Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough
by XorNot on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:36PM
(#36703603)
This still doesn't make sense though: the reality is that your content will be private right up till someone reposts it publicly. Or saves the image, recompresses, posts it to reddit, reddit posts it to ActivityPub etc. etc.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough
by mcv on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:43AM
(#36706456)
Of course. On Google+, you got a warning if you reshared something that wasn't shared publicly, but it was possible. It's also a matter of trusting the people you share it with.
In the end, every private, highly encrypted message can always be made public by the recipient. That doesn't mean encryption is worthless for privacy.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough
by XorNot on Thursday July 13, 2023 @06:29AM
(#36707121)
Right but even then the basis of protection was still being gated in punishment metted out by a higher power. That literally doesn't exist in a decentralized model - not only can anyone setup a new instance, instances which are blacklisted can also simply rebrand.
Beyond the tightest group of confidants who you can actually trust, your content can and will leak if you put it online - and the probability of this goes up as the legal entities involved become smaller and have less and less to lose.
Re:Why just blocking Meta's Threads won't be enough
by joe_the_user on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:07PM
(#36703876)
The funniest thing about people wanting this kind of transitive control is that the only technical way to achieve this is through a wall-garden model like ... Facebook. Indeed, Meta/FB is eager to train people to want this model 'cause they know you at least one referee controlling everything if you have this transitive model.
Diapora has something similar, but considering it's federated, I'm not sure if you can really guarantee it.
Exactly, this level of access requires a hegemon. Who will be the hegemon?
I think the only way to guarantee this control in a federated system, is to encrypt everything that's not completely public. If everybody has a public key, you can use that to encrypt the secret key. It's a hassle, but I think this would work.