I’m terrified of losing access to all my stuff because of forced 2FA I never signed up for. I get that it’s more secure, but it can be secure to the point of having unrecoverable data. All it would take is someone carelessly deciding to get a new phone number. I have a friend who recently talked about wanting to get a new number with his new phone. I asked about 2FA and he seemed to have no knowledge of it and said he didn’t have anything like that. He kept his number, but if he didn’t, I could see him easily getting locked out of his Apple account (which he has), and his bank.
If you have recovery keys enabled, it’s a different story. Enabling screen clearly states that you can get locked out of your account without your recovery key. You can set up recovery accounts too, like those of your family members.
Then 1 yr later a hn thread will remind you to try to log into your google SSO and.. bam it works. And you still have no idea why ALL of your g servces (domains, email, gphone, etc) were disconnected a year ago.
1) I’ve never ever heard Apple lock someone out of their Apple ID. Maybe they are obligated to do it for law enforcement in US but even none of that. Meanwhile I’ve heard a ton of stories of Google locking people out of their accounts.
2) The convenience of using Safari, with 2FA and passkeys set via iCloud Keychain is too good to ignore. Literally 1 click (passkeys) or 2 clicks at most, authenticated with Face ID.
So I’m using this setup rn. You can set custom domains with your iCloud email too.
Always the tradeoff with Apple is choice and flexibility versus a seamless and pleasant user experience.
I can often go through an entire sign-up, entering shipping, and payment, at a new site, without typing a single thing.
If someone has pwned my 1Password I don’t really care if they log on to my Discord or order a limited amount of crap on Amazon because I am in much deeper shit at that point.
Oh, wait: Steam has them I guess. Every so often (once every few months?) I have to type in one of their codes.
I did just check and I guess I could be doing this with non-sms codes if I added them to my password manager. If I had more than just Steam that used them, I’d do that.
But.
Those synced passwords are a huge, juicy target. Someday, someone is going to get them. This process is a vulnerable mess.
How is that possible?
That being said, I feel the parent’s viewpoint is naively idealistic, the payment industry is huge with many players and most attempts at new standards or interoperability are by people trying to get a cut of the action, no one is going to adopt a new standard unless they feel they absolutely have to.
ApplePay is pragmatic in that it largely hooks into the existing CC systems and thanks to Apple’s market size they have enough clout to convince people it’s worth the effort.
A whole new standard just for the “general good of the public” will never get any traction without regulation, and in places like the U.S. where bribery is essentially legal (so long as you call it lobbying), any new regulation like this faces an extreme uphill battle to being introduced except where someone standing to make lots of money is behind it.
Do you actually have to give them the card? Or is it only stored somehow on the phone? I wonder how this works exactly.
When I replaced my old iphone with a new one, I did the whole "transfer everything" dance. Waited around for two hours (didn't restore from icloud, but transferred from old to new), and still had to manually add my CCs to Apple Pay again.
Apple then checks if your card issuer has ApplePay enabled and if so provisions a “virtual” card which is what is stored on the device’s Secure Enclave.
I also just checked my banking app quickly which can initiate the adding of the card to wallet, showing the wallet’s add card screen with the card holder name and the last 4 digits and asking if you want to proceed.
There is no way to see what the full virtual card number is, so there is no way to use this virtual card aside from tapping your phone on CC machines or using websites which have set up ApplePay as a payment method.
CC machines don’t actually have to support ApplePay specifically, as long as it supports tap to pay without insisting on a PIN, then ApplePay works with it. In essence your phone’s NFC exactly implements the same capabilities and protocols as NFC chips on normal credit cards.
IIRC it's not exactly the same. One user-facing example where things are different is that contactless payments with a regular credit card have a 50 € maximum. If there is a limit when paying with the iPhone, it's much higher.
I also seem to recall that the merchant's payment contract must support this, but I'll have to confirm with a colleague. Although Apple Pay support is very common where I live, it did happen a few times that some restaurant's terminal accepted VISA contactless but not Apple Pay.
I've also had a situation where my CC is set up to not allow payments outside my country. Payment with Apple Pay was denied as being "out of country", whereas the physical card worked fine. The store is from a big national chain, in the heart of the capital city.
I’m pretty sure that the limit amount before PIN verification is required is embedded in the NFC, or checked online or something. Both my credit cards have limits of R500 (~26USD) after which it requires I enter my PIN after tapping it.
For one of my credit cards I’m able to pay it off with my other credit card and I have in the past tapped my iPhone to do so for payments over R50,000 (~2600USD), I don’t think there’s a limit.
However, the biggest grocery retail chain here initially had a very annoying “custom” rule on their CC machines where it would ignore the card limit and insist on asking for PIN for any payments over R500, which would cause ApplePay tap attempts to auto decline, they eventually fixed this.
