But the fact is if there is a bad enough electrical/wiring fault, especially as the car gets older, you are toast and you have no steering.
Of course the same thing can happen with mechanical steering (eg a broken linkage) it comes down to the quality of the design and build.
Probably won't even allow you to start the car if one of them is faulty.
This kind of thing will almost certainly be designed to comply with ISO 26262.
Nissan has steer-by-wire with a backup mechanical system.
The stability control part is probably the biggest safety benefit of this steer-by-wire system.
Other manufacturers have had similar levels of electronic steering "augmentation" of one kind or another for a long time (e.g. electronically steered rear wheels). In this kind of thing, the safety case is probably that the system only provides small adjustments so that:
1. The driver can overcome any errors in the electronic augmentation system using the main steering system
2. If the system fails, it can switch off and the driver can still steer the old-fashioned way.
The shock over it on HN is just because of how few people here work in automotive.
What's new about the Cybertruck is it _only_ has a steer by wire system with no mechanical linkages at all. But this is being misreported as the first steer-by-wire system which doesn't cooperate with a mechanical linkage- Nissan has done that for quite a while in some models.
Airbus has been FBW for nearly 40 years now. And recent Boeings are FBW as well, the mechanical linkages are only between the yokes, something which is not relevant on a car.
For one, mechanical steering is still very complicated, with many meters (miles?) of hydraulic hoses, actuators, pressure control systems etc.
Two, aerospace is healthily paranoid about QA and failure modes. I'm sure a steer-by-wirw can be extremely safe when done with that mindset. But Im not sure if that's the car industry's mindset, let alone Tesla's.
Finally, fly-by-wire offers enormous safety benefits in aeroplanes, because of what it enables. But I have no idea what steer by wire enables for a car.
>For one, mechanical steering is still very complicated
Yes, and digital steering is by nature even more complicated.
>aerospace is healthily paranoid about QA and failure modes. I'm sure a steer-by-wirw [sic] can be extremely safe when done with that mindset
What? So if we have the right 'mindset' then we can ignore any complexity and adapt anything we want. Why even let users drive cars now? Make their fleet 100% autonomous. Just do it with a mindset of QA and safety!
People are killed by vehicles every day, and some of those are vehicle failures as well. Saying someone will be killed by it isn't interesting. The question instead is will it fail more often than existing designs, which is something only time will tell. But we've had throttle by wire for a long, long time now, and unintended acceleration issues caused by the system failing are largely unheard of. It's completely possible to engineer a robust electrical system just as it's completely possible to have design faults in the mechanical systems that cause premature wear & failure.
The only possible advantage I can think of is that when you start the car up again after having reverse parked, it'll be more obvious what way the wheels are currently pointing, so you can straighten up. But that's such a trivial problem.
A much easier to manouver car, because you can get true variable speed ratio steering.
It's explained really well here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agMrewRJTow
Tbh I still think it's a bit of a silly idea. But it's not completely without its merits(the one done by Tesla was though - that was completely entirely pointless).
I'm skeptical but I can see the potential benefits of drive-by-wire, definitely. The yoke, nope (except maybe for racing drivers).
With this it literally changes how much your wheel turns for the same amount of steering wheel/yoke movement. So at high speeds turning the yoke by 90 degrees will turn the wheels maybe 10 degrees so you don't kill yourself, but at low speeds the exact same movement will move the wheels 45 degrees so the car is a lot more manoeuvrable.
(I assume you don't mean removing the whole steering column. That's definitely a big deal, but it's independent of the shape of the steering control)
The current 400V architecture would charge even slower than the raw math would imply, because it requires the car to handle the voltage difference internally. Going through that path bottlenecks the charge rate at something Chevy-Boltish like 50kW that's simply not very viable for road trips.
GM's clever solution is to present the battery pack as 2 400V packs. It does pose some very tricky pack balancing requirements though.
Other 800V cars charge quite poorly on 400V stations, usually with a hard cap at much lower than the potential max charge due to inverter limits.
I think no one else is doing that at the moment.
https://twitter.com/baglino/status/1730391023799386480
It will be interesting to see Tesla's rollout of 800V stations, so far they don't have any within their own network.
