News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by rafaelero on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:21PM (#35310473)
When DALL-E 2 was released, I remember reading lots of people here in HN saying it would never take the jobs of artists. Well, seems like this argument is aging badly. This is exactly the type of conversation we need to have as a society. Instead of deluding ourselves that our skills are impossible to be reproduced by a machine, we should strive to build a system with values in which we can find a way to build a good live knowing that everything we do will eventually be better reproduced by AI.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ChatGTP on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:40PM (#35310608)
Interesting development, these machines have little value but for economic gain. No one employed, means no one will pay to keep the machines alive which means we go back to where we were before the machines?
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by chii on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:48PM (#35310676)
> No one employed

i highly doubt no one will be employed even in the advent of a true AI singularity. Just differently employed - there will be reasons why someone would pay for your labour.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ChatGTP on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:08AM (#35310805)
Yeah, my theory is there will just be more shit to do, more startups, more tech, more than ever before. More ways to scale your business, spend your free time, yada yada yada.

Also most western countries have severely aging populations, there’s are big problem there which automation can help with, if it’s applied right.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by blackoil on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:58PM (#35310736)
Player does not care if graphics or code of the game are created by a person or AI. For them it matters how much fun they are having and for companies how low the cost are.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by thomascgalvin on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:26PM (#35310501)
I just wish I was part of the first generation to benefit from post-scarcity, and not the generation that is going to have to go through the turmoil of getting to post-scarcity.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by thot_experiment on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:28PM (#35310509)
Oh don't worry my guy, the odds that we make it to post-scarcity at all are not super high. Just vibe with the slide down the slippery slope, it's all you can do.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by chii on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:47PM (#35310666)
the generation that went thru the industrial revolution would have said the same thing, except they'd wished they were in your position today.

People just don't realize how good today is compared to the past - and of course, how good the future would be (nuclear war notwithstanding).

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by tspike on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:23AM (#35311283)
Any time this argument gets trotted out it's using a baseline of European post-agrarian feudalism. There were definitely peoples in the past who enjoyed a high quality of life for many generations, but they tended to be small groups concentrated in areas of abundance, and were usually among the first to be exterminated by outsiders.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by borissk on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:50AM (#35311774)
The fact that the industrial revolution created better life for most people doesn't prove an AI revolution will do the same.

The classical counter-example are horses - the industrial revolution increased the demand for horses, but once the cars became cheap horses numbers and jobs drastically decreased.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by chii on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:18AM (#35312282)
But in this scenario, the horses had no agency to become anything else.

I refuse to believe humans don't have agency.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:33AM (#35313783)
Agency is only half of the equation. The other half is opportunity. With Industrial Revolution, horses had neither. With AI revolution, people may retain agency, but I doubt there will be many opportunities available.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Fricken on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:39AM (#35314336)
People find ways to make themselves miserable no matter how much they have. This is why objective quality of life metrics are bunk.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by coffeebeqn on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:54PM (#35310709)
I guess we can get AGI and that will lead to great and numerous inventions. Of course how power works in that world is extremely uncertain. Most likely power would flow to a corporation or an authoritative government unfortunately. Not to the people.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by kodah on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:54PM (#35310710)
AI won't take a thought workers job. It just sucks the life out of it. Like the person who wrote this post, I make bespoke software. I tinker, I experiment, and I produce high quality results in reasonable timelines. Executives could not give a shit about that, except that those qualities in me are a good signal that I am dependable. Now, if most companies allow AI bottom performers will speed up and their quality will likely slightly increase. As with most things, those on the top end of the spectrum will need to regress to the mean to compete. The result will be that mediocrity takes over because the AI will be in charge of the boilerplate, which is often the foundation for the rest of your code. You can either find enjoyment in the boilerplate being rote and finding places to spend your time in a higher level of abstraction or you can let what used to be your passion sail away like a little red balloon on a windy day.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by rafaelero on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:03AM (#35310766)
> AI won't take a thought workers job.

I don't understand how you can hold this position considering not only where we are but also the rate of progress in AI. It has been taking thought workers job and it will increasingly do so in the future until the surplus cognitive workers offer is just so minimal that it's not worth to automate it.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by kodah on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:07AM (#35310794)
What jobs have been totally replaced thus far?
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jay_kyburz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:48AM (#35311058)
Companies are slow to move on things, but I think "video game concept artist" is done. An art director can now sit down in front of Midjourny and pump out years and years of a concept artists work in just an afternoon.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by whateveracct on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:54AM (#35311095)
This feels like a comment written by someone without practical experience with concept art (creator or consumer) - correct me if I'm wrong though!

Like personally, I think I will still draw concept art instead of asking a GAN. Feels like that greases my creative wheels more. Just me though.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by coldtea on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:07AM (#35311174)
Whether you have experience or not, game companies already use AI for concept art.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by lunfard000 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:18AM (#35311607)
not only art, Obsidian is using already for voices[0]. The future is here.

0:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YajBa5PO1Hk

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jay_kyburz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:23AM (#35311284)
You are wrong, I have worked for many years as an artists and level builder in video games. Bioshock is the most famous game, and Void Bastards the most recent.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by spoiler on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:33AM (#35312014)
Could you instead use AI to reduce drudgery in your work, or to iterate faster between ideas until you settle on a final peace? What if you have something in mind that is hard to prompt for, or the tool just refuses to generate what you had in mind? I would try to lean into it as a tool to speed up some of the tedium, instead of fear it, if possible
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jay_kyburz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:41AM (#35312051)
I'm not in the camp that fears it, I think it will be an awesome tool and I can't wait to use it in my next game. I've been playing with Midjourny a lot already, but have been watching Stable Diffusion and the control net stuff closely as well.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by lozenge on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:33PM (#35317786)
I could see drawing a couple of characters and getting an AI to extend the style to more. Especially if you can give it feedback. But the idea that you could get years of concepts in an afternoon is silly. That's like saying I can generate hundreds of business plans using ChatGPT.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bruce511 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:37AM (#35311703)
When electric sound amplification came along, it put most professional musicians out of business. Instead of an orchestra all you need is a band of 3 or 4.

Making music expanded though. In the sense that more people played, there was more variety, and indeed more professional musicians today than 100 years ago. (the bar for entry is also lower, and most are permantly broke - take that as you will.)

Some orchestras still exist. But they're pretty rare.

So yes, alot of job descriptions and job titles will change. Making indie games just got a lot easier. But where you see loss, many others see opportunity.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by FranzFerdiNaN on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:34AM (#35312021)
It’s nice that the barrier became lower but people still need jobs to afford food and rent. I doubt that UBI will come anytime soon so less jobs that pay enough is a serious issue.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by OOPMan on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:51PM (#35317302)
Agreed. It feels like a lot of the people burning hard on AI seem to think that when the jobs are gone some benevolent benefactors (who exactly?) will decide to institute UBI for all because....why exactly?

It seems much more likely to me that all that will happen is there will be a lot more poor people...

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bruce511 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:06PM (#35318243)
it's not like "all jobs" will be taken by Robots and AI. That will be of little consolation though to modern-day buggy-whip-makers.

Jobs are a way of "adding value" to society. But over the last 120 years we've figured out how to add a Lot of value with minimal people. 95% of people used to grow food. Now it's like 2%.

People moved to factories, where today robots and automation rule. People moved to hi-tech, and leveraged that tech. Now AI is moving into that space.

In truth, we now create way, way, more value than we need. We need to figure out how to distribute the value created. Somehow I doubt that the US will be the leader here; things like UBI are too far against the "American Way".

When we see UBI emerge, in whatever form that takes (basically basic human needs met) it'll likely come from places that value community over individuality. Places that rate their success by their poor, not their rich. Places that celebrate achievements which don't require the exploitation of others.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jay_kyburz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:51AM (#35312115)
I was just pointing out one job that I could see in my industry. I for one welcome the wealth of interesting new indies games with great looking graphics we'll soon see.

People will be able to take more risks and do more interesting projects. It will be awesome.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by omnimus on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:24AM (#35312312)
Amplification allowed for more original creation.

AI is opposite of human creation. Its definition of anti-creation. Its a spell that locks visual culture to year 2025. And it can only do this by illeagly stealing all the human work.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by AJ007 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:50AM (#35313895)
If we can steal all human work (images) and compress it down to 2gb, then we should be questioning what artists have really been creating.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ericd on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:01AM (#35314545)
You don’t think we can make it come up with variations, and use people’s feedback on what’s interesting to figure out what new avenues are promising? It’s not that hard to do this sort of exploration, it’s not limited to just mimicking what it’s seen. If anything, I think we’ll see an increase in the pace of evolution of art as it becomes economical for normal people to get personalized art.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by 1attice on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:30PM (#35316318)
> Its a spell that locks visual culture to year 2025.

What a fantastic way of putting it.

I'm constantly reminded of _the Matrix_, with Agent Smith telling Neo that 1999 (the apparent year inside the Matrix) was the peak of human civilization.

Our own Matrix will use the year 2025.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by coldtea on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:06AM (#35311168)
First, of all, why it has to be "totally replaced"? It's enough for positions to be dramatically reduced, and most such "though workers" tasks getting done automatically, e.g. under the final supervision of much fewer people.

Second, why it has to be "thus far"? If it happens in 1 or 5 or 10 years does it disqualify it?

Because above you claimed it will "never take thought workers' jobs". Suddenly the goalposts moved so that it has to have happened "totally" and "thus far" to qualify as taking their jobs?

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by CommanderData on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:58AM (#35311508)
I'm witnessing engineers on my team and myself saving a lot of time in development and in operations (scripting).

I have no doubt in my mind it is reducing the need for more engineers and has probably already contributed to a reduction of them and I think it's just getting started.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by saurik on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:49AM (#35312432)
Compilers and high-level languages assuredly reduced the number of engineers needed, right? No: we just started making much more complicated things and the basic level of "this isn't even a serviceable solution" has gone up so high that if you sat around and wrote a trivial program designed to be used over a teletype--which is much much easier as you can do it in C instead of assembly--you'd lose in the market to your competitors who are willing to put in the effort to build a modern fancy reactive single-page whatever's-hot-now web app.

The reality is that companies are going to continue allocating a similar percentage of their budget to tech that they were before, and what we DO might change a ton; but, frankly, I've been doing this now for 30 years, and the stuff I used to do 30 years ago already often isn't a thing anymore. Every time my job gets easier, the expectations for the products I architect also increase, because we're all in a rat race attempting to compete for the same customers to defend our margins.

Hell: I remember when the first step to deploying a new service--even if you were a company that only had a handful of people--was to attempt to predict how much capacity you needed and then buy a ton of parts so you'd be able to sit around and build machines for your server room to run your new product. I was involved in a project back in like, 1998/1999, for a company with all of maybe five people, and someone's job was just sitting around building the server room... that specific task is now a few lines of YAML configuration and a couple of accounts (AWS and Twilio, as we had to have custom T1 lines brought in not for data but for phone service to hook up to the Dialogic hardware we needed to simulate phone lines).

The concept of cloud-computing entirely changed that part of the business--having a small handful of companies manage all the servers at scale and run numerous jobs on shared hardware, in some sense reducing the cost to the point where you can both outsource this and pay less--to the point where doing that almost sounds insane; and yet, I'm sure there are more people getting paid more to deploy and manage ever more virtualized servers in the cloud than there ever were people (including me!) literally screwing around with screwdrivers in the ubiquitous server rooms.

