News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by snailmailman on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:26AM (#39967108)
I don’t know much about how music licensing works. But would this cause smaller musicians to decide to pull their stuff off Spotify?

I listen to a lot of music on Spotify. And some of it is from smaller indie artists. Not a huge amount, but I’ve definitely listened to songs that are in that <1000 plays category, and for some undiscovered artists that’s a good amount of their library.

It surprises me how much of my Spotify library is no longer available. There’s at least a few dozen songs in my Spotify library that have been taken off the platform. It shows up in the list greyed out. A lot of good songs too.

As much as I love Spotify and music streaming, it seems like the economics of it fundamentally doesn’t work and can’t work.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by kredd on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:33AM (#39967157)
I’m not sure how it can affect those artists given it’s like $0.5 for 1k streams. I mean, I guess if they have 100 songs all at like 999 streams, that’s about $50 loss/year if they never pass that threshold. It sucks obviously, but not enough to for artists to pull out.

My understanding is they’re playing a cat-and-mouse game with auto generated content, that syphons away some percentage of the royalties.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by basisword on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:02AM (#39967312)
While it might not have a big impact on smaller artists financially, the idea of a multi billion dollar company deciding unilaterally to steal a few cents from you could be enough to drive you away.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by lnxg33k1 on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:31AM (#39967501)
Probably if being actively exploited by a multi billion company is a problem for them, it might be better for them to change dream.. or species
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by coldtea on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:54AM (#39968394)
>the idea of a multi billion dollar company deciding unilaterally to steal a few cents from you

So, like all the rest of them?

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by isodev on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:27AM (#39967463)
As a part-time indie artist, one can do a lot with $50 you get on the side from streams.

Also, what is Spotify going to do with these 50$? What if it happens twice, 100$... do they pay you back eventually? Perpetually free access to all their premium services?

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by kredd on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:02AM (#39967679)
I'll take this bad faith argument, and give you even a worse one - $50 is about 5 drinks or less at a bar with tips nowadays. I genuinely doubt a serious person who makes music on the side will look at that number as a potential loss of income.

And if you have made 200 songs (so loss of $100), all streaming less than 1K each, maybe your current production is not marketable on Spotify, and yeah, maybe you should find another venue. Eventually there will be a marketplace for this type of production, and hopefully willing users to pay for it.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by spookie on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:36AM (#39967927)
You're assuming every artist lives in a first world country. The problem seems a lot more severe under a more general lens.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by antifa on Monday April 08, 2024 @01:36PM (#39971972)
Must artists are struggling, so that loss of $50 means picking up an extra shift at McDonald's to pay rent instead of making or promoting their music.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by throwaway8414fr on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:34AM (#39967525)
That wss an extreme example I think. Most probably end up with less than $5 loss
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by isodev on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:44AM (#39967579)
it's not up to Spotify to decide what I do with that. What if I use it to pay a sub for some app I like and helps me create music? Then Spotify is taking value away from 2 Indies, not just one.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by SSLy on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:15AM (#39967386)
I though labels job was to prevent content like that
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by whstl on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:27AM (#39967470)
Spotify allows people to self publish.

Not to mention people can set up labels themselves, it's just a company like any other.

I'm sure we don't want big labels being gatekeepers. They have their own set of problems, and make streaming even more difficult for everyone but very large artists/groups (and sometimes even for those, as they eat a big chunk of royalties).

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by smallerfish on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:36AM (#39968285)
Spotify does not allow you to self publish. However, you can pay a distributer like DistroKid an annual fee in order to upload to the platform (and all other majors).
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by whstl on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:21AM (#39968568)
Ah thanks for the correction. I also used DistroKid.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by boxed on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:45AM (#39967584)
Seems silly. The reason they have that problem is that their logic for funneling subscription revenue to streams is broken. This won't fix that fundamental problem. You can still use Spotify to scam money out of the system.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Lewton on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:01AM (#39967674)
> The reason they have that problem is that their logic for funneling subscription revenue to streams is broken

Changing it to splitting out a users monthly payment to what they're actually listening to, would make the abuse they're trying to stop easier and not harder (as it would mean all the money they're trying to launder will go to the correct artist instead of just some of it)

Not saying that that's a good argument for the current system, but it wouldn't fix the issue they're trying to solve

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by grujicd on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:13AM (#39968148)
I would much rather prefer that my subscription money gets split between niche artist I'm listening to instead of going to Taylor Swift. I assume it's harder to calculate royalties, you can't keep single counter per track, you have to agregate listens within a month for each user. But that doesn't seem insurmountable. Or maybe it is on Spotify scale?

I don't think any subscriber (i.e. people giving them money) would prefer current model over where your money goes directly to who you listen.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by doikor on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:54AM (#39968030)
Yea there are better ways to fix the problem but the problem is selling that fix to the big labels. The current system gets them a larger share of the revenue so why would they be interested in changing it?
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by boxed on Monday April 08, 2024 @09:46AM (#39969667)
Laundering would be easier yes. But extracting money from the system would be impossible. I was talking about the latter where you pay for an account of 10 usd/month and extract > 10 usd/month in stream revenue.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by kredd on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:50AM (#39967602)
You can, but the game isn’t to drive the abuse to 0. It’s about to bring it down, and hope abusers find an easier target to extract money from. It’s the same concept as “why would you steal a secured bike, when there’s an unsecured one right next to it”, and hope you’re the one who secured yours.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by atoav on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:58AM (#39967297)
I am in a small and new band. In 2023 we earned roughly

     500 Euros via Bandcamp (digital, physical and merch)
     300 Euros selling merch on gigs
    2000 Euros playing gigs
      20 Cents on Spotify
There is no monetary reason to be on spotify, the only reason we are on there is because fans asked.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by whstl on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:14AM (#39967382)
Similar experiences (but from a few years ago).

