News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by brucethemoose2 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:03PM (#36554477)
Meanwhile, I can see this very Mastadon post with no login just fine.

And the interface is not trying to assault me. It loads quick.

...Seems like a better product than Twitter for a public feed.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by amelius on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:32PM (#36554847)
I'm sure the loads are not comparable.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by brucethemoose2 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:40PM (#36554950)
Doesn't really matter if it works?

And if some massive org needs bandwidth for posts, can't they host their own public instance? I'm sure many organizations would prefer that over being at Twitter's mercy.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by paradaux on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:37PM (#36554920)
Equally, neither is the budget. Load isn't an excuse.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by hinata08 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:39PM (#36554937)
It withstands being one of the first link on HN, and it still loads comfortably.

For a personal website, that's a great performance.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by WJW on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:00PM (#36555149)
HN traffic is not nearly the DDOS people make it out to be. I made it to spot #2 once and that was a few dozen hits per second at most. Maybe not something to serve with wordpress from a raspberry pi, but hardly apocalyptic levels of traffic.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by hparadiz on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:02PM (#36555178)
Wordpress on a raspberry pi will handle static, properly cached content just fine.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by distantsounds on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:50PM (#36555661)
previous HN articles linking to instances has caused them to become overloaded. this instance just seems to know how to handle it
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by vGPU on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:59PM (#36555730)
HN itself is run on a single server. So long as you’re not running something bloated or trying to host on a DSL connection, you’ll be fine.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by candiddevmike on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:54PM (#36555082)
It's not crunching a bunch of analysis or ads in the background. I bet it scales wonderfully with maybe some kind of cache/CDN if necessary.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by dijit on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:51PM (#36555667)
Honestly.

what the fuck is this response?

I hear always that centralising everything is great because efficiencies of scale: but then we have something that works as good or better and the response is; “ah yeah, but the load is so high!”

Why do I care? I don't honestly give a shit about how much load you have, you could be factoring Pi on every page load; it means -nothing- to me. I kindly invite you to give more of a shit about user experience.

This also goes for when “complicated” systems fail, maybe making them so complicated and centralised is not the way.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:04PM (#36555773)
Mastodon isn't truly decentralized. Every instance is its own feifdom and you have to communicate directly with them to exchange messages. This is unlike how Usenet, FidoNet, and SMTP work. They are truly decentralized as you can exchange data without directly accessing a peer's host server.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by tedunangst on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:42PM (#36556096)
How do plan to send me an email without talking to my mail server?
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by kstrauser on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:28PM (#36555996)
I genuinely don't understand what you mean here. I don't directly access any peer's server when I want to talk to them.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jtode on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:58PM (#36555721)
I've been arguing with Twitter emigres who seem to think that the UX on masto sucks.

I would say that Twitter is an automatic transmission, mastodon is a standard.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by latency-guy2 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @07:52PM (#36556582)
I couldn't see a few threads on Mastadon a few weeks ago, the post was up for 24 hours, and the perceived outage never dropped through that entire period, and probably longer after I stopped caring about the post. There were numerous people on HN experiencing the same.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by kfrzcode on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:26PM (#36554766)
Tell that to your three friends who use mastodon.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jrflowers on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:40PM (#36554949)
Seeing a random stranger on the internet and assuming they have three friends that use Mastodon isn’t really a big dunk in them or Mastodon
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by teawrecks on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:39PM (#36554935)
Why? They know.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by bboygravity on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:22PM (#36554722)
Most of the rest of the world doesn't agree.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by teawrecks on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:38PM (#36554927)
Also most of the rest of the world doesn't use Twitter (I'm seeing about 240M total users?). The ones that do use Twitter do so because of a significant amount of money going into marketing Twitter's platform.

Conversely, relatively nothing goes into pushing people to use mastodon. It can only take off if it really does prove, not just useful, but more useful than a centralized version that's got money behind it.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by Brybry on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:14PM (#36555293)
What microblogging service does most of the rest of the world use? Weibo? Telegram channels?
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by antiframe on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:19PM (#36555355)
I imagine 'none'. With Twitter, the most recognized micro logging site in the world only has 240M of the worlds population, I conclude micro logging isn't popular worldwide.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by Shared404 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:22PM (#36555383)
> What microblogging service does most of the rest of the world use?

Most of the world doesn't.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by hengheng on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:58PM (#36555712)
The rest of the world uses WhatsApp Status. Twitter is for those who hand in their sanity in pursuit of an audience.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by dopa42365 on Sunday July 02, 2023 @11:33AM (#36562408)
Twitter is basically a platform for social media managers, no one uses it to stay in touch with their 20 friends. Memefied prnewswire.

