News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by kunagi7 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:54PM (#28474541)
The Chinese Government is speeding up their efforts to swallow Hong Kong and Macau into the Mainland.

Closing the media outlets, museums, websites that speak against them. And a few key people get abducted here and there to scare more people and force them to accept the Beijing Regime. But... The people from Hong Kong still demonstrates and tries to fight for their lost rights.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by MangoCoffee on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:44PM (#28476865)
its sad. when Sun Yat-sen the father of modern China take on the Qing dynasty. Hong Kong was the base. It wasn't part of China and a lot of Chinese who is educated under the British rule understand what Sun try to achieve. a modern and free country. Hong Kong have been a base for a lot of progressive Chinese.

Now that Hong Kong is fully back into China and the 50 years of no changes (for Hong Kong) promised by Deng Xiaoping is gone with Xi, basically a emperor for life. There is no hope for China to turn into a democratic country.

Taiwan is the last place for the progressive Chinese. After Chiang's family, Taiwan have progressed to be the most democratic and open minded country. It elected a first female president in Taiwan, allowed gay marriage...etc. While American left Taiwan to have a business relationship with China (CCP) for more than 40 years.

I fear Taiwan will soon be conquered by China, not by force but suppression and economic ties. After Taiwan is gone, there is no more place for any open minded and progressive Chinese.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by JackeJR on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:35AM (#28477848)
Some think that if the US extended their protection to Taiwan, Beijing would not attempt to take Taiwan.

Let's just assume for a moment that the US will fight off attacks by China to take Taiwan. And that US successfully ward off an attack. What next? What is there to prevent China from trying again and again and again? Will the US be prepared to ward off attacks after attacks after attacks? This is unlikely to happen.

With this, lets again assume that China eventually successfully takes Taiwan. What next? They would have taken over an island with a large number of people who resents their rule. There will be a persistent resistance group as long as Beijing continues her ways and Beijing is aware of this and is trying to shape the education of the younger generations so that the resentment does not cross generations.

Even if all these were to take place and all hope seems to be lost. There is a glimmer of hope. A totalitarian state has one major fault. There is no effective feedback mechanism and to assume that this one man can make the right call, the right decision all the time is a stretch. At some point, be it internal infighting, or a policy misstep creating intense misery amongst the people, there will be discontent and if the history of China is any indication, the discontent can trigger uprisings and eventually a change of regime.

The only way the regime can be changed is from the inside.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by hker on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:47AM (#28478205)
> Some think that if the US extended their protection to Taiwan, Beijing would not attempt to take Taiwan.

> What next? What is there to prevent China from trying again and again and again?

> The only way the regime can be changed is from the inside.

Worth noting that the Chinese Army “may not be willing to fight” (‘pay the bill’ for the aggressive stance of the Foreign Ministry). [1]

If the Chinese Army did not score decisive victories early on, they may be the one to give up, pushing back pressure from the top, instead of trying again and again.

[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/geopolitics/comments/p0nqla/chinese...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by blagie on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:47AM (#28479454)
I predict:

1) China won't attack Taiwan until it can be assured a swift victory.

2) China will reach that state within our lifetimes.

WWII was won, in part, by US manufacturing prowess. China has that advantage. It's military is currently behind in equipment, but if it chose to, it could build a blue water navy or whatever else it wants in record time. It also has the political ability to engage in major projects like these (see respective COVID19 responses).

I suspect Chinese military leadership is far more competent than US or EU. The cream of the crop in the West doesn't go into the military (see Afghanistan for an good example of how US armed forces are managed).

I also think we will see major disruptions in military from autonomous and semi-autonomous machines which will really reduce the US lead. DJI is headquartered in China, as are many of the other players here. If heave machines like carriers are obsoleted, the US advantage might turn into an expensive liability.

The Chinese military also has more manpower.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dTal on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:33AM (#28479692)
Carriers are already obsolete in a superpower war. Both sides possess weapons that can destroy them utterly from a great distance, and their location cannot be kept secret. Carriers won't last a day.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:54AM (#28480829)
China's hypersonic missiles have shorter range than an F35 launched from a carrier with midair refuel drone.

The only issue is that we'd want our carriers closer in practice. Close to the action means faster response times. If we are willing to destroy Chinese satellites, then China's kill chain becomes much harder.

I'm not convinced that a drone or spyplane can reliably penetrate the defensive line of destroyers + cruisers + E2 Hawkeyes.

And satellites aren't even that reliable either, it may be possible to hide a carrier between satellite flyovers in practice.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by blagie on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:05PM (#28483483)
A drone could not penetrate a defensive line of destroyers, cruisers, and E2 Hawkeyes.

However, a destroyer costs $870 million. I can build a drone for around $870 which has decent range, and sufficient firepower to do real damage if attacking with sufficient precision (e.g. placing a small explosive charge directly within a barrel).

That means I can launch a million drones for the cost of one destroyer. I'm pretty sure that a line of destroyers, cruisers, and E2 Hawkeyes wouldn't be able to destroy a fleet of a million drones. If they could, the cost of destroying each drone would likely be greater than the cost of the drone.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by imtringued on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:46PM (#28485575)
You can also launch 870 cruise missiles for the cost of one destroyer from a greater range with greater destruction.

Actually, this is wrong. That is the cost of the missiles, not the cost of the launch platform, nor the cost of the personnel, nor the cost of the logistics.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:08PM (#28483528)
CRAM bullets cost cheaper than your drone, and those CRAMs are on each Destroyer. I think our cruisers have 2 CRAMs on them (but I forget exactly)

These CRAMs can aim-bot and destroy subsonic cruise missiles (500mph), and even supersonic cruise missiles (1000mph). That's why China has spent billions developing hypersonic missiles (2500+mph) to dodge our CRAMs and missile defenses.

How fast is your drone flying? Does it pull enough lateral Gs to dodge CRAM shots or avoid the Patriot defense missiles?

--------

https://youtu.be/0bmSCC823tM?t=205

The "city-version" has shorter range, because we need the bullets to self-destroy themselves before they land on someone's property. So the Israeli "Iron Dome" is in fact, inferior, to the defense system on these Destroyers / Cruisers that surround the Carrier.

Tel Aviv's Iron Dome also has a much more difficult job: defending a population center rather than just a few ships. There will naturally be "holes" in the Iron Dome (just areas of the city that aren't as well defended).

In contrast: we can position our ships to maximize the chance of interception, and minimize the chance of our CRAM's failing.

-----------------

The worry about China's drones is their stealth spydrones which will try to triangulate the position of the carrier strike group. The drone then sends the coordinates to a hypersonic missile.

I'm not convinced that the stealth systems on those drones are sufficient to "hide" from radar, probably only good enough to prevent things like CRAM/Patriots from locking on. Without the ability to lock on, we don't have an ability to kill those drones from Destroyers / Cruisers.

That's where the Carrier comes in. The E2 Hawkeye has an aerial radar system and can get "eyes in the sky", making our targeting superior (maybe then our Patriots can hit). We can also launch fighters (F22 is probably sufficient) to close the distance and lock on / destroy the target... or even engage in a dogfight (radar-drones wouldn't have much dogfighting ability).

--------

How is China launching a million drones anyway? Their carriers aren't like ours. We have 4x catapults and 2x runways per carrier, I'm pretty sure China's carriers are only 1x runway. How many minutes does it take per launch?

If its an air battle you want, the 4x catapults + 2x runways the Supercarriers push will get more planes into the air than anything in the Chinese Navy... and we have something like 10 carriers fielded right now.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by blagie on Saturday September 11, 2021 @11:55AM (#28492975)
We're talking about Taiwan. China sets them up in the fields in a few of the rural communities near Xiamen. They simultaneously lift off from the fields. They fly at ~25mph. They take perhaps three hours to clear the water between Taiwan and China. There's a million of them. They're slow, but fairly agile.

Looking at the video, it looks like the C-RAM system is shooting perhaps dozens of rounds per second. Shooting down a million drones would take many hours of continuous shooting, assuming every bullet hit, which it wouldn't.

And a Patriot missile is $2-3 million.

I think the future of warfare is likely to be cheap, small, but smart and precision.

* A small drone flies into a gun barrel and explodes.

* A small drone flies into a jet air intake, and explodes, spraying material designed to damage the engine as it passes through

* A small drone deposits a chemical weapon in a ship's HVAC intake

* A small drone sprays corrosive paint on a camera, on a jet window, other surface we look through

* A small drone launches a single bullet to kill a mechanic

... and so on.

I think a lot of this goes like rock-paper-scissors, where a million $1000 drones overwhelms a $1 billion ship. On the other hand, a hundred thousand $10,000 drones could probably make quick work of a million $1000 drones. And so on.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Saturday September 11, 2021 @01:38PM (#28493945)
> They fly at ~25mph.

You know that US Warships run at 35mph to 50mph over water, right? You literally can't hit a warship at that speed.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dTal on Saturday September 11, 2021 @07:24PM (#28497053)
Only if the warship is at flanking speed directly away from the battle, commonly referred to as "running away". In which case, you've won.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Saturday September 11, 2021 @09:04PM (#28497646)
CRAMs have an effective range of like, 10km.

As long as the ship is traveling 25mph away from a 25mph drone, its shooting them down with machine guns (and bullets are very, very cheap). A flock of drones flying at 25mph isn't a weapon, they're sitting ducks. Fully and completely ineffective at ever dealing damage to these warships.

Like, 25mph means that these drones are going to be within effective range of the machine guns for 10 minutes when the ship is standing still. And these AEGIS systems on these destroyers have 300km+ effective radar range.

Unless you have very expensive equipment on those drones: they'll be flying in blind and getting sniped. Either stealth (which prevents the CRAM from locking on), or superior radar (to see the ships before the ships see it), or a combination thereof.

And again: if they're not standing still: the ships can basically run around in circles and the drones would never catch up.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by blagie on Sunday September 12, 2021 @06:04AM (#28499851)
I think that depends on the mission.

1) China doesn't need to destroy US ships; it merely needs to keep them distracted long enough to take control of Taiwan. If China moves quickly, the Taiwanese leadership are deported to Beijing, and there are boots on the ground, it's a done deal. Once that's done, it will be like Crimea. There's no way the US is getting drawn into a land war in Asia.

2) Ten minutes, at a dozen shots a minute, means a gun firing at 10 RPS can take out 6,000 drones. That's 0.6% of a flock.

3) You can't run circles around a flock of millions of drones, no matter how fast you go. A flock can cover a lot of space. The best you can do is run away, which would take US forces out-of-commission.

4) The Taiwan Straight is simply not that large. It's not hard for China to be aware of everything that happens there, even with a fleet of small, cheap AUVs. Heck, they could drop a few hundred thousand of these as well, if they wanted to.

5) It's equally not hard for China to communicate with a flock of drones. A directional spread spectrum link isn't easy to jam. At that range, even an optical link is practical, and not something where we have countermeasures.

6) A million drones can effectively blanket the whole Taiwan straight.

7) In terms of stealth, I'm not sure how technology will progress, but I'm pretty sure that building drones indistinguishable from birds on radar just wouldn't be that hard. I'm also pretty sure a flock of drones could be made to emulate other forms of craft, on radar.

8) I'm also pretty sure China wouldn't telegraph what they're doing. It's not like we can prepare countermeasures. I gave one example of a disruptive technology; there are dozens of others. To be honest, I have no idea how AEGIS would deal with a million targets, nor what having that many targets would do to its ability to track things like Chinese landing craft, unless the US were explicitly prepared for this particular threat.

Also, the C-RAM price-per-round is about $30. With a $1000 drone, things are cost-neutral if about 3% of rounds hit. At 10 kilometers, it would take rounds a little under 10 seconds to arrive. Even modestly chaotic trajectories would dodge most rounds.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Sunday September 12, 2021 @12:50PM (#28502734)
Frankly: the discussion point of "suicide drones" is pretty ignorant.

25mph drones will not hold back a warship. They can't effectively close range at 10km out, let alone at 5km, 1km, or shorter. As I stated earlier: warships are literally faster than that.

The "meta" under discussion, by serious people (including Chinese investments / Chinese saber rattling) is the missile. 500mph cruise missiles, 1000mph supersonic missiles, and 3000mph hypersonic missiles.

If you're going to "suicide drone", you do it at 3000mph to impress people. You don't do it at 25mph. Even at 500mph and 1000mph, the methodology is so clearly ineffective that China has spent billions making 3000mph missiles instead.