Even people who have Spotify end up buying stuff in Bandcamp. Sometimes people would buy two physical copies to gift.

For me there was never any difference between Spotify and piracy.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Hoasi on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:29AM (#39967481)
Absolutely. I always buy music from artists to support them on Bandcamp. Spotify lets you discover bands that are little known, which is cool, but it's not a place that enables you to support those artists. Unfortunately, Bandcamp might also change since they are changing owners.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by magicalhippo on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:36AM (#39968287)
I use Spotify because my SO wants it for podcasts and stuff and family subscription is just tad more, and it's in my car and similar which is convenient.

I also buy the music I listen to a fair bit on Bandcamp or at concerts.

As an example, last fall a song from a band came up in the randomized post-album "radio" on Spotify as I was driving, and I added the band to my favorites. A month ago Spotify notified me the band was playing in town, so I went and ended up buying several CDs, including from the warmup band as well.

That said, I agree that Spotify should pay more to small artists. I really dislike that my money goes to Talor Swift and similar artists who have more than enough and that neither I nor my SO listen to.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by whstl on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:19AM (#39968555)
Those are fair points, and I agree.

I think I should have said that Spotify is the same as piracy from an artists POV.

It's definitely not illegal for users, and it definitely helps with "exposure", but it's not really a platform for making real money with your music, except when it's listened to in massive quantities.

For me, it's no different than putting a free album link in Instagram, or when Nine Inch Nails put it on PirateBay as a stunt...

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by runiq on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:41AM (#39967562)
I'm intrigued. What's your bandcamp page? :)
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by atoav on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:46AM (#39967586)
Warning — we are probably pretty niche with our noisy music, but here ya go: https://maschinkaput.bandcamp.com/
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by BLKNSLVR on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:28AM (#39967876)
Listening on Bandcamp right now - the song 'drop'. I like some pretty out there stuff, and this is right at the outer limits, and I mean that as a compliment.

I might not "enjoy" it as one would traditionally enjoy listening to music, but I enjoy that it exists and the uniqueness of the experience it provides.

If you can handle LAMC by Tool, you can handle this.

'kabelbrand' is giving me flashbacks to Providence by King Crimson, just a bit more raw and industrial. All build-up without the instruments actually synchronising together for the payoff as per Providence.

The band name is great; apt.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by em-bee on Monday April 08, 2024 @08:14AM (#39968905)
i second that. i would not go to a concert, but i can see this used in games or exhibits of industrial art.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by atoav on Monday April 08, 2024 @11:20AM (#39970643)
We are an improvisational band, so no concert is alike ; )
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by runiq on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:29AM (#39967884)
Nee, ich mag's. Danke für den Link, und Grüße nach Hamburg!
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by meindnoch on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:01AM (#39968072)
Nice! Reminds me of Nazoranai.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by rglullis on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:41AM (#39967564)
Would you/your band be interested in trying out a pay-what-you-want system? I started the work to add crowdfunding support to communick (described on https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39399121) and I'm looking now for musicians/artists/FOSS developers for some beta testing.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by anentropic on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:14AM (#39967762)
it's already possible to do pay-what-you-want in Bandcamp

always good to have more options though!

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by rglullis on Monday April 08, 2024 @08:02AM (#39968824)
But does it provide a way for them to stream all of the artists catalog?
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by jaculabilis on Monday April 08, 2024 @10:14AM (#39969931)
Yeah, most artists let you listen to the whole album before you buy it. Sometimes there are songs that don't have previews, and I think there are sometimes hidden songs included with the album but not even listed, but in general you can stream a few times before buying, and then stream as much as you want afterwards.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by rglullis on Monday April 08, 2024 @10:24AM (#39970040)
> but in general you can stream a few times before buying, and then stream as much as you want afterwards.

Not exactly what I have in mind. I am working with the model where all songs are always available (like Spotify) and people simply choose how (a) how much they want to give per month and (b) how to split this amount among their preferred artists.

In effect, it's the same as a "pay as you want", but there is no overhead of thinking about which songs to "buy".

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by asdof on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:55AM (#39967634)
I'd wager the income from playing gigs would be substantially lower if you weren't on Spotify.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by atoav on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:21AM (#39968193)
I have no data on that, but my stochastic feeling (based on conversations I had with people visiting our concerts) does not imply that at all. Most came because (in that order of frequency):

1. They saw our sticker/poster and thought the name is interesting

2. They checked the venue/festival-site and thought it sounded interesting

3. They knew us from social media

Exactly zero times I had someone tell me the found us on spotify and came because of that. Of course that doesn't mean no such people exist, my sample size might be too small. There might also be people who find us on spotify and then buy on bandcamp, no way to check on that.

But my feeling right now is that our more traditional boots on the ground marketing does a lot more than the online stuff. That doesn't mean that dynamic can be totally different for other bands or other genres tho.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by subroutine on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:45AM (#39968343)
Yeah for some bands, letting people listen to a sample of their music before paying the cover charge might work against them ;)
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by tgv on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:07AM (#39967713)
Your arguments veers close to the "for exposure" payment.

