News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by noahmbarr on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @06:48PM (#35063105)
(Uninvolved growth-stage CFO perspective)

The IRS mandates that stock option grants expire after 10 years. My best guess is these early employees are quickly approaching those grants' 10 year mark, and face an exercise or "lose it" situation.

If you exercise, you have to pay the gain. For early employees, this could/would be a massive bill -- probably well into the 7-8 digit range for some early hires.

Stripe seems to be teeing up a secondary sale of these stocks themselves -- where Stripe is offering to buy some of their shares back from those early employees, allowing the employees to exercise ('buy") all of those early options and (at least) pay their tax bill.

Usually, a company will limit the # of shares eligible for a secondary purchase so current/former employees can buy all the stock, sell enough to the company to cover that person's resulting tax bill, and keep the remaining stock until IPO. By limiting the # of shares they will allow to be purchased via the secondary, Stripe will almost certainly make sure the secondary does not create post-tax cash gains to make people wealthy!

It doesn't have to be that way:

Stripe could allow ANY investor to buy the shares directly from those employees -- but guessing Stripe has a blocking right on stock transfers-- so they have, and will continue to block early employee sales to new investors. Stripe and many companies have these transfer "veto right" to make sure they can control their ownership ("cap table") and also to make sure early employees don't get rich before the IPO.

This is my best guess-- I am not familiar with the Stripe's situation.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by paxys on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @05:00PM (#35075339)
> This is my best guess-- I am not familiar with the Stripe's situation.

All of what you said is literally the content of the article.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by noahmbarr on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:17PM (#35076637)
Other people asked a bunch of q's so I tried to present it a little differently

Key concepts that were net-new from the article: * 10 year concept IRS restriction * Concept of a transfer Block essentially requiring a company sponsored secondary * Idea that Stripe could stay out of it, and just allow (partially) transfer waiver to 3rd party investor * The concept of most startups strong preference against creating liquid wealth events for early employees prior to IPO

Perhaps you knew all of this, but the other commenters didn't seem to have this knowledge top of mind.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Swizec on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @05:00PM (#35075341)
> to make sure early employees don't get rich before the IPO

But why? What's wrong with early people getting wealthy?

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by dboreham on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @05:07PM (#35075414)
Getting wealthy before VCs isn't good.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by mrexroad on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:32PM (#35076765)
Gotta keep those workers hungry!
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by nlitened on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:16AM (#35078525)
Will somebody please think of the poor workers with 500k salaries?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by rodgerd on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:17PM (#35076638)
They're the wrong sort of people.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by akamia on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:31PM (#35076761)
The concern could be a brain drain. If lots of your early employees cash out and leave, you are potentially losing a lot of historical knowledge and expertise at a time when you are trying to build up to a successful IPO. Early employees often leave after an IPO. At that time, it is still disruptive but the company's priorities have changed.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Analemma_ on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:58PM (#35076992)
It's difficult to sympathize with Stripe when these options coming up on the ten-year mark, especially because we all know the reason it has been taking so long is that they would really like to just raise private capital forever instead of giving these employees their due.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by xyzzyz on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:53PM (#35077450)
The employees can always exercise and quit even if they cannot sell it, this doesn’t do a lot for the brain drain. Instead, the main reason is that company wants to control who its shareholders are. They don’t want just any entity to be able to become a shareholder and by this virtue, acquire extra privileges and access.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by oblio on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:09AM (#35081296)
> Instead, the main reason is that company wants to control who its shareholders are.

Why?

> They don’t want just any entity to be able to become a shareholder and by this virtue, acquire extra privileges and access.

They're early employees, why wouldn't they be rewarded? What makes a random person that just walked in with a wad of cash more deserving?

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by xyzzyz on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:15PM (#35085326)
For the same reason why you might want to borrow money from one person, but not from another: people typically want to choose to whom they are responsible. You don’t want to suddenly acquire an activist minority shareholder, who’ll sue you for alleged breaking of your fiduciary duty to him, and distract you or force you to change your plans.

> They're early employees, why wouldn't they be rewarded? What makes a random person that just walked in with a wad of cash more deserving?

Not sure what you mean. The entire point is that people who run private companies often do not want random people/organizations to come in with a wad of cash and become shareholders, without people running the company having any say in it.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by bombcar on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:32PM (#35076773)
Many employees leave the moment they can sell millions of dollars of stock.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by HDThoreaun on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:38PM (#35076822)
Probably a combo of wanting theme to stay instead of retiring and investors wanting to be able to offload their shares first in an IPO.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by throw3823423 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @05:30PM (#35075678)
It's pretty accurate: Employees don't have a few million in change, each, to turn the RSUs into plain stock.

I don't think the issue is making employees wealthy or not: It's 10 year old RSUs, so most of them are owned by former employees. But consider the size: If the tax bill is 3.5B, the full size of the grants we are talking about here is over 10B! last valuations in the press are at something like 60b. So 1 in 6 shares in the secondary market? Might as well be an actual IPO.

Without 2022 going the way it did, I'd have expected that there would have been yet another regular round, where the investors ate enough common stock for current and former employees to vest the RSUs. That, or maybe the company really IPOs, which clears out all the comp problems. But Stripe finds it very valuable to keep the company closed, so instead of IPOing when everyone else does, they delayed too much.

So there's no real need for not wanting people to get rich here: It's just a very uncomfortable amount of stock to have to turn into liquidity either way.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by morepork on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:59PM (#35077001)
I wonder whether there could be space here for a bank to come in and specialise in loans to cover the tax bill, using the currently pre-IPO stock as security
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by MajimasEyepatch on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:14PM (#35077130)
Some companies are doing that, like https://vested.co/.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by zamnos on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:13AM (#35078717)
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by kodah on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:02PM (#35077028)
Pre-IPO stock is about as secure as super glue based on toothpicks and bubblegum.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by renewiltord on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:53PM (#35077824)
That's literally what the Bolt CEO did. He ran a company that offered his employees the loans.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by fshbbdssbbgdd on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:02AM (#35078466)
That’s absolutely a thing, I know people who did it. However “security” can be expensive, they might demand some of the upside as well.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by KptMarchewa on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:03PM (#35077030)
I don't understand why there's tax on unrealized gains there.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by valzam on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:07PM (#35077079)
The gains a realised, you just aren't getting cash but company stock. The 'gain' is the difference between option strike price and market value of the shares. Since stripe is privat the market value is a bit murky but that doesn't deter the IRS.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by xyzzyz on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:50PM (#35077417)
No, this is completely incorrect. The issue in question is about stock options, not stocks themselves. If you hold actual stocks, there is no tax bill until you sell these to realize the gains, and you can hold these forever. Instead, the issue at hand is about stock options. For those, the tax bill is due on exercise. For as long as you can hold the options without exercising, you don’t owe any tax, but the problem here is that you cannot have options that do not expire or have expiration date longer than 10 years. As this deadline is getting closer, option holders need to choose between exercising (and owing taxes on resulting difference between strike price and FMV), and forfeiting the options.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by theIV on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:12PM (#35077570)
If they are ISOs, tax won't be due _upon_ exercise but will show up on that years tax return. Usually the AMT will hit you (if the exercise was worth it), and you'll owe the following year.

This is a slightly longer way of saying I'm not totally sure how what you're saying invalidates what valzam said: as far as the IRS is concerned, you did realize gains (you got something of value), just not on anything "liquid," hence AMT. Perhaps they (IRS) use different terms, but that's basically what's happening.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by iav on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:59PM (#35077853)
when the gain shows up is irrelevant - IRS requires taxes to be paid on income in the quarter it is realized. Everyone needs to pay the estimated tax and then file the return for the final adjustment.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by theIV on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:38PM (#35078063)
I'm not super familiar with this aspect, so this could be totally off-base: because this is sort of "out-of-band" income, it might factor into what you should be paying, but you won't be penalized for it; you didn't know exactly what the estimated income was (i don't believe you have to get a 3921 immediately upon exercise) so you can't necessarily estimate the taxes owed. This could be totally wrong? Also, I think there's a lookback period of a year that you can base your estimated taxes on.