I'll admit that I honestly kind of enjoyed doing that work?... and yet, I also was quite happy to never have to do it ever again. I'll never forget the day I took the first real-world server I was in charge of and just like, uploaded it to 1&1 where I had an early software-based hypervisor-like stack I was experimenting with (UML, aka User Mode Linux, which is no longer something people bother with due to the advent of Xen/KVM/etc.); it just worked and I was like "omg I'm never building another server again, am I? that was it: it's over". (It then turned out that I did build another complex hardware solution in 2016 to start doing work with GPUs, but there was only a small window of time there before cloud services caught up.)

So like, sure: at some point the AI is going to entirely replace what we do--not the specific frustrating coding tasks we do today, but the entire concept of our jobs--but, the issue at that point isn't going to be me figuring out what I'm going to do next to make ends meat... it is going to be that I'm not a serviceable warrior in the war against the machines as the world devolves into some kind of Terminator-inspired hellscape; because, if you can manage to do my job in its totality, then you frankly can also do the job of everyone who has ever hired me and you can do the job of every investor who has ever given us money to do those things... we are all obsolete and, if AI actually gets as good as so many people here fear it will, at best we all become pets :(.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by chimprich on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:07AM (#35312820)
Would being the pet of an AI-run civilisation be so bad though? Iain M Banks's Culture novels explore basically this concept, and his vision of utopia is quite appealing.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by saurik on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:03AM (#35313132)
I honestly don't like how we treat our pets (and especially so here in the United States). I keep imagining that the situation will end up feeling--at best--like this episode of (The New) Outer Limits. :(

https://theouterlimits.fandom.com/wiki/The_Human_Operators

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ben_w on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:23AM (#35314158)
Is Jernau Morat Gurgeh the Player of Games, or a mere pawn moved by Minds beyond his comprehension?

The Culture appeals to me, but there are literary critics who find even The Culture, let alone the grander environment beyond it, to be dystopian. And I definitely don't want to wake up dead with my mind in one of Joiler Veppers' simulations.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by gaganyaan on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:23PM (#35316977)
He's definitely a pawn. But I'd sign up for being kept around as a pawn/pet/whatever in an instant if it meant living in the Culture.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by coldtea on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:27PM (#35317723)
>Would being the pet of an AI-run civilisation be so bad though?

Only for people with dignity. So, in general, no!

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by atchoo on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:26AM (#35314195)
> companies are going to continue allocating a similar percentage of their budget to tech

I think your argument requires a paradigm shift like teletype -> web to soak up the new productivity. I don't think we have that today. For how many purposes have we reached peak consumer software capability? i.e. global reach to publish text, images, video and make purchases is the entire use case of most media and commerce businesses. If you gave every company double the amount of dev resources tomorrow, do they even have anything to build? Even for those with deep feature roadmaps, how much of that stuff is just nice-to-have things that won't move the revenue needle anyway?

Maybe we will get that new platform from AR or direct brain interfaces... but without it, the situation looks more like how the human role of "computer" just vanished... sure we then got programmers, but they weren't necessarily the same people.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by kodah on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:09PM (#35318998)
> Suddenly the goalposts moved so that it has to have happened "totally" and "thus far" to qualify as taking their jobs?

I was asking a question. I don't think anyone can confidently quantify the effects of AI at this point so I was seeing if I was missing something. What I said is just some word vomit about what I'm seeing on the ground as an engineer. I'm happy to accept a refutation as we gather more concrete data. The reason I asked the question the way I did is because as I stated there is no doubt AI will impact our jobs, but I'm understandably more concerned about less jobs because of AI. I also have the experience of writing a lot of automation, and hearing this same style of rhetoric when we started doing that heavily. For all the scare around automation, it did end fact end up creating more jobs and typically made lives easier.

Jumping to "shifting goalposts" over that is pretty trash conversation.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by fxtentacle on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:20AM (#35311934)
Didn't all major companies do mass-firings recently?

What do you expect will happen if an entry-level software engineer becomes 2x as productive? You need 2x less, so you fire half the team.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by spoiler on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:29AM (#35311990)
A smart company will realise it's better to be 2x productive for the same money than to be at the same productivity for half the money.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jokethrowaway on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:53AM (#35312126)
Wrong, there's just so much a company can dedicate itself too, otherwise you'll start doing little useless experiments that go nowhere like google
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by spoiler on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:38AM (#35312388)
I think Google has a weird pathological case maybe. So, I'm not sure I would use them as a forecast.

I think R&D is good in any company. Sure, the nature of R&D is that most of it is failure; that's just the way it is.

AI makes the R&D iteration shorter and cheaper, IMO. The more you try, the more likely you're to succeed (aside: I should listen to my own advice sometimes lol).

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by vasco on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:43AM (#35312064)
If performing a job is even just 10% faster, you can fire 1 person out of a team of 10 (or need to hire in the first place). This should be obvious.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by raincole on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:53AM (#35312131)
I'm sure most programmers work more than 10% faster with syntax highlighting and autocomplete. But no one says IDE replaced humans' jobs.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:11AM (#35313620)
They did, and so did high-level languages, and not to mention the entire profession is first and foremost about automating other peoples' jobs away. Thing is, nobody is really tracking how improvements for software developers are replacing people, because this only manifests at slowing the absurdly high growth rate in this industry.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by vasco on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:15PM (#35316138)
Yes they did, what are you thinking would have happened if all we had was assembly? To build any meaningful software you'd need armies of people and it'd take way longer and it wouldn't be as good.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jayd16 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:50AM (#35312104)
First, this argument applies to everything from WFH adding efficiency to computers themselves being faster than ink and paper.

But that's not how the economics works out. The business can simply choose to sell 10% more content.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by wwweston on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:12PM (#35322112)
At some point, you saturate the market for whatever’s being produced and then prices drop and you have diminishing marginal returns for production so the economics of making more doesn’t make sense.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by cthalupa on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:26AM (#35314198)
You could say this about every efficiency improvement in any field ever. If everything still had to be written in C and we didn't have fancy IDEs and access to a vast ocean of libraries, cheap services doing the work for you and returning results over an API, etc., we would need many many many times over more software devs to have everything software based in the world that we do now.

But do you think if none of these things had changed, and everyone was still doing nearly everything themselves, with a limited subset of libraries in use, writing everything in C, we would have all of these applications, services, pieces of software, etc? That all of these viable businesses employing people would still exist?

I doubt it. And like the poster from the reddit link, a lot of software devs truly did enjoy a lot of that work that they did. I've talked to plenty of greybeards who will wax nostalgic over spending months writing things that a pip install and import solve in a few seconds now.

If we double the efficiency of a team, do we fire half of them? Or do we double the amount of products we're releasing? Or double the amount of features for one product?

I think we have far more software devs today because of the advent of higher level languages, large library selections available with package managers, feature-rich IDEs, etc.

Is this always the case, for every industry? Obviously not. There are a lot fewer people making furniture by hand today than there was before automated manufacturing, and any individual only needs so many chairs. But there is, of course, still demand for hand built furniture using traditional joinery techniques.

"Art" is a big space, and I don't think that the impact will be universal across every part of it. For games in specific, I think we'll see something more like the software development side - people will make more and more unique assets vs. reusing them, we'll see the artwork be more detailed and "populated" in general. We'll see more and more smaller studios putting out work with higher quality and more art assets. Same thing for other media-related positions. And the people who are reliably selling prints for people to hang on walls, collect, etc., I think are also likely quite safe. I think people relying on twitter/instagram/etc. commissions to draw people's D&D characters or anime waifu are likely in a lot of trouble.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by vasco on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:14PM (#35316125)
Do you think it takes as many people to build whatever software you want today vs in the 80s? I agree more software can be built with the improvements, but per unit of functionality, way less people are needed, or they can do it much faster, which in both cases mean you spend less of your revenue on labor, which means "less jobs".
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by cthalupa on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:12PM (#35317546)
>which in both cases mean you spend less of your revenue on labor, which means "less jobs".

You can't view things in the void like this, though. Reducing the overall cost of doing something makes it viable for more businesses, which means more jobs. We have more jobs in software development overall now because of how much more productive it is today, which opens up so many more viable use cases for it. We have more CG artists for movies, games, etc. now in large part because more efficient workflows and more powerful software have increased productivity.

Will it be the same thing with generative AI? I think so, at least for the foreseeable future.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Zvez on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:20PM (#35317644)
their point is simple: during the last 20-30 years we had efficiency improvements by orders of magnitude. Still we didn't have developers jobs reduction in any way. We evolved into doing more and more high-level and high-scale jobs. So no, -10% of time needed to build the same unit of functionality won't lead to -10% reduction of workforce. It will change the scope of said workforce.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by happytiger on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:48AM (#35312428)
I have seen at least one outsourced programming job slow down to the point where it’s effectively no longer outsourced. Previously there were two engineers working, and now there is one as the work isn’t needed anymore.

That in a very real way is a replaced job.

The remaining job is running large scale data loading for a startup and really now is just eyeballs to make sure errors are caught. No longer requires much skill either.

I think some degree of low end engineering work in the outsourcing world is at risk.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by code_witch_sam on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:50AM (#35312748)
paralegals seem like they're very much at risk
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ericathegreat on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:24PM (#35320827)
There are still professional, high quality hand knitters in the world.

Of course, having people hand knit garments used to be the only way to get a knitted garment at all.

Then we invented industrial knitting machines, and those hand knitters found their roles had changed. Instead of knitting a whole garment, they would be closing up the toe on the socks, or doing finishing work on a sweater. Of course, companies didn't need anywhere near as many knitters under this system, so a huge proportion of them lost their jobs.

Then the knitting machines got better. They could close the toes on the socks themselves, could do most of the finishing work automatically. Some of the remaining knitters became industrial knitting support workers, but most of the actual knitting jobs dried up.

But there are still professional, commercial hand knitters, even today! They test hand knitting patterns for the hobby market. Make the samples up for photographing, and make sure that all the sizes come out right.

They number... Dozens? Maybe? And most of them treat it as a side gig, despite being the absolute pinnacle of hand knitting talent, since it pays terribly.

A job doesn't have to have been totally replaced to be effectively replaced. As we find ways to hand over larger and larger pieces of the work to an automated system, the number of real roles in that field diminishes, until it eventually becomes infeasible as a career choice.

This is what a lot these digital content creation jobs are heading. Gradual obsolescence.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Pandabob on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:23AM (#35314742)
Lots of reasonable people seem to hold this view. Sam Altman himself mentioned believing this in the Lex Friedman podcast.

Here are tweets from famous HN users Simon Willison[0] and Patrick Mckenzie[1] endorsing the viewpoint as well.

[0]: https://twitter.com/simonw/status/1639692312585572352

[1]: https://twitter.com/patio11/status/1639787193580519424

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by rafaelero on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:49AM (#35315032)
I hope they are right. But one thing that seems to be conflated in this debate is the comparison of AI with previous disruptions. The tools we have built before were taking some specific parts of the process and making it more productive. They were not trying to mimic human cognition in a way that can be applied to so many different processes at the same time.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by coldtea on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:01AM (#35311139)
>AI won't take a thought workers job. It just sucks the life out of it.

It already has started taking them.

Also note that it sucking the life out of them doesn't preclude this, since nobody cares for quality anyway. Neither the companies, who prefer profit, nor most consumers, who will eat up whatever mediocre shit.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by rakejake on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:04AM (#35311152)
Amen. AI will make us all "managers" of some sort. Goodbye to getting in flow state and trying to build something yourself, and say hello to a gazillion meetings from morning until evening figuring out what to build and what prompt to feed to the AI.