People don't go to indie concerts because of a spotify track. Nor to big name concerts. And 20 cents corresponds to around 50 to 100 plays according to the numbers mentioned here.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by jug on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:31AM (#39967895)
I'm not sure what your basis is for this claim? I've most certainly discovered artists from Spotify and later on bought e.g. merch to support them. I would in a heartbeat also go on their concerts if I was given the opportunity with travel distance, vacation plans etc.

Spotify can't give you these experiences no matter how hard they try so this claim doesn't make much sense to me. A concert isn't exactly competing with streaming services or anything.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by subroutine on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:48AM (#39968351)
Same. Anecdotally I discovered khruangbin on spotify and will be seeing their concert next tuesday.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by epolanski on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:18AM (#39967802)
> People don't go to indie concerts because of a spotify track

Do you have numbers behind this claim?

I definitely got aware of some unknown artists thanks to Spotify and YouTube, some of them had low hundreds views/listens.

Ended up supporting them, going to concerts and buying merch.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by nsteel on Monday April 08, 2024 @11:31AM (#39970744)
Same. I see a show advertised and I want to hear what the bands sound like, the easiest way (for me) is to search for them on Spotify and check out the top few tracks and the new release. If I like what I hear then I'll buy a ticket and go. I probably could have found the tracks other ways if I really tried, but this way just works, almost always.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by helsinkiandrew on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:19AM (#39967813)
> And 20 cents corresponds to around 50 to 100 plays

Unfortunately more like 5000+ plays. People tend go to concerts of music they listen to and for a lot of people that means hearing it on Spotify

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by peapicker on Monday April 08, 2024 @09:41AM (#39969623)
Actually, the spotify rate is 0.003 cents per track, which reflects my 83 plays ‘earning’ $0.25 on Spotify before this.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by coldtea on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:49AM (#39968364)
>Your arguments veers close to the "for exposure" payment

While it does, note that paying or doing stuff free "for exposure" is exactly how many artists got big and huge hits were made, from payola to DJs (starting way earlier than Alan Freed with radio DJs, and going all the way to EDM DJs being paid to break a track), all the way to paying for artist ads or record shop placement, buying fake streams, followers, and views to appear more popular and drive exposure, or doing for free (or, often, paying for) the support spot on a bigger band's concert.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by herculity275 on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:08AM (#39968110)
> People don't go to indie concerts because of a spotify track

Anecdotically I've attended multiple gigs for artists I discovered via Spotify.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by antifa on Monday April 08, 2024 @10:40AM (#39970225)
If Spotify's search page wasn't so broken and useless, I'd probably have gone to _more_ indie concerts.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by cal85 on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:26AM (#39967861)
It is extremely common and often perfectly rational for creatives to do things in exchange for exposure. There is nothing fallacious about this.

> People don't go to indie concerts because of a spotify track.

Yes they do.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by m000 on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:15AM (#39968163)
If there's any fallacy here, it is comparing "for exposure" between a gig at your local dive bar (this is where you typically hear the phrase), and uploading your material to Spotify.

The first requires committing time and effort to get 50 people to see you, 20 of which are your personal friends. The second is making the music you have already produced available to millions of people around the world, with virtually no effort.

Surely Spotify should improve on compensating artists, but all-in-all it is still a better deal for the artist than the "for exposure" gig at the local bar.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by cqqxo4zV46cp on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:54AM (#39968034)
Your absolutist claim is already false by virtue of the fact that I have gone to an “indie” show after hearing a track on Spotify.

Next?

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by coldtea on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:51AM (#39968380)
Next should be the advice to not take comments of that form as "absolutist" but understand them to mean as "in general"...
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by FireInsight on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:01AM (#39967673)
This is exactly the reason why my preferred method of music consumption is piracy + Bandcamp. Every Bandcamp Friday (when Bandcamp doesn't take a cut) I buy about 2 to 6 albums I've listened to in the past month or a few. If an artist is not on Bandcamp, I'm less likely to listen to them, but if I do, I eventually pirate their stuff.

All the music I buy and pirate is in FLAC and funneled into my local library, where I can enjoy it without any streaming service taking it away from me.

And I usually end up contributing more to my favorite artists financials than fans who use streaming service, so that's a bonus.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by aaaarc on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:14AM (#39967760)
In case of smaller artists we'd be better off pirating music instead of helping cement Spotify's brand as a central platform. The only person losing money in this case is the platform holder so we could argue the decentralised aspect of piracy helps fighting monopolisation of the industry.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by margorczynski on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:07AM (#39968102)
But don't they give out a flat % of what they earn from the subscriptions? The low return would mean that either:

a) Spotify doesn't charge enough for a subscription

b) Spotify takes too big of a cut right now from the subscription revenue

c) The model doesn't work as a lot of people from low-income (and low subscription cost) countries are "sucking out" the money that goes mainly from rich ones. So 1 listen from USA = 1 listen from India even though the USA listener pays around 7-8x times more and the subscription income gets divided equally by listens.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by yreg on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:25AM (#39968221)
People use Spotify because it is comfortable and provides additional features liked by users. That has always been the only way to beat piracy.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by the_other on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:25AM (#39968217)
> Every Bandcamp Friday (when Bandcamp doesn't take a cut) I

It's great that BC still does BC Fridays... but if fans only buy music from BC on BC Fridays, BC will lose all revenue and will fold or resort to shitty tactics. BC are one of the few "good" businesses in this space, and have reached an impressive scale. I'd hate to see them fold. I reckon it's worth buying some music on normal days as well as BC Fridays.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by rchaud on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:47AM (#39968725)
BC was acquired recently, so that may come sooner rather than later. It's not due to BC Friday, bur rather that selling MP3s piecemeal is a hard business. Artists sometimes also remove their albums from BC if they sign with a label that wants exclusive distribution rights.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by the_other on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @05:05PM (#39984240)
Selling mp3s piecemeal might be hard but they were profitable for 12 years prior to the previous sale to Epic. Spotify havn’t turned a profit in 18.

