News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by rafaelero on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:03AM (#35310766)
> AI won't take a thought workers job.

I don't understand how you can hold this position considering not only where we are but also the rate of progress in AI. It has been taking thought workers job and it will increasingly do so in the future until the surplus cognitive workers offer is just so minimal that it's not worth to automate it.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by kodah on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:07AM (#35310794)
What jobs have been totally replaced thus far?
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jay_kyburz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:48AM (#35311058)
Companies are slow to move on things, but I think "video game concept artist" is done. An art director can now sit down in front of Midjourny and pump out years and years of a concept artists work in just an afternoon.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by whateveracct on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:54AM (#35311095)
This feels like a comment written by someone without practical experience with concept art (creator or consumer) - correct me if I'm wrong though!

Like personally, I think I will still draw concept art instead of asking a GAN. Feels like that greases my creative wheels more. Just me though.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by coldtea on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:07AM (#35311174)
Whether you have experience or not, game companies already use AI for concept art.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by lunfard000 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:18AM (#35311607)
not only art, Obsidian is using already for voices[0]. The future is here.

0:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YajBa5PO1Hk

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jay_kyburz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:23AM (#35311284)
You are wrong, I have worked for many years as an artists and level builder in video games. Bioshock is the most famous game, and Void Bastards the most recent.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by spoiler on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:33AM (#35312014)
Could you instead use AI to reduce drudgery in your work, or to iterate faster between ideas until you settle on a final peace? What if you have something in mind that is hard to prompt for, or the tool just refuses to generate what you had in mind? I would try to lean into it as a tool to speed up some of the tedium, instead of fear it, if possible
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jay_kyburz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:41AM (#35312051)
I'm not in the camp that fears it, I think it will be an awesome tool and I can't wait to use it in my next game. I've been playing with Midjourny a lot already, but have been watching Stable Diffusion and the control net stuff closely as well.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by lozenge on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:33PM (#35317786)
I could see drawing a couple of characters and getting an AI to extend the style to more. Especially if you can give it feedback. But the idea that you could get years of concepts in an afternoon is silly. That's like saying I can generate hundreds of business plans using ChatGPT.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bruce511 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:37AM (#35311703)
When electric sound amplification came along, it put most professional musicians out of business. Instead of an orchestra all you need is a band of 3 or 4.

Making music expanded though. In the sense that more people played, there was more variety, and indeed more professional musicians today than 100 years ago. (the bar for entry is also lower, and most are permantly broke - take that as you will.)

Some orchestras still exist. But they're pretty rare.

So yes, alot of job descriptions and job titles will change. Making indie games just got a lot easier. But where you see loss, many others see opportunity.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by FranzFerdiNaN on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:34AM (#35312021)
It’s nice that the barrier became lower but people still need jobs to afford food and rent. I doubt that UBI will come anytime soon so less jobs that pay enough is a serious issue.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by OOPMan on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:51PM (#35317302)
Agreed. It feels like a lot of the people burning hard on AI seem to think that when the jobs are gone some benevolent benefactors (who exactly?) will decide to institute UBI for all because....why exactly?

It seems much more likely to me that all that will happen is there will be a lot more poor people...

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by bruce511 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:06PM (#35318243)
it's not like "all jobs" will be taken by Robots and AI. That will be of little consolation though to modern-day buggy-whip-makers.

Jobs are a way of "adding value" to society. But over the last 120 years we've figured out how to add a Lot of value with minimal people. 95% of people used to grow food. Now it's like 2%.

People moved to factories, where today robots and automation rule. People moved to hi-tech, and leveraged that tech. Now AI is moving into that space.

In truth, we now create way, way, more value than we need. We need to figure out how to distribute the value created. Somehow I doubt that the US will be the leader here; things like UBI are too far against the "American Way".

When we see UBI emerge, in whatever form that takes (basically basic human needs met) it'll likely come from places that value community over individuality. Places that rate their success by their poor, not their rich. Places that celebrate achievements which don't require the exploitation of others.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jay_kyburz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:51AM (#35312115)
I was just pointing out one job that I could see in my industry. I for one welcome the wealth of interesting new indies games with great looking graphics we'll soon see.

People will be able to take more risks and do more interesting projects. It will be awesome.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by omnimus on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:24AM (#35312312)
Amplification allowed for more original creation.

AI is opposite of human creation. Its definition of anti-creation. Its a spell that locks visual culture to year 2025. And it can only do this by illeagly stealing all the human work.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by AJ007 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:50AM (#35313895)
If we can steal all human work (images) and compress it down to 2gb, then we should be questioning what artists have really been creating.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ericd on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:01AM (#35314545)
You don’t think we can make it come up with variations, and use people’s feedback on what’s interesting to figure out what new avenues are promising? It’s not that hard to do this sort of exploration, it’s not limited to just mimicking what it’s seen. If anything, I think we’ll see an increase in the pace of evolution of art as it becomes economical for normal people to get personalized art.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by 1attice on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:30PM (#35316318)
> Its a spell that locks visual culture to year 2025.

