Since everybody knows that, only the most sketchy employers consider something along these lines. Again one ofnthe reasons I am really happy with my job and the country I have it in.
The heavy monitoring of communications, access etc is mandated by regulators primarily for the protection of customers. There's zero chance a union, or any other body below government, will get them to change that. I doubt they'd even try and nor should they.
I also don't believe for a second that JPM are doing what the original post is saying they're doing in regard to private devices. It would be astonishingly expensive and illegal in some jurisdictions. And thousands of people would need to know, in detail, for it to be useful so wouldn't just have come out in a subreddit. It would be widely known in the industry (and it isn't).
Any union of citizens will have power.
(As a Muslim your comment is especially funny!)
And it's as pervasive as it is primarily because of the scandals of the credit crunch. Similar controls existed before then but they were less pervasive and not as strictly enforced.
That’s very different from constantly recording audio and video of the employee which is what the grandparent described as dystopian. I’d also argue the focus here is on audits / transparency, rather than employee productivity.
The FAANGs do this for the EU employees...
Why do you think the EU would make it illegal to see who badges into secure buildings?
You probably signed an agreement to allow audio and visual recording. This is usually for the company to CYA to allow video conferencing but also for more nefarious reasons like you said. If you signed an agreement for audio recording (almost every Fortune 500 requires this), then assume your mic is always hot and that you cannot control when it records
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiscriminate_monitoring
The right to privacy in the constitution is most explicitly mentioned in Amendment I, Amendment III, and Amendment IV of the U.S. Constitution. The privacy of belief, privacy of home, and privacy of the person and possessions is included in the U.S. Constitution.[19]
Further reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_privacy
In regards to my comment about contracts, I have seen several contacts where employers think they can negate laws by adding clauses to their contracts. I am sure you have seen some of these these clauses, such as non-compete clauses. I know this is still legal in some states, but it isn't here, and adding such a clause is not enforceable.
“No, our suite detects nudity and automatically deletes related imagery.”
You see, its not really about having an airtight case to win a billion dollar settlement. It's about being able to bluster your way out of a situation that's trying to be used against you.
You can't get to those positions without speaking smoothly and spinning situations. Unless you are completely incompetent you can always find a way out, when given a chance to do so. Being given the chance is a result of how good you are at forging relationships.
This one is the most out there for me. How common is that?
Mitm is done via the proxy, which has its own SSL certificate, using company CA, so anything you send or receive is obviously captured and repackaged by the proxy. One more reason not to do anything related to your private life on company systems. TBH it is not that big a deal in this age of tablets and mobile phones and mobile subscriptions.
A bit more annoying is the blocking of Stackoverflow, for example (you can read stuff, but you can't post / ask), for this reason internal QA sites exist, with more or less success.
And by far the most annoying thing is that you cannot post to HN, well, at least it is not univserally blocked, otherwise you wouldn't be reading this post now... :)
If you care about your organization you would stop using stackoverflow. The license on stackoverflow responses are CC-SA. How many are copy and pasting these stackoverflow responses directly into their proprietary code base? Even reading the responses could taint your codebase.. but I haven't seen that level of litigation in 20 years
I haven’t heard of any StackOverflow-related IP litigation-can anyone cite examples of any?
You also couldn't use unapproved tools so you were limited to VS Code and PuTTY on Windows.
Eventually they got smart and issued Macbook pros to programmers and implemented zero-trust policies for related internal services. Unfortunately, technical managers and product managers were not so lucky.
Of course, in some other cases, a client proxy is configured instead of/in addition to a VPN, in which case obviously all your traffic will be sent to this proxy before reaching the internet.
Honestly, why would one go anywhere near one's personal email account - or indeed one's personal anything - from any device owned or controlled by someone else, barring a complete emergency?
In the old times people used their work email for everything - browse the ashleymadison leak from way back and you will likely find people registered using their @jpmorgan work email.
Edit:- I was also in a European office so it's possible that we didn't get to experience some of the more dystopian facets.
Edit:- we all had personal phones that we could use out of work, which compliance did not track. But it was strictly enforced to not communicate to any business connection using that. They would just fire us if we were caught and shun liability that way.
