News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Nextgrid on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:40PM (#36699688)
If you have personal information you do not wish bad actors to see, do not publish it using an open protocol explicitly designed to allow anyone to read said information.

Defederating from Meta as a solution is stupid - Meta can (and will if they actually care enough) just rejoin undercover.

Furthermore, when it comes to the fediverse, Meta is actually one of the more trusted actors compared to whatever else is on there - at least they're a known legal entity instead of some random.

Finally, the fact that publishing private information publicly on the fediverse wasn't considered an issue before Meta came along shows just how irrelevant the whole thing is - the data has been public all this time, but the network is so irrelevant that not even bad actors cared enough to actually scrape it (or at least do anything with it).

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by zzzeek on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:46PM (#36699782)
I think the point they're making is that Meta is in a special place, where by using their unusually vast amounts of personal data and photos, they are somehow (?) going to dox anonymous users by publishing their real names, based on matching their profiles in some way. At least that is the implication based on the quoted tweet right at the top of the post (which is lacking any real detail how exactly Meta got this person's real name matched up with an online alias).
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by yodsanklai on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:30PM (#36700384)
> they are somehow (?) going to dox anonymous users by publishing their real names, based on matching their profiles in some way.

Aren't there laws against that? are there even allow to build internal links between FB/IG accounts without user consent?

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by zzzeek on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:38PM (#36700487)
I'm sure the US justice system will be glad to let you sue after you've been murdered by an online mob that found out where you live
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Vecr on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:07PM (#36703402)
If you get doxed buy {a gun, multiple guns}, preferably a rifle with a red dot or EOTECH and a suppressor, if you can. Guns stop riots.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by gowld on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:59PM (#36703801)
What if the rioters have guns with red dots and a suppressor?
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Vecr on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:07PM (#36703868)
I think it would probably stop at some point, due to the chilling effect on riots due to a lot of rioters being killed and the probable presence of police and federal agents. It would probably be too late to save you, but it might be a cause to repeal the machine gun ban, so future people could mount machine guns to the back of their pickups, etc.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by xigoi on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:19AM (#36706694)
Ah yes, the American way of solving violence with more violence.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Vecr on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:29PM (#36714763)
I get feelings about pacifists I have to suppress. You can say that there are people aligned closely enough to you that dying is not actually an existential threat in the same sense as your country or species getting destroyed is, but it's not a good precedent to let them roll you over without a reasonable application of force. I would personally start questioning it if I had to kill over a thousand people to save myself, but if I'm mostly avoiding collateral damage (i.e. I mostly avoid killing non-rioters/non-attackers), I would keep going. Give them a couple kilodeaths and the riot will stop.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by xigoi on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:42PM (#36726408)
Ah yes, I believe you're such a badass that you'd definitely be able to kill a thousand people.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Vecr on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:57PM (#36726583)
I never said I would, I would probably be killed by a couple, at least without a lot of support. Look at the Black Hawk Down incident for what killing a thousand people requires. That actually failed because the Americans left, they should have stayed even if it required killing a thousand more.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by meepmorp on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:53PM (#36700724)
In the US, yeah. We're famously unwilling to do anything about that kind of stuff.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by adolph on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:10PM (#36700942)
> Aren't there laws against that?

Law is a weak form of mitigation for risk of harm. If it can be done and there is motive to do it, expect that it will be done.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Guvante on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:00PM (#36702264)
Have you read the terms of service?

Any rights that they are allowed to strip from you are gone as part of the ToS.

Unless there is a law saying what you said explicitly, then 100% for certain Meta gives themselves permission to do it when you sign up for either service.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by not2b on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:21PM (#36702471)
The terms of service on Facebook require that real names be used, and anonymous users aren't permitted. I know, many ignore that, but they occasionally demand a user's real name or proof that an unusual name is a real name.

Instagram used to have different rules, but they seem to be trying to integrate everything.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by chongli on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:43PM (#36702676)
I think they’re talking about Meta doxing anonymous users on Mastodon. That is, by having Threads join the fediverse they can pull in information about anonymous users on other Mastodon servers and match it up with Facebook and Instagram accounts, linking them and potentially unmasking them.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by not2b on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:53PM (#36702751)
They could do that just as easily without federation (and in fact they already do: they've been found to create "shadow users" from people who aren't even Facebook/Instagram users from the tracking cookies they've gotten lots of sites to add, and they plug in all that info if that person later joins Facebook or Instagram).

I can't think of anything they can find out if federation is turned on that they can't find if federation is turned off. Even if there were some info that could only be obtained by being in the federation (and I can't think of anything but I might be wrong), that's easy enough: just create some small instances that don't identify as Meta or Threads and have the users of those instances follow people on all the large instances.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by chc on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:11PM (#36700147)
The only entity that could realistically tell us how Meta linked the profile to that person's real name is Meta, and they aren't likely to share that information — so it's not exactly surprising that the tweet lacks detail on the matter.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Tempest1981 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:05PM (#36702312)
Phone numbers and recovery email addresses?
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by housemusicfan on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:02PM (#36702829)
Or consider the fact that nearly every goddamn site on the planet has javascript or web bugs from Facebook embedded into their site, including banking websites, where you regularly submit PII without a second thought, which could easily be correlated to your logged-in session. Facebook would never create shadow profiles, right? The "Like" button was the biggest Trojan horse of all time.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Havoc on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:54PM (#36700746)
>using their unusually vast amounts of personal data

Jikes. Hadn't considered that. Certainly seems plausible, not just via technical means but also content. I've got a reddit profile that I try very hard to keep "clean and anonymous" yet I've had people from halfway around the world message me say "Hey you're Jack from X". Post sufficient volume and it becomes identifiable no matter how hard one tries.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by omoikane on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:47PM (#36702141)
I think people can make that discovery but you could always deny that association, and it might be difficult for random strangers to gather enough proof to say that two accounts are linked.

Meta appears to be publicizing account associations that were previously difficult to confirm, in a way that defeats any previous efforts to maintain deniability.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by mcpackieh on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:25PM (#36704676)
When somebody confronts you with PII like that, the best move is probably radio silence. Neither confirm nor deny it, and don't even confirm that their message was received. Don't do free battle damage assessment for potential adversaries.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by giancarlostoro on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:28PM (#36701177)
I am assuming they used the same email address they use on Facebook.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by not2b on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:18PM (#36702432)
Meta (when they were Facebook) had a rule that members would use their real names, that their users consented to as part of the terms of service. Apparently they used that as justification to find out someone's real name who was using a pseudonym. Kinda stinks, but I could see how they could justify it (though in the cases I'm aware of they just demanded that people provide real names or verify that the name that they were using was real).

But someone who uses a completely different site hasn't consented to the Threads terms of service, and if Threads randomly decided to dox people and alter their posts to add real names (or perhaps deadnames for trans folks), that's a very different matter, and I'm sure that their lawyers are going to tell them not to do that (or risk legal consequences). Since non-users haven't agreed to any terms of service Meta face real court, none of that binding arbitration stuff, and possibly class action if they do it a lot.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by zzzeek on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:50PM (#36704804)
What if Meta identifies a user on Threads and/or Instagram (who has therefore agreed to the TOS) using a pseduonym on a totally arbitrary Mastodon server? All Meta has to do is drop a little sidebar on that person's Instagram profile that says "This user also identifies as XYZ@server"

Person has been doxxed, the content is entirely on Threads or Instagram , they agreed to the TOS, and it seems very plausible Meta would do something like this.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by JohnFen on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:49PM (#36700668)
> Meta is actually one of the more trusted actors compared to whatever else is on there - at least they're a known legal entity instead of some random.

But they're a known entity with a long track record, which is how I know they can't be trusted.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by nomel on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:23PM (#36701105)
But, you know the space they operate. That space is limited by profits, what their immense legal team allows, and their immense security team controls. The alternative is, literally, a complete stranger, with no track record, unknown motives, and (as the recent hacks showed) doesn't have the skillset to keep your information secure anyways.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by JohnFen on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:32PM (#36701232)
This is true, but it's also a "the devil you know is better than the devil you don't" argument. Which is not to say it's invalid, of course, but it's not a strong argument.

Personally, while I certainly don't trust a random stranger, I trust Facebook even less.

Not that any of this matters, really. My opinion affects nothing.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by thrashh on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:17PM (#36703468)
Trust is more nuanced more than that though.

I trust my grandma to make a good cake, but I do not trust my dad to do the same. But I trust my dad to be there when I call him, whereas I wouldn't of my grandma.

And that level of trust nuance comes from a long track record. To me, there is no other source of trust.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by JohnFen on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:42PM (#36712113)
I agree entirely!

And the long track record I see of Facebook tells me that I can trust them to abuse people any time they can make a dime doing so. They have no benefit of the doubt, because there is no doubt.

A stranger might also abuse people any chance they get, but there is also a chance that they're better than that.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by nobody9999 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:51PM (#36702740)
>The alternative is, literally, a complete stranger, with no track record, unknown motives, and (as the recent hacks showed) doesn't have the skillset to keep your information secure anyways.

That's not the only alternative. Another is, literally, me, someone I know very well, with a lifetime track record that I'm intimately familiar with, known motives and the skillset to keep my information secure.

It's called "hosting your own instance."

And it doesn't stop me from following users on other instances, nor does it require me to accept the TOS of other instances either.

That said, I'm not interested in juicing my "follower" count or building/enhancing my "brand," nor am I interested in doing so for others.

That's the alternative. And when someone comes up with an AP hub that can interact with other AP instances like an email client (my Thunderbird[0] can talk smtp, pop3, IMap, xmpp, Matrix, nntp and more) that's a viable alternative for the hoi polloi. Until then, more technical folks like myself can just roll their own.

I don't really care what most other people say anyway, including (well, especially) "influencers", celebrities, politicians, advertisers and other scum of the earth.

So I'll just follow whoever I want to follow from my own AP instance. Or not, if I choose not to federate with other instances.

[0] https://www.thunderbird.net/

Edit: Added the missing link.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by nomel on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:15PM (#36703924)
My understanding is that many popular lemmy instances use an allow list, which means your replies to comments will go to the void. Is this true? I'm having trouble finding a clear answer.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by nobody9999 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:04PM (#36704554)
>My understanding is that many popular lemmy instances use an allow list, which means your replies to comments will go to the void. Is this true? I'm having trouble finding a clear answer.