The minute you start thinking about how these drones are going to take off, refuel, get their payloads (etc. etc.), is the minute you realize how impractical the whole proposal is. What kind of launch platform will these drones take off in? What's the effective range of a drone?

US Destroyers have tomahawk cruise missiles that can reliably hit targets 2000km away, and these missiles fly at 500mph+. How long does it take for your 25mph drone to cover the 2000km range that these Destroyers are at defending Taiwan?

By the time your drones get there, the Destroyers have already launched all their missiles and have gone home.

------

How do you even find the warships in the first place? You keep saying "hundreds of drones", but drones flying at 10km high can only see 300km out.

Secondly: if you fly "like a bird" at say 1000meters, you can only see 100km out before the horizon blocks you. It'd be impossible to track down the warships firing from 2000km away.

At these ranges, the E2 Hawkeye of the Carrier will see your drones, and an appropriate response will be dispatched. Most likely, the warships will just avoid the drones. Hiding behind the horizon.

What kind of drone are you using to even try to tavel 2000km over water? I'm pretty sure that your typical $1000 drone simply don't have the range or speed to even get to the warships.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragonwriter on Sunday September 12, 2021 @06:20AM (#28499915)
> There's no way the US is getting drawn into a land war in Asia.

Classic blunder or not, the US gets drawn into land wars in Asia fairly regularly (especially in the 21st century, where we’ve spent most of it involved in two at once.) 1950-1953 Korea, 1955-1973 Vietnam, 1991 Iraq, 2001-2021 Afghanistan, 2003-2011 Iraq II: Elecric Boogaloo, 2014-? Iraq III: Now with Syria, too.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ericmay on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:01AM (#28480893)
I either agree or think your predictions make sense, but I think your premises that lead to them are a little bit suspect.

China doesn't have the same manufacturing prowess that the US did because of its location. In World War II, the US was essentially an untouchable supply chain with access to both oceans. It could fight Japan and supply Russia through the west if necessary, and it could fight Germany and supply England and Russia through the eat too.

In China's case, the main issue is that while the factories are certainly humming right along, they need to import food, oil, and other raw materials. Where do those come from? Certainly Russia, despite its blustering, isn't going to do too much to help China because that gives the U.S. an easy excuse to attack Russia in the east. Expect Russia to sit this one out and maybe screw around in a inconsequential way in Europe at best.

Will China then get resources from neighbors? Sure. Except now they have to transport all of these raw materials to the east coast of China where all the factories are. Lots of lead times here.

Meanwhile, the US can simply purchase the same materials from untouched supply chains in Europe and South America.

> it could build a blue water navy or whatever else it wants in record time.

I very much doubt this. And this has to happen years (decades?) before a war breaks out. China would have to build these ships in docks on the shore, which would be vulnerable to any number of U.S. bombing campaigns from strategic locations (Guam, Japan, carrier fleet, etc.). Not to say why wouldn't the U.S. also build hypersonic missiles?

> It also has the political ability to engage in major projects like these (see respective COVID19 responses).

Sure, that's always the general strength of the authoritarian regime. The ability to issue dictates. But that's also the great weakness, because you can go down a very wrong path and you won't know until its too late. Japan experienced this in World War II.

But the U.S. (and allies) would undoubtedly be united in a response to a Chinese invasion of Taiwan. The center-left, center, and entire right wing of the US for sure would be. So I'm not sure I'd look at the U.S.'s COVID-19 response and generalize from that.

> I suspect Chinese military leadership is far more competent than US or EU. The cream of the crop in the West doesn't go into the military (see Afghanistan for an good example of how US armed forces are managed).

What do you base this on? If nothing else, the United States and European Union (NATO allies) have been engaging in actual joint operations all over the world for the past 20-some years.

And the U.S. fought a different kind of war in Afghanistan than it would the one it might have to fight against China in the Pacific. First, the U.S. occupied the country just fine for 20 years, and then got tired of it. The U.S. also operated with very strict rules of engagement. Like, shoot at US soldiers then throw your Ak-47 in the weeds and say it wasn't you and nobody could do anything since you didn't have your weapon on you. Iraq looks to be a better example but neither should be relied upon as a good case.

> I also think we will see major disruptions in military from autonomous and semi-autonomous machines which will really reduce the US lead. DJI is headquartered in China, as are many of the other players here.

Who cares about DJI?

> If heave machines like carriers are obsoleted, the US advantage might turn into an expensive liability.

Weren't you saying that China would build a blue-water navy in record time? What would they do with this obsolete navy?

But the U.S. doesn't need to keep its carrier groups within range of any Chinese action to cause lots of problems for China. A naval blockade, they can go sink ships in ports that are friendly to China but aren't in China, etc.

> The Chinese military also has more manpower.

True that quantity does have a quality all of its own, but it seems like a bottle neck to me. Are they going to load up boat after boat and sail soldiers to Taiwan? Seems like a pretty expensive offensive and will Chinese moral handle losing soldiers in boats going to attack Taiwan? Lots of uncertainties.

Anyway, my point here was just to provide some counterpoints to some of yours here. Frankly, this is all really stupid.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:50AM (#28482363)
> Not to say why wouldn't the U.S. also build hypersonic missiles?

China isn't even building missile-defense cruisers (equivalent to the AEGIS system on US-ships). Our tomahawks (cheaper, subsonic cruise missiles) would obliterate them at much cheaper prices.

Why fly at 3000mph (hypersonic) when 500mph is already too fast for their defenses?

There's no reason to build hypersonic missiles until China (or Russia) demonstrates missile-defense capabilities. Even then: the methodology of "launch 20 missiles simultaneously to overwhelm their defense system" seems a lot cheaper than using developing or using hypersonic missiles.

Cheap subsonic cruise missiles are all you need unless your opponent can shoot them down. China needs Hypersonic because of AEGIS (ie: we've reliably demonstrated that we can shoot down missiles flying at 500mph). China hasn't done that, and doesn't seem to have any plans to obtain this technology yet.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ALittleLight on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:37PM (#28487182)
"The center-left, center, and entire right wing of the US for sure would be."

I doubt that. I am an American and wouldn't support war with China over Taiwan. I don't know a single person who has ever said anything suggesting they think we should commit the country to war to protect Taiwan.

Coming off the failed Afghanistan war I expect war would be extremely unpopular. Especially with an enemy so much more capable than assorted Afghan militia.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by AnimalMuppet on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:53PM (#28487321)
I really don't want another war. At the same time, I don't want the world that would result from China taking Taiwan, either.

What's wrong with that world? 1) We didn't keep our promises. 2) Another 23 million people oppressed by force against their will. Even if it isn't our job to defend them, it still doesn't sit well to see it happen. 3) We can't get chips (much less important than the other two).

Where does that leave me? Not wanting war, but not wanting the alternative? There are a fair number of people with that perspective. If it comes to it, what will we decide? I don't know, even for myself.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by PakG1 on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:33AM (#28478426)
War is tough and horrible. Any person can see that. There are many complex reasons why the larger Afghan army could not stand up to the Taliban, and while the situation is not comparable at all to the Chinese military, my point is that around the world, there are military units that aren't prepared or willing to fight the wars that their politicians wage.

I do wager that China's PLA would win a war that involves Taiwan, just due to sheer numbers and resources, but that the experience would be so bitter that the PLA would lose morale in various respects. This is partly because they don't actually have real war experience in the modern era.

Even armies with real war experience can get bitter. Armies without real war experience that suddenly get thrown into the fire, I'd wager that they would get even more bitter. PTSD and suicides would only be par for the course, the real issue would be inexperienced soldiers starting to question "what are we really doing and why am I killing people, do I really believe in what I'm doing?" I wager it would create cracks in what is currently a fairly unified country in China.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by belter on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:03AM (#28480913)
You are seeing too much from a modern occidental perspective although I dont know where you are from.

No PTSD in the divisions that were driving over their own citizens in this event: https://imgur.com/bGP9oKf

Also no hesitation, dissent of any kind is known, from the internal departments implementing it in Hong Kong, Tibet, or Xinjiang.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tasogare on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:55AM (#28478255)
The local big player is Japan. It would be hard to intervene because of its current constitution but I don't see them letting PRC push its border so close. Moreover Okinawa was historically a vassal state of both Chinese empires and Japan, so it's possible China greed could extend there as well.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by rackjack on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:08AM (#28478005)
> Let's just assume for a moment that the US will fight off attacks by China to take Taiwan. And that US successfully ward off an attack. What next? What is there to prevent China from trying again and again and again? Will the US be prepared to ward off attacks after attacks after attacks? This is unlikely to happen.

America did this in Korea and it split the country in half.

> With this, lets again assume that China eventually successfully takes Taiwan. What next? They would have taken over an island with a large number of people who resents their rule. There will be a persistent resistance group as long as Beijing continues her ways and Beijing is aware of this and is trying to shape the education of the younger generations so that the resentment does not cross generations.

Also, brainwashing via complete control of the media, disappearing dissidents... They're doing it to the Falun Gong and the Muslims and others and they'll have no problem doing it to more.

> Even if all these were to take place and all hope seems to be lost. There is a glimmer of hope. A totalitarian state has one major fault. There is no effective feedback mechanism and to assume that this one man can make the right call, the right decision all the time is a stretch. At some point, be it internal infighting, or a policy misstep creating intense misery amongst the people, there will be discontent and if the history of China is any indication, the discontent can trigger uprisings and eventually a change of regime.

Also possible for there to be enough bureaucratic momentum that those within it have enough skin in the game to want to install a new head. But once China's growth starts to slow down I wouldn't be surprised at the CCP losing the Mandate of Heaven and the Ouroboros eating its tail again.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by klodolph on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:11AM (#28478333)
> America did this in Korea and it split the country in half.

That is not even close to what happened. Korea was divided at the end of WWII into Soviet and US occupation zones after the Japanese surrender. Prior to that, it had been occupied by Japan.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by JackeJR on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:05AM (#28482599)
I agree that once the growth slows China will start to see cracks in its society. This, I submit, is the reason why Beijing is doubling down on the nationalist path. Cast the West as the enemy and China as the victim of oppression to drum up nationalist sentiments.

The social compact I believe that exists in China is that the people put up with the curbs either out of ignorance of the lacks of curbs or because of the promise of a better life which comes along with increased job wages as long as they toe the party line.

The moment the bargain is not held up for the increased wages, the compact starts to get eroded. Turmoil in China if it happens will have a widespread and largely unknown consequences. Unknown because too many pieces are intricately linked to the stable functioning of China.

For one, I hope to be able to witness this one day.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Monday September 13, 2021 @12:54AM (#28507981)
> Cast the West as the enemy and China as the victim of oppression to drum up nationalist sentiments.

Well, no, this is what US is doing, paint China as the source of all evil.

Yourself is the product of that ploy.

Think about Afghanistan, after so many years of wasted money life and time, one still think war is the answer.

How effective the propaganda has been...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by belter on Friday September 10, 2021 @07:53AM (#28480258)
From a tactical point a view it looks a minor issue, except of course for the people of Taiwan. I cannot imagine what somebody in Taiwan, born and raised in a democracy, might be thinking when looking at what is happening in Hong Kong

From the Strategic point of view, you have to look at a map to see what that would mean. China would take over Taiwan, and immediately expand its sea island building around its borders. Cut off the Philippines and Japan across the South China Sea. From Taiwan a fighter jet can be over Japan in 10 min. Australia with its rich mineral resources and empty spaces would be next...

That the US, Australia, Japan together not make it clear to China invading Taiwan would mean a price not worth paying, will prove to be the Strategic blunder of this Century.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nmfisher on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:37AM (#28483041)
I don't know where this absurd idea came from that "China invading Taiwan" means "Australia/Japan would be next!".

As far as the PRC is concerned, Taiwan is a part of China. They wouldn't be invading another nations, they would simply be reclaiming sovereignty over a renegade province.

That is something entirely different from invading a Western ally. One thing has absolutely no bearing on the other.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by belter on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:53PM (#28484986)
Well historically Taiwan could argue China is the renegade province. See other comments in this thread for the context.

I think you are missing the main point. Despite an arbitration court ruling against it, China decided all of the China Sea is theirs: https://im-media.voltron.voanews.com/Drupal/01live-166/style...

