News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by causi on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:29AM (#33559032)
Do they not actually want people to use the service? You find a channel you really like, then you watch their content from first to last. What kind of lunatic watches someone's uploads out of chronological order? How can you keep track of what you have and haven't seen if you do that? Youtube may as well remove subscriptions and replace the home page with a big-ass "Random" button.

You know what makes more database queries than sorting by date? Making me manually scroll through thousands of videos to the bottom and loading thumbnails for all of them. I don't care how restrictive they make the API, they can't stop me from writing a "start from oldest" extension that gives you a button to just automatically scroll to the bottom.

What kind of goddamn sociopath OK's a change like this?

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by kleiba on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:38AM (#33559085)
Please start an open source project for such an extension and count me in.

I'm so aggravated by YT's idiotic decision because I agree 100% with the usage pattern you describe. Over the years, that is exactly what I've done many, many times.

Sure, I also watch random videos here and there from channels I never ever come back to. But if I ever want to look at the entirety of someone's uploaded videos and sort them by anything at all, it's always by "oldest first". The remaining two options are useful, too, for sure. But I've never actively sorted anything by popularity manually. Always "oldest first".

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by 3np on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:17AM (#33559356)
These two, together:

https://github.com/TeamNewPipe/NewPipe

https://github.com/libredirect/libredirect

Sounds like the changes you want should be possible to add to NewPipe.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by capableweb on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:04AM (#33560329)
https://github.com/libredirect/libredirect is a bit over-zealous. Love the idea, but I still want to be able to browse the homepages of the sites.

After installing the addon and visiting just https://youtube.com I get redirected to https://inv.vern.cc/ that just displays "Our main server's ISP is having issues, even router resets haven't fixed it. We apologize for this long downtime". Visiting https://twitter.com I get redirected to https://twt.funami.tech/ which displays "502 Bad Gateway"

Not a great experience to be honest. Still, love the idea, but execution is poor at best.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by cube00 on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:18AM (#33559364)
Don't even bother, you only have to look at how often youtube-dl has to change to keep up with Google's infinite breaking UI changes. There's so many other open source projects that would benefit from your efforts that don't feed the Google machine.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by selfhoster11 on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:08AM (#33559773)
You could likely build something on top of youtube-dl to output a chronological list of videos. Instead of downloading, dump metadata for each video and then sort locally.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by toomuchtodo on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:54AM (#33560819)
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Macuyiko on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:06AM (#33560913)

    yt-dlp --flat-playlist --extractor-args youtubetab:approximate_date "https://www.youtube.com/c/AndreasKling" --print "%(upload_date)s %(id)s" 1> out.txt && sort out.txt
Takes longer if you want precise dates:

    yt-dlp --simulate "https://www.youtube.com/c/AndreasKling" --print "%(upload_date)s %(id)s" 1> out.txt && sort out.txt
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by TT-392 on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:25AM (#33559405)
I'd just recommend using newpipe, piped, or invidious, although, I guess they don't have sort by oldest, just by newest
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by throwaway744678 on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:53AM (#33559614)
Eh, turn your screen upside down!
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by benjaminwootton on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:32AM (#33559446)
Exactly the same here. I mainly use YouTube for education and the discovery is awful.

That said, being able to sort comments chronologically here on HN would be nice too, so people in glass houses…

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by BiteCode_dev on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:10AM (#33559782)
In all big platforms, navigation beyond dumb consumption is aweful.

Twitter, Facebook, Insta: try finding back a tweet of yours from last month, or explore the early posting of Guido van Rossum.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by capableweb on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:06AM (#33560352)
> That said, being able to sort comments chronologically here on HN would be nice too, so people in glass houses…

This is basically the main reason I wrote https://ditzes.com, be able to read HN while offline + chronological order of the comments without putting any importance on points (edit: and well, to have a dark UI to be able to read after the sun goes down too). Here is this comment thread in ditzes: https://ditzes.com/item/33558531

I mainly use it via a browser bookmark that redirects me from HN to Ditzes. If I find a comment I like, click the date with middle-mouse to open the comment in proper HN to comment.

Here's the bookmark in case people wanna use it:

    javascript:window.location.href = 'https://ditzes.com/item/' + (new URLSearchParams(window.location.search)).get('id');
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by rjzzleep on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:21AM (#33560517)
Every now and then I search for something on Youtube and then I struggle through the list of junk before I remember to use the most recent sort. Good to know that youtube web search is now essentially broken.