I wish I could answer that question, but I haven't messed around with Lemmy.

I suggest setting up an instance and seeing for yourself what admin/moderation tools exist and how they impact interactions with the instance.

Sorry. Wish I could do better for you.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by joe_the_user on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:55PM (#36700748)
Defederating from Meta as a solution is stupid - Meta can (and will if they actually care enough) just rejoin undercover.

I agree with the rest of your post but I suspect that in this instance Meta, a large public company, that might leery about doing something that potentially embarassing.

But your basic post remains. A wide variety of companies, many bad actor, are going to be scraping, processing and connecting any data anyone makes puts online and that will happen whether Meta joins the fediverse or not. If Meta wanted fediverse data bad, they'd likely just buy it.

Indeed, all the hand wringing about Meta in particular in the article and here seems deeply confused - of course Meta isn't the only problematic actor out there. Indeed, the anonymity-problem of all the walled-gardens is that they explicitly attempt to stop online anonymity in various overt ways. But everywhere entities are trying to deanonymize covertly and these can be at least as bad.

The main is that anyone wanting anonymity needs to take active measures to achieve it. And these measures vary on how visible you are and effectively how much your enemies are capable and interested in you.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by jdp23 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:39PM (#36701341)
I should have been clearer about how this relates to general issues. I added a sentence

"Of course, Meta's far from the only threat out there, but as I discuss in 'Threat modeling Meta, the fediverse, and privacy', looking at Meta-related threats also points to solutions that increase privacy and safety in the fediverse more generally."

Here's a link to the longer post (still a draft). https://privacy.thenexus.today/fediverse-threat-modeling-pri...

And agreed, it doesn't scale for Meta to infiltrate people into every single fediverse instance -- although threat actors who are targeting specific people or communities might well do this, so it's also something to take into account.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by kevinventullo on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:00PM (#36700814)
Meta, a large public company, that might leery about doing something that potentially embarassing.

I don’t know, they did depend on Onavo analytics for a while: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onavo

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by joe_the_user on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:14PM (#36701002)
Yeah, the (less-important, subsidiary) point is they'd be happier to use some other source than engaging deception overtly and results would be the same.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by hackernewds on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:51PM (#36701485)
Meta has walled gardens at least with privacy settings that cannot be scraped.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by callmeal on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:47PM (#36703682)
>I agree with the rest of your post but I suspect that in this instance Meta, a large public company, that might leery about doing something that potentially embarassing.

I wouldn't say that the company directly responsible for the state of online discourse today as being leery of doing anything.

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jun/29/facebook-...

  It has published details of a vast experiment in which it manipulated information posted on 689,000 users' home pages and found it could make people feel more positive or negative through a process of "emotional contagion".
  ...
  One test reduced users' exposure to their friends' "positive emotional content", resulting in fewer positive posts of their own. Another test reduced exposure to "negative emotional content" and the opposite happened.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by joe_the_user on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:09PM (#36703887)
>...the company directly responsible for the state of online discourse today...

The company, huh? Not Twitter, not "us", not the properties of online discourse, the polarization of American and world political ideologies...

Anyway, this "hating on" FB doesn't change the situation.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by godelski on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:20PM (#36701074)
> Defederating from Meta as a solution is stupid

One question I've had for fediverse people is how you prevent a federated system from centralizing. I am legitimately curious. Email is often given as an example, but imo that a perfect example of a decentralized system BECOMING centralized. Sure, other players exist but the vast majority of people are on gmail, apple, or outlook (which is much smaller than the other two). Things tend to follow power distributions due to the momentum force being critical. In network systems (e.g. twitter,facebook,HN,email,ISPs,Walmark,etc) the utility/value is not linearly proportional to the userbase, but super-linear (this was one of the big problems with cryptocurrencies too. "Gotta have money to make money"). In these systems resources are "attractive."

So with this in mind, how is a decentralized paradigm any different than an attempt to just reshuffle the top players? (i.e. re-centralize but with a different group at the top) I just don't see the mechanism that prevents centralization.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by fossuser on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:31PM (#36701213)
I think you don’t, which is why I think federated systems built on the existing stack are doomed to fail (by recentralizing). You’re right to point out email as an example of this failure.

You need urbit or something like it to fix it, the problems are deeper.

https://martiancomputing.substack.com/p/tlon-urbit-computing...

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:54PM (#36702214)
I am continually impressed by how much more relevant Urbit has become (contrary to people years ago arguing it would fade out into irrelevancy). Urbit was designed holistically to solve the problems the "web 2" internet experienced in a structural way, not just apply some fancy "web 3" bandaids to some them. So of course it is a lofty project. But time and again it's proven that it took the right stance on socio-technological issues. Will it ever gain enough traction so that it replaces your text message app? Well that's really a social question, and one can wish. But it certainly solves all the problems people keep bumbling into when trying to "do web3". I wish more people would give it a serious look.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by fossuser on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:11PM (#36702369)
I work at Tlon (the main startup behind urbit, so disclaimer) - it's a lot easier to use urbit now than it used to be thanks to free hosting.

It needs to be a lot easier still (particularly the mobile experience isn't there yet without a fully formed app), but if it's been a while it's worth checking out again: https://tlon.io/

It'll be insanely hard to actually pull off, but it's the only attempt in this space that I think has a legitimate chance of a successful outcome. The others are dead on arrival because they don't actually fix the underlying issues. (Success being widespread adoption of software the users actually own and control.)

I personally self-host mine which has also gotten a lot easier too: https://martiancomputing.substack.com/p/product-review-nativ...

The UX needs to be just as good as a centralized service - I think urbit is the only design where that's really plausible (without recentralizing).

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by erenyeager on Thursday July 13, 2023 @07:11AM (#36707438)
Thoughts on Nostr?
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by wmf on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:29PM (#36701194)
You can force decentralization in certain ways like only allowing one user per domain but nobody has the courage to try it.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by fossuser on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:32PM (#36701236)
This is similar to how urbit’s ID system works fwiw - the ID is tied to the computing node itself 1:1 and you can’t have an account that’s separate from a node.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by wizofaus on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:46PM (#36701428)
> the vast majority of people are on gmail, apple, or outlook

What do apple email addresses look like? I genuinely don't know anybody that uses an address that says to me "provided by Apple"... I do know a lot of people that use their corporate/organisational addresses for personal email though, which always surprised me.

Edit: just read that "me.com" email addresses are apple-provided - I have at least seen them used occasionally, though nowhere near as much as gmail and hotmail/live.com (outlook).

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by someNameIG on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:20PM (#36701846)
me.com is the old address, it's been icloud.com for years now.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by wizofaus on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:46PM (#36702131)
I couldn't recall ever noticing anyone use an icloud.com address as their primary personal email address, though searching through my inbox it has cropped up once or twice. Actually my sister did use one briefly in 2018.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by mattl on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:47PM (#36702133)
And mac.com previous to that. Plus you can use your own domain name.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by wizofaus on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:53PM (#36702203)
Are there any stats on how many people do that? It seems me the only way it could be true that Apple mail has far more users than outlook/live/hotmail is if the former tend to be associated with custom domains.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by mattl on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:57PM (#36702236)
Apple mail the client has a lot more users than any Apple-offered mail.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by badwolf on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:47AM (#36709049)
just to muddy the waters a bit, I recently moved my personal domain to use iCloud as the mail provider, so you wouldn't see @me.com/@iCloud.com, but just my domain.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by jdp23 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:50PM (#36701468)
It's certainly a challenge. Mastodon's development tends to prioritize mastodon.social (Eugen Rochko is BFDL of the software platform and also runs mastodon.social) -- for example, the mobile app now signs people up by default on mastodon.social, and functionality that people running smaller instances have implemented in forks hasn't been integrated back into the main line. So there's the weird dynamic that people generally have better experiences on small instances (as long as they're well-admined) but the vast majority of the current fediverse is on large Mastodon instances. So it'll be interesting to see what happens in response to Meta. There's likely to be a partition, and if .social winds up taking a Meta-friendly position, then the anti-Meta region may be much less centralized.

https://heat-shield.space/mastodon_two_camps.html looks at tensions between people who just want a "better twitter" (which tends to lead to centralization) and people who focus more on small communities (a more decentralized solution).

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by awwaiid on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:01PM (#36701623)
I've seen email being centralized mentioned a few times but I don't think it's true. I email with plenty of people who don't use gsuite... seems to work fine. I can see a power distribution, sure, but that's still a distribution not a central organized cabal that stops newcomers.

Still I agree -- decentralized paradigms that are successful seem like they'd end up with big players like you describe eventually. Still better than actually centralized like slack or something.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by godelski on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:11PM (#36703909)
The reason there's this confusion between us is that we're using the term monopoly (and consequently centralization) to refer to different things. A lot of people don't use the word to refer to the pure sense but rather the practical.

A pure monopoly (a single story) is rather uncommon and usually associated with government direction. Generally these don't exist without government intervention because if anyone is able to create a company, in any form, and sell the same product/service (in any form/price) then it's technically not pure. So doesn't happen unless it's illegal or some other factor. Whereas an effective monopoly refers to dominance in market share.

The reason a practical monopoly is used is because we need to look at the reason to why we discuss monopolies in the first place. Usually it is because they are bad (but they aren't always). The reason they can be bad is because abuse of power: they are able to dictate the market and force prices that are unreasonable.

So with this understanding, we usually call things like Coke+Pepsi a duopoly despite a combined market share of 68% (48% + 20.5%). Or we talk about oil despite OPEC not even being 40% (followed by Persian gulf, oapec, then US), and all of these are multiple players. Similarly we say the same about ISPs. The problem with these isn't that it's single player control, but rather significant market share and the leverage that comes with that, which includes the ability to reduce competition and effectively cornering the market.

I want to give this explanation so we can discuss on the same page and understand what each other means. Because when I'm referring to email (context clues should tell you I don't mean pure -- I mentioned multiple players) I'm referring to these companies abilities to force aspects onto others. Maybe a more clear example is browsers because Chrome's pressure is frequently discussed here and Explorer's previous history also shows similar influence.

I'm not saying decentralized services will become 100% centralized by a single player (it would be incredibly naïve to interpret my words to mean that), but that people will collect into a small set of servers (likely seeing a power distribution) who then have a clear ability to use their leverage and dictate the format of smaller servers. Effectively this is not too different than the power that Salesforce has over Slack. While not absolute power, it is closer to that end of the spectrum than a fully decentralized system. If you make the mistake of creating two bins -- centralized vs decentralized -- you are missing the entire point of decentralized systems. At least the point that is philosophically argued.

