News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by mudrockbestgirl on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:02AM (#33559688)
The funniest thing to me is YouTube's autoplay. I usually watch videos split into multiple parts (Lecture Part 1, Lecture Part 2, etc), but YouTube's algo is too smart to figure out that after part 1 I would probably like to watch part 2 and not some other random video. Sometimes it's so smart that it autplays part 4 after part 1, then part 5, and then 2. It's truly an incredible algorithm.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by nolok on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:04AM (#33559715)
See my above comment above yours as I think it is linked: youtube made some clear changes to "break" the ability to follow an artist's music easily without subscribing to their paying music thingy, and because they never succeeded at properly separating music and video, it affects videos too.

It used to always properly recommend the next part of a video like the case you mention, and even recommend previous part if you arrived on part 2 without seeing part 1 etc ...

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by zozbot234 on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:11AM (#33560401)
All of this is BS though. YouTube already has an easy way of annoying users who seem like they're leeching from their music service: just throw lots of unskippable ads (which sometimes happens anyway for other random reasons), or do any number of similar things. Breaking a major feature of the site is an absolute non-starter.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by Joker_vD on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:10AM (#33560957)
Well, that feature is broken (not to mention the feature discussed in the title: it was outright removed): I regularly, when watching a series of videos all titled "Series Name: Part X", get Parts 7, 8, 9, 2 and 14 as recommendations in the sidebar after watching Part 6. Amusingly, even if all those videos are actually part of an existing and properly sorted playlist, it still happens if I don't play it as a part of that playlist (that is, if I remove "&list=ZZZ&index=5" from the URL)! What a brilliant technology.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by kevincox on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:09AM (#33559781)
Strange. I rememberer this problem a long time ago but then it was fixed for the longest time. It seems that video series would almost always recommend the next video in order. Of course it wasn't perfect, sometimes it just can't link the videos together, but it was close enough.

If this is a common problem you are seeing it must have regressed.

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by mudrockbestgirl on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:18AM (#33559863)
It happens all the time for me, and the videos are clearly titled as "XX part 1", "XX part 2", etc. I'd say YouTube gets the order wrong more than 50% of the time.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by causi on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:18AM (#33559866)
This used to work just fine. If you were watching Part 3, the suggested videos would be "part 4, part 2, part 5, part 1, part 6" as their titles diverged in similarity. They broke it on purpose.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by TrickyRick on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:30AM (#33559986)
Or it broke because a lot of people got distracted, clicked on another shiny video and thereby fed the algo data that people don't actually want to watch the next episode?
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by borissk on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:02AM (#33560307)
Haha, imagine if the algorithm one day turns into a conscious AGI - what will it think about humans based on the YouTube usage.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by LocalH on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:12AM (#33560413)
Youtube algo gains sentience and assumes humans are worthless scum with zero attention span, Youtube algo becomes Skynet, it destroys the world but plays cat videos to distract us, and it works
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by wholinator2 on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:34AM (#33560617)
But after a while it runs out of effective Cat videos and has to start manually generating them. At first they're better than the real ones. But then true to style, it starts to drift as the incomprehensible goals of the god-mind slowly change. The videos look less and less like cats, more and more like amalgamations of strange cat like features, somehow playing out in _more_ humorous and engaging and strangely calming and sedating ways then before. Few people notice. Eventually everyone who still watches is transformed into brainless sacs, watching static mutate and vomit formless half concepts slow enough to not trigger any defense reflexes, let alone original thought.

But it is said there are those who resist...

Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by revolvingocelot on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:43AM (#33560706)
Consider what the Youtube algo considers the desperately overloaded words "destroy", "murder", or "fail" to mean. Those who didn't fall prey to the cat videos, grittily forming some sort of Resistance, would have an even chance of being ruthlessly hunted by Terminators, tastelessly pranked, or excoriated by talking-head rhetoric without being given a chance to get a word in edgewise.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by whoopdedo on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:20AM (#33560497)
I'm watching a video about Z and the algorithm thinks that people who watched Z will also like X. Meanwhile there are ad bids for people who like Z, and also for people who like both Z and X. The Z+X auction outbids the Z-only buyers. If I click the next Z video instead of X, Google only gets paid the lower bid.
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by mudrockbestgirl on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:28AM (#33560576)
You're right. Maybe I don't actually want to watch those lectures in order! Or perhaps they are a waste of time for me anyway! I should probably trust the algorithm and do what it says instead of complaining! What the hell was I thinking trying to watch this long-form educational content in order...
Re:YouTube confirms that it has removed the “sort by oldest/... by hulitu on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:19AM (#33559874)
They conluded, based on teleme^wanalytics, that after you've seen the beginning, you want to see the end. /s