It’s a little bit like the government’s argument that they collect data but they don’t read it
Lots of companies track you, the flow of data, your use of USB ports, web traffic, etc. But they don’t do anything with it 99% of the time. The one time Google or Goldman Sachs realizes you’ve exfiltrated source code or something though, they have the full paper trail they can pull up at will sound they choose to pursue it
And then Snowden was like "actually Ive seen them snooping on your nude pictures".
Always use a separate machine for work, and another for personal.
You have the right to have your counsel filter what’s turned over for personal content.
It could also come back to you in terms of IP ownership of personal code - using company-provided hardware can be a big factor for cases where the company claims that some amount of work you did was work-for-hire and thus owned by them.
What happens if your company realizes they need to track leaks of their data for compliance? Do they need to force you to install software that looks at every file you download on your personal machine?
Separate machines is better for both the employee and employer.
Sure, if you’re careful enough with notifications that shouldn’t happen, but I’d much rather take a personal iPad with me on travel and never risk it.
A lot of people don't have this issue, but I can't be the only one that does. I find strictly compartmentalising everything the only way to go.
Nobody will care about your average web development shop working on the usual stuff. Why would they spend all the money and resources to track you?
Once you have worked in both environments you realize it's just not that big a deal. I do have my private laptop anyway, and I prefer to keep it separate from workplace stuff anyway - even when I was in the same position (working for a company who provided a laptop that I had full control over). It just seems healthy to me.
The reason why you do not want to co-mingle personal and work compute resources. If you are part of a legal discovery request at your organization, any device used to access corporate resources is at risk for retention. Suddenly all of those private photos and messages are not so private. So do yourself a favor and never ever ever mix your work resources with your personal devices. Never.
A double click of the middle mouse button and I can instantly switch between my work laptop and my phone. Interacting with my phone with a keyboard and mouse is surprisingly fast and easy.
The most common scenario is when people conduct business via text/iMessage/WhatsApp/etc on personal equipment. It’s easy to establish that the phone number doesn’t belong to the company.
If you do that for convenience you should have a practice of regularly cleaning up your personal stuff (or work stuff as applicable) periodically. If you have a consistent practice, you avoid exposing your entire personal/work paper trail while avoiding getting tagged for destroying evidence.
Of course I would, but I don't work in that kind of environment.
You expect to be paid in full and in exactly the right amount at the right time, but if we so much as superficially check you are actually present it is dystopian?
I know checking “results” is what should be happening, but guess what? That’s actually pretty difficult and open to all kinds of debate. You being “present” during office hours is not up for debate and easy to check. We all know you are not “making up for it” in the evenings. You are watching netflix and eating hot dogs while sending some superficial emails and notes to give off the impression you are working.
It’s not some small marginal group taking advantage every way they can every chance they get, it’s nearly everyone I know. It’s insane. But they expect to be paid in full. I am not completely opposed to introducing some metrics to track your value.
I agree time “in seat” is not the best metric, but it’s better than nothing.
In one paradigm, people are paid per productivity unit. In the other, people are paid a set amount per time period but are required to perform above some minimum threshold.
They tend towards the latter paradigm outside of specialized scenarios... so the hope is that someone performs well above the minimum and perhaps even at some extraordinary level in this second paradigm. But the pay does not increase for the employee if he or she does overperform.
However, the minimum performance is rarely spelled out, and can (and does) increase without employees being aware that this has happened. Regardless though, the pressure is to demand that employees work in a way that would only make sense if they were paid-per-unit. That is to say, constantly, and with the minimum amount of rest that they must have without being injured or dying of exhaustion (maybe without even that!).
This is bad enough if your work is pulling onions out of the ground by hand (a job that I remember reading is sometimes paid-per-unit). It is far worse for someone salaried, working something semi-creative. I don't know that the drugs exist that might make me able to focus only on work for 8 or 9 hours at a stretch, day-in and day-out. I have my good days when I look up and its 5pm, and I never let go of a problem the entire time. And then there are the mornings where I flounder about, not even sure where to start.
Bonuses for those who can do it seem rare to non-existent. So those that can drive themselves that way are often angling for promotion, sometimes for positions that aren't even available.