This sounds a little different. It operates at 800V and switches to 400V for charging.
I think that will simplify things and hopefully avoid Ultium's weird glitches during charging.
TBH, I'm really looking forward to seeing the Tesla tested on 800V CCS chargers via the adapter. It seems like it is at least possible that it might charge faster on those than on the current 400V superchargers.
Of course, that would change if Tesla starts enabling 800V support on V3/V4.
Considering how bad the 4680 Model Y was, I'm not optimistic.
These systems have existed for quite some time, since it was a lot easier to use high voltage rated components for all of the 48V high power stuff (e-turbochargers, e-hybrid-compressor-whatevers, other motor driven stuff) but keep just a single downconverter to 12V for everything else.
The problem is that most digital electronics expect something like 1-5V to operate, including most controllers, processors, sensors etc, and typically this conversion is done at the module level in a distributed way. Going from 12V to 1V isn't really a problem (or 24V ish for that matter, which is what they use in notebooks), and 20V and 30V class semiconductors are easy to find and have desirable performance characteristics.
Going from 48V at every module to 12V as an intermediate bus, usually requires a transformer because otherwise you'd be switching the current on for a very short time per cycle (duty cycle proportionate to voltage ratio), and this has implications for efficiency and component sizing. So I'd think this is quite a huge change compared to the old mild hybrid systems
sort of like turning mouse acceleration on and off.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steering_ratio#Variable-ratio_...
Electric power steering is essentially the same in use as traditional hydraulic systems - they just replace the hydraulic assistance with electric motors.
The big advantage of decoupling and steer by wire is dynamic variable ratio, as well as packaging - no steering column to worry about making space for.
With steer by wire, you can easily implement say one turn lock to lock at low speed for easier parking, increasing to 2-3 turns at highway speeds for stability. Which is essentially exactly what the recent Lexus model with such a system does. At low speed it can turn its wheels from one extreme to the other in just 150 degrees of steering wheel rotation - no hand over hand turning etc. 150 degrees is essentially unthinkable on a mechanical rack and pinion system, as it would make the car incredibly twitchy on a highway.
> https://www.motortrend.com/reviews/2023-lexus-rz450e-steer-b...
It can't change the spacing of the teeth on the fly.
Geez, Elon really ought to start a goalpost moving company. But hey I'll play: yes, yes it can. That's precisely what BMW's active steering is, yes it's mechanical, yes it varies the ratio depending on speed, and yes it's been around for a couple decades now.The vast, vast majority of rack and pinion systems ever made, both old and modern, don't adjust number of turns lock to lock at all, whereas the ability is inherent in all drive by wire steering systems.
BMW active steer doesn't get remotely close to 150 degrees lock to
lock when maneuvering
Well, no. Super fast steering ratios are not an advantage, they're a necessary evil with a square steering control. There's nothing inherent in the BMW design that would prevent such a fast ratio beyond the reputation for emulating analog interfaces with quite a bit of fidelity. It speaks more to the intended use (gadget vs car) than to the underlying technology itself. its just abundantly clear there are some design and packaging
advantages when you lose the mechanical link in anything with
a steering wheel.
Every time I see this I wonder if the commentor has seen a hydraulic power steering pump. They're tiny as hydraulic and pneumatic drives are often quite a bit smaller than comparable electric ones (e.g. cordless vs pneumatic power tools). The only clear advantage that electric steering offers is one of efficiency (as a result of not driving a hydraulic pump all of the time). The rest is largely a series of trade offs, especially if you look at recirculating ball / worm gear vs rack and pinion drives.The pump size is totally irrelevant to this discussion.
There is no steering column. If you have seen a mechanical steering column, it requires a significant amount of space to route from cabin to the front wheels. This is completely gone in drive by wire - that's the packaging advantage - not the pump, not the motors.
Taken to the extreme, you can do designs that are completely impossible with mechanical steering columns - see the Canoo design for example, which uses drive by wire to create a cabin impossible with a mechanical link:
You can even design interiors that can switch from left hand to right hand drive, with a sliding steering wheel.
