation. So there is nothing theoretical about it.

Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:13PM (#40278382)
> That isn't true.

People find out it is true when they try to sell something.

> If you wouldn't sell your house for $1M, then it is worth $1M to you

If you're willing to pay $1M for it, then it's worth that to you.

Re:How I Think About Debt by Nevermark on Monday May 06, 2024 @07:12PM (#40280541)
>> If you wouldn't sell your house for $1M, then it is worth $1M to you

(Sorry, deleted that phrase after getting distracted while making my comment. In my mind the edit was instant!)

> What a house is worth is what someone else will pay you for it. There is no intrinsic worth to it.

> People find out it is true when they try to sell something.

Of course there is intrinsic value. A buyer has to pay you what you want for your house.

You are setting the market price.

If someone wants it, thats what they will need to give you.

We often use the word “worth” to mean “what would be the best offer I might get. But you won’t sell it if it is “worth” more than that to you. Which “worth” is usually obvious from context.

Valuations happen on both sides of every trade, and most often both participants end up with surplus value. The seller getting more than their minimum price, the buyer paying less than their maximum price.

Even market makers commonly post prices with surplus relative to their neutral trade valuation, and typically move their price if their are no takers. They want a trade at X, but will try for as much surplus as they can before settling for X if they have to.

Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @08:55PM (#40281168)
> A buyer has to pay you what you want for your house. You are setting the market price.

A buyer offers what he wants to pay for it. You negotiate until reaching an agreement. That is the market price.

I.e. The Law of Supply and Demand.

If you think the seller sets the market price, try selling your car for $10 million.

Re:How I Think About Debt by Tade0 on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @03:55AM (#40283350)
Don't you think that your take is a little bit reductionist?

There are plenty of things which are valuable or bring value, but are never sold or bought.

Case in point: how much is the Sun worth according to you?

Re:How I Think About Debt by Nevermark on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @04:28AM (#40283477)
I don’t have any ability to make choices about it that depend on any conscious valuation.

But do you doubt I value it because I am not buying or selling it?

I suppose near infinite, in that I would certainly sacrifice everything I have to protect it - given it represents the survival of all of us - which for me at least would be the apex of value.

It is worth noting that value can often be measured in currency, but not always. It is ultimately an ordering of everything, by kind and quantity.

In the end, even money is just another “thing” which we value on a gradient and relative to context (what we need to survive, we value a lot. To live Without stress, a lot, but less. More than that, even less, even if we are ambitious.)

Market value comes directly from each of our personal, “intrinsic” as another commenter called it, valuations. There is no market value where there are no personal valuations. But there can be personal valuations where there is no market.

Each of us still prioritizes what we have against what we want, and the costs to us of that, even if we were hermits. Each of spends our time, the ultimate resource, based on our relative values of things.

That is the source of all “value” or “worth”. Individual or (and before) collective.

Re:How I Think About Debt by fwip on Monday May 06, 2024 @01:29PM (#40277097)
Well, you don't always know if you're going to want to sell later. Maybe you lost your job, maybe you need to move to another city, maybe you just hate the neighborhood.
Re:How I Think About Debt by francisofascii on Monday May 06, 2024 @04:45PM (#40279304)
Right, all it takes is for the large local employer to suddenly downsize, causing both the loss of job, and the crash of the local housing market simultaneously.
Re:How I Think About Debt by roland35 on Monday May 06, 2024 @05:46PM (#40279861)
Not just one employer, sometimes the entire industry goes down! Just look at the housing market in Detroit or Youngstown
Re:How I Think About Debt by llukas on Monday May 06, 2024 @05:56PM (#40279972)
Shouldn't this be priced into the house value in this local market?
Re:How I Think About Debt by bobthepanda on Monday May 06, 2024 @06:52PM (#40280407)
it usually isn't because banks are not all-seeing and cannot tell which local employer or industry is likelier to go bust. in that sense all metro areas are often equally risky.
Re:How I Think About Debt by glitchc on Monday May 06, 2024 @01:39PM (#40277207)
No, it's far less risky to invest in housing. These two graphs over long term illustrate the difference in risk:

Average home price since 1965: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ASPUS

Average Dow Jones index since 1919 [adjust scale to ~1965]: https://www.macrotrends.net/1319/dow-jones-100-year-historic...