All of this to say, I think what you're saying is a much more precise way of saying what I was trying to get at. :)

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by danielmarkbruce on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:41PM (#35078383)
If they are given to you as income, you owe tax on the $$ value as though it was income. Ask anyone who works at Google or any of the big corps who give RSUs. The number of them that hit your account is always about 2/3 of the number which actually vested. The rest are withheld as taxes.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by xyzzyz on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:48PM (#35078407)
Again, you are talking about stocks. Options work completely differently. Unlike with RSUs, you don’t owe any tax on options when they vest, only when you actually exercise. I know how RSUs works, I have actually worked at Google for a number of years. Instead, you should ask someone who works at an earlier stage company how options work.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by danielmarkbruce on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:12AM (#35078512)
Yes, I am talking about stock, in response to:

>> If you hold actual stocks, there is no tax bill until you sell these to realize the gains

There are taxes to be paid as soon as you get the stock. If you are at google - have you noticed the number of RSUs which hit your schwab account are less than those which vested according to that chart in your schedule? That's taxes being withheld. The stock vesting is considered income at that moment and taxed as such.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by polishdude20 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:49AM (#35078638)
I may be woefully misunderstanding here but say you exercise your options, sell them then get real cash for the sale all in the same day. Can you use that cash to pay your taxes when tax season comes around?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by akhosravian on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:11AM (#35078707)
Yes. The problem is there are various reasons why you can’t just sell stock or an early stage company the same day.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by danielmarkbruce on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:50AM (#35078649)
You can use whatever cash you have to pay your taxes.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by kgwgk on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:55AM (#35080084)
Note that the 3.5bn (withholding) tax under discussion is not about options. It's about RSUs.

(There is also a less important amount of tax due - by more ancient employees - which is about options.)

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by alasdair_ on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:58AM (#35081822)
It's about double-trigger RSUs with a 7 year limit. Stripe is now in year six. If they wait any longer, the RSUs become worthless (and the employees riot).
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Apofis on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:52PM (#35078145)
What's realized about these gains if the company is blocking the sale of the stock on the secondary market? This is toilet paper these people were duped into thinking was worth something. Sounds more like a lawsuit.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by valzam on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:00PM (#35078192)
Yes for sure it's a raw deal for the employees, but I think Stripe is planning to enable a secondary market? In any case, we are all adults, they accepted stock options as part of your renumeration. If they don't know the risks then don't work at a private company that offers stock options.

EDIT: That being said, I think it would be reasonable to contemplate regulations that prevent private companies from blocking secondary market sales if they offer stock options/RSUs to employees.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by nirvdrum on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:34PM (#35078351)
To be fair, a venture-backed company remaining private for 10 years wasn't terribly common and probably wouldn't factor highly in anyone's risk assessment. If someone asked "what happens to these options in 10 years if you don't go public or get acquired?" they'd likely be ridiculed for being difficult. And I don't think start-ups want that to become the new mentality or they'll get more push-back on comp structure.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by hyperhopper on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:34AM (#35078578)
> If someone asked "what happens to these options in 10 years if you don't go public or get acquired?" they'd likely be ridiculed for being difficult.

Let's hit the presses: tech startups hate engineers that think of edge cases

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by mavelikara on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:45PM (#35078397)
> That being said, I think it would be reasonable to contemplate regulations that prevent private companies from blocking secondary market sales if they offer stock options/RSUs to employees.

Either that, or IRS not consider the exercise as taxable until those conditions imposed by the company preventing secondary sale are lifted.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by KptMarchewa on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:11AM (#35082809)
How are they, if you're literally prevented from exchanging them to legal tender?

It's like taxing lottery tickets on potential win prize.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by valzam on Thursday March 09, 2023 @03:47PM (#35086449)
Actually that's not a bad analogy but against your point: options are winning lottery tickets. As long as you don't exchange them for the prize (the actual stock) you are not taxed. When you do, you have to pay tax on the difference between how much the options cost and the value you get back.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by KptMarchewa on Friday March 10, 2023 @10:26AM (#35095523)
>Actually that's not a bad analogy but against your point: options are winning lottery tickets.

They are not unless you exchange them for legal _money_. Not stock.

>As long as you don't exchange them for the prize (the actual stock) you are not taxed.

Stock is not the prize - it's worth nothing alone, especially if you can't exchange it for mone. For some reason you don't tax unrealized gains on a stock you already owned, yet do the same for illiquid ones.

>When you do, you have to pay tax on the difference between how much the options cost and the value you get back.

And if you just taxed "at the end" when someone sells the stocks, you'd gain the same amount of money - difference between stock value and 0 - just in a different moment of time.

What I propose is logical and it's how it works in Poland.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by bagacrap on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:56PM (#35084309)
What does the IRS use as market value?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by mis1988 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:53PM (#35077445)
Joys of the Alternative Minimum Tax. The difference between the exercise and the FMV counts towards your AMT income.

(Disclaimer: not advice of any kind)

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by konfusinomicon on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:15PM (#35077942)
the biggest joy is that you get it back in the form of a credit over several years, all the while paying interest and fees on the tax bill you cant initially pay because your "gains" are in a private company's stock that you cant sell! I've yet to get a rational explanation of why the current AMT law is fair. sure for some people it makes sense, but for the exercise of ISOs in a private company, it's basically robbery where they give you a chunk of what they stole back every year, and hopefully a liquidity event comes along sooner rather than later
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by tyre on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:27PM (#35078012)
It’s fair because otherwise you could compensate people for zero tax. For example, you have a CEO that can either be paid:

1) $1m in cash

2) $1m in stock

3) an option grant to buy 1m shares at $0.000001. Each share has a FMV of $1.

Without AMT, you could always take (3) and they would get $1m of stock for $1. Tax free.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by kelnos on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:39PM (#35078069)
So what? $1M in stock doesn't pay the rent. They'd still get taxed when they sell the shares.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by ctchocula on Thursday March 09, 2023 @03:00AM (#35079197)
Per Buy, Borrow, Die, they could take a margin loan using that $1M and use borrowed money (say $100K) to pay the rent. With enough accumulated shares, they wouldn't need to sell the shares in their lifetime. After they've passed away, they would pay off the loan and the stock gets a free step up to the appreciated cost basis.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by konfusinomicon on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:02AM (#35080764)
that's assuming the stock is actually transferable though. that day could never come
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by KptMarchewa on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:04AM (#35082710)
How would you pay off the loan without selling at least the interest?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by caseysoftware on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:45PM (#35078105)
With (3), they'd be taxed on the gains when they sell. Not "tax free" at all.

The difference is that they wouldn't be taxed until the gains were realized not when they were imagined on paper.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by tyre on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:01PM (#35078206)
The reason we have capital gains is to encourage investment. They're not investing $1 for 1m shares to build something better. They're getting $1m worth of something for $1, risk-free.

That gap between strike price and FMV is much more like compensation than it is an investment.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by buryat on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:08AM (#35078499)
you can borrow against this asset and get basically a tax-free loan
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by KptMarchewa on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:09AM (#35082785)
Can you _actually_ borrow against completely illiquid, pre-IPO asset?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by konfusinomicon on Thursday March 09, 2023 @07:58AM (#35080712)
exactly this. tax time will come, hopefully. until then it's a tax on monopoly money.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by travem on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:21AM (#35078539)
Doesn't the option have to match the FMV at the time of issuance? E.g. Option 3 would be Option Grant at FMV of $1 with that constraint
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by KptMarchewa on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:03AM (#35082700)
But you can't sell those stocks/options/whatever until IPO. If you could I'd not mind.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by samclearman on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:47PM (#35077797)
Because the system is crazy, but it only affects early employees of successful startups so there's no political will to fix it.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by notyourwork on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:55PM (#35078437)
Crazy isn't an explanation.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by mschuster91 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:44AM (#35080018)
The problem is that "unicorns" in general or companies exploding in market cap are a relatively recent (i.e. dotcom era and afterwards) phenomenon, and the rules of the finance world didn't keep up with developments. At the same time, it affects only relatively few people, so the political incentive for fixing the situation in an increasingly grid-locked Congress is not very high.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by alxmng on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:07AM (#35078929)
Because receiving any kind of asset is a gain. For tax purposes an asset is valued at market or assessed rates depending on the type of asset (real estate, cars, stocks, etc.)

It’s tempting to think that we should just tax cash income, but that introduces tax avoidance incentives like being paid in assets instead of cash, unless it’s paired with a corporate income tax.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by KptMarchewa on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:02AM (#35082690)
>For tax purposes an asset is valued at market or assessed rates depending on the type of asset (real estate, cars, stocks, etc.)

If you can't sell them on a market (as the stocks are before IPO) they should not be taxed. At the very least, it's like that in Poland. Not that a lot of companies offer stock compensation here.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by friendzis on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:55AM (#35079170)
While I personally think there ARE gains, even if you insist on there being no gains then there is simple tax adjustment.

An employee is compensated with *contracts* to buy stock. Those contracts *themselves* are valued at the strike price, i.e. an employee is accounted to gain ${strike-price} worth of value.