This "famous person/brand posts something medium witty 10 times a day, urge to consume intensifies" thing isn't that popular worldwide.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by pronik on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:42PM (#36554968)
Early days of Twitter were just like that. Mastodon hasn't had the time to go to shit yet.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by Macha on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:54PM (#36555087)
The point of it is that it isn't a company but a standard, so if one instance owner goes crazy and patches ads in you can move to another (or your own) and keep your network
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by bdw5204 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:35PM (#36555501)
The problem there is that there's nothing stopping the crazy instance owner from retaliating by "defederating" your own instance and cutting you off from your network.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jtode on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:00PM (#36555743)
He could defederate from you, but one for his instance. If you haven't pissed off the whole federation and you backed up your data (another thing you can do on mastodon) you'll be fine, and keep all your followers too.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by LexiMax on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:28PM (#36556007)
Only if you have a single account. Most Mastodon clients allow multi-accounting quite trivially.

Also probably not the best argument to make in a thread whose main topic of conversation is about how one of the biggest social networks on the internet is disintegrating in real time thanks in part to the management of its owner.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by 0xblinq on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:03PM (#36555191)
Sorry if this is a dumb question, I’m still new to it. Wouldn’t you have the same problem as with an email address? I mean, your handle or whatever it is called would still point to that instance/owner right? Or is there some kind of “DNS” or registry so you can move your handle to other instances?
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by ploum on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:35PM (#36555500)
Let’s say that I want to move my @[email protected] account (my real Mastodon account) to another server, let say "writing.exchange".

1. I create an account @[email protected] on writing.exchange.

2. I go to mamot.fr and, in the settings, I enable migration to @[email protected].

3. I go to writing.exchange and, in the settings, I start the migration from @[email protected].

All my followers and following are automatically transfered. For them, it is transparent. They still follow me on my new account without them being even notified.

Of course, you need cooperation from mamot.fr. If mamot.fr decide to close your account, you can’t migrate it.

But it works well, I’ve used it myself. It is really great and allows people to do "server hoping" to join a community that fit better their need.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by 0xblinq on Sunday July 02, 2023 @02:01AM (#36558679)
Thanks for the explanation.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by vidarh on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:29PM (#36555438)
Assuming the old instance doesn't just totally shut down, you can trigger a "move" process that makes your followers automatically re-follow your new address.

On top of that, you can host your own webfinger alias, as sibling suggests, which lets you have an unchanging address that forwards to your current server. But note that accounts follows URI's not the handles, so you still need the move process to migrate existing followers.

It's not by any means perfect, but it's improving (e.g. the move process is relatively new) and probably will keep improving.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by Macha on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:20PM (#36555360)
Yes, you can use your own domain as a handle even if you're relying on someone else's server for hosting. It's sadly a little more complicated than DNS though:

https://blog.maartenballiauw.be/post/2022/11/05/mastodon-own...

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by egypturnash on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:28PM (#36555425)
You can transfer your account to another Mastodon instance, yeah.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by dmje on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:58PM (#36555718)
Yes. This IMO is one of the 3 key issues with federation as it is now:

1. Noone understand what "federation" is so they all flock to the big servers hence making the majority of the system totally non-federated in nature

2. Findability (of users, topics, servers) is terrible which pushes people to 1)

3. What you said. Until there's such a thing as federated identity, we're all still tied to one server, thus one server owner can ban / switch off / over-moderate and we're all back to square one

Some of this can be solved with ux and education but I worry that some of it is basically baked in to federation.

Edit: yeh I mean in theory you can move servers but it's apparently not easy...!

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by agluszak on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:13PM (#36555287)
Mastodon doesn't have the incentive to go to shit, as there's no company trying to earn as much money as possible behind it.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by viraptor on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:50PM (#36555663)
Apart from Facebook (I mean Meta (I mean Threads)). Let's see how that one plays out, but initially it seems like they'll be blocked by almost every bigger instance anyway.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by agluszak on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:13PM (#36555858)
Even if Facebook starts using ActivityPub in one of their products the protocol will still be just a protocol. And if FB's product goes to shit it won't affect ActivityPub.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by mod50ack on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:53PM (#36555069)
Well, it's a FOSS self-hostable server program. Mastodon isn't a service, so it's not susceptible to enshittification per se. A particular Mastodon host, sure. But Mastodon itself is just a codebase.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by Shawnj2 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:04PM (#36555209)
The biggest problem with Mastodon is that 3 instances comprise 50% of all traffic. That’s not that bad but that creates the conditions for the largest X instances to become Mastodon Inc., use VC money to fund advertising for their site and fund improvements the other instances don’t get, eventually defederate from the other instances, and finally enshittify. I think Mastodon is a bit more insulated from this than fully private companies, but it’s not invulnerable while that many users are on the biggest instances.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by kjkjadksj on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:12PM (#36555279)
Make no mistake though, enshittification follows the population. Mastodon is about as protected as html in that sense. Could you build a nice lean mean performant static site in html? Of course, but hardly anyone does that. Most popular sites that you are able to discover these days are enshittified because the incentives favor that.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by qchris on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:44PM (#36555587)
> Mastodon is about as protected as html in that sense.