They want the productivity from A, but to pay the wages of B. I don't think this is some conspiracy... they don't even realize they're doing this, when they do it. If they were that self-aware, they might start to wonder what happens when exhaust the supply of what is a rare and difficult-to-acquire resource. They can't make more of it. And once it's used up and gone, business will eventually take a big hit.
But, as un-self-aware as they are, and given the timetables involved (it can take years for the consequences to rear their heads), they'll chalk it up irrationally in their heads as that things beyond their control changed to make the business unviable. Supposing of course, that any of the original management is still there to worry. One might think it would almost be better to be managed by supervillains than by buffoons.
So, to answer your question... the problem with Netflix and hot dog eating is that if an employee is doing that, then they aren't performing at the maximum theoretical output. They're not constantly working at that level.
If you don't know definition of "results", then how can you be sure that making people tired will somehow achieve the results? In the end do you need "results" from work or do you just want to make people maximally tired?
Even more than they want profit.
Your problem is unproductive employees - the ones who are going to get you business results are not going to appreciate being spied on and nickel-and-dimed for their time, and the ones who are not going to do so will not be suddenly transformed by you checking how long their laptop is open for.
And it just reeks of control freak.
Also, I always like to flip it around. What do managers even do? Those layabouts, I bet they're watching netflix and eating hot dogs while sending superficial emails all day while I'm here coding and actually producing value.
"I know checking “results” is what should be happening, but guess what? That’s actually pretty difficult and open to all kinds of debate"
"It’s not some small marginal group taking advantage every way they can every chance they get, it’s nearly everyone I know."
You might be running a bad business.
JPM just reported a $38 billion profit in Q1 and 18% ROE ... I think they are doing just fine, but maybe you should email them and offer some advice?
I didn't stop thinking about the problems I was solving, even when I went to sleep.
I frequently woke up having solved bugs that I hadn't even realised existed.
Each day, the entire trip to work I contemplated what it was that I was going to do and the trip back what it was I had yet to complete.
And I sure as shit didn't get paid for that.
Also good luck answering the phone at night and while “thinking what to do”.
Assume good faith.
> As a developer my job was less the typing and more the thinking about what I was going to write.
Where was it exactly that I stated that the bulk of my work was done in my sleep?
I never said that - but rather stated that the majority of work was contemplation rather than typing.
However, at least once a week I woke with a solution to something - just because your brain doesn't function that way on a regular basis does not mean that no-one else's does (or perhaps you need to think harder?).
My point was, it didn't really matter what time I actually arrived at my desk, the actual contemplation of the issue was happening regardless of where I was.
So, for at least two hours a day outside of the office I was continuing to do the most important part of my job.
> Also good luck answering the phone at night and while “thinking what to do”.
What the hell are you on about?
Also the side of the "economic engine" that historically cheerfully exploited workers until the labor movement enacted basic protections. IMO employers (in general) are guilty until proven innocent when it comes to workers' rights.
> I know checking “results” is what should be happening, but guess what? That’s actually pretty difficult and open to all kinds of debate.
Yeah my job is difficult too, but I don't take shortcuts because it was "pretty difficult" to do things correctly. Seems like a bad example to set for your employees if you want them to be hard workers...
> You being “present” during office hours is not up for debate and easy to check.
It's also not part of my employment agreement! I'm salaried, I'm paid for getting the job done. Of course, part of "the job" is to be available during business hours in order to participate in meetings, off the cuff discussions, and of course I value that part too. But so long as I communicate when I may be away from my keyboard for a bit, we're all able to manage this easily.
> We all know you are not “making up for it” in the evenings. You are watching netflix and eating hot dogs while sending some superficial emails and notes to give off the impression you are working.
This is such condescending arrogance it almost doesn't merit a response. But rest assured, there are plenty of us who say they'll make something up in the evening, and they do it without hot dogs and Netflix. (Also, if somebody did their job functions successfully and efficiently while eating hot dogs and watching Netflix... who cares?)
> It’s not some small marginal group taking advantage every way they can every chance they get, it’s nearly everyone I know. It’s insane. But they expect to be paid in full. I am not completely opposed to introducing some metrics to track your value.
Obviously you should track the value of employees, but you track it by results, not by this garbage. If your management isn't able to detect freeloaders who aren't getting results: that's a problem with your management and business.