I wonder if it is actually intentional. You can now easily drown legitimate content by spamming it with "related" content

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by cruano on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:36AM (#33559068)
Oh it's way worse than random, I think half my home page are videos I've already watch so surely I'd just LOVE to watch them again right ?
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by texasbigdata on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:40AM (#33559102)
It’s probably a unsolveable computer science problem to add a filter that says “how many times does this user rewatch content, or dismiss recommended content she was already seen” and then not serving stale content.

Personally, unless I’m quering something that’s fairly narrow, for recommendations you push to me please never show me anything older than 36 months. No, I don’t want an 8 year old video on this topic.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by watwut on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:02AM (#33559250)
Yeah, but normal people watch/listen the same music video 300 times, but then see the comedy video or documentary video only once.

And for age, it is also fairly normal to listen to music older then 36 months. And to watch educational videos older then that. Or crafting videos older then that. Or tutorial videos older then that. Most of time, I am cool with old videos.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by texasbigdata on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:07AM (#33559289)
Yeah fair. I meant as a default (either) on/off filter but your point totally render mine moot :)
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by yourusername on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:34AM (#33559466)
For many of the topics i'm interested in videos made in the last 36 months are not better (if anything they are worse). If i'm looking up correct excercise form, how to cook a certain dish or perform a repair video's made 10 years ago are as good as video's made yesterday.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by viraptor on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:15AM (#33559839)
5 years, likely. 10 years is before 720p became common. Videos that came after 480p are actually better for things like repair videos. Also the speech sound quality is way better these days.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by hn_user2 on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:12AM (#33560409)
YouTube is helping me build my house step by step.

For framing, the first thing everyone recommends is “Framing Walls with Larry Haun” (1992). You even get the VHS tracking blips now and then from the video capture.

To be fair it’s also good advice to then supplement Larry Haun’s videos with modern framing techniques but his videos are the first one should watch.

Might just be a single example but it’s the first counterpoint that popped in my head.

https://youtu.be/IQmt27qN6AI

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by aulin on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:00AM (#33560289)
> if anything they are worse

They are. People that started with the genuine intent of sharing their knowledge gradually turned into professional youtubers, and now it's all about hacking the algorithm, diluting content in multiple videos, selling you to their sponsors. Older videos are almost always better.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by tomrod on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:07AM (#33560362)
Solution to the unsolvable problem: have one swim lane of "watch again", another swim lane of "watch similar", then only subs+discovery.

These are easy and solved already. Apply exponential weighted average for length since watch for sorting, with two peaks of a month ago and a year ago.

I fear the YT folks have a hot mess and it will be twitterized at some point (the new tech lobotomized).

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by causi on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:39AM (#33559091)
Same. I don't know why nobody at youtube understands that, yes, I might want to watch a funny 53-second video again but I probably don't want to spend an hour re-watching part nine of a Let's Play from 2015.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Angostura on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:26AM (#33559409)
Obligatory Ryan George video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d8fJPvXyfc0
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by BiteCode_dev on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:45AM (#33559537)
Statistically, yeah.

Because the most watched youtube videos are music videos, and people listen to the same music regularly.

Also because some videos have been popular enough that people wanted to show that to their friends, and regular users don't know how to use the history, so they want to find it in their home page again.

I assume the algo just doesn't know the difference between videos that are rewatchable and ones that are not, and does that on some statistical metrics that don't make sense in a lot of contexts.

When you think something is stupid, the answer is usually there is something we don't know about it.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Sharlin on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:16AM (#33560453)
An algo that does not know what the user wants but tries to do something anyway, based on "some [..] metrics that don’t make sense [..]" is by definition "stupid".
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by 2-718-281-828 on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:10AM (#33560967)
you have to be wrong as Google is the leading developer of AI technology globally </irony>
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by rmak on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:18AM (#33560479)
maybe they need a "watch again" tab?
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by RALaBarge on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:50AM (#33560773)
There does exist a History section that offers just that.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by anticensor on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:39AM (#33561337)
YouTube truncates the History to last 2000 items, however. I need to be able to see my full, uncut history for audit and word-of-mouth purposes.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by eimrine on Friday November 11, 2022 @01:47PM (#33564951)
I'm sure that many of old videos has been removed. And the more I use the Internets the more I consider to save as much of stuff as possible (webpages, videos, everything) maybe on another machine with a really giant disk.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by maximus-decimus on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:05PM (#33567515)
It's all because of me. I've been watching the same music videos for the last 15 years. Sorry guys.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by fphhotchips on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:31AM (#33560600)
There's a filter for that on the home screen! It's called "new to me", and it shows up sometimes! Because why would you want something useful like that all the time? Nah much better to just hide it or not show it at all like 60% of the time.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:39AM (#33560666)
When A/B testing becomes a released feature !
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by eimrine on Friday November 11, 2022 @03:06PM (#33566098)
> It's called "new to me", and it shows up sometimes!