Try to realize that when people are talking they have different priors than you. Language is messy and communication is about the exchange of ideas. So even if you disagree with my definitions (neither of ours are objective) you can still argue my points. Just claiming semantics is problematic because it derails the conversation or creates artificial contention. See 5.11 of the Simple Sabotage Field Manual.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by not2b on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:23PM (#36702482)
The fight over whether or not to federate with threads might actually cause more decentralization, as people move off instances if they don't like the policies the admins have chosen, and different admins make different choices.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by usrusr on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:37PM (#36702625)
Even "effectively re-centralized federated" will still provide much better ways to keep all that browser fingerprinting stuff and the like away from Meta et al than a closed system. E.g. if for some reason you need to operate a Google email address you could run the day to day read and write behind a forwarding setup never connecting your regular browser or your imap client to Google servers, dealing with the occasional setup/maintenance from a browser properly isolated from your search history and the like.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by boyter on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:07PM (#36702886)
For the moment it cannot be too centralized since Mastodon being the main software becomes prohibitively expensive to run.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by godelski on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:26PM (#36703982)
Prohibitively expensive implies more centralization not less
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by boyter on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:16AM (#36704948)
Let me rephrase. I don’t think the current iteration of Mastodon can scale well enough no matter what hardware you throw at it. It’s not designed for it. You would need to build a new system to achieve what was proposed.

I suspect that the above along with the cost is why it hasn’t happened. Although you do miss a lot of what’s going on by not being on one of the larger instances.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by xigoi on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:14AM (#36706658)
What's the problem with most people being to Gmail? It doesn't prevent you or me from being on a different server and communicating with them. On the contrary, e-mail is a great example of how a decentralized protocol can be widely adopted.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by thworp on Thursday July 13, 2023 @06:15AM (#36707015)
It's not just that there is a risk of re-centralization from network effects.

Since you mentioned email, there is also a large risk that filtering unwanted content and impersonators from appearing on your instance becomes so expensive and/or time-consuming that only a few instances have the resources to do it, just like happened with email.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by itronitron on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:30PM (#36701199)
You're overlooking the fact that Meta is collecting a whole lot more information than just what people post publicly, and they're not transparent about that.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by alwaysbeconsing on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:03PM (#36701642)
There's a huge gap between sharing a post and having that be replicated and consumed or archived elsewhere by other users/hosts, and having that same post processed against a giant pile of other data specifically to de-anonymize it. The first one is, yes, just normal use of public information. The second is more like spying, and since we know Facebook does stuff like that, being apprehensive specifically about them is justified.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by fooofw on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:21PM (#36701867)
I feel like the fact that Meta (and anyone) can see posts and users regardless of whether or not they are defederated is a bit of a distraction.

However, I do see the point of considering ways for instances to somehow distance themselves from Meta's instance. If another instance/admin was publicly known to comparably engage in pervasive user tracking (both on and off their own websites) and algorithmic attention monopolization, would we not expect many other actors in the fediverse to defederate or otherwise distance themselves from those practices/that instance? Obviously, several instances have decided to do so by premptively saying they will defederate. I'm just saying that I think it makes sense to at least consider it. E.g., compare the labels the data collected by the Threads Android app (https://play.google.com/store/apps/datasafety?id=com.instagr...) to those of the Mastodon one (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.joinmastod...), and I at least see the contrast.

But perhaps this is just me being naively unaware of rampant community-sanctioned indiscriminate collection of user data in the fediverse (I'm not part of it, just curiously observing Meta's entry).

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:36PM (#36702019)
Yeah I stopped reading the article once it mentioned people getting annoyed and wanting to control who sees their public content. You don't get to make that call. The community doesn't get to make that call. The protocol makes that call and the protocol allows anybody to view stuff you post publicly. You don't get to say "I publish this but Meta can't view it". Not even legally you don't.

Copyright cannot restrict who can view a work you created once you transfer or license that work to somebody else (e.g. by releasing it publicly on the fediverse). You don't get to say "here's my post but if you show it to Meta then that's illegal". We don't even have a common legal framework for dealing with content distribution that isn't copying (we got "lucky" that you have to copy content to view it digitally so copyright can be poorly jammed onto the digital content distribution model and everything doesn't burn down).

Where the heck did people get the idea that they get to dictate how culture spreads and evolves?

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Guvante on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:57PM (#36702233)
Your understanding is flawed. Copyright is 100% okay with transitively controlling production of content.

After all how else would you describe someone allowing Netflix to stream your content?

You can't restream Netflix and Netflix is restricted on how it can stream to you. Both rooted in the original Copyright protection and the licenses to content given out by intermediaries.

Most posting platforms give themselves very broad rights with what they can do in a transitive fashion.

But that is "companies don't want to get sued for user uploaded content and are lazy" not "you don't have any rights over things that are published".

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:04PM (#36702305)
It's not that simple. If I sell you a book, I cannot place a restriction on that sale saying you can't resell that book (first sale doctrine). You're allowed to do that because you own the copy of the book. You can't copy the book and sell it, because you don't own the copyright, but you can sell the original copy, show it to whomever you want, etc. It's not that "copyright is okay with transitive licensing" but more that "copyright simply prevents you from copying a work you didn't create (or otherwise don't have copyrights over)". That's all it does.

If you want to place downstream restrictions on your content then you have to license it (and get someone to agree to your license). You have rights over how you license content. Yes. And users may agree that they're only "viewing" a copy and don't in fact own it when engaging with your licensed content, sure. But my main point was that you don't get to publish content to the public domain and then say oh wait no I didn't want Meta to see that oops #privacy #cancelmeta. And further that it's kinda silly to imagine a world where everyone licenses every little toot they make. At some point we're in a public forum and we just all need to understand what that means, including that someone you don't like might be listening.

Anyway, I don't think licensing content is a positive thing for society. It may benefit media conglomerates, but not individuals. Arguably, creators shouldn't be allowed to say "Netflix you can stream this content to users but not in Brazil". I don't think it's a sealed deal that downstream restrictions on content distribution are healthy or in any way in the public interest. Charging a royalty for a views/streams of some show is one thing. Saying "only on Tuesdays and not in Brazil" gives too much control to creators to dictate how their art should be interpreted. And nobody can prevent you from using Netflix to stream a show to your Brazilian friend on the couch next to you... nor should they ever be able to. That would be really really bad technology, were it to exist.

So short of attaching licenses to every post you make, no, there's not a socially healthy, let alone even viable, strategy to control content distribution in the "fediverse".

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by wpietri on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:26PM (#36702515)
> So short of attaching licenses to every post you make

I think you have this backwards. Full copyright protection is the default for all content not licensed otherwise. Publishing does not put content into a "public domain" status. Social media platforms already have strong legal terms around every piece of content. If you violate that license, platforms may choose to fuck you up. E.g.: https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2023/01/untraceable-s...

It would be easy enough for particular Mastodon servers and/or accounts to be explicit about their downstream licensing.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:01PM (#36702824)
I understand that generally you retain the copyright to your works implicitly and that you don't have to actively file for copyright in order to gain the protection of copyright law.

I'm arguing that it's pretty preposterous for a decentralized federated social platform to assume some authority (enforced by whom, that'd require a central group of enforcers) over the copyright of posts on the network. Conceptually it doesn't make any sense. So the only thing Mastodon can do is at a protocol level require that public content flowing through the pipes be licensed for public copying and consumption, the colloquial "public domain".

> It would be easy enough

I can't really imagine the matrix of which nodes can federate with which others based on the default content license they impose on posted content. "Oh you can only view my post if you use this server over here because it uses a compatible downstream licensing configuration." Would that really "work"?

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Tijdreiziger on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:27PM (#36703076)
Mastodon-the-software doesn't have to do anything. Mastodon instances have to choose whether to block Threads or not.

Of course there is no 'central enforcement', that would be at odds with the very principle of federated social media (namely, that instance admins are free to choose how they run their own instance).

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:48PM (#36703260)
Blocking Threads doesn't prevent your content from getting to Meta. Some other instance that you federate with might not block it. See: TFA.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by jdp23 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:37PM (#36704044)
Blocking Threads is necessary but not sufficient. I should probably be clearer about that in the article.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by XorNot on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:31PM (#36703574)
This gets you right back to the issue of having to transmit licenses with all content. Which is fine - this can absolutely be a thing which exists within the protocol.

But then people are suddenly going to find they don't get the impact they want either: because the immediate outcome is simply going to be "license for public distribution or we'll reject your content" because everything else is too much hassle.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by jayd16 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:24PM (#36704671)
Its important to remember that the tech must conform to the law, not the other way around. If it's not compatible, the the tech that must bend.

That said, why is it strange to think that a license agreement must happen before a node can reshare a post?

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:18PM (#36712699)
How can the node copy the bytes to display the post to users and to send it to other nodes, if obeying US copyright to a T, if the node does not either have copyrights over the content or the content is sufficiently licensed in a way that allows the node those privileges?
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by wpietri on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:02AM (#36704874)
> I'm arguing that it's pretty preposterous for a global decentralized federated social platform to assume some authority (enforced by whom, that'd require a central group of enforcers) over the licensing

Why is that not-an-entity the only thing you're considering as able to enforce copyright or otherwise check a platform for doing something legally dubious?

> the colloquial "public domain".

That is not what public domain means.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by ben_w on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:06AM (#36706272)
> That is not what public domain means.

FWIW, I've had a discussion with a British lawyer, IIRC British law has no specific term for what is named "public domain" in US copyright law, and the term "public domain" in UK law means "the public can access it".

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:31PM (#36712902)
Would you like to elaborate instead of just a snarky "that's not how that works" with no real contribution to the discussion?

1. Who would enforce copyright on a globally distributed content platform? Which country's "copyright" laws does a node follow? Who is responsible (who do you sue) when Meta federates with a node and receives a copy of content it allegedly isn't licensed to have or doesn't have copyrights over? (Hint: not Meta, they didn't make the copy.)