I think you're probably using the term "enshittify" differently than the parent comment. Enshittification, at least as I tend to see it used, doesn't really follow from a particular technology stack, but more about how an organization itself approaches its end users, particularly against over-exploitation/monetization of a given platform. It typically doesn't speak to the underlying technology (i.e. html vs. MB of Javascript vs. WASM), since that is (within reason) somewhat orthogonal to how the organizations running instances treat their users/how end users actually experience the platform.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by sseagull on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:04PM (#36555210)
In Twitter’s early days only one celebrity could tweet at a time

https://theoutline.com/post/4147/in-twitters-early-days-only...

HN discussion:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17147404

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by candiddevmike on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:53PM (#36555071)
How could a decentralized thing go to shit?
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by kjkjadksj on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:13PM (#36555290)
Take the current crop of decentralized website as an example. No one forces you to make an enshittified website, people do it on their own accord.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by meepmorp on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:54PM (#36555684)
What? Remember the fail whale?

Twitter shit the bed all the time in the early days.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by redox99 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:03PM (#36555187)
On Mastodon simply discussing certain topics will get you banned, and instances that don't ban those users get defederated.

I prefer Twitter in the sense that it's more laissez faire in terms of what kinds of speech get you banned.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by hinkley on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:06PM (#36555234)
When someone says, "certain topics will get you banned" that doesn't make me judge the platform, that makes me judge the person.

People are going to assume it's something you don't want to name, if you won't name it.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by screye on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:15PM (#36555309)
Come on, in a lot coastal discourse it is practically taboo to mention vanilla opinions that are held by 70+% of the population.

Mastodon instances are largely moderated by people from the other 30%. You are free to judge if you want. But don't pretend this is a violation of publicly accepted morals in the 1st world.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by antiframe on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:22PM (#36555378)
I am having trouble imagining what you mean. Can you illustrate your point with an example opinion that is held by 70% of the population but is taboo to discuss?
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by ploum on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:39PM (#36555539)
It is funny how, in their own bubble, people assume that their opinion is held by 70% of the population while it is often the opposite (fun fact: more people voter for Hillary Clinton that Trump yet Trump voters believe that they are the majority. Same for abortion where polls showed that a clear majority of the US was pro-choice yet a very loud minority has a lot of political power)
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by murderfs on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:52PM (#36555674)
86% of Americans think that police funding should increase or stay the same: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/02/03/before-re...

80% of Americans think that the southern border should have increased security: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/09/08/republica...

50% of Americans oppose affirmative action (with 33% approving, 16% not sure): https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2023/06/08/more-america...

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by pessimizer on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:17PM (#36555902)
Nearly 70% of U.S. adults say transgender athletes should be allowed to compete only on sports teams that correspond with the sexes they were assigned at birth

https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-news/americans-oppose-in...

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by morelisp on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:26PM (#36555990)
This is obviously not taboo to discuss since every mainstream media source has been discussing it nonstop with virtually no reference to like, actual data, for over a year.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jmopp on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:13PM (#36555865)
None of those are really taboo to discuss: police funding has only increased in recent years, Joe Biden has been quietly upgrading security on the southern border since the start of his term, and the supreme court recently ruled against affirmative action.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by GolfPopper on Saturday July 01, 2023 @07:31PM (#36556455)
I've noticed than when people on the internet say "I'm not allowed to discuss X", what they actually mean 99% of the time is "I'm not allowed to be an abusive jerk to other participants". (The other 1% of the time, they're posting off-topic in a tightly focused forum.)
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by clipsy on Saturday July 01, 2023 @10:00PM (#36557437)
Don't forget, in 1967 (the year in which Loving v Virginia was decided), interracial marriage had less than 20% popular support: https://news.gallup.com/poll/354638/approval-interracial-mar...
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by ESMirro on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:23PM (#36555394)
It’s amusing you’re perfectly illustrating the OPs point. “Vanilla opinions” is so vague as to be completely meaningless.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by thereare5lights on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:34PM (#36555487)
> vanilla opinions

Like what?

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by guelo on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:22PM (#36555386)
"coastal" is ridiculous. American vs American hate is out of control.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by morelisp on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:32PM (#36555461)
Americans used to literally own other Americans, while committing genocide against other Americans.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by pessimizer on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:21PM (#36555942)
That didn't really count, because they all agreed that black people and natives weren't Americans and had no rights they were bound to respect. The real oppression is when relatively wealthy upper-middle class people get criticized.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by bigbillheck on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:29PM (#36555439)
> vanilla opinions that are held by 70+% of the population.