What a fantastic way of putting it.

I'm constantly reminded of _the Matrix_, with Agent Smith telling Neo that 1999 (the apparent year inside the Matrix) was the peak of human civilization.

Our own Matrix will use the year 2025.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by coldtea on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:06AM (#35311168)
First, of all, why it has to be "totally replaced"? It's enough for positions to be dramatically reduced, and most such "though workers" tasks getting done automatically, e.g. under the final supervision of much fewer people.

Second, why it has to be "thus far"? If it happens in 1 or 5 or 10 years does it disqualify it?

Because above you claimed it will "never take thought workers' jobs". Suddenly the goalposts moved so that it has to have happened "totally" and "thus far" to qualify as taking their jobs?

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by CommanderData on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:58AM (#35311508)
I'm witnessing engineers on my team and myself saving a lot of time in development and in operations (scripting).

I have no doubt in my mind it is reducing the need for more engineers and has probably already contributed to a reduction of them and I think it's just getting started.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by saurik on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:49AM (#35312432)
Compilers and high-level languages assuredly reduced the number of engineers needed, right? No: we just started making much more complicated things and the basic level of "this isn't even a serviceable solution" has gone up so high that if you sat around and wrote a trivial program designed to be used over a teletype--which is much much easier as you can do it in C instead of assembly--you'd lose in the market to your competitors who are willing to put in the effort to build a modern fancy reactive single-page whatever's-hot-now web app.

The reality is that companies are going to continue allocating a similar percentage of their budget to tech that they were before, and what we DO might change a ton; but, frankly, I've been doing this now for 30 years, and the stuff I used to do 30 years ago already often isn't a thing anymore. Every time my job gets easier, the expectations for the products I architect also increase, because we're all in a rat race attempting to compete for the same customers to defend our margins.

Hell: I remember when the first step to deploying a new service--even if you were a company that only had a handful of people--was to attempt to predict how much capacity you needed and then buy a ton of parts so you'd be able to sit around and build machines for your server room to run your new product. I was involved in a project back in like, 1998/1999, for a company with all of maybe five people, and someone's job was just sitting around building the server room... that specific task is now a few lines of YAML configuration and a couple of accounts (AWS and Twilio, as we had to have custom T1 lines brought in not for data but for phone service to hook up to the Dialogic hardware we needed to simulate phone lines).

The concept of cloud-computing entirely changed that part of the business--having a small handful of companies manage all the servers at scale and run numerous jobs on shared hardware, in some sense reducing the cost to the point where you can both outsource this and pay less--to the point where doing that almost sounds insane; and yet, I'm sure there are more people getting paid more to deploy and manage ever more virtualized servers in the cloud than there ever were people (including me!) literally screwing around with screwdrivers in the ubiquitous server rooms.

I'll admit that I honestly kind of enjoyed doing that work?... and yet, I also was quite happy to never have to do it ever again. I'll never forget the day I took the first real-world server I was in charge of and just like, uploaded it to 1&1 where I had an early software-based hypervisor-like stack I was experimenting with (UML, aka User Mode Linux, which is no longer something people bother with due to the advent of Xen/KVM/etc.); it just worked and I was like "omg I'm never building another server again, am I? that was it: it's over". (It then turned out that I did build another complex hardware solution in 2016 to start doing work with GPUs, but there was only a small window of time there before cloud services caught up.)

So like, sure: at some point the AI is going to entirely replace what we do--not the specific frustrating coding tasks we do today, but the entire concept of our jobs--but, the issue at that point isn't going to be me figuring out what I'm going to do next to make ends meat... it is going to be that I'm not a serviceable warrior in the war against the machines as the world devolves into some kind of Terminator-inspired hellscape; because, if you can manage to do my job in its totality, then you frankly can also do the job of everyone who has ever hired me and you can do the job of every investor who has ever given us money to do those things... we are all obsolete and, if AI actually gets as good as so many people here fear it will, at best we all become pets :(.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by chimprich on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:07AM (#35312820)
Would being the pet of an AI-run civilisation be so bad though? Iain M Banks's Culture novels explore basically this concept, and his vision of utopia is quite appealing.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by saurik on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:03AM (#35313132)
I honestly don't like how we treat our pets (and especially so here in the United States). I keep imagining that the situation will end up feeling--at best--like this episode of (The New) Outer Limits. :(

https://theouterlimits.fandom.com/wiki/The_Human_Operators

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ben_w on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:23AM (#35314158)
Is Jernau Morat Gurgeh the Player of Games, or a mere pawn moved by Minds beyond his comprehension?