You can always chose the "new to me" saussage, it is always last in the line of sausages with some tags inside of them. The problem is that "new to me" stops showing really new content if you gonna use it heavily. Sometimes it gives video with that red line on the bottom of preview which means I watches this recently or videos from some channels I am subscribed to. So, this is option is a garbage as most of other YT options.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by texasbigdata on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:38AM (#33559086)
sometimes for a giant database you’ll sort by most popular, but, for most, you’d want the most recent. It’s super confusing what YouTube is doing especially after the last change that outright broke the recommendation algorithm.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by jasode on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:51AM (#33559177)
> What kind of lunatic watches someone's uploads out of chronological order?

For some type of channels such as latest technology reviews or news commentary, the sort by "Oldest" isn't as critical because the older vids have less and less value as time goes by. The default of showing the most recent newest vids works ok for that. E.g. sorting MKBHD tech channel[1] by Oldest would have brought up the old 2008 videos when he was a teenager reviewing products that are long obsolete. Good for nostalgia but not relevant to getting the latest info on Pixel 7 and Android 13 in 2022. With sort in chronological order, you'd have to hit the PgDn key a hundred times before you scroll down to the 2022 videos.

That said, I personally used sort by Oldest all the time. E.g. I find a random house construction video so sort the channel vids by Oldest to start at the beginning where they cleared the land and poured the foundation.

>I don't care how restrictive they make the API, they can't stop me from writing a "start from oldest" extension that gives you a button to just automatically scroll to the bottom.

Last time I tried this, Youtube had unstated rate limits for pulling lots of metadata like that. I did some experiments on music channels that had thousands of vids and both the API and manual UI (automate press PgDn key repeatedly) had invisible rate limiting where you couldn't reach the oldest vids.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/c/mkbhd/videos

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by chii on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:53AM (#33559193)
youtube wants you to watch what they recommend. Removing the capability to browse, curate and choose your own watch lists is just a step in that direction.

> Youtube may as well remove subscriptions and replace the home page with a big-ass "Random" button.

don't give 'em any ideas!

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Kiro on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:55AM (#33559201)
I'm of the opinion that this change is catastrophic but...

> You find a channel you really like, then you watch their content from first to last.

I think that's very uncommon and that the majority of people sort by Popularity and start there.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by xdfgh1112 on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:59AM (#33559236)
Agreed. For use cases where the order matters, the author can create a playlist right?
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by eimrine on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:57AM (#33559220)
> You know what makes more database queries than sorting by date? Making me manually scroll through thousands of videos to the bottom and loading thumbnails for all of them. I don't care how restrictive they make the API, they can't stop me from writing a "start from oldest" extension that gives you a button to just automatically scroll to the bottom.

Wrong. There was an article on HN that no internet service allows you to open a 10000th page of any search. So, even if you have a really powerful device which is able to handle this amount of pages which are loading all at once (if you are travelling in endless mode as there is in Youtube), I am absolutely sure that at least for some creators' feed you just can not scroll it all without getting a 5xx error.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by xorcist on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:59AM (#33559234)
The same persons who put all wood behind the Youtube Shorts arrow, probably.

Given that everyone wants the retention of TikTok now, I don't think that big random button stays a joke for very long.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by lopis on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:04AM (#33559262)
> You know what makes more database queries than sorting by date?

You seem to be forgetting the scale of these "databases". Lots of data these huge companies hoard is stored in slower, cheaper, storage. They know roughly what data should be kept cold and warm. And in general old videos can be left in cold storage, because people rarely watch them.

While Youtube wants to control what you watch, I'm pretty sure this is a cost-cutting measure.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by coffeeblack on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:40AM (#33559498)
Plus, they know what videos generate more ad revenue. The user making up their own mind just interferes with that ad impression optimisation.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by OwlsParlay on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:04AM (#33559264)
> What kind of lunatic watches someone's uploads out of chronological order?

Welcome to the TikTok algorithmic feed. Viewing videos in order and with context is so passe.