"The South China Sea Arbitration (The Republic of Philippines v. The People's Republic of China)" https://pca-cpa.org/en/cases/7/

Started making artificial islands in the middle of nowhere, and now says all foreign vessels need to report in their ‘territorial waters’.

"China to require foreign vessels to report in ‘territorial waters’" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28395358

Have a look at a map, and see the distance from Yonaguni ( Japan ) to Taiwan and the distance Yonaguni to mainland Japan. You think China will do what they are doing in Hong Kong, Xinjiang, South China Sea and suddenly...Come to their senses and stop, specially if unchallenged for previous actions?

If they do this in the other side of the world: "Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s waters" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27412691

What will they do at their door?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by greyhair on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:58AM (#28481658)
Are you in the diplomatic corps? Are you certain that US, Australia, and Japan are not communicating to China? Not all diplomatic exchanges are made public. For example, it is clear that the US is currently talking with the Taliban leadership. What are they saying? We have no idea, but it is taking place. I suspect the same is true for the above.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Rd6n6 on Saturday September 11, 2021 @07:04PM (#28496926)
Huge thread about a war between the USA and China without serious mention of nuclear weapons and nuclear winter
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ukoki on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:01AM (#28478559)
There will be political unrest as soon as the populace realise that the easy victory they were promised is not materialising and in fact tens of thousands of sons -- only-children who represent the future, pride and prosperity of their parents -- will not be returning home.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jeswin on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:29PM (#28477120)
> I fear Taiwan will soon be conquered by China, not by force but suppression and economic ties.

A majority in Taiwan (two-thirds) are against unification, and that's hardended further after what's happened in HongKong. This is especially so among young people, who mostly also identify as being exclusively Taiwanese. Support for unification mostly comes from KMT, who are older and identify as Taiwanese and Chinese. As that generation fades away, these ratios will tilt even further.

For most young Taiwanese, Mainland China has nothing to offer for them to want unification.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Bayart on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:42AM (#28478775)
>It elected a first female president in Taiwan, allowed gay marriage...etc

It's a trap to equate "progressive" social change with democracy. It's perfectly possible to have a socially liberal society that's also very authoritarian. In fact the Western world is going in that direction.

The rule of law is a better example of an artifact of democracy.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by etaioinshrdlu on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:31PM (#28477509)
There's still Singapore, and it is not in the line of fire of China.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tablespoon on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:07AM (#28477713)
> There's still Singapore, and it is not in the line of fire of China.

Isn't Singapore already pretty authoritarian?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by bakuninsbart on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:09AM (#28478010)
Singapore does not significantly differ in its authoritarianism from the PRC. They are however much richer, much smaller, and decided to follow a "capitalist" model, so they get less hate in our political discourse.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by AussieWog93 on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:49AM (#28478224)
That is the most ridiculous hyperbole I have ever heard.

Yes, Singapore does have strict limitations on freedom of speech, but at the same time have separation of powers, free elections and a national identity separate to the PAP.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by shkkmo on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:31AM (#28478421)
Singapor only has "Free Elections™" where the opposition is strictly controlled and not allowed to win more than a token number of seats. See also: Nicaragua, Venezuala, etc...

> That is the most ridiculous hyperbole I have ever heard.

That's an ironically hyperobolic statment itself.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by AussieWog93 on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:02AM (#28478560)
>Singapor only has "Free Elections™" where the opposition is strictly controlled and not allowed to win more than a token number of seats.

Through limitations on campaigning, gerrymandering and defamation suits. Not ideal, but no threats, no bullets, no bribing the electoral commission. A far cry from China where they crush entire populations with police brutality.

(In regards to my original comment, SG's elections are free in the sense that all citizens can vote without fear of backlash, but they are not fair because the PAP rig things in their favour)

>That's an ironically hyperobolic statment itself

That's the joke.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by baybal2 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:38PM (#28477555)
> Singapore, and it is not in the line of fire of China.

...

Please keep watch of news. They already started "tickling" Singapore since a few years ago.

Not to mention, Mao been sending his subvertionists to Malaysia, and Singapore through sixties, and seventies

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Monday September 13, 2021 @01:01AM (#28508017)
You'll be startled to know that Sun Yat-sen was a favorite of USSR and Comintern, better than CCP and Mao. And Mao has been the propaganda department head of KMT...

Thinking of politics as some random personal preference, what a showing of naivate...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by krageon on Friday September 10, 2021 @04:32AM (#28479066)
Of course there are places, they'll just be outside of China.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by baybal2 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:36PM (#28477540)
> There is no hope for China to turn into a democratic country.

With enough ammunition, any country can be made a democracy

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tjpnz on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:39PM (#28477562)
In name only perhaps.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by rmujica on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:48PM (#28477603)
turned out alright for Afghanistan
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by howaboutnope on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:59PM (#28477660)
Turned out alright for Nazi Germany. As a German, I'm absolutely grateful the Nazis were crushed militarily, rather than, you know, still reigning.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by inglor_cz on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:36AM (#28478162)
A question out of curiosity: would you prefer DDR to be crushed militarily as well, instead of just giving up the ghost in 1989?

As a fellow European, I can see that communists are somehow still considered better than the Nazis, and part of the difference might be that their gulags were never conquered by an external force and photos of their skeletal prisoners never made it to the media. They mostly dismantled them themselves once Stalin was dead and the regimes behind the Iron Curtain turned from outright murderous to just oppressive.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by howaboutnope on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:24AM (#28478394)
> would you prefer DDR to be crushed militarily as well, instead of just giving up the ghost in 1989?

Why are you assuming I wouldn't have prefered the Nazis to have "given up the ghost" as well? Are there any signs of the CCP "giving up the ghost" anytime soon? Given the choices that actually existed, I prefer, as the White Rose put it in one of their leaflets, an end with terror rather than terror without end. Human mortality is a given either way, the dignity that comes with agency and intellectual integrity is what the struggle is about. I don't ask for how long someone lived, but as who they lived.. or as Hannah Arendt put it:

> Once upon a time, there was a happy time when people were free to choose; better to die dead than to be a slave, better to die standing than to live on one's knees. Once upon a time there was a wicked time when imbecile intellectuals declared that life was the highest of goods. Today the terrible time has come, when it is proved every day that death begins its reign of terror exactly when life has become the highest good; that he who prefers to live on his knees dies on his knees; that no one is easier to murder than a slave. We the living have to learn that one cannot even live on one's knees, that one does not become immortal by chasing life, and that when one no longer wants to die for anything, one dies even though one has done nothing.

-- Hannah Arendt via DeepL

> As a fellow European, I can see that communists are somehow still considered better than the Nazis

That's still like saying something with a lethal dose of 50g is better food than something with a lethal dose of 5g. I don't see the point of even ranking them.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by bryanrasmussen on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:09AM (#28478591)
well you can get trace amounts of the 50g poison in your food and maybe not even get sick.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:38AM (#28477872)
> It wasn't part of China

HK was sold to Britain as part of the corrupted and weak China's humiliation.

What do you want to say?

Are you trying to depict the image that HK has been forcefully claimed by China?

Please stop this type of propaganda behavior. I don't like CCP, but that does not make HK not part of China.

We Chinese eventually will get rid of CCP, but we don't want the great nation get split. Just like any patriot in US would not want this great nation get split.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by blkhp19 on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:23AM (#28478679)
Who cares what it was / wasn't part of. The majority of people in HK don't want to be part of China. That's all that matters.

> We Chinese eventually will get rid of CCP, but we don't want the great nation get split.

Dude, what? HK hasn't been part of China for years. What possible justification could you have for re-integrating it. This isn't about preventing a split, this is about undoing a split, and destroying a democracy in the process.

For someone who is anti-CCP, you don't seem to empathize with the people in HK who tasted democracy and have had it ripped away.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tluyben2 on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:46AM (#28478804)
> Who cares what it was / wasn't part of

You can wipe it away like that, but it is the entire point of Chinese leadership since a long time, even opposing parties, that what once was China will be China again. So the 'who cares' is the vital point in why they are doing this; they care very much, not about the pieces of land or the people, but just the simple fact that they consider it China because it was taken from them (and they always said they will get it back) no matter who say they own it now (Taiwan is not uniformly recognised as a state). And I believe many (majority?) on the mainland agree with this, even if they don't agree with the CCP.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by krageon on Friday September 10, 2021 @04:38AM (#28479096)
> HK hasn't been part of China for years

HK was always a part of China, just under specific rules.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ksec on Sunday September 12, 2021 @06:34PM (#28505681)
>For someone who is anti-CCP,

You now get why it is pointless to argue with the Chinese. And Hong Kong wasn't returned to China. It was Handed over. You can also tell most of their assumption about China were taught when they were young. It is always hard to break those assumptions.

Most part of Hong Kong doesn't belong to China for close to 150 years. And you can read why they want Taiwan with so called unification. Taiwan wasn't even part of so called China for most of human history.

They also claims to be Anti-CCP. But have done absolutely nothing against CCP. But because their love of China they must save China first ( helping CCP ) before they somehow get rid of CCP. Oh the irony.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Monday September 13, 2021 @12:39AM (#28507907)
Dude your comment is pure racism without self awareness. And a showing of ignorance beyond saving!

> You now get why it is pointless to argue with the Chinese

I suppose you say similar things in private, just swap Chinese with black, Mexican, Japanese etc.

It was OK to say this type of statement on “Chinese”, because, of cuz, even US president did this.

> And Hong Kong wasn't returned to China. It was Handed over.

Don't play the word on me...

The treaty was signed long time ago. And was the results of foticful invasion.

Returned or handed over, that's for Chinese, UK, and HK people to decide. You as a random (probably racism inclined as well) has no privilege to apply one word or another! And you are probably the least qualified as well, based on the amount of ignorance demonstrated in such a small number of words.

> You can also tell most of their assumption about China were taught when they were young.

WTF we Chinese told you things about China, and all those are what we were taught?!

First, is there anything wrong with that? You are boasting racism statements, which I assume was also taught in school? Is that OK?

And outside of class, we Chinese cannot learn the truth about China? For God's sake, CCP are not omnipotent entity who can control people's mind...

Or you are simply stating that Chinese are not capable of independent thinking, because we are just Chinese? (Of cuz, I am placing a racist trap for you, but likely that's what you are thinking right now...).

> It is always hard to break those assumptions.

Assumption?

I see things with my own eyes, and hear words with my own ears, and read books with my own mind.

You, someone, who randomly punce on Chinese topics, based on 300 years+ colonists education and indoctrination, and plagued by a racism bigot president, who should lead the nation on the positive and good, instead base his whole presidency on demonizing Chinese and China, are free from assumptions!?

You, are having a assumed righteous mindset, which couldn't be farther from the truth...

> Most part of Hong Kong doesn't belong to China for close to 150 years.

You failed to mentioned HK was abducted.

And UK applied brutal colonial ruling, and harsh indoctrination in all levels of the society.

Oh, of cuz, for someone who was decent from the people, who genocide the indigenous people, forgetting the source, omitting the root, is always the standard practice of demonizing the people with strong cultural roots...

> And you can read why they want Taiwan with so called unification.

What? Shed some light on the facts then.

> Taiwan wasn't even part of so called China for most of human history.

LMAO national states were not a thing for the most of human history, so what? Let's dissolve and ask UN to rule the world. I'll be very happy, if the head of the Mafia, would be willing to relinquish the supremacy...

> They also claims to be Anti-CCP.

Why? Why? Why do you relate to CCP? To paint a picture of hideous valin through association, right?

I am not surprised such ploy is well learned by the observers of the US mainstream media...

> But have done absolutely nothing against CCP.

When I was preaching the Chinese citizens rights and the need to stand strong against the bully and unfairness of the CCP officials, you would be calling me a CCP sponsored propagandist.

You are anti CCP, but only superficially in the name.

> But because their love of China they must save China first ( helping CCP ) before they somehow get rid of CCP.

What? Why save China needs to helping CCP? Are you suggesting that CCP is the only medium through which one can help improve China? I thought you are anti CCP, and want me to be one as well...

> Oh the irony.

Yep, your whole post is an irony. One that someone who does not have a clear mind, even muddier writing, delivered an outrageous irony of human ignorance...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:38PM (#28483948)
> Dude, what? HK hasn't been part of China for years. What possible justification could you have for re-integrating it.

Dude, how ignorant can you be?