The out of country issue sounds like a configuration issue with your bank or that particular merchant. My cards by default disallow use out of country and I’ve never had an issue tapping anywhere with ApplePay.
"Somehow" their information makes it around? No, you have to add them, yourself, on every device you use them from, individually.
Apple has issues with privacy, but I don't really see how this is one of them.
Now they only sell (arguable mid) pizza, but when I order there it’s delightful (to use an overused 2023 marketing buzzword)
I worked in a Pizza Hut delivery place when I was in college. I just took my son back for a campus visit and yeah, 30 years later, its still there - same location and save a few minor changes, the building still has the exact layout. A testament to whoever laid out the original floor plan.
To be fair we don’t have many fast food pizza chains in my country, it’s mostly dominos and a few small ones (with abysmal online order experience)
They’re still the worst about it AFAIK but more of their competitors now do that at least once an order now, too, so the difference isn’t as large.
(I too eat Domino's on the odd occasion the app doesn't take long enough for me to change my mind).
My credit card card [1] has fundamentally changed my online purchasing experience as it bridges what I feel is a gap between new payment methods (Apple, Google, et al) and classic payment methods (CC).
An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.
When I purchase something line, I create a new one-time card (three taps on my phone) and use that new, valid CC for purchasing. Everybody takes a CC. The card is instantly deleted after purchase, and I don't have to worry about my paypal account, apple pay account, google wallet account, ghost subs, account hacks, identity theft -- the works.
Paypal absolutely lets you stop recurring payments unilaterally on their side. I use Paypal for subscriptions wherever it's offered precisely for this reason.
https://www.paypal.com/us/cshelp/article/what-is-an-automati...
I think it maybe only shows companies you had recent transactions with.
In 2023, I had a fraudulent $0.99 Paypal Automatic Payment for "Domain Name Forwarding - Renewal" from a company (DomainsPricedRight/OwnMyDomain aka GoDaddy) that I last did business with in 2005. Yes, 18 years prior.
I was able to 'deactivate' the 'subscription' on the Paypal site after I noticed the charge but I don't think automatic payments existed on Paypal in 2005 and I'd certainly never signed up for it.
The original 2005 business I did was a one time domain purchase that was transferred to another registrar within a year.
It was real fun to also see on Paypal that I could have been fraudulently charged up to $10,000.
It's kind of scary to think that any company I've done a Paypal transaction with could maybe do the same thing (or any of the companies that eventually acquire their merchant accounts...)
https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_manage-paylist
[ EDIT: which redirects to the one you cited, so forget my attempt to be less wrong ]
There are also authenticator browser extensions so you do not have to use a phone app for those either.
The software I use for the SMS codes is KDE Connect and SMS code.
The seller is motivated to make the buying process as easy, fast, and uncomplicated as possible. This is a direct correlation with how many things they sell, and in response how much money they make.
On the other hand - consumer opinion and regulation forces them to ensure that the buying process is secure, that someone else isn't buying things on your account, that they have proper logging of what goes on, etc.
The seller shouldn't "Fix" the buying experience by removing the security aspects of it. They should fix the buying experience by using modern authentication like passkeys and ensuring that their applications and sites support password managers.
https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/ebay-picks-up-paypal... - August 2002
Of the two applications I use for the SMS flow, one is generally useful to have anyway. The authenticator extension or an app is absolutely necessary for this type of 2FA and the alternative to some app is to not use 2FA at all or use SMS authentication.
Is this a native phone feature or an app? You're lucky if that's the only place it sends notifications.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_customer_authentication
I'm not sure what triggers it.
And a credit card I've got recently also asks for a second code, after the 3ds code.
No, it's the shop that decides actually. More and more accepts do direct payments from card numbers without additional checks, by the way.
Have never seen that with VISA or MC.
I have no words to express how much I hate this.
I'll happily take this shit-show cacophony of various 2fa methods and authentication types if nobody is stealing money from my bank account or ordering stuff on ebay on my behalf.
The flip side of this - is that if companies properly setup auth and allow you to use username+password (or passkeys) and a TOTP method then this is all basically copy/paste from your password manager or verify on your phone and the process is super easy.
Even better: I wouldn't care about people stealing money from my bank account if cleaning it up and making whole was my bank's responsibility and not mine or some hapless vendor. Neither I, nor store vendors should have to put up with the "shit-show cacophony." The bank's entire reason for existence is to secure access to my money--it should be entirely their problem.
I also don't do this on my phone, but on a regular PC.
https://www.theguardian.com/money/2022/mar/14/uk-shoppers-fa...
https://www.visa.co.uk/pay-with-visa/changes-in-payment-secu...