Name three.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by chasing on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:42PM (#36555575)
> vanilla opinions that are held by 70+% of the population.

Ooh, ooh, ooh? Like what kind of "vanilla opinion?"

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by mardifoufs on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:26PM (#36555987)
Trans people in sports? Wanting strong borders? Disagreeing with stuff like drag reading sessions?

Not American or white or whatever, just stating the obviously less widely supported stuff that may sound uncontroversial to the more terminally online.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by morelisp on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:27PM (#36555994)
> Disagreeing with stuff like drag reading sessions?

What does this mean? Drag queens shouldn't be allowed to read? Like what concrete policy are you saying they can't propose which isn't obviously overreach?

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by mardifoufs on Saturday July 01, 2023 @07:35PM (#36556478)
To be clear it's not personal beliefs that I have, just contentious issues I could think of that are far more controversial irl versus online. Also I think the issue is the reading sessions for kids.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by morelisp on Sunday July 02, 2023 @04:22AM (#36559464)
Drag queens reading at libraries is one of those things that's absolutely more controversial online than IRL. Nobody gave a shit until Facebook and Twitter groups whipped it up as a culture war issue, and so far even conservative analysts and judges are like "wtf, this is nothing, you can't ban it" and they've had to shift to broad obscenity bans instead, which do not have popular support.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by chasing on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:03PM (#36622991)
Ah, yes, the bigoted ones.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by mardifoufs on Saturday July 08, 2023 @04:53AM (#36642621)
Sure, but that's besides the point. They can be bigoted and still held by a majority of people.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by SSLy on Saturday July 01, 2023 @07:36PM (#36556486)
Coastal? Like, related to beaches, tides, or some kind of environmental impact?
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by redox99 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:23PM (#36555391)
When you name something, then it becomes a flamewar about that something.

But generally speaking, anything that the US/"San Francisco" left wing ideology deems "bad" is generally unwelcome.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by echelon on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:23PM (#36555396)
I'm LGBT and my spouse is trans. I don't believe you should silence anti-trans rhetoric. I believe you should engage it.

The ability for /r/conservative to ban my counter arguments is just as harmful as Mastodon shutting down the anti-trans positions.

Conversation is what moves us forward and is how we find commonality.

I grew up religious and conservative. I changed a lot of my viewpoints through friendly conversations in the internet of 2000-2010, before tumblrism, cancel culture, and censorship took hold.

If I grew up in today's world or internet, I might never have been exposed to different opinions in a non-hostile, no-judgment environment. By trying to segregate, censor, and ban we're only leading to intractable polarization. Never giving folks an opportunity to change. Never accepting that people are capable of growth.

Please let's talk with each other. Even if we disagree. You'd be surprised how effective that can be.

We're all suffering though this world together. Laugh away our differences and find the ways and the things that we share. We all hold more in common than you might think.

Love your enemy, even if they don't love you (yet).

If I could have one lasting impact on this world, it would be this message.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by egypturnash on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:35PM (#36555499)
I'm a fifty-something trans lady and I am just fucking tired of trying to change viewpoints. I just want to live my life and talk with my friends without some butthead coming in and telling me I shouldn't exist, I get enough of that by checking the news lately.

If you have the energy to politely engage people who think of you as a child molester who should be shot on sight, great! Go for it! But I have done that, and I am tired, and I do not want to do it any more. I run a Mastodon and I just want it to be a space to talk to my friends and maybe make some new ones, and thus, I block the fuck out of places I do not expect to get anything but hate from.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by hinkley on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:42PM (#36555576)
Common rhetoric among PoC even twenty years ago was essentially, "We're tired of being spokespeople and tutors for your problems."

Not everyone is cut out to be an educator, and I think you should have the option not to be voluntold for the job. Not just because it should be your right, but because insisting that everyone in a group can speak for that group is itself stereotyping. I think once you see that it's really hard to be patient with people who don't.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by ktm5j on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:35PM (#36555504)
As a trans woman living in a conservative area, I get where you're coming from but I seriously disagree. The hardest pill for me to swallow through all of this has been realizing that some people will never change no matter how much you engage them. The only way I maintain my sanity is to do whatever I can to reduce my exposure to that kind of thing so I don't end up engaging with it.. because it just never goes well.

I realize it's a complicated issue, and I'm never a fan of banning speech. But not all speech deserves a response.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by krapp on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:46PM (#36555613)
Mastodon isn't shutting down anti-trans positions, specific instances are choosing not to federate with other instances that harbor those positions. Those instances and the homophobes and transphobes are still there.

And you're free to engage the people who want to put you and your spouse on a train car in conversation all you like. Maybe you'll deprogram one or two, but you'll just help spread their propaganda to exponentially more people than you could ever help.