HK was returned to China because of the original treaty between Qing and Britain.

Integration? WTF? It's part of the country, how can it not be integrated. I am startled by these showing of ignorance and self grandizlsing...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:35AM (#28483018)
> The majority of people in HK don't want to be part of China.

Where is your evidence?

I have friends live and working in HK. Certainly the silent majority doesn't care much. Like any normal people, they prefer better life and rewarding career, than being full time protester.

The 2016 US election already showed that the silent majority rarely aligned with the mainstream rhetoric.

Please be mindful about the reality.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by hker on Friday September 10, 2021 @04:22PM (#28486466)
> > The majority of people in HK don't want to be part of China.

The pro-democracy camp, who overwhemingly supported the anti-extradition (anti-CCP) protests in 2019, had a landslide victory during the District Council Election in 2019 [1].

CCP, realizing that fair elections could threaten its rule in Hong Kong, later imposed the National Security Law and arrested lots of opposition members [2].

And then many HKers voted with their feet, literally not being part of China, to show their distrust of the future of Hong Kong under CCP rule [3].

> Where is your evidence?

> Please be mindful about the reality.

[1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/24/world/asia/hong-kong-elec...

[2]: https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/one-year-hong-kon...

[3]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2021/07/14/hong-kong-ex...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:39PM (#28487202)
You are mixing different things together.

[1] is for local district election. It's ridiculous to say that these elected personels are pro democracy, as if pro democracy is conflicting with CCP. CCP sanctions the democracy state of HK. That's part of deal of the treaty. This is one thing.

Additional, these elected officials are for local executive branches. They actually have no say in how the fundamental political structure ought to do or what to do in the place.

In the typical NYT fashion, they link two groups of people together without formal evidences.

[2] And the national security law. As a common practice all over the world, the law does not change anything in how the HK political system working. I am not sure why any patriotic citizens in HK would find national security law impairs their activity to uphold the democracy in HK. I mean the law literally has nothing to say about how power structure should be. It only states that no one share impair China's sovereignty over HK.

Lastly, stop painting the HK protests as some grandiose ideology fight. It's just young people are not getting the opportunity for flourishing. It's no different than "occupying wall street" it was just that China happen to be the favorite punching bag of disfunctional government to offset their incompetence.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Haga on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:50AM (#28478227)
This "great" nation was built on the corpse of several smaller nations a d ethnic groups. Theire reservations are a Disneyland of death by funny dances and deserve to be protected?
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:47AM (#28483192)
This great nation was not built on the corpse of smaller nation.

Since the Zhou dynasty, which derived from tribal era, China was already a unified entity. The process of creating Zhou was certainly not involving any other nations.

Qin dynasty, China have already been a unified country, under unified laws, economic rules, and mixed culture. With a great deal of characteristics of modern nations.

Qin's unification process is standard warfare between feudal lords. Very much like what happened in the long history of Europe.

Once China was unified this way. The cycle of division and unification have never ceased.

Your statement is at best inaccurate. At worst just random imagination.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Dah00n on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:35AM (#28479701)
The same could be said of the US. I'd even go as far as saying it is historically worse in the US.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:41PM (#28484005)
Well, no, China's unification was a cultural and ethnicity blanding. It was never a genocide.

First I already debunked the notion that China conquered small nations to form its heritage. No China got it's heritage long ago through tribal merger.

And the US history of founding is patently different, and vastly more brutal and immoral...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by yuy910616 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:13PM (#28474724)
Really reminds me of the Taiwan election commercial that compares Taiwan and Hong Kong https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykcVIQMrc4A
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by yodsanklai on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:50PM (#28475612)
The amount of effort China is putting to sabotage Taiwan independence is astonishing. I have Taiwanese relatives and I'm very worried for them.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Aperocky on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:39PM (#28476026)
Replace Taiwan with Republic of China (i.e. formal name) and it isn't nearly as astonishing anymore isn't it.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by KidComputer on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:14AM (#28478025)
Deep. Bet you think New England belongs to the British.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Aperocky on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:11AM (#28481025)
No, but Republic/Kingdom of England is way more confusing innit.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by gogopuppygogo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:54PM (#28475645)
The USA has been losing all war games where it defends Tawain against China.

https://nypost.com/2021/03/11/us-war-games-over-china-threat...

It is not okay to assume USA supremacy against adversaries anymore.

Why Americans still do business with China is astounding to me.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ranger207 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:56PM (#28476157)
Wargames are designed to be lost. It's not as useful to say "welp we stomped all over them" as it is to push the forces being tested further and further until they break, then fixing or compensating where it broke and pushing even further. Wargames aren't constrained by reality, and the game's opposing force may be more powerful than in reality. Just hearing that the US lost a wargame doesn't mean anything without knowing more details. Think of a wargame as the military's version of a pentest.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tablespoon on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:18AM (#28477778)
> Wargames are designed to be lost. It's not as useful to say "welp we stomped all over them" as it is to push the forces being tested further and further until they break, then fixing or compensating where it broke and pushing even further.

Wasn't there a pretty famous case, in a wargame meant to simulate conflict with Iran, where the red team general actually played to win but the game leaders reset things with new constraints that played to US advantages?

There are also pretty significant intrinsic problems with a Taiwan strait conflict: it's literally in China's backyard and the PLA is modernizing so the US can no longer rely on having an overwhelming technological advantage. IIRC, Taiwan's military strategy also assumes that they'll have a technological over the PRC, so they haven't embraced asymmetric tactics as much as they should.

From my armchair, it seems to me that Taiwan needs to adopt something like the Israeli model, where pretty much their whole population is in the reserves and can be mobilized quickly for a conflict. The US needs to figure out a way to reinforce and resupply it, and disentangle its supply chains from China to make that workable.

However, I'm not hopeful with the kind of leadership we have now. It's thinking is too short term and it's unwilling to make any really costly commitments.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ranger207 on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:28PM (#28483824)
You're probably thinking of the 2002 Millennium Challenge. That was a wargame plus a training exercise, which complicates things. For example, there were real US Navy ships out in the Persian Gulf, but to avoid disrupting commercial traffic they were confined to a specific area. The OPFOR (opposing forces) commander knew the confines, so he didn't have to scout for BLUFOR (US forces), and BLUFOR couldn't maneuver to avoid him. For another example, BLUFOR was jamming and destroying all of OPFOR's communications, so OPFOR switched to motorcycle runners. Unfortunately the simulation software didn't exactly support motorcycle runners, so they moved just as fast as radio communications but were invulnerable to BLUFOR strikes.

BLUFOR kept getting revived because it was also a training exercise in addition to a wargame. You've got dozens of ships gathered in the area to practice formation maneuvering, underway replenishment, etc, under wartime conditions. If you're on a ship that's blown up on day 2 of 20, what are you supposed to do for the rest of the time? It's better for training to revive casualties.

Stuff like this is why it's not easy to trust the outcome of a wargame.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by bryanrasmussen on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:26AM (#28478688)
>Wasn't there a pretty famous case, in a wargame meant to simulate conflict with Iran, where the red team general actually played to win but the game leaders reset things with new constraints that played to US advantages?

yes, wargames are designed to be difficult to win, unless political expediency interferes with the design.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:26PM (#28477094)
It's an accurate portrayal. The US also made wargames where it won against China, that required future weapons systems against present-day China.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Aeolun on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:05PM (#28476218)
I mean, they’re playing a wargame against themselves, so technically they won too.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by coliveira on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:17PM (#28477425)
Similar words were said right before the invasion of Afghanistan... Now we see the folly of foreign invasion.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by delecti on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:26PM (#28477483)
We won Afghanistan fairly easily (a few months), and held it fairly easily for 19 years. And not to trivialize 4000 dead, but if it had mattered, that would have been a pretty small sacrifice.

Where we failed miserably was at turning the result into a stable country, but Taiwan is already a country.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jacquesm on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:47PM (#28477601)
Once upon a time Afghanistan was also a country.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by fnord77 on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:28AM (#28477821)
I don't think it was ever a _stable_ country.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jacquesm on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:49AM (#28477924)
https://www.theatlantic.com/photo/2013/07/afghanistan-in-the...

Besides that, stability is always relative, in the longer term no country is ever stable, in the shorter term in the case of countries like Afghanistan they are stable about as long as other nations don't cross their borders.

Vietnam, Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran and many others besides. All of these were at some point reasonably stable, and then someone somewhere decided to attempt to enlist them in one scheme or another and/or tried to wage a proxy war through them or actively tried to install regimes more friendly to foreign interests.

The Roman Empire in the long run also wasn't stable, but it fell to rot from within, as most countries eventually do. But in the case of Afghanistan the destructive force was applied from without.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dirtyid on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:49PM (#28476906)
Sure, but you can also examine recent US defense proposals / thinktank wonks gaming out indo pacific strategy, i.e. AGILE deployment in Japan, hosting IRBMs in region. The overwhelming pattern and prevailing consensus for those that follow the space is that despite proposals being aspirational / borderline geopolitical fantasy, US blobs aren't even pretending to pursue strategies that explicitly defend TW anymore. Force balance has changed so much with PRC military modernization that US simply cannot defend TW against PRC off her shores. So much so that it's barely worth speculating anymore. Focus is on containing PRC which =/= defending TW. Entirely different propositions that normies still try to conflate with TW defense.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dforrestwilson on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:02PM (#28476964)
Japan would care a lot if China made a move on Taiwan. They recently strengthened defense ties there.

Wouldn't just be the U.S.

Oh, and two of the above mentioned countries have real blue water navies that can go anywhere to cut supply lines like say, oil from the Middle East. One does not.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by smegger001 on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:21AM (#28478065)
the thing is Taiwan can't count on the US as we have demonstrated that we aren't willing to help when called on by a nation we have treaty obligations to. The US agreed to defend Ukraine from Russia in event of invasion in exchange for Ukraine getting rid of its nuclear stockpile. Then Russia invaded the Crimean peninsula, part of Ukraine, and the US did nothing.

Why would the US treat Taiwan any differently when China is the US biggest trading partner?

As for Japan, they are constitutionally prevented from declaring war.

So of Taiwans strongest alies, one cant defend them,and one wont defend them.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dforrestwilson on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:34AM (#28480615)
TSMC.

We legit need their semi production for defense much more than we need cheap plastic kids toys at Walmart.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:28PM (#28477107)
There is absolutely nothing that Japan could do.

Cutting oil from the ME would not be enough. China would ration oil and increase imports from Russia massively as well as reactivate domestic oil production, it would be great for the environment, China would carry on, and the US would make a lot of enemies.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by seanmcdirmid on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:01PM (#28477301)
The Ryukyus are mostly adjacent to Taiwan, it’s also where most of America’s Japan based military bases are. So in terms of air power brought to bare, China has a huge hill to climb with enemies right next door. The main reason that China has pushed for dominance of the entire South China Sea is simply so that they aren’t easily hemmed in from the rest of the world.

A war between the USA and China would ultimately do no one good, even Chinese wolf warriors should realize that.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:00AM (#28481679)
No, it really doesn't. Japan doesn't have the capacity to deploy enough air power to affect the invasion. If Japan made the strategic mistake of getting involved militarily before the US, the Chinese would use ballistic missiles to strike Japanese airbases and supply infrastructure and carry on.

I agree it would do no good to have a war between the US and China for anyone. I want Taiwan to stay independent and chose its own destiny. But the reality is that China has an overwhelming advantage in-theater over anyone and it's only getting worse.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by simonh on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:49PM (#28477223)
If China invaded Taiwan, Europe would stand together with the US on any retaliation. It would be the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait all over again, geopolitically. China would be cut off dead from the global economy, no matter the cost. I don’t think it would be practical to liberate Taiwan, but China would be ruined.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:00PM (#28477298)
China is not Iraq. It's insane to compare the two.

Europe was okay with the first invasion of Iraq because they frankly had very little to lose and a lot to gain.

Meanwhile suiciding the EU economy by cutting off Chinese exports would hurt the EU a lot more than it would hurt China and certainly much more than the invasion of Kuwait.

In any case I'd recommend reading what Chinese generals write on the subject. For the exact same reason as you cited they don't want to invade Taiwan unless "necessary" until the balance of trade shifts far more into the Chinese side.

Yet when confronted on the possibility of doing it now they make a very solid point. China is the only country in the world that produces everything it needs for daily operations, without a single exception, in one way or another.

