News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by InTheArena on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:45AM (#29188336)
Historically the thought "we have gotten the hang of this" has ended badly when dealing with spacecraft and rockets. The potential failure profile that we are in now is that there may be somethings that engineers accepted the risk that can lead to loss of mission, vehicle and life. See Apollo 1, Apollo 13, Challenger (after 25 shuttle missions) and Columbia (after a further 88).

Its great to see the "routine-ness" - but SpaceX needs to stay humble and stay focused. A accident now could cost everything they have done to this point.

-- edited to clarify potential failure mode.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by rbanffy on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:30AM (#29188908)
> and Columbia (after a further 88).

I'll never get over the fact that NASA never made an assessment of tile damage after liftoff in over 100 flights before Columbia. All these machines are experimental in the sense we still don't understand completely what happens with them and treating them like 737's is a huge mistake.

Even in the case of the 737, the MAX proved we didn't understand a 737 thoroughly enough to ensure safe operation.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by dotancohen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:29AM (#29189810)

  > Even in the case of the 737, the MAX proved we didn't
  > understand a 737 thoroughly enough to ensure safe operation.
Actually, we did. But it was thought economical to ignore proper engine placement and weight distribution, and make up for it with automated elevator trimming.

Economical being a conservative word. Designing a new airframe for the newer, larger, more efficient engines would have been very expensive.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by laverya on Thursday November 11, 2021 @03:59PM (#29193107)
NASA not running an actual assessment after STS-27R was almost lost to a similar foam strike in 1988 is really the flabbergasting part. If that foam strike had been almost anywhere else on the wing, it would have resulted in the crew and vehicle being lost. But instead it punched a hole right where there was a double-thickness aluminum plate for an antenna mounting, and so didn't burn through.

Columbia had a foam strike on the leading edge and wasn't so lucky.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by elif on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:27AM (#29188867)
The programs you listed with 4 failures launched 164 times including test flights. Falcon 9 has provided 127 successful missions and 1 failure.

On visits to the ISS it's 37 vs 25.

If you look at the ratio of non-human flights to human flights SpaceX is far more conservative of human life.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by ortusdux on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:34AM (#29188990)
Also, the 1 failure was during a pre-flight static test fire. If it had been a crewed flight, the crew would not have boarded at that point. It's considered a failure because they test fired the rocked with the payload attached, resulting in its destruction. They have since stopped performing this test with the payload attached.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by croddin on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:00AM (#29189378)
The 1 failure in those numbers is actually CRS-7, not Amos-6. If you count Amos-6 there have been 2 failures but as you pointed out crew wouldn’t have been on board and they don’t static fire with payload anymore. Also for CRS-7 the dragon survived and would have been fine if the parachutes had been programmed to deploy in that situation. Either way there have been a lot of improvements and ~100 successful launches since either of those.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by ortusdux on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:20AM (#29189668)
Ahh, my mistake. This chart is very informative for those interested: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Falcon_9_and_Falcon_He...
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Fatnino on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:55PM (#29190864)
Amos6 style explosiw would have been surviveable if there was crew on board because of the launch escape thrusters.

See Soyuz T-10a

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by oxplot on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:21AM (#29189683)
Don't forget that assuming a crew onboard Dragon, the launch escape system (LES) is engaged before propellant loading, so even if the tanks blow up, the capsule will escape the explosion and crew will be safe.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by dotancohen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:26AM (#29189761)

  > If it had been a crewed flight, the crew would not
  > have boarded at that point.
SpaceX is unique in the field of human spaceflight in that they fuel the manned vehicles with the airmen already on board. It took quite some convincing to get NASA to allow this on NASA flights.

The advantages are that if there is a problem before the astronauts are strapped in, firing the LES on a loaded rocket will seriously hurt the astronauts and ground crew. Also, with less time between propellant loading and launch, denser, super chilled propellants can be used. This provides significant margins for boostback and recovery of the first stage boosters.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by ourmandave on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:03AM (#29188559)
You'll know they've really reached routine when people's main complaint is about the in-flight meal.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by pkdpic on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:35AM (#29189011)
You'll know they've really reached routine when people's main complaint is about not having enough leg room :^)

Also wondering what the timeline comparison is here too. Wasn't one of the problems with Columbia the advanced age of the shuttle? I'm assuming this isn't comparable to the situation with spacex?

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by dotancohen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:31AM (#29189841)

  > Wasn't one of the problems with Columbia the advanced age of the shuttle?
No. The problem that led to the loss of Columbia was fundamental and well understood - if underestimated - since STS-1 was inspected after its first landing.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Fatnino on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:58PM (#29190891)
STS-1 was known to be missing some tiles while still in space. Like as soon as they opened the payload bay doors they could see holes in the tiles on the OMS pods.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by 14 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:20AM (#29189665)
I think we will lower the bar of what is acceptable. You seem to think they need perfect track record or it’s a no go but we know that is not true. People are willing to take the odds to do something awesome. Look at the first time one of Tesla’s self driving cars caused a fatality. No one stopped using their auto pilot. It will be the same if a rocket full of people blows up, they will investigate the issue and build a safer one the next time. Then with the prospect of heading to space another crew will eagerly line up.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by dotancohen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:33AM (#29189875)

  > they will investigate the issue and build a safer one the next time
The parallels between the new Starship and the Comet are many. As excited as I am to see the new Starship flying, and I would fly it, I wouldn't want my children to fly on it.

At least, not the landing part. If they could launch and perform all exatmospheric activities in a Starship yet land in a Dragon (or Soyuz) I'd be fine with that.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by an9n on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:27PM (#29190554)
I think it's going to be a long time and many many launches of Starship before a human is put on it, at least for launch or reentry. Having a reliable separate launch system in Falcon 9/Dragon gives SpaceX a ton of flexibility in terms of launch/reentry on a relatively proven system, with transfer to orbital Starship for Moon/Mars as necessary.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by dotancohen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:23PM (#29191173)
I agree that it will take many launches before a human is put on Starship.

That said, SpaceX will probably be able to relaunch early Starships with a few months of their initial launches, and might be able to refurbish a Starship for launch within a few weeks in short order. I would not be surprised to see a single Starship perform three launches and landings by the end of 2022. We could see a dozen total Starship launches and landings in that same timeframe.

We might see people fly on it by 2023. That's not a long time.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by chinathrow on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:49AM (#29188383)
> The failure profile that we are in now is that there may be somethings that engineers accepted the risk that can lead to loss of mission, vehicle and life.

How did you get to that conclusion regarding Crew Dragon?

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by idealmedtech on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:58AM (#29188478)
Crew Dragon only has a handful of missions. What the previous commenter is talking about is risks that may have been ignored/downplayed/unsuccessfully mitigated but that Crew Dragon is simply lucky enough not to have faced.