At some point said employee decides to exercise said option contracts, i.e. convert contracts to stock. At the moment of conversion stocks are worth x and ${strike-price} previously paid to employee magically turns into x.

You can either think that employee gained `x - ${strike-price}`, or that employee was previously taxed on ${strike-price} and tax base was adjusted to x. In any case there is income equal to `x - ${strike-price}`.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by KptMarchewa on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:15AM (#35082872)
> While I personally think there ARE gains, even if you insist on there being no gains then there is simple tax adjustment.

How are those gains if you're explicitely forbidden to turn those gains into legal tender?

You'd get same tax when IPO hits - just without that earlier step.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by nullc on Friday March 10, 2023 @05:40AM (#35092778)
Executing the option realizes the gain!

It's just the it realizes it into an illiquid asset whos price is imaginary nonsense. The problem of imaginary prices is one of the reasons that we don't tax unrealized gains, but it can still arise when the gain is realized if its realized into something illiquid.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by MajimasEyepatch on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:03PM (#35077039)
I don't think it really changes the overall point you're making, but these would presumably be ISOs, not RSUs.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by snotrockets on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:02PM (#35077863)
According to the story, Stripe has been compensating employees with double triggered RSUs
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by tyre on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:22PM (#35077985)
But not from ten years ago. Initially everyone was on options (ISOs) then moved to double trigger RSUs, around 2017 iirc
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by kgwgk on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:51AM (#35080057)
According to the story, Stripe's need to withhold billions in (employee's) taxes is related to (waiving the second trigger in) the double triggered RSUs it has been using to compensate them.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by elbigbad on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:39AM (#35078596)
Typically a company starts with ISOs or similar, and then moves to RSUs when they are confident there will be an IPO or other liquidation event in the foreseeable future. In this case, Stripe did that, and only later started issuing RSUs.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by choppaface on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:42PM (#35077361)
At Uber, employees got loans to cover exercise. Is that not happening here?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by nrmitchi on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:48PM (#35077401)
Taking out 7-8 figure loans to exercise start-up options in a private company in a time of decreasing valuations and market uncertainty sounds like a pretty poor idea.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by akavi on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:14PM (#35077583)
You can get loans backed by the shares themselves. Ie, the lender gets x% of the shares, rather than being paid back a specific dollar amount at a later time.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by runako on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:40PM (#35077753)
In this market, the X% might well need to be so near to 100% as to make the transaction not worth doing.

For ex: Stripe has marked itself down ~50% over the last year. Suppose you think the haircut should be more like the 70% comps like SQ and PYPL have taken, and build that into the X%. Then on top of that loss buffer, you prudently demand an illiquidity premium and a profit margin. That arithmetic doesn't leave much room for the employee to retain any stock.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by zamnos on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:02PM (#35078208)
More explicitly, if the shares go to zero, you don't owe any money
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by nrmitchi on Thursday March 09, 2023 @03:31PM (#35086257)
If the shares to go 0, and the loan is discharged, the discharged amount is still considered taxable income (at least if you are subject to US taxation)
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by choppaface on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:46AM (#35078630)
Right, that's what banks were doing for Uber employees, for AFAIK, as low as 7-digit packages. I believe the interest was conditional on an IPO happening tho, and in some cases the IPO not only got delayed but the IPO price was actually a little below secondary market price right before the IPO (same as Facebook).

I would think banks would do this again? But perhaps with a longer IPO window? Like the banks that would do this would also likely participate in the IPO anyways ...

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sopooneo on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:16AM (#35078727)
One thing I've never understood about this: why on earth aren't there financial products specifically for people in this situation? Especially around Silicon Valley?

Bankish Corp floats you the tax bill at some mutually beneficial interest rate, and in return gets a signed repayment guarantee for when you can actually cash out?

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by mcherm on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:40AM (#35078823)
Well, it might be a good idea, but there is a lot of risk. There is, for example, a risk that the employees get utterly screwed and are never permitted to cash out.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by madaxe_again on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:40AM (#35079092)
That isn’t a risk. That’s a near certainty.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by gadders on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:31AM (#35081523)
You can price risk. People buy distressed debt. No reason why they wouldn't buy illiquid private company stock (at a discount the holder might not like obviously).
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by RandallBrown on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:33AM (#35078787)
That does exist. I was able to do that with options at my last job with Carta.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by bagels on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:48AM (#35079129)
There are, I think. Forge global and others have services like this.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by mytailorisrich on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:16AM (#35079565)
You mean a loan? I think banks do that ;)
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sopooneo on Friday March 10, 2023 @10:23PM (#35104877)
You're right, I guess it would just be a loan with interest rate and terms fit for the risk. But I wonder if the financially rational terms might fall afoul of usury regulations or something. So I wondered if the lender would have to structure it other than a simple "loan" to get around that.

But I'm deeply ignorant of that world so may be making this much more complicated than it actually is.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by orenbarzilai on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:35AM (#35083159)
There are. That's why we have created Equitybee (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35083120)
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by choppaface on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:41PM (#35077355)
Some start-ups will both help employees exercise 83b as well as even bonus them the amount to cover the strike. Then if an employee leaves, the non-vested shares are clawed back and the bonus is not returned.

If Stripe did this, wouldn’t they have avoided much of the tax issues here? It seems they’re only able to raise in this case because of their strong valuation and success. Like, most companies either could not do this, or would only do it for the founders.

Moreover, what about performance-based comp for employees instead of time-vested ISOs? For example, employee gets percentage X at different valuation targets where these is liquidity? The ISO basically prohibits employees from having shareholder voting power where they work. Perf-based comp could perhaps offer employees the same fraction of a percent of any windfall while simplifying the tax / equity risks, which are very outsized for employees who are not accredited investors.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by acjohnson55 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:53PM (#35078425)
Yeah, but they would have had to have spent a lot more cash upfront, both in the bonus amounts and the payroll taxes on those amounts. ISOs are pretty ideal for early stage companies because they are very cash efficient and very light on taxes pre-liquidity. They begin to get more complicated when the company has non-negligible value. But they're still alright as long as you don't get to the point where the options are expiring without liquidity. The real question is why has Stripe allowed this to happen?

I'm not sure what you mean with the performance-based comp to comment on that idea.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by choppaface on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:02AM (#35078682)
While it's true that cover-to-exercise is more cash-intensive, if it's only for the first 50 or so employees, it would seem viable for a company like Stripe that has strong cash flow. The problem with ISOs is they effectively halve the value of the award due to taxes, and furthermore can impose extremely risky tax situations on people who can't afford to lose much (e.g. employees who exercise before IPO).

Performance-based comp could follow the public CEO comp model where the percentage of the package vests as a function of share price and/or milestones like liquidity events. Usually the milestones are also KPI-related, but ignore that for a moment. The packages could be RSUs and/or cash. This way the employees don't have to deal with the risk of options, and the company doesn't have to vest shares until they're actually worth something and taxes can be paid. Not sure how the package could survive after termination. It could end up being regulated the same way AMT was introduced but ... the reason ISOs exist is tradition, not because modern tax risks. Should be open for disruption / competition.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Xcelerate on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:03AM (#35079497)
> The problem with ISOs is they effectively halve the value of the award due to taxes

Could you explain this?

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by zamnos on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:01AM (#35080115)
Federal + California tax on those kinds of amounts totals 43%, which is easier to estimate in your head if you call it 50% after taxes.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by acjohnson55 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:26PM (#35087698)
RSUs are less tax efficient because they are considered ordinary income, marked to market, at the time they vest. ISOs, on the other hand, are subject to moer advantageous capital gains, and there's more control over when taxes will be realized.

The downsides of ISOs are: - They cost money out of pocket to exercise. - They have to expire within 90 days of separation from the company. - They get complicated when you can't simply early exercise+83b them.

As I said earlier, I think RSUs are ultimately probably better after the exercise cost becomes non-negligble. But ISOs have their perks under the current tax code.

Ultimately, I think the IRS should scrap the ISO. Just let employers award stock with a cash basis at vest time and gains realized at the point of liquidity. It would be much simpler for everyone to deal with.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by clintonb on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:10AM (#35078946)
An 83(b) election is only useful if the value of the shares is low. The income tax is negligible and the capital gains tax is zero. The price of many RSUs was not low when they were granted, so the income tax bill would have still been higher than many could pay.

Edit: Also, RSUs are not eligible for 83(b) elections.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by dataflow on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:44PM (#35077377)
> guessing Stripe has a blocking right on stock transfers

Often there's right of first refusal, but blocking rights? Do they actually have that? Is this common? If so, (why) would they need right of first refusal?