That is to say, in the Chinese calculus, the EU and US cutting themselves off of Chinese trade would hurt the former more in the short term and medium term than it would hurt China, and their arguments for it are compelling.

Beyond that, the truth is that there is a lot more to the economy than the EU and the US. China would still trade with Russia, Africa, South East Asia, almost definitely South Korea, and most of Central and South Asia.

The real thing that is at issue in Chinese military planning is not a voluntary embargo, it's a blockade by the US. But even the ability for the US to execute such a maneuver is already questionable and dwindles every year, and it would assuredly royally piss of the entirety of the world and definitely kill millions outside of China from economic dysfunction.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by goatsi on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:16PM (#28477422)
>China is the only country in the world that produces everything it needs for daily operations, without a single exception, in one way or another.

Tell me what I'm missing about their domestic oil industry then, because everything else I'm reading tells me they need to import around 10 million barrels of crude oil a day (primarily to produce gasoline and diesel, so it's very hard to substitute).

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:53AM (#28481586)
Indeed, they do. They still have the domestic capacity to expand internal production to cover most of those 10 million barrels. I didn't say they produce everything they need in sufficient quantities, just that they produce it. It would cause short term trouble and rationing but long term the impact is mitigated.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by goatsi on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:10PM (#28483562)
Looking at the most recent numbers, they produced just under 4 million barrels a day domestically. Oil production isn't something where you can just triple the output over a few months. China has been working to expand their internal production for a while, and it takes billions of dollars and years to do so: https://www.forbes.com/sites/edhirs/2019/06/06/china-is-bett...
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:18PM (#28488302)
They don't need to triple it in months. Increasing domestic supply by 50%, increasing Russian oil imports from 1.7 mbd to 3mbd.

Meanwhile, China has reserves for 100 days of imports.

In the long term domestic and Russian production will catch up fully.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by goatsi on Saturday September 11, 2021 @05:09PM (#28496057)
Did you read the article? Why would they plan to spend 77 billion over 5 years for a 50% increase in production if they could crank it out of their existing infrastructure in under 100 days?

And even if Russia repudiated every other contract they have in Asia, it doesn't look like they have the pipeline capacity to get that much oil to China, even if the cross border capacity for China to import it existed. So it would have to come on tankers, which would generate some interesting geopolitical brinkmanship.

That's assuming things don't escalate far beyond sanctions or a possible blockade. The risk with a naval confrontation is that it's very easy to quickly generate casualties that would make backing down politically suicidal. Even just a few of the smaller ships getting sunk means hundreds of dead sailors.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Sunday September 12, 2021 @12:24AM (#28498609)
77 billion is the price to do it right over 5 years. If you don't care about quality and are willing to spend more you can do it faster. We have historical examples of this.

The pipeline capacity alone from Russia to China is 1.6mbd. Of that, 600 000bd are used, so there is 1mbd of spare capacity just in that pipeline.

It doesn't really matter if the US can or can't back down. It will be disastrous politically and economically to the US and its allies to a level that can scarcely be imagined. Even then, US naval forces have a serious chance of defeat. China is not a small country you can roll over. They have a very well thought out, multilayered, exceedingly technologically sophisticated A2/AD umbrella that means that millions of square kilometers will be in practice off limits to the US. Beyond those zones, China enjoys extremely prompt hypersonic strike capability that has no real counter, which means that in a hot war any US vessel that gets it's rough location leaked running a blockade or running through a strait risks getting sunk straight up.

It's not a war that the US can win. What are the objectives? Take back Taiwan? Literally impossible. Regime change in China? Forget about it. About the only thing that can be done is to hurt the Chinese economy roughly as much as the US economy, enrage the entire rest of the world and destroy any semblance of goodwill the US has, and trigger a recession followed by a restructuring of the US economy that reduces the place of the US in the value chain.

It's simply a stupid move that has no upside. It doesn't matter how the public acts immediately, eventually the US will have to give up.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by c_o_n_v_e_x on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:41PM (#28477576)
"China is the only country in the world that produces everything it needs for daily operations, without a single exception, in one way or another."

...produces finished goods. China cannot do this without massive imports of raw materials copper, iron ore, coal, etc. China has effectively colonized Africa for access to said raw materials.

Belt and Road is a way to set up overland routes to avoid any naval blockades.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:55AM (#28481607)
China hasn't colonized Africa.

China produces very significant amounts of copper ore, iron ore, coal, and has the facilities to expand production on short notice .

It would hurt production in the short term, yes, but there wouldn't be anything that China would completely miss.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by throwaway210222 on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:23AM (#28478677)
> China has effectively colonized Africa

Where do you you get this crap from?

I live in Africa and I have never been told what to do by a Chinese official or business - or even a local official actin on the instructions of a mandarin.

Unless you have watered 'colonisation' down to 'Chinese interests own some stuff in parts of Africa'.

Which - to indulge my woke hat - pretty offensive to people who lived under actual colonisation.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by simonh on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:36AM (#28481341)
That's fair, don't understand the downvotes. The thing is colonisation now extends to things like believing western science and liking western music. It's become watered down to just mean any form of developed world influence.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by throwaway210222 on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:49AM (#28482333)
Just a small correction: there is no such thing as Western science.

There is just science.

[Unless people truly believe the Chinese space programme uses its own, different physics, or that the concrete in the new Ethiopian dam on the Nile river has its own chemistry.]

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dirtyid on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:30AM (#28478707)
JP/TW had "security" dialogue that basically amounted to JP begging Taiwan for semi fabs. JP isn't going to do shit because like US they're even less capable of defending TW. JP actions has been all rhetoric. It means nothing until they commit to credible but politically expensive actions. Some notional missile force increase on Ryukyu is theatre when what's needed is massive mobilization of main islands (and put every JP civilian in harms way) outside of Okinawa as prescribed in AGILE. It's not going to happen, they can't even commit to land based Aegis Ashore ABM to save themselves from NK nukes.

>One does not.

PRC has blue water Navy that operates up to ME and has been for years. It's also signifantly larger and more capable than Japans. I suspect you need to update understanding from old Zeihan powerpoints.

With respect to US, PRC has 30 CEP ICBMs which means USNavy vessels become scrap the second they pull into port. Even nuclear carriers can't stay at sea forever, nevermind their sustainment / oilers / resupply ships will be long gone. US carrier groups will likely be one-time deployment assets. This is roughly reality now, and and even more dire in the coming years. US can sink every PLAN ship on the waters and PRC can sink every USN ship in port. Or destroy entire east Asian fab supply chain, setting back US industry/tech decades. Or bait US security commitments in Korea / Japan which compels US to send assets within 1st island chain where they are weakest, negating point of blockade outside of 1st island chain. The wank over blockading PRC via Malacca / SLOC overlooks the fact that at minimum PRC can force US to sign a hegemony suicide pact. PRC can make US lose everything even in defeat. And is willing to over TW.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dforrestwilson on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:38AM (#28480653)
This is not your first wolf warrior post.

I don’t see a need to rebut your false claims and would encourage folks to read your comment history.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dirtyid on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:16PM (#28485231)
Acknowledging reality is wolf warrior now? Yes, I encourage people to read my comment history on the subject to get sense of current US/PRC strategic thinking and update their model likely formed by bad takes from pop Chinawatching sources. Consensus today is dramatically different than consensus from 5/10 years ago, yet there's still folks pretending TW is hard to invade / easy to defend nonesense arguments from 20 years ago.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by neom on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:14PM (#28475823)
The only thing that will stop china from interfering in Taiwan is, universal consciousness willing, South Korea and Japan along with the other Asian nations having enough sway with China to keep them at bay. I very much prefer not to entertain WW3, but as others have said many times recently, if it is going to start, it may very well be over Taiwan.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tomrod on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:23PM (#28475903)
The issue is, the CCP sees Taiwan as theirs when in reality China belongs to Taiwan.

It would seem a treaty acknowledging Taiwan as an independent sovereign would be an ideal outcome, but it's weird to see nations express wounded pride, imo

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Shorel on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:13PM (#28476671)
I wish that was the reality. But CCP has the military power.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Dah00n on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:40AM (#28479731)
That would be like saying the US belongs to the Native Indians, the Vikings or the British. It might be true, but what is the point exactly? Like it or not but Might Is Right and in less than 20 years Might equals PRC above all else (including the US, yes).
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by fouric on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:31PM (#28488357)
> That would be like saying the US belongs to the Native Indians, the Vikings[...]

That's not quite right. The government of Taiwan consists (consisted?) at least partially of the literal former government of the country now commonly known as China before the "cultural revolution" that murdered tens of million of people and put the CCP into power.

The closest analogy that you can get is the idea that the US belongs to the British (as they were our former government) - which you can make a decent case for, although I would still argue that the vastly different natures of the Revolutionary War and the Cultural Revolution still make them distinct.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tomrod on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:08AM (#28480987)
Indeed. Despite all our efforts to improve, we seem inevitably stuck at might makes right.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:25PM (#28475919)
> The issue is, the CCP sees Taiwan as theirs when in reality China belongs to Taiwan.

What on earth is this supposed to mean?

I'm no fan of the Chinese government, but trying to claim it is illegitimate seems a pretty big stretch.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nullc on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:10PM (#28476261)
> What on earth is this supposed to mean?

The Republic of China was the government of China from 1912 until 1949 when it was overthrown by the CCP and retreated to Taiwan. Until at least 1971 the UN recognized it as the legitimate government of all of China.

The poster's comment is outdated, but that's the historical background -- and why it's less crazy than you might have assumed without knowing the history.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by seanmcdirmid on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:05PM (#28477329)
There is more relevant history: when the ROC retreated to Taiwan, they killed a lot of the upper crust of the Taiwanese already on the island. Truth is, while Japan treated Korea fairly bad, they treated Taiwan as an almost province, so that fostered a lot of distrust between the KMT and the Taiwanese on the island before they arrived, leading to atrocities. The pre-1949 Taiwanese distrust the mainlanders a lot (represented by both the ROC and PRC).

Most Taiwanese would rather refer to throw off the legacy of the ROC completely, but doing so would be considered an act of war by the PRC.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ethbr0 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:21PM (#28477057)
I remember my mind being blown when I read about internal Taiwanese politics and learned that both parties are more or less anti-independence.

The liberals / doves think it would provoke China, and be too high a price to pay for something that's already de facto truth.

But the conservatives / hawks argue against it because they deny the legitimacy of the PRC, so why would Taiwan need to declare it's independence from rebels in its own country?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by account42 on Friday September 10, 2021 @04:11AM (#28478943)
> The liberals / doves think it would provoke China, and be too high a price to pay for something that's already de facto truth.

This does not make them anti-independence, just not suicidal.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Aeolun on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:07PM (#28476238)
> I'm no fan of the Chinese government, but trying to claim it is illegitimate seems a pretty big stretch.

That’s exactly what the Chinese government is doing though. Isn’t that a bit of a stretch too?

China claims Taiwan just as Taiwan (more or less seriously, but I doubt with any will to ever try and recover it) claims China.

Or more like they both claim to be the legitimate government of greater China.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nradov on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:13PM (#28476669)
Possession counts for a lot more than theoretical legal legitimacy. Who is physically in control of the bulk of Chinese territory?
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by howaboutnope on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:15PM (#28477413)
> Possession counts for a lot more than theoretical legal legitimacy.

So in your mind, the act of murder "counts for a lot more" [0] than someone's right to their own life, and theft does not exist, since whoever possesses something owns it?

[0] What's the unit we're counting in? How do you "count" intellectual integrity or moral character?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by salawat on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:08PM (#28477359)
Might does not make right in questions of rule of law.

Unless it's barbarism then. At that point I'm pretty sure the biggest functional nuclear stockpile wins though.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tomrod on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:38AM (#28477874)
Isn't that international law?
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Dah00n on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:47AM (#28479776)
>Might does not make right in questions of rule of law

Sure it does. The laws are written by those who can enforce them. That is by definition those with Might. If that is barbarism then all of earth is under barbarism (and I'd argue that this is true).

History is full of good examples. The Nuremberg trials is a great example of Might Is Right. The exact same laws used against the Nazis never were enforced on US citizens.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by salawat on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:39PM (#28488414)
Rule of law does not have baked into it that laws are written by the mighty, or even that they can or will be enforced, consistently or otherwise. Merely that laws exist, can be made, and unmade, and should be followed.

