The growing elephant in the room is SpaceX's Starship. What happens if Boeing says "Yeah, sorry, we need to delay the moon landings 3 more years- at $2B/year out of your pockets" and SpaceX steps up and says "Cancel the SLS/Orion program, give us $2B one time and we'll put your astronauts on the surface on schedule with Starship".
All that would need to happen to reach that is SpaceX succeeding and Boeing falling behind. A formerly-unlikely scenario that now is the norm.
[1] take Falcon 9 as a reference - it first launched in 2010 and their first manned mission was only last year in 2020. yes, SpaceX has grown significantly since then, but so have their ambitions with Starship. Fuel transfer and 2nd stage reentry/landing are significant further milestones to reach besides just getting it to orbit. And then they'll have to prove safety margins, life support systems, abort scenarios...
If they can relaunch the same entire stack more than say 2 times per day, they're going to absolutely hit the reliability margins[1] that NASA / the FAA want to see in a very short time period.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human-rating_certification
The NASA CCP human-rating standards require that the probability of a loss on ascent does not exceed 1 in 500, and that the probability of a loss on descent did not exceed 1 in 500. The overall mission loss risk, which includes vehicle risk from micrometeorites and orbital debris while in orbit for up to 210 days, is required to be no more than 1 in 270.[3] Maximum sustained acceleration is limited to 3 g.There is a lot of background in the biographies of both Chuck Yaeger AND John Glenn about some of this if you like that sort of thing.
And they achieved the exact opposite.
SpaceX didn't do significant work on Dragon until 2015 since Congress didn't properly fund Commercial Crew until then.
Not sure what you are seeing.
If you actually did a clean sheet architecture, there is literally zero reason to do SLS/Orion.
Starship is one on the critical path anyway. The only difference is you go from the capsule to Starship in LEO instead.
The problem is that the current design for the lunar Starship doesn't have enough propellant left over to leave lunar orbit, let alone enter Earth orbit (and it has been stripped of its heatshield, so no aerocapture). Going back on a Starship requires first delivering fuel for that Starship to lunar orbit, which adds another ~8 launches to each mission.
They could even send the same kind of vehicle ahead of schedule to the moon as a backup for when the astronauts are going home.
And just saying 'its complex' therefore lets spend 40 billion on development and then limit our options by paying 3 billion per launch is an insane plan.
Overall complexity is reduced by not having those two legacy systems.
Basically you use Falcon9 to get in and out of LEO using Dragon.
A Falcon Heavy can push a larger space craft into LEO and it saves weight by the fact that a LEO-to-moon vehicle doesn't need heath shield and other stuff which makes a Dragon capsule heavier.
And with Falcons being cheap you could even send a whole bunch of LEO-to-moon vehicles straight to the moon surface, as well as just dump fuel tanks there.
SpaceX has a lot of these and can build them quite cheaply, so the mission will have a lot more built in safety. E.g. if you got an extra lunar ascent vehicle sitting on the landing site already before astronauts arrive, you have extra redundancy.
Never underestimate the size of his ego or his sheer force of will.
That's already going to happen assuming things go to plan (and Bezos doesn't play any further shenanigans). They could offer seats to lunar orbit and back either with Starship or Falcon Heavy in expendable mode.
I sure hope they do and give that money to either SpaceX or pretty much any other promising startup around (can't think of any with the payload requirements needed for a moon/mars mission).
Seems SpaceX didn't want to play that collusion (or prisoner's dilemma) game many government contractors play.
If government would stop handing out contracts, SpaceX would try to go on as best they can anyway.
But of course as long as government is sharing in the goals SpaceX will use those.
They do, but remember they were the low-risk bet, on tech and engines NASA already had, with contractors they already had. It most likely (Starship isn't in service just yet) will not pay, but, still, it was the right decision at the time. Betting that SpaceX would be able to a reusable booster would be risky and betting they'd be able to deliver a fully-reusable super-heavy-lift rocket would be insane.
NASA's role is not to offer the best flights for the money, but to keep the aerospace industry busy and up-to-date with their own latest technology (and to prevent them from working for foreign powers). The science is mostly a side-effect.
But you're right, it wasn't completely insane in 2010. Nobody could have predicted how successful SpaceX would be and how untrustworthy Boeing would be.
The insanity of SLS was obvious to all but the deliberately blind by 2018 when Falcon Heavy flew.
You mean the political pork game sold as 'low' risk?
In fact, NASA own analysis showed this was not the case.
> Betting that SpaceX would be able to a reusable booster would be risky and betting they'd be able to deliver a fully-reusable super-heavy-lift rocket would be insane
That was not required for a much, much better solution.
> NASA's role is not to offer the best flights for the money, but to keep the aerospace industry busy and up-to-date with their own latest technology
So they spend 40 billion on legacy technology that is mostly pointless?
Of course not. Rockets and spacecraft were never the final product of NASA. The end-product of NASA is a large, trained aerospace workforce. While I agree SLS sucks, that earlier, less modified options still based on shuttle technology (such as the Shuttle-C) were better ideas in general, with SLS they had the opportunity to research and develop new materials and techniques that may be employed elsewhere, much like previous programs had vast spin-off industries.
All this investment should be able to make American aerospace companies more competitive in the global market.
Is SLS a better rocket than Starship/Superheavy? Probably not, but, again, that's not their goal.
You would get a larger better workforce if you actually developed new things, not put together 50 year old parts.
> less modified options still based on shuttle technology
Everything based about anything Shuttle is basically a horrible idea. Shuttle is what has dragged down NASA for 50 years now.
Literally non of those solutions would ever be even close to be cost efficient.
