News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by kllrnohj on Thursday November 30, 2023 @07:16PM (#38481181)
Lexus is already doing steer by wire, they used it to make a vehicle with a yoke that didn't suck to operate (as much anyway): https://www.motortrend.com/reviews/2023-lexus-rz450e-steer-b...
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by alistairSH on Thursday November 30, 2023 @08:55PM (#38482016)
What happens if the engine shuts off (and the alternator stops spinning)? Does the steering just run off the 12v system?
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by jimt1234 on Thursday November 30, 2023 @11:21PM (#38483090)
Engineering Explained did a really good video about this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agMrewRJTow
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by dkjaudyeqooe on Thursday November 30, 2023 @11:47PM (#38483253)
To save going through that whole video for the answer: they have redundant power supplies (3 batteries total) and redundant actuator motors.

But the fact is if there is a bad enough electrical/wiring fault, especially as the car gets older, you are toast and you have no steering.

Of course the same thing can happen with mechanical steering (eg a broken linkage) it comes down to the quality of the design and build.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by HPsquared on Friday December 01, 2023 @02:44AM (#38484219)
The whole design will be such that a single electrical fault can't make it fail. It probably has at least 3 channels.

Probably won't even allow you to start the car if one of them is faulty.

This kind of thing will almost certainly be designed to comply with ISO 26262.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by sfjailbird on Friday December 01, 2023 @08:57AM (#38486681)
I've had the power steering cut out on me in a traditional ICE car, you're pretty much hosed in that situation, too, as far as steering is concerned.
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by vostrocity on Thursday November 30, 2023 @10:47PM (#38482888)
That Lexus is an EV.
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by 65a on Thursday November 30, 2023 @11:20PM (#38483085)
Hasn't VAG had steer-by-wire for nearly a decade now?
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by dharmab on Thursday November 30, 2023 @11:56PM (#38483301)
Only as part of four-wheel-steering systems in combination with mechanical steering for the front wheels.

Nissan has steer-by-wire with a backup mechanical system.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by HPsquared on Friday December 01, 2023 @02:39AM (#38484194)
I had a BMW from 2007 that had something called "active steering", where an electric motor in between the steering wheel and the rack-and-pinion sort of "adjusted" the steering, which gave it a variable steering ratio (add according to speed) and also stability control interventions (it would countersteer in a slide even if I didn't turn the wheel).

The stability control part is probably the biggest safety benefit of this steer-by-wire system.

Other manufacturers have had similar levels of electronic steering "augmentation" of one kind or another for a long time (e.g. electronically steered rear wheels). In this kind of thing, the safety case is probably that the system only provides small adjustments so that:

1. The driver can overcome any errors in the electronic augmentation system using the main steering system

2. If the system fails, it can switch off and the driver can still steer the old-fashioned way.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by harambae on Friday December 01, 2023 @12:25PM (#38489387)
Yes as well as some BMW’s, McLarens, at least some of the electric Hyundai/Kias and I’m sure a bunch of others I’m not as familiar with.

The shock over it on HN is just because of how few people here work in automotive.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by dharmab on Saturday December 02, 2023 @01:33AM (#38496465)
In those systems the steer by wire works in cooperation with a mechanical system. Other cars have had backup mechanical steering systems that engage if the steer by wire fails.

What's new about the Cybertruck is it _only_ has a steer by wire system with no mechanical linkages at all. But this is being misreported as the first steer-by-wire system which doesn't cooperate with a mechanical linkage- Nissan has done that for quite a while in some models.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by oceanplexian on Friday December 01, 2023 @01:23AM (#38483786)
Sounds like a terrible idea to me, honestly. Even Boeing aircraft still have a mechanical linkage. And Cybertruck won’t be a fighter jet no matter how much Elon proclaims it so, it’s just worlds away in terms of maintenance and safety engineering compared to what happens on an aircraft. Not saying it will be common but some sucker will eventually be killed by this.
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by masklinn on Friday December 01, 2023 @01:26AM (#38483811)
> Even Boeing aircraft still have a mechanical linkage.

Airbus has been FBW for nearly 40 years now. And recent Boeings are FBW as well, the mechanical linkages are only between the yokes, something which is not relevant on a car.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by ikekkdcjkfke on Friday December 01, 2023 @04:08AM (#38484742)
When i hear fly-by-wire i think of wire rope going from the flaps the cockpit
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by rich_sasha on Friday December 01, 2023 @06:10AM (#38485482)
I think aeroplanes are not a good point of comparison.