With time and more flights, more things will have a chance to go wrong, and in spaceflight, resting on your laurels is the best way to make sure that when it does go wrong it will be catastrophic.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:16AM (#29188714)
NASA calls it "normalizing of deviance", and it's why we lost both Shuttles.

For example, the O-Rings were designed as a backup, the force generated by the solid rocket motors was supposed to seal the SRM sections together. But they knew after the first launch that the O-Rings were what was actually sealing the SRM's. But the O-Rings worked, so they didn't stop the program to fix the design. Later they found evidence of blow through the O-Rings, and again decided that since that didn't cause a crash, they were OK. Until they didn't. Tile strike damage was a similar normalization that killed 7 people.

Does SpaceX normalize deviance? They fixed the toilet, so they didn't normalize that, but what about the delayed opening of the 4th parachute in the Crew 2 landing? It seems suspicious that they launched Crew 3 so quickly after an apparent anomaly. They do claim that the delayed opening is nominal behaviour seen and accepted in testing -- that this behaviour only happens when the other 3 parachutes are working fine. If one of the others had failed the 4th would have opened quicker due to increased air pressure.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/11/double-dragon-nasa-p...

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by thaeli on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:33AM (#29188970)
NASA seems to normalize deviance when they're under political pressure to do so. I'm not sure they can be entirely trusted when it comes to their own launch systems, because of the politics involved - but so far they haven't shown similar hesitancy with commercial launch systems. It's a good separation of concerns; when NASA is "just the customer" and it's not "their rocket" they are in a better position to hold a firm line on safety issues.

That NASA did not see the parachute as an issue speaks volumes. It looked bad visually, but having watched enough space launches and how mission control reacts to off-nominal data - clearly they were comfortable with the performance, because they didn't flinch at all. NASA just doesn't sign off on these commercial launches with NASA astronauts on board if they have any inkling that something won't go right - they aren't under the political pressure to "save the Shuttle program" or whatever.

I have more concern about NASA getting politically-imposed "go fever" with SLS.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by jpgvm on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:36AM (#29189029)
SpaceX is on the other end of the scale, they continually change their vehicles to make small improvements all the time. It's highly unlikely the same paralysis could manifest at SpaceX with it's current culture.

More likely is a failure of the other extreme where if changes are normalized and something that seems sufficiently simple actually has an outsized impact on the craft. I think such a thing is still relatively unlikely given how much testing and modelling goes into all their changes but it's much more likely than catastrophic failure occurring due to known design deficiencies that are left because they haven't yet caused failures.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by 14 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:28AM (#29189798)
This made me think of a local pilot who didn’t load his load correctly and when he went to climb some of the load shifted back in the plane. The sudden weight caused the plane to nose up and the plane lost lift and fell to the pilot and passenger death. Something as simple as a missing strap can bring down a plane. I can only imagine the amount if potential disasters on a rocket.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by dotancohen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:35AM (#29189901)
That was a cargo 747, it wasn't the pilots who secured the load.

There's actually a video of the plane trying to recover with the COM so far back, it is horrific.

EDIT: The video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5fpxm0D46iQ

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by 14 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:37PM (#29195751)
That video isn’t available in my country but the one I was thinking of was some local pilots who crashed.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by dotancohen on Saturday November 13, 2021 @09:10AM (#29209819)
That's horrible. I wonder if the shifting of loads is a common creash precursor.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by jpgvm on Sunday November 14, 2021 @07:01AM (#29216731)
Not that common. The loadmaster is tasked with ensuring cargo is loaded correctly in commercial and military settings. In private aircraft there is generally less or no cargo of note other than the fuel and passengers so it's very uncommon.

Because the loadmaster is a member of the aircrew they incentivized to be good at their job and veto unsafe loads because it's their life at stake if the aircraft becomes tail heavy in flight.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by dotancohen on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:51AM (#29224535)
Thank you.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by rbanffy on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:33AM (#29188963)
> that this behaviour only happens when the other 3 parachutes are working fine

I'd love to see the causal relationship between both that makes it safe to land with 3 parachutes (I remember they added the 4th as an added precaution that reminds me of the O-ring issue)

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by chinathrow on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:00AM (#29188512)
I agree regarding the handful of missions argument with Crew Dragon, but let's not forget all the successful Cargo Dragon missions here as I'm sure they play a role in (ongoing) safety assessments.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by InTheArena on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:05AM (#29188585)
Sure. It helps. One of the things NASA considered was Shuttle-C, a cargo varient of the space shuttle system, which would have given NASA a way to tinker on the engine /SRB stack without crew onboard. Of course, that would not have saved columbia (the orbiter itself was the problem).

This stuff is called rocket science for a reason.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by progre on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:01AM (#29189386)
Well, still... It's not exactly brain surgery is it?
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by cletus on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:29AM (#29188157)
Estimates of costs for getting payloads into LEO in the Apollo era are around $50,000/kg (in modern USD terms). I believe the Shuttle was pretty similar.

Estimates for SpaceX seem to be around $2,700/kg but I'm not sure this factors in first stage reuse so it's probably closer to $1,000/kg.

Starship will get this into the $hundreds/kg while also being able to launch individually much larger payloads. It's hard to overstate just how important that is.

I personally believe this will have a profound effect on commercial space operations including a likely commercial station that is much larger than the ISS. Personally I think we should invest in a station with spin gravity on at least part of the station. All of this being a necessary step towards industry.

And all of this from a private investment of ~$20 billion, which I believe was roughly the development cost of either SLS or Orion.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by brianwawok on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:36AM (#29188227)
F9 price could also drop a bit if they could nail fairing recovery, as they are still dumping a pretty expensive thing in the water every launch. Seems a much harder problem than stage1 recovery though.

But either way, this is insane. Taking something from $50,000 to < $1,000 per KG in a handful of years. Curious all the applications that come form this. I don't fully understand what all we can do in space even with it cheaper. A base to asteroid mine could be a cute start.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:51AM (#29188396)
They are already doing fairing recovery. The fish it out of the water and reuse it. The stopped trying to catch them. Dropping them in the ocean for a shore while is not doing enough damage.

Also, the price is not low margin, lower cost is just more profit for SpaceX.

Estimations are that internal cost is only ~20 million $ or maybe 25. The price has not gone down much with re-usability.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by chasd00 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:13AM (#29188679)
the problem is spacex doesn't have a price competitor so, ironically, the only price pressure is upward. I was hoping Blue Origin would at least keep pace because then there would be an alternative in the same neighborhood on price.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by plopz on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:29AM (#29188889)
Who knows, maybe one of the other up and coming companies like Rocket Lab could add some pressure.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by brianwawok on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:25AM (#29188838)
Oh I missed the bit where they were still usable after a fishing out, that is great.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by qnsi on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:47AM (#29188351)
Regarding commercial space station, there is Bezos-led Orbital Reef

https://www.orbitalreef.com/

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:00AM (#29188510)
NASA received 12 applications for commercial space station concepts. Only 4 of them have been made public so far, and some of those likely cost under $1 billion. Orbital Reef has to be well over $10 billion so the only way that's ever going to happen is if Bezos pays for it himself.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fJ01AtbRH2Y&t=2s

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by ceejayoz on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:20AM (#29188750)
Bezos-led companies should probably get their engines sorted out and make orbit before they go planning any space stations.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @08:41AM (#29187703)
How totally they have beaten Boeing is quite amazing. Boeing received almost 2 billion more money (or will if they actually finish). SpaceX total development contract was for only 2.3 billion.

