BMW active steer doesn't get remotely close to 150 degrees lock to
lock when maneuvering
Well, no. Super fast steering ratios are not an advantage, they're a necessary evil with a square steering control. There's nothing inherent in the BMW design that would prevent such a fast ratio beyond the reputation for emulating analog interfaces with quite a bit of fidelity. It speaks more to the intended use (gadget vs car) than to the underlying technology itself. its just abundantly clear there are some design and packaging
advantages when you lose the mechanical link in anything with
a steering wheel.
Every time I see this I wonder if the commentor has seen a hydraulic power steering pump. They're tiny as hydraulic and pneumatic drives are often quite a bit smaller than comparable electric ones (e.g. cordless vs pneumatic power tools). The only clear advantage that electric steering offers is one of efficiency (as a result of not driving a hydraulic pump all of the time). The rest is largely a series of trade offs, especially if you look at recirculating ball / worm gear vs rack and pinion drives.The pump size is totally irrelevant to this discussion.
There is no steering column. If you have seen a mechanical steering column, it requires a significant amount of space to route from cabin to the front wheels. This is completely gone in drive by wire - that's the packaging advantage - not the pump, not the motors.
Taken to the extreme, you can do designs that are completely impossible with mechanical steering columns - see the Canoo design for example, which uses drive by wire to create a cabin impossible with a mechanical link:
You can even design interiors that can switch from left hand to right hand drive, with a sliding steering wheel.
If you have seen a mechanical steering column
I have in fact had to remove the column on one of my cars, mostly to deal with the attached electronics. It's a relatively small device with a couple of u-joints. see the Canoo design for example, which uses steer by wire to create a
cabin that would literally be impossible with a steering column
See the first three generations of Volkswagen vans.If you have seen a column - congratulations, you will then know it needs room to route to the wheels, and is restricted in the paths it can take to get there quite significantly, vs of course plain ole wires that can snake any way you like. Those restrictions are exactly why your VW vans have a column between the drivers legs.
This is getting genuinely funny now, however I think I'm about done with this one. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Again, one mighty big steering column, present on the T2, T3, "the first three generations of Volkswagen vans" etc etc.
> https://www.cnet.com/a/img/resize/309b66cd757b35f8a47ba3d385...
Are you just ignoring the ZF articles now they don't fit your arguments anymore? Again - it's not just me saying this!
The Canoo - no column, and a ton of front cabin space:
> https://i.pinimg.com/originals/96/28/33/96283349b392b1da2f0f...
> "SbW's (Steer by Wire) additional advantages include gaining space in general and new design options in the cockpit... There is now more legroom because there is no longer a steering structure running through it."
https://www.zf.com/mobile/en/technologies/vehicle_motion_con...
The vast, vast majority of rack and pinion systems ever made, both old and modern, don't adjust number of turns lock to lock at all, whereas the ability is inherent in all drive by wire steering systems.