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by rpearl on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:33PM (#35077712)
At least some companies have board approval of transfers. Less common but not exactly weird
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by samclearman on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:48PM (#35077804)
Yes, it's common. They'll say that it's because they don't want unapproved investors on their cap table, which I guess is reasonable, but obviously the main reason is "because they can".
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by tetranoir on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:13PM (#35084587)
It's supposed to prevent hostile takeovers.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by orangepurple on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:08PM (#35077540)
Can you work out a payment plan with the IRS for such a massive bill?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by theIV on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:16PM (#35077597)
As far as I'm aware, yes. I believe the IRS would much rather get money than no money.

Note: I'm about to try this myself (though far less massive).

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by cyanydeez on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:41PM (#35077764)
Why do people act like the tax's is greater than the cash flow, like it's some unthinkable crime to pay tax.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by samclearman on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:45PM (#35077787)
In this case, the way it works is:

1. You exercise your options, for a paper gain of millions of dollars

2. However, you can't actually sell the shares (there are likely contractual restrictions on selling them, and even if not, there's not a liquid market)

3. So you have to pay millions of dollars of taxes even though your cash flow is zero.

And before you say "but they're ISOs", there's no such thing as ISO's under AMT so it doesn't help at all.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by chii on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:15PM (#35077936)
> for a paper gain of millions of dollars

which is why this part should never have been taxed. Until there's a sale of those shares, the price is merely an estimate and thus is not and should not be considered the FMV.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by samclearman on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:19PM (#35077961)
Not sure what you mean by "should" here, but the IRS definitely considers it to be a gain that you have to pay taxes on, regardless of whether you can sell the shares.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by zamnos on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:40AM (#35079096)
Yes that's exactly the problem. Why does it seem okay for the IRS to demand a million dollars from someone who has no way to pay that? Like, doesn't that seem like something is wrong/broken somewhere? There's a cottage industry of loan sharks who will lend people money so they can pay, but how about instead the IRS not take money from people who don't yet, and may not ever, actually have the money to pay, until they, y'know, have the ability to pay off that tax bill.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Keyframe on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:13AM (#35080183)
Would I own tax then on the classic car I bought 20 years ago which is now worth 10x the buying price and I can actually sell it for that, even though if I won't sell it?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by refurb on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:34AM (#35080271)
No, because the IRS has special rules about exercised options being recognized as income in the year they were exercised.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by georgeecollins on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:00AM (#35078675)
A tax deferred is a tax avoided. I can take any financial gain and turn it into a "paper profit". So those have to be taxed.

PS: I feel for these employees. My question is: Did they have the same access to the secondary market as the founder?

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by chii on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:09AM (#35078937)
> I can take any financial gain and turn it into a "paper profit"

if you did, you would not have access to make use of those "paper profits" for consumption - it would remain an investment. This makes taxing it egregious imho.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by seattle_spring on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:50PM (#35077811)
Because in this case they're going to be taxed on money they can't, and possibly won't ever, be able to access. It's like being required to pay tax on lottery winnings before you get a chance to enter the lottery.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by polishdude20 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:52AM (#35078653)
Why is that even treated as income then? That's like the government asking for more taxes from me because I have the potential to make money in the future if I'm lucky.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by akhosravian on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:19AM (#35078738)
Because shares in a company represents something of value. Just because a company’s shares are privately held doesn’t make them worthless. The IRS has ways to estimate valuations of privately held companies.

The problem unique to folks likely to be reading here is the exponential growth that can happen in early stage start ups. The options might’ve represented 100k in value when they were granted, but grown to 1m in value by the time they vested.

If you exercise you owe ~300k in taxes. Even if you have that cash the exercised shares could become worth 0 and you’ll just be out the money.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by liketochill on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:10AM (#35078945)
If they become worth zero do you not have a capital loss to deduct from future income? So you would gradually recover the tax paid when you got the now worthless shares in the form of future taxes you don’t have to pay.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by akhosravian on Thursday March 09, 2023 @07:11AM (#35080455)
You would have a capital loss to carry forward, and this is part of why the current rules aren’t great for people who aren’t already wealthy. If the tax bill is a big chunk of your net worth it makes it hard to take advantage of what might be a great opportunity.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Ferret7446 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:59AM (#35079807)
I understand how the law works, but it's quite silly to consider the shares as having value when it's literally impossible to convert them to that "value" to pay the tax. By definition the shares do not have value.

It's like if I handed you a coin that I promise is worth one million because I will buy it from you for one million right now, except I won't buy it from you now and I don't plan on buying it from you ever in the foreseeable future, and if I do buy it from you later it won't be for one million.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by akhosravian on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:56AM (#35080374)
In this context companies aren’t a pinky swear “I promise this has value”. A 10x valuation increase for a private company happens for a reason: for VC funded start ups that is often because they did an up round. Someone else put a lot more money on the line than an employee exercising their options would.

I agree with you the current rules kind of suck for employees at start ups increasing in value, but framing values as just made up is overly reductive.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by kgwgk on Thursday March 09, 2023 @07:03AM (#35080418)
> By definition the shares do not have value.

Good thing that nobody is forcing you to take ownership of that worthless thing then.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by alvah on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:31AM (#35078778)
mainly because the tax is greater than the cash flow?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by refurb on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:33AM (#35080265)
The tax is greater than the cash flow because stock you can't sell provides $0 in cash flow.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by matchagaucho on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:04PM (#35077877)
IIRC there's still a limit of 2,000 shareholders for private companies.

So if those employee options transfer to outside buyers, they potentially hit the 2K limit really fast.

btw - Nearly this same set of circumstances forced the FB IPO. Dozens of early employees were allowed to sell their shares pre-IPO, triggering the max private shareholder rule.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by WatchDog on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:44PM (#35078096)
Dumb question, but does another company count as a single shareholder? Could you setup some kind of SPAC that only owns shares in the given company, to open up another 1,999 shareholders?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by caseysoftware on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:50PM (#35078132)
Not a dumb question at all.

Many angel investors will create pool their money to create an LLC to hold their shares so there's only one investor. It also makes it easier when you need to get "all the investors" to sign off on something. You have ONE signature to get instead of the N angels involved.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by bcrosby95 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:09PM (#35078235)
IIRC there's no limit, it just triggers a lot of the same compliance regulations as being public.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sillysaurusx on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:47PM (#35078116)
Could anyone translate this into “The early employees will get wealthy from this” or “they’ll get slightly more than they would’ve gotten from getting a job at BigCo over 4 years”?

My problem with equity grants is that everyone treats them like they’re so valuable, when in fact the EV is usually close to zero. That wouldn’t be so bad if the upside was really good, but dealing with nonsense like this makes them even less attractive.

The whole point of working at a startup — of working very hard, instead of coasting — is to increase your standing in life. Some people care about skill set (you learn a lot more in a startup) but you end up a lot more stressed.

Stripe’s early employees are in the best possible scenario, short of winning the lottery: they joined a unicorn early. If they don’t come out of it with lots of after-tax cash, then that calls into question why to even work at one. Unless you really love hard work without proportional reward, logically you wouldn’t choose that path — pg said as much in many of his essays.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by zamnos on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:51PM (#35078137)
couldn't some of them have cashed out with the Shopify thing?

https://finbold.com/shopify-reportedly-buys-over-350-million...

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by vorpalhex on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:16PM (#35078269)
There are a whole bunch of conditionals here. If you excised your options as soon as you could (and constantly paid small amounts) then you own a good amount of shares.. but don't have anyone to sell to.

I have heard that the average equity grant is ~40k of value. I suspect the median is in a very weird place towards the low end though, if that number is true to begin with.

Options are complicated and timing is crucial. They carry real and meaningful risk.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by alasdair_ on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:53AM (#35081764)
>I have heard that the average equity grant is ~40k of value.

levels.fyi is pretty accurate. A staff engineer at Stripe gets around 260k base, 55k bonus and 360k in stock per year. I strongly doubt 40k is the average - $200k RSUs a year seems a lot more likely (unless they count commission-only sales people in the average, which would be weird).

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by notyourwork on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:54PM (#35078434)
> of working very hard, instead of coasting

I work at a FAANG, not coasting and make a lot of money and have made a lot of money every year for nearly a decade. I'll continue to make a lot of money and not worry about whether my startup will or won't succeed.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sillysaurusx on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:11AM (#35078507)
I think I misread your comment, so I deleted my earlier one. Sorry.

You’re right: if you’re going to work hard, you may as well choose the path with the highest rewards. If Stripe can’t make it worthwhile, is there a good reason to trade away what you’d get at FAANG?