Boeing high price was partly justified by 'higher schedule certainty'. They were selected over Sierra Nevada who had a 3.6 billion $ proposal using the Dreamchaser aircraft.

Some news emerged that Boeing believed that SpaceX could not deliver anyway and if they both didn't deliver the could renegotiate with NASA and demand more money. Unfortunately for them, SpaceX delivered without asking for more money.

Since then Boeing has failed its first test flight and has run into major issues with the second one, and it will not launch for many more months. All of these costs are carried by Boeing, only when they complete further milestones will the get paid.

This is very unlike the contracts that Lockheed Martin and Boeing work under for the Orion capsule and the SLS contract. Just in comparison, those system already at up almost 20 billion each, they have sometimes over 2 billion a year in funding. The extra cost for failing to deliver these systems is paid by NASA.

So the complete Dragon capsule development is basically 1 yearly budget for one of those programs. Dragon could do almost everything Orion does with a few enhancements (certainty not costing billions every year).

SLS and Orion are left over from the dark days and they need to be canceled, all future human spaceflight need to be done at fixed cost. If you want to play, you need to be willing to risk your company on it.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by mabbo on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:26AM (#29188129)
> This is very unlike the contracts that Lockheed Martin and Boeing work under for the Orion capsule and the SLS contract. Just in comparison, those system already at up almost 20 billion each, they have sometimes over 2 billion a year in funding. The extra cost for failing to deliver these systems is paid by NASA.

The growing elephant in the room is SpaceX's Starship. What happens if Boeing says "Yeah, sorry, we need to delay the moon landings 3 more years- at $2B/year out of your pockets" and SpaceX steps up and says "Cancel the SLS/Orion program, give us $2B one time and we'll put your astronauts on the surface on schedule with Starship".

All that would need to happen to reach that is SpaceX succeeding and Boeing falling behind. A formerly-unlikely scenario that now is the norm.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by m_mueller on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:40AM (#29188268)
I'm big on following Starship development, but I think people are a bit overly optimistic about what can be achieved with it in the next couple of years (while having a blind eye on what it will be able to do within a 20y timeframe). From current development and past experience at human rating their Dragon I think that it will take 7-10 years[1] for Starship to reach that level. But once it does reach it, it will make pretty much everything else obsolete and it will start a new spaceflight era, where ISRU and space mining suddenly become a thing within just a few years.

[1] take Falcon 9 as a reference - it first launched in 2010 and their first manned mission was only last year in 2020. yes, SpaceX has grown significantly since then, but so have their ambitions with Starship. Fuel transfer and 2nd stage reentry/landing are significant further milestones to reach besides just getting it to orbit. And then they'll have to prove safety margins, life support systems, abort scenarios...

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by SEJeff on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:50AM (#29188387)
But Falcon 9 also took a long time because it doesn't launch all that often and SpaceX had a lot to learn about how to work with NASA. The "idea" of Starship / Superheavy is that the same first and second stage can get caught by the landing tower "chopsticks", have a crane re-mate them, fuel them, and relaunch them within 24 hours or less.

If they can relaunch the same entire stack more than say 2 times per day, they're going to absolutely hit the reliability margins[1] that NASA / the FAA want to see in a very short time period.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human-rating_certification

    The NASA CCP human-rating standards require that the probability of a loss on ascent does not exceed 1 in 500, and that the probability of a loss on descent did not exceed 1 in 500. The overall mission loss risk, which includes vehicle risk from micrometeorites and orbital debris while in orbit for up to 210 days, is required to be no more than 1 in 270.[3] Maximum sustained acceleration is limited to 3 g.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by voakbasda on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:25AM (#29188846)
I would very much like to see the data and math used to calculate these odds.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by cryptonector on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:37AM (#29189034)
According to Feynman, in the case of the shuttle there was no such calculation, just assertion.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by SEJeff on Thursday November 11, 2021 @07:37PM (#29195051)
The shuttle progam's motto was "beat the russians" more or less, so that checks out.

There is a lot of background in the biographies of both Chuck Yaeger AND John Glenn about some of this if you like that sort of thing.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:47AM (#29198342)
> The shuttle progam's motto was "beat the russians" more or less, so that checks out.

And they achieved the exact opposite.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:54AM (#29188431)
That's a general rule of thumb in tech predictions -- people overpredict the short term and underpredict the long term. So yes, Dear Moon is unlikely to fly in 2023. But it'll definitely fly before 2028. Starship has already retired their most significant technical risks. Fuel transfer and 2nd stage reentry aren't easy, but the Shuttle and ISS did them both in the 80s.

SpaceX didn't do significant work on Dragon until 2015 since Congress didn't properly fund Commercial Crew until then.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:32AM (#29188958)
I disagree. Starship HLS with requires 10 launches per mission. An extra expendable Starship/SuperHeavy launch with Orion on top is not a substantial challenge in comparison (although lots of engineering involved, but they’re good at that).
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by numpad0 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:17AM (#29188724)
Am I the only one to think Starship is starting to look a lot like X-33 program...
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by rbanffy on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:50AM (#29189233)
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:49AM (#29198361)
I mean, the X-33 was sub-orbital technology demonstrator. It was totally different in terms of reentry and control control surfaces. It uses different fuel. It doesn't use an areospike engine. Its a different color.

Not sure what you are seeing.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:39AM (#29188261)
SLS/Orion is already not needed. You could use Falcon 9/Dragon to get astronauts into Orbit and back. Then use Starship to do the moon and back part.

If you actually did a clean sheet architecture, there is literally zero reason to do SLS/Orion.

Starship is one on the critical path anyway. The only difference is you go from the capsule to Starship in LEO instead.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Denvercoder9 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:48AM (#29188371)
> Then use Starship to do the moon and back part.

The problem is that the current design for the lunar Starship doesn't have enough propellant left over to leave lunar orbit, let alone enter Earth orbit (and it has been stripped of its heatshield, so no aerocapture). Going back on a Starship requires first delivering fuel for that Starship to lunar orbit, which adds another ~8 launches to each mission.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:57AM (#29188464)
More launches are fine, that is far cheaper then SLS/Orion.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Denvercoder9 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:19AM (#29188736)
It's not just about money though, it's also about operational complexity. We don't have experience launching that many ships in that short of a timeframe (propellant boil-off is a real issue), and any one failed launch breaks the whole plan.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by socialdemocrat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:38AM (#29189932)
They don't need to use the huge starship though. In principle they could build a dedicated space craft which is fitted on top of Falcon Heavy and delivered to LEO. Being smaller than Starship you should not need refueling. Astronauts arrive to LEO using F9 and dragon, where they dock and transfer to this dedicate space craft which takes them to the moon.