The Culture appeals to me, but there are literary critics who find even The Culture, let alone the grander environment beyond it, to be dystopian. And I definitely don't want to wake up dead with my mind in one of Joiler Veppers' simulations.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by gaganyaan on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:23PM (#35316977)
He's definitely a pawn. But I'd sign up for being kept around as a pawn/pet/whatever in an instant if it meant living in the Culture.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by coldtea on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:27PM (#35317723)
>Would being the pet of an AI-run civilisation be so bad though?

Only for people with dignity. So, in general, no!

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by atchoo on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:26AM (#35314195)
> companies are going to continue allocating a similar percentage of their budget to tech

I think your argument requires a paradigm shift like teletype -> web to soak up the new productivity. I don't think we have that today. For how many purposes have we reached peak consumer software capability? i.e. global reach to publish text, images, video and make purchases is the entire use case of most media and commerce businesses. If you gave every company double the amount of dev resources tomorrow, do they even have anything to build? Even for those with deep feature roadmaps, how much of that stuff is just nice-to-have things that won't move the revenue needle anyway?

Maybe we will get that new platform from AR or direct brain interfaces... but without it, the situation looks more like how the human role of "computer" just vanished... sure we then got programmers, but they weren't necessarily the same people.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by kodah on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:09PM (#35318998)
> Suddenly the goalposts moved so that it has to have happened "totally" and "thus far" to qualify as taking their jobs?

I was asking a question. I don't think anyone can confidently quantify the effects of AI at this point so I was seeing if I was missing something. What I said is just some word vomit about what I'm seeing on the ground as an engineer. I'm happy to accept a refutation as we gather more concrete data. The reason I asked the question the way I did is because as I stated there is no doubt AI will impact our jobs, but I'm understandably more concerned about less jobs because of AI. I also have the experience of writing a lot of automation, and hearing this same style of rhetoric when we started doing that heavily. For all the scare around automation, it did end fact end up creating more jobs and typically made lives easier.

Jumping to "shifting goalposts" over that is pretty trash conversation.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by fxtentacle on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:20AM (#35311934)
Didn't all major companies do mass-firings recently?

What do you expect will happen if an entry-level software engineer becomes 2x as productive? You need 2x less, so you fire half the team.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by spoiler on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:29AM (#35311990)
A smart company will realise it's better to be 2x productive for the same money than to be at the same productivity for half the money.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jokethrowaway on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:53AM (#35312126)
Wrong, there's just so much a company can dedicate itself too, otherwise you'll start doing little useless experiments that go nowhere like google
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by spoiler on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:38AM (#35312388)
I think Google has a weird pathological case maybe. So, I'm not sure I would use them as a forecast.

I think R&D is good in any company. Sure, the nature of R&D is that most of it is failure; that's just the way it is.

AI makes the R&D iteration shorter and cheaper, IMO. The more you try, the more likely you're to succeed (aside: I should listen to my own advice sometimes lol).

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by vasco on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:43AM (#35312064)
If performing a job is even just 10% faster, you can fire 1 person out of a team of 10 (or need to hire in the first place). This should be obvious.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by raincole on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:53AM (#35312131)
I'm sure most programmers work more than 10% faster with syntax highlighting and autocomplete. But no one says IDE replaced humans' jobs.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:11AM (#35313620)
They did, and so did high-level languages, and not to mention the entire profession is first and foremost about automating other peoples' jobs away. Thing is, nobody is really tracking how improvements for software developers are replacing people, because this only manifests at slowing the absurdly high growth rate in this industry.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by vasco on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:15PM (#35316138)
Yes they did, what are you thinking would have happened if all we had was assembly? To build any meaningful software you'd need armies of people and it'd take way longer and it wouldn't be as good.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by jayd16 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:50AM (#35312104)
First, this argument applies to everything from WFH adding efficiency to computers themselves being faster than ink and paper.

But that's not how the economics works out. The business can simply choose to sell 10% more content.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by wwweston on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:12PM (#35322112)
At some point, you saturate the market for whatever’s being produced and then prices drop and you have diminishing marginal returns for production so the economics of making more doesn’t make sense.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by cthalupa on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:26AM (#35314198)
You could say this about every efficiency improvement in any field ever. If everything still had to be written in C and we didn't have fancy IDEs and access to a vast ocean of libraries, cheap services doing the work for you and returning results over an API, etc., we would need many many many times over more software devs to have everything software based in the world that we do now.

But do you think if none of these things had changed, and everyone was still doing nearly everything themselves, with a limited subset of libraries in use, writing everything in C, we would have all of these applications, services, pieces of software, etc? That all of these viable businesses employing people would still exist?