If you have seen a mechanical steering column
I have in fact had to remove the column on one of my cars, mostly to deal with the attached electronics. It's a relatively small device with a couple of u-joints. see the Canoo design for example, which uses steer by wire to create a
cabin that would literally be impossible with a steering column
See the first three generations of Volkswagen vans.If you have seen a column - congratulations, you will then know it needs room to route to the wheels, and is restricted in the paths it can take to get there quite significantly, vs of course plain ole wires that can snake any way you like. Those restrictions are exactly why your VW vans have a column between the drivers legs.
This is getting genuinely funny now, however I think I'm about done with this one. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Again, one mighty big steering column, present on the T2, T3, "the first three generations of Volkswagen vans" etc etc.
> https://www.cnet.com/a/img/resize/309b66cd757b35f8a47ba3d385...
Are you just ignoring the ZF articles now they don't fit your arguments anymore? Again - it's not just me saying this!
The Canoo - no column, and a ton of front cabin space:
> https://i.pinimg.com/originals/96/28/33/96283349b392b1da2f0f...
> "SbW's (Steer by Wire) additional advantages include gaining space in general and new design options in the cockpit... There is now more legroom because there is no longer a steering structure running through it."
https://www.zf.com/mobile/en/technologies/vehicle_motion_con...
By contrast, with steer-by-wire your system is essentially a black box you bolt on somewhere and then a more compact set of motors which can be coupled to the wheels at whatever is mechanically optimal.
The main reason not to do it is because your control systems need to be perfect. Conversely, above a certain vehicle mass, it's also not realistic to think that a human would be able to control the car anyway if the power steering failed, or that control system failures would still be devastating (i.e. if the power steering starts fighting you, you're going to lose).
At what point does it go from feedback to lies? Some computer saying "yep, this is what's happening", if you're lucky.
I'll yield that has been the trend for eons. That said, I don't want more of it.
What lead to my first comment is the understanding that Tesla doing something where it's... different wires.
Bus vs Ethernet or whatever. It sounds even more muted/numb.
I don't want a real car to feel like a sim. It's getting harder to tell the difference for the wrong reasons.
It's not that the simulators are closing the gap, but that the cars are becoming simulators. Lowering standards is definitely one way to meet them.
Take your "we have feedback at home" and keep it
I'm half joking through most of this, by the way. The problem is there but I'm deliberately overstating it
I'd appreciate more feel in something basic like an Altima. Not even for remotely high performance situations
I can already hear the road, I might as well feel it /s
More importantly, how my tires are reacting to it. For something so underpowered they spin in the wet from a complete stop, something awful.
Yes, tow trucks are great, but sometimes it's handy to push a car out of the way while waiting for a tow.
Another benefit in theory is packaging - you can free up more space for cabin, front trunk or motors etc when you don't have to route a physical steering column.
A variable ratio is just a regular rack and pinion setup, except the teeth on the rack are more narrowly spaced at the centre. It’s pre-defined, fixed and static. 30 degrees of steering input will always result in the same movement of the front wheels. It’s mechanically fixed.
The Cybertruck is a truly dynamic steering ratio. 30 degrees of steering input will result in a different outcome depending on othe variables such as road speed.
For example, Ford F-150 and RAM 1500 trucks from the US are exported to Australia where they need to undergo an expensive conversion process before they can be sold. This is why a base model F-150 is US$74000 in Australia.
And you have thieves stealing cars by hacking into the easily-accessible car light CAN bus - a CAN network switch could also act as a firewall to fix those thefts without re-engineering every single part.
It makes sense for Tesla since they're more vertically integrated but other car manufacturers seem more "parts bin" and having to migrate your whole car over to a new architecture will limit the parts you can use massively until the whole industry switches.
Although this particular example is from what some would consider a controversial video, this is an example of how water ingress can result in the disablement of vehicle electronics: https://youtu.be/Gio3DSTkQH4?feature=shared&t=181
Drive by wire kind of scares me.
As long as the same rigour that is applied to the aviation industry is used and that they don't use an MCAS, I think I'm ok with it.
Though I would also guess the mechanical linkages of an airliner are under a lot more stress than a car’s, so the gains from FBW would be a lot larger, even aside from not having to run mechanical linkages through the entire hull.
