News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by ragebol on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:03AM (#29187903)
> Dragon could do almost everything Orion does with a few enhancements

What can Dragon not do that Orion will be able to do? Can Orion go further from Earth?

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:18AM (#29188059)
Orion is being qualified for faster reentry. Dragon currently only qualified for LEO reentry. But they both use ablative heatshields which scale in a straightforward way to higher speed reentries.

Orion also has more propellant, more delta-v, so it has more post-separation maneuvering capability. Dragon would need either expanded tanks on board or maybe some extra propulsion capability in the trunk or perhaps docking with a small propulsion module (think like how the Apollo command module docked with the LM in Apollo 13 and used that for maneuvering delta-v).

Neither of those things are huge. There are a few other things that are relatively minor, like shielding (literally just mass of plastic, very little engineering involved) and extra consumables for longer free flight mission and getting Falcon Heavy fully up to Falcon 9 human rating standards (pretty straightforward as it’s almost identical to Falcon 9 but with 2 side boosters).

You could test those things on an uncrewed test flight fairly cheaply. In some ways, it’d be safer than Orion/SLS as the vehicle and spacecraft have a lot more flight history already.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:36AM (#29188229)
Past NASA administrator Bolden said that NASA would never human rate Falcon Heavy, so SpaceX didn't design Falcon Heavy for human rating. There are a couple of places where the margin is less than the 1.4 that NASA considers to be a requirement for human rating. The walls of the F9 are strong enough to have a 1.4 margin on their own, but adding the force and torsion of 2 extra boosters lowers the margin significantly. Getting those margins up to 1.4 would require a fundamental redesign and that's something SpaceX will never do. They expect Starship to become operational before any Falcon Heavy redesign ever could.

But in the opinion of experts Falcon Heavy is considerably safer than the human rated SLS[1] and massively safer than the Shuttle ever was, so human rating Falcon Heavy is just a matter of NASA swallowing their pride and acknowledging that.

1: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2021/02/24/sls-is-cancell...

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:54AM (#29188430)
Bolden has said a lot of things dismissive of SpaceX, and they haven’t turned out to be very accurate. The Administrator has Congressional political constraints and is part of the aerospace old guard that had a sort of learned-helplessness about new aerospace endeavors. Falcon Heavy can absolutely be human rated. There’s also the possibility of LEO rendezvous between a Dragon launched on a Falcon 9 and a filled Falcon Heavy upper stage with a docking port on it.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:44AM (#29189148)
Falcon Heavy cannot be human rated under current NASA design guidelines. So NASA would have to change those guidelines to human rate Falcon Heavy. Which they should absolutely do -- being able to closely inspect returned boosters gives far better data than design guidelines based on computer models.

That's the plan for Starship. It doesn't follow the NASA man rating design guidelines either, AFAIK. But SpaceX doesn't need NASA human rating to fly non-NASA personnel and have no immediate plans to fly NASA astronauts on Starship. By the time they do compete for a NASA human contract with Starship they expect to have enough flight data to meet NASA's standard of less than 1/500th of a chance of loss of mission using hard test data rather than computer modelling.

Even Bolden has changed his tune now that he's retired and doesn't have to answer to Congress. He says that SLS should be cancelled. I wonder if Senator Shelby will change his tune after he retires? Somehow I doubt it.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:45AM (#29190030)
Can you be more specific about what is strictly outside human rating?

Nothing in Starship should be outside of human rating specifications. They have never done those for powered landings but its not outside of scope.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @02:21PM (#29191967)
The most egregious is that Starship doesn't have a full envelope launch escape system.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:52AM (#29198387)
Those systems simply don't make sense once you reach a certain scale.

There are very few cases in the history of space flight where these escape systems have saved anybody.

Depending on where in the flight profile the main engines of the second stage could be uses as an escape system.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:02PM (#29190944)
> * Falcon Heavy cannot be human rated under current NASA design guidelines. *

Just repeating a false statement doesn’t make it true.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:20AM (#29188079)
The Dragon Heat Shield was designed for Moon reentry as far as we know.

If they actually had to change the heat shield it would be quite a bit more work.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:30AM (#29188163)
That’s right. But there’s a bunch of engineering that goes into finally qualifying something for lunar flight. Remember they haven’t been planning to fly dragon the lunar vicinity for several years now since the pivot to Starship, so there are dozens of tiny things that would need to be tweaked to make that demonstrable again. I don’t think it will take SpaceX very long. I think they could do it in about a year from the word “go.” It took them just a few months to design, build, and qualify the bubble cupola window thing for Inspiration 4.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:14AM (#29188011)
The problem is we don't know exactly. This is not totally public information.

Dragon was originally designed for moon missions. We know that the heat shield can do moon reentry.

What we don't know is if the avionics can navigate in deep space. However upgrading this shouldn't require much redesign of the core structures.

Additionally Orion has a Service Module. This is made by ESA. Dragon would need something along those lines at well. Mostly this is about DeltaV.

Dragon has a trunk and with some work likely they could carry additional fuels in the trunk. Dragon has the engines of the required power.

SpaceX would have to be asked to provide a design. My estimation is that they could do significantly less then 1 billion $.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by simonh on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:17AM (#29188047)
Orion is designed for cislunar operations with 21 days of independent operations, while Dragon is capable of up to 10 days. It's supposed to be capable of missions to Mars as well, but as part of a larger vehicular system.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:08AM (#29189486)
"Red Dragon" was supposed to be capable of missions to Mars, but it was a significantly different design than the current Dragon, and it didn't get past the proposal stage.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by simonh on Thursday November 11, 2021 @03:59PM (#29193109)
And wasn't designed to carry people.