I doubt it. And like the poster from the reddit link, a lot of software devs truly did enjoy a lot of that work that they did. I've talked to plenty of greybeards who will wax nostalgic over spending months writing things that a pip install and import solve in a few seconds now.

If we double the efficiency of a team, do we fire half of them? Or do we double the amount of products we're releasing? Or double the amount of features for one product?

I think we have far more software devs today because of the advent of higher level languages, large library selections available with package managers, feature-rich IDEs, etc.

Is this always the case, for every industry? Obviously not. There are a lot fewer people making furniture by hand today than there was before automated manufacturing, and any individual only needs so many chairs. But there is, of course, still demand for hand built furniture using traditional joinery techniques.

"Art" is a big space, and I don't think that the impact will be universal across every part of it. For games in specific, I think we'll see something more like the software development side - people will make more and more unique assets vs. reusing them, we'll see the artwork be more detailed and "populated" in general. We'll see more and more smaller studios putting out work with higher quality and more art assets. Same thing for other media-related positions. And the people who are reliably selling prints for people to hang on walls, collect, etc., I think are also likely quite safe. I think people relying on twitter/instagram/etc. commissions to draw people's D&D characters or anime waifu are likely in a lot of trouble.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by vasco on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:14PM (#35316125)
Do you think it takes as many people to build whatever software you want today vs in the 80s? I agree more software can be built with the improvements, but per unit of functionality, way less people are needed, or they can do it much faster, which in both cases mean you spend less of your revenue on labor, which means "less jobs".
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by cthalupa on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:12PM (#35317546)
>which in both cases mean you spend less of your revenue on labor, which means "less jobs".

You can't view things in the void like this, though. Reducing the overall cost of doing something makes it viable for more businesses, which means more jobs. We have more jobs in software development overall now because of how much more productive it is today, which opens up so many more viable use cases for it. We have more CG artists for movies, games, etc. now in large part because more efficient workflows and more powerful software have increased productivity.

Will it be the same thing with generative AI? I think so, at least for the foreseeable future.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Zvez on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:20PM (#35317644)
their point is simple: during the last 20-30 years we had efficiency improvements by orders of magnitude. Still we didn't have developers jobs reduction in any way. We evolved into doing more and more high-level and high-scale jobs. So no, -10% of time needed to build the same unit of functionality won't lead to -10% reduction of workforce. It will change the scope of said workforce.
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by happytiger on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:48AM (#35312428)
I have seen at least one outsourced programming job slow down to the point where it’s effectively no longer outsourced. Previously there were two engineers working, and now there is one as the work isn’t needed anymore.

That in a very real way is a replaced job.

The remaining job is running large scale data loading for a startup and really now is just eyeballs to make sure errors are caught. No longer requires much skill either.

I think some degree of low end engineering work in the outsourcing world is at risk.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by code_witch_sam on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:50AM (#35312748)
paralegals seem like they're very much at risk
Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by ericathegreat on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:24PM (#35320827)
There are still professional, high quality hand knitters in the world.

Of course, having people hand knit garments used to be the only way to get a knitted garment at all.

Then we invented industrial knitting machines, and those hand knitters found their roles had changed. Instead of knitting a whole garment, they would be closing up the toe on the socks, or doing finishing work on a sweater. Of course, companies didn't need anywhere near as many knitters under this system, so a huge proportion of them lost their jobs.

Then the knitting machines got better. They could close the toes on the socks themselves, could do most of the finishing work automatically. Some of the remaining knitters became industrial knitting support workers, but most of the actual knitting jobs dried up.

But there are still professional, commercial hand knitters, even today! They test hand knitting patterns for the hobby market. Make the samples up for photographing, and make sure that all the sizes come out right.

They number... Dozens? Maybe? And most of them treat it as a side gig, despite being the absolute pinnacle of hand knitting talent, since it pays terribly.

A job doesn't have to have been totally replaced to be effectively replaced. As we find ways to hand over larger and larger pieces of the work to an automated system, the number of real roles in that field diminishes, until it eventually becomes infeasible as a career choice.

This is what a lot these digital content creation jobs are heading. Gradual obsolescence.

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by Pandabob on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:23AM (#35314742)
Lots of reasonable people seem to hold this view. Sam Altman himself mentioned believing this in the Lex Friedman podcast.

Here are tweets from famous HN users Simon Willison[0] and Patrick Mckenzie[1] endorsing the viewpoint as well.

[0]: https://twitter.com/simonw/status/1639692312585572352

[1]: https://twitter.com/patio11/status/1639787193580519424

Re:I lost everything that made me love my job through Midjou... by rafaelero on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:49AM (#35315032)
I hope they are right. But one thing that seems to be conflated in this debate is the comparison of AI with previous disruptions. The tools we have built before were taking some specific parts of the process and making it more productive. They were not trying to mimic human cognition in a way that can be applied to so many different processes at the same time.