They could even send the same kind of vehicle ahead of schedule to the moon as a backup for when the astronauts are going home.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by cnlevy on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:16AM (#29189597)
90% will be tanker launches, and will be reused. If one fails, you just launch the next one coming out from the Starship assembly line instead of reusing.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:40AM (#29189966)
Propellant boil-off is not that big of an issue unless you somehow blow up multiple launch sites.

And just saying 'its complex' therefore lets spend 40 billion on development and then limit our options by paying 3 billion per launch is an insane plan.

Overall complexity is reduced by not having those two legacy systems.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by socialdemocrat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:35AM (#29189897)
But this can be done before any humans are launched into LEO, so they have the luxury of screwing this up without putting any humans at risk. If it doesn't work, cancel the mission without ever launching humans into LEO, get back to the drawing board and fix the refueling issue.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by cryptonector on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:38AM (#29189057)
Meh. Give it a couple of years and it will be routine.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by oconnor663 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:45AM (#29189160)
Do they not plan to do that anyway, to reuse the HLS? Or is it a question of what can be done without risking the lives of astronauts?
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by socialdemocrat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:34AM (#29189882)
Yeah lots of ways of doing this. You could fit a LEO-to-moon transport vehicle, as described by Robert Zubrin, on a Falcon Heavy.

Basically you use Falcon9 to get in and out of LEO using Dragon.

A Falcon Heavy can push a larger space craft into LEO and it saves weight by the fact that a LEO-to-moon vehicle doesn't need heath shield and other stuff which makes a Dragon capsule heavier.

And with Falcons being cheap you could even send a whole bunch of LEO-to-moon vehicles straight to the moon surface, as well as just dump fuel tanks there.

SpaceX has a lot of these and can build them quite cheaply, so the mission will have a lot more built in safety. E.g. if you got an extra lunar ascent vehicle sitting on the landing site already before astronauts arrive, you have extra redundancy.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by iso1210 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:49AM (#29188375)
I think most people accept it's likely. I suspect Starship will land (unmanned) on the moon before Starliner enters regular service, let alone SLS
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by cryptonector on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:35AM (#29188998)
Or if SpaceX says "y'all keep waiting for SLS and Orion, we're going to the moon on our own at no cost to you".
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by jpgvm on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:44AM (#29189153)
As extreme as it sounds it really isn't that unlikely. Musk may fund it out of his own pile of fuck you money just as a marketing stunt. The first Falcon Heavy launch was pretty much the same thing. Pretty sure he could ask a bunch of folks if there is any cool payloads they want to put on the moon and just yeet it up there with a Tesla Roadster, first car on the moon.

Never underestimate the size of his ego or his sheer force of will.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by tjpnz on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:42AM (#29188292)
>we'll put your astronauts on the surface on schedule with Starship

That's already going to happen assuming things go to plan (and Bezos doesn't play any further shenanigans). They could offer seats to lunar orbit and back either with Starship or Falcon Heavy in expendable mode.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by oxplot on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:28AM (#29189791)
> Cancel the SLS/Orion program

I sure hope they do and give that money to either SpaceX or pretty much any other promising startup around (can't think of any with the payload requirements needed for a moon/mars mission).

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Causality1 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:38AM (#29188242)
Boeing is a company built for extracting the maximum possible amount of taxpayer money. SpaceX is a company built for colonizing Mars.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by xqcgrek2 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:08AM (#29187948)
>Some news emerged that Boeing believed that SpaceX could not deliver anyway and if they both didn't deliver the could renegotiate with NASA and demand more money. Unfortunately for them, SpaceX delivered without asking for more money.

Seems SpaceX didn't want to play that collusion (or prisoner's dilemma) game many government contractors play.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by capableweb on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:13AM (#29188006)
SpaceX and Boeing are in wildly different situations. SpaceX needs to do anything they can do gain contracts in the future, while Boeing is trying to extract as much value from their existing ones while not caring about the future. Boeing thought they were invincible and could just coast, SpaceX are punting today's profits into the future instead.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:15AM (#29188033)
SpaceX is motivated beyond the next government contract. They have a overarching goal and they are going there government or not. The contracts are just a temporary working with the government to advanced the overall goal.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:32AM (#29188185)
I definitely think SpaceX would do Starship deep space missions even without the government at this point, but I don’t think it is temporary at all. SpaceX gets a lot out of their relationship with NASA (massive expertise, testing capability, infrastructure, etc… SpaceX gave NASA some money for using some of their infrastructure for Inspiration 4), and NASA is a huge customer.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:46AM (#29188348)
I didn't say the relationship was temporary, or that is should be. I said any individual contract is temporary and extracting money is not the primary goal. The primary goal is advancing the overall mission.

If government would stop handing out contracts, SpaceX would try to go on as best they can anyway.

But of course as long as government is sharing in the goals SpaceX will use those.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:38AM (#29188244)
Colonizing Mars is a multi-trillion dollar operation, SpaceX can't do it alone.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by voakbasda on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:30AM (#29188913)
We have trillion dollar corporations these days. Economically, this does not seem as far out of reach as you might think.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:43AM (#29188306)
I didn't say they will do it alone. I said they are working towards their goal and take government as they can but the future profit is not the primary reason. The primary reason is getting them closer to their goal.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by rbanffy on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:43AM (#29189128)
> SLS and Orion are left over from the dark days and they need to be canceled

They do, but remember they were the low-risk bet, on tech and engines NASA already had, with contractors they already had. It most likely (Starship isn't in service just yet) will not pay, but, still, it was the right decision at the time. Betting that SpaceX would be able to a reusable booster would be risky and betting they'd be able to deliver a fully-reusable super-heavy-lift rocket would be insane.

NASA's role is not to offer the best flights for the money, but to keep the aerospace industry busy and up-to-date with their own latest technology (and to prevent them from working for foreign powers). The science is mostly a side-effect.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:03AM (#29189425)
SLS was never the low-risk bet. The low-risk bet was Atlas V Phase 2.

But you're right, it wasn't completely insane in 2010. Nobody could have predicted how successful SpaceX would be and how untrustworthy Boeing would be.

The insanity of SLS was obvious to all but the deliberately blind by 2018 when Falcon Heavy flew.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:43AM (#29190005)
> They do, but remember they were the low-risk bet, on tech and engines NASA already had, with contractors they already had.

You mean the political pork game sold as 'low' risk?

In fact, NASA own analysis showed this was not the case.