So the hard workers have a lucrative path (FAANG), and the ones who want to spend more time away from work have a more lucrative path (BigCo). That doesn’t leave a lot of reasons to choose to be an early startup employee.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Godel_unicode on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:44AM (#35078842)
First, for some people front loading their earnings is important so they can enjoy more of life. Second, as another thread goes into, the risk-adjusted picture of startup vs established tech company is quite different.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by rattray on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:51AM (#35078855)
FWIW I joined stripe at around 600 people and almost certainly will prove to have done much better there than at faang financially (and quality of life/work). N=1 but I expect the same is true of most people who've worked there even until recently.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by scarface74 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:11AM (#35078952)
But statistically, the chance of any startup succeeding is about 10% and buy “success it just means that the investors didn’t lose money - not that you made a killing
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by dasil003 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:33AM (#35079052)
Joining Stripe at 600 was not that kind of bet. It was significantly derisked by that point was really a question of how far that early momentum could carry them.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by scarface74 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:43AM (#35079107)
So isn’t it still risky since you can’t get access to your equity?

My RSUs are deposited into my account every six months and I can sell and diversify them.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by fallingknife on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:45AM (#35080022)
Eventually the tech market will turn around, and they will be able to IPO. Stripe is projected to turn a profit this year, so there is no runway, and they can wait as long as the want for the right time. So Stripe equity isn't that risky. For 95% of startups it would be, though.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by scarface74 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @10:12AM (#35081995)
How does that help someone with financial needs now?

I’m not one of those people who keep my RSUs after they vest. I diversify over six months. I wouldn’t buy 30% of my company’s stock with cash if I were getting paid in cash , why would I keep my RSUs instead of diversify?

Of course that doesn’t mean I think the company I work for is going to disappear anytime soon.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by fallingknife on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:12PM (#35085277)
It doesn't, but if you accepted an offer where the base salary doesn't cover your financial needs, then that's on you.

And it's good to remember, that while RSUs are nice for the reasons you state, companies that give them out tend to pay a lower cash salary because of that, and if those stock prices go down, so does your TC, and it could be quite a big drop.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by scarface74 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:29PM (#35085505)
Well, all indications are that the BigTech companies are issuing new stock to at least keep people at their initial cash+stock compensation grant+a modicum of a raise.

I’ll know myself in a couple of months.

I’m in my 3rd year and my first full year of base + RSUs instead of base + 2 years prorated signing bonus + back heavy vesting schedule.

(Yeah I know, how do I say where I work without saying where I work)

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by fallingknife on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:46PM (#35087199)
I passed on interviewing there b/c I hear the culture is brutal with no work life balance. Is that true in your experience?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by scarface74 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:58PM (#35087344)
I work in Professional Services as a billable consultant (cloud app dev). Most of us are much older with families and wouldn’t deal with interference with our home life. Our division is much more “enterprisey”.

Also, since our division is mostly remote (even pre-Covid) and most of us are established in our career, we have much more optionality, a larger network, and hopefully a larger nest egg.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by bboygravity on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:25AM (#35079024)
As a European I feel like both those concepts (big money jobs or big money startups) are a USA only concept.

Anywhere else in the world that has those kinds of options? China maybe?

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by admissionsguy on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:40AM (#35079095)
But we get frEe hEaLtHcaRe!
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by wreath on Thursday March 09, 2023 @03:38AM (#35079387)
You dont have free healthcare. You pay for it like tech employees in the US do and you probably get worse service. At least there is a chance in the US to make generational wealth for a middle class, but no way in hell in Europe.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by messe on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:22AM (#35079601)
> You dont have free healthcare

If you’re going to use that sort of reasoning, then you don’t get free anything other than air.

Yes, it’s paid for by taxes (or through insurance depending on country; yes we have cheap private insurance here). Thank you for bringing that to our attention, our feeble European brains were unable to deduce that on our own.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by thomascarney on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:55AM (#35080083)
In Germany, my wife and I pay together about ~2,000 USD per month for public health insurance. It's not cheap!
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by admissionsguy on Thursday March 09, 2023 @07:59AM (#35080727)
Nor is it universal: I can count at least one extended family member who is not insured and is one accident away from bankruptcy - not unlike some people in the US - except that personal bankruptcy is exceedingly difficult process in their EU country, and it would be quite doable (if not straightforward) to go to prison for the debt.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by ghaff on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:31AM (#35080958)
Which is about what a good family plan on the exchanges would be in the US.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sgc on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:14AM (#35081351)
Not good. Basically bankruptcy insurance, you pay for all your typical health expenses outside disaster. I don't know what Germany offers for that price, but given the overall lower cost of healthcare, presumably it actually covers your healthcare.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by thomascarney on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:38AM (#35081611)
It's fairly good coverage without frills (i.e. you get a shared room in the hospital). Doctors tend to de-prioritize public insurance when giving appointments, because they earn less from them, particularly for elective or non-urgent issues, so you usually have to wait a bit longer than privately insured patients.

On the other hand, the insurance costs ~15% of income with a cap, so it has an element of solidarity to it - if you earn less, you pay less, and children and non-working spouse get covered without extra cost.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by ghaff on Thursday March 09, 2023 @10:50AM (#35082502)
It's not public insurance though. It's private insurance companies on a given state's exchange which may be pretty similar to what you have through an employer. The big thing with Obamacare is that you can now get private insurance even with pre-conditions. I'm not going to especially defend health insurance in the US but the idea that you can only get it through an employer is just not true.

There's also Medicaid if you're poor of course.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by hnbad on Friday March 10, 2023 @05:02AM (#35092548)
If you pay $2000 per month combined (which btw includes all children up to the age of 18 and all children not in full employment up to the age of 25) you're paying the maximum rate.

Your public health insurance rate in Germany is based on your annual income up to €59,850 (i.e. you pay the same whether you make €59,850 per year or €200,000 per year). At the maximum rate, you usually pay €807.99 per month for health insurance (including the average extra fee of 1.6%, which varies slightly by insurer) if you're a salaried employee.

In addition to the public health insurance you also pay for public nursing care insurance, the rate of which depends on whether you have children or not and are older than 23. Assuming both of you are self-employed, have no children, are older than 23 and have not opted out of public sick pay (which for employed people giving birth includes a combined 14 weeks of pre and post-natal leave known as "maternity protection", or a combined 18 weeks for early births or twins) and assuming the same average of 1.6% for the extra fee, you indeed pay €977.50 or just above $1000 per month each.

For the record, if you're self-employed, the absolute minimum you have to pay for public health insurance is €158.43 (without sick pay) plus public nursing care insurance plus the variable extra fee. This basically assumes your income is at least €1131.67 in any given month even if you make less than that: you can't pay less than that as long as you're self-employed unless you switch to a private insurer instead.

Another issue for self-employed people is that because your insurance rate is paid by you in full (unlike salaried employees where 50% of it is paid by your employer and your rate is adjusted automatically if your salary changes in either direction) your rate is much less dynamic and will often have to be adjusted retroactively. Public health insurers are legally only allowed to adjust your insurance rate based on your tax returns which means even if you magically manage to file your taxes in January of the following year and the tax agency immediately processes it, you may end up having to backpay (or be refunded) the difference for an entire year if your rate changes. If you are self-employed and not incorporated, you can file quarterly tax advances and the insurers are allowed to use these to temporarily adjust your rate until the final tax return is available but once you incorporate you're stuck in the worst of both worlds.

As this hopefully illustrates, there are many problems with how the public health insurance system works, especially for self-employed people and founders (and especially people who can get pregnant as it's not common knowledge that "sick pay" includes "maternity protection" and self-employed people often opt out of sick pay because it's an easy way to cut costs), but pretending our public health insurance is "not cheap" is a bit dishonest.

To reiterate for emphasis: if you pay a combined 2000 USD together per month that means the two of you each make at least 60k USD per year and you will not pay a single cent more for health insurance no matter how much more money you make. Arguably this ceiling is the main problem and if it were abolished, the rates could be considerably lowered for everyone else. The insurance rate is very painful if you're self-employed and make less than 60k EUR per year. It becomes increasingly less painful the more you make beyond that and that doesn't seem very fair.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by thomascarney on Friday March 10, 2023 @10:47AM (#35095884)
I'm not sure what is dishonest about what I said.

My point is that the German system is not a magical system of free healthcare. Rather, it's financially backed by charging a considerable chunk of earnings.

As a side note, the idea that the employer pays 50% of the contribution is a political slight of hand - an employee's labor covers 100% of the health insurance payment.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by CalRobert on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:52AM (#35081128)
I just spent 3 hours calling around every damn pediatrician in Ireland to have somebody, ANYBODY check my 3 year old daughter who hasn't grown in 5 months and is under the 1st percentile in height now. I am happy to pay them a lot of money to do so.

