2. There is no specialized lab for it that works in space. It has to be invented.
3. Astronauts can't survive on ship's biscuit and space MREs. Malnutrition is already a problem on ISS.
4. There are no glaciers between Earth and Mars, and by the way you're not allowed to touch the Martian glaciers because of contamination risk.
You’re now moving the goalposts from “no food is edible for 5 years” to “MREs don’t count”.
And the trip from Earth to Mars is only like 4 months if you use a BIG ROCKET. :) 4 months without resupply is no huge challenge.
You can't subsist on MREs for five years. Here's a cite for you about the space food problem: https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/150/9/2242/5870322
However fast your imaginary rocket goes, you have to wait 26 months for the planets to align so you can use it.
Multiple versions and designed to be repairable. Common parts, 3D printers and so on.
We 100% will need to use martian water. Otherwise its impossible to go.
I have never heard of 2) can you provide a link with some information what is actually required?
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20110012747/downloads/20...
If it breaks in storage, without been used - yes. If it breaks in use, for reasons related to usage - no.
> Everything's easy in space until it has to run for three years or more without breaking.
Only 90% reliability ? So let's bring 5 of each, since we're not limited by weight, we get to 99,999%
> there's no good way to analyze air/water for trace volatiles on a spacecraft
How much weights a specialized lab for that ?
> there's no food that stays edible for five years
Its been solved a long time ago: dried and salted food, basically
https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/ship-food-research-rec...
> Mars mission (by NASA estimates) would need 99%+
There are glaciers on Mars. Its about the only thing they wont have to bring.