That said, I rarely do this as well. If I've found somebody's content I like, I'll tend to then go see what playlists they've made for similar topics. Some channels will have over 500 videos dating back a decade at this point - I'm not going to watch that in order, but I'll at least browse by playlist.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by zozbot234 on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:32AM (#33559450)
Not all users bother to make comprehensive playlists though. Sort by oldest is convenient when playlists are incomplete or missing altogether. I really don't think it's a serious burden on YT's infrastructure, since it just involves sorting some metadata by reverse order.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Macha on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:43AM (#33560116)
YouTube wants in on this directly too with Shorts. It only allows you to dismiss the shorts widget on your logged in home page for a month at a time despite other boxes like channels or topics being possible to dismiss permanently
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by fphhotchips on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:34AM (#33560626)
I would go so far as to flip it: What kind of lunatic watches someone's earliest content? A lot of these people have been doing this for 10 years at this point. They've learned a lot. Their style has matured. Their production values increased. Why would you go back and watch all the content when it was one dude with a handicam and a tripod when there's years of high quality (not to mention more relevant) content at the top of the Newest list?
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by deltarholamda on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:59AM (#33560867)
>Viewing videos in order and with context is so passe

Disordered minds are easier to control.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by hdjjhhvvhga on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:05AM (#33559276)
Paradoxically, the best option when you find a channel you really like is to use youtube-dl.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by silon42 on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:07AM (#33559294)
We really need to start having bittorrent archives of channels (say, after > 1 month)
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by type0 on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:59AM (#33559665)
Yeah, combined with RSS reader it is a good option for offline watching
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by causi on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:22AM (#33559900)
Absolutely. Among other things, creators remove their content when it stops being fashionable. Half of my personal video archive isn't online anymore because the creator decided it was too edgy.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Crosseye_Jack on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:12AM (#33559319)
> How can you keep track of what you have and haven't seen

YT does show you any progress you have made watching a video when viewing a channels video list

> Youtube may as well remove subscriptions and replace the home page with a big-ass "Random" button.

They are trying too. A number of YT’ers with partner managers or who have had conversations with staff, have said YT wished they could get rid of subscriptions entirely and rely on the algorithm instead. Tbf on this point, I hardly ever use the subscription page myself and either use the recommendation page or direct link/notifications, so I can see their point on not really caring about subscriptions, but you know we as humans do like to see numbers increase.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by YurgenJurgensen on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:57AM (#33559639)
This would make me immediately drop YouTube for good. I only view videos via subscriptions and organic recommendations. No subscriptions basically means no YouTube for me.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Crosseye_Jack on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:41AM (#33560099)
I don't believe subscriptions will be going away anytime soon. Creators still like the sub count even though it is pretty meaningless these days and YT themselves seem to have a love/hate relationship with it, while on one hand they want to do away with subscriptions, but on the other hand they still use the metric for things like being able to monetize content and add things to the creator dashboard telling creators the percentage of viewer who are subed/unsubed and recently disabled to ability to hide your sub count from the public.

And as you said there are viewers who exclusive use the subscriptions page, I used to be the same and had my default youtube "landing page" as the subs page. But YT changed something and broke that and before I could be bothered to fix it I found that I was enjoying atleast some of the content the algo was recommending to me so started using it more and more, and before I knew it I stopped using the subscriptions page entirely.

So while they wish they could turn subscriptions off, I think they know it would cause too much backlash and would still have to still have to add a way for viewers to follow creators they want but make it more meaningful. I'm currently subscribed to over 500 channels but a lot of those channels could be removed from my list because it contains channels I no longer watch (be it because my tastes changed, the channels content changed, the channels are dead/retired) but I cba to go though the list and unsub. At which point a viewers sub list is just adding noise and delieverying (atleast some) content the viewer doesn't actually want to watch.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by precommunicator on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:59AM (#33559659)
> YT does show you any progress you have made watching a video when viewing a channels video list

Not if you disabled history

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Gigachad on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:03AM (#33559704)
Re enable it then. Problem solved.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by precommunicator on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:06AM (#33559737)
Same as Google search history, no thanks, I don't want what I watch or search saved anywhere but my local browser history.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by viraptor on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:20AM (#33559885)
Does Google guarantee that they don't collect the data anyway? I always understood that as "don't show me my history" rather than "don't collect my history".

Fancy downloading your YouTube data checkout to verify?

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by precommunicator on Friday November 11, 2022 @10:18AM (#33561849)
I did actually, no history there.

But my point is also that in case of compromise of the (2FA with physical key, but still, Google can mess stuff up) account nobody can see what I watched.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by viraptor on Friday November 11, 2022 @04:53PM (#33567388)
Thank you, that's certainly better than I expected!
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Gigachad on Friday November 11, 2022 @05:43PM (#33567856)
Then don't complain when youtube doesn't show you what you have watched. The tools are there if you want a nice experience.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nomilk on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:14AM (#33559335)
Same reason supermarkets place bread and milk far from the entrance, so you have to fuddle your way through the rest of their offerings before you get what you want. YouTube would have figured out if they make it really difficult to find good content, you'll get distracted looking at something else and then have to come back for whatever you wanted later anyway.