There IS No healthcare in this dump of a country. I am looking at flying to Barcelona to have her seen, and moving out of this dysfunction as soon as possible while I'm at it.

In Europe you don't go bankrupt on healthcare because you just die.

Yeah, yeah, anecdata, but right now I'm liking the "I get an appointment quickly and pay lots of money but that's OK because I earn lots of money" model more and more.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by oblio on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:25AM (#35079626)
> You dont have free healthcare. You pay for it like tech employees in the US do and you probably get worse service.

True, but there's no stress due to possible crazy variations in prices, "in network" - "out of network" garbage, etc. When people talk about "free healthcare", what they're really saying is: "out of pocket healthcare expenses are very small and always capped at a decent level, and I have access to healthcare even without a job".

> At least there is a chance in the US to make generational wealth for a middle class, but no way in hell in Europe.

https://www.oecd.org/economy/growth/49849281.pdf

TL;DR: The US has worse social mobility that many equivalent Western European countries.

What the US does is amazing marketing for their big outliers (and amazing marketing for everything, even piles of rocks in a desert, for that matter). I.e. 1 person in 100 million becomes a billionaire and suddenly you'd think 1 in 10 000 people did it :-)

Also:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Social_Mobility_Index

The US is in 27th spot, after 21 (!) European countries.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by refurb on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:14AM (#35080186)
The problem with those social mobility scores is they rank it by “chance of going from lowest quintile to highest quintile”.

But the quintiles aren't the same.

A good example is Canada vs the US vs the UK.

The top US income quintile is 153,000 USD.

Canada is 131,000 CAD (98,000 USD).

The UK is 87,000 GBP (105,000 USD).

So you could have less social mobility in the US (going from 1st to 4th quintile) than Canada (1st to 5th), but end up better off financially.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by hagbarth on Thursday March 09, 2023 @07:20AM (#35080491)
I think the reasoning is that you likely won't get out of 1st at all.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by refurb on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:32AM (#35080968)
But that's not how economic mobility is generally measured. It's usually movement from bottom to top quintile. The measure is relative mobility within a society, not absolute mobility.

But the WEF reference for the grandparent uses a "social mobility index" which includes such factors as: "Adolescent birth rate per 1,000 women", "Pupils per teacher in pre-primary education (%)", "Extent of staff training (1–7 best)", "Internet users (%)", "Meritocracy at work (1–7 best)", so it's clearly quite subjective when it comes to "social mobility".

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by praestigiare on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:28AM (#35079648)
It might interest you to look up income and social mobility rankings. In short, you are much more likely to build generational wealth in the Nordics.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by conjectures on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:12AM (#35080182)
Yeah, I'm not sure why people are surprised that having a safety net allows poorer people to take more risks.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by blodkorv on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:33AM (#35079670)
There are plenty of chanses to make generational whealth for the middle class in europe. Especially in the nordic countires.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by greedo on Thursday March 09, 2023 @03:53PM (#35086554)
You should look up "Temporarily Embarrassed Millionaire."
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by oblio on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:20AM (#35079579)
> And when you factor in the municipal bus network, a $40k salary at Klarna in Stockholm is basically the same as a $350k salary at Stripe in the US.

Sorry, I'm European but this is just silly.

There's no way $40k in Sweden buys you equivalent quality of life as $350k in the US, even when taking all the welfare state factors into account.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by lifty on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:44AM (#35079725)
I think it was a joke.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by oblio on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:51AM (#35079771)
I guess too much time spent on the internet does that to a person (me).

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sverhagen on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:10AM (#35080170)
Is it? The numbers may be pushed a bit to their respective limits, but with all the talk about cost of living in the Valley, $200k there may poorly approximate a similar quality of living as a sub-$100k salary does in a European city. Something about apples, oranges, and generalization.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by alasdair_ on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:47AM (#35081703)
They are talking about how the municipal bus network makes up for a roughly 900% difference in two salary figures. It's definitely a joke.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sohtym on Thursday March 09, 2023 @07:45AM (#35080633)
$40k is less than the average salary in Sweden while $350k is probably at least top 5% in the US (even without all the very relevant differences).

Sweden for the most part sucks these days but part of that is the idea that you can lounge through some average free education and then get $350k while leaving early on Fridays.

Yes, some Americans are born wealthy and some have a lot of privilege. Everyone else, at least that I've known, works at it. Often for 15 years. Then they might get $350k, or laid off.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by FuriouslyAdrift on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:17AM (#35082896)
$350k is top 1%, $175k is top 5%
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by lrem on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:53AM (#35079162)
Switzerland, to not search far. There might be worthwhile startups in London and Berlin, but they don't tend to go as large as the ones in the US.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by golergka on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:26AM (#35079629)
Remote means anywhere.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by pc_edwin on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:04AM (#35079828)
I understand that my opinion may be controversial, but I believe that the presence of unions is a contributing factor.

The impact of unions is far-reaching and can be seen in everything from the salaries of grocery chain CEOs to startup stock option allocation for early employees.

Here in the UK, it's not uncommon to come across articles in major publications about a CEO's pay being multiple times higher than the average employee and you look at the number its peanuts compared to the US.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by jen20 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:14AM (#35080835)
It would be a lot less controversial perhaps if you stated why you believe that.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by syliconadder on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:18AM (#35079885)
India also has jobs that pays a similar wage compared to the rest of the population. But these are more outliers than the norm. Europe doesn't seem to have that many options at upward mobility, even a salary of 80,000 euros seems paltry when compared to the housing crisis across board, inflation and the general lack of innovation when compared to the US or China.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by zamnos on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:51AM (#35080059)
On the other hand, an €80k salary also includes not going bankrupt if you dare get cancer or cost you $19k if you want to birth a baby, and also allows you to live in a place where there's decent public transportation so you don't need a car and all that stress if you don't want. It means not going $200k in debt to go to college. It means drug laws that are more aimed at harm reduction rather than moralizing. I'm sure there's others.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by koromak on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:08AM (#35078497)
That is the definition of coasting
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by versteegen on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:40AM (#35078598)
My reading of GP is that by working at a BigCo you remove the worry of whether your company will go under. Regardless of how hard you work.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by smarmgoblin on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:13AM (#35078714)
Most definitions of coasting would involve not working hard.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by thrashh on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:52AM (#35078861)
Some people love that kind of stress though.

Like some people like working hard so they can up front all their work and retire earlier.

And others like coasting so they can live their 20s before it’s gone.

Different strokes.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by oblio on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:18AM (#35079568)
True, but group A has a 1% (5%?) chance of achieving their goal while group B has a 80% (100%?) chance of achieving theirs.

Always include the odds in these calculations :-)

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by WJW on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:41AM (#35080004)
Indeed. Apart from option A (work hard at startup, get rich if startup exits successfully) and option B (work less hard FAANG, get paid with very high likelihood), there are also at least option C (work hard at startup, get almost nothing because the startup fails) and option D (work less hard at FAANG, don't get paid). Option C is much more likely than option A, but option D is much less likely than option B (unless you work at Twitter I guess).
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sverhagen on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:05AM (#35080133)
Or you'd never qualify for a FAANG, and startups are your only chance to riches...
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by WJW on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:30AM (#35080259)
I think you focused too much on the "FAANG" part of my previous post and not enough on the "odds" part. Let me rephrase my previous point:

    Startups are not a reliable path to riches, anymore than the casino is.
A "normal" career, whether in FAANG or in the less flashy parts of the industry, has a vastly lower variablility than the startup route with the same or higher expected value when measured over a few decades. Don't get fooled by the marketing posts that feature only successful founders while ignoring the mountain of failed startups that cost their early employees millions in opportunity costs.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by ghaff on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:22AM (#35080886)
There's this certain FAANG vs. startup dichotomy in this thread. There are a ton of IT-related jobs that pay very decent professional salaries (in not necessarily the very most expensive locations to live) and have interesting --if not necessarily cutting-edge--work. A ton of people are just fine with that.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by brandall10 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:46AM (#35080331)
It does seems that unicorny startups are full of ex-FAANG though.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by ghaff on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:20AM (#35080867)
Is that surprising? They've probably already made lots of money at a large company and want to do something they consider more exciting albeit financially risky.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @03:37PM (#35086334)
Nah, it's that they feel they didn't make enough from FAANG cos they got there too late (everyone in a successful growth company feels this way) and want to try again.

Additionally, at the time they joined FAANG those companies weren't as big and they might prefer that environment (I know I do, at least).