AI is going to make our bullshit jobs even shittier.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by paweladamczuk on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:38AM (#35311708)
Instead of grinding away over a piece of code, I will get to talk to people more?

Doesn't sound like such a bad deal to me.

I get your point, of course. I just think communication can be like a craft, challenging and rewarding. I try to frame things positively, it helps me stay motivated at work.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by dsego on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:45AM (#35312075)
> Instead of grinding away over a piece of code

crafting

> get to talk to people more

about KPIs and OKRs

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by rakejake on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:34AM (#35312971)
I appreciate your attitude, and it is something we all have to pick-up eventually. When you pose it as "talk to more people", that does sound better. But I see it as a job with more pressure and tension, more politics, and less freedom to experiment.

Think about the average day of a manager/management consultant/VC (whose job it is to talk to people, make deals etc). I always looked at their careers and walked away thankful that a programmer career exists.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by riwsky on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:18AM (#35311258)
“Reasonable timelines” are not absolute quantities. They’ve always been an equilibrium of whatever the market can bear. It was simply easier to ignore this before, when things changed much more slowly.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bruce511 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:28AM (#35311658)
>> The result will be that mediocrity takes over because the AI will be in charge of the boilerplate, which is often the foundation for the rest of your code.

Your take is interesting, but I'll provide an alternate point of view from my experience.

I have spent my career working in a low-code environment. There's a boiler plate framework into which people add code.

Since most of all programs are similar (data in, data stored, data processed, data out etc) this allows for high productivity because almost all time is spent on things that are unique to the domain space, not programming the common stuff. It means individual programmers, and very small teams, have written and maintain huge systems.

But what's interesting to me is the boilerplate code. My career has been spent improving the underlying boilerplate, and extending it to new feature areas. This turns out to be a great lever. Improve the boiler-plate and _existing_ programs get better, with minimal effort. Sometimes no effort.

It's kinda like the way I get TLS 1.3 support simply by upgrading my OpenSSL libraries. But at a source level. Which is then retro-applied to existing source code.

Instead of being mediocrity the goal is to always keep improving the boilerplate because that in turn improves a lot of programs.

I say this not to tell you nothing will change. It will change. But change in programming is fun. It stretches the mind, and opens up new horizons. The AI can write code, but that just becomes the next tool, like IDEs were, like code complete, online help or Stackoverflow. I didn't have any of those things growing up, but their introductions allow me to dream bigger, be better, make more.

AI is an opportunity for those with eyes to see.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by steveshurley44 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:46AM (#35312079)
SAP?
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by candiodari on Sunday March 26, 2023 @11:24AM (#35315427)
If you look at it from the bottom, then yes. SAP/Salesforce/IBM DB2/Oracle/OpenERP are ways for company departments to all work on one common set of data.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by danjac on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:45AM (#35311749)
There was a fear that nanotechnology could accidentally turn everything into gray goo.

AI is that, but for intellectual output.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anoy8888 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:14AM (#35311906)
This statement is a bit arrogant considering the current pace of AI progress. I bet it won’t age well in a couple of years
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by globalise83 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:01AM (#35312490)
Question is: would a 2x or 3x developer paired with an AI be more productive than a 2x or 3x developer paired with a team of several 1x and 0.5x developers? Cutting out coordination costs while still getting the grunt work done by someone else seems like it would lead to much higher and more coherent output.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by MachineBurning on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:48AM (#35312732)
The person who wrote the post says that they can produce the same quality content in "2-3 days" instead of "several weeks", and that there are two people working in essentially the same position.

If the amount of content to be produced remains constant, then from a purely financial point of view the company should be looking at cutting one of them. AI would have then taken their job.

For the amount of content to be produced to not remain constant either the studio would have to go for increased art quality, or scale up the rest of the business to keep up with the new art productivity. It's not clear they'd make that decision over cutting their art department spending in two. At the very least their job is at risk.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by washadjeffmad on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:02AM (#35313551)
Oof. Firing isn't free, comrade. Reducing redundancy to a single point of failure has two major effects: the latency penalty becomes quadratic as workload scales, and if any person quits, you lose the whole team.

In general, creative roles like artists are the sum value of their education and experience, not just their measured output. If you don't possess art history vocabulary, you're going to be very limited in prompting or designing more advanced embeddings and LoRA or training models. I'm seeing this a lot right now - people don't want to share their prompts because they don't want everyone to know how much the model carried them and how little any actual "prompt engineering" went into it.

The smart thing for their boss to do would be to scale projects and have one of them focus on managing and filtering the new volume of assets. Since it sounds like they like working from scratch, even adding external time to "research tooling and methods" would probably keep them happy until they find the challenge in their new duties.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Deegy on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:44AM (#35314978)
Even if we agree that your strategy is optimal, it would require the manager acting in a significantly pragmatic manner.

I would wager that the majority of managers will rather reactively jump at the chance to cut an entire salary from their cost structure.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by the_lonely_road on Sunday March 26, 2023 @11:46AM (#35315727)
The majority of managers would jump at the opportunity to reduce their number of direct reports? Owners might want to cut salaries but managers want to increase direct reports.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Hoasi on Monday March 27, 2023 @06:11PM (#35333470)
> people don't want to share their prompts because they don't want everyone to know how much the model carried them and how little any actual "prompt engineering" went into it.

Right. Because this whole "prompt engineering" is just another job title, not an applied science, and then again, prompts can and will be automated away.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by eternalban on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:11AM (#35314641)
> allow AI bottom performers

Starting in early '00s, it was getting annoying to have to sit in tech meetings with workers who barely had any actual experience designing systems debate technical decision empowered by wikipedia and some randos blog on hype du jour. Before the internet they would keep quiet since they actually knew zip. It is going to be absolutely awful now.

How all this will affect the youth in context of education, higher learning, students' drive, teachers' domain authority etc. is a more critical issue than labor transitions.

It is interesting and important to note that AI (as it is today) disempowers humans in every dimensions except capital.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by gwbrooks on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:06AM (#35310791)
>> This is exactly the type of conversation we need to have as a society.

Comments like this always make me wonder: How would that happen? Here in the U.S., there's relatively little appetite for job-saving labor protections and, once you leave the regulatory sphere, everyone -- employers, employees, consumers of products and services -- is consistently self-interested.

Not saying that sort of societal conversation is impossible; just saying I don't have the imagination to see how it could happen with actionable results in the 2023 version of the U.S.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jay_kyburz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:42AM (#35311026)
I don't think the conversion we need to have is about how to stop it, its about what we do with all the unemployed artists, accountants, journalists, truck and taxi drivers.

Do we pay half of them to dig holes, then pay the other half to fill them?

We just need to keep the economy wheel turning while everybody finds new meaningful work.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by coldtea on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:07AM (#35311178)
Who is "we"? The rich will decide, and probably that they can do without most of the "we".
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Radim on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:08AM (#35314035)
I agree with that sentiment, just a small correction:

It's not the rich who will decide; it's the powerful. In the classical sense of "capacity to impose will" – up to and including the capacity to turn off {machines, humans, institutions}.

There's a strong correlation between wealth and power, but those groups are not identical. And neither are their staying prospects in the coming years.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Radim on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:21AM (#35314150)
On seconds thoughts, interestingly, that difference between "wealth" and "power" also becomes relevant when quantifying your "most" in They can do without MOST of the "we".

Like, how many people do the most wealthy/powerful actually need? What level of automation will allow maintaining their lifestyle, including:

1) Biological needs: Food & a sufficiently diverse pool of mates for themselves and their children.

2) A social hierarchy large enough to flex their power beyond mere biological survival (very important to primates). I'd expect this number to be strictly smaller than for 1), so likely subsumed by 1) and not a concern.

3) Technological scaffolding to produce, maintain and bootstrap (in case of calamities) said automation. Currently humans are a necessary physical substrate for the continued inflow of energy that automation needs. I don't have the numbers but the footprint necessary to run even a single power plant must be tremendous: a large and complex society, once you include 2nd order effects. Without energy, the machines don't go "VRRROOM" and neither does AI.

And if the human population drops too low to interfere with any of these point, the automation was self-defeating. It doesn't matter how rich or powerful you were.

I mean, I'm sure someone somewhere ran the numbers and has a plan ready, while the rest of us wax lyrical about "just find a new job LOL" and UBI. Although to be fair, there are also preppers, who've taken the above analysis to its logical conclusion.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by IX-103 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:04PM (#35315981)
The true limit is item 2 on your list. Eventually AI can take care of the food production portion of 1 and most of item 3. The fact is that energy and secure storage are much less of a problem for AI and robots than people.

For population replacement, you can get by with a couple thousand people. That's really only about a dozen large tribes. If the tribes are kept suitably insular and antagonistic (with either ritualized external marriage or slave-taking to ensure proper genetic circulation) that society might even be stable. The trick would be keeping the population stable.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by lazyeye on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:30AM (#35311669)
They just move into the more AI resistant sectors of the economy (putting a big downward pressure on wages for those remaining jobs of course).
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by borissk on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:47AM (#35311759)
Who's going to pay for those remaining jobs?

E.g. currently mostly the middle class pays for home improvements, which creates jobs for construction workers. Remove the middle class and there's a lot less demand for construction workers - so what are the IT people turned into construction workers going to do?

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by whitemary on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:49AM (#35311773)
The low wages cannot go any lower. As it stands, poor workers in the US already don't make nearly enough to survive. They just keep increasing their debt until they either climb the ladder or die of an overdose or some other tragedy.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by herbst on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:59AM (#35312180)
That's a process that didn't start with AI but now it became obvious very fast that it gets to late to ignore.

There is no model that works in a purely capitalistic setting. The reality this this issue will hit us hard, everywhere and faster every day.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by justrealist on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:48AM (#35311054)
It doesn't even really matter what the US regulations are. If a firm in the Philippines can run Midjourney for pennies to generate content that would take hundreds or thousands of dollars in illustrator costs, there's simply no way to mandate labor protections in the US that would keep customers from outsourcing the work.

The gradient is just too strong, and you can't keep a pedigree on every image you publish that originated from a design firm.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by trafficante on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:04AM (#35311547)
We’re creating a new global average standard of living with disastrous consequences.

The poor areas rapidly gain wealth but at great cost to the environment and the whole thing is dependent on a never-ending fire hose of capital and tech transfers from the “wealthy” areas.

The wealthy areas, already unable to offer many citizens the ability to raise a family, are desperately engaging in extreme financialization, ludicrous political distractions, and “make work” shell games just to present an increasingly unconvincing veneer that society is still functioning and fully worthy of participation.

Western civilization is the metaphorical Biblical statue from Daniel: After spending decades replacing the support structures with ever cheaper materials, we’re now finally in the “feet of iron and clay” stage, and it’s likely AI will complete the metaphor by representing the boulder that smashes into the weakened base and topples the entire statue.

I realize this all sounds hilariously alarmist, but I have yet to see a positive spin on the impact of AI that isn’t ultimately the same old decoupled Pete Peterson style nonsense of “it’s gud because worker productivity number goes up”: as if we don’t already have two generations of human beings that grew up in an age of massively increased productivity yet cannot afford a family nor a home to put them in - a state of existence that even some medieval serfs would pity.