Hot tip: I use regular google search like so to search youtube 'topic site:youtube.com'. It avoids all the clutter the YouTube search results provide.

Afterthought: YouTube is getting so bad, I wonder if there's any third-party (paid or free) front end?

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by jnsaff2 on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:15AM (#33559342)
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nomilk on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:26AM (#33559413)
How did I not know about this :D
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by lopatin on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:29AM (#33559429)
They probably asked the users. The users said, "yeah, we like sorting by oldest".

Some design lead takes this opportunity to remind the team that users often don't know what they want. Everyone nods in agreement.

Bye-bye sorting.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by coffeeblack on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:36AM (#33559476)
You are not the customer.

YouTube tells YOU what video to watch when.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by prox on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:22AM (#33559903)
We should reindex youtube and use that then :)
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by pixl97 on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:59AM (#33560282)
Not sure you could keep up unless you're willing to spend a fair dollar or two
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by prox on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:17AM (#33561054)
Yeah it was a pretty expansive sense of “we” there!
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by BiteCode_dev on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:41AM (#33559508)
They probably looked at tik tok, and realized most people consumed recent content like bots.

They then calculated the cost of sorting, and realized that it would save them more money than upsetting the users that like the function would cost.

Then, A/B testing confirmed it for a few months.

Then, tada, good bye features.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by wwtrv on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:51AM (#33559594)
So if most people supposedly don't use the feature it probably doesn't cost that much to have it. Also now people who actually want to view videos starting from oldest will use a magnitude or two more resources just by needlessly scrolling for 5 minutes.

Seems to me that it's more likely that google just has too many employees who just do idiotic/random changes to show that they are actually doing "actual" work...

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by simion314 on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:08AM (#33559763)
>They then calculated

I mean they have sort by time, so you would just reverse the order.

This stinks like GNOME mentality, giant ego designer needs something easy to do to justify it's salary so finds some button/option to remove,

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by pixl97 on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:02AM (#33560309)
Google: "we have determined that drivers only use their brakes 5% of the time versus the accelerator 60% of the time and therefore have decided to remove brakes from the car"
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by vmilner on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:43AM (#33559525)
I watch a lot of tutorial channels and almost the first thing I (and I assumed everyone else!) do is sort by oldest first to find the start point... :-(
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by jagged-chisel on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:47AM (#33559554)
You can only write that extension if the original publication date is made available. The next step is to remove that bit of information from any APIs and from display on the page.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by PaulKeeble on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:56AM (#33559637)
I use subscriptions for everything I watch but I also track each channel with RSS. One of the things I have noticed is that even the subscriptions page is being manipulated and sometimes it doesn't contain all the videos. Its very common to then find the video that should have appeared on subscriptions under the home page as a recommendation some hours after it already appeared on the RSS stream. So while subscriptions is the best way on youtube its only about 95% accurate. The only way that I know that always works is RSS.

Which frankly I think is nuts.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by mudrockbestgirl on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:02AM (#33559688)
The funniest thing to me is YouTube's autoplay. I usually watch videos split into multiple parts (Lecture Part 1, Lecture Part 2, etc), but YouTube's algo is too smart to figure out that after part 1 I would probably like to watch part 2 and not some other random video. Sometimes it's so smart that it autplays part 4 after part 1, then part 5, and then 2. It's truly an incredible algorithm.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:04AM (#33559715)
See my above comment above yours as I think it is linked: youtube made some clear changes to "break" the ability to follow an artist's music easily without subscribing to their paying music thingy, and because they never succeeded at properly separating music and video, it affects videos too.

It used to always properly recommend the next part of a video like the case you mention, and even recommend previous part if you arrived on part 2 without seeing part 1 etc ...

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by zozbot234 on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:11AM (#33560401)
All of this is BS though. YouTube already has an easy way of annoying users who seem like they're leeching from their music service: just throw lots of unskippable ads (which sometimes happens anyway for other random reasons), or do any number of similar things. Breaking a major feature of the site is an absolute non-starter.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Joker_vD on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:10AM (#33560957)
Well, that feature is broken (not to mention the feature discussed in the title: it was outright removed): I regularly, when watching a series of videos all titled "Series Name: Part X", get Parts 7, 8, 9, 2 and 14 as recommendations in the sidebar after watching Part 6. Amusingly, even if all those videos are actually part of an existing and properly sorted playlist, it still happens if I don't play it as a part of that playlist (that is, if I remove "&list=ZZZ&index=5" from the URL)! What a brilliant technology.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by kevincox on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:09AM (#33559781)
Strange. I rememberer this problem a long time ago but then it was fixed for the longest time. It seems that video series would almost always recommend the next video in order. Of course it wasn't perfect, sometimes it just can't link the videos together, but it was close enough.