Even in europe you quiet often have CarbonBlack installed (cb.exe) as an Administrator, which provides the employer with full access to everything you do, including screengraps etc.
You just might not be aware that this is true over here as well, even if its technically illegal for the employer to do so. they usually dont care any way.
The worst part about it is that I could barely use my machine! Typing `ls` in a terminal made me wait 5 seconds. Using Vim was soooooo bad.
# Define the registry path where installed programs are listed $registryPath = "HKLM:\Software\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Uninstall*"
# Get the name of all installed programs from the registry $InstalledPrograms = Get-ItemProperty -Path $registryPath | Select-Object -Property DisplayName
# Check if Carbon Black is among the installed programs $CarbonBlackInstalled = $InstalledPrograms -match 'Carbon Black'
if ($CarbonBlackInstalled) { Write-Output "Carbon Black is installed." } else { Write-Output "Carbon Black is not installed." }
My wife works at a BigCorp and I work at a small but established company. The differences in this arena couldn't be starker. I was given a laptop (and assembled my own desktop) and told to set it up according to my preferences first day. My wife has many metrics that she knows about tracked through her locked down MacBook (and I'm sure many more she doesn't know about). For my case I can't even think of how they'd track me while I work from home; for hers, she already knows that they do.
If you have 200k employees, it makes sense.
What you care about diverges from everyone else, and the main thing you have in common is maximizing the compensation / enjoyment curve.
Most people's enjoyment at work is not going to go down sharply because their employer is looking at how much time the average person spends in the office.
I have a hard time thinking this is actually true. Is there any data on this?
The distinction is borne of the different methods of decision-making within the business. Traditional capitalist enterprises put the last in that list as the highest priority at the expense of the other two. Worker-owned coops attempt to do away with the distinction between the latter two entirely. Communes ignore the first and the last and focus only on the second.
The point is, there are different ways of organizing people into a coherent mass to achieve certain goals, but Westerners are mostly only comfortable considering these issues in terms of capitalist modes of business (see the framing used throughout this discussion, e.g., the casual use of the word "employer", etc.).
I am aware that capitalist enterprise is the default setting of economies across the globe. I just want to point out how the conversation and insights into the problem are obscured by the normalization of certain ideological choices over others.
It's not the norm for white collar professional jobs, no.
On the other hand, some blue collar jobs have a long history of detailed tracking. Clocking in when you arrive, maybe with biometrics, and clocking out when you leave. A call centre worker might find their employer monitors the number of calls they take, the time they spend on each call, records the contents of the call, and surveys the caller for their feedback.
For example, if you recorded personal conversations people have on break. This is effectively what happens if you record all audio and video, and possibly the screen, of a work from home device. Not sure blue collar workers have been surveiled using hidden microphones and other such devices, say, 20-30 years ago.
If you are tracking time by "how much time the employee spends in the building" then yes, you need to check when they come and go.
You dont need to do this in jobs where performance is very obvious based on commits and similar metrics, as compared to jobs where possibly your attendance is your job (i.e. you dont produce anything, by "just" protecting something, or surveiling something, etc).
There is a reasonable degree of employee surveilance, such that you can make sure someone does their job. Most of the stuff in the article absoutely goes beyond that.
I dont think this has ever been about poor vs rich, imperial core vs colony (yikes), or blue collar vs white collar. Its simply that white collar workers may have more ways to see theyre being surveiled (i.e. webcam being on). White collar workers are IMO more likely to be in a position where they know that their livelihood is not at risk by simply speaking out about being surveiled to this degree.
In lab you had to use a clock, only got a 30 min lunch, all work was tracked including time per unit, weekly/monthly quotas, manager breathing down your neck, strict PTO rules (if you have to leave for 1 hour, you must submit for it), station checks, gear/equipment checks, workmanship checks. Basically the pinnacle of "cog in the machine" work.
Then once in the office, it basically became "you get a salary, do whatever you want as long as your work gets done". Hell it's not uncommon for me to go a week without even talking to my boss.
I will say though, working in the lab as a "cog", when you clock out you are done, and when you take off, others pick up your load. In the office you end up taking work home with you and taking off means having to work extra to get ahead. I kind of miss being able to wake up and say "I don't want to go to work day" and just call it in.
He sounds like someone who doesn't actually enjoy their job.