Re:How I Think About Debt by crooked-v on Monday May 06, 2024 @02:09PM (#40277647)
Though it helps to keep in mind that returns there are because the US housing market has been distorted beyond all recognition by under-building that goes back to the civil rights era.
Re:How I Think About Debt by jopsen on Monday May 06, 2024 @05:43PM (#40279831)
You could also argue that there was population growth, and we might not see that in future.

So under-building in the future will be harder, as houses exist.

Of course, it's hard to know how population growth will work out in the future. And even harder to know how it'll work out in your neighborhood :D

Re:How I Think About Debt by bobthepanda on Monday May 06, 2024 @06:53PM (#40280419)
even without population growth, household size decline means that there will be more demand for housing, since the same amount of people divided by smaller household size = more households.
Re:How I Think About Debt by aidenn0 on Monday May 06, 2024 @02:38PM (#40277986)
Isn't the latter CPI adjusted, but not the former?
Re:How I Think About Debt by glitchc on Monday May 06, 2024 @05:01PM (#40279476)
Thank you for that, I forgot to mention it: Both inflation adjusted and log plotting need to be turned off (as checkboxes) for an apples to apples comparison.
Re:How I Think About Debt by pdonis on Monday May 06, 2024 @02:18PM (#40277771)
But your primary home isn't an investment, it's a necessity. You're going to live somewhere. The only choice you have is whether to buy or rent the place you live in. So that's the comparison that should be made. Comparing your primary home to your stock portfolio is pointless because you can't live in your stock portfolio.

The GP is pointing out a key advantage of buying your primary home vs. renting: you're not exposed to the risk of rising rents. Others have pointed out disadvantages, such as being exposed to the risk of rising property taxes and rising insurance costs. How those things balance out is going to depend a lot on where your home is.

Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @02:35PM (#40277956)
Houses have always been a lousy investment for me. Once you factor in all the costs (property tax, insurance, repairs, 6% real estate commissions, the time the house sits empty waiting for a buyer, etc.) the returns are not that good at all.

Most people think: "I bought my house for $200,000 and sold it for $300,000, I made $100,000!!!!!" and neglect to do a proper accounting.

Re:How I Think About Debt by Kirby64 on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:00PM (#40278241)
Anyone buying a house with a mortgage generally is taking a 5:1 leverage (a 5% down loan is 20:1 leverage) position on the house. Making $100k on a $200k investment, with 5:1 leverage means making 100k on a 40k investment, which isn't a 50% return... it's a 250% return. And it's tax free, assuming it's your primary residence (up to 250k cap gains). You have to spend an obnoxious amount on costs to not have it make sense.
Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:14PM (#40278401)
Remember, leverage works both ways.
Re:How I Think About Debt by Kirby64 on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:32PM (#40278603)
Obviously. Which is why 20:1 leverage (5% down) is kind of foolish, since you can quickly become underwater on a house purchase if the value shifts. At 5:1 leverage though, you still maintain enough equity to weather any valuation swings if you have a need to leave and sell the house.
Re:How I Think About Debt by throwaway2037 on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @01:42AM (#40282719)
This post is somewhat misleading. If you put 0% down (yes, it is possible in many places), effectively you have infinite leverage. But let's use your 5% example. If you house price falls by 50%, nothing happens to you -- even with huge negative equity. You keep making monthly payments. There is no "weathering" to be done. Sure, at the end, you might have a giant paper loss, but you still have a roof over your head -- that you own.
Re:How I Think About Debt by Kirby64 on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:26AM (#40285174)
I agree mortgages cannot be called in, unlike margin trading on stocks, but if you’re wildly upside down on a house then it literally traps you in the house unless you take those losses. If housing prices fall 50% it is also likely that economic conditions may mean you cannot afford the same house anymore. In a situation of missed payment, they can certainly foreclose on your house.
Re:How I Think About Debt by temporarara on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:35PM (#40278624)
While there is some "leverage" in mortgage, you actually need to pay the whole sum, and with interest too, so taking a $200k loan means you pay usually something like $250k for it in the end, and this means you have to make $50k profit to not lose. And houses age too. If the location is superb you can justify it as an investment, otherwise it's pure nonsense in every way. Thinking normal housing as an investment is one of those reasons why we can't have nice things.
Re:How I Think About Debt by Kirby64 on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:45PM (#40278721)
What do you think leverage means?