After all, there was a reason the Founders advised that it was a great evil to put a law on the books that couldn't be reasonably enforced due to the tendency to deligitimize the authority in question.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by samus on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:17AM (#28480463)
The current status quo depends on the PRC pretending that Taiwan is ruled by a regional government, while the Taiwanese government has restricted its actual scope to Taiwan. To this effect, in 1991 Taiwan has added articles to its constitution to account for the fact that its government has only control over the "Taiwan Area".

The actual policy of the Taiwanese government depends on who is in charge at the moment. The Pan-Blue Coalition favors reunification, while the Pan-Green Coalition tries to assert a separate Taiwanese national identity.

The claim on the rest of China is still there, but only because it cannot be dropped in practice. The PRC would interpret dropping the claim on the rest of China as a declaration of Secession and Independence, which would have diplomatic and possibly military consequences.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:29PM (#28477114)
>> I'm no fan of the Chinese government, but trying to claim it is illegitimate seems a pretty big stretch.

> That’s exactly what the Chinese government is doing though. Isn’t that a bit of a stretch too?

Yes it is.

Doesn't make the OP's comment any less surprising through.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tomrod on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:31PM (#28475976)
Why?
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by neom on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:36PM (#28476002)
I also don't understand your comment. I went so far as to quickly skim through the history of Taiwan and I don't understand why you said China belongs to Taiwan?
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:03PM (#28476205)
Why were the Fourth Republic upstarts allowed to take control from the Vichy regime? De Gaulle's people ran for the hills and lost any claim to their old territory.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:40PM (#28476042)
I expect his argument is that the former national government of mainland China fled to Taiwan during the revolution.

This is true, but it doesn't make a strong argument for legitimacy. Former governments flee countries frequently, and unless there is a rapidly implemented plan to try to get them back into power they are generally ignored.

Taiwan is better viewed as a breakaway state than having any legitimate stake in the government of mainland China.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by anonymousiam on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:20PM (#28476331)
One could even argue that the agreement Great Britain had for the 100 year lease of Hong Kong was with the Nationalist (Taiwan) government and not the PRC.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:30PM (#28477128)
In any case, the treaty is broadly illegitimate as a colonial treaty nowadays.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by samus on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:40AM (#28480678)
Whether it is colonial or not does not matter for legitimacy. A blanket rejection of treaties on the basis of being colonial and unfair would invalidate all border agreements between former colonial countries.

Of course, the international community can condemn treaties and push for decolonialization, but in most cases this is foiled by the refusal of the colonial power to give up the claim. Examples: Falkland islands, West Sahara, Goa (reconquered by India using military force).

In many cases, it is advantegeous for both parties to seek a peaceful decoloniazation treaty, which becomes a part of international law and formal basis for the future claim on the decolonized territory.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:04AM (#28481744)
It has a huge impact in practice. The international community will look much more favourably on a country that violates a colonial treaty with its former Metropolis than with any other country.

In practice, colonial era treaties are less legitimate. No one except the parties directly materially affected care.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:36AM (#28478163)
> the agreement Great Britain had for the 100 year lease of Hong Kong was with the Nationalist (Taiwan) government and not the PRC

This appears to be a difficult argument to make in a consistent way. HK was ceded to GB a the Treaty of Nanking[1] which was between the UK and the Qing Dynasty Chinese government. It was later expanded in 1897, again with the Qing Dynasty.

That Dynasty collapsed in the early 20th century. That was followed by the warlord era, and then the nationalist government in the 1930s. That lasted until defeated by the Communist government in 1949.

So there were only around 20 years the Nationalist government governed mainland China, and it was long after the treaty ceding HK.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Nanking

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by anonymousiam on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:48PM (#28489035)
So the smart thing for the British government to have done would have been to declare the treaty invalid when the PRC came to power. GB could have claimed Hong Kong in perpetuity and the PRC would not have dared to stand up to GB in that era.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:37PM (#28476004)
Well apart from over 70 years of mostly stable government (with Tiananmen square being the exception) they are broadly recognized by most countries and the UN and have been for close to 50 years.

There's little evidence of support in China or even in Taiwan for the idea that the Taiwan government are the legitimate government of mainland China, and Taiwanese ambition is pretty much limited in practical terms to self government.

Indeed, I don't believe Taiwan claims China in anyway I can find reference to.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by anonymousiam on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:22PM (#28476349)
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by taf2 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:01PM (#28476607)
Fair - perhaps because all opposing voices have been disappeared… it is after all one party.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:25PM (#28477082)
Talk to Chinese emigrants. Plenty don't support the CCP as the government of China. Few support Taiwan as having any claim.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dnqthao on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:57PM (#28476587)
It will start with Vietnam instead.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:16PM (#28476688)
SK is waiting for China's push to unite with NK.

Japan surely want to help, but US daddy won't allow rearming herself.

Other Asian nations?

"Why should I care, where is my economy development"

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tw04 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:09PM (#28475789)
> the latest war game was based on a Chinese biological-weapon attack that swept through US bases and warships in the Indo-Pacific region more than a decade in the future

If China starts a war by releasing a biological weapon, Taiwan will be the least of their concerns. I don't see any scenario in which every Western and neutral nation on Earth doesn't turn against them. Maybe Russia helps, but I doubt it.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nradov on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:30PM (#28476785)
If such a weapon were to be used it would probably be done covertly with plausible deniability. Maybe a false flag operation.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ilaksh on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:59AM (#28478867)
Hmm. Hard to imagine. Nothing remotely similar has ever happened. But, now that I think of it, the consequence might be something like a pandemic, which coincidentally we are in now.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by andruby on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:06PM (#28484411)
I am a European and the idea that two superpowers would actually go to full-on war seems absurd. At least, I hope all sides agree that it is a terrible idea.

We haven't had full-on war between two sides that are "in the same league" since WW2. The cold war was tense, and there have been proxy wars, or wars between a super power and a tiny power.

When two sides are matched somewhat evenly, that's when the loss of life has been dramatic, as we've seen in both world wars.

I really hope I don't see a full on war between super powers in my or my children's lifetimes, because it would be brutal.

I mean, would we really see aircraft carriers and bombers in action? submarines? Will both sides blow up each other's satellites and create a Kessler syndrome? At which point do they start threatening with nukes?

No, I can imagine some power projection and rough play, but I don't think anyone is considering full-on war.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by frostburg on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:23PM (#28475895)
Keep in mind that those results are publicized to argue for budgets.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by darkerside on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:42PM (#28476054)
This is definition of ad hominem. Sure, there's a motivation, but do you think the war games are a conspiracy? I don't find it difficult to imagine the US would fail to protect an ally on enemy turf.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jollybean on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:42PM (#28476059)
1) "Last fall, the latest war game was based on a Chinese biological-weapon attack that swept through US bases and warships in the Indo-Pacific region"

These are superfluous conditions (i.e. predicting bioweapons), and of course, and you're not going to hear about the 'real' results. And of course it ignores the after effects.

2) Defenders have considerable advantage in that situation, especially with a water gap. The 'amphibious assault' situation is severely hampered by the fact that even with air cover, all Chinese surface vessels are 'extremely vulnerable'.

Literally just a single, 2-man style team weapon system, if it could actually be deployed without sabotage, could make it nary impossible for such landings. I think it would be crazy for Taiwan not to have specialty capabilities against that kind of assault. Landing operations very dangerous for the landers.

3) Taiwan has 23M most of whom won't go down without a fight. It's incredibly difficult to occupy a place like that.

4) The 'angle' for China is likely political, and to land a vanguard of political operatives, saboteurs of all kinds, media controllers etc. and possibly to try a 'coup from within' as opposed to a frontal military confrontation.

5) Any direct military engagement would be met with pretty serious repercussions, for the first time maybe, from the West. It would be 'a big deal'.

If there were actually even a small US confrontation and say a couple of US frigates were sunk ... don't underestimate how Americans will rally under the wrath of that offence. 90% of the generally anti-war voices will quiet and look the other way while the 'other half' of the US releases the dragons in one way or another. If, as in the stated example there were 'Bioweapons' used against the US, then it would be WW3 level escalation and a nuclear standoff.

So again 'military confrontation' is a big deal, but 'military confrontation with Americans' is a much bigger deal they won't forget.

In either case, the tide of geopolitics will shift dramatically.

NPTO - the Asian equivalent of NATO would be formed instantly, with UK and EU as participating members.

TPP v2 - this would happen immediately and China would be de-facto ignored / out of the WTO.

There would be a China v. 'Almost Everyone Else' Cold War in which everyone would be forced to choose sides. In that scenario, there are actually very few places that would chose China, if forced. Aside from Russia, which would try to 'broker peace' (and of course Iran/N. Korea/Afghanistan/Syria) I think the only real holdouts would be in Africa, and they wouldn't be consequential. The Arab world would mostly go 'With the US/EU-led rest of the world' and so would South American for the most part.

6) We 'do business' with Taiwan in the hope that they can remain at least at their current levels of independence.

If China wants to take Taiwan and leverage the kind of spineless 'look the other way' artefact of our businesses and politicians they'll do it piece by piece, and/or make it look like a popular and legitimate 'coup' - and that Chinese forces are there 'only to ensure order and stability' and to 'protect democracy'. They need to give enough political cover to Nike, Pizza Hut and Apple to not pull out from China etc.. Kind of like Crimea, where we just 'forgot about it'.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by mLuby on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:40PM (#28476472)
2) A giant smokescreen? Creeping (missile) barrage of the beach? There are plenty of ways to make it hard to target anything on a beach. Air cover and missile defense will be a big deal.

3) You mean the civilian population will fight to the death? Absolutely no way that's true. Russia showed the way in Crimea: offer incentives to those who support the "liberation"; it both erodes defender support and gives the attackers more legitimacy.

5) Headlines for days, sure, but recently the West has shown that its "red lines" are more crossable than they might appear.

If the PRC ever manages to take even momentary control of Taiwan, there's no way they let it slip away again. And remember that the ocean supply lines heavily favor China over the US (even from Japan or South Korea) for any sort of protracted conflict. The only wild card is nuclear weapons, and all we can do is hope that neither side is insane enough to use them, "tactically" or "strategically."

Pacific NATO was called SEATO. We might be surprised at how few committed and capable allies we'd have. It'd be in most countries' interest to stay neutral in an uncertain war between the current and future economic superpowers. I'd also wager that there'll be much less domestic support for sending hundreds of thousands of Americans to die over Taiwan than there was as a response to Pearl Harbor.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by chrononaut on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:09PM (#28476649)
> I'd also wager that there'll be much less domestic support for sending hundreds of thousands of Americans to die over Taiwan than there was as a response to Pearl Harbor.

The US was interfering in Japan's affairs (particularly hampering access to oil) in the lead up to late 1941, even though support for either war was in the low 60%s prior to Pearl Harbor (amazingly as low as 7% when the Netherlands, Belgium, and France were invaded).[0] The US government, in some respects, forced the Japanese's hands in a stretched gamble by attacking it first. In a hypothetical confrontation, given the historical support US (among others) have shown Taiwan, even the existing interference alone could force China's hands to take some action that causes a drastic increase in domestic support.

In other words, my wager is that you're probably correct, but the probability of a forced action after some aggression has taken place, which subsequently causes an increase of domestic support would be more likely to occur.

[0] https://exhibitions.ushmm.org/americans-and-the-holocaust/us...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jjaammee on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:40PM (#28477567)
Not sure US baiting Japan for Pearl harbor, but nowadays US is not the country 80 years ago. Politicians, military leaders are not as capable, more critically the industrial base is crippled. The king almost naked.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jollybean on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:25PM (#28477075)
2) If you've seen these type of landings, you know that 'smoke screens' are not an area cover, just some very local cover. They can be accounted for.

Missiles barrages are not particularly useful unless they have some kind of targeting ability that we don't know about. There are not enough missiles, same for artillery. They will be able to hit communications centres and established defences, but as I said, if there is a '2 man team weapon' - and Taiwan can actually deploy them, the landings will be painful.