I too fear the recent change of ownership will bring on changes in business model. But I live in hope that it wont, because it doesn’t need to.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by FireInsight on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:46PM (#39973028)
Well, I do sometimes buy on normal days too, but not as much :)

And if they removed BCFs or took a small cut I wouldn't stop buying from them either.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Helmut10001 on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:05AM (#39968085)
If bands are not on Bandcamp, I buy them on mp3million.com, which is legal but feels like piracy given their pricing.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by 10729287 on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:27AM (#39968604)
Well. It doesn't seem that legal, and certainly not a good solution is your primary goal is to help artists : https://musicfans.stackexchange.com/questions/1045/do-those-...

Very shady at best.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by ornornor on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:24AM (#39968210)
> mp3million.com

Reminds me of allofmp3.com before the WTO asked Russia to kill it if they wanted to join.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Ringz on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:14AM (#39968153)
Wow thats cheap! How is that even possible?
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by 10729287 on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:27AM (#39968607)
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Ringz on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @04:53PM (#39984122)
Thanx a lot. That’s insightful.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by rchaud on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:44AM (#39968702)
It ain't piracy if the record I want is out of print and no longer commercially available. Most of the music I listen to is pre-2010, so there are a lot of records that fit that description.

Same goes for live recordings, remixes and radio sessions. P2P has had this for 20+ years, Spotify doesn't and never will.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Tanoc on Monday April 08, 2024 @12:32PM (#39971365)
Same here. A lot of artists and a good chunk of the recording crews from before the early 1980s are dead and have been for decades, and the only ones getting the money are the record companies. Otis Redding, Marvin Gaye, Jim Croce, Stevie Ray Vaughan, all of them have been gone for thirty years or more at this point. Not even their kids or some sort of charity managed by their estate get any of the money. Piracy of their albums is denying wealth from graverobbers, really.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by chgs on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:01PM (#39974186)
It’s still copyright infringement just like copying the latest Taylor swift album is.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by rchaud on Monday April 08, 2024 @09:50PM (#39975594)
Taylor Swift albums are not out of print and she owns her record label. I am talking about recordings that were never released commercially, or released by labels that are long gone. This is closer to the videogame emulation legality argument than it is Metallica v Napster.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by chgs on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @05:16AM (#39977619)
Still copyright infringement (assuming it’s not so old to have left copyright). Doesn’t matter if it’s a song that was last printed on a 78 in 1945 and the artist decided to burn all copies, or the latest album from some k-pop band that you can get free with your cornflakes.

Being in print or not makes no difference

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by ornornor on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:25AM (#39968218)
> All the music I buy and pirate is in FLAC and funneled into my local library, where I can enjoy it without any streaming service taking it away from me.

Where do you get these FLACs? Do you have a pipeline/automated system or it’s done manually? Asking for a friend.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by 11001100 on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:28AM (#39968615)
You can get these FLACs via Bandcamp. In some cases, you can download for free (enter $0.00 if there is a "name your price" tag)
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by FireInsight on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:51PM (#39973070)
If you wish to sail the high seas, look up "piracy megathread". Soulseek and Doubledoubletop are some of my favorites.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by subroutine on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:04AM (#39968453)
Your process sounds a lot like this new change by Spotify... Anything you don't listen to very much doesn't get paid for.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by nextlevelwizard on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:07AM (#39968097)
Problem is that in take of new music is harder with these.

I don’t know if YouTube is any better, but I have switched all of my music consumption to youtube music app with the premium subscription.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by FireInsight on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:42PM (#39972992)
I don't require a huge intake of new music: I obsess over those dozen albums I really love a month, always listening to them in full and appreciating them as art. Browsing Bandcamp tags, music review and catalogue sites, and music critics album reviews is really all I need to get that hit.

But it's not for everyone ig...

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by pydry on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:17AM (#39967788)
These numbers definitely give piracy a shine.

What's better for music as a whole? Boosting Spotify's share price and Taylor Swift's private jet habit? Or putting that $11/month towards some gigs for an artist you really like?

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by namanyayg on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:18AM (#39968178)
Where do you store the files, how do you take your music with you on the go?
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by the_other on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:29AM (#39968250)
Not the poster you're replying to, but I acquire music the same ways as them.

a1) on my computer, in folders. I manage it using iTunes/Music, but could just as well use anything else, or do it manually. I also have Serato for DJing, which imports my iTunes/Music library xml to share the same collection.

a2) to be fair, in the past year, I've gotten lazy and started streaming from the band camp app for more recent purchases. I'm not DJing much these days.

b) I buy phones with a lot of storage and don't upgrade very often

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by brabel on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:42AM (#39968329)
Music is just files, so just use any filesync service like iCloud, Google Drive, Keybase, OneDrive, DropBox etc.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by altacc on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:26AM (#39968225)
There are media servers you can host locally and Bandcamp has an app you can play music in.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by FireInsight on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:45PM (#39973007)
I have both a Jellyfin and a Subsonic-compatible (Gonic) server on my local NAS. Those are used for streaming and work anywhere where there's internet thanks to Tailscale. If I need to go offline, for a flight or something, I pick a dozen albums to download full quality to my phone and listen to them with the Retro music player.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by helsinkiandrew on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:11AM (#39967734)
> There is no monetary reason to be on spotify, the only reason we are on there is because fans asked.