Not especially. He sounds like someone that has hobbies and a life outside of work.
If anything he has a _healthy_ relationship with work.
I'm British...
didn't expect to see that over here :)
https://www.earlytorise.com/spend-more-time-with-this-destru...
In my opinion, this is the only ethical and sensible way to do it. You judge an employee by whether or not they're producing acceptable work in an acceptable amount of time. Nothing else should matter.
Different roles are judged on different work; "I pay you based on what you get done in an hour" is supportive of fundamentally different work than "I pay you based on what you get done in a year" or "I pay you based on how much you get done".
There's no need to engage in intrusive surveillance. If the employee isn't performing acceptably well, that shows in the work.
It's well known that even famous companies Meta, Google and Amazon track various forms of SLOC-related metrics, tickets closed, etc of their SWE. It's usually left to the managers discretion to use it, but its is there and is used often as a coarse measure of productivity.
Either way workplace isn’t personal space. What exactly are folks planning at work that shouldn’t be recorded? Some may say have unions. But only Union activity would be covered under that. I don’t think you’ll ever get a Union that can negotiate for not tracking time and activity while on the clock.
Ngl I’m not doing this at the moment. Thinking of getting a Mac mini asap
That's because it is
Think about any dystopian sci-fi. There's always groups that live in the dystopia and groups that don't feel the effects of it. That's the current state of the world. 1% of the population (including basically everyone on this site) live in luxury, while the rest of the 99% of the population toil under increasingly desperate and precarious living standards.
There's no avoiding it anymore, it's unambiguous, the world is a hellscape of our own doing that we could have avoided if not for wanton, rampant anti-social greed.
Think of this quote and it will be clear: "The future is here it's just unevenly distributed"
Where "future" is synonymous with "hope, life, time, joy"
If they ever come up with a way for tech to read your mind, companies like Chase will have zero qualms about employing it. Fun thought: Gaddafi got knife-raped by a mob while Jamie Dimon roams free.
Might I introduce you to Neurallink?
How about WorldCoin that is based on your Iris (Iris changes are correlated with specific brain activity[1]).
[1]https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fncir.2018.0002...
> Where "future" is synonymous with "hope, life, time, joy"
You have dropped the crucial last word from that quote: “The future is already here. It's just not evenly distributed yet”
The idea that the newly middle-class in Asia ( including software developers working for international companies ) are increasing desperate and precarious is simply not true.
Wait, what? I don't think everyone on HN is a billionaire tech mogul. Most of us are probably just common office worker schmucks. This is one of the main ways the actual Elite 1% works to divide us, by trying to convince the blue collar half of workers that it's those uppity white collar workers who are the problem.
2. Are you aware of how many past SEC and bank regulation actions against JP Morgan and Chase?
Those two factors play heavily in the current tracking solutions and systems.
Curious for a source on that. My BigCorp has disallowed Zoom recordings, since they don't want legal liability of anything embarrassing leaking out. Or the usual reason of having to produce all those recordings when they get sued.
My singular anecdote: I worked for a company I won’t name but you’d be familiar with if you work in tech. We did a lot of expansion and hiring in European offices. The EU managers were far more likely to track and show things like number of lines of code written and they’d want to publicly reward employees who worked nights and weekends. Not all of them, of course, but it was common enough that we had to spend some time training that habit out of some of those teams when they came on. We had a few projects that went bad because the teams were chasing vanity metrics like number of commits, number of lines of code written, or number of Jira tickets closed.
It happens in the US, too, but it’s definitely not a US-specific thing.
I won’t even begin to talk about some of the draconian work time measurements that happened in our Asian offices. The work culture in some countries is… harsh.
> I think everyone expects their employer to track them to some extent. It is pretty standard practice for employers to monitor and run analysis on things like building badge swipes and the amount of time spent connected when working from home. It has also become very common place for employers to record audio and video at the office.
That sounds dystopian to me already (maybe because I'm not in the US? Or haven't spend much time at BigCorp? But is that really the default minimum these days?)
If you asked someone 10-20 years ago if that description sounded dystopian, would you be more likely to get a "yes definitely" than you are today?
I'm way more worried by the dystopia society accepts as "normal" than one that is forced on us and that we could potentially fight against.