News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by mabbo on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:26AM (#29188129)
> This is very unlike the contracts that Lockheed Martin and Boeing work under for the Orion capsule and the SLS contract. Just in comparison, those system already at up almost 20 billion each, they have sometimes over 2 billion a year in funding. The extra cost for failing to deliver these systems is paid by NASA.

The growing elephant in the room is SpaceX's Starship. What happens if Boeing says "Yeah, sorry, we need to delay the moon landings 3 more years- at $2B/year out of your pockets" and SpaceX steps up and says "Cancel the SLS/Orion program, give us $2B one time and we'll put your astronauts on the surface on schedule with Starship".

All that would need to happen to reach that is SpaceX succeeding and Boeing falling behind. A formerly-unlikely scenario that now is the norm.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by m_mueller on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:40AM (#29188268)
I'm big on following Starship development, but I think people are a bit overly optimistic about what can be achieved with it in the next couple of years (while having a blind eye on what it will be able to do within a 20y timeframe). From current development and past experience at human rating their Dragon I think that it will take 7-10 years[1] for Starship to reach that level. But once it does reach it, it will make pretty much everything else obsolete and it will start a new spaceflight era, where ISRU and space mining suddenly become a thing within just a few years.

[1] take Falcon 9 as a reference - it first launched in 2010 and their first manned mission was only last year in 2020. yes, SpaceX has grown significantly since then, but so have their ambitions with Starship. Fuel transfer and 2nd stage reentry/landing are significant further milestones to reach besides just getting it to orbit. And then they'll have to prove safety margins, life support systems, abort scenarios...

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by SEJeff on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:50AM (#29188387)
But Falcon 9 also took a long time because it doesn't launch all that often and SpaceX had a lot to learn about how to work with NASA. The "idea" of Starship / Superheavy is that the same first and second stage can get caught by the landing tower "chopsticks", have a crane re-mate them, fuel them, and relaunch them within 24 hours or less.

If they can relaunch the same entire stack more than say 2 times per day, they're going to absolutely hit the reliability margins[1] that NASA / the FAA want to see in a very short time period.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human-rating_certification

    The NASA CCP human-rating standards require that the probability of a loss on ascent does not exceed 1 in 500, and that the probability of a loss on descent did not exceed 1 in 500. The overall mission loss risk, which includes vehicle risk from micrometeorites and orbital debris while in orbit for up to 210 days, is required to be no more than 1 in 270.[3] Maximum sustained acceleration is limited to 3 g.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by voakbasda on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:25AM (#29188846)
I would very much like to see the data and math used to calculate these odds.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by cryptonector on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:37AM (#29189034)
According to Feynman, in the case of the shuttle there was no such calculation, just assertion.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by SEJeff on Thursday November 11, 2021 @07:37PM (#29195051)
The shuttle progam's motto was "beat the russians" more or less, so that checks out.

There is a lot of background in the biographies of both Chuck Yaeger AND John Glenn about some of this if you like that sort of thing.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:47AM (#29198342)
> The shuttle progam's motto was "beat the russians" more or less, so that checks out.

And they achieved the exact opposite.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:54AM (#29188431)
That's a general rule of thumb in tech predictions -- people overpredict the short term and underpredict the long term. So yes, Dear Moon is unlikely to fly in 2023. But it'll definitely fly before 2028. Starship has already retired their most significant technical risks. Fuel transfer and 2nd stage reentry aren't easy, but the Shuttle and ISS did them both in the 80s.

SpaceX didn't do significant work on Dragon until 2015 since Congress didn't properly fund Commercial Crew until then.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Robotbeat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:32AM (#29188958)
I disagree. Starship HLS with requires 10 launches per mission. An extra expendable Starship/SuperHeavy launch with Orion on top is not a substantial challenge in comparison (although lots of engineering involved, but they’re good at that).
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by numpad0 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:17AM (#29188724)
Am I the only one to think Starship is starting to look a lot like X-33 program...
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by rbanffy on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:50AM (#29189233)
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:49AM (#29198361)
I mean, the X-33 was sub-orbital technology demonstrator. It was totally different in terms of reentry and control control surfaces. It uses different fuel. It doesn't use an areospike engine. Its a different color.

Not sure what you are seeing.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:39AM (#29188261)
SLS/Orion is already not needed. You could use Falcon 9/Dragon to get astronauts into Orbit and back. Then use Starship to do the moon and back part.

If you actually did a clean sheet architecture, there is literally zero reason to do SLS/Orion.