This isn't an excuse for Spotify not paying much for plays, but I bet having music on spotify helps the gig revenue though.

In some ways this is also true for Taylor Swift et al - they also make thousands times the amount from playing gigs than 'selling' albums, streaming, and radio plays but that drives ticket sales.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by jfoster on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:20AM (#39967817)
Indie: No one pays you.

Popular: Gigs pay you.

Taylor Swift: Governments pay you millions of dollars for regional exclusivity. (essentially, play 2 - 3 concerts instead of 10+)

https://www.theguardian.com/music/2024/mar/05/taylor-swift-s...

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by brabel on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:49AM (#39968366)
The music industry is the most vicious example of inequality.

While some artists are so big that governments compete to have you come to their country (and NOT to your neighbours), the vast majority has trouble even getting to play free gigs.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by coldtea on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:45AM (#39968340)
Of course that's a quite rare case of a small nation with many neighbors with interested listeners, trying to get an artist to play there exclusively in order to drive concert tourism.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by jhrmnn on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:23AM (#39967848)
Spotify should then be run as ad business—charge artists to let them advertise on Spotify.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by l33tman on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:07AM (#39968099)
Isn't that exactly what they do if they have the stream-cutoff discussed in this thread then? At least implicitly..
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by zadokshi on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:15AM (#39968158)
This is literally their current business model. Large music distributors pay for streams, the songs rise up the charts, people see the songs. If that’s not advertising I don’t know what is.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by neocritter on Monday April 08, 2024 @08:16AM (#39968915)
That sounds like good old fashioned payola.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by petecooper on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:25AM (#39967854)
Reading this has made me buy the last two physical items on my Bandcamp wishlist.

Bandcamp isn't perfect, but it fits well with my listening habits and I'm glad it earns _some_ money for you in the grand scheme of things.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by whstl on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:08AM (#39968108)
Yep. Last I checked, it still pays 90% royalties to artists, all with a sane interface that is pleasant and just works, and no dark patterns.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by atoav on Monday April 08, 2024 @11:25AM (#39970678)
Thanks for supporting your local artist : )
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by jug on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:29AM (#39967878)
Yeah, no cash in it but I figure it's mainly to gain exposure to hopefully later on get those into the "playing gigs" / merch audience, because reach is on the other hand massive on Spotify.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by mkl on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:42AM (#39967966)
How many Spotify plays was that?
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by atoav on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:23AM (#39968207)
Not sure, and I am too lazy to ask our drummer for that ; )
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by TomK32 on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:59AM (#39968066)
I buy my music at bandcamp and other sites. I always feel a bit angry if an artists doesn't offer a proper download for their music.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by defrost on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:08AM (#39968111)
Whether or not you buy Only The Shit You Love by Damian Cowell's Disco Machine on bandcamp:

https://damiancowell.bandcamp.com/album/only-the-shit-you-lo...

you can get the "free" synced multi episode animated web comic from youtube:

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLkRxIMJ3GpPH_NurdvJLL...

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by TomK32 on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:24AM (#39968212)
Wow, that's really Only the Shit I Love. It's now on my wishlist until my bank account allows to buy it.

Talking of Aussie bands: https://drunkmums.bandcamp.com/album/beer-baby and https://3pod.bandcamp.com/album/middleborough-rd

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by dzek69 on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:40AM (#39968317)
I wonder if is there a monetary reason to be on youtube (music)?

I listen to most music on yt music (although their client sucks) and buy stuff on bandcamp whenever i love some band and it's available there. I've never seen a value in spotify - limited library with no ability to fill the gaps with custom files (like you can do on YT music), client is meh, additional cost or ads are meh too.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by greenie_beans on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:57AM (#39968798)
real heads buy music from bandcamp
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by em-bee on Monday April 08, 2024 @08:15AM (#39968913)
do you have listener numbers for spotify and bandcamp?
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by nickburns on Monday April 08, 2024 @08:45AM (#39969138)
lots of commercial endeavors rely on investment, capital or otherwise, to increase exposure and growth. sucks to be feeling like you're working or 'spending' for nothing in any context. but hopefully you guys ultimately see the return you deserve.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by jzzskijj on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:31AM (#39967140)
> It surprises me how much of my Spotify library is no longer available. There’s at least a few dozen songs in my Spotify library that have been taken off the platform. It shows up in the list greyed out. A lot of good songs too.

This probably has more to do with publishers and licensing contracts than artists pulling their music off from platforms. Sometimes even bigger artists' albums disappear when publisher is sold or goes out from the business. Or the licensing contract's period runs out. As sad it is, many artists don't own the rights to their music, and if the rights owner is defunct, then there are missing albums or even discographies.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by snailmailman on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:37AM (#39967176)
It’s infuriating.