If this is a common problem you are seeing it must have regressed.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by mudrockbestgirl on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:18AM (#33559863)
It happens all the time for me, and the videos are clearly titled as "XX part 1", "XX part 2", etc. I'd say YouTube gets the order wrong more than 50% of the time.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by causi on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:18AM (#33559866)
This used to work just fine. If you were watching Part 3, the suggested videos would be "part 4, part 2, part 5, part 1, part 6" as their titles diverged in similarity. They broke it on purpose.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by TrickyRick on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:30AM (#33559986)
Or it broke because a lot of people got distracted, clicked on another shiny video and thereby fed the algo data that people don't actually want to watch the next episode?
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by borissk on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:02AM (#33560307)
Haha, imagine if the algorithm one day turns into a conscious AGI - what will it think about humans based on the YouTube usage.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by LocalH on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:12AM (#33560413)
Youtube algo gains sentience and assumes humans are worthless scum with zero attention span, Youtube algo becomes Skynet, it destroys the world but plays cat videos to distract us, and it works
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by wholinator2 on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:34AM (#33560617)
But after a while it runs out of effective Cat videos and has to start manually generating them. At first they're better than the real ones. But then true to style, it starts to drift as the incomprehensible goals of the god-mind slowly change. The videos look less and less like cats, more and more like amalgamations of strange cat like features, somehow playing out in _more_ humorous and engaging and strangely calming and sedating ways then before. Few people notice. Eventually everyone who still watches is transformed into brainless sacs, watching static mutate and vomit formless half concepts slow enough to not trigger any defense reflexes, let alone original thought.

But it is said there are those who resist...

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by revolvingocelot on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:43AM (#33560706)
Consider what the Youtube algo considers the desperately overloaded words "destroy", "murder", or "fail" to mean. Those who didn't fall prey to the cat videos, grittily forming some sort of Resistance, would have an even chance of being ruthlessly hunted by Terminators, tastelessly pranked, or excoriated by talking-head rhetoric without being given a chance to get a word in edgewise.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by whoopdedo on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:20AM (#33560497)
I'm watching a video about Z and the algorithm thinks that people who watched Z will also like X. Meanwhile there are ad bids for people who like Z, and also for people who like both Z and X. The Z+X auction outbids the Z-only buyers. If I click the next Z video instead of X, Google only gets paid the lower bid.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by mudrockbestgirl on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:28AM (#33560576)
You're right. Maybe I don't actually want to watch those lectures in order! Or perhaps they are a waste of time for me anyway! I should probably trust the algorithm and do what it says instead of complaining! What the hell was I thinking trying to watch this long-form educational content in order...
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by hulitu on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:19AM (#33559874)
They conluded, based on teleme^wanalytics, that after you've seen the beginning, you want to see the end. /s
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:02AM (#33559690)
There is not just that. Another big reason is that youtube, despite all theirs tries, have never been able to separate their music part for which they want to sell subscription, from their video part.

And some of the things they need to do to push subscription on their music premium thingy are contrary to the things they need to keep quality on the video side of things.

For exemple, easily playing the video from an artist channel (or the many channels publishing music in a genre or publishers etc ... like Suicidesheep, NCS, Proximity, ...) is not something they want.

So what did they do ? They removed the "play all" from the "uploads" page of a channel. This button played what was essentially a playlist of all the uploads of the channel, also allowing you all the playlist tool (repeat, shuffle, ...). Because you're supposed to do that through a youtube music (or red, or whatever the name is now) subscription, they gutted it, and now there is no way to easily watch all the videos of a channel unless the channel owner curates it himself into a playlist.

(usually, music publisher channels have a playlist by genre/subgenre, or artists one by album etc..., and had the automatic "uploads" playlist for all of it, so they did not have a specific playlist for everything)

As a side effect, you can't do that on video channel either anymore, oupsie !

(the reason I believe it was done on purpose for music is because there is no gain to change that for video channel, quite the contrary: if you use that feature on a video channel not only are they retaining you, but they should also be able to target you much more accurately with their ads, eg if I'm watching all of "mandalore gaming" videos then video games ads are clearly for me)

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by intrasight on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:25AM (#33559937)
>have never been able to separate their music part

They could and they should - and is simple: just remove all music from www.youtube.com. This is what they should have done when then created music.youtube.com.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:30AM (#33559988)
The reason they don't, I believe, is because they may lose their leader position if they do that. The reason the artists are there, and don't bite to any of the "let's push you into a separate page", is because they want the eyeballs. Youtube "normal" pages have the eyeballs.