My weirdly accelerationist hope is that AI advances quickly enough (and management stays short-sighted enough) to cause a meaningful political coalition to form between the already-marginalized blue collar workers and the newly disrupted paper-pusher/cubicle class.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by whitemary on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:46AM (#35311757)
FWIW you are not crazy. I completely agree with every part of your comment.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bruce511 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:51AM (#35311778)
>> The poor areas rapidly gain wealth but at great cost to the environment and the whole thing is dependent on a never-ending fire hose of capital and tech transfers from the “wealthy” areas.

While I sympathize with your angst at the coming future, a future where the US isn't the highest, I see that for most of the world your prediction is both highly desirable, and inaccurate.

Firstly, let's dispel the great-cost-to-the-environment myth. The US has done, and continues to do great harm to the environment. Indeed many developing nations are skipping the harmful phase and embracing new tech like solar , better urban planning and so on.

Also, while it's fun to posit that thd globe depends on US capital, there's a bigger picture in play. TikTok is developed without western capital, suddenly its a surveillance risk (because Facebook and Google wouldn't spy on me).

Sure there's environmental cost to development, but complaining about the environment of others is a bit rich for the US (as it approves drilling in Alaska). The US accounts for 25% of global emissions, and about 5%ish of thd World population.

So yeah - you want your job yo be remote? Be careful what you wish for.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by maeil on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:06AM (#35312225)
I agree with most of your comment but comparing Facebook or Google with Tiktok remains a classic "both sides" false equivalency that takes away from other valid points that you make. Yes, US social media companies too have to comply with government requests, which have at times been abused. No, the scale and impact that this has is in no way comparable to Chinese tech companies and their relation to the government.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by DecoySalamander on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:02AM (#35313126)
There is an "easy" solution - a regulation that would remove copyright protection from AI-generated art, or perhaps even art that has an AI-generated output somewhere in the pipeline. Art could still be AI-generated for efficiency, but large studios would be forced to keep humans on a payroll for accountability.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by tekknik on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:43AM (#35325936)
I mean if you’re creating regulation just require a human to oversee any job done by AI. Instead of just protecting copyrighted works.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by melagonster on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:15AM (#35310865)
unfortunately, we have capitalism. in our society, if people and their kids starving and dying, we think this ia justice.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ChatGTP on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:28AM (#35310938)
That’s because it’s a minority of people in that situation, once it’s > 50% facing prospects like that, it all changes in the blink of an eye ?
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ben_w on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:37AM (#35312990)
Second sentence yes, first sentence… well, the potato famine comes to mind.

Change happened, yes, but it's not necessarily fast even in such situations.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by xdennis on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:32AM (#35312011)
This is childish. People are starving more in non capitalist societies.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by melagonster on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:33AM (#35314268)
yes, their kids are starving. but our kids will starve. this is our problem.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by kentrado on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:33PM (#35318599)
I think the ones you are referring to are still capitalist as companies are owned by an elite "capitalist" and the workers have no say in their workplace.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by orbital-decay on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:31AM (#35310955)
It didn't take OP's job, though. It gave them another tool that produces better output, but which they don't happen to like (in contrast to their colleague who doesn't have issues with it).
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by nirvdrum on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:39AM (#35311017)
It didn't take the job in the sense that the OP is still employed. It changed the job into something that barely resembles what the OP was hired to do. It's not quite constructive dismissal, but many people choose fields for reasons of maximizing income. It's hard to stay motivated doing something you hate, especially when a week ago your job had you doing something you love. And that says nothing about the OP's ethical quandry about IP laundering.

I might be too cynical, but given the reported productivity gains, it's quite possible the company decides they can do with a single artist. I'd imagine at the very least it sets a ceiling on advancement.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by orbital-decay on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:57AM (#35311112)
The reality is that an artist in a mobile games company is hired for their technical skills, with very little creative freedom. The real artist is usually the art director or a similar position responsible for stylistic/creative/conceptual decisions.

If your job is mostly technical, be ready to re-learn and reshape your skills when your tool goes the way of cel animation. I personally had to do this at least three times in 25 years, not entirely from scratch of course, but I had to relearn the vast majority of my skills. And I think I'll need to do more of it to stay relevant. So to me it's pretty normal.

The work of a creative professional is to deliver meaning. If you can't separate this from your tools and are only able to enjoy one specific tool, you have to question yourself what you're doing in the field. (yes, I'm also being too cynical)

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anigbrowl on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:14AM (#35311225)
I personally had to do this at least three times in 25 years [...] So to me it's pretty normal

Very relatable, but it seems unwise to just consider it normal. If you find yourself having to retool 3 times within 25 months, you'll be well on the way to burning out.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by orbital-decay on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:31AM (#35311333)
25 years, not months; it wasn't that hard. It wasn't just retooling though - aerospace engineering to SE in gamedev, to the management in the unrelated creative area, to ML.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anigbrowl on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:07PM (#35316785)
Yes, I know you said 25 years. I was trying to point out that with the accelerating technological capabilities, you could find that need to retool happening faster and faster.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by HervalFreire on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:24AM (#35311286)
You're not being cynical. You're being overly optimistic here about creative professionals.

The creative professional IS a target for replacement. What LLMs do best is specifically what the "creative professional" does. Better than coding or mathematics, LLMs excel at creative English text. This is because creative output is trivial when compared with technical skills.

I don't think the "creative professional" will get replaced though. Because usually the task is so trivial that positions like these largely only exist because of politics. You convince people around you and yourself that your "creativity" has no peer.

It amounts to this: I want a photo-realistic animation of a cowboy with blue skin with a laser cannon riding a unicycle through the grand canyon with a dwarf chasing him. <<This sentence is trivial to come up with, ANYONE can come up with thousands a variations and tweak the sentence in various ways. No special talent needed here.

A creative director simply comes up with high level instructions (like the one above) THEN the ultra hard part is making that high level instruction a reality. That is HARD and as of now it looks like both skills are being replaced by AI.

But like I said, the directors' position is in actuality largely political. Thus his position is safe even though the actuality of what he does is EASY and therefore a prime target for replacement.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by orbital-decay on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:00AM (#35311517)
> A creative director simply comes up with high level instructions (like the one above) THEN the ultra hard part is making that high level instruction a reality. That is HARD and as of now it looks like both skills are being replaced by AI.

This is the opposite of what I see in reality right now. The hard part is to make the artists do exactly what you want, down to the subtle but meaningful details. That happens because the high-level instructions don't have enough capacity to deliver the full meaning. This is the same with generative models: extremely hard to control with the "prompt engineering" gimmick, it's only fine when you are OK with random output. Besides, they are purely functional and lack feedback mechanisms the creative director usually employ with artists.

That's why people are trying to make techniques more complex - large animation houses experiment with training their own model architectures and software. This is the way 3D CGI was born - simple at first, and yes it got plenty of doomposting at first (we are getting replaced by computers!), until it was clear that the field becomes extremely technical and complex, so it even has dozens of specializations inside it.

All entertainment is ultimately based on novelty, as human brain is really good at distilling meaning from the ocean of information. If you start with little meaning (your example - "a cowboy with blue skin with a laser cannon riding a unicycle through the grand canyon with a dwarf chasing him"), people get bored - no matter how much randomized artsy-looking stuff you add around it.

If you think that AI can generate all meaning that is relevant to people, I don't buy it, as it doesn't have the same training material. It's trained on the result and is forced to reverse engineer what moves people; reverse engineering is a fundamentally more costly and opaque task.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by HervalFreire on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:46AM (#35314998)
Train the AI exclusively on well lauded texts. Then you can get a generative AI that moves people.

The problem with "reverse engineering people" is that you don't need to, the things they like in any era follows predictable and generic patterns. These patterns can be encoded into AI provided we find enough curated training data.

> The hard part is to make the artists do exactly what you want, down to the subtle but meaningful details.

This is because the artist can't read your mind. It has nothing to do with your skill or the artists skill level. That feedback loop you are alluding to is more a reflection of the unclarity of your instructions or your imagination.

You thought what you imagined looked good but the artist in following your directions created something that showed you how flawed your imagination was.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by orbital-decay on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:37PM (#35316415)
> The problem with "reverse engineering people" is that you don't need to, the things they like in any era follows predictable and generic patterns. These patterns can be encoded into AI provided we find enough curated training data.

That only works to a certain degree. For the infamous example, try making GPT output the correct number of asterisks, you will get mixed results. You don't have any problem with typing exactly 1589 asterisks because you run the stateful counting algorithm in your head. GPT has no idea about the algorithm - it has to reverse engineer it from the text, and can only extract the vague correspondence between a number and a string about this or that length. You don't give humans examples, you teach them to count.

This is a simplest example, it might even learn to count eventually, as it's far more capable in certain aspects. But as the dimensionality of the task grows, the amount of resources and training data required to reverse engineer it grows much faster.

Sure, it can spot some patterns and that can look good, but some things are just plain invisible in the result - you will have a hard time making it learn higher level concepts because they highly depend on hardwired things like the dumber part of neural circuitry and biochemistry in humans, which the model doesn't have.

It's like trying to make a photo in a dark room - no matter how you improve the sensitivity of your camera, you might not have a single photon in it.

> This is because the artist can't read your mind.

Yes, this is what I mean by the limited capacity of a simple textual description. It's a fundamental limitation - natural language is just poorly suited for the detailed conceptualization. A sketch, or a conceptual diagram, or other higher order control methods have far more capacity to explain your intent, and that's the direction those models move to. At which point their usage is nothing like "type something simple and receive the result".

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by HervalFreire on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:05PM (#35317469)
The asterisks thing is another issue. LLMs don't need to do this to replace directors.

>Yes, this is what I mean by the limited capacity of a simple textual description. It's a fundamental limitation - natural language is just poorly suited for the detailed conceptualization.

Except LLMs can accept sketches as input. The higher order methods of communication are covered by encoders.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by spoiler on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:07AM (#35312227)
I think you're conflating imagination and creativity with taste. Your example might be cute and funny, but as you yourself alluded: it's completely bland and tasteless. It's maybe good enough for a "meme dump" but that's all.

Maybe I'm not sure what point you're trying to make either?

All fiction writers suck? I don't know how much fiction you read, but it's incredible varied. There's a lot writers need to think about and control in the reader (and account for multiple profiles) outside of just an idea. But the ideas themselves need to be coherent.

Creative directors suck? It's incredible difficult being s creative director having to organise multiple people to perform coherently, and even much harder for whole teams.

I think it's natural for humans to reduce and simplify things we don't engage with every day, or our brains would be overloaded. So we just handwave it off. We do it to other people too unfortunately... Remember how complex your life (internal and external) is; other's lives are equally complex and nuanced.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by HervalFreire on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:27AM (#35314779)
>Creative directors suck? It's incredible difficult being s creative director having to organise multiple people to perform coherently, and even much harder for whole teams.

Difficult in terms of effort. Not difficult in terms of skill. Make no mistake the quality of a movie is more the sum of the quality of the parts then it is the creative director. Who wrote the script? Who did the digital effects? Who did the lighting? Who did the editing?

The director did the hard work of picking the people and issuing orders.

>I think it's natural for humans to reduce and simplify things we don't engage with every day, or our brains would be overloaded. So we just handwave it off. We do it to other people too unfortunately... Remember how complex your life (internal and external) is; other's lives are equally complex and nuanced.

Except I am more or less a director. Not one for movies but for a company.

There is a difference between handwaving something off versus being delusional about your own role within the world. Directing is hard work, management is hard work. But none of these things are skilled work.