> Betting that SpaceX would be able to a reusable booster would be risky and betting they'd be able to deliver a fully-reusable super-heavy-lift rocket would be insane

That was not required for a much, much better solution.

> NASA's role is not to offer the best flights for the money, but to keep the aerospace industry busy and up-to-date with their own latest technology

So they spend 40 billion on legacy technology that is mostly pointless?

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by rbanffy on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:56PM (#29191599)
> So they spend 40 billion on legacy technology that is mostly pointless?

Of course not. Rockets and spacecraft were never the final product of NASA. The end-product of NASA is a large, trained aerospace workforce. While I agree SLS sucks, that earlier, less modified options still based on shuttle technology (such as the Shuttle-C) were better ideas in general, with SLS they had the opportunity to research and develop new materials and techniques that may be employed elsewhere, much like previous programs had vast spin-off industries.

All this investment should be able to make American aerospace companies more competitive in the global market.

Is SLS a better rocket than Starship/Superheavy? Probably not, but, again, that's not their goal.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:43AM (#29198306)
> The end-product of NASA is a large, trained aerospace workforce.

You would get a larger better workforce if you actually developed new things, not put together 50 year old parts.

> less modified options still based on shuttle technology

Everything based about anything Shuttle is basically a horrible idea. Shuttle is what has dragged down NASA for 50 years now.

Literally non of those solutions would ever be even close to be cost efficient.

> with SLS they had the opportunity to research and develop new materials and techniques that may be employed elsewhere, much like previous programs had vast spin-off industries.

What are you talking about? SLS is maybe the list innovative large rocket ever made. The engines are literally Shuttle engines. The Upper stage is literally a Delta IV Upper Stage with an adapter on it.

The boosters are mostly the same as Shuttle booster with one more element (that mostly seems to have been added so they can give that contractor a couple 100 million in development money.

The core stage is based on the Shuttle external tank and outside of a some welding technology its not innovative at all.

The whole SLS program was LITERALLY designed to be the least innovative possible program. That's what is his whole justification was that it would be minimal development.

NASA own evaluation pointed out that they would end up much more cost effective by doing some development but congress killed that:

https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceLaunchSystem/comments/kt1vlf/r...

> All this investment should be able to make American aerospace companies more competitive in the global market.

Funny then that US had literally 0% of the global commercial launch market. Seems like they achieved the exact opposite, make companies that are depended on government contract that were mostly good at maintaining legacy systems.

A lot of the best sat companies were from places like Canada and Britain. The companies that made the most money from NASA are exactly those that are not that competitive.

> Is SLS a better rocket than Starship/Superheavy? Probably not, but, again, that's not their goal.

The goal was to pay the same old contractors, in pure pork program.

You don't have to be close to Starship to make a rocket far better then SLS. SLS spend 20 billion and they didn't even reach the 130t to LEO rocket that congress demanded.

The SLS that will finally launch in 2022 is like 70-90t to LEO rocket and to get to the actual design goal it will require another 10 billion or so.

Not being critical of it with the defense 'it was designed to be pork' makes no sense.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by kilroy123 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:34AM (#29188215)
"I'm convinced that the first person to step foot on Mars will arrive there riding on a Boeing rocket" —Boeing CEO Dennis Muilenburg (2016)
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by InTheArena on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:47AM (#29188359)
Boeing passing over Mulally, and eventually hiring Muilenburg is the single largest mistake in their long history.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by capableweb on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:06AM (#29188600)
Maybe mistake for their own stock price/financials, but for humanity, avoiding passing certification/testing/examination again in order to ship a new airplane model seems to be some magnitudes worse.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by ragebol on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:03AM (#29187903)
> Dragon could do almost everything Orion does with a few enhancements

What can Dragon not do that Orion will be able to do? Can Orion go further from Earth?

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:18AM (#29188059)
Orion is being qualified for faster reentry. Dragon currently only qualified for LEO reentry. But they both use ablative heatshields which scale in a straightforward way to higher speed reentries.

Orion also has more propellant, more delta-v, so it has more post-separation maneuvering capability. Dragon would need either expanded tanks on board or maybe some extra propulsion capability in the trunk or perhaps docking with a small propulsion module (think like how the Apollo command module docked with the LM in Apollo 13 and used that for maneuvering delta-v).

Neither of those things are huge. There are a few other things that are relatively minor, like shielding (literally just mass of plastic, very little engineering involved) and extra consumables for longer free flight mission and getting Falcon Heavy fully up to Falcon 9 human rating standards (pretty straightforward as it’s almost identical to Falcon 9 but with 2 side boosters).

You could test those things on an uncrewed test flight fairly cheaply. In some ways, it’d be safer than Orion/SLS as the vehicle and spacecraft have a lot more flight history already.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:36AM (#29188229)
Past NASA administrator Bolden said that NASA would never human rate Falcon Heavy, so SpaceX didn't design Falcon Heavy for human rating. There are a couple of places where the margin is less than the 1.4 that NASA considers to be a requirement for human rating. The walls of the F9 are strong enough to have a 1.4 margin on their own, but adding the force and torsion of 2 extra boosters lowers the margin significantly. Getting those margins up to 1.4 would require a fundamental redesign and that's something SpaceX will never do. They expect Starship to become operational before any Falcon Heavy redesign ever could.

But in the opinion of experts Falcon Heavy is considerably safer than the human rated SLS[1] and massively safer than the Shuttle ever was, so human rating Falcon Heavy is just a matter of NASA swallowing their pride and acknowledging that.

1: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2021/02/24/sls-is-cancell...

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:54AM (#29188430)
Bolden has said a lot of things dismissive of SpaceX, and they haven’t turned out to be very accurate. The Administrator has Congressional political constraints and is part of the aerospace old guard that had a sort of learned-helplessness about new aerospace endeavors. Falcon Heavy can absolutely be human rated. There’s also the possibility of LEO rendezvous between a Dragon launched on a Falcon 9 and a filled Falcon Heavy upper stage with a docking port on it.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:44AM (#29189148)
Falcon Heavy cannot be human rated under current NASA design guidelines. So NASA would have to change those guidelines to human rate Falcon Heavy. Which they should absolutely do -- being able to closely inspect returned boosters gives far better data than design guidelines based on computer models.

That's the plan for Starship. It doesn't follow the NASA man rating design guidelines either, AFAIK. But SpaceX doesn't need NASA human rating to fly non-NASA personnel and have no immediate plans to fly NASA astronauts on Starship. By the time they do compete for a NASA human contract with Starship they expect to have enough flight data to meet NASA's standard of less than 1/500th of a chance of loss of mission using hard test data rather than computer modelling.

Even Bolden has changed his tune now that he's retired and doesn't have to answer to Congress. He says that SLS should be cancelled. I wonder if Senator Shelby will change his tune after he retires? Somehow I doubt it.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:45AM (#29190030)
Can you be more specific about what is strictly outside human rating?