3) I don't agree with the Crimea Taiwan comparison.

  a) 1/2 of Crimeans were pro-Russian, the rest not necessarily nationalist, or prepared. There was no material military defence of Crimea, Ukraine is poor, corrupt, and uncoordinated. Crimea is fairly sparsely populated, and nobody in the world cares about it, other than the fact it was 'taken'.

  b) Taiwan is a rich, highly populated country, a strong sense of identity even if their a Pro Mainland nationalists, there are millions otherwise. They wealthy, very well prepared, very well organized. They have weapons, training a political cause. Taiwan is a mid-sized economy 'that matters'.
If CCP completely overruns Taiwan in a very heavy-handed way, with visible footprint everywhere (tanks rolling through most areas), then there might be a lack of an uprising.

But if there is any coordinated attempt by Taiwan to prepare for that, and any material ability for fighters to operate, there will be ongoing fighting.

5) I think you're misunderstanding the 'reaction'.

Yes, if CCP did 'Take Taiwan' - then there's probably no way anyone would uproot them directly. Unless there was an ongoing civil uprising etc. - then it's going to belong to China.

But there would be a 1) Geopolitical re-orientation like there never has been and 2) Americans do not rollover when there is blood involved. If China 'sinks a US ship' then 'they will pay' probably a disproportionately heavy price.

'Asian NATO' will form under completely new auspices: India, Vietnam, Philippines, Japan, Korea etc. are now witnessing the China Dragon with a military conflict and so their fear escalates.

To your point about 'Neutrality' - Singapore might be, but not others, like India, Japan, Korea, and Arab countries which the US has incredible power over.

The 'South China Sea' probably becomes the forum for retribution, and I can see a multinational force, led by the US declaring that area 'open seas' and basically attacking any Chinese forces there. That'd be one way for the US to get their 'pound of flesh' to save face.

Pan Pacific Trade v2 would surely happen for the same reasons - it was going to happen, the only reason it did not was Trump, and now that he's killed it, it's just too hard to get going again. But a Taiwan invasion would trigger that. The 'possibly neutral' countries on the military side would more likely join this - their 'neutrality' is mostly based on fear of China, not fear of the West.

A Taiwan invasion might probably mean immediate trade war between the US and China, with the rest of the world dragged in.

And the more global geopolitical repercussions would be a little bit similar to the Cold War. The US/EU/UK/India/Japan/Korea+Others 'side' would put immense pressure on the system to try to isolate China.

Again, yes, I think China would end up keeping Taiwan, but it's the 'realignment' outside China that is the real impact.

Anyhow - direct invasion of Taiwan would be a big deal.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:51PM (#28477237)
I think you are radically underestimating the soft power China has in Asia. Countries like Vietnam and the Philippines are far from Chinese allies, but have little faith in US commitment to the region and have to survive in the region.

There's probably a number of people in leadership positions in the region who accept the realpolitik that is isn't worth fighting China over Taiwan.

> Americans do not rollover when there is blood involved.

Plenty of recent evidence says otherwise.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jollybean on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:14AM (#28477755)
Your point about Vietnam and Philippines wavering on direct conflict is well taken but I did hint at that.

I didn't say 'they would be going to war over Taiwan' - I would agree with you there there.

In the geopolitical realignment, they'd be in a difficult situation, and though they might not join the Asian NATO, they'd join the new Trade Pact.

Neither Sweden nor Finland nor Austria belong to NATO either, but there's a fair degree of coordination still.

But Japan, S. Korea, India would, and that's the start of a fairly powerful coalition - some of which would probably engage the Chinese Navy in S. China sea, and maybe be involved in blockades.

"Americans do not rollover when there is blood involved Plenty of recent evidence says otherwise. :

I don't know what you mean. 9/11 resulted in two major wars and that was a non-state actor.

China sinking a couple of US ships is definitely an act of war, the only question would be 'how' the US would respond. It would be in blood, not just 'sanctions'.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:26AM (#28478102)
> I don't know what you mean. 9/11 resulted in two major wars and that was a non-state actor.

As I said elsewhere: In the last few years the US has been run out of Iraq by Iran, Syria by Russia and Afghanistan by the Taliban. I don't see much appetite for going back to any of those.

Or more starkly: The US lost both those wars and the US population is sick of it.

If China sank a couple of US ships, I'm sure the US would declare war. But China would be 100% committed to winning an invasion of Taiwan, no matter what the cost.

The US.. not so much.

> Japan, S. Korea, India would, and that's the start of a fairly powerful coalition - some of which would probably engage the Chinese Navy in S. China sea, and maybe be involved in blockades.

Note that none of these countries have every said they would defend Taiwan in the event of an invasion. That's statement is conspicuously absent from anyone at all, actually.

As for a blockade, I think you are - again - overestimating support Taiwan has, and underestimating the realpolitik that would happen.

Where are the blockades over Chinese behaviour in Hong Kong? Or diplomatic protests? Or...anything at all other than newspaper articles?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jollybean on Saturday September 11, 2021 @05:33AM (#28490622)
The US was not run out of Iraq by Iran, not was it run out of Syria by Russia. That's a total misrepresentation of the situation.

The US lost the political will to stay in Afghanistan. It wasn't actually that difficult or costly, just not worth it.

There was no appetite for war after Vietnam, and yet Iraq 1, Iraq 2 and Afghanistan all happened.

If China invaded Taiwan, then the 'appetite for war would change' and if a couple of American ships were sunk, then the 'appetite for war' would be at 100%.

Sometimes I think I'm debating young people with no living memory of how these things change over time and how Americans absolutely do not tolerate direct attacks.

Pearl Harbour, 9/11, both had devastating consequences.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Saturday September 11, 2021 @07:15PM (#28497000)
I'm 46.

America was run out off Syria by Russia. There was lots of other things going on too, but Russia got a deep water port in the Mediterranean - something that both the British and American empires tried to stop for hundreds of years - before the Crimean war.

https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/10/08/after-five-years-of-fig...

https://www.news18.com/news/opinion/after-10-years-of-syrian...

https://www.businessinsider.com.au/trump-applauds-russia-vic...

I mean Turkish forces shelled a US post in Syria at one point and laughed about it. That's how worried the rest of the world is about US appetite for war.

https://www.militarytimes.com/2019/10/13/us-troops-believe-t...

Iran has run America out of Iraq.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/nov/18/leaked-cables-...

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/nov/18/leaked-cables-...

Where was any appetite to do anything about China's actions in HK?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by kenneth on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:52AM (#28478507)
> As I said elsewhere: In the last few years the US has been run out of Iraq by Iran, Syria by Russia and Afghanistan by the Taliban. I don't see much appetite for going back to any of those.

As was said elsewhere here, the Afghanistan war was won quickly. Afghanistan was also easily kept. And that's fighting against an opponent using guerilla tactics. What failed was nation-building. But that's not the goal with a confrontation with China. The goal is symmetric warfare to hold back an invasion. Defensive warfare is easier than offensive, so the cost would be far higher on China invading than Taiwan/US defending.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:09AM (#28479578)
At what point was the Taliban defeated?

There was perhaps a short period before the Iraq war where they were close to defeat but from memory there was never a point they stopped fighting.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by mLuby on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:00PM (#28477288)
Second time you've mentioned this mysterious "2-man team weapon" that can make hostile amphibious landings "nary [sic] impossible" or "painful."

Care to share a link? All I can think of is https://pacificrim.fandom.com/wiki/Jaeger XD

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:21PM (#28476341)
> If there were actually even a small US confrontation and say a couple of US frigates were sunk ... don't underestimate how Americans will rally under the wrath of that offence.

I suspect you are drastically overestimating the US public's appetite for another war. In the last few years the US has been run out of Iraq by Iran, Syria by Russia and Afghanistan by the Taliban. I don't see much appetite for going back to any of those.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by porknubbins on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:00PM (#28477299)
Those essentially local attempts at occupation and state building are completely different to a potential hypothetical symmetrical war with China that implicates the whole global order.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:26PM (#28477484)
> US public support for a war over Taiwan is modest: one recent poll found significant majorities of foreign policy elites supporting US intervention, but only about 40 per cent of the American public backing it. (Even that figure likely reflects soft and reflexive backing; the country has not fought a major war against a peer adversary for two generations, and in the event of catastrophic US losses amidst perceptions that the war was unnecessary, public support could collapse very quickly.)[1]

And if the last 10 years of US politics has taught us anything it is how vulnerable the US is to arguments that cause division. China has plenty of money, and plenty of people who will be economically hurt by a war. It's pretty easy to make an argument against defending China.

[1] https://www.lowyinstitute.org/publications/countering-china-...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by yann2 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:46PM (#28476509)
Piece by piece sounds good. But after Xi and the rest of the old men who run the country kick the can, I find it hard to believe next gen Chinese leaders will care about Taiwan as much. Whats the upside to them for all this drama?
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nradov on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:33PM (#28476804)
The drama serves as a useful tool to unify the domestic populace against an external enemy and distract them from CCP corruption.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by account42 on Friday September 10, 2021 @04:16AM (#28478972)
If that is the primary reason, then at least actually invading Taiwan is not in their interest since it would remove that tool.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jollybean on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:29PM (#28477117)
Taiwan is the #1 foreign policy issue of China and maybe a top 3 long term goal - they consider it existential to their existence.

China is an ethnocentric state, they have long memories and they plan for things.

Xi is definitely more aggressive than the others, but China basically will be trying to 'get Taiwan back forever'.

Frankly, the 'long term solution' if Taiwan remains free, may be something like a 'One China' where Taiwan is actually completely independent. Maybe even Tibet and HK. That would probably only happen if China fell apart, there were wars, and we had this Peace Agreement where the world nominally recognized China as 'One Entity' even if they were actually completely different nation states. That is obviously not likely to happen but aside from a Chinese->Taiwan invasion I don't see how union happens.

The 'Taiwan Issue' is totally nonnegotiable to China, any attempt to bring the issue up in foreign policy discussions would have the Chinese Officials walk out in anger. As far as they are concerned 'Taiwan is China and There Is No Discussion' about it.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by elihu on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:29PM (#28474887)
Note: there's English subtitles available if you enable close captioning.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by AussieWog93 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:56PM (#28475130)
Even creepier listening to it with no subtitles and a primary school level understanding of Chinese.

All I heard was "husband", "daughter" and "whole family".

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by vmception on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:19PM (#28474792)
wow

that was really powerful

makes me want to rethink some of my flippant comments about Taiwan's impending doom after we get our semiconductor pylons up in other places, but now at least they have my sympathy

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by stickfigure on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:20PM (#28475869)
Honest question: Why not just give Taiwan nukes?

MAD seems to be a very effective peace strategy. China already has nukes. Seems the essential missing ingredient is the 'M'.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by xnyan on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:40PM (#28476039)
Step back and just think about it in realpolitik terms. If you were the leader of china, what would you think about the idea of nuclear weapons being brought to your borders?

In a similar situation (the US had nukes in turkey and other areas close to the USSR) the Soviet Union used the same rational (in part) to justify putting nukes in Cuba. Just leveling the playing field. The result was the closest we’ve ever gotten to a nuclear conflict.

From one point of you could argue this was “fair”, because the US already had missiles close to the USSR and this was leveling the playing field, but fair is a meaningless concept in geopolitical relations. Leaving bad and good aside, who would ever want their rival to place nuclear weapons close by?

The government of China would have to be either traitorous or insane to not do everything in their power to prevent this from happening.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by stickfigure on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:57AM (#28478531)
Let me try reframing this.

If you were an abusive ex-husband, who felt that women are property and need to submit to you (and you regularly beat your girlfriends bloody to prove it), how would you feel about your former spouse buying a gun?

Sure, you'd do everything in your power to prevent that from happening.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by systemvoltage on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:04PM (#28476211)
India, North Korea, Pakistan and Russia are all bordering nations to China with nuclear weapons. During the cold war and to this day, there are no bordering states or any one close to 3000 miles of US borders with nuclear weapons. So, your comparison to US/USSR cold war to China/Taiwan scenario is slightly misplaced I think.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by xnyan on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:37PM (#28476456)
I could be wrong, but I don’t think you’re really giving it a good faith effort to look at this from the eyes of China.

Imagine it in your head: the senior intelligence officer walks into the briefing room and says “The United States has placed their nuclear missiles in Taiwan, but don’t worry - that’s exactly the same as Russia having missiles, or India having done some nuclear tests and maybe having a shitty delivery system that’s 1/100 as advanced as the US. No cause for concern. Nothing has changed.”