If I take a leveraged position on a stock via margin trading and the stock goes to $0 (or, more realistically, it dips in value enough that I get a margin call) then I owe the whole balance, not just what I put up as capital. This is true of literally any leverage. And on top of that, I pay a margin rate in the form of an interest payment based on the amount of money I have outstanding beyond my capital. Sounds familiar, right? Because it's exactly identical. The only difference between a mortgage and a margin interest payment is that a mortage is amoritized across the term and is a fixed period, whereas margin interest is indefinite and acts more like a HELOC (i.e., you only pay interest on the amount that you have outstanding... and that amount can vary over time).

I absolutely hate the idea that "paying X in interest means that's money you have to earn in addition to make it worthwhile". No, it's not. It's money you are paying to free up extra capital elsewhere that can be invested more efficiently. Unless you're spending well beyond your means (which, admittedly, some people do), then paying interest on a mortgage payment should mean making much much more elsewhere by investing money you would have spent on buying a house in cash.

Re:How I Think About Debt by temporarara on Monday May 06, 2024 @06:22PM (#40280188)
You HAVE to pay back your debt if you want to pocket all your profits. If your down payment is 25k and you buy 250k house, you need to borrow 225k for your "leverage". Now you get lucky and years later, AFTER you have paid 25k + 225k + interest + fees which amounts to at least 300k, prices have gone up and you can sell that house for 400k. Nice you think! I will make 375k profit just by investing 25k! NO, that's not how "leverage" works at all. At that point you have paid at least 300k to get 400k which makes not that great considering it's been 20 years or so.

The logic you are using is flawed beyond all reasoning to be honest. People who are in a position to both pay back their mortgages AND invest heavily elsewhere are already rich.

Re:How I Think About Debt by Kirby64 on Monday May 06, 2024 @06:37PM (#40280298)
You don't make 375k in profit off a 25k investment (in your example) if you sell a house for 400k. You would make 125k in profit using your numbers (minus fees, interest, etc). It's exactly how leverage works, and the equivalent in margin trading is 100% identical. The only difference with a mortgage is that you slowly deleverage yourself over time as a consequence of paying off the loan (principal that goes to value of the loan).

As an example, if you sold a house 5 years into owning it, at current interest rates, you would only have paid down approximately 6% of the 30 year loan, so the 'leverage' of a 20% down loan would still be ~4.8:1.

Re:How I Think About Debt by Dylan16807 on Monday May 06, 2024 @06:29PM (#40280238)
What you're skipping in this equation is that the amount of leverage drops every month when you make your payment. The average leverage is a lot lower than the starting leverage. That's what makes a mortgage pretty different from a leveraged trade.

> Unless you're spending well beyond your means (which, admittedly, some people do), then paying interest on a mortgage payment should mean making much much more elsewhere by investing money you would have spent on buying a house in cash.

There's no free lunch. Often, investments will get you a better return than your interest fees. Often they won't. And "much much more" is downright wrong.

Re:How I Think About Debt by Kirby64 on Monday May 06, 2024 @06:41PM (#40280339)
In today's 7% interest rates, yeah it's potentially a wash. In the era of 3-4% rates, it's free money. 'much much more' is absolutely correct at 3-4%, which a lot of people currently have mortgages at today.
Re:How I Think About Debt by jjav on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @03:52AM (#40283333)
> and this means you have to make $50k profit to not lose

No, it doesn't. Because the alternative was renting, which isn't free.

Even if you end up losing 50K on the home, all told, but if renting for the same number of years would've cost you 100K, you're ahead by 50K.

Re:How I Think About Debt by giaour on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:05PM (#40278291)
The returns might look better if you factor in imputed rent (assuming this is your primary residence). There are definitely investments with higher growth, but the (untaxed!) imputed rent is solid income over the lifetime of the house.
Re:How I Think About Debt by rqtwteye on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:56PM (#40278825)
It depends on where you live. In CA renting is usually cheaper than a mortgage for the same property. Here in New Mexico my mortgage (2.6%) is cheaper than renting the same thing. With higher mortgage rates it’s not that clear but it still looks favorable knowing that mortgage stays stable for the next 15 years vs rents constantly increasing.
Re:How I Think About Debt by throwaway2037 on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @01:44AM (#40282730)
To be clear, no one is getting a 2.6% mortgage these days. Your post isn't a very good comparison. It is better to compare renting today vs taking a new mortgage today.
Re:How I Think About Debt by rqtwteye on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:06AM (#40286512)
Where I live, rents have gone up a lot in the last two years so even with the higher interest rates owning is still competitive with renting.
Re:How I Think About Debt by throwaway2037 on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @05:18AM (#40295925)