Nothing in Starship should be outside of human rating specifications. They have never done those for powered landings but its not outside of scope.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @02:21PM (#29191967)
The most egregious is that Starship doesn't have a full envelope launch escape system.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:52AM (#29198387)
Those systems simply don't make sense once you reach a certain scale.

There are very few cases in the history of space flight where these escape systems have saved anybody.

Depending on where in the flight profile the main engines of the second stage could be uses as an escape system.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:02PM (#29190944)
> * Falcon Heavy cannot be human rated under current NASA design guidelines. *

Just repeating a false statement doesn’t make it true.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:20AM (#29188079)
The Dragon Heat Shield was designed for Moon reentry as far as we know.

If they actually had to change the heat shield it would be quite a bit more work.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:30AM (#29188163)
That’s right. But there’s a bunch of engineering that goes into finally qualifying something for lunar flight. Remember they haven’t been planning to fly dragon the lunar vicinity for several years now since the pivot to Starship, so there are dozens of tiny things that would need to be tweaked to make that demonstrable again. I don’t think it will take SpaceX very long. I think they could do it in about a year from the word “go.” It took them just a few months to design, build, and qualify the bubble cupola window thing for Inspiration 4.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:14AM (#29188011)
The problem is we don't know exactly. This is not totally public information.

Dragon was originally designed for moon missions. We know that the heat shield can do moon reentry.

What we don't know is if the avionics can navigate in deep space. However upgrading this shouldn't require much redesign of the core structures.

Additionally Orion has a Service Module. This is made by ESA. Dragon would need something along those lines at well. Mostly this is about DeltaV.

Dragon has a trunk and with some work likely they could carry additional fuels in the trunk. Dragon has the engines of the required power.

SpaceX would have to be asked to provide a design. My estimation is that they could do significantly less then 1 billion $.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by simonh on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:17AM (#29188047)
Orion is designed for cislunar operations with 21 days of independent operations, while Dragon is capable of up to 10 days. It's supposed to be capable of missions to Mars as well, but as part of a larger vehicular system.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:08AM (#29189486)
"Red Dragon" was supposed to be capable of missions to Mars, but it was a significantly different design than the current Dragon, and it didn't get past the proposal stage.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by simonh on Thursday November 11, 2021 @03:59PM (#29193109)
And wasn't designed to carry people.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by JKCalhoun on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:10AM (#29187974)
Reading the article and thinking how much we're finally getting the future I was promised in "2001: A Space Odyssey". Had Kubrick plastered the Boeing logo on the side of the space clipper rather than Pan-Am it would have been just as ironic today (neither Stanley nor Arthur could have foreseen SpaceX, I suppose).

It occurs to me how much the film "2001" suggested a cold-war future still dominated by nations (US/USSR). Even the corporations depicted in the film, Bell Telephone, Hilton, somehow exuded a feeling of nationalism: our capitalist Pan-Am is better than your state-owned Aeroflot.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:17AM (#29188049)
NASA is currently asking companies to provide designs for privately designed and operated space stations. These will be the successor to ISS and will have their own commercial parts.

We are slowly getting there.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by kingcharles on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:14AM (#29188691)
I just got out of jail. I made a new LinkedIn profile. First e-mail I get from them is a recommendation that I apply for the position of CEO at Boeing.

Don't worry, guys, I got this!

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by idlewords on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:25AM (#29188827)
It will be interesting to see how SpaceX approaches partially closed-loop life support. This is an unglamorous and refractory technical problem unrelated to what they've done well in the past, but required to achieve their loftier goals.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:30AM (#29188914)
Less important than you might think if you have as much mass margin as they do. You can do years with just oxygen (Starship HLS will use oxygen from the propellant tank) and regenerative CO2 scrubbers (which are pretty simple). Also, they have access to NASA’s technical expertise, and NASA has been working with closed loop life support for decades on ISS, now.

Tons and tons and tons of mass margin covers a multitude of sins. A lot of the difficulties of “must haves” for Mars are really just a side effect of substantial mass constraints. Relax those, and it’s much simpler with tech close to what they’ve already demonstrated.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by idlewords on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:45AM (#29189163)
Everything's easy in space until it has to run for three years or more without breaking. The idea that mass margin fixes everything falls apart a bit when you get into details.

Some examples: there's no good way to analyze air/water for trace volatiles on a spacecraft (ISS flies samples down to earth), there's no food that stays edible for five years, water recapture (which has to be closed loop) has been a headache for the entire life of ISS, so has managing trash and human waste.

You're also wrong that ISS has had anything like closed-loop life support. They are entirely dependent on regular resupply, a full-time ground crew, and lab analysis done on earth. The closest they come to closed-loop anything is 93% re-use of water; a Mars mission (by NASA estimates) would need 99%+.

There's a large class of space flight problems you can't giant rocket your way out of.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by cnlevy on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:57AM (#29189345)
On the contrary, I'm convinced weight can (ab)solve many sins. The JWST's solar shade would have been much less difficult to develop if it wasn't so weight constrained.

> Everything's easy in space until it has to run for three years or more without breaking.

Only 90% reliability ? So let's bring 5 of each, since we're not limited by weight, we get to 99,999%

> there's no good way to analyze air/water for trace volatiles on a spacecraft

How much weights a specialized lab for that ?

> there's no food that stays edible for five years

Its been solved a long time ago: dried and salted food, basically

https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/ship-food-research-rec...

> Mars mission (by NASA estimates) would need 99%+

There are glaciers on Mars. Its about the only thing they wont have to bring.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by idlewords on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:08AM (#29189493)
You can bring 100 of something and still be screwed if it turns out to break because of a common cause. You'd think people on this site of all places would understand that reliability engineering is hard.

2. There is no specialized lab for it that works in space. It has to be invented.

3. Astronauts can't survive on ship's biscuit and space MREs. Malnutrition is already a problem on ISS.

4. There are no glaciers between Earth and Mars, and by the way you're not allowed to touch the Martian glaciers because of contamination risk.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:29AM (#29189816)
On the contrary, the specialized lab for volatiles has been in space for years already on ISS. They bring samples back to prove it works, and it does.

You’re now moving the goalposts from “no food is edible for 5 years” to “MREs don’t count”.

And the trip from Earth to Mars is only like 4 months if you use a BIG ROCKET. :) 4 months without resupply is no huge challenge.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by idlewords on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:00PM (#29190222)
The volatiles analyzer on ISS works against a short list of known compounds. For anything else you just get a generic warning and have to rely on earth labs to figure out what's going on.

You can't subsist on MREs for five years. Here's a cite for you about the space food problem: https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/150/9/2242/5870322

However fast your imaginary rocket goes, you have to wait 26 months for the planets to align so you can use it.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:35AM (#29189900)
Of course its hard, the point that mass margin helps a huge amount is still true. A bigger rocket doesn't provide a solution but it provides a gigantic amount of more solution space and that matters.