I have no commonality with such people and don't want to find any. I don't want to share a society with them, and I know they don't want to share one with me. I certainly don't want to debate the Jewish Question or "groomers" or race science with them on my gamedev instance.

>We're all suffering though this world together. Laugh away our differences and find the ways and the things that we share.

You know these people want you dead, right? They don't believe you have a right to exist. You and your spouse. Especially your spouse. We're not talking about a difference in belief about tax laws or support for opposing soccer teams here. "Laugh away our differences?" I'm sorry but with all due respect fuck that.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by ohgodplsno on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:57PM (#36555705)
They're not looking to debate you or find common ground with you. They're looking to eradicate you, or at the very least send you back to the closet.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by pessimizer on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:23PM (#36555961)
That's just monstering your enemy to justify any behavior towards them.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by clipsy on Saturday July 01, 2023 @10:07PM (#36557466)
It's an accurate description of right-wing views: https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/cpac-spe...

And no, there is no such thing as eradicating "transgenderism" without eradicating transgender people anymore than you could eradicate "blackism" without eradicating black people. It is a meaningless distinction invented to provide a paper-thin veneer over what is simply a call for mass murder.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by guilyio on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:13AM (#36573162)
I agree with this, I think the only way we'll get answers to the most controversial and divisive issues are for people to discuss them. Especially since many viewpoints being shouted down as "anti-trans" are actually very reasonable and need more discussion.

For example, the fairness and safety issues with regards to males competing in women's sports, or the issues of safety and dignity in women's prisons when males are incarcerated there.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by sourcecodeplz on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:13PM (#36555288)
Why would you judge the person because some kid somewhere is a trigger happy moderator?

What happened to thinking for yourself?

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by hinkley on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:20PM (#36555364)
> What happened to thinking for yourself?

What do you think I'm doing, right now?

Someone is invoking censorship as a reason not to adopt a new platform. No specifics, just rabble rousing. That's manipulation. Pushing back is thinking for yourself.

Or, they are being imprecise and undermining their position, in which case what I said works as advice on further conversations. Either way is thinking.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by pessimizer on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:26PM (#36555992)
Or they're assuming good faith in their opponents. To not know what has been censored on twitter, and that the recent interest in mastodon was a reaction to the lifting of some of that censorship, is either to be playing stupid or to actually not have the background to discuss the subject usefully.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by hinkley on Sunday July 02, 2023 @03:34AM (#36559187)
We weren't talking about twitter. We were talking about one Mastodon server defederating another for hate speech. That's not 'some topics'. That's hate speech.

If they're talking about some other kind of speech that I might actually care about, they should have mentioned it. Because the next bad one I can think of is even worse than hate speech.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by ceejayoz on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:05PM (#36555216)
“On Mastodon” is like saying “in restaurants”. There’s a wide variety of instances to various tastes.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jug on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:09PM (#36555257)
Yes, but the point being made is that you then choose a more welcoming instance and then it's defederated instead because it allowed your post, so then your Mastodon experience sucks anyway and you only gave yourself an illusion of freedom.

I'm not sure how common this issue is but I _can_ say that I've been through a defederation bullshit myself because the large instance did something as egregious as welcoming people regardless alignment to Swedish government party (i.e. any party with over 4% of votes in Sweden). That was far too much for some instances like mastodon.art to handle. The admin got fed up since he had neither will nor moderation resources of that kind and shut down the instance, so everyone had to migrate which is a headache by its own even if supported.

From other stories, I swear the greatest threat to the Fediverse is politics and more or less childish cross-instance strife. I just now checked my Mastodon feed and this very fucking issue was discussed once more so I guess some drama has went down again while I was away. There's been trouble of this kind on Lemmy too already.

People say "it's like e-mail". Yeah, if we have like 20 major e-mail servers in the world and there's drama across them as we bet on the winners via Patreon.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by VWWHFSfQ on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:14PM (#36555292)
Maybe you can make you own instance and then you can have all the swedish government parties you want
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jug on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:17PM (#36555334)
And then I get defederated for having done so. Did you even read my post? It's an illusion freedom that does not exist in practice because this is Mastodon we're talking about.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by vidarh on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:36PM (#36555518)
Free speech is not freedom to force everyone else to listen. You get defederated from those instances who choose not to want to listen to you.

Users on those instances who want to listen to you are free to go to instances that don't defederate you.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jug on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @05:32AM (#36584248)
I see I received many replies like yours so I will just pick yours to reply to. My issue with this is that this kind of instance hopping can easily kill a network. Many who were on my instance that shut down didn't migrate away in time and now they lost all their posts, follows, and followers. Many of those won't bother to come back from that terrible experience. This affected about ten thousand users or so that time, so not as many as would be affected now that Mastodon has grown even more. I still see those people in some users' friend lists over there and if I click on them, Mastodon just breaks with a cryptic error message.