For one, mechanical steering is still very complicated, with many meters (miles?) of hydraulic hoses, actuators, pressure control systems etc.

Two, aerospace is healthily paranoid about QA and failure modes. I'm sure a steer-by-wirw can be extremely safe when done with that mindset. But Im not sure if that's the car industry's mindset, let alone Tesla's.

Finally, fly-by-wire offers enormous safety benefits in aeroplanes, because of what it enables. But I have no idea what steer by wire enables for a car.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by s3p on Sunday December 03, 2023 @01:30PM (#38509464)
This answer seems to generate its own proof.

>For one, mechanical steering is still very complicated

Yes, and digital steering is by nature even more complicated.

>aerospace is healthily paranoid about QA and failure modes. I'm sure a steer-by-wirw [sic] can be extremely safe when done with that mindset

What? So if we have the right 'mindset' then we can ignore any complexity and adapt anything we want. Why even let users drive cars now? Make their fleet 100% autonomous. Just do it with a mindset of QA and safety!

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by kllrnohj on Friday December 01, 2023 @03:07PM (#38491582)
> Not saying it will be common but some sucker will eventually be killed by this.

People are killed by vehicles every day, and some of those are vehicle failures as well. Saying someone will be killed by it isn't interesting. The question instead is will it fail more often than existing designs, which is something only time will tell. But we've had throttle by wire for a long, long time now, and unintended acceleration issues caused by the system failing are largely unheard of. It's completely possible to engineer a robust electrical system just as it's completely possible to have design faults in the mechanical systems that cause premature wear & failure.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by iainmerrick on Friday December 01, 2023 @05:25AM (#38485224)
Yikes! Even assuming it all works correctly and safely, who actually wants a steering wheel like that? What's the upside?

The only possible advantage I can think of is that when you start the car up again after having reverse parked, it'll be more obvious what way the wheels are currently pointing, so you can straighten up. But that's such a trivial problem.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by gambiting on Friday December 01, 2023 @06:18AM (#38485522)
>>What's the upside?

A much easier to manouver car, because you can get true variable speed ratio steering.

It's explained really well here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agMrewRJTow

Tbh I still think it's a bit of a silly idea. But it's not completely without its merits(the one done by Tesla was though - that was completely entirely pointless).

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by iainmerrick on Friday December 01, 2023 @07:06AM (#38485838)
I just meant the yoke -- variable ratio steering would still work with a wheel, right?

I'm skeptical but I can see the potential benefits of drive-by-wire, definitely. The yoke, nope (except maybe for racing drivers).

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by gambiting on Friday December 01, 2023 @07:39AM (#38486026)
Oh I guess it's just that once you elimited the need to ever turn the steering device more than 90 degrees, it doesn't need to be a wheel anymore - same reason why bicycles don't have steering wheels but handlebars.
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by kllrnohj on Friday December 01, 2023 @08:42AM (#38486534)
The yoke is to make visibility of the dashboard better. You can deal with rectangular screens easily then instead of needing to force things into a curve. Not necessarily a good enough reason, but it's not entirely frivolous.
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by drcongo on Friday December 01, 2023 @07:58AM (#38486159)
Forgive my ignorance, but is "variable speed ratio steering" not what the Citroen SM was doing 50 years ago? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DIRAVI
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by gambiting on Friday December 01, 2023 @08:16AM (#38486311)
No, that just seems to be variable speed power assisted steering - so at high speeds it gives you little assistance, at low speeds it gives you loads.

With this it literally changes how much your wheel turns for the same amount of steering wheel/yoke movement. So at high speeds turning the yoke by 90 degrees will turn the wheels maybe 10 degrees so you don't kill yourself, but at low speeds the exact same movement will move the wheels 45 degrees so the car is a lot more manoeuvrable.

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by drcongo on Friday December 01, 2023 @08:27AM (#38486404)
Ahhh, got you, thanks. I'd misunderstood the Citroen system as being somewhat like your second paragraph.
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by devnullbrain on Friday December 01, 2023 @07:58AM (#38486162)
Transformationally easier packaging requirements.
Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by iainmerrick on Friday December 01, 2023 @09:20AM (#38486952)
Can you clarify? You just mean by going from a round wheel to a rectangular yoke, right?

(I assume you don't mean removing the whole steering column. That's definitely a big deal, but it's independent of the shape of the steering control)

Re:Tesla Cybertruck Pricing and Specs by devnullbrain on Friday December 01, 2023 @10:44AM (#38488060)
I was talking about the steering column - looks like I missed what OP was focusing on.