There are lots of ways that stock in food and energy companies could go down while prices go up. A drought or pipeline disruption come to mind.
Re:How I Think About Debt
by yowlingcat on Monday May 06, 2024 @02:10PM
(#40277665)
Absolutely. And I think the same is true for the commodities market correlates there; if memory serves correctly, crude commodity futures went negative for a break period during the supply chain volatility spike during the beginning of the pandemic.
You are correct, for oil contracts near expiration. All oil containers (in certain areas) were full, so anyone taking delivery would need a place to store the oil.
The market needed a way to transfer this risk (risk of delivery) so prices went negative meaning you were paid to find a place for the oil.
It's really neat actually and shows how almost all of the financial system is really a big "risk transfer" mechanism.
You already are in "debt" by being alive. You have the huge liabilities of needing food and housing and maybe sometimes some healthcare, in order to stay alive.
By buying a perpetual source of one of those you aren't investing or expanding your liabilities-- just the opposite, you are hedging against and closing out your liability by prepaying for it. To take this idea further, this is why I think buying a little bit of stock in energy and agriculture companies is "risk free" because while they could go down if those things get cheaper, you would then win out as a consumer. You will need food and energy down the line anyway, so a modest investment in those closes out that hedge rather than expanding liability