>All fiction writers suck? I don't know how much fiction you read, but it's incredible varied. There's a lot writers need to think about and control in the reader (and account for multiple profiles) outside of just an idea. But the ideas themselves need to be coherent. own position.

It is certainly easier to create an entire space opera in writing then it is to do it via a movie. Writing is skilled work in terms of one skill only: your ability to write. Every other aspect of it is hard work but, unfortunately, unskilled work.

I realize there are complex plots, paradoxical stories and imaginative settings and the pacing of a story is important as well. But all of this doesn't really require skill just time and deep thought to come up with. Plenty of the most popular authors never had a writing background or talent.

I would say again that these director positions while in principle are easily replaceable they are not in practice due to politics. A director or CEO is where he is mainly due to politics. Politics is unfortunately a skill with aspects that not only need to be imitated by AI but imitated by robotics as well, and it's simply a gateway into the role with no relation to the actuality of the job requirements.

Its hard to imagine a computer issuing the same exact orders as a director. But with LLMs computers are really close to doing that in principle. The issue is as I mentioned the social and political aspect of directing that cannot be replaced yet.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by spoiler on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:57AM (#35312159)
I've had to do something similar in a much shorter career as well (about 10 years or so). I think the rate of change is much quicker these days too. It was still always within the tech field, but for better or worse my career has been incredibly diverse. Not sure if I'll be able to keep up when I'm older (entering my 30ies now) or not, but so far I've always seen it as personal growth opportunities.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by linkjuice4all on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:09AM (#35311185)
Jobs change and hopefully peoples’ skillset changes and gets better when they do.

This job was different 5 years ago and this entire animation process would be unrecognizable 50 years ago. Tweening didn’t ruin animation it just lowered the barrier of entry. This too will lower the barrier of entry so our future will be more high quality animation. Some of it will be lasting and some of it will be appreciated for mere seconds for throw away content such as ads.

Maybe when everyone gets home from their boring prompt engineering jobs they can go back to hand rolling animation stacks or whatever other workflow is currently getting destroyed by AI for the “fun” of it.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by 7speter on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:39AM (#35312687)
Everyone isn’t going to be lucky enough to have a prompt engineering job
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by nmz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:05AM (#35311160)
We never needed to be this productive anyway, we are completely swarmed with content, to the point that if we stopped producing today we would still be consuming new media after 100 years.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by orbital-decay on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:12AM (#35311216)
This process has been happening for at least a couple decades (arguably more) without any AI, though. The entertainment industry almost ran itself into the ground that way, long before those things emerged. Or rather, the demand made it to.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by HervalFreire on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:11AM (#35311201)
Think about the implications of it. Don't just take it at face value.

How much longer will he be able to KEEP his job.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anigbrowl on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:12AM (#35311214)
It turned OP from a craftperson to a machine operator. Their less-skilled colleague (either due to lack of talent, experience, or application) is now cruising past them them because they don't care as much as OP did about the work itself. OP is still employed, but now some of the necessary grunt work has become the main task. And that, too, will be easier done by machine before long.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by quonn on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:20AM (#35313683)
I‘m hoping, perhaps unreasonably, that the work in the short to medium term actually gets better. I‘m currently working on something very interesting after having worked an complete shit a few months last year: Shit where a designer draws up the exact thing and then it is redundantly implemented on mobile by overpaid developers. Let that be done by the AI. Good riddance.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by tekknik on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:55AM (#35326073)
Good riddance to what? Those developers have a job in this scenario, soon they will not.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by herbst on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:01AM (#35312202)
I have to agree. If I get hired somewhere and one day I get suddenly forced to use Mac or Windows to run the Adobe suite I would hate the situation but most people would argue that's just the Industrie standard
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by coldtea on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:00AM (#35311131)
It's like how Dropbox would never replace running SFTP and rsync or something to that effect...
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by nomilk on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:26AM (#35311304)
> This is exactly the type of conversation we need to have as a society.

Jobs have been disappearing at a high rate for at least a couple of generations now, and have steadily been replaced with new ones, often high paying ones.

We can't control which jobs are in high, low, and no demand, so we're best off swimming with the current, whichever way it flows. 1. Accept that professionals come and go. 2. Expect jobs to disappear every decade or so and plan accordingly. 3. Look forward to an awesome new job after your current one is made obsolete. That goes for all of us.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by thorncorona on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:56AM (#35311490)
> 1. Accept that professions come and go. 2. Expect jobs to disappear every decade or so and plan accordingly. 3. Look forward to an awesome new job after your current one is made obsolete. That goes for all of us.

What can we do? Hope to save enough to not go into more debt for a second degree?

Hope that second degree isn’t obsoleted either?

As AI becomes more advanced the minimum education and likely IQ required to even get a job that pays above minimum wage will increase.

What are we gonna do about the ever increasing N+1% of people who won’t be cost effective versus an AI?

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Turskarama on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:40AM (#35311726)
The solution is the same one we should have had from the start: take some of the responsibility from peoples careers off individuals and place it on society. As mentioned above, this has always been a problem it's just that now it's a problem for intellectual careers and not just laborers.

Education (and re-education) should be at least affordable if not completely free. Unemployment benefits should be enough to live on (if not well) and be freely available to anyone getting an education. If that is "too expensive" then limit it to specific educations which are currently in short supply.

And lastly, tax income from investments exactly the same as income from labour. This part is actually necessary because if automation is a future we actually want (and we should!) then this will increasingly become the _only_ form of income.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by peyton on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:49AM (#35311770)
You’re taking a central planner’s view of a decentralized system. You can’t say “here’s a problem; let’s just make it go away.”

We are going to print so much money. I don’t see how bumping up capital gains taxes are going to change anything.

People will plow extra help into speculative bubbles. Casino thesis.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:27AM (#35311973)
How about striding for one of the core societal values that make many advanced democraties (including the European nordics) so much better/happier than the US? It’s called Equality.

Insert strong progressive taxes, especially on wealth, and use it to fund a strong public sector, so _everyone_ has as access to basic goods and services for free, like education/health/transport/… .

I think you vastly underestimate how much money is the rich have siphoned from society, what do you think that printed money goes to? The change impact would be _massive_, suddenly people would have disposable money instead of crushing debts, nd actually stimulate the economy!

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jokethrowaway on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:42AM (#35312055)
Europe is unable to innovate exactly because of this.

All the disruptive people move to the US where they have a chance to get rich.

I worked in Europe my all life and I still have to find a company with people who give a damn about their job.

Without leeching off the states Europe would still be in a technological middle age.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by danjac on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:09AM (#35312242)
Um...Python, C++, Linux, Erlang, mobile phones (Nokia), Spotify, HTML...

Having worked for both European and US companies, I would say that a) innovation is mutual (we learn from each other) and talent/mediocrity are pretty much evenly distributed.

The US has a more "dynamic" economy in some sense - for example the VC ecosystem is far better funded - but is detrimental in others (Byzantine health care system deters would-be entrepreneurs).

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by roenxi on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:25AM (#35312317)
And yet if we take a snapshot literally right now:

Guido van Rossum - Microsoft Distinguished Engineer

Bjarne Stroustrup - professor of Computer Science at Columbia University (City of New York)

Linus Torvalds - Nationality American/US since 2010 (should I write GNU/American/US? Someone educate me).

Erlang - I don't know anything about Erlang so I've got nothing to say.

Nokia - brutally ejected from the market by the Americans, bought out and sepukku-ed under Microsoft leadership. Now phones may as well be an Asian technology. Oversaw the collapse of European leadership in the mobile space, to the point where it is going to be a case study in how to fail at innovation.

Spotify - Leading EU tech success story. Makes up 50% of the counterexamples, along with ASML. Not detectable as a serious tech company when compared to Google, Microsoft, Amazon, etc, etc.

HTML - I mean, we'd probably have managed without the Europeans on this one. Although useful, HTML isn't a very technical accomplishment. Anyone could invent this, including most CS undergrads.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:45AM (#35312416)
You are not wrong but also forgot the reasons…

Most stuff you cheer here is basically a few tech giants out of Silicon Valley. The science kickstart for all that came from a bunch of scientists (like Von neumann) you got when winning WW2 from europe. In a time when many potential competitors were still rebuilding from ruins.

This is over now, europeans tend to no longer go to the us but still produce excellent scientists, Asian countries catched up and both continents start to leave the US behind in most aspects as a desirable place to live, except for 2 things: Military power and billionaires.

Enjoy your 5 tech giants while they last, but also keep in mind that these are international now and draw from nonamerican intellectual power also.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Gordonjcp on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:02PM (#35315946)
> The science kickstart for all that came from a bunch of scientists (like Von neumann) you got when winning WW2 from europe.

Don't forget that the USians would all be speaking Japanese if it wasn't for the technology they "borrowed" from the British.

American "RADAR" was a laughable non-starter until they got shown how to make magnetrons by Randall and Boot.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by danjac on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:14AM (#35312557)
That's the point though. Van Rossum, Stroustrup and Torvalds made their name early on in their careers or even at college, while still in Europe. Sure, later on they emigrated to the US for the money, but that was on the back of their accomplishments.

Of course Nokia was eclipsed by foreign competition (mostly due to terrible management), but it was still innovative in its time. Just as US companies today face competition from Asia.

> Although useful, HTML isn't a very technical accomplishment. Anyone could invent this, including most CS undergrads.

Yes, but they didn't, did they? It's easy to look at something with 20/20 hindsight and say "anyone could have done this". Back in 1989 Berners-Lee had that insight.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by finikytou on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:00AM (#35312787)
this is right. but its mostly the proof that when you have the highest military spending in the western world you suddenly get things moving your way.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:14AM (#35312855)
Ever played some civilization (the game)? A mostly military focussed society can force others into unfavorable agreements, but while doing so other areas of society are lacking, amounting to huge problems later on when

a) blackmailing for some reason stops working

b) non-military related businesses are vanishing

c) increasing %share of your population has a degrading life quality

d) military costs become unsustainable for questionable ROI

… doubling down on military is a death spiral, especially when the funding money comes from slashing public services.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by namaria on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:16AM (#35312870)
"Europe is irrelevant" is such a weird take for a country built by Europeans, populated by Europeans, using European legal system, European language, etc etc.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by tekknik on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:19AM (#35325708)
Yet we don’t call ourselves European, perhaps because of a divorce in somewhat recent history.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ta1243 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:46AM (#35313439)
> HTML ... Anyone could invent this, including most CS undergrads.

Yes, For a Linux user, you can already build such a system yourself quite trivially by getting an FTP account, mounting it locally with curlftpfs, and then using SVN or CVS on the mounted filesystem. From Windows or Mac, this FTP account could be accessed through built-in software.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:21AM (#35312299)
That’s the total opposite most people around me (many immigrants from the US!) experience for the like last 2 decades actually, where have you been to that draws such a funny picture?

Europe has more % Entrepreneurs/Self-employed people than the US, lots of great companies even though not leading in the richest top5-ranking, and the work ethic is focussed during working hours instead of chitchatting/looking busy 12h+ per day.

Maybe you are also fooled by one critical thing: US companies are muuuuch better at marketing than European ones, outshining them so you tend to see exclusively US blogvertising and not where real innovation actually happens: all around the world now and the US actually falling behind.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by mkmk3 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:16AM (#35312568)
Could also be the advantage of a unified market helps US startups scale faster, maybe someone else can speak to that better. Its been influential where Ive worked, at least.