I don't know the details of when it is and isn't required. I am asked pretty much all the time for transactions using my Danish cards, and only some of the time for the British cards.
I do the same. Too many times I've had major issues trying to buy stuff on mobile so I just stopped doing it like 8 years ago. Literally the only thing I pay for with my phone is my hockey sessions via Venmo.
I don't need to worry about my details still being with that merchant. I don't have to worry about the merchant's convolution and likely-illegal cancellation process. The only negative I can think of is that any dispute has to go through PayPal, and while I've never done it I would bet money they are going to be skewed more in the merchant's favor than the credit card company. But that being said I have had fully legitimate chargebacks (as in not "I want a refund and they said no" but "this is a fraudulent charge I never agreed to") get denied and reversed by Discover so that's not a 100% certainty either.
I never receive money through PayPal so while I've read all the same horror stories everyone else has, that doesn't seem likely to affect me. My biggest gripe is the full-screen advertisement for whatever service they're pushing every time you log in on the website.
Or you are saying it’s not worth reducing your usage of PayPal unless you get rewards?
I got fed up and opened a refund ticket with paypal describing the problems and within 30 min the merchant contacted me promising to send the missing items and refund 20% of the cost if i closed the ticket in paypal.
The aim is not "profit" but to get the deserved attention and bypass clear stalling tactics like having to prove a negative. Needles to say that I Did not ever use that merchant again.
Want to have charges go direct to your bank for 2 weeks ? you move it up on the list.
Want to try a new card but are not sure you'll keep using it ? add to the wallet and move up or down depending on how much you want to use it.
And it also managed subscriptions.
It is now a steaming pile of garbage for so many reasons, and it has always been a death trap for any small merchant, but they gave a fairly good shot at the wallet side of things. Good luck getting Nintendo for instance trust any other third party wallet system.
They owned PayPal for a while, so it was heavily promoted. It's still their first choice AFAICT.
When you use a 3rd party payment provider like PayPal it does a really good job of forcing all of this to be automatic compared to things trying to autofill custom forms just because it's integrated by the site instead of the user. MFA hell is starting to erode that actually being easier though and now there is more and more often no simple approach left.
Still, PayPal is an absolute last resort for me.
First it can pay directly from a bank account.
Second a lot of countries don’t have many options other than PayPal.
The most glaring odd thing here is that you apparently don't have your password vault available on the same machine you're shopping from, which seems odd to me. Even so, if I went that route it'd still be easy b/c with the Apple ecosystem, the clipboard is shared between devices. One can copy a password from the phone and paste it on the Mac.
The tl;dr here is that I really don't understand why you had to retype your password. I never type my strong passwords. Why would you put yourself in a position where that's required?
Finally, when I pay via Paypal using my Amex, I never have to re-auth to Amex. It just flows through. So it sounds like that's something you've chosen to set up, not something inherent to the process.
Likewise I've used a half dozen different cards and multiple bank accounts through PayPal for the last couple decades and can't remember the last time I've had to reauth on any of them during a checkout.
That one's on me, yes. The Yubikey I needed to unlock the password manager on the PC was upstairs and I couldn't be bothered to get it, so I used my phone instead.
(Why was the yubikey upstairs? Well you see, that's where the fireproof safe is. But I can't blame ebay for that, so I didn't mention it)
If the machine with the passwords is less exposed it's on average a lot safer (but now you have the problem of keyloggers of course)
To be fair to the parties involved, they might well blame "EU strong customer authentication rules"
I bought some lottery tickets online for a present to myself and the experience was smooooth. No cart, no checkout steps, no need to create an account, there was a QR code right next to the tickets that I had to scan with my banking app to buy them right here, right now.
"BTW, for your own safety, we implemented two factor on your account, and tied it to your old phone. Wait, you don't have that phone anymore, cause it was something like a 10 yr old retirement that you never obsessively check? And we didn't give you the option for an email? Or even warn you? Too bad. We now no longer accept logins for your own money."
First I had to log into ebay - no problem, got my password manager right here, as soon as I unlock my phone with my fingerprint. Now I'll just key in my 12 character, randomly generated password with mixed case letters, numbers and symbols.
Then ebay decided they wanted to send me a code by SMS. I'd never enabled that security option, but whatever. I can do that, quick fingerprint to unlock the phone then key in the code.
Then I chose to pay with paypal, requiring a second password. And a 2FA code, this time from a TOTP app. For some reason paypal ask for TOTP every time. Easy enough, quick fingerprint auth then just key in the code.
Then I told paypal I wanted to pay by card, as I always do. They redirected me to my bank, who asked me to use their mobile app to authorise the payment with my fingerprint. After unlocking my phone with my fingerprint, naturally.
Clearly, the days when businesses thought online shopping ought to be low-friction are long gone.