Multiple versions and designed to be repairable. Common parts, 3D printers and so on.

We 100% will need to use martian water. Otherwise its impossible to go.

I have never heard of 2) can you provide a link with some information what is actually required?

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by idlewords on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:08PM (#29190319)
This paper (Lessons Learned from the Integration of Monitoring Resources in Addressing an ISS Water Quality Anomaly) gives you a good sense of (2), and the resources required to track down mystery volatiles.

https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20110012747/downloads/20...

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by avmich on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:34AM (#29189883)
> You can bring 100 of something and still be screwed if it turns out to break because of a common cause.

If it breaks in storage, without been used - yes. If it breaks in use, for reasons related to usage - no.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by idlewords on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:03PM (#29190257)
If your common cause is a 200A electrical fault, no number of spare 100A fuses will help you.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:50PM (#29190809)
Component level repair is something NASA does actually do on ISS. And Big Rocket allows you to also bring dissimilar redundancy.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by avmich on Thursday November 11, 2021 @02:08PM (#29191786)
No, my point was that even similar redundancy helps. The example of 200A vs. 100A fuse is just an example of something which is not suitable for the problem - like, a tractor on the Moon helps little if you have a broken leg, you need to have medical supplies for that. But with big rocket you could, of course.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by avmich on Thursday November 11, 2021 @02:06PM (#29191764)
Ah, but did you try to put them in parallel? I've heard Apollo-13 crew were in position of necessity to improvise.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:28AM (#29189800)
You claim “ There's a large class of space flight problems you can't giant rocket your way out of.” …but every single one of your examples is wrong and proves the point that large rocket DOES solve it.

For example: > The closest they come to closed-loop anything is 93% re-use of water; a Mars mission (by NASA estimates) would need 99%+. Oh, really? Why precisely do you think NASA estimated 99%+ water recycling would be required? Because MASS.

>trace volatiles In fact, ISS has had trace volatiles measured in real-time for years: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20070030106 ISS sends samples back to validate the instrument because ISS is a testbed. It isn’t absolutely required.

> there's no food that stays edible for five years

Wrong. Anything will stay edible for 5 years if put in a deep freezer. And canned food lasts a LOT longer than that. “Oh, it’s not as yummy and the nutrient profile changes”, well sure. It’s nice to have fresh food. But the claim no food stays edible for 5 years is trivially false. All of us have eaten food that old, and the radiation environment isn’t enough to change that equation massively.

ISS can withstand long periods without resupply, and has done so when there has been launch failures. If you can prepare for it ahead of time, it’s just a matter of having a sufficient spare pool on-orbit instead of just having the spare pool on Earth. In other words, MASS.

Waste management is annoying if you don’t have canisters to place the waste in, but again, that’s also just MASS. You can put the waste in double sealed containers and then just place it outside the airlock. Can do that on orbit, so that’s actually one advantage Mars has over ISS.

And I don’t see why Mars can’t have a full time ground crew, too. Time delay annoying but not in any way a showstopper.

In fact, a large rocket solves these problems so completely, people who should know better still haven’t wrapped their heads around just how completely it changes the situation. The water recycling thing you repeated is illustrative of this. It literally is just mass.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by idlewords on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:47AM (#29190048)
I wish you'd read your own links. The machine that measures volatiles on ISS works against a target list of 20 or so compounds. This is an excellent solution as long as your compound of interest is on the list. But when it's not (like when siloxanes turned out to be a big problem for catalyst bed poisoning) then you are entirely dependent on an earth lab.

Here's the Journal of Nutrition saying that five-year stable food adequate for space flight doesn't exist: https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/150/9/2242/5870322. You should write them with the good news that this is trivially solved.

These arguments about "everything is trivial with big enough rockets" remind me a lot of trying to have a discussion with blockchain people. Yes, if you have a warp drive, you can resupply Martian astronauts daily with fresh foods. But maybe let's see it in action before we call it a solved problem.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:55PM (#29190861)
5 year NON-FROZEN food “adequate for Spaceflight”doesn’t exist. But if you simply bring a big freezer, the problem is almost trivial. Why don’t they normally do that on ISS already? Fundamentally, MASS. Freezers are heavy (mass) and use a lot of power (mass).

Fun fact, but SpaceX has launched ice cream in a freezer to ISS before. This isn’t hypothetical.

See how many hidden assumptions there are which can be relaxed if mass constraints are relaxed? It’s just assumed freezers aren’t viable because they’re too heavy. There’s stuff like this all over the place. The entire field is built under the assumption that mass is extremely rare.

Thanks for highlighting the point that big rocket solves these problems in almost a trivial way.

(And what does blockchain have to do with it? Blockchain is simply a worse solution to a database problem.)

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by avmich on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:39AM (#29189941)
Space-specific problems are: 1) weightlessness - but people can deal with that, and if needed, I'm sure centrifuges can help; 2) radiation - but large shields can alleviate this problem; 3) space debris, attacking with large speeds - but we can use radars, shields, plasma clouds to reduce problems from this.

With all of these problems large rockets do help.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:47AM (#29190052)
Space debris is a much worse problem in LEO than anywhere else from here to Mars. Mars’ surface itself at likely landing sites is shielded from all micrometeorites by the atmosphere which burns them up or slows them down to a reasonable terminal velocity (low for micrometeorites, even in the thin Martian atmosphere).
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by idlewords on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:50AM (#29190096)
A centrifuge solves microgravity problems, but no one has ever flown one at human sizes. Seems like a big to-do list item.

With cosmic rays, having a large mass of metal around you will actually increase your dose (because of secondary radiation). So you need to figure out shielding that helps more than it hurts.

Space is hard.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:00PM (#29190918)
Why the heck would you use metal for shielding when cheap plastic works way better? But anyway, the “shielding increases dose” is only true for a small portion of the thickness curve at the very beginning. Vast majority of the time even metal shielding helps.

“Space is hard” is kind of a low-effort mantra. Space radiation shielding really is one of those things that is extremely straightforward to address with mass. Polyethylene, or actually any hydrocarbon solid, works fantastic.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by avmich on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:53AM (#29190141)
Large rockets still help, even if shielding is not straightforward though.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by idlewords on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:11PM (#29190350)
Certainly. And if we had a big enough rocket, we could put its fins on earth and the tip on Mars and just climb up the middle.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by avmich on Thursday November 11, 2021 @02:05PM (#29191738)
That all skips the interesting middle values of the problem parameters :) .

Seriously, for long time already it's not a rocket science.

Existing technologies - with engineering efforts - are capable to bring humans to any point between Mercury and asteroids. We'll likely develop something better, and Solar system would be all reachable without major breakthroughs. Certainly not of the kind "rocket fins on Earth, tip on Mars".