So. With Mastodon instance admins and this kind of drama, making internal strife about politics, gender equality, whatever random subject they like debating, between a few persons affect thousands of users and greatly inconvenience them, and running a personal Mastodon instance taking great technical know-how and basically being a bit of a geek, I still consider these major issues with Mastodon as it stands today.

So, yes, I want to "enforce" people to hear me. If they choose to follow me. Because this means all the above problems are solved. The only problem federation solves today seems to be the scaling problem. Everything else is about friction and this kind of trouble and persistent worry. "Which instance do I pick" where it feels like you want to have an interview over a beer with the admin first. This has thus far been the major demotivator from what I've seen as a Mastodon user. I think I'd like it more like a P2P-based social network.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by VWWHFSfQ on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:23PM (#36555387)
that's because nobody wants to hear what the people on your instance has to say. you think they should be forced to?
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jug on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @05:49AM (#36584369)
Yes, I think they should be forced to.

Note that this still (of course) requires following said person on said instance. So people won't be spammed by views they disagree with. Mastodon is no different than, say, Facebook there. You still need to explicitly follow people. Mastodon doesn't even have an "algorithm".

But I can't see any positives from being able to defederate like this. What is the main benefit to remove the freedom of your users to follow people?

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by alpaca128 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:49PM (#36555647)
Freedom doesn't mean everyone gets whatever they want.

Your freedom just doesn't override the freedom of others to avoid you. You can't force others to interact with you and there's nothing wrong with that.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jug on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @05:53AM (#36584413)
> You can't force others to interact with you and there's nothing wrong with that.

On Mastodon, no one is forced to listen to anyone without a follow. You don't have to worry about that. This is not what I'm talking about, but the infrastructure problem.

I've repeated myself a lot already so I refer you to one of my replies to your sibling comments if you still want to discuss this.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by rsynnott on Saturday July 01, 2023 @08:07PM (#36556703)
You can, generally, say whatever you want via Activitypub. However, no individual Mastodon instance is obliged to facilitate this, nor is any particular Mastodon user obliged to listen to you.

Personally, I prefer not to listen to certain peoples’ Important Opinions about how people like me shouldn’t have rights (life is too bloody short), so I use a Mastodon instance which doesn’t tolerate that. People with such opinions are of course entitled to use a Mastodon instance which does (and there are plenty of them). I’m struggling to see an issue here. Person A is free to say whatever old nonsense they like, Person B is free not to listen to it.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jug on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @05:42AM (#36584320)
> Personally, I prefer not to listen to certain peoples’ Important Opinions

Of course you can avoid hearing this!

You do so by not following said person. Mastodon works just like Twitter or Facebook in this regard.

This is not the problem that I'm talking about at all. I'm talking about the infrastructure problem. It's about instances shutting down, people not having had time to migrate, and thousands of users losing everything (their entire account and content) because some admin decided he didn't like furries enough or let any political party member join his instance, admin is defederated, admin says fuck this.

Sure, I can make my own instance to guarantee my place on the network if I buy a server and run it on that but how many do you guys expect are enough Mastodon enhtusiasts (of all things, haha) to even bother with learning and doing so. It's a stillborn workaround if this problem keeps resurfacing.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by andrekandre on Saturday July 01, 2023 @08:16PM (#36556764)

  > And then I get defederated for having done so.
if i don't like what someone is saying i have the freedom to disassociate from them, wether its in real-life or in mastodon or whatever

  > It's an illusion freedom that does not exist in practice because this is Mastodon we're talking about.
i think you are confusing freedom with privilege.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by jug on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @05:50AM (#36584381)
> if i don't like what someone is saying i have the freedom to disassociate from them

Yeah, on Mastodon we usually do so by not following that person?

This is not what I'm talking about but the infrastructure issue of internal strife between admins affecting tens of thousands of users for the most ridiculous of reasons, and this has not just been a hypothetical scenario, unfortunately.

And no, setting up your personal instance isn't a realistic solution for most people who just want to chat.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by sleepycatgirl on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:07PM (#36555235)
That is.. quite opposite from the experience I have had. I have discussed a fair amount of topics, it was civil, and things were fine.

Though, the only time when I did see that happen, was when someone was transphobic, homophobic, racist and such.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by SV_BubbleTime on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:11PM (#36555272)
>Though, the only time when I did see that happen, was when someone was transphobic, homophobic, racist and such

“I mean, when all the wrong and bad people are kicked out everything is great!”

No one is complaining about people with Ford vs Chevy comments being banned. It’s the controversial things that need to be refuted, not hidden.

What makes you so absolutely certain you are on the “right side” of any opinion? Because the people in charge of these services are censoring the other side?

How long before you find yourself with “the wrong thoughts”?