2. Why do you think I used "colloquial"? On a platform where people are free to publicly view, share, copy, remix, etc. the content then the content is said to be in the public domain. In the US specifically (post 1988) the terms of use of the platform would probably need to explicitly have you release your copyrights on the content before you post, to make it clear that the content is to be treated that way. But I'm saying, the spirit of a public social network where everyone is free to engage with the text of other people's posts, is that the content is "in the public domain". Unless you can provide an alternative context and definition of "public domain" where you're technically correct...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by 542354234235 on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:28PM (#36726233)
>Not even legally you don't… Copyright cannot restrict who can view a work you created once you transfer or license that work to somebody else (e.g. by releasing it publicly on the fediverse).

This is literally the opposite of what you are saying now. Saying you legally have no right to restrict then trying to act like you were saying that, in some sort of practical sense, it would not be possible to enforce a legal restriction.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Friday July 14, 2023 @09:22PM (#36732185)
I can see how my wording was confusing. Sorry. Just focus on this:

> So short of attaching licenses to every post you make, no, there's not a socially healthy, let alone even viable, strategy to control content distribution in the "fediverse".

I'm arguing that copyright in and of itself does not grant you the right to control how owned copies of your work are used. This is evident by the first sale doctrine.

You can choose to only distribute your work with an attached license that does not confer ownership rights. And because of the license I've agreed to I can't do anything with that work that would breach the license agreement. And because you didn't transfer ownership to me of an actual copy of the work, the first sale doctrine does not apply. And I'm not allowed to copy that work, because of copyright. The limits you've imposed on the work are because of the license not because of copyright.

There's no component of copyright that statutorily grants an author any control of the transitive flow of copyrighted content. It's all in the license.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by scarface_74 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:31PM (#36702567)
> Saying "only on Tuesdays and not in Brazil" gives too much control to creators to dictate how their art should be interpreted.

Do you feel the same way about restrictive open source software licenses like GPL3?

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:35PM (#36702605)
Yes all software should just be public domain. But because we have icky copyright, we have to have icky software licenses.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by bruce511 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:14AM (#36705262)
While your view here is perfectly valid, it would have resulted in a -very- different world than the one we have today.

There would basically be no software industry. There couldn't be because there would be no way to economically do it.

Software would thus only be made by hardware manufacturers- and would need specialised hardware for every task.

For evidence of this alternate reality I point to an era when thus was the case. In the 60s and 70s there were a number of hardware companies who all wrote the software for their specific machines. You paid for yhe hardware, not the software.

This model flowed into the fame consoles of the 70s (atari, intelivision and so on.) PCs started either this model, although software-only plays start appearing. They make money selling games, visicalc etc. Microsoft famously licenses Dos to IBM but non-exclusivly. Suddenly hardware is a commodity and clones appear.

All the big companies today are software companies. The cloud is proprietary software running on commodity hardware. The ability to grow, to make big bets, to develop is predicated on the existence of copyright.

But wait, Linux right? That surely negates my argument. Leaving aside the distinction that it's copyrighted, not public domain, Linux is a clone of a commercial system. That inspiration came from somewhere. It exists because Linus had a general-purpose computer, which arguably only existed because of copyrighted software.

Aside all that, original Linux was pretty primitive. It grew in part on revenues supplied by other software companies. While it would be fun to imagine a world with only Linux, it's harder to imagine how that world is funded.

SQLite is in the public domain. Its an example of what can be done. It's an amazing fantastic bit of software. For all that it's built on the proprietary work of others (SQL). And it's far less capable than proprietary database engines of the 90s (oracle, informix et al.)

So while I understand your viewpoint, it's also earth noting that copyright built the world we are in now, and the alternative would look very, very, different.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:50PM (#36716533)
If you don't believe in isolated software patents, then a world where you have to actually make a hardware system to patent your invention as hardware with supporting software doesn't seem so bad. At this point the iPhone patent would be just about to expire and we'd all be able to legally clone, sell, remix, improve, etc. the system Apple spent the last 14 years profiting off of, royalty free, nonetheless.

I'm not so sure the world today where we don't own our iPhones because Apple retains an exclusive license to the software deployed on the hardware is really a good thing for the world. And I'm 100% sure society would have figured out how to make the iPhone in a world where all software was public domain, regardless.

As an example, we see more and more open source SASS companies as time progresses. This directly validates the model that you can profit off of a well run service provider business on top of software which you allow any user to copy for free.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by scarface_74 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @07:34PM (#36717530)
Apple’s patents aren’t the issue. The world can’t just figure out how to manufacturer hardware scale. The market is littered with failed hardware startups and even companies like Sony and Microsoft can’t figure out how to manufacturer the number of consoles in three years to match the number of phones Apple sells in less than a quarter.

Literally dozens of Android manufacturers can’t figure out how to compete with Apple at scale. Android is already open source

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Thursday July 13, 2023 @07:54PM (#36717683)
If you could run iOS on other hardware, you'd get an iPhone for $300. That would be competitive.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by scarface_74 on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:17AM (#36719433)
Why do you think running iOS on cheap commodity hardware would be any better than Android?

Apple designs it’s hardware and software in concert.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Friday July 14, 2023 @07:49PM (#36731543)
I have no idea, but at least we'd be able to try it out and see. Plus the iMessage blue bubble thing would be dead and that's a big part of Apple's social platform lock in today.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by giaour on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:49PM (#36702718)
> but you can sell the original copy, show it to whomever you want, etc

The license associated with physical media does have restrictions. You can't mount a public display of the work without acquiring a separate license. E.g., you can't buy a DVD of a movie and then screen it for a group (outside of what's permitted under fair use). If you sell tickets to that screening or intersperse ads, thereby infringing copyright for commercial gain, you're in even hotter water.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Friday July 14, 2023 @07:48PM (#36731526)
There's no license attached to physical media, it's all statutory.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by justcool393 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:51PM (#36702737)
> If you want to place downstream restrictions on your content then you have to license it (and get someone to agree to your license)

That's not how copyright works like... at all. HN needs a license to display your comment right now (see here: https://www.ycombinator.com/legal/#tou). Copyright works by default (in the US) of being the most restricted. The first sale doctrine applies but online when you distribute something you're not making 1 copy.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:46PM (#36703249)
I understand how copyright works. I'm arguing it's silly to try and apply it to a public forum in the way it's implemented. And all the centralized social platforms agree as you've pointed out because they require users to forfeit their copyright to posts made on their platform, or at least force them to licenses the content for redistribution on/within their network.

Like, by quoting me on HN you're actually violating the content license and terms of use agreement (you're only allowed to use your "user content" not mine). You'd argue fair use, and you'd probably win. But nevertheless you'd have to argue it.

I think we're in the weeds with copyright. What's the problem we're trying to solve? A federated public communication protocol/system. What do centralized platforms do in the face of copyright? Require users essentially forfeit their copyright over the content they post (if they're nice limited to the scope of the content traversing their network). Why? Because it doesn't work any other way. What is the expectation I have when reading a public post? I expect I am allowed to read it, quote it, remix it, etc. because it's been posted publicly. Nobody asks permission to quote each other even though they technically should in accordance with US copyright law. How would a discussion transpire without a shared understanding of how the content is allowed to be used on any network?

---

And I mean if you really want to get into the weeds, copyright prevents you from e.g. playing a digital music file on your computer since the bytes need to be copied over the network, into memory, onto output devices, etc. This was the original observation: copyright basically prevents you from doing anything digital with any digital media. That's why everyone needs a license and we're in license hell. In digital it's copying all the way down so hit it with the copyright hammer.

Imagine if we applied our digital understanding of copyright to traditional artwork. I have a painting. You visit. By shining light on the painting I'm reproducing the image on your retinas. You say copyright violation? I say preposterous! What if I take a picture of the painting that I own and show you? Uh oh.

Copyright just doesn't make sense when applied to a public social network. At all. And it doesn't make any sense because a social network isn't about artists trying to make money off their works, it's about anons trying to win internet points for the day.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by giaour on Thursday July 13, 2023 @08:55AM (#36708392)
> I have a painting. You visit. By shining light on the painting I'm reproducing the image on your retinas. You say copyright violation? I say preposterous! What if I take a picture of the painting that I own and show you? Uh oh.

Those are all fair use. The definition of fair use is intentionally somewhat vague, leaving a lot of room for courts to exercise discretion, but showing an artwork to a guest and taking a photo of a copyrighted work for noncommercial purposes are clearly protected by precedent.

Two of the key factors a court will look at in deciding whether a use is fair is the use's purpose and character and what effect (if any) the use will have on the market for the used work[0]. Threads is an ad-supported, commercial endeavor, so I don't foresee them winning on a fair use argument when they republish a post from another site in order to sell ads next to it. If you have your own mastodon instance and you sell a single ad on it, then Threads would, by republishing your post, be depriving you of revenue for your creative work in order to increase the value of their own ad real estate via exhibition of your copyrighted content.

[0]: https://www.justia.com/intellectual-property/copyright/photo...

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by slikrick on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:03AM (#36708479)
I feel like you're being needlessly obtuse when the other person is being objectively correct.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Thursday July 13, 2023 @06:11PM (#36716823)
I'm not disagreeing with them. I'm just a little confused why people are bringing up that you don't need to explicitly attach a notice to content you create to retain the copyright (since 1988 in the US). Of course that's objectively correct. I never argued otherwise. And to add, I pointed out that by the letter of the law, quoting my post on HN is a violation because I never granted you a license to do that (you'd have to argue fair use before a court if I sued you). I'm not disagreeing I'm just continuing the discussion.

My argument is that it's not implicitly fair use for a social network to copy user content to which they don't have the copyright and distribute it across a network. And that that's crazy because a (distributed nontheless) social network doesn't work if there isn't a shared understanding that when users post publicly that they're granting the public a license to copy, re-share, remix, etc. their content. Which is de facto releasing it to the public domain.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by sanderjd on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:46PM (#36703248)
I can't believe people who are into decentralization and federation now essentially want to reinvent DRM!
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:53PM (#36703293)
Thanks for putting it succinctly.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by gowld on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:53PM (#36703741)
Why not? These are separate concepts.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by sanderjd on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:38PM (#36704739)
It's a good question, so let me try to explain why this is dissonant to me, if I can.

I think maybe the easiest way to illustrate it is through the person of Cory Doctorow. I don't know for sure because I haven't been following him for awhile, but I suspect he is a fan of the fediverse concept. He and the kinds of people that he influenced (like me) strike me as the kind of people for whom open federated social networks are appealing and satisfying as a solution in contrast to closed centralized corporate social networks.