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by brandall10 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:48PM (#35088541)
Not at all, this is in response to the notion that it’s easier/lower barrier of entry than FAANG. The ones I’ve interviewed at were basically FAANG interviews conducted by ex FAANG engineers and managers.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by thrashh on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:31AM (#35083102)
There's also many other options. My buddy works 15 hrs/week at a non-FAANG and non-startup tech company making 200k base. It's not FAANG money but it's still very good and he has a lot of free time.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by thrashh on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:21AM (#35082948)
Their goal IS the startup environment. By being in a startup, they have already achieved their goal.

This isn't tech related but I have a friend that buys failing retail businesses and fixes them. She could just chill and make a lot of money but that's just not her thing.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by tsunamifury on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:21AM (#35079003)
I dunno if I’d be so sure of yourself if I were you.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by notyourwork on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:17AM (#35082890)
In what way? 10 years of engineering shouldn’t instill some confidence in my skill set?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by tsunamifury on Friday March 10, 2023 @07:11PM (#35103253)
Skill has nothing to do with layoffs.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by notyourwork on Saturday March 11, 2023 @08:21PM (#35115196)
Skill doesn’t but choosing what parts of a global conglomerate you chose to work in does. Going to build the newest AWS service that will change th world, maybe you will see a layoff, maybe you fail, maybe you succeed. Going to work in a core money printing factory for your business like Google ads, layoffs are less likely. GOing to work on HR/recruiting software to help your company hire more people, you sure as shit will see layoffs coming your way.

Not all roles in these big companies are viewed as equal when it comes to how leadership views the value your team/department/org plays within the companies bigger picture. Be business smart, not just engineering smart and layoffs likely don’t come your way.

Further this with being non-financially illiterate, save money, don’t live beyond your means, treat your stock RSUs as bonus income and life will start to look a lot different.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by tsunamifury on Saturday March 11, 2023 @09:19PM (#35115686)
So be a drone. I mean it works until it doesn’t. I wouldn’t be so confident.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by nugget on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:06AM (#35078483)
Based on internal data I have from similar companies my guess would be the first 50 employees average about $15-20m each and the next 100 average about $5-10m each just from their initial 4 year grants, with a lot of variation based on team and seniority. Stripe options have probably grown about 100x in value since the Series B so if you were an engineer who joined around that time, received $100k in RSUs, and left upon fully vesting then you'd be looking at around $10m in value today.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sillysaurusx on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:15AM (#35078520)
Stripe employee #130 made $5m (after taxes) from 4 years of options? Is there any data to support that?

It sounds mistaken, but exponential curves are hard to reason about.

50 x $15m + 100 x $5m = 1.25B post-tax, so probably north of $1.7B pre tax. Stripe had a post-money valuation of $10B+ in March 2021, so that’s around 15% of the company. I guess that’s in the right ballpark.

Hmm. Thank you for the concrete numbers. That’s a nice payoff for four years of work, even if you do have to wait ten years for it.

Happy to hear the startup reward structure still makes sense in 2023. In that case, it might be a good idea to join one that seems promising. The payoff is rare, but it’s a lot less rare than the lottery: there have been n YC startups, so the odds are around 10 in n. And I think n is something like 2k to 5k. (Edit: yeah, 4k according to Wikipedia.)

1 in 400 chance of $5m is still pretty low odds, though. But you do learn a lot, and you meet a lot of people that have a higher than average chance of being a future founder, so the benefits still seem to make sense. Interesting.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by kgwgk on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:47AM (#35079750)
> Happy to hear the startup reward structure still makes sense in 2023.

At least for people who joined a successful one ten years ago.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by nl on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:26AM (#35079921)
Also worth noting that in today's market a company like Stripe isn't paying significantly below market rates, so there's not huge downside in that regard.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by bradleyjg on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:17AM (#35080848)
Companies like stripe today or companies like stripe just after its series B?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by nl on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:10PM (#35087511)
Both.

After Series A most should be paying competitive salaries.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by bradleyjg on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:01PM (#35088067)
Just so I understand correctly, levels.fyi is saying that a Google L5 offer in a HCOL city is around $200k/$100k/$30k right now. If we are very conservative and value the RSUs at 75% that’s still $305k total.

Are you saying the cash component of post series A offer should be competitive with $200k, $230k, $305k, or $330k?

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by pcthrowaway on Friday March 10, 2023 @02:47PM (#35099861)
I don't know why you didn't just look it up, you were right there. Stripe pays about the same as google if you just consider base+bonus, much more if you consider stock.

Of course it's not a fair comparison because google stock is liquid

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by bradleyjg on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:00PM (#35100058)
We aren’t talking about stripe, we are talking about just post series A companies.

The question is whether it is a no brainer to work for such a company because you get a competitive offer plus lottery tickets.

My sense is that this isn’t true. The claim of competitiveness is setting to zero the value of liquid google RSUs. But I’m open to being corrected.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by zamnos on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:04PM (#35100126)
So to answer bradleyjg's question, you're saying $230k. Which is $100k less than the total Google compensation of $330k.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by madaxe_again on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:37AM (#35079083)
Based on personal experience and friends who have been at unicorns in their early days - the first 50 employees average about $0. The next 100 average about $0.

In every case, the stock that the employees holds gets reclassified and diluted until it’s a funky employee-only stock that’s only saleable back to the company at nominal value, but the company isn’t buying.

So sure, maybe there’s some kind of nominal value, but actual cash money? $0.

I hold 10% of a business valued at £150M. My holding is worth £0 because I can never sell it to anyone.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sverhagen on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:02AM (#35080117)
Doesn't that mean these the decision makers also don't have liquidity? If so, wouldn't the lack of liquidity not be for them still believing that there's a bigger payday behind the horizon? Still sucks if you want/need the cash now, of course.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by ethbr0 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @07:46AM (#35080636)
Without employee power on the board, there's nothing to prevent leadership from issuing themselves a different class of stock.

Especially for pre-IPO companies that are beholden to fewer financial regulations.

Either you have power, or you have a promise.

... And promises depend on how much you trust your counterparty.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by j-bos on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:58AM (#35080391)
Are these experiences in the US? Asking because I imagine conditions would differ country to country.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by madaxe_again on Thursday March 09, 2023 @07:24AM (#35080512)
US, U.K., EU - I mean, sure, maybe you’ll have better luck in Liberia.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by blitzar on Thursday March 09, 2023 @07:55AM (#35080694)
Zuckerberg, Brin, WeWork Guy etc all first 50 employees of unicorns ... you saying that their 100's of billions are actually zero value because they are 100's of billions of funky employee-only stock that’s only saleable back to the company at nominal value?

Also why pay $3.5bn of tax on $0 of value? Given how sharp tech is about tax minimization you would think they would have better tax people.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by pjc50 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:04AM (#35080774)
They're not usually employees, they're owners. Adam Neumann even managed an extraordinary scam whereby he had the shares with voting power and the investors didn't. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/10/24/adam-neum...
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by blitzar on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:13AM (#35080826)
Ahh ok, so Marissa Mayer then ... didn't make anything more than salary from being #20 employee at google?

Adam Neumann even managed an extraordinary scam of being currently worth 2x the company that made him all his money ...

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by jossclimb on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:03AM (#35080770)
Anyone reading this comment, know that this is the other end of the extreme to saying everyone does well. The truth is far more in the middle with many shades of grey.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by sgc on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:02AM (#35081230)
Without data it is all just anecdotes. I don't know where the definitive data is to say it is white or black, or reasonable characterized as gray rather than a shade of one of the two extremes. IPO data is public of course, but not the pre-IPO contortions affecting the set up for that moment.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by gbasin on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:53AM (#35081134)
At least in the US, this will only be true before a company goes public. After that point, the shares will all be freely salable and have the same value (except for a small premium for supervoting shares which some founders may retain).
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by jjav on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:49AM (#35079132)
> If they don’t come out of it with lots of after-tax cash, then that calls into question why to even work at one.

When joining any early startup, you really want to be able to do an early exercise of your options immediately when you join. If this is not possible for whatever reason, I consider it too risky to join.

When joining a startup one already knows it can fail the traditional way (bankrupcy), so that's the risk we take. But getting stuck in the position of having hit it big on paper but you can never leave the company because there is no liquidity, or having them expire.. just too painful.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by gitfan86 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @07:32AM (#35080560)
After the 2000 dotcom bubble equity for employees became a lottery. If you got really lucky your shares were priced at a 50k market cap and the company ended up only diluting those down by 50% and the company went public making your shares worth 800k. But now that situation is rare. The investors and founders and bankers ensure that they take the vast majority of the upside when going public.