Spotify for instance had some Spotify exclusive “DJ mixes” that were all an hour of well-mixed playlists. Spotify got artists to curate them and would have “XYZ’s DJ Mix”. They were perfect for seamless music listening at the gym. No breaks between songs. Non stop music. I listened to them all the time.

But one day a few months ago they all just vanished. Every one. I had added several to my Spotify library. For a bit they were playlists of grayed out songs. And then the playlists themselves vanished too. This content was all Spotify exclusive- the music is just gone now. It’s not available elsewhere.

It was all “mixed” versions of songs with smooth transitions in an out. Luckily I had added most of the original songs to other Spotify playlists that I had. But still, the mixes themselves are gone.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by input_sh on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:59AM (#39967302)
You should know: Apple Music filled that niche to perfection. Hands down, better than it ever was on Spotify. More choices, easier discovery, more collaboration with external brands, etc.

https://music.apple.com/us/curator/apple-music-dj-mixes/1441...

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by snailmailman on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:11AM (#39967365)
Interesting! I’ll definitely take a look. I’ve been meaning to try Apple Music.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by jonathantf2 on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:16AM (#39967777)
It's the reason I use both. Spotify's recommendations and social features are much better than Apple's - but the exclusive DJ sets and recordings of concerts etc are a great value add.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by znpy on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:04AM (#39967327)
Frankly, this is why I always ignored Spotify and other streaming services and keep a jolly roger above my head.

If you had pirated or ripped those mixes off Spotify, you'd still have them. And you probably paid enough months of subscription to feel okay with that.

Because in the end https://xkcd.com/488/

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by dieselgate on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:17AM (#39967395)
Thanks for the comic link and enjoy the riff off the book title “steal this book”.

Just looked into deleting my Spotify account through the app and appears that’s not an (obvious?) option. Ugh

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by lotsofpulp on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:49AM (#39967595)
The comic does not make sense for iTunes, since if you buy music from Apple, you get the non DRM file that is yours to use however you want.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by xerox13ster on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:17AM (#39967787)
It’s xkcd number 488, it was probably made when iTunes was still selling or just after it stopped selling DRM music.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by lotsofpulp on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:24AM (#39967849)
Good point, the comic was published Oct 2008 according to xkcd and Apple stopped selling DRM music in Jan 2009.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by WickyNilliams on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:15AM (#39967772)
Not sure what genre you listen to, but soundcloud and mixcloud are the place to go for high quality mixes imo. That's where the DJs post. It's not immune to takedowns and tracks disappearing. But I have a playlists of hundreds of mixes curated over years and they're all still there. Many even with an option to download if you so wish
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by jillesvangurp on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:32AM (#39967505)
A lot of that is also bad meta data. I have a few playlists for around 10 years or so. Every so often I have to go in and hunt down greyed out tracks that are no longer there but are available in identical versions elsewhere. Publishers apparently regularly update what they have on the platform and there's a lot of duplication as well between best off albums, remastered albums, etc. And some artists, like Neil Young, actually pulled most of their content. Spotify seems very happy to just break everybody's playlists continuously.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Macha on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:35AM (#39968281)
These disappearing tracks are the reason I moved back to managing my own music collection.

I do have YouTube Music for listening to stuff I don't own yet, but primarily I use Jellyfin these days for music.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by nmeagent on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:48AM (#39968006)
> Spotify seems very happy to just break everybody's playlists continuously.

I remember this being particularly infuriating with movie soundtracks or other compilations, where individual tracks would often evaporate one day for bogus (licensing) reasons.

> And some artists, like Neil Young, actually pulled most of their content.

Yeah, I actually left Spotify with Neil. Apparently though he and other artists like Joni Mitchell that left at the time are now back on the service as of a few weeks ago.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by geraldhh on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:07AM (#39967708)
> Spotify seems very happy to just break everybody's playlists continuously.

definitely possible to avoid this, but given it would be a follow-up cost from the failing core business, it probably could not be done. hell, they didn't even get around to making basic meta-data reliably present.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by pydry on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:34AM (#39967914)
>Spotify seems very happy to just break everybody's playlists continuously.

This is an artefact of the industry and not something they have much control over. Labels for larger artists just don't just sell global streaming rights in perpetuity. They will carve it up by region and time in order to try and maximize profit.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Sparkyte on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:18AM (#39967410)
Or it would force small musicians to advertiwse more. Which is mutually beneficial to Spotify and the user.

1k is a relatively low number to hit at least they didn't set the demonizations level the same as other platforms.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by countmora on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:11AM (#39967363)
I think royalties from <1k streams are basically nothing anyway. Giving up the ability to distribute your music for free and reach more people would be a terrible idea.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by realprimoh on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:38AM (#39967184)
I use YouTube Premium 90% of the time now for this reason. All the remixes and other indie mixes that I listen to are on YouTube and YouTube has so much more that I find it a hard value proposition to beat.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by klausjensen on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:20AM (#39967427)
Slightly off topic, but where do you go to find this now?
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by rchaud on Monday April 08, 2024 @09:02AM (#39969289)
Why compensate YT to listen to tracks they're not compensating the artists for?
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by TonyTrapp on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:59AM (#39967298)
> But would this cause smaller musicians to decide to pull their stuff off Spotify?

It's already happening. Even some artists which are above the limit pull out to show their support for smaller artists.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by vvillena on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:10AM (#39967357)
> There’s at least a few dozen songs in my Spotify library that have been taken off the platform. It shows up in the list greyed out.