But then, a big part of my time following him and just generally being in that milieu, one of the primary boogeymen for us was the DRM being pushed by corporate interests.

So to me, DRM seems anathema to this entire aesthetic of federation.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Nursie on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:26AM (#36705643)
Licensing != DRM though ... ?

You can have a very strict license without actually using any cryptographic 'protection' on the content.

See, for example, the way IBM used to in the 00s (still does?) release software. There was no copy protection, no license servers, no keys. But copyright was absolutely retained and you couldn't legally just give it to anyone.

If you were found to be running their stuff without the appropriate commercial license then their sales department will be along very shortly to work out a nice cost-effective plan for you, and failing that the lawyers will be involved.

Closed, licensed, but it's not DRM.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by sanderjd on Thursday July 13, 2023 @08:49AM (#36708331)
Yeah fair. My reading was that the intention is a technical solution to lock down public data. I do think a legal solution makes more sense.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by indigochill on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:09PM (#36714483)
You could also look at the FOSS world. Licenses are actually important because if you license some software under GPL, you have legal grounds to sue if a corporation then uses that software in violation of the license. Most corporations just treat GPL as anathema because it's rarely worth the legal effort.

So far we haven't thought of social media content as licensed but it effectively is: the license is usually the EULA of the host giving them the ability to do whatever they want with it.

So really to be responsible with social media content we really should both get a license from our users and then provide a compatible license to federating peers. At that point they can decide not to accept the license, thereby refusing to federate that content. There are already filters like this for filtering certain kinds of content from peers, so it doesn't seem like it should be a huge reach.

Creative Commons might be sufficient here. If you license content as non-commercial, then would Facebook be barred from choosing to display it to the users of their commercial platform?

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:59PM (#36716655)
It's important to note that Stallman considers the GPL a hack on the copyright system (a clever one, sure, but a hack nonetheless). He'd rather it not have to exist, because we shouldn't need to exist in a world where companies can own the recipe to mix bytes around and achieve a certain software flavor.

I mean you can't copyright a food recipe. It so obviously would be stupid to have designer meals and chefs who are the only person that can cook a certain dish. The argument is that software isn't any different. And you can't copyright the fastest route from point A to B on a map. So why can you e.g. copyright the preferred method of sending bytes down an HDMI cable?

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by indigochill on Friday July 14, 2023 @06:40AM (#36722042)
I'm sympathetic to that perspective, but that would entail pushing an ideal upstream to where change isn't going to happen because there's far too much financial interest in copyrighting arrangements of bytes. So if the system's unfixable, then hacking it seems like the right approach.

Besides which, ignoring GPL, Creative Commons seems like a good license because creative works are more than logical arrangements of bytes (there are only so many useful ways of sending bytes down an HDMI cable, but many more ways to write a novel) and is probably the more appropriate license for social media content (at least assuming the author wants to apply that license to their content).

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by jstanley on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:09AM (#36706627)
This is the classic problem of assuming that people who share a few opinions with you share all your other opinions as well.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by sanderjd on Thursday July 13, 2023 @08:32AM (#36708170)
Yes, totally. But that is common because it is useful for understanding how aggregates of people behave. It's an estimation heuristic. It's bad to get caught thinking estimates are truly reality, but it's not bad to try to estimate things.

I do think there is a throughline between the ... techno-hippies? of my youth for whom DRM was a big concern, and those of today, for whom corporate concentration of social media is a big concern. But I know that's just a heuristic. Nevertheless, I think it's interesting to me that there is now some subset of the newer group who is arguing for something that seems very analogous to DRM for social media content.

I think you're probably right that it's totally different people, not the same people being inconsistent.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by themitigating on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:48PM (#36704796)
Because people who create decentralized networks usually also subscribe to the concept of free flowing information, hence the decentralized network.

One is their issues with a centralized service is control. Their issue with copyrighted material is control.

Of course not everyone holds the same beliefs

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by sanderjd on Thursday July 13, 2023 @08:50AM (#36708339)
Hey well put! Your answer is both more succinct and better than mine :)
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by themitigating on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:12AM (#36708586)
I'm such a negative person I can't tell if you are being sarcastic
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by sanderjd on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:51AM (#36709139)
Ha, sorry about that, not sarcastic at all.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by rocqua on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:01AM (#36705515)
DRM could be cool if, rather than cryptographically preventing copying, it would encode complicated licensing agreements especially if it effectively, when transmitting, rewrites the license for the recipient.

This could be guaranteed by laws rather than tech. Laws don't do much to protect big companies from the little people. That's why DRM is currently about technical solutions. But laws can have a huge impact on protecting little people from big companies. That's why big companies lobby!

I don't doubt that such 'license encoding DRM' as I envision will be abused by media publishers by linking it to cryptographic protection. But the underlying idea is pretty nice.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by sanderjd on Thursday July 13, 2023 @08:22AM (#36708063)
This is a very thoughtful take! I agree that an encoding of intent for enforcement by law rather than code would be a useful solution.

But let's come up with a different name for that than DRM :)

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by mattigames on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:39PM (#36704740)
Is Facebook supposed to scan all Twitter everytime you post something to check if it's not violating the copyright of someone there? Or scan the entire internet for that matter? That is not "lazy", that is just a ridiculous expectation, no (legal) social network would survive if that was necessary to operate

Not to mention the billions of derivative works where the definition gets fuzzy: I applied a filter to someone else photo and put an emoji over it, is still the same work? Should FB algorithm be smart enough to classify it as a copyright violation?

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Friday July 14, 2023 @07:53PM (#36731584)
That's the point, they're not. Copyright is a dumb concept when applied to social network posts (let alone the internet) and we shouldn't be wanting to emulate it on a decentralized social network.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by nobody9999 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:31PM (#36702575)
>Yeah I stopped reading the article once it mentioned people getting annoyed and wanting to control who sees their public content. You don't get to make that call.

A fair point, and one that's not really new either.

Don't want something to be public? Don't post it publicly. As I recall, when my employer at the time (mid 1990s) "federated" their email with the rest of the world, they sent out a memo which stated, in part, "don't put anything in an email that you wouldn't want to see on the front page of your local newspaper."

That was back when local newspapers were a thing, but I imagine you can see the parallels.

That said, I do get to control who sees my content -- by not making it public (i.e., I don't federate my AP instances and curate who can create accounts on them).

If you want something to be private, don't post it publicly. I'm not sure why that's such a foreign idea to some folks since, as I mentioned, it's not even close to being a new idea.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by jdp23 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:42PM (#36704072)
The article explicitly says that talking only about public posts ignores other privacy risks, and has an example related to a followers-only post. Knowing that, do you really think his point is fair?
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by nobody9999 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:16PM (#36704629)
>he article explicitly says that talking only about public posts ignores other privacy risks, and has an example related to a followers-only post. Knowing that, do you really think his point is fair?

I was responding to the idea that if you post something publicly, whether that's on a Mastodon instance, a bulletin board at the library, in a Craigslist ad or any other public forum, it's unreasonable to attempt to limit access to the information contained therein. That's intuitively obvious, no?

If you only want specific people to see that information, only give it to those folks. And if they're trustworthy, they won't share it with others but that's not guaranteed.`

How does the old saw go? "Three can keep a secret, if two are dead."

Don't want something to be public? Don't post it in a public forum. Full stop.

I am unfamiliar with the example you mention and its potential privacy impacts. But even if (and maybe especially if) there are the risks/issues you allude to, that doesn't obviate (and perhaps even strengthens) my point.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by jdp23 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:23AM (#36705632)
I wasn't objecting to your point so much as you calling their summary a fair point. They stopped reading the article before they got to the example of non-public information in it, so mischaracteried it, which doesn't seem fair to me.

Agreed that if something's available encrypted on the web with no login required then usually the only protections you can put on it is security-through-obscurity like hard-to-guess links that don't show up on profiles (YouTube's "unlisted videos") or advisory like "noindex". But, although it's not something I talked about in this article, there are design choices. Mastodon (etc) could evolve so that a lot of what's currently "public" isn't available on the web with no login required.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by nobody9999 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:17PM (#36714614)
>I wasn't objecting to your point so much as you calling their summary a fair point. They stopped reading the article before they got to the example of non-public information in it, so mischaracteried it, which doesn't seem fair to me.

I'm confused by what you wrote. Are you claiming that people who post information in a public forum should be able to dictate who gets to see that information?

I didn't read TFA, so I have no idea what it says.

I specifically responded to what GP wrote, and only that. Full stop.

As to the rest of your comment, I don't see how that's relevant to public postings in public forums.

As in this very comment. It's on a publicly available website and is indexed by the major search engines. I have no expectation that anything I write here is "private," nor do I believe I should be able to dictate who is allowed to read this comment.

Contrast that with my Matrix server. Access to what I post there is limited to those who are invited to the specific "room" I post in. And I limit access to the site to those I wish to share such information with. What's more, I don't allow web crawlers to access that information.

Public posts are, well, public and can be viewed by anyone. Private posts are not. That some folks can't keep that straight astounds me.

As for any protocol/implementation shortcomings of Mastodon and/or ActivityPub, that's a different discussion. And one that I'm not engaging in.

As such, I think we're talking past each other. I hope I've clarified myself enough that you'll stop making assumptions that what I'm talking about is related to your (which may well be completely valid and deserving of discussion -- just not with me, at least not in this thread) concerns.

Edit: Fixed prose and typo.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by nobody9999 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:42PM (#36715696)
I think I see the disconnect here.

I didn't really pay attention to your username and am seeing now that not only are you the submitter (to HN), but also the author of the submitted post.

As I mentioned, I haven't read your piece so I won't (as I can't knowledgeably do so) comment on the validity of your complaint about GP's point.

I don't have any issue with you, your blog or anything surrounding those things.

In fact, I'm sure you make a bunch of valid, interesting and insightful points in your post.

That said, while you're responding to me as if I had read, digested and considered all the points you make in that post, that's not the case.

My comment was completely unrelated (except as it elicited a response from GP) to your blog post and addressed a completely different set of issues.

N.B., I actually did read your blog post, but didn't realize it was the submission for this discussion thread. I agree with much of what you wrote, especially as it relates to the greedy scum who run Meta and its ilk, as well as the very real risks to a wide swathe of folks who are disfavored by some (many?) in our societies. Especially when those greedy scum "out" folks to add to their sewer of filthy lucre, which is then seized upon by the intolerant jerks to harass innocent people.