Starship is one on the critical path anyway. The only difference is you go from the capsule to Starship in LEO instead.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Denvercoder9 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:48AM (#29188371)
> Then use Starship to do the moon and back part.

The problem is that the current design for the lunar Starship doesn't have enough propellant left over to leave lunar orbit, let alone enter Earth orbit (and it has been stripped of its heatshield, so no aerocapture). Going back on a Starship requires first delivering fuel for that Starship to lunar orbit, which adds another ~8 launches to each mission.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:57AM (#29188464)
More launches are fine, that is far cheaper then SLS/Orion.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by Denvercoder9 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:19AM (#29188736)
It's not just about money though, it's also about operational complexity. We don't have experience launching that many ships in that short of a timeframe (propellant boil-off is a real issue), and any one failed launch breaks the whole plan.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by socialdemocrat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:38AM (#29189932)
They don't need to use the huge starship though. In principle they could build a dedicated space craft which is fitted on top of Falcon Heavy and delivered to LEO. Being smaller than Starship you should not need refueling. Astronauts arrive to LEO using F9 and dragon, where they dock and transfer to this dedicate space craft which takes them to the moon.

They could even send the same kind of vehicle ahead of schedule to the moon as a backup for when the astronauts are going home.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by cnlevy on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:16AM (#29189597)
90% will be tanker launches, and will be reused. If one fails, you just launch the next one coming out from the Starship assembly line instead of reusing.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by panick21_ on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:40AM (#29189966)
Propellant boil-off is not that big of an issue unless you somehow blow up multiple launch sites.

And just saying 'its complex' therefore lets spend 40 billion on development and then limit our options by paying 3 billion per launch is an insane plan.

Overall complexity is reduced by not having those two legacy systems.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by socialdemocrat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:35AM (#29189897)
But this can be done before any humans are launched into LEO, so they have the luxury of screwing this up without putting any humans at risk. If it doesn't work, cancel the mission without ever launching humans into LEO, get back to the drawing board and fix the refueling issue.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by cryptonector on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:38AM (#29189057)
Meh. Give it a couple of years and it will be routine.
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by oconnor663 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:45AM (#29189160)
Do they not plan to do that anyway, to reuse the HLS? Or is it a question of what can be done without risking the lives of astronauts?
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by socialdemocrat on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:34AM (#29189882)
Yeah lots of ways of doing this. You could fit a LEO-to-moon transport vehicle, as described by Robert Zubrin, on a Falcon Heavy.

Basically you use Falcon9 to get in and out of LEO using Dragon.

A Falcon Heavy can push a larger space craft into LEO and it saves weight by the fact that a LEO-to-moon vehicle doesn't need heath shield and other stuff which makes a Dragon capsule heavier.

And with Falcons being cheap you could even send a whole bunch of LEO-to-moon vehicles straight to the moon surface, as well as just dump fuel tanks there.

SpaceX has a lot of these and can build them quite cheaply, so the mission will have a lot more built in safety. E.g. if you got an extra lunar ascent vehicle sitting on the landing site already before astronauts arrive, you have extra redundancy.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by iso1210 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:49AM (#29188375)
I think most people accept it's likely. I suspect Starship will land (unmanned) on the moon before Starliner enters regular service, let alone SLS
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by cryptonector on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:35AM (#29188998)
Or if SpaceX says "y'all keep waiting for SLS and Orion, we're going to the moon on our own at no cost to you".
Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by jpgvm on Thursday November 11, 2021 @10:44AM (#29189153)
As extreme as it sounds it really isn't that unlikely. Musk may fund it out of his own pile of fuck you money just as a marketing stunt. The first Falcon Heavy launch was pretty much the same thing. Pretty sure he could ask a bunch of folks if there is any cool payloads they want to put on the moon and just yeet it up there with a Tesla Roadster, first car on the moon.

Never underestimate the size of his ego or his sheer force of will.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by tjpnz on Thursday November 11, 2021 @09:42AM (#29188292)
>we'll put your astronauts on the surface on schedule with Starship

That's already going to happen assuming things go to plan (and Bezos doesn't play any further shenanigans). They could offer seats to lunar orbit and back either with Starship or Falcon Heavy in expendable mode.

Re:SpaceX is beginning to get the hang of human spaceflight by oxplot on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:28AM (#29189791)
> Cancel the SLS/Orion program

I sure hope they do and give that money to either SpaceX or pretty much any other promising startup around (can't think of any with the payload requirements needed for a moon/mars mission).