Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire
by Xcelerate on Thursday March 09, 2023 @04:03AM
(#35079497)
> The problem with ISOs is they effectively halve the value of the award due to taxes
Could you explain this?
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire
by zamnos on Thursday March 09, 2023 @06:01AM
(#35080115)
Federal + California tax on those kinds of amounts totals 43%, which is easier to estimate in your head if you call it 50% after taxes.
Re:Stripe Faces $3.5B Tax Bill as Employees' Shares Expire
by acjohnson55 on Thursday March 09, 2023 @05:26PM
(#35087698)
RSUs are less tax efficient because they are considered ordinary income, marked to market, at the time they vest. ISOs, on the other hand, are subject to moer advantageous capital gains, and there's more control over when taxes will be realized.
The downsides of ISOs are: - They cost money out of pocket to exercise. - They have to expire within 90 days of separation from the company. - They get complicated when you can't simply early exercise+83b them.
As I said earlier, I think RSUs are ultimately probably better after the exercise cost becomes non-negligble. But ISOs have their perks under the current tax code.
Ultimately, I think the IRS should scrap the ISO. Just let employers award stock with a cash basis at vest time and gains realized at the point of liquidity. It would be much simpler for everyone to deal with.
Performance-based comp could follow the public CEO comp model where the percentage of the package vests as a function of share price and/or milestones like liquidity events. Usually the milestones are also KPI-related, but ignore that for a moment. The packages could be RSUs and/or cash. This way the employees don't have to deal with the risk of options, and the company doesn't have to vest shares until they're actually worth something and taxes can be paid. Not sure how the package could survive after termination. It could end up being regulated the same way AMT was introduced but ... the reason ISOs exist is tradition, not because modern tax risks. Should be open for disruption / competition.