> with SLS they had the opportunity to research and develop new materials and techniques that may be employed elsewhere, much like previous programs had vast spin-off industries.
What are you talking about? SLS is maybe the list innovative large rocket ever made. The engines are literally Shuttle engines. The Upper stage is literally a Delta IV Upper Stage with an adapter on it.
The boosters are mostly the same as Shuttle booster with one more element (that mostly seems to have been added so they can give that contractor a couple 100 million in development money.
The core stage is based on the Shuttle external tank and outside of a some welding technology its not innovative at all.
The whole SLS program was LITERALLY designed to be the least innovative possible program. That's what is his whole justification was that it would be minimal development.
NASA own evaluation pointed out that they would end up much more cost effective by doing some development but congress killed that:
https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceLaunchSystem/comments/kt1vlf/r...
> All this investment should be able to make American aerospace companies more competitive in the global market.
Funny then that US had literally 0% of the global commercial launch market. Seems like they achieved the exact opposite, make companies that are depended on government contract that were mostly good at maintaining legacy systems.
A lot of the best sat companies were from places like Canada and Britain. The companies that made the most money from NASA are exactly those that are not that competitive.
> Is SLS a better rocket than Starship/Superheavy? Probably not, but, again, that's not their goal.
The goal was to pay the same old contractors, in pure pork program.
You don't have to be close to Starship to make a rocket far better then SLS. SLS spend 20 billion and they didn't even reach the 130t to LEO rocket that congress demanded.
The SLS that will finally launch in 2022 is like 70-90t to LEO rocket and to get to the actual design goal it will require another 10 billion or so.
Not being critical of it with the defense 'it was designed to be pork' makes no sense.
What can Dragon not do that Orion will be able to do? Can Orion go further from Earth?
Orion also has more propellant, more delta-v, so it has more post-separation maneuvering capability. Dragon would need either expanded tanks on board or maybe some extra propulsion capability in the trunk or perhaps docking with a small propulsion module (think like how the Apollo command module docked with the LM in Apollo 13 and used that for maneuvering delta-v).
Neither of those things are huge. There are a few other things that are relatively minor, like shielding (literally just mass of plastic, very little engineering involved) and extra consumables for longer free flight mission and getting Falcon Heavy fully up to Falcon 9 human rating standards (pretty straightforward as it’s almost identical to Falcon 9 but with 2 side boosters).
You could test those things on an uncrewed test flight fairly cheaply. In some ways, it’d be safer than Orion/SLS as the vehicle and spacecraft have a lot more flight history already.
But in the opinion of experts Falcon Heavy is considerably safer than the human rated SLS[1] and massively safer than the Shuttle ever was, so human rating Falcon Heavy is just a matter of NASA swallowing their pride and acknowledging that.
1: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2021/02/24/sls-is-cancell...
That's the plan for Starship. It doesn't follow the NASA man rating design guidelines either, AFAIK. But SpaceX doesn't need NASA human rating to fly non-NASA personnel and have no immediate plans to fly NASA astronauts on Starship. By the time they do compete for a NASA human contract with Starship they expect to have enough flight data to meet NASA's standard of less than 1/500th of a chance of loss of mission using hard test data rather than computer modelling.
Even Bolden has changed his tune now that he's retired and doesn't have to answer to Congress. He says that SLS should be cancelled. I wonder if Senator Shelby will change his tune after he retires? Somehow I doubt it.
Nothing in Starship should be outside of human rating specifications. They have never done those for powered landings but its not outside of scope.
There are very few cases in the history of space flight where these escape systems have saved anybody.
Depending on where in the flight profile the main engines of the second stage could be uses as an escape system.
Just repeating a false statement doesn’t make it true.
If they actually had to change the heat shield it would be quite a bit more work.
Dragon was originally designed for moon missions. We know that the heat shield can do moon reentry.
What we don't know is if the avionics can navigate in deep space. However upgrading this shouldn't require much redesign of the core structures.
Additionally Orion has a Service Module. This is made by ESA. Dragon would need something along those lines at well. Mostly this is about DeltaV.
Dragon has a trunk and with some work likely they could carry additional fuels in the trunk. Dragon has the engines of the required power.
SpaceX would have to be asked to provide a design. My estimation is that they could do significantly less then 1 billion $.
It occurs to me how much the film "2001" suggested a cold-war future still dominated by nations (US/USSR). Even the corporations depicted in the film, Bell Telephone, Hilton, somehow exuded a feeling of nationalism: our capitalist Pan-Am is better than your state-owned Aeroflot.
We are slowly getting there.
Don't worry, guys, I got this!
Boeing high price was partly justified by 'higher schedule certainty'. They were selected over Sierra Nevada who had a 3.6 billion $ proposal using the Dreamchaser aircraft.
Some news emerged that Boeing believed that SpaceX could not deliver anyway and if they both didn't deliver the could renegotiate with NASA and demand more money. Unfortunately for them, SpaceX delivered without asking for more money.
Since then Boeing has failed its first test flight and has run into major issues with the second one, and it will not launch for many more months. All of these costs are carried by Boeing, only when they complete further milestones will the get paid.
This is very unlike the contracts that Lockheed Martin and Boeing work under for the Orion capsule and the SLS contract. Just in comparison, those system already at up almost 20 billion each, they have sometimes over 2 billion a year in funding. The extra cost for failing to deliver these systems is paid by NASA.
So the complete Dragon capsule development is basically 1 yearly budget for one of those programs. Dragon could do almost everything Orion does with a few enhancements (certainty not costing billions every year).
SLS and Orion are left over from the dark days and they need to be canceled, all future human spaceflight need to be done at fixed cost. If you want to play, you need to be willing to risk your company on it.