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:01PM (#29190929)
Shielding ESPECIALLY is straightforward, though. The parent was wrong about it being hard.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by rbanffy on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:35AM (#29189017)
> Tons and tons and tons of mass margin covers a multitude of sins

This is also why building spacecraft is so expensive - they need to be engineered to the absolute minimum mass that does the job and that takes the majority of the time.

Relax that and you cut design time to 10% of it used to be.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by wffurr on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:45AM (#29189161)
There's a nice writeup of what 100X more launch capability means for space missions on this blog: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2021/10/28/starship-is-st...

We'll see if SpaceX can actually achieve their cost-to-orbit goals. Progress so far is promising, but they have a long way to go still.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:46PM (#29190772)
“ However, limited water, storage, crew time, and food preparation capability (e.g., add water, heat) restrict the crew to a limited choice of shelf-stable, single-serving food products either in their natural form or preserved by dehydration, retort thermostabilization, or irradiation.”

So “limited water, storage, crew time, and food preparation capability (e.g., add water, heat)” all sound like things that can be addressed either directly or indirectly by “giant rocket.” And using a freezer for food (which a big rocket would allow) isn’t in the list of options they mainly considered. Deep frozen food is a very straightforward way of preserving food and high levels of nutrients for a very long time.

And as far as SpaceX meeting their goals, I agree they haven’t done it YET, but in order for Artemis to work, they now have to achieve those goals. It takes on the order of 10 Starship launches per HLS mission, more than a Mars launch would require! And they’re only charging like $2.5 billion for that, which includes two HLS missions and HLS development. Starship working and meeting its goals (at least enough for initial Mars mission) is now something NASA is reliant on for the critical path for Artemis. NASA is effectively all-in on Starship now.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by ProAm on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:18AM (#29189634)
I have a hard time finding interest and value in human space flight in 2021 when its clear we are on track to destroy the planet were currently on. In the 60's it was for a cold war, and in turn provided a lot of new technology advancement. This time around Im not as interested, intrigued or impressed. We have micro plastics covering pretty much every inch of this planet, people in need of food, people in need of basic medical care. I know they are in different arenas, and these problems even existed in the 1960's. But what is the point of going back to the moon at all? I don't see a point in going to Mars except for the fact it has not been done yet. It's cool but I have a hard time with it.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by avmich on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:23AM (#29189715)
Spaceflight can very well have a large role in saving the planet from climate crisis.

Going to Mars is sort of mundane business - we want new markets, but on this scale it's bigger than that - we, humans, operate like that, we expand, we strive to better our lives, to know more or our surroundings, to conquer potential resources. So, if you don't see a point in going to Mars, perhaps you also don't see a point in, say, a company expanding operations in new cities or new countries.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by ProAm on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:28AM (#29189793)
> So, if you don't see a point in going to Mars, perhaps you also don't see a point in, say, a company expanding operations in new cities or new countries.

I think there is a middle ground between the two. But Im just not excited to land on Mars, just as Im not excited about people on the space station. I dont disagree it can have (and does have) some value, but the value seems disproportionate to the media, money, and return on it is all. I can't fully explain why either, which doesnt help for internet discussions, but I just see closer issues that could use billions and focus on.

> Spaceflight can very well have a large role in saving the planet from climate crisis.

I would like to see this explained, or the forethought on it. Not to dismiss it but it seems like much of what we are doing now is for the sake of doing it. Maybe a mini-cold war with China. But just to say it very well may doesn't convince me this time around is all.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by avmich on Thursday November 11, 2021 @02:12PM (#29191846)
> I would like to see this explained, or the forethought on it.

Once we had this discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21397285

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by timeon on Thursday November 11, 2021 @03:25PM (#29192704)
> we expand, we strive to better our lives, to know more or our surroundings, to conquer potential resources

like locusts

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by oxplot on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:25AM (#29189753)
> I have a hard time finding interest and value in human space flight in 2021

It's impossible to predict what tech can come out of such efforts that will be of use here on Earth in the future. The amount of money going to space exploration is peanuts so I think it's well justified if it has even a trace of potential to improve future of humanity and that has been true historically - e.g. satellites (GPS, weather, etc), medicine (MRI), and whole bunch of NASA spinoffs and more.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by polishdude20 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:29AM (#29189818)
We hear that argument a lot with space but why can't we apply that same principle to healthcare? Or renewables? Why is it that pouring billions of dollars into space is considered as potentially improving humanity but other things don't get the same treatment?
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by oxplot on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:38AM (#29189933)
Billions is peanuts. I think SpaceX to date has received less than 10 billion (say 20 to be safe) in total for everything! That's 20 years of research, development, coming up with never done before re-usable rockets, etc.

People spent nearly half a trillion dollars (not billion) on cosmetic products in a single year! You want to point fingers, point at something you can actually locate. Money spent on space is negligible to the point that it doesn't even warrant justifying spending it.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by polishdude20 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @04:04PM (#29193160)
I'm not saying the money is not well spent. I just think the argument of "but think of all the research and new tech that may possibly come out of this" is something that's always applied to space.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by ProAm on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:03PM (#29190950)
I never said space flight, I said human space flight. I see great value in space flight itself.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by greedo on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:31AM (#29189830)
We can chew gum and walk at the same time. Space exploration really doesn't detract from combatting climate change or pollution. Those are both political issues really.

Visiting the Moon, and establishing a base there will help in establishing colonies on Mars and in the Belt. And don't despair. The Earth is much more resilient than many give it credit for.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by ProAm on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:39AM (#29189940)
Oh for sure you can't kill a planet. Humanity may suffer but Earth will be just fine for another 4 billion-ish years.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by chrisjc on Thursday November 11, 2021 @12:31PM (#29190598)
As mentioned, walk and chew gum...

But I also think that moving a lot of harmful activities into space would be an all-around benefit.

For example, I think space mining will help reduce the need to mine a lot of resources on earth.

Potentially the same may be true for certain manufacturing operations that are better suited to zero-gravity, and whose harmful bi-products might just be jettisoned off towards the sun instead of having to be buried in the desert or dumped off the coast of Africa.

Apart from getting everything into orbit to begin with, any transportation thereafter is merely left up to gravity and dropping the final/semi-final products back to earth. Today, the amount of emissions resulting from striping, digging, transporting, refining, transporting, manufacturing, transporting, etc... is alarming.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bfrog on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:33AM (#29189876)
I think the headline is getting ahead of reality by about 30 years.
[dead]
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:06AM (#29188599)
Eric Berger is a well known and well respected space journalist who has been working in this for decades. He does not write for money articles. The 'journalist' who do that are known.

And SpaceX also doesn't pay for articles, they have no need to do that.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by fnord77 on Friday November 12, 2021 @10:51AM (#29200495)
"And SpaceX also doesn't pay for articles, they have no need to do that."

of course they do. it is well known