Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight
by dotancohen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:29AM
(#29189810)
> Even in the case of the 737, the MAX proved we didn't
> understand a 737 thoroughly enough to ensure safe operation.
Actually, we did. But it was thought economical to ignore proper engine placement and weight distribution, and make up for it with automated elevator trimming.Economical being a conservative word. Designing a new airframe for the newer, larger, more efficient engines would have been very expensive.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight
by laverya on Thursday November 11, 2021 @03:59PM
(#29193107)
NASA not running an actual assessment after STS-27R was almost lost to a similar foam strike in 1988 is really the flabbergasting part. If that foam strike had been almost anywhere else on the wing, it would have resulted in the crew and vehicle being lost. But instead it punched a hole right where there was a double-thickness aluminum plate for an antenna mounting, and so didn't burn through.
Columbia had a foam strike on the leading edge and wasn't so lucky.
I'll never get over the fact that NASA never made an assessment of tile damage after liftoff in over 100 flights before Columbia. All these machines are experimental in the sense we still don't understand completely what happens with them and treating them like 737's is a huge mistake.
Even in the case of the 737, the MAX proved we didn't understand a 737 thoroughly enough to ensure safe operation.