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by burtness on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:19PM (#36555924)
First they came for the Nazis...
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by pessimizer on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:31PM (#36556026)
That's what happened. People started demanding that Nazis be censored on Myspace. I knew people at the time who were under the impression that being a racist was already illegal in some way, and thought that Myspace not immediately banning all of them made the site an accessory to the crime. The worst part was they seemed to be centering it around me because I was the only black person they knew.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by kstrauser on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:42PM (#36556101)
I run a Mastodon instance. You don't have to see eye to eye with me or my users to talk to us. However, I have defederated from instances that host:

* Loli porn

* Extreme neo-Nazi content; I'm talking about swastikas, hardcore racial slurs, and the like

* Targeted bullying and harassment

You want to spark a conversation about the relative merits of Republican fiscal policy, let's chat! You want to say that we should still own slaves, Jews eat babies, or gay people shouldn't exist? Go away. I don't owe you a soapbox.

Disconnecting from a server with despicable content doesn't take away that server's right to speak. It just preserves my -- and my users' -- right not to hear it.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by mejari on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:30PM (#36555448)
>I prefer Twitter in the sense that it's more laissez faire in terms of what kinds of speech get you banned.

Musk literally just said that the term 'cis' is a slur that will get you banned.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by nkozyra on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:08PM (#36555251)
> I prefer Twitter in the sense that it's more laissez faire in terms of what kinds of speech get you banned.

I really don't think it is. It's still largely political, and subject to the whim of the reader.

The guy who tracked and reported on Twitter Blue subscriptions was suspended today.

You always have to kiss someone's ring.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by mastodon_acc on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:10PM (#36555265)
Which instance? Sounds like you joined a niche instance of a few hundred people. I find twitter to be extremely restrictive, you can’t have open discussions, you either get banned or get piled on by abusive blue check accounts.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by reaperman on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:09PM (#36555261)
> On ~~Mastodon~~ Twitter simply discussing certain topics will get you banned.

Also true.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by redox99 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:18PM (#36555338)
Yes, that's why I said its more permissive, not that Twitter is fully permissive.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by Saris on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:05PM (#36555218)
You can hang out on an instance with like minded people, everyone else might defederate you but you'll have your space.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by bigbillheck on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:08PM (#36555245)
What kind of topics would those be?
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by kstrauser on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:43PM (#36556114)
"Oh, you know."
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by golergka on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:05PM (#36555212)
Can I read more about this? What topics are banned?
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by LeoPanthera on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:11PM (#36555268)
When they say "banned", they mean "if I say grotesquely offensive things, other people will chose not to listen".

You know, just like in real life.

There are plenty of instances that allow abhorrent content, if that's what you want, but you can't force others to receive it.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by meepmorp on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:14PM (#36555291)
Some people confuse the freedom of speech with the right to be listened to.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by golergka on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:18PM (#36555339)
In twitter, people can choose not to follow or mute you on individual basis, that's basically what “not listening” means. Banning somebody means preventing other people from listening to them, so it's not the same.

Maybe it works different on Mastodon?

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by vidarh on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:39PM (#36555545)
On Mastodon, people can choose to pick an instance that will rarely defederate anyone and follow or mute on an individual basis, or they can choose an instance where moderators will take a firmer line.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by tinus_hn on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:59PM (#36556209)
So the alternative to Twitter is Balkanized safe spaces where you only talk to like-minded people.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by LeoPanthera on Saturday July 01, 2023 @08:35PM (#36556897)
This is a weird way of saying "a platform where you can't force other people to read your posts", yeah.

That's vastly superior to Twitter, which routinely shoves stuff in your timeline from people you do not follow.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by tinus_hn on Sunday July 02, 2023 @03:32AM (#36559173)
And that is how you end up in an echo chamber where it looks as if your ideas are the only ideas and everyone obviously agrees with you.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by morelisp on Sunday July 02, 2023 @04:37AM (#36559538)
Well, and like, the entire rest of the world.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by vidarh on Sunday July 02, 2023 @03:44PM (#36564944)
If you choose to only talk to like-minded people, that is your right, as it should be. And might well be one of the reasons most people aren't on Twitter, and many who are subscribe to extensive block lists.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by erik_seaberg on Saturday July 01, 2023 @07:04PM (#36556247)
The trouble is how to judge them. Automated censorship of others is invisible unless they announce it or you somehow know what you should have been able to see.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by wolfgang42 on Saturday July 01, 2023 @07:10PM (#36556292)
Mastodon instances have a section on the About page (under “Moderated servers”) which shows you exactly that. You can even get it programatically: https://docs.joinmastodon.org/methods/instance/#domain_block...
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by erik_seaberg on Saturday July 01, 2023 @07:15PM (#36556336)
Thanks, it looks like they fixed some prior complaints about not being able to see this.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by vidarh on Sunday July 02, 2023 @03:47PM (#36564970)
Mastodon instances tend to have admins who are if anything pretty loud and argumentative about what their mod policies are. If that matters to you, you can easily find instances that make a point of being open about what they block. A whole lot of people don't care about the how or why as long as they're not subjected to content they don't want to see, and that's their choice.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by ploum on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:48PM (#36555627)
The fact is that Twitter makes you believe that you are listened to, even if you say shitty stuff.