    > rents have gone up a lot in the last two years
Where? In most places, rent is capped by the median income. Also, many people here are about middle income, so they are living in way above average homes. Yes, there, rents can really run away because you have higher income people, but middle class housing will barely budge.
Re:How I Think About Debt by bluGill on Monday May 06, 2024 @03:14PM (#40278394)
if you don't live there long term houses are a bad investment. Live in the same place for 20 years and it becomes much better.
Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @04:10PM (#40278948)
Generally, to break even you've gotta stay at least 5 years. The transaction costs of selling a house are enormous.

Meanwhile, Microsoft stock is about 10x over the last 10 years. Transaction costs are minimal. I can sell it on a moment's notice. I was paid dividends. No insurance costs, no property tax, no maintenance.

I just had to replace the roof on my house. Wow, that was a whopping bill. The roofer told me if I'd delayed another year, the bill would have been a lot higher, as he would charge $150 per sheet of plywood replaced. As it was, only one was water damaged bad enough.

Re:How I Think About Debt by bluGill on Monday May 06, 2024 @04:20PM (#40279036)
you have to live someplace though. Over the 30 year life of that roof it is cheap enogh but that is a large one time cost if you only are there for 5 years.
Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @05:06PM (#40279530)
Roofs are so expensive they factor heavily into what you can sell the house for.

Asphalt shingle roofs are lucky to get 20 years, cedar shingles are even worse.

Re:How I Think About Debt by roland35 on Monday May 06, 2024 @08:09PM (#40280926)
Too bad metal roofs don't look great on traditional houses... I would love to install that
Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @09:09PM (#40281235)
I bought a metal replacement roof. I was sold because there's a new kind of metal shingle. It's stamped to have the shape of asphalt shingles, and it has a coating of grit on it to match the color and make it safer to walk on. It's lighter and fireproof, too. (Lighter makes the house more earthquake resistant.)

I'm picky and it looks great.

Re:How I Think About Debt by prawn on Monday May 06, 2024 @09:26PM (#40281318)
In Australia, some houses have a tiled roof but most have Colorbond (galvanised, pre-painted iron). Life expectancy 70 years. Warrantied for 30 years.

https://www.google.com/search?sca_esv=d265e0c6ccb16526&q=col...

Not that expensive given the life of it. Mine is 15 years old and you couldn't tell it wasn't new.

Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @11:24PM (#40282038)
I wanted that kind of metal roof, but the pitch of the roof would make it very dangerous to walk on to clean. See my other post for what I did pick.
Re:How I Think About Debt by rqtwteye on Monday May 06, 2024 @06:54PM (#40280429)
"Meanwhile, Microsoft stock is about 10x over the last 10 years. Transaction costs are minimal. I can sell it on a moment's notice. I was paid dividends. No insurance costs, no property tax, no maintenance."

If you manage to pick Microsoft in 2014, Apple in 2000, Tesla in 2015 and BTC in 2010, you are definitely way better off not buying a house but keep renting.

Re:How I Think About Debt by WalterBright on Monday May 06, 2024 @09:06PM (#40281224)
There are a lot of stocks that pay off better than housing. The 10 year return on the S&P 500 is 167%. It would be higher if you leveraged it with margin.

On QQQ it's 450%.

Re:How I Think About Debt by jjav on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @03:51AM (#40283328)
> Most people think: "I bought my house for $200,000 and sold it for $300,000, I made $100,000!!!!!" and neglect to do a proper accounting.

Most people might not do the proper accounting, but not in the direction you suggest.

Maybe they made 100K gross profit but after deducting all the expenses they only made $1000. Ok, was that bad? No, it's great because the comparison is to renting where they would've lost tens of thousands of dollars.

Re:How I Think About Debt by jjav on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @03:46AM (#40283312)
> People don't realize how risky housing is compared to other investments.

Do not compare your house to other investments, that's as apple to oranges as it gets.

Compare it to renting, since you have to live somewhere.