All that said, I stand by my initial point: Don't want something read by the "public"? Don't post it in a public forum. Full stop.

All the rest is orthogonal to the argument I made in the comments to which you replied.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by mcv on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:39PM (#36702634)
Controlling who can see your content is actually a very reasonable feature; some things are not meant for everybody, but just for the people who actually know you. But it's not a use case that ActivityPub was designed for. Google+ had a really nice feature where you could easily control who can see your post. Diapora has something similar, but considering it's federated, I'm not sure if you can really guarantee it.

I think the only way to guarantee this control in a federated system, is to encrypt everything that's not completely public. If everybody has a public key, you can use that to encrypt the secret key. It's a hassle, but I think this would work.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by XorNot on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:36PM (#36703603)
This still doesn't make sense though: the reality is that your content will be private right up till someone reposts it publicly. Or saves the image, recompresses, posts it to reddit, reddit posts it to ActivityPub etc. etc.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by mcv on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:43AM (#36706456)
Of course. On Google+, you got a warning if you reshared something that wasn't shared publicly, but it was possible. It's also a matter of trusting the people you share it with.

In the end, every private, highly encrypted message can always be made public by the recipient. That doesn't mean encryption is worthless for privacy.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by XorNot on Thursday July 13, 2023 @06:29AM (#36707121)
Right but even then the basis of protection was still being gated in punishment metted out by a higher power. That literally doesn't exist in a decentralized model - not only can anyone setup a new instance, instances which are blacklisted can also simply rebrand.

Beyond the tightest group of confidants who you can actually trust, your content can and will leak if you put it online - and the probability of this goes up as the legal entities involved become smaller and have less and less to lose.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by joe_the_user on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:07PM (#36703876)
The funniest thing about people wanting this kind of transitive control is that the only technical way to achieve this is through a wall-garden model like ... Facebook. Indeed, Meta/FB is eager to train people to want this model 'cause they know you at least one referee controlling everything if you have this transitive model.

Diapora has something similar, but considering it's federated, I'm not sure if you can really guarantee it.

Exactly, this level of access requires a hegemon. Who will be the hegemon?

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by mcv on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:40AM (#36706442)
Not necessarily. You can do it through encryption. But that creates overhead.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by echelon on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:44PM (#36702678)
There's a portion of the far left and the up-and-coming gen-zalpha that takes on a dictatorial "censorship is okay for things we dislike" attitude. They don't realize that in the 90's and 00's free speech was a place of refuge for liberals to escape from evangelical attacks on everything from LGBT rights to Pokemon.

They also don't appreciate that the "come one and all" nature of the internet back then led to many people crossing the fences and experiencing viewpoints they'd never seen or heard before. This is an atmosphere we desperately need to return to.

Present day censorship, "gotcha" moderation, and algorithmic manipulation of emotion have led to hyper polarization. We should 1) deescalate the intrusion of these systems and remove them from our day-to-day experience and 2) reinforce the fundamental rights we all deserve.

Social media networks with over 100,000,000 daily active users should not be considered as "private companies with a right to free speech through censorship". They are effectively public squares that we have all elected and chosen to share. Right and left alike.

Public companies tend to censor to protect profits, but small individuals (such as Reddit moderators and Fediverse instance maintainers) do it from either a position of laziness or political retribution. The latter is a form of disgust and hatred for fellow humans and should be called out as such, even if the other party is guilty of the same.

I've seen the free speech argument twisted into "right wing figures trying to force their views into everyone's feed", but that need not be the case. There are tools for individuals to block. And if we'd finally divorce ourselves from platforms and federation and escape to true p2p social networking, we'd all have maximum individual control: we could institute any blocking, boosting, ingestion, sharing, and ranking criteria we wanted. Many amongst the left obsesses over what the right is doing (and vice versa), which tells me people enjoy rubbernecking rather than tuning out. It's a game of "neener-neener" high school football rivalry.

But back to the core point - you shouldn't get to choose who people talk to if you're not a first party in that conversation. You shouldn't get to choose who can publish openly or who can read public broadcasts. If you want to keep your words private, share them in private. Your choices should be limited to blocking what you personally dislike at your own consumption level, and it should be that way for everyone. Because that's fair.

The pendulums of politics will swing. One day liberals will need the free speech refuge again. Preserve it now even if you want to get rid of it. Question yourself if you find yourself wanting to mute or persecute others. If you're angry with my words right now, please ask yourself why you want the other party to shut up.

I want to emphasize that I do not agree with the far right. But I will fight with my last breath to preserve the right to free speech for us all. If we lose it, we will slide into tyrannical oppression from those in power.

I wish we could all just get along. I know that's not going to happen in my lifetime, but we should make best attempts at deescalation and maintaining open communication with one another. Conversation can be a bridge.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by justsomeadvice0 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:52PM (#36702741)
> Social media networks with over 100,000,000 daily active users should not be considered as "private companies with a right to free speech through censorship". They are effectively public squares that we have all elected and chosen to share. Right and left alike.

Shouldn't this also apply to TV channels? Chat apps like iMessage? Popular newspapers, blogs, and email newsletters? And indeed, why stop at 100M DAUs - why not 10M, or 1M? The problem I expect is this path leads to the death of freedom of the press.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by gowld on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:57PM (#36703780)
It's not 100M readers that makes it a public square. It's 100M writers.

Like a shopping mall, the classic US example of a privately owned public square

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by BizarroLand on Thursday July 13, 2023 @06:14PM (#36716856)
To be fair though, freedom of the press should be limited to things that at the time of publishment/boardcast were believed to be true by reasonable actors.

They shouldn't get carte blanche to claim wild conspiracy theories and to turn people into figurative monsters and then claim 1st amendment rights to protect them from the consequences of their public agitating slander.

On the other hand, reviewing and moderating anything other than their current carte blanche status quo would be an inhuman ordeal, so it's not like I have a more perfect idea to replace it with, just an understanding that there are bad actors using the rules of our American Social Contract as a weapon against the fundamental rights of "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" that the self-same social contract they are exploiting has promised us for our abidance.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Friday July 14, 2023 @08:00PM (#36731639)
I understand where you're coming from, but I'm not sure it matters. If you don't like the bad actors spreading "disinformation" then speak louder. You're 100% right that it's untenable to moderate "the news". We have laws preventing bad faith actors from spreading demonstrably false information that damages somebody. Anything else is just... insignificant to your life, liberty, or pursuit of happiness unless you aren't mature enough to ignore opinions that make you unhappy.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Karrot_Kream on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:44PM (#36703231)
> algorithmic manipulation of emotion have led to hyper polarization.

I don't think algorithmic manipulation is really that big of a problem. Look at HN during the Reddit blackout. Tens of overemotional posts, lots of low quality pithy responses, and not an algorithm in sight. Flame wars are at least as old as Usenet itself. I think the truth is humans online, without the context of body language and the consequences of long term relationships, are just emotionally attracted to rage and strong emotions. Algorithms may exacerbate the forum but plain old upvote behavior is plenty to surface it.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by mcpackieh on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:23AM (#36704988)
Hacker news is an algorithmically influenced discussion board, the comment voting system shared by both HN and reddit influences the way people conduct themselves, and not always for the better.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by Karrot_Kream on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:51AM (#36705135)
Usenet had no upvotes and still had plenty of flamethreads.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by fsckboy on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:38AM (#36706113)
that doesn't mean that voting doesn't make the problem worse. And before eternal September, the internet was nerds, the "unpopular kids". When all the normies showed up, the incentives shifted.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by fsckboy on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:37AM (#36706102)
> low quality pithy responses

pithy means the opposite of low quality, concise and meaningful

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/pithy

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by CyberDildonics on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:40PM (#36703634)
Social media networks with over 100,000,000 daily active users should not be considered as "private companies

Your solution to private companies not broadcasting what you want is for the government to take the companies over and then dictate what they broadcast? Then what? Anything goes? There are plenty of sites that show you what happens when there is no form of moderation at all and they turn into complete cesspools.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by xigoi on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:01AM (#36706573)
> There are plenty of sites that show you what happens when there is no form of moderation at all and they turn into complete cesspools.

Well, that's precisely because there's only a few of them. If the only site with free speech is some obscure forum, then all people with extremist opinions are going to concentrate there. If all popular social networks have free speech, extremist content is going to be diluted in normal content.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by CyberDildonics on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:26AM (#36708771)
What are you basing that on? The word extremist is there for a reason, people spam and try to overwhelm any site without some bare minimum of moderation. Even sites that say they are going to be all about "free speech" end up immediately having to come up with a plan to weed out all sorts of horrible stuff. Voat, 4chan, 8chan, parler, zero hedge, slashdot with the filter score on minimum... How many examples do you need that are the opposite of your prediction.

Extremists don't want discussion, they want to blast something outrageous to as many people as possible, it is directly opposed to what you think will happen.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by XorNot on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:50PM (#36703709)
> Many amongst the left obsesses over what the right is doing (and vice versa), which tells me people enjoy rubbernecking rather than tuning out. It's a game of "neener-neener" high school football rivalry.

You mean like rolling back Roe v. Wade?[1]

You mean like trying to overthrow an election?[2]

Denying access to gender-affirming care for adults?[3]

What exactly do you think people are being unfairly obsessed over? Because there's a reason people follow politics: it's because politics, and because we're in a democracy - public opinion and discourse - has direct, kinetic effects on people's lives.

This is a real cheap opinion to have provided you're never weighed down with having to engage with the content and stick to vague insinuation. The fiction of "both sides".

[1] https://www.npr.org/2022/06/24/1102305878/supreme-court-abor...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_6_United_States_Capito...

[3] https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2023/02/28/anti-trans-...

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by xigoi on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:08AM (#36706613)
While I oppose these things, I think people who agree with them should be allowed to express their opinion. Maybe if we allow them to explain why they support these things, we can better understand how to come to a mutual agreement.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by XorNot on Thursday July 13, 2023 @06:04AM (#36706954)
The quote I was responding to in the top:

> Many amongst the left obsesses over what the right is doing (and vice versa), which tells me people enjoy rubbernecking rather than tuning out. It's a game of "neener-neener" high school football rivalry.