Mastodon confronts you that if you say shitty stuff, nobody wants to listen to you.

People complaining being banned or being on defederated instances are people other don’t want to listen. They pretend to have a personal opinion while they are only assaulting others.

LGBT is a good example: you cannot have an opinion about it. Those people exist. They have the right to exist. You have the right to not engage in any LGBT activity. But you don’t have the right to talk about a "debate". There’s none. If you do, I you maintain that using "cisgender" should be a banned word, you are simply an asshole and can’t complain that people don’t want to listen to your ramblings. And yes, this will get you banned.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by pessimizer on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:36PM (#36556064)
> Mastodon confronts you that if you say shitty stuff, nobody wants to listen to you.

Mastodon isn't a person, you're talking about the guy who runs the instance.

> nobody wants to listen to you.

The person who runs your Mastodon instance is not everybody.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by mardifoufs on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:29PM (#36556012)
What would be grotesquely offensive stuff to you? You realize that grotesquely offensive to very online Americans is an extremely niche thing? It makes sense to NOT want your online presence to be tied to whatever some Americans think makes perfect sense, right?

I don't think you'd agree that it would be weird to not want your social media and what you see online to be tied to what some, for example, Saudi dudes think is acceptable at the moment.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by LeoPanthera on Saturday July 01, 2023 @07:00PM (#36556212)
I'm not sure what you're complaining about. Don't join the Saudi instances, then? That's kind of the whole point of Mastodon, and federated services in general. There will always be instances that match whatever worldview you may have.

What you can't do, and should never expect other people to do, is to be forced to receive what you're posting, or to put it another way, you can't force people to listen to you.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by echelon on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:18PM (#36555336)
> On Mastodon simply discussing certain topics will get you banned, and instances that don't ban those users get defederated.

This is why P2P is superior. Federation nodes can be used to strong-arm collective behavior against the will of individual users.

I don't mind being exposed to liberal and conservative thought. I want to consume almost the entire spectrum of human discourse so that I can synthesize ideas for myself and understand more effectively. As long as the signal is reasonably high.

Reddit and fediverse moderators wield absolute power over their fiefdoms. They're intellectual dictatorships. (Not to mention egotistical behaviors some of them have.)

P2P allows the end user to consume what they want, weight discussions how they want, and participate in any number of emergent clusters. It's the real path forward.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by misnome on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:28PM (#36555429)
Then just make your own instance?

Or is the complaint that you don’t have the power to force yourself on people who don’t want to read your shit?

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by kelvinjps on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:20PM (#36555931)
I think that with p2p you don't have to think of servers and still be decentralized like downloading a torrent file, peertube etc
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by pessimizer on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:34PM (#36556052)
You've figured it out entirely. Mastodon is run by the kind of people who are willing to put in a bunch of time, effort, and money into dictating the conversation of others. People who enjoy that kind of power.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by kstrauser on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:46PM (#36556125)
> I want to consume almost the entire spectrum of human discourse

...said no one who's ever been a moderator.

You find out quickly that there are some perfectly horrid people out there. You absolutely do not want to hear everything that people say. It seems like you would, but you really don't.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by pessimizer on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:11PM (#36555852)
It's a shitty monoculture mostly filled with a particular demographic (like most new and obscure tech things), the people who program computers, and the people who they meet at parties.

This would disappear with more widespread usage. The problem is the software, not the culture. If the software is improved, or the dead ends are pruned and something else is created that learns the lessons from previous tries, the new cultures will bury the old.

If building software required experts on model trains or K-pop, the culture would suck, too. The goal is to make that a stage rather than an endpoint.

edit: I enjoy model trains, but I do not get into political or social discussions with model train guys.

Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by papito on Saturday July 01, 2023 @09:12PM (#36557168)
May I suggest 8chan? Almost no moderation at all, but make sure you have a gallon of Clorox by your desk because you will want to pour that into your eyes.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by sph on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:33PM (#36555482)
It's MastOdon, not MastAdon.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by revskill on Saturday July 01, 2023 @05:41PM (#36555556)
No difference to me.
Re:“It appears that Twitter is DDoSing itself” by ComputerGuru on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:00PM (#36555738)
Mastodon absolutely does not load quickly. I clicked the link and saw the followup tweet/post/whatever for a couple of seconds before it reflowed and showed me the actually linked tweet in a smaller body font. The had to wait longer for the whole thing to finish loading. There is a ton of unnecessary JS bloat on the linked site.