As infuriating as this is, it's the reason I still use Spotify. A music service that hides their catalog changes by subtly modifying my playlists is a no-go. Having the songs still appear lets me know, as it gives me the opportunity to find those songs elsewhere.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by junon on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:36AM (#39967533)
Yeah I have to admit, Spotify uses the least amount of cruddy dark patterns. Their model is very upfront about paying, so they have never nagged me for anything. Their interface isn't the best but it's consistent.

These days there's a lot of worth in that, the bars been set quite low.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by cranberryturkey on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:28AM (#39967122)
Back to torrenting I guess. If I’m not mistaken snoop said he made 45k off 1 billion plays. Thats ridiculous
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by reliablereason on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:42AM (#39967206)
That was apparently a track that was not his own, he was only a partial co author of that track.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by ansc on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:46AM (#39967234)
To be fair, that's because the label siphons the rest. Spotify pays $4 per 1000 streams.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by djxfade on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:17AM (#39967400)
Where do you get those numbers from? I'm a self published artist. I had 150k streams on Spotify last year. I only earned roughly $450. There's no label or other middleman here taking a cut. Spotify is just cheap.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by ssl-3 on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:39AM (#39967550)
They say: $4 / 1,000 = $0.004 per streamed track.

You say: $450 / 150,000 = $0.003 per streamed track.

The two sets of numbers don't seem so far apart that the discrepancy cannot be explained by rounding errors.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Dylan16807 on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:27AM (#39967465)
Snoop's number was $0.045 per thousand plays.

ansc's number was $4 per thousand plays.

Your number is $3 per thousand plays.

It sounds like you basically agree with ansc. While Spotify might be cheap, that cheapness is not the problem Snoop is having.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Martinussen on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:22AM (#39967445)
It's somewhere around $3.5/1k streams - you're not exactly super far off their estimate either, though. It varies a bit based on (listener, or artist?) regions too, I believe.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by auggierose on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:29AM (#39967482)
That's not too far off, is it? 150 * $4 = $600 ≈ $450.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by jstummbillig on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:58AM (#39967296)
Ah. Music income numbers, where the details are not actually details. He did say that[1], but the statement is misleading (and has little to do with Spotify).

A very rough global average per-stream payout is often estimated at around $0.003 to $0.005. That brings the payout for 1 billion streams between $3,000,000 and $5,000,000. Let's go with the lower end. This is actual money paid out by Spotify for 1 billion streams, as in, a bank transfer of $3,000,000.

How do you get from there to $45,000?

- As with any legacy artist, the record label gets most (maybe 70%). Why that is, oh well. It's less shocking if you think of the label as an employer and how little an average employee gets compared to what they produce. Do you need an employer? Absolutely not. Do you need a record label? Absolutely not. Anyway, a 70% cut would leave the artist with $900,000.

- Expenses: There are various costs associated with producing, distributing, and promoting music, hotel costs. Let your imagination run wild. Safe to say: This is a black hole, depending on how you want the process to look. If Snoop wants to sit in a big studio for months, he pays prices, for month, but that's not required to make music. Renting a high end studio on end is lifestyle. Sure, it's an expense, but it's like complaining about your profit while driving a Porsche. Awkward. Let's assume a 20% deduction here, reducing the revenue to $720,000.

- Focus on Publishing Royalties: Publishing royalties are just one part of the total royalties an artist earns. So there's quite a bit of double accounting going on if you want to pretend that the above costs are all deducted from your Spotify income.

If we assume publishing royalties make up only 10% of the total, that brings the figure down to $72,000.

- tldr: Snoop is living the big life, confused about money, and then proceeds to confuse others about money.

[1] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/us/s...

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by tibu on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:12AM (#39967739)
If the ownership is with the publishing studio then AFAIK they pay the producing, distribution and promotion. It is an investment into the artist, so they shouldn't have these costs.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by addicted on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:46AM (#39967990)
A record label is probably much more of a VC than it is an employer.

The business has changed since streaming and self publishing but the labels took bets on artists and gave them expensive recording studios and marketing dollars, gave them some basic money, and in return took the majority of rights to the first few albums.

They also knew that if the artist truly made it big they would likely go to a different label where they could get better terms or start their own where they’d keep all the money after the initial contract which drove their side higher.

The record label model clearly doesn’t work as well in modern days but it was successful for good reasons at the time it really flourished.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Daz1 on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:03AM (#39967314)
Ah yes performative postering by people who 'really care' about artists getting paid.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by dkjaudyeqooe on Monday April 08, 2024 @03:58AM (#39967293)
Just use YT Music with an ad blocker. The artists still get paid.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by Mashimo on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:50AM (#39967604)
> Back to torrenting I guess.

Or just buy it on bandcamp friday and give it all to the artists :)

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by amelius on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:58AM (#39967653)
I hear taylor swift is a billionaire. Is she on Spotify?
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by easyThrowaway on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:28AM (#39967477)
>I don’t know much about how music licensing works. But would this cause smaller musicians to decide to pull their stuff off Spotify?

A lot of smaller artists don't have a say regarding licensing and distribution. They're usually managed by a local minor label, which in turn has specific agreements with bigger players (Columbia, UMG) once your music sells more than, let's say 50.000 copies and they need a partner to publish a release on more territories. A few artists also get their own label.

For example, Peggy Gou tracks are usually released trough Dudu Records (Her own label) -> Ninja Tune -> XL Recordings, which is basically the same label that nowadays publishes Adele and Radiohead. Adele went even a step further, and her music is handled by Columbia Records for the US market.