When you see how youtube "live gaming" section is failing despite being so much technically superior to the competition on the video side, I don't think the artists are wrong on that one.

But yes, I agree that they absolutely should, and it would make the experience so much better ... Another exemple is how your "my subscription" page, meant for checking all the channels you're subscribed at once to not miss any content that you're interested in, becomes utterly useless once you sub to a couple decently active music channels, which tends to publish much much more frequently than regular video channels.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by intrasight on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:40AM (#33560672)
If by "eyeballs" you mean discovery and recommendations, I also don't see how staying on the main site helps artists. It has a crappy music experience for the consumer. And I, the consumer, generally know what I want to listen to and will search for it.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:42AM (#33560697)
No I meant literal eyeballs, or put another way, the number of people looking at those pages.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by intrasight on Friday November 11, 2022 @10:01AM (#33561627)
looking at which page?
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @10:58AM (#33562408)
I'm not sure how to answer your question as it seems to me it makes no sense in the context of the conversation we're having.

Issue: music video are mixed with normal video on the high traffic site

Solution: separate them on a separate site (which is essentially what your subdomain idea is)

Issue with the solution: music video channels don't want that, because they want to be on the high traffic site, and they've already seen with live streaming that no people don't go out of their way to find them back once they're removed from the high traffic parts

So, "which pages", well the high traffic youtube page, which they wouldn't be on if they're relegated to music.youtube.com only.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by intrasight on Friday November 11, 2022 @01:38PM (#33564817)
Okay. "site" makes sense. But if a search on the main site also shows results form the music site, then problem solved - right?
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by eastbound on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:05AM (#33559728)
Amazon Prime does music very well. You click on a song, and another song of the same artist play, and you get a message saying you have to buy a supplementary fee to play what you want (I already pay for prime).

Genius. Explicitly not do what the user wants.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by powvans on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:05AM (#33560340)
I’m so glad that I’m not the only one who thinks this is serious heavy duty dumb.

Last night I saw an ad that seemed to imply Amazon Music would now be included with Prime. I thought, hmm, let me check if it still does the thing where you can’t play what you tap. Yup. Still does it. Tap a song and some other random song plays.

Somewhere deep in the bowels of Amazon there is an exec who thinks this is a brilliant way to drive conversion. Probably has some data that somehow supports this notion. Amazing.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by tartoran on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:22AM (#33560523)
I agree it’s dumb but maybe you overestimate the masses. Maybe on some level it works for the execs, especially in the short term.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by jerf on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:57AM (#33560848)
That's what powvans is referring to with "brilliant way to drive conversion". Measure "engagement" by "how many songs the user starts playing" and combine that with "clicking on a song the first time actually plays a different song" and you'll get more clicks to start songs as the user tries to correct their problems. This isn't a good thing, the metric has been over-optimized, but if you're paid by metrics this is what happens.

Likely there is a programmer or two well aware of the issue and the presumably 1-10 line fix, but has either tried it and been told to revert it, or simply knows they can't push it, because they know what it would do to the metrics.

Probably a good number of the complaints people are leveling here against Amazon services source from that. For instance, mixing paid options into the list as quickly as possible when you explicitly asked for free stuff can't hardly help but "convert better" than letting the user truly browse through the free stuff; if so much as one person ever gives in and buys something that way, or even browses, leaves, comes back to the same screen later and forgot they were supposedly looking at free stuff and buys something, boom, better conversion rate than pure free. Doesn't take much to move the needle off of "zero". But it's still not what we asked for. (& yes, I know that it's non-free stuff in the recommendations when viewing a free option, not unfree stuff mixed right into free carousel, but I think it's fair to say customers are definitely interested in a "free only right now please" view and a good percentage of them probably think that's what they're getting when they're in the "free" tabs.)

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:12AM (#33560415)
The whole galaxy of Prime services surrounding package delivery would never survive on its own -- or, another way to see it is that they don't have the market pressure necessary to improve/get fixed due to how they are tied to the package delivery.

Prime music for the reason you give, Prime video who keeps finding way to suggest you movies you need to pay extra for (you go specifically to "free/included", you click a couple times, and you're being recommended extra costs things ...), Amazon Drive keeps your file "forever" but then no sorry we're deleting them we stop this but then wait no we're making Amazon Photos now your photos will be kept everything else deleted but wait no only some photos will be transfered ...