Physical linkages break too.
Same with keyless starters, i remember this story about some French car experiencing a kind of highway run-off that couldn't be stopped due to this BS solution to a non-existing problem.
"But hey, that's not innovative enough"
shit breaks a lot when you'e been driving for 35+ years
I could go through a list of critical mechanical systems that have broken on cars I've driven over the years, including my beloved Toyota pickup.
> i want less SW in a car, not more
I just want Good Engineering Practice. Good engineering encompasses a lot, including doing a DFMEA (Design Failure Modes Effects Analysis) that will advise whether the software system is safer than the hardware linkage or vice versa.
I don't know anyone with a passenger car who's ever had the steering wheel linkage break to the point turning the steering wheel stopped affecting the wheels. I like the failsafe there. Hopefully at least the brake cylinder is still connected to the brake pedal mechanically?
Cutting corners is cutting corners. Build cheap firmware or use materials with poor corrosion resistance and you get problems.
A firmware bug just happens, and there's no way (as an owner) to detect it beforehand.
Fly-by-wire systems in airplanes are way more complicated than cars and they have excellent safety records, which even improved as those systems became widespread.
The reason so much bad software exists in the world is because of the prevalence of people writing software without an accredited engineering education, licensing, or regulation. Software can be good if built to the engineering standards expected of any other engineering discipline.
I am not aware of many that are actually steer by wire.
Not according to this:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Titan_submersible_implosion
> A modified Logitech F710 wireless game controller was used to steer
Even then, it wasn't responsible for the implosion, right?
There's no such thing as 'simple' transformer-based DC-DC conversion. If you want to use just a transformer, you're looking at AC. If you then want to convert it to DC after, you're going to need a rectifier plus a buck converter. The CyberTruck is 48VDC meaning if you want to do any kind of voltage conversion you're going to use a switching architecture of some sort.
> ... Perhaps PCB planar transformers will help here, but this may be one reason we don't see 50V EPR USB C devices yet (disappointed that the Cybertruck didn't decide to be the first 240W USB-C device, still stuck at 65W)
EPR is 48V.
Switching regulators are a pretty well known quantity now - and super efficient. I don't think there's much faff.
Pretty much all DC-DC converters nowadays are switching - and those chopping - and - rectifying steps you mention would be standard for any DC-DC converter whether or not it uses a transformer. In this particular case, a transformer is necessary in addition to those components, as opposed to a simple fixed inductor.
> EPR is 48V
Yes, I got confused with the maximum rating on the most popular EPR capable tester (Power-Z KM003)
> Switching regulators are a pretty well known quantity now
I'd agree with this, insofar as they're very common and we know how to design them effectively. With that said, I think it can be observed that topologies used with higher voltages generally do come with increased cost and complexity. First of all, the transformer is going to be a custom part, as opposed to something with jelly bean substitutes like inductors. Second of all, the kinds of components typically used with higher voltages like 48V are less integrated than ones for lower voltages, likely due to the kind of process technology you need to use to handle it. It's possible to get "smart" drive chips for applications like Intel processor VRMs that integrate all of the switching, gate drive, and control logic, but with higher voltage you typically have to source discrete gate drivers, controllers, feedback, etc, and I'd think it does add complexity.
Interesting, why do you say that? Maybe I misunderstood. Do you have a link?
Seems like if there were to be some kind of electrical failure, now with full steer-by-wire it could be quite a harrowing situation.
Based on the images posted from the event [1] it seems to have two discrete power steering motors (we know from previous vehicles that these have two motor driver channels internally for failover), so there's probably a decent amount of redundancy here. There seems to also be some kind of a sensor that's only populated on one side, though I can't tell what it does from the picture (position sensor?)
Given that the steering is variable gain now, seems like the vehicle speed data would also be important, as in, the communication bus is now quite important for the function of the steering module.
With the Ethernet architecture they're using now, it's likely that it's not as problematic as with CAN bus (where water intrusion can take down the whole bus) but it would be interesting to see what the design choices there were.
[1] https://twitter.com/DriveTeslaca/status/1730305183572177107/...