I also think at least US tech has significantly larger firms, but I dont think thats directly in line with societal good. Seems pretty fucking cancerous to me. Cant speak to industries outside of software though.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by danjac on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:25AM (#35312610)
Europe (mostly, at least) does have a unified market on paper, but not culturally, which makes marketing, localization etc. harder - a commercial that sells well to Germans might go down like a lead balloon in Spain.

The biggest advantage I've seen in the US has been the VC ecosystem. For all we deride VCs - and sometimes (particularly given events over the past few weeks) with very good reason, the money spigot is just much more generous in the US. Of course that will change in the new low interest rate economy, but that to me seems more the deciding factor than silly claims that Americans are somehow more innately "innovative" than Europeans.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:39AM (#35312685)
Money as a forcing function seems to come to an end, also I really am laughing right now how the US tries to suppress TikTok so it doesn’t overtake all these social media companies seemingly unable to compete :-)
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by tekknik on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:24AM (#35325761)
Your takeaway from the news around TikTok is the US is scared to compete?
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by danjac on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:21AM (#35326354)
Sensible legislation would be a level playing field - better privacy laws and regulations that apply to all players.

Instead you have hick senators asking if TikTok listens to your Wifi.

It may be about competition, but it's more likely grandstanding over the latest Red Scare.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by tilt_error on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:08AM (#35312831)
There is also a language factor here. 100 years ago, English was not the ‘lingua franca’ of the world, traveling in Europe you were better off with French, German or even Latin.

US marketing currently happen to be understood almost everywhere and native speakers of English have an advantage. A company does not necessarily need to execute better, but through effective communication they may be able to pretend they are.

There are lot of examples of ideas being picked up and reimplemented in the US, where the original was better but where the adaptation got better traction. The film industry is full of it.

Why should ingenuity not be evenly spread around the globe as well as hopes for a better future? The US represents one particular policy for wealth distribution that happen to work well for, in particular, VCs.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jacquesm on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:31AM (#35313319)
This is the key point. The single unified market with 300+ million people speaking the same language is the advantage that will make all the other ones more or less irrelevant.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:46AM (#35313442)
This factor is dimishing in importance with the absurdly increasing wealth gap.

Who cares about this big majority of people that can’t afford stuff?

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jacquesm on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:09AM (#35313604)
Sorry? You think the American economy is so broken that people 'can't afford stuff' anymore?

That there is an absurdly increasing wealth gap is a fact, but that doesn't mean that - for the time being - US households as consumers are still spending lots of money. And if you're in the B2B side of the market then it's even easier.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:22AM (#35313693)
I said dimishing, not gone already. A shrinking middle class is a real problem, leading to all kinds of issues, like reduced spending power - something that until recently was hidden by people going into debt massively… which now turns into even more problems soon.

All the while you can now do stuff in English all over europe increasingly well and legislations are getting normalized between countries, ignoring the odd brexit events here and there.

Ultimately what I am saying is: the factor exists and is significant, but getting lower for the US and other parts of the world are catching up rather quickly.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by tekknik on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:26AM (#35325784)
This comment can be read as you being happy for the demise of the US. It’s wonderful to see how many actual allies we have, who the minute we trip up they’re immediately on scene saying “i told you so” and ready to pick the bones.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:48PM (#35331436)
You are reading that wrong, and it even sounds you want to read it that way.

For sure Europeans are not keen to have to deal with china or Russia as the new world powers instead of the US. Really! But sometimes friends have to call out each other when things go in a bad direction.

But most Americans probably have to deal with the fact that they really aren’t the greatest country on earth any longer, except for military spending, gun deaths and prisoners. This realization is needed before one can really make steps into improving things again.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by megaman821 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:31AM (#35314816)
The wealth gap can increase and the median household can also have more discretionary income at the same time.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by pharmakom on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:59AM (#35312484)
If the US was half a competent at city planning as Europe it would be a no brainier for me. Unfortunately the US cities that are remotely walkable are also the most expressive. Phoenix / LA / Texas car dependency? HELL NO
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:11AM (#35312540)
You are right, still I always think of https://www.quora.com/Why-are-American-cities-essentially-al... this on the topic… :-)

Yes a walkable city is a massive life quality factor, but one can only „get it“ after experiencing it. Add good public transport on top of that and you can see why european/asian cities are so popular nowadays

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by walthamstow on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:26AM (#35312616)
London Oyster card introduced June 2003

NYC Omny card introduced October 2021

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by stavros on Sunday March 26, 2023 @11:47AM (#35315739)
I agree. What does it matter if healthcare costs an arm and a leg when you have drones delivering your weed?
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Gordonjcp on Sunday March 26, 2023 @11:59AM (#35315906)
All that companies do in the US is make money from other people's ideas. It's like a furtive and sneaky version of China.

There is no innovation in the US, nothing that would make me want to get up and go to work in the morning.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ChatGTP on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:54AM (#35312767)
I can’t describe how much better Europe, specifically Netherlands felt due to the social safety nets provided, and do not tell me that The Dutch aren’t hard working people, because they are.

People are so much more relaxed there. 99% of the concern about AI is because we’re living in a cut throat capitalistic society, if we knew that AI didn’t mean starving or losing our homes, we’d be way more relaxed about it, and imo we’d take out time a bit more and think about safety.

It’s the American race to the bottom attitude which is IMO no longer compatible with a highly automated world.

To start with, if the economy breaks, AI breaks. I saw Microsoft is winging because other search engines are stealing ChatGPT responses, get used to it M$, you own nothing.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:24AM (#35312910)
I cannot imagine being rich and be surrounded by homeless people, crime, drugs and the like.

The only „solution“ that still avoids realizing the problem is to try to escape into gated communities and shoot those plebs coming too close, ideally robots so no human is at fault conveniently. Or what useful is having that mercedes when most others want to steal or at least damage it?

I, for one, prefer to treat other humans as, well, humans. And by making everyone around me better off, my quality of life also improves.

For simple striking example, how about giving homeless people housing for free, so they can get their stuff together again? You can argue about how „they„ don’t deserve this all day long or simply do it and eliminate a problem https://world-habitat.org/news/our-blog/helsinki-is-still-le... - and even save a lot of money in the process as a society!

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ChatGTP on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:44AM (#35313029)
When you think about it, All wealth, every single bit of it has come from the same earth we’re all born on. This is the one truth which binds us all, including the AI, it’s too a child of this Earth, which means all people should have fairly equal access to at least basic protections the Earth provides us with. That’s all there really is to say about it.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jacquesm on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:27AM (#35313292)
Yes! The world where you end up in a random position with zero influence over the outcome if you could pick it before you were born is the one you should strive to create. That one has true equality.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ChatGTP on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:16AM (#35314691)
I like that idea, but I don't even think it has to be "perfect equality", just if you're not inclined to strive for more, or you lose your job to a computer, you don't have to go home and tell your family that there live is about to get much worse.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jrochkind1 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:47AM (#35314411)
> The only „solution“ that still avoids realizing the problem is to try to escape into gated communities and shoot those plebs coming too close, ideally robots so no human is at fault conveniently. Or what useful is having that mercedes when most others want to steal or at least damage it?

You say this like it shows how it's not a plausible outcome or shows the error of this path, but unfortunately that's exactly the American plan. Yes, that. Is what is literally already happening in USA. It is pretty nightmarish. The rich don't seem to think it's a problem, or don't seem to think there's any available option more desirable to them.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:37PM (#35317134)
The great thing about fascism (the extreme form of conservativsm when going more rightwing) is that it’s always a matter of in-group vs out-group, THE stereotype of thinking of the right-wingers.

Like, we have the true values and they are immoral. This thinking naturally Leads of subselects within the in-group that are even more true than the others… and it gets recursively smaller going towards fascism.

So ultimately you end up with a tiny in-group (the führers are now some billionaires), that still want to backstab the others secretly, who become paranoid over time, isolate themselves to minimize contact with these lesser human beings left behind… and loose touch with reality.

this is where it ends, usually, one way or another.

But the important part is that it actually DOESNT MATTER what they think - at some point people are frustrated enough and simply take it all away from them… the tipping point is when even public security staff (like police) is willing to let it happen - mostly to reduce suffering from family/friends/… .

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by tekknik on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:14AM (#35325664)
> The great thing about fascism (the extreme form of conservativsm when going more rightwing)

Stopped reading after you asserted that fascism is a right only attribute.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jrochkind1 on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:54AM (#35326053)
Self-righteousness, violence, or tendencies to authoritarianism can be found on both left and right. But fascism means a certain kind of far-right populist politics, not just these attributes in isolation.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:55PM (#35332446)
words do have definitions. every political direction can have authoritarian traits, still fascism is the extreme form of conservatism. So is communism as the extreme form of socialism, to compare it with left-wing words. The third political direction is liberalism that ultimately leads to anarchy (no state at all). Both American parties are in the area of liberal-conservative… as a European it simply looks like slightly rightwing (dems) and bordering fascist (reps).

Political classification is a complex topic though, it needs multiple dimensions to somehow get to something useful as a mental model.

I am „green“ first and foremost, and while the solarpunk or eco-socialist movements surely have socialist aspects, the „green“ main focus isn’t even covered in previous models. Green is neither left nor right nor liberal, it’s… future oriented? Dunno.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Applejinx on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:42AM (#35313020)
Yup. One of the things that's going to become starkly obvious is this: being in ownership of the money machine doesn't entitle you to power and compensation matching the output of that machine.

Feedback loops set in. If you need X amount of power and Y amount of resources to get it going, but it pays you enough for X times 2 power and Y times 5 resources, the first person to get the machine cranking becomes a human version of that AI paperclip maximizer.

And this has obviously already happened…

So now it's just a matter of, how obvious does this need to get before all the world is paperclips with one idiot sitting there, in his limited human perception, thinking he's won.

It really is Star Trek Future or bust. We don't have the luxury of steampunk attitudes towards power and societal structure anymore. Machine assistance and its multiplier effect are too big, and the runaway feedback effects are too obvious.

Do we have to wait until it's no longer Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos or Mark Zuckerberg, who are at least very aggressive ambitious idiots paying high prices for their goals, and instead it's some feckless Sam Bankman-Fried who ends up holding the bag? What's it going to take to illustrate the scale of the problem?

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jacquesm on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:25AM (#35313270)
Morally comparing order of magnitude I don't really see the difference between any of your examples. They're all structurally lacking in empathy and every one of those would sell their mother if it got them ahead in the game.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Applejinx on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:05AM (#35313582)
I don't disagree, but there's a profound difference in effort (most notably seen in Bezos vs. Bankman-Fried). This changes the result, and I think it also significantly changes the framing.

Bezos started in the days of Windows 3.1, and already was positioning himself near Microsoft as a force multiplier even though, in those days, he and other humans had to do vast amounts of work and thinking.

If the only requirement for dominating the world is adjacency to AI, the gameplan is still exactly the same but now the work and thinking is what you turn over to machines as a force multiplier. Without that, where is the justification for producing individuals who dominate the world? It becomes, not arbitrary, but purely a factor of who is adjacent to the AI at the right time.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jacquesm on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:10AM (#35313618)
There is always the French Revolution option... That's how historically we've dealt with too much inequality. It may well get to that.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:15AM (#35313644)
About time. I am willing to disgruntle some dozens of billionaires in exchange for massive QoL improvements for the billions of people.