Until you reach this level of clout, you have very little direct control over your syncs and streaming rights in the "regular", Billboard-tracked, market.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by kunley on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:51AM (#39967610)
The mechanism there is kind of "dontcareism": yes, indie musicians will go away, but Spotify doesn't care, because ultimately this won't stop listeners from using it, over time most of them will forget what they really wanted
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by pydry on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:22AM (#39967838)
They do care, they're just exploiting the indie musicians' lack of leverage. Together they matter a lot, they're just powerless individually.

It's the same dynamic companies use against ununionized labor.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by bashwizard on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:56AM (#39967641)
I have a few thousand of streams per month and I make pennies from it. It's not like I care about being demonetized on spotify and losing a few pennies.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by baby on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:59AM (#39967660)
It’s not just about the money. It’s about the exposure! If you’re not a big band you’re making money from touring. More people listening and discovering you online = more people attending your tours and maybe reaching a threshold where you can make good money
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by rchaud on Monday April 08, 2024 @09:09AM (#39969349)
It's the opposite. If you're not a big band, you usually cannot afford to go on tour. You have no manager, no contacts, you have to handle booking venues, lodging and transport yourself and hope that you can make some of it back in ticket sales.

Most bands can't do this. They're not full time musicians, many have a day job. The ones that can are likely to come from rich families where they get time and money to pursue their passions, insteas of going to college and getting a job.

Lana Del Ray, Grimes and Billy Eilish are some of the biggest artists of the 2010s, all of them grew up rich and connected.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by baby on Monday April 08, 2024 @10:35PM (#39975799)
If not a tour you play in cafes and bars
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by richrichardsson on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:40AM (#39967944)
I have roughly 25-30 tracks on Spotify.

They send me a monthly email detailing the number of plays I received as an artist, and it averages around 300.

So each track is getting around 10 plays per month.

So none of them come anywhere close to the minimum threshold.

I made around $10/year from Spotify plays, it's a pittance, but over all the streaming platforms I would get enough for a new plugin each year, this makes it "worthwhile".

I absolutely will not allow Spotify to have content on their platform without reimbursement.

The only people losing from this are the handful of fans who like my music.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by rohansingh on Monday April 08, 2024 @07:29AM (#39968620)
Article states "threshold of 1,000 plays in the preceding 12 months".

Sounds like you're well over that, at around 3-4K plays per year.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by richrichardsson on Monday April 08, 2024 @10:33AM (#39970153)
If I understand correctly it's each and every track needs 1k plays. As an artist over all my tracks I'd meet the threshold of 1k plays, but I don't think that's how it works.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by rohansingh on Monday April 08, 2024 @10:44AM (#39970279)
Yeah, good point. This would probably be better received overall if it were a per-artist minimum rather than a per-track.

On the other hand, that would make it pretty trivial for garbage/AI content distributors to circumvent.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by richrichardsson on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @04:18AM (#39977195)
If they really cared about musicians they would have just left it at fining the aggregators for allowing crap on the platform. Just a tiny amount of KYC from the aggregators would solve the problem, but instead the aggregators were just as greedy as Spotify and were happy to allow any old shit in, so they could grab another slice of the pie.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by danpalmer on Monday April 08, 2024 @05:54AM (#39968033)
This is the reason I have stuck with Apple Music so long (and previously Google Play Music). I have a fair number of sentimental tracks that I've carried with me in my collection for decades which aren't on streaming sites.

Spotify doesn't have an answer for this. Just don't listen to things outside the Spotify library. Apple Music (and GPM before it) lets me upload my own tracks and sync them between my devices.

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by sanketskasar on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:46AM (#39968349)
Finally, someone else who feels the same pain as I do. Believe me you, I keep subscriptions of both Apple Music and Spotify. Apple Music for the better in general catalog and better syncing, Spotify for better discovery. I plan on creating a tool that would allow me to download all the songs in my library so that I don't lose on them when Spotify or AM decide to remove it from their catalog. Apple Music, at least, shows the track details but greys it out. Spotify simply shows an empty entry, which frustrates me even more.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by dkn775 on Monday April 08, 2024 @09:44AM (#39969652)
There’s an app called song shift that works 90% well. It’ll transfer the music over from one service to another. Also you can export Apple songs to CSV using desktop iTunes
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by danpalmer on Monday April 08, 2024 @10:14AM (#39969920)
That's solving a different problem. If you have a track that is not on any service, Apple Music will still accept the song file being added to your library and sync it for you. Spotify will not as it does not do cloud file sync.
Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by keeperofdakeys on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:32AM (#39968262)
And maybe it wasn't removed by their choice. Below is a video of someone who had all their Spotify music removed with no recourse, due to a claim the were buying streams. No recourse.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kVY7-Ti77UQ

Re:Spotify demonetizes all tracks under 1k streams by coldtea on Monday April 08, 2024 @06:39AM (#39968311)
>I don’t know much about how music licensing works. But would this cause smaller musicians to decide to pull their stuff off Spotify?

It might, but then there's this:

(1) they're not making money already anyway (they'd be getting like $3 for 1000 streams before)

(2) that's were the listeners are (not the listeners they have, since they don't have many to begin with, but the ones they wish to attract)

(3) most of such a low number as 1000 streams are usually themselves, band members, friends, and family, plus whoever they sent a link to and gave it a short listen before moving on.