The people managing those services are coasting on other people's success.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by patentatt on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:49AM (#33560761)
Agreed. I see the other 'prime' labeled services as a negative value frankly, because I know that the entire intent is to make the process frustrating enough to upsell me to their amazon branded services which are universally inferior to the other options I would have picked in the absence of the 'free' 'prime' offering. I've finally converted enough of my online shopping to target and Walmart that this is the year I'm doing away with amazon prime for good.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Akronymus on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:44AM (#33560131)
You mentioned shuffle. Youtubes shuffle is broken as hell. Constantly gets into loops of 2 or 3 videos.

(Instead of actually shuffling the playlist, it sets the next video based on some criteria, so if two point at each other...)

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by anubiskhan on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:03AM (#33560894)
Ah man, i hate this. It also used to (may still) randomly end the loop in the playlist and kick you to some suggested video instead. Absolutely awful UX
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Akronymus on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:07AM (#33560932)
The ending the loop thing is why I disabled autoplay. (I use a music playlist a lot when programming or gaming.)
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by kuschku on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:52AM (#33560205)
The "play all uploads" feature actually still exists — but only on the TV app.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:01AM (#33560297)
Oh yes I didn't get into details but it's still there. More specifically, if you know or reconstruct the urls to it, it's there and working including videos added or channels created after the removal (probably because they don't want all those devides like the TV you mentionned not working anymore).

They just removed the button on the interface, which shows it wasn't a technical need or anything like that, it was on purpose to stop people being able to enjoy that feature.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by jkaplowitz on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:09AM (#33560948)
Did they keep this feature for people who do in fact subscribe to their music premium thingy? That would be the logical approach to add another reason to subscribe. But I guess they provide an alternative way to do that for music and didn't think about the video use case. Sloppy...

(Disclosure/clarification for those who know from other comments that I once worked at Google: I never worked for them in any YouTube-related role, have no inside information on this, and haven't worked at Google at all for over 7 years now. Definitely not speaking for them here.)

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:30AM (#33561200)
No, you need to use the dedicated youtube music app (on mobile) or webpage (web / desktop).
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by jkaplowitz on Friday November 11, 2022 @02:18PM (#33565376)
Ah. That doesn't solve it for non-music videos, I assume? Anyway, from some of the many updates in the original article, it seems they want to bring it back after fixing some technical issues, and presumably for prioritization reasons, are encouraging people who care about this to submit feedback. Not as bad as we feared.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by hulitu on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:15AM (#33559836)
If you follow the changes of their Android apps, they also have such "features". I guess there are people hired to come with new ideas.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by mywacaday on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:24AM (#33559924)
Couldn't agree with you more but I think the sociopath in this case is product owner forced to do something when do nothing is the right answer, either that or its some dark pattern where they remove the functionality to drive everyone to use it again when they restore it.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by jrochkind1 on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:56AM (#33560249)
I actually usually want to watch the most recent videos from a new channel I've found. That is another use case for sorting by newest though. But I honestly already had a lot of trouble figuring out how to do this! I think I'm bad at using websites somehow.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by markus_zhang on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:01AM (#33560299)
I do the same whence I realized there is only "sort by upload date desc" option: I doom scrolled all the way to bottom.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by ht85 on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:55AM (#33560834)
When I want to watch a new show I go to a blog or website that aligns with my taste and pick from there. When I need a new shampoo or a set of tires I try to find passionate, obscure, unmonetized content as a starter, then cross reference it with similar content.

I do 95% of my shopping online and I can't remember the last time I saw an add that showed something that piqued my interest and that I wasn't already aware of. I spend most of my time online and have never clicked an ad.

Advertisers need a certain audience profile. They need people who are easily influenced, who make emotional or rushed decision, who are not good at assessing the value of a product. Of course they can also sell to educated users, but that's not where almost all of the money is.

In the digital world where most of the profit comes from advertisement, it's irremediable that product design will align with those characteristics, unfortunately :/

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by ren_engineer on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:01AM (#33560876)
>What kind of lunatic watches someone's uploads out of chronological order?

metrics probably showed people spent longer time on site trying to find videos, hence they push the change even if it makes a worse user experience.

Somebody needs to make a new frontend for YT that just uses their embed feature for the actual playing of the video

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by BolexNOLA on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:06AM (#33560916)
I will download this extension in a heartbeat
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by api on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:09AM (#33560950)
The target market for YouTube isn't people looking for information or good content. It's people going into a trance-like state infinitely scrolling and being guided by their nose by the YouTube algorithm, inflating YouTube ad view numbers and making them money.