Just waiting for enough momentum, will happily join/support.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Applejinx on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:07PM (#35316018)
You'd best have good implementation or they'll be using ChatGPT to aim your guillotines towards their business rivals, further consolidating their power.

This is the challenge. Anything we've got, people like this have tenfold, or a thousandfold, or a millionfold. As long as we're still running on 18th and 19th century societies.

Mind that you're not literally being steered by the billionaires to accomplish their ends, because that has been the history for the last decade or two. The only thing AI brings to the equation is, perhaps, making the process more obvious and providing a toy version of it that anyone can play with.

Before that, we played with the zeitgeist through marketing, big business… and politics. The only difference is that now we can use it to draw pictures or have it talk back to us like it was a person. The billionaires have been 'prompt engineers' for as long as I've been alive.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:34PM (#35317802)
The „aiming problem“ for me isn’t really an issue. The goal must be that no one can have too much power over others, no matter why/how. So yeah, the first victims might be tricked targets, but it doesn’t end there.

This might sound totally absurd when you hear it first, but I am fully in favor for randomized rulings in short/limited durations! Lottery style, a bit tweaked to have good entropy.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by revelio on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:20PM (#35316202)
It's how France historically tried to deal with too much inequality, except it was a complete failure and after staggering levels of evil, bloodshed and oppression they simply ended up with a new elite that had absolute power. No inequality was solved.

Other countries didn't go down that road and none regretted it.

Yet it's amazing how quickly some will still exploit any new technology or change to justify reaching for violence. Some never learn.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ransom1538 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:16AM (#35313654)
"I think you vastly underestimate how much money is the rich have siphoned from society"

I think you vastly OVER estimate the riches control. "U.S. Billionaire Wealth Surged by 70%, or $2.1 Trillion, During Pandemic. They Are Now Worth a Combined $5 Trillion". [1].

Just some napkin math, 5T / 165million people = 15k per person. So, if you go on a jihad to take all billionaire funds in the US, you would get a one time fee of 15k per person. I don't think that would last most households a few years. I don't understand the obsession with the wealthy. Wouldn't it just be easier and cheaper to just print money (which the fed has now figured out).

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by revelio on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:26PM (#35316268)
>> so _everyone_ has as access to basic goods and services for free, like education/health/transport/…

Access? UK tries this. High taxes and high borrowing to fund a large public sector. Result:

- People can't reliably see dentists or get doctor's appointments because the nationalized health system can't manage capacity properly.

- People can't reliably move around the country because the public sector transport workers are constantly going on strike, despite Tube drivers earning £56k/yr, only a bit less than that of a software engineer.

Putting the public sector in charge doesn't guarantee access to anything, it can easily lead to the opposite, which is why the USSR was constantly being wracked by bizarre shortages especially for anything that mattered to the general public like consumer goods. And now the UK suffers massive healthcare shortages. Same problem.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:34PM (#35316374)
> People can't reliably see dentists or get doctor's appointments because the nationalized health system can't manage capacity properly.

Not accurate in the slightest, this is due to the current administration deliberately funding the NHS less than it needs to function effectively.

> People can't reliably move around the country because the public sector transport workers are constantly going on strike

Only currently true because of similar reasons, it's not structurally true of that sector.

> Putting the public sector in charge ... And now the UK suffers massive healthcare shortages. Same problem.

Not accurate at all.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by anonyfox on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:23PM (#35316970)
This is a forced imageproblem try to get privatizations look better than state run, by defunding public sectors and claiming all kinds of weird stuff upto straight lies some people want to believe.

Don’t buy into that propaganda, look at the US how privatization ends up: still lots of tax money, additionally people can’t afford stuff, and a few assholes getting insanely rich in the process by siphoning money out of the society.

Try to ensure appropriate money is used to make the NHS effective again, including wages that allows people to live where they work (<1h commute).

Most communist shortages came from being cutoff from international trades with wealthy countries, and having to start from ruins or nothing at all btw. These are different problems, and you might learn in the process why capitalism is going to end soon. :-)

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by enjoy-your-stay on Monday March 27, 2023 @11:21AM (#35327861)
In the UK dentists are mostly private, it hasn't increased the quality or availability in the least.

Public transport is actually a fairly small part of the nation's transport, the UK is very car-centric so the strikes largely inconvenience commuters and drive even more people onto the roads, unless they can WFH.

Strikes are also a very recent phenomenon, just in the last 6 months or so, so this is quite a new thing driven by inflation.

Problems with the NHS are very much poor management by the last run of governments where there is a quite a growing suspicion they are deliberately trying to run down the NHS in order to make a case for to privatise it, following e.g. America's disastrous model.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by lwhi on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:06AM (#35312516)
Distribution of capital.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by steveshurley44 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:40AM (#35312046)
The other way this goes down is 90% of people wind up dead either out of listlessness and lack of purpose of because economic reality doesn't give a shit about what we should do. AI is going to be the biggest mistake humanity has ever made.

I don't think anything you said is an actual solution to the AI problem.

Automation is not and should not be viewed as an inherently good thing, it's a neutral thing. Its good in the same way economic efficiency is good, which is not always.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bitwize on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:14AM (#35311908)
Socialism. The answer is socialism.

AI is a philosopher's stone that transmutes labor into capital. This is as good as lead into gold for capitalists, but the rest of us are hosed.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bennysonething on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:48AM (#35312426)
How many times do we have to try socialism before we're convinced it doesn't work?

Or maybe you mean something like Nordic countries that are capitalist but tax more heavily and redistribute wealth more?

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by broken_thesis on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:18AM (#35312575)
That magical Nordic system is called "social democracy", it's of course rooted in socialism, and it's so old that one of the first dark memes amongst left-wing groups ("You killed Rose Luxemburg!) is about them.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:36AM (#35312983)
It's strange how those who say the Nordics aren't really socialist will be the first to dismiss their policies as socialist when they're suggested for the US.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bennysonething on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:41AM (#35313842)
They have free markets and businesses, doesn't sound like a socialist system to me.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by IX-103 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @11:19AM (#35315375)
You're thinking of Communism. Socialism doesn't imply government ownership and control of the economy.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bitwize on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:03PM (#35316738)
Neither does communism. Communism implies ownership and control of the economy by the people at large, but the presence of a state is, supposedly, a transitional phase.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by RGamma on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:42AM (#35313403)
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by antifa on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:00PM (#35321619)
OP didn't say "let's make an exact copy of USSR/China's homework" so your opinion on those countries is mostly irrelevant grandstanding.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by fxtentacle on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:15AM (#35311913)
> What are we gonna do about the ever increasing N+1% of people who won’t be cost effective versus an AI?

Fairly tax companies' profits.

And then you can afford to just feed 10% of society even if they don't contribute a thing. Also, free world-class education seems to do wonders in Europe ;)

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by fullsend on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:28AM (#35312334)
That is step 6. Step 1 is “fundamentally change how modern Capitalism considers making money the only moral good.” It will collapse first.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by megaman821 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:37AM (#35314880)
Low corporate tax is fine. Fairly tax the recipients of those profits. Warren Buffet should pay more on his share of Apple's profit than some retiree with Apple in their portfolio. A large corporate tax ends up being regressive.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by asah on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:25AM (#35311952)
What about jobs that take years of training? We need them done...
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jokethrowaway on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:48AM (#35312092)
> What are we gonna do about the ever increasing N+1% of people who won’t be cost effective versus an AI?

Their quality of life will increase because of all the cheap stuff we can make with ai and robots. They will coexist and compete with robots. Upward mobility should be better, given the access to advanced technology.

Worst case scenario, they can all band together outside of the advanced civilisation, grow their food and live a separate life.

There is no need to make high iq people to pay for low iq to live in a high iq society.

We're already seeing a divide of cities for rich people and cities for poor people. It will just be more pronounced.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Epa095 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:28AM (#35312339)
> Their quality of life will increase because of all the cheap stuff we can make with ai and robots.

Ahh, the old "modern poor people are better off than medevial kings since we have microwaves and supercomputers in our pockets". No matter that they are all stressed, living paycheck to paycheck and a single (treatable) disease from crippling debt.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by MichaelZuo on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:26AM (#35314196)
> single (treatable) disease from crippling debt.

This sounds a lot better than being a single (treatable) disease from guaranteed death?

Which many, many, historical monarchs experienced.

I'm very certain at least some fraction of such monarchs would have gladly taken the opportunity to swap places if they had known in advance.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by antifa on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:03PM (#35321635)
> This sounds a lot better than

You can justify pretty much any horrible thing with "sounds better than a torment nexus"

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by MichaelZuo on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:21PM (#35331914)
What's a 'torment nexus'?
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:38AM (#35312999)
By the same logic there's also no need for high IQ AIs to pay for low IQ humans.

It's all fun and games until suddenly you're the one on the outside, wondering how you get there.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by OOPMan on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:15AM (#35325672)
Right...we make stuff cheaper than ever before...but because all these people don't have jobs they can't afford it anyway...
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by dukeofdoom on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:56AM (#35311492)
Endless amount of things that need improving.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by borissk on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:39AM (#35311712)
The things that are easy to improve have been improved long ago.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by dukeofdoom on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:45AM (#35311750)
Not really, have a closer look at anything outside. The Sun and rain and weather constantly erode the condition of human creations.

Try fixing some roads and bridges to start with. They're in terrible shape in most of the US. Any city could probably employ 10 times as many gardeners to take care of the plants and build nicer things.

Elderly need taking care of, and young people teaching. Houses need cleaning. Shoes need shinning. Endless list really.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by borissk on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:54AM (#35311801)
What are you talking about?

Stop the traffic on a road to fix it without local administration permission? Do you think getting such permission is easy? How are you going to pay for the materials to do the repairs? Do you think it's easy to get a job as a gardener?

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bbor on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:43AM (#35312066)
I think you need to read other’s thoughts more charitably. I doubt he was suggesting bored artists and call center workers grab a hard hat and pick a road. The point is that AI makes it easier for humans to do work, and there’s an endless amount of work we as a society want done. Avandon capitalist frameworks of wages/capital/“deserved poverty” for a minute, and just consider a group of humans and a pile of tasks that need to be done.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by danjac on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:41AM (#35311729)
3. Look forward to an awesome new job after your current one is made obsolete.

You do realize that "awesome new job" will require years of training and experience?

Enjoy working at the Amazon Fulfilment Center in the meantime (until of course that's automated too).

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by 7speter on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:21AM (#35312592)
Don’t forget all the people who laugh in your face and tell you you don’t actually know your newly learned skills, and reduces you to a bartender fraudulently entering their field.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Dma54rhs on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:12AM (#35313178)
Its been like that forever. Factory workers had to adapt when the jobs went to Asia. I don't see how comfortable office guys should get any other treatment.

It used to be learn to code then maybe learn to weld or plumb it something that is harder to automate away.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jstummbillig on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:29AM (#35311987)
While fundamentally true, this comment is astonishingly tone deaf in light of the entirely unprecedented amplitude and timescale at which the shift is happening this time.

"Just prepare" does not work when years become days.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by onion2k on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:14AM (#35312558)
Jobs have been disappearing at a high rate for at least a couple of generations now, and have steadily been replaced with new ones, often high paying ones.

In the past jobs took a while to disappear. People had time to retrain, to change career, and to come to terms with things ending. The difference now is that it seems like you could be in a high demand role today, and the whole industry you work in might not exist any more in a few years time.