This is a complete failure to understand that politics is real and has real consequences for real people. If your think that "actually none of this matters, why can't we all just get along?" then your world view and privilege is simply such that you have the leisure of ignoring it.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by echelon on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:41PM (#36719230)
My wife is trans. By turning this into a game of sports and one-upsmanship, you're hurting us.

Listen to the left and to the right. Talk with them. Engage them. Humanize them.

Do this the Dr. King way, not the Malcom X way. You won't win hearts and minds if you're bearing your teeth all the time. People in the middle don't want deal with that. People that could be convinced are instead turned away.

Maybe you grew up in a completely liberal city and don't realize that the opposition have lives filled with joy, happiness, pain, trauma, and feelings too. Maybe you didn't go to school with them and don't work with them. Maybe you're not in a diverse, politically purple city where you can see that we're all in this together.

By being so offended and not turning the other cheek, you're letting the bullies know that they hurt you. You're giving them all the more endurance to continue. When social media and the news media obsess over what Trump is doing, they give him power. It's the same thing.

I'm not saying don't campaign, don't vote, and don't be strong. Those things are essential. Policies of tolerance and equity can win this faster than division and hate. But don't turn the other side into monsters so that you can feel good about yourself - you're just giving them fuel to keep fighting this decades-long guerilla war and making us all miserable for longer.

You gain nothing in vilifying.

Friendliness, strength, and pragmatism.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by XorNot on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:15AM (#36719416)
> Do this the Dr. King way,

Martin Luther King had this to say about "the white moderate" [1]:

"First, I must confess that over the last few years I have been gravely disappointed with the white moderate. I have almost reached the regrettable conclusion that the Negro's great stumbling block in the stride toward freedom is not the White Citizen's Council-er or the Ku Klux Klanner, but the white moderate who is more devoted to "order" than to justice; who prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace which is the presence of justice; who constantly says "I agree with you in the goal you seek, but I can't agree with your methods of direct action;" who paternalistically feels he can set the timetable for another man's freedom; who lives by the myth of time and who constantly advises the Negro to wait until a "more convenient season."

Shallow understanding from people of goodwill is more frustrating than absolute misunderstanding from people of ill will. Lukewarm acceptance is much more bewildering than outright rejection."

[1] http://www.hartford-hwp.com/archives/45a/060.html

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by echelon on Friday July 14, 2023 @01:13AM (#36719728)
Understand the difference between respecting your enemy and not doing anything to address problems. These are orthogonal.

Setting up censorship traps is slapping your enemy in their face.

You should read his "Loving Your Enemies" sermon [1]:

> Now let me hasten to say that Jesus was very serious when he gave this command; he wasn’t playing. He realized that it’s hard to love your enemies. He realized that it’s difficult to love those persons who seek to defeat you, those persons who say evil things about you. He realized that it was painfully hard, pressingly hard. But he wasn’t playing. And we cannot dismiss this passage as just another example of Oriental hyperbole, just a sort of exaggeration to get over the point. This is a basic philosophy of all that we hear coming from the lips of our Master. Because Jesus wasn’t playing; because he was serious. We have the Christian and moral responsibility to seek to discover the meaning of these words, and to discover how we can live out this command, and why we should live by this command.

[...]

> Another way that you love your enemy is this: When the opportunity presents itself for you to defeat your enemy, that is the time which you must not do it. There will come a time, in many instances, when the person who hates you most, the person who has misused you most, the person who has gossiped about you most, the person who has spread false rumors about you most, there will come a time when you will have an opportunity to defeat that person. It might be in terms of a recommendation for a job; it might be in terms of helping that person to make some move in life. That’s the time you must do it. That is the meaning of love. In the final analysis, love is not this sentimental something that we talk about. It’s not merely an emotional something. Love is creative, understanding goodwill for all men. It is the refusal to defeat any individual. When you rise to the level of love, of its great beauty and power, you seek only to defeat evil systems. Individuals who happen to be caught up in that system, you love, but you seek to defeat the system.

[...]

> Now there is a final reason I think that Jesus says, “Love your enemies.” It is this: that love has within it a redemptive power. And there is a power there that eventually transforms individuals. That’s why Jesus says, “Love your enemies.” Because if you hate your enemies, you have no way to redeem and to transform your enemies. But if you love your enemies, you will discover that at the very root of love is the power of redemption. You just keep loving people and keep loving them, even though they’re mistreating you. Here’s the person who is a neighbor, and this person is doing something wrong to you and all of that. Just keep being friendly to that person. Keep loving them. Don’t do anything to embarrass them. Just keep loving them, and they can’t stand it too long. Oh, they react in many ways in the beginning. They react with bitterness because they’re mad because you love them like that. They react with guilt feelings, and sometimes they’ll hate you a little more at that transition period, but just keep loving them. And by the power of your love they will break down under the load. That’s love, you see. It is redemptive, and this is why Jesus says love. There’s something about love that builds up and is creative. There is something about hate that tears down and is destructive. “love your enemies.”

[...]

> Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.

I regularly drive over a bridge with those words printed on it [2]. They're more powerful than hating your enemy.

[1] https://kinginstitute.stanford.edu/king-papers/documents/lov...

[2] https://www.google.com/maps/@33.7608328,-84.3678862,3a,75y,2...

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by krapp on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:21AM (#36719449)
>Do this the Dr. King way, not the Malcom X way. You won't win hearts and minds if you're bearing your teeth all the time.

You don't understand MLK if you think he was less radical than Malcom X[0]. He absolutely did not engage with and humanize his oppressors. He didn't patiently and calmly listen to what racists had to say and try to find common ground and a way to tolerate them. Read his "Letter from a Birmingham Jail[1]" His tolerance for white America was limited to those who were willing to do the work of fighting white supremacy. He had no love at all for the centrists of his day who preached what you're preaching here, or the "colorblind" politics that people have twisted out of his "I have a dream" speech.

You come off like the guy who'd be in 1930s Germany telling the Jews they shouldn't be so intolerant, that maybe the Nazis have some fair points to make and everyone should just hear them out, share a beer and a laugh, and surely everything will be fine if only they realized Nazis were people too. And then point out your wife is Jewish, like somehow that gets you a pass.

Your views are dangerously, almost maliciously naive.

[0]https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2021/1/18/martin-luther-k...

[1]https://www.africa.upenn.edu/Articles_Gen/Letter_Birmingham....

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by XorNot on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:50AM (#36719595)
It's also worth noting there also definitely was a group in Nazi Germany who were colloquially called Jews For Hitler[1]. You can guess how it turned out, but they absolutely echoed similar sentiments. They were as wrong as you might expect.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_of_German_National...

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by echelon on Friday July 14, 2023 @01:20AM (#36719771)
I forgive you for thinking that.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Friday July 14, 2023 @08:48PM (#36731980)
At this point I have come to the conclusion that you can find a King quote to support whatever argument you're trying to make. I'm not so ignorant as to subscribe to the rose tainted Martin vs Malcolm dichotomy. I understand they were contemporaries. I've read LfaBJ. Which is why I think it's a steaming pile to try and argue "Martin was just as radical as Malcolm".

Martin was a human being. He was frustrated with the speed of progress. He did not preach violence. And he rightfully criticized people who wouldn't lift a finger in support of his peoples' rights to share in the same liberty under the law as everyone else. That's justice.

There is a huge difference between allowing immoral/evil unjust racist oppression to exist because you're unwilling to stand up and say "that's wrong", and demonizing your fellow countryman because our scientific understanding of when a human life begins is ever-evolving, or because of differing views on whether tax money should be used to subsidize elective cosmetic surgery. (I'm not arguing one way or another, I'm just stating these examples rhetorically since they're what started this discussion.)

Point being, there's intolerable immoral oppression, and there's acceptable functional political "oppression" (speed limits are oppressive, for instance, but we agree they're generally a useful oppression, so we tolerate the oppression). Racism is the first category. The first world problems of today (save abortion, that one's fuzzy and complicated) fall squarely into the second. And regardless of which category of oppression you're facing, there's still wisdom in understanding that sharpening your edge will only cause the other side to follow and is rarely the way to change minds.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by xigoi on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:05AM (#36720769)
I'm not saying that politics don't have real consequences. But by pointing everyone who even slightly disagrees with you as literally the incarnation of evil, you're only making things worse. Do you think Fundamentalist Christians are less likely to support anti-abortion laws if you keep being toxic to them?
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by XorNot on Sunday July 16, 2023 @05:08AM (#36744982)
Why would fundamentalist Christians change their mind about a core belief? That's the point of being a fundamentalist.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by echelon on Sunday July 16, 2023 @10:19AM (#36747285)
I grew up in that kind of church and over 30 years watched the entire world around me change: I have zero connection or desire to be in that world, my family mellowed out, the tv preachers all died.

Now that far left liberals are attacking conservative people on social media directly, there's no opportunity for de-escalation. Every confrontation is personal. Conservatives put up barriers and become protective of their beliefs rather than engage in direct, vulnerable dialogue. They tune you out entirely and focus on defending or attacking - because that's what your side is doing too.

Do you even realize the rich spectrum of conservative beliefs? Or do you see it all as a single position? There's so much opportunity to change hearts and minds, but it's all being squandered and perhaps permanently so on these petty fights and turf wars.

The other side is human, just as you. If they'd had a different life journey, they might stand beside you. If you'd had theirs, you might be in their camp.

I assume you've experienced a lot of change in your personal life's journey. Understand and appreciate that everyone can change dramatically and take new paths.

All I'm asking is that you don't make petty attacks. You can fight for what you believe without belittling.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by XorNot on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:11PM (#36765981)
Attacking them for what? This isn't theoretical, I'm connected to giant global database where the public availability of this information is well known. Attacking them for what?

If you moral compass is "someone was mean to me on the internet, now I don't support abortion rights for rape victims" then there was no causative effect, you're just doing what you were going to do anyway.

Because it makes the priority pretty clear: these aren't hard to find stories[1]. The victims aren't "the far left" they're just people[2]. It isn't hard to empathize with them, but apparently the conclusion you reach is that they deserve what's happening to them, because an unrelated group of people might've been mean to you on the internet.

"People are mean to me on the internet" is a lie used to deflect from the data. Because someone is always saying something shitty on the internet. Because someone, somewhere on the far-left might tell someone their an asshole. But then the far-right will rock up to what they think is Obama's house[3]. But then here you are, telling me the only reason conservatives don't support my issues is because someone is mean to them. I don't know who that person is, I don't know why they were mean, but because they were that's all the justification needed to support denying healthcare to women.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/jul/16/rightw...