If you are joining a company and taking less than 1% of equity in the company the best way to think about the equity is "This may end up being a yearly bonus of 50-150k, but probably will be worth nothing"

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by matthewowen on Thursday March 09, 2023 @08:10AM (#35080811)
I don’t really buy this, but that’s largely based on own fairly positive experience of stock compensation at private companies.

I will say that I think these conversations tend to be a little distorted because people who have had positive experiences feel awkward about saying “i made $xxMM from employee stock” but people who haven’t seem comfortable saying “stock based compensation was worthless”.

Also tbh a lot of people are just really bad at judging companies and wind up working at startups that are obviously going to fail. You really do have to make an honest assessment of if you are good at picking winners.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Retric on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:10AM (#35081303)
Sure people may not want to talk about it, but a big part of this is so few people make $xxMM from employee stock.

Yes, if you where one of the first 50 employees at Google you probably made low $xxMM, but it’s a long wait until IPO and the overwhelming majority of people at Google didn’t get anything close to that much. Worse the overwhelming majority of companies aren’t Google style success stories.

Also, don’t forget nobody at Stripe has gotten to cash out yet. Your looking for very early employees, at wildly successful startups, who started 10+ years ago, and are still poking around online forms, and willing to talk about it.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by rcme on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:34AM (#35083128)
I think Google employees did alright. Let's say you joined in Sep. 2013 (random date). 4 years later, the stock was up 200%. So if you got a $500K grant over 4 years, you'd have 1.5 million. After taxes, that'd be around $1 mm.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Retric on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:39AM (#35083206)
The kind of person you just described likely also got a total of around 1 - 1.5 million in salary across those 4 years.

It’s not like they where handing out stock options like that to secretaries in 2013.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Retric on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:00PM (#35083483)
People getting 500k grants in 2013 from Google were just making a lot of money in general. Remember a grant isn’t an option you’re getting actual stock even the company stayed roughly flat they could have sold the 500k worth of stock.

Grants that size don’t represent a typical employee either. It’s closer to a 2-30% annual bonus that happened to appreciate rather than some life changing payday.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by matthewowen on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:50AM (#35083347)
If you take a look at some of the examples in https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/equity-for-software-engin... you see that you really don't have to be at a "first 50 at google" level of success to see 8 digit equity values. Bear in mind that even private companies have some level of liquidity for option holders via secondary sales.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by Retric on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:08PM (#35083578)
Highly compensated employees handed grants aren’t startup employees taking risks they are well compensated employees getting deferred compensation. Even if the stock stays flat they still get the face value of the grant.

That said, the double digit examples were “software engineer 2” and “first 10 employees”.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by matthewowen on Friday March 10, 2023 @07:31AM (#35093562)
Software engineer 2 is a reference to level, not when they were hired (doordash was big by then)
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by marcus_holmes on Thursday March 09, 2023 @09:17AM (#35081382)
> Also tbh a lot of people are just really bad at judging companies and wind up working at startups that are obviously going to fail. You really do have to make an honest assessment of if you are good at picking winners.

It's luck, not good judgement. No-one knows how to accurately assess whether an early-stage startup is going to succeed or fail.

If it was possible, accelerators would have better-than-background rates of success. Even YC, who get their pick of pretty much every startup, has barely better than background rates of success.

If it was possible, VC's would have better than background rates of success. They don't. They rely on the successes being much bigger than the failures because the failures are limited by bankruptcy while the successes have no limits.

I think blaming people for being bad at judging early stage startup success likelihood is poor form when no-one else in the entire industry has any idea how to do this.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by matthewowen on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:55AM (#35083427)
You don't need to join an early-stage startup – as a mid-to-senior engineer, even if you only join places that are series-B or later you can still get equity packages that ultimately end up netting to >1MM/year with the kind of valuation growth that the successful companies in that profile see.

I think luck is a big part of it absolutely, I just don't think it's the only piece. But I also know that IME some engineers looking at new roles think about likelihood of company success way less than they should relative to "do I like the technology/culture/whatever" and so it is not surprising if they don't end up at successful companies.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by marcus_holmes on Thursday March 09, 2023 @12:40PM (#35084069)
I think the reverse: that entering a company based on "am I going to enjoy it here?" is a better bet.

If you hate it there, you'll probably leave and never vest your equity. Even if you hang on and suffer through it to get your equity, it'll damage you in ways that money won't help with.

If you hate it, chances are that everyone else does too, which means the good people will leave and the startup is less likely to succeed even if everything else is good.

Most engineers enjoy interesting challenges, and this can be a big factor in choosing a role. If the startup is providing interesting challenges then it's doing interesting/difficult stuff. This is a factor in success - startups that aren't doing interesting/difficult stuff are easier to copy and have less barriers to entry for competitors.

Even if you don't get lucky and win the equity lottery, you had a good job and probably learned some interesting things.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by nkjnlknlk on Thursday March 09, 2023 @02:37PM (#35085584)
Can you speak as to how you would develop the skill to identify companies that end up having success but _also_ compensate their employees well? Also, if you're actually good at that skill, aren't you incentivized to just be an investor instead?

Regardless, being able to identify "company success" is something that's always been taught as luck/lottery so I'd love to improve my ability here.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by gitfan86 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @03:12PM (#35086020)
I'm in that situation, I've made more money on investing in technology companies than working at them. Unfortunately the skillsets are somewhat orthogonal so I was unable to get a job at Google, but was able to buy in at the IPO.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by jjav on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:30PM (#35086995)
> You don't need to join an early-stage startup – as a mid-to-senior engineer, even if you only join places that are series-B or later

I'd say the mid-growth time (series B and nearby but of course depends on the company) is a particularly bad time to join a startup. It is too late to get favorable stock options but too early to tell if it's going to be a home run. So for individual contributors it's pretty much all blind risk with low probability of reward.

Good times to join a startup are very early when the valuation is a couple pennies or less so you can get meaningful percentage of stock and you can early exercise all of it for little money and file 83b.

Or join late in the game startups that are big hits and clearly going to the IPO. Way less stock, but risk of failure is now small.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by hardware2win on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:35AM (#35078801)
>f you exercise, you have to pay the gain. For early employees, this could/would be a massive bill -- probably well into the 7-8 digit range for some early hires.

Why is this relevant.

Wouldnt they still be ahead?

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by ConcernedCoder on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:40AM (#35078821)
> Wouldnt they still be ahead?

on paper, yes, you'd be ahead, but owning stock doesn't equate to cash, you'd have to liquidate by selling... in the interim, you'd still owe the tax bill, even though you haven't sold yet, and for some without the means to pay that bill, it can be a problem.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by hardware2win on Thursday March 09, 2023 @10:51AM (#35082524)
Cannot you receive stock and sell it on the next day?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by s1artibartfast on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:21AM (#35082937)
No, the stock cannot be sold until stripe has an IPO. This is the bind employees are in.

Together they have a 3.5 billion tax bill, but don't have the cash to pay it and cant sell the stock.

It is like if I gave you a magic bean worth 1 billion this year, but the only magic bean buyer will come to town next year (hopefully). how will you pay your taxes.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by tetranoir on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:12PM (#35084567)
Not entirely true. There's a grey area where you can sell futures of your own stock on the secondary market that can avoid requiring board approval.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by s1artibartfast on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:25PM (#35084735)
perhaps technically (I'm not very familiar with private futures), but now we have a large number of employees looking for niche buyers to acquire $3.5 billion of stripe futures, which doesn't seem very realistic.

I get why a buyback makes sense here.

What I don't understand is why they didn't just let the current options expire and issue new ones with a fresh 10 year expiry, an IPO vesting trigger, and no employment contingency.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by kgwgk on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:10AM (#35082802)
If you received stripe shares today how would you sell then tomorrow?

Essentially the company is going to intermediate that sale by selling shares to external investors and buying shares from you.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by tetranoir on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:16PM (#35084624)
There are many services that offer loans for leveraging options, for decent rates too. A lot of people I know do this to pay the exercise tax
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by rattray on Thursday March 09, 2023 @01:58AM (#35078884)
> to make sure early employees don't get rich before the IPO

Former stripe employee here. This is not the case - early employees have been able to cash out on favorable (or at least reasonable) terms. Some limits, not perfect, etc, but I don't think that part of the narrative applies in this case.

Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire by gadders on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:27AM (#35079636)
>>Stripe and many companies have these transfer "veto right" to make sure they can control their ownership ("cap table") and also to make sure early employees don't get rich before the IPO.

The founders are rich though, right? What a douche move.