The suggestion that this is just like it was in the past ignores that massive difference.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:20AM (#35312892)
I suspect this comment won't age well.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jzb on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:31AM (#35313325)
This is what I would call toxic positivity. Maybe with a side of survivor bias. Lots of people don’t get awesome new jobs. They struggle, they fall out of the workforce.

People don’t want to “accept” that’s some thing they have trained to do and gotten good at is going to just go away. It’s a reality, but it’s also pretty fucking awful.

My father used to make a very good living doing sign painting until the late 80s when vinyl signs became cheap and fast to make. They weren’t as good, they didn’t last as long, but they were cheap. And so his good living went away, and he spent the rest of his working years doing jobs that were not well paid. (The full story is more complicated, but the larger point stands.)

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by deepsquirrelnet on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:29AM (#35314804)
When faced with the reality of capitalism, maybe toxic positivity is all there is. I’d like to think that there’s a way that we could plan our society better, and evaluate tech against social costs, but the reality is that in the US we have never done that.

I disagree with your point. The problem is that people will gladly accept changes brought by technology up until the point that it affects them personally. The people that bought a cheap vinyl sign were not forced to purchase them, and yet they did.

This is not a problem with tech, it’s a problem with us. If you like liberty, then you know the choice that people will make, and that’s what is terrifying.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by flippinburgers on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:34AM (#35314847)
Naively positive. People whose jobs are outpaced by technology end up working "dead end" jobs that nobody else wants or fall into poverty if they are not lucky enough to be able to retire. Turning around in your 40s, 50s, or 60s to find new employment in a new field? This is exceptionally challenging.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by tekknik on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:36AM (#35325873)
> Jobs have been disappearing at a high rate for at least a couple of generations now, and have steadily been replaced with new ones, often high paying ones.

You don’t feel like you should quote some data for this claim?

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by HervalFreire on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:33AM (#35311344)
>Well, seems like this argument is aging badly.

This is a nice way of putting it. It just shows how people have a tendency to deny a reality that may replace everything they stand for.

What you will see as AI continues to get better along the obvious trendline is these "denial" arguments become more and more specific. First the AI will "never" replace jobs, then it will "never" replace specific jobs involving "programming skills" or "skills related to what I do" until eventually when the reality of it all is too all encompassing the arguments will evolve into attacks at AI for being "low quality" or something along those lines.

But if AI progresses to the point where the quality of the output becomes undeniably superior to human output the "denial" arguments will inevitably shift to the REAL argument. The heart of it all. What is the purpose of being alive if AI is doing everything? Should we ban it for the sake of the economy for purpose?

These arguments of course only occur based off the assumption that the technology will progress so quickly that the repercussions hitting everyone like a freight train. If the progression slows down enough then there won't be much opposition. Only acceptance as it slowly assimilates into our society without people noticing the change.

If you in your heart are one of these people who has no worry about AI taking over jobs because AI is simply too "stupid" perhaps consider the fact that my description above fits you. Are your arguments evolving along a similar trendline? If so, consider shifting your perspective a bit.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by elforce002 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:54AM (#35313084)
100x this. I think will see something like France but on a global scale.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by juvvel on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:09AM (#35314041)
Comments like this always read as "we can already extrapolate that everything we do will be done better by a machine soon". Pushing back against this argument isn't just ignorance or avoidance of change. It just asks the relevant question of whether we can be so sure that AI does everything "better". But how dare we challenge the hubris of tech bros, right?
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by HervalFreire on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:35AM (#35314854)
Naw there are many possible futures. There is nothing saying the trendline is absolute. However...

The future predicted via extrapolation of a trendline is unfortunately more probable and more realistic then a future predicted via mistrust of AI.

Artists have already formed lawsuits against companies that own LLMs, this one in the article already involves an artist complaining about his job being more or less replaced.

You have to be next level delusional not to consider the extrapolation to programming.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by juvvel on Sunday March 26, 2023 @11:11AM (#35315249)
Oh, I do believe programming as a profession is at risk and will change a lot, if not rendered obsolete. What I'm talking about is this idea of "just get used to the fact that there is no human skill that won't be replicable by AI in 2-10 years". It's a very bleak view of the future and our own biological complexity. We need to remember that we are the ones inventing the AI in the first place. We are limited by our imperfect ability to understand ourselves. It will get better, sure, there will be emergent properties, but there's no need to reject the inherent value of humanity even if it happens to produce less economically viable output.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by HervalFreire on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:16PM (#35317595)
Not everything will be replaced, but you can extrapolate that much of what we do will be replaced.

The thing that is harder to replace is the versatility of the human form. Manual labor can't fully be replaced because robotics have yet to catch up.

>there's no need to reject the inherent value of humanity

There's no fundamental rejection here. Capitalism simply selects the most efficient methodology. If humans arent the most efficient methodology for a given task then capitalism eliminated that methodology. That's the logical extrapolation. You subjective opinions on humanities worth is irrelevant to the most likely outcome.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by juvvel on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:08PM (#35322081)
Capitalism and its value system is subjective, too. It's not set in stone. I believe we can still steer away from profit as the sole driver of, well, everything, if we want to.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by HervalFreire on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:24AM (#35325766)
It's possible. But unlikely.

Historically speaking, from crypto to AI, the market constantly evolves towards the next most profitable thing.

Only regulatory systems like the government has the tendency to temper such things (see the Fed and rising interest rates). However do note that capitalist entities have infiltrated the government and have huge sway over it's regulatory policies meaning that anti-business regulatory policies are unlikely to occur.

All of this just means that my conclusions are most likely going to play out. Barring some event that will cause intense negative public reaction.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by juvvel on Monday March 27, 2023 @12:58PM (#35329121)
> However do note that capitalist entities have infiltrated the government and have huge sway over it's regulatory policies meaning that anti-business regulatory policies are unlikely to occur.

Maybe this is the case in the US, the EU is known for being much more strict in its regulations, which is often ridiculed by the rest of the world. Those same people are going to hope for regulations once we see the effects of the current Wild West that is AI.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by HervalFreire on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:34PM (#35332111)
Agreed. The EU is ridiculed but it's also one of the happiest places to live. The relationship between the US and EU is almost parasitic with the EU simply feeding off most of the business innovation coming from the US.

I don't think the world needs this much constant innovation. Additionally the innovation itself can be disruptive. The US will doggedly pursue profits even if those profits involve technology that can cause the US to eat itself. If AI replaces all jobs and nobody has any money to buy stuff who will the companies sell shit too?

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by rebuilder on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:45AM (#35311415)
I still would argue against AI being able to do art better.

There’s a line of thought that art is specifically meaningful because it’s humans thinking about things, but let’s leave that aside for now.

Generative models are revealing how many jobs in e.g. entertainment are essentially mechanical, from management’s POV. So far, they’ve just happened to require an artist’s education to do well. Now, the craft part is going out the window, and artistic creativity, if it was ever required, is being pushed out of production roles.

This is going to change the type of person who works in entertainment. I expect, while by technical metrics we will probably see quality stay the same or even improve while output increases, we’re also going to see a kind of McDonaldsification of entertainment, even more than we already see, because we’re pushing creative people out of the industry.

TL;DR: Process matters. Art is notoriously difficult to manage and predict what will or will not be successful , in large part because it’s a classic greater-than-the-sum-of-its-parts thing. Devalue the process, devalue the end product.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Zetobal on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:52AM (#35312445)
He is not an artist he is an operator.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by karmasimida on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:37AM (#35312679)
It is NOT taking artists job in OP though.

What happens is that it changes the job into something different.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by s__s on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:48PM (#35317983)
Yes, it changed his job in to something a 6th grader could do with little to no training. In other words, it’s now a meaningless, low-value job that won’t pay well.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by tekknik on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:03AM (#35326162)
There’s too many people in this thread claiming this. This artist did not lose their job, correct. This artist is currently underemployed. Most of us can predict the rate of AI improvement, and realize soon his job will be entirely replaced once they can bridge the gap.

My wife and I were recently talking about hiring some artists to do some work for us. However with generative AI, we decided to instead have her do the work using the AI tools instead. The result, less artists hired.

This is how it’s going to be from now on. The only hope is if humans find more opportunity with this power.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by nec4b on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:18AM (#35313667)
>> I remember reading lots of people here in HN saying it would never take the jobs of artists. Well, seems like this argument is aging badly.

And yet nobody lost his job. He wasn't fired. He is unhappy because automation equalized the playing field and mediocre artists became good enough with the right tools. The technology enabled him and other artists to be more productive. It feels similar to the best ditch digger getting angry at the invention of excavator, because he doesn't stand out anymore.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by cyrialize on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:32AM (#35313771)
He's also angry because now his job has completely changed. He enjoyed spending his time making 3D models. Now that expectations have shifted because of these tools he has to use them. He went from making things from scratch to writing prompts instead.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ModernMech on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:04PM (#35315974)
Okay so? Back in the day people trained up for 2D art, and then suddenly not long after 3D graphics came around. Imagine working on Final Fantasy 6, and then being told you now have to do 3D art for Final Fantasy 7.

Amazingly, despite 3D graphics, in the year 2023 there are now more employed 2D pixel artists than there were in the 90s. They are still making new games for the NES!

So while I’m sad for this person’s loss of love for their current job, I’m sure they will be able to find work.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by cyrialize on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:11PM (#35319677)
I understand where you're coming from. I don't think this person really fears losing their job. It's more that their current job, and probably all future ones, will be done in a way that they dislike. That is a valid complaint.

There are probably some employed pixel artists that liked creating things pixel by pixel and are disliking the fact that their job is radically changing since these tools create an expectation for faster output.

I apologize if I came across arguing with anyone.

I just wanted to call out that to me - it doesn't seem like this person thinks they are going to lose their job. They did their job in a way that they really enjoyed. That's changed.

Does that happen all the time in other industries? Yes. Is it valid to point out that this has happened before? Yes. Will this person be able to find work? Yes.

This person is just expressing their frustration. With the way all these tools are progressing, I imagine we are going to be seeing posts like these more in the future.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Laaas on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:26AM (#35313721)
They could fire him and only keep the other artist though. It's likely they have more capacity now than needed, which if they halve, they can spend more money on a good developer.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Hoasi on Monday March 27, 2023 @06:59PM (#35333998)
> When DALL-E 2 was released, I remember reading lots of people here in HN saying it would never take the jobs of artists. Well, seems like this argument is aging badly.

And yet, the more I play with these image models, the less I worry they might replace all artists.

Granted, it will commoditize some skills, such as photo bashing, mockups, and visual exploration.

It is a "creative" tool in a way, in the sense that a prompt can give unexpected results, such as associations that were uncalled for. But as much as you can replace higher-paid video game concept artists, you'll still need people to operate these text-to-image tools. We are past the initial discovery days, where all the results look incredible, and even the public will grow more discerning. Artists can't ignore these tools. As tools for the individual, they can be a lever. As a full-time, corporate job? Not so much. That is to say, as a job, this is not different from many other bullshit jobs. Prompting all day long is as fun as filling boxes in Excel. That will probably attract a new crowd of less specialized workers, and artists will have no choice but to adapt.

Digital artists could find new ways of expression using traditional art (a luxury), diversify, and engage in content creation. There are many alleys to confront pessimism, despair, and the fear of becoming obsolete.

Artists thrive in adversity and uncertain situations because they are problem-solvers first. Imagination is their job.

Photography made portrait artists redundant, but it didn't eliminate artists. It will change the nature of an artist's job and kill some of the joy in some cases, but it will trigger creative responses, too.