[2] https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/11/15/1135882...

[3] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jun/30/capitol-atta...

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by kmeisthax on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:32PM (#36704373)
Liberals never actually left the free speech refuge - they just wanted to keep the far right out of it. There's a logic to this; you don't want people advocating for mass censorship to be able to use free speech as a weapon to cut your head off. In other words, it's OK to censor Hitler[0]. Not everyone will agree, I suspect you don't. I put that disagreement in the same category as, say, the BSD vs. GPL arguments back in the day.

The problem with true P2P social networking is that I don't want to have to make individual moderation decisions based on each identity that happens to try and send me a message. That is makework best delegated to someone at least marginally trustworthy so that I can spend my time actually using the network as intended. Moderation is a necessary precondition to any kind of online forum actually, y'know, working as a forum.

In order to actually have effective moderation, you need scarcity of identity. In a completely P2P network, you can just make new identities to spam people with, so blocking them has no effect. Centralized platforms have a certain magic to them in that they can make identities cost money without actually charging people for them. That's why everything wants a phone number now - because phone numbers cost money, and they can limit sign-ups to a few per number per year. The closest Mastodon has to this is domain names, which is why defederation is the first thing instance operators run to when dealing with rule breakers. It forces you to at least burn a domain name to continue harassing someone.

> Many amongst the left obsesses over what the right is doing (and vice versa), which tells me people enjoy rubbernecking rather than tuning out. It's a game of "neener-neener" high school football rivalry.

No, this is just Twitter. Twitter is structured to encourage clout-chasing and toxic behavior.

[0] Or spammers. Actually I don't get why people who call for extreme free speech aren't also calling for getting rid of spam filters. Spam filters are censorship, but it's censorship we tolerate in exchange for a functional e-mail system.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by mcpackieh on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:20PM (#36704651)
You're right about one thing; those who are liberals today never abandoned free speech. Many progressives did, but in so doing, they ceased to be liberal.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by xigoi on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:05AM (#36706589)
> Liberals never actually left the free speech refuge - they just wanted to keep the far right out of it. There's a logic to this; you don't want people advocating for mass censorship to be able to use free speech as a weapon to cut your head off.

The political censorship on current social media goes far beyond “we don't want people advocating for mass censorship here”. Ironically, they do like advocating for mass censorship, as long as it's censorship of the “correct” side.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by kmeisthax on Thursday July 13, 2023 @08:40AM (#36708242)
If you mean Twitter specifically they jumped from "we have a bunch of rules that accidentally censor right-wingers more because they break the rules more" to "we intentionally censor left-wingers for the sake of balance" the moment Musk jumped in.

I'm not entirely sure how that refutes my point, though - the liberals the grandparent post was talking about aren't the same class of people who actually have moderation privileges on Twitter. Their crimes here are... cheering when Twitter did a thing that might technically go outside one's core values?

The biggest thing I can fault liberals for is adopting the Comcast argument: i.e. that Twitter is allowed to censor because it's a private platform and only government action carries the Evil Bit that makes content removal into censorship. This was always a losing argument, and we knew it was a losing argument because we'd already shat on Comcast for trying to do the same thing back when Net Neutrality was still a thing. But it's less "leaving the refuge of free speech" and more "adopting obnoxiously technical arguments that only Daddy SCOTUS would love right before Daddy SCOTUS decides to start tearing down Roe v. Wade."

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by xigoi on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:57AM (#36709239)
> we have a bunch of rules that accidentally censor right-wingers more because they break the rules more

“Accidentally”? When people got banned for hating on black people, but hating on white people was fine, for example?

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by themaninthedark on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:25PM (#36716211)
see also 'Learn to code'

It was fine for journalists and others to say to blue collar workers, coal miners, truck drivers(obstentionally politically right wing).

The moment that it started to be 'weaponized' by the right, it became hate speach. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learn_to_Code

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by ben_w on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:23AM (#36706351)
> Social media networks with over 100,000,000 daily active users should not be considered as "private companies with a right to free speech through censorship". They are effectively public squares that we have all elected and chosen to share. Right and left alike.

I live in a country with less than that number of people in total.

Which country gets treat the corporation as if the corporation was an arm of the government? Can't really be the servant of two masters.

And if the advertisers don't like what they see, should the government(s) subsidise the sites to make up the difference? That kinda already happens a bit with TV licences in some countries.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by c0balt on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:33PM (#36703130)
It's entertaining from an outsiders perspective. On the one hand it's public content for everyone. However onnthe other hand ithey desire the public content to be restricted making it by definition not public, i.e., private anymore.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by lakomen on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:29AM (#36706751)
Of course I can say who can't use my work. It's my creation, I get to make the rules.

If I explicitly deny Meta to use my work, then that is my wish and I can sue them.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dcow on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:59PM (#36760736)
> It's my creation, I get to make the rules.

As has been explained multiple times, that's now how it works. If you sell me a copy of your work, you do not have any authority after that to dictate how I use your work.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by bmacho on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:39PM (#36702048)
* * *
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by not2b on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:30PM (#36702561)
Even though Threads isn't federated yet, you can find any user's public messages via https://threads.net/@username (which is identical to the scheme Mastodon and other fediverse sites use). Anyone's public postings can be found in the same way, and defederation doesn't prevent it. There is nothing to stop the Meta folks from looking at https://sfba.social/@not2b even if our admin blocks threads.net.

Mastodon and the fediverse explicitly offer public posts to everyone. Some sites use robots.txt to block search engines and web crawlers that follow the conventions. Others don't.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by dathinab on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:04PM (#36702307)
> If you have personal information you do not wish bad actors to see, do not publish it using an open protocol explicitly designed to allow anyone to read said information.

you seem to not even have read the first paragraph, or not understood what it imples

the whole point of this article is that meta has a precendence of aggregating and combining data from all kind of sources. This includes data which is not supposed to be public, but e.g. was sold without your knowledge, awareness or explicit consent. A situation you could argue the huge majority of people on the internet is in.

For example consider this hypothetical scenario:

So they might take the supposed to be public data of e.g. your anonymous political activism (lets say anti corruption in a very corrupt country).

Then take a public profile you created e.g. in your teens, which you never linked or used the same email address with as you politic profile and should have no connection at all (you acted carefully).

But then meta is like, oh see through the data we bought/own we know that that profile was using that (non public) email address and through other data we brought we know that that email is belived to be owned by the same person as that other email (e.g. you used is for forwarding or account recovery, also non public) so we conclude they are the same and publish *to the whole world trivially accessible that the anonymous political activists is you*.

Or another scenario: They used AI body/face recognition to make the link even through you never posted the face in you anonymous account without appropriate masking or at all.

Or another scenario: Metadata of locations leaked through the usage of social media created the link.

Or another scenario: Someone marks you on a image they took without your consent (and/or knowledge), doesn't matter if they later delete it or make it only visible to their frinds followers.

Or in other words as long as you don't live as a complete hermit and have far above average tech knowledge and also treat absurdly careful to a point where it causing major annoyance in your life stuff like that can totally happen to you.

This is why the GDPR was created to make it illegal to aggregate information about third parties without their consent in surprising ways. But it's also where it failed the hardest to archive it's goals you could say (but thats a different discussion altogether).

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by 8organicbits on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:39PM (#36702633)
> wasn't considered an issue before Meta came along

This is false, there's been frequent discussion around how indexing and search should be performed in a privacy preserving way. Meta is just the latest concern.

[1] https://www.anildash.com/2023/01/16/a-fediverse-search/

[2] https://blog.joinmastodon.org/2018/07/cage-the-mastodon/

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by boyter on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:33PM (#36703137)
I totally agree.

Using a protocol designed to distribute content with the expectation that you remain in control of it is asinine. If you really want to control it, either allow list federate with only instances you know are in the same circle (IE make your own smaller fediverse), or move to a private forum.

I argued with the Fediverse about this several months ago, and raised all of the same problems in the article with them. Only to be shouted at, doxed, abused, insulted and attacked. I still think that what I experienced would be enough to drive some people to self harm. The level of toxic interactions on the fedivese was the worst I have ever experienced on the internet.

As such I find the fact that there is a freakout over what has been predicted multiple times hilarious. I welcome Meta joining. The sooner people on the fedivese grow up and realize the reality of what is coming the better.

I really like ActivityPub. I really like the fedivese idea. However when you visit you rapidly discover its full of the really annoying people from twitter, and people with "ex tumblr poster" in their bios.

Forget where this came from but it sums it up perfectly.

    Fediverse: We are open for federation and you to join!
    Meta: Ok here is what we are doing with instagram.
    Fediverse: Not that kind of open!
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by sanderjd on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:43PM (#36703226)
Yeah when I saw this headline I was really confused. What is the privacy concern with respect to publicly published data? It really doesn't compute for me...
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:57PM (#36703331)
The threat here is about Meta harvesting already-public information. The risk here is about them doing to people off their network what they do extensively within their own network already: harvest information on your interactions with their content and users. Meta doesn't just build a profile of you based on your posts, its secret sauce is building a profile of you based on what you like, repost, comment-on, hover-over, etc.

Yes they can go out and spider ActivityPub content already, though they probably don't currently bother. But what they will gain by being part of the fediverse is the ability to associate your interest in their content back to your identity and learn out a graph about you. Boost/like/share something off Threads, and you've helped them build a model about you in a way that they can't currently do with all the free content out there already.

I'm not sure why other people aren't making this connection. Again, the threat is that Meta could extend its abilities to build a model on how users from outside its own user database interact with its content and users. They're known to already do this in the form of tracking pixels on 3rd party sites already, but this is a richer source of information.

That said, I also think the Fediverse is so tiny that this particular market isn't of much interest to Meta in reality. I suspect this feature will never launch.

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by barbariangrunge on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:11PM (#36703913)
That was one of the problems with mewe. Sure, there's a good privacy policy. But what you're posting is more or less public, so the point is almost moot.

MeWe was nice though, really great communities on there back in the day

Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough by jezzamon on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:19AM (#36710607)
There's a few different concerns, one concern is about the reach of your posts changing dramatically, and meta handing your content to people who will then harass you, share your posts into their network multiplying the effect, etc (a common experience for trans people on some networks). Like, these people could've found your posts but they have no reason to search for you explicitly. L