It’s a wholly unrealistic analysis that does not even pass a cursory sniff test. The United States of America putting their nuclear warheads in Taipei, a region they consider to be stolen from them with the support of western power, would be taken as a unique and massive escalation of hostilities because it would be, they would be stupid not to consider it as such.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by stickfigure on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:11AM (#28478602)
I don't think anyone is interested in putting US nukes in Taiwan. Presumably US nukes are already in the area on US naval vessels. It doesn't really change the balance of power; the US isn't going to start nuclear war over Taiwan.

The more meaningful scenario is what happens when Taiwan gets its own nukes. Either developed domestically or acquired shrinkwrap ("POINT THIS SIDE AT ENEMY"). At that point it's out of US control, and you can imagine the Taiwanese would use them in an existential crisis.

Of course China (specifically, the CCP) wouldn't be happy about that. That's not the point.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by systemvoltage on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:08PM (#28476643)
As a counter, I could imagine this to be alarming if hypothetically US is openly interested in invading Mexico who is allied with China. China then decides to place nuclear arsenal near Mexico city to defend it. This would be far less alarming than China initiating placement of nukes in Mexico without any intention from US to invade Mexico.

The subtle difference is offense vs. defense. If China openly agrees with the world to never invade Taiwan, US placing nukes in Taiwan would be unacceptable. But that is not the reality here.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sangnoir on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:57PM (#28476943)
> The subtle difference is offense vs. defense.

China got antsy, and vociferously complained about plans for the US to supply South Korea with advanced radar defense system (THAAD)[1], which China contended would extend into Chinese airspace. Radar, which is on paper, purely for defense. Nukes will be 2+ orders of magnitude worse.

1. https://www.uscc.gov/research/chinas-response-us-south-korea...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by warning26 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:55PM (#28476579)
I agree that Taiwan wouldn't want to accept US nukes for the reason you state. However, what if they had domestically developed nukes instead?

I feel like that would be a much more tenable position that would largely address your concern, and also grant Taiwan the ability to forestall any invasion indefinitely.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sudosysgen on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:34PM (#28477145)
There is zero possibility for Taiwan to domestically develop nukes and the ways to deliver them reliably without the Chinese figuring it out and shutting it down with massive prejudice.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dirtyid on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:08PM (#28476640)
Taiwan is thoroughly infiltrated by PRC intelligence, facilities for nuclear programs would be glassed before TW could develop any capabilities.

PRC fought with US / USSR while both were nuclear powers and China was not over much less important core interests than TW. Like there's currently 10s and eventually 100s of vunerable mainland coastal nuclear power plants that TW missiles can strike right now. TW has a lot of ability to fuck up PRC if they want to. Scope of TW actions/resistence will determine proportionality of destruction by PRC. Though ultimately there is nothing TW can do to deter PRC who has fought harder opponents with less means and more sacrifice.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jollybean on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:50PM (#28476114)
They would not be able to stop it though.

By the time it was announced, it would already be done.

The only real option China would have would be 'force' and a frontal war with China is a really big deal.

That said, US-provided nukes for Taiwan would be a major escelation and fingers would be pointed in the direction of the US for 'blame' etc.. A lot of people would throw a fit over that.

It might be better to just put a US base there because it means the same thing, and more: if you mess with Taiwan, even if you overrun the local US forces, you have 'awoken the actual Dragon' and no amount of 'internal division' in the US would hamper them from becoming united against China and of course all sorts of other huge material fallouts.

Ironically, I think it's the American regime who would not be able to pull it off. It would require cooperation among to many agencies and serious leadership. There'd have to be a pretty good President, with a lot of leverage, he'd have to be popular in the polls, have the backing of the Pentagon etc. etc.. I just can't see that working out so directly. It'd have to be done in a roundabout way.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by xnyan on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:54PM (#28476572)
Something that most westerners, particularly my fellow Americans, are unaware of is that the Soviets already had over 100 nuclear warheads in Cuba, many of them having fully functional delivery systems capable of striking the US. Even if we got them there, it’s not the end of the story

For some reason the following simple truth is difficult for my countrymen to accept, but you have to know on some level that all of this matters more to China than it does to us, and unless we completly overmatch them in power (as we did in the past, and do not now) in the long term they will always win in the east.

We could not even keep Afghanistan before our commitment flagged - what makes you think we could outlast the efforts of the largest economy in the world to remove weapons of mass destruction from Taipei?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jollybean on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:33PM (#28477142)
'They will always win in the East'?

The didn't win in Korea, they didn't win in Japan.

They didn't even win in Vietnam, the US completely destroyed N. Vietnam military machine ... and then left.

By the time the US actually left Vietnam there was very little fighting and no casualties. The US could have stayed.

Similarly in Afghanistan ... there were very few soldiers there, with a different Foreign Policy there's no reason to believe the US could have chosen to 'stay'.

There are still major bases in Korea, Japan and Germany, no reason not to keep a base in Afghanistan if they thought they wanted to.

Nukes in Taiwan would really upset China (a lot!) and throw a big wrench into everything, but it's a very legit threat, it would make direct assault really hard.

Certainly one 'Omega Weapon' would be a short range, small yield nuke that Taiwan could use against an invading maritime force. Scary, but real power.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by thenewwazoo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:54PM (#28476150)
Your presumption of unity is doing a lot of work here. I, for one, would absolutely oppose going to war against China for the sake of Taiwan, instead preferring that that money go to humanitarian causes that would help Taiwanese suffering under a CCP regime. War, especially nuclear war, is abhorrent and I would not stand for it.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jollybean on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:59PM (#28477658)
It doesn't matter whether you or I would support war, it matters what the population wants, and given a direct assault on US forces and the invasion of an ally, 1/2 the US population would be gunning for war and enough of the rest would be convinced.

Unfortunately 'some money to helping Taiwanese' would basically be futile, as there wouldn't likely be a way for that to be applied. (Donations are not going to help Hong Kong, now and won't help Taiwan in the event of invasion)

It also doesn't matter if we 'abhor war', force is a fundamental part of the equation even in 2021, if you're not prepared to use it in the right context, you'll lose the freedom to have the choice. And by that I don't mean 'You need to carry a gun!' because you don't, I mean we need to be prepared to use the Armed Forces (or force in generally) as is reasonably necessary.

And that would effectively be a pretty much necessary case.

These conflicts have 'knock on effects' - for example, if Saddam was able to simply roll into Kuwait willy-nilly, there's no reason to believe that Qatar or Saudi wouldn't be next. That, and 'because Oil stability' -> War.

It's unlikely the US would respond with an invasion of Taiwan because that would be essentially impossible, but probably there would be a 'war' in the South China sea and a Cold War after that.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by stickfigure on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:40AM (#28478448)
> I, for one, would absolutely oppose going to war against Germany for the sake of Jews, instead preferring that that money go to humanitarian causes that would help Jewish suffering under a Nazi regime.

Neville Chamberlain, is that you?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by eloisius on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:41PM (#28476481)
>By the time it was announced, it would already be done.

There are almost no surprises on either side of the Straight. Spies from both sides have thoroughly penetrated the other.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by eloisius on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:27PM (#28475928)
ROC had its own nuclear program in the past and almost made it to the point of being able to produce their own. The US, of all parties, intervened to have it stopped. Probably because Chiang was an unhinged madman intent on retaking the mainland. ROC is now an imminently nuclear nation. Something like six months away from having nukes at any time.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by retrac on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:33PM (#28475987)
This is true of most medium-sized industrial countries, actually, if they have power reactors. If Japan, Germany, Canada or even Finland or Argentina, really wanted nukes and wrote a blank cheque for domestic spending to that end, they could have one within a year, probably much less. Only lack of desire (mostly for the diplomatic and possible military consequences, I figure) really keeps them from doing so.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by seanmcdirmid on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:09PM (#28477366)
Both Taiwan and Japan are known to be capable of fielding nukes but do not because it would inflame tensions in the region and the USA has implicitly guaranteed to back them with an existing MAD solution. If the USA withdrew from east Asia, both Taiwan and Japan would probably start producing nuclear weapons within a few months (or before the USA had left if given a head’s up).
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by yyyk on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:17PM (#28476303)
Even putting the proliferation issue aside, a Taiwan nuke program just won't deter China, will merely justify an invasion. This may have worked - in the sense of deterring PRC - 30 or more likely 40 years ago, when their army was much weaker. It's far too late to think about that now.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by seanmcdirmid on Thursday September 09, 2021 @11:14PM (#28477408)
I agree. The biggest issue for Taiwan would be war head delivery. They can nuke a few cities in fujian, but the communist party has never fully trusted Fujian anyways and wouldn’t see it as a great loss, let alone a deter it from turning the island into a waste land rock.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by throwaway210222 on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:41AM (#28478770)
> Honest question: Why not just give Taiwan nukes?

Fair question, here's at least one answer:

1. that's a violation of the non-profileration treaty and the USA and the West basing its entire legitimacy on the rule of law. Values and all that.

See how far student-union whataboutism gets you once you do that.

2. because nukes are counter-productive: you cannot fire one nuke - you have to fire them all. The second Russia sees the nuclear flashes from US assets, ALL of their nukes start flying.

Unless you think Putin is going to wait to see exactly where in Asia hundred of thermonuclear ICBMs are aimed at.

And the first to land will be in Berlin, Tokyo, Paris, London, Amsterdam, Rome, Jerusalem, Sydney, Toronto [1]. (Before you press the down-vote, take the time to investigate the Sampson Option in orthodox MAD nuclear deterrence).

And that is not counting the Chinese nuclear response.

Childhood fanstasies.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samson_Option

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by _AzMoo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:26PM (#28475926)
You couldn't possibly give them enough to make it Assured Destruction.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:28PM (#28475943)
Nuclear proliferation is a bigger concern than a Chinese takeover of Taiwan.

If the US gives nukes to Taiwan, what would stop China giving nukes to eg Venezuela (or whatever South or Central American nation the US doesn't like that month).

Edit: previously I wrote "If the US gives nukes to China". I meant Taiwan here of course.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dkislyuk on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:39PM (#28476031)
What? China is already a nuclear power with nuclear weapons, and has been for decades.

The question posed by the parent is arming Taiwan to defend itself.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nl on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:27PM (#28476387)
Yes, I meant "If the US gives nukes to Taiwan" of course (previously wrote China here).
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by davesque on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:46AM (#28478201)
Hong Kong seems really like a canary in a coal mine. Shouldn't it be easy for any of the world's democracies to speak out for such a small territory that is being threatened by a dictatorship? Apparently not in this sad era of decline. I swear I can feel it in the air. Principles are seeming more and more old fashioned. Money trumps all.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by me_me_me on Monday September 13, 2021 @08:35AM (#28510674)
Hong Kong is chinese at the end of the day.

Sure Xi is breaking agreements of backing of for few decades, but in the end HK was to be integrated.

Not a lot of interest in fighting china on this as they have 'colonialism' card ready.

But not acknowledging Taiwan as a country, denning them flag in the Olympics is a worrying creeping level of Chinese soft power. Eastern countries should be working on decoupling as much of their economies from china.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by belter on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:03AM (#28480345)
Aided by the finest Silicon Valley intelligentsia:

"Apple Removes App That Helps Hong Kong Protesters Track the Police"

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/09/technology/apple-hong-kon...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by qwerty456127 on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:30AM (#28478706)
They don't only want to close those who speak against them. Actually everyone they don't have full control of. AFAIK the mainland China is a separate world with its own different Internet and business ecosystem and little interaction between it and the rest of the world allowed.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Zenst on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:22PM (#28476727)
Makes you wonder how much transpired over the past COVID News saturation that may of been buried, or missed completely by the media.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by vmception on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:14PM (#28474740)
What’s going on in Macau? I thought there is no contention there. They can if they want, they can do the perpetual lease if they want.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by niij on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:03PM (#28475183)
Portugal gave up their perpetual lease of Macau in 1999.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by arcticbull on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:34PM (#28475467)
On the same terms as Hong Kong.
[dead]
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by warning26 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:30PM (#28474896)
Or, consider this alternative hypothesis -- people are downvoting you for whining about being downvoted.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by president on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:13PM (#28476280)
Happened well before my edit. People associate narratives with tribal politics and vote accordingly. For those like me who think and speak independently, it is a massive disappointment to get caught in the crossfire.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by kemiller on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:14PM (#28475276)
Nowhere in the constitution are you protected from consequences when you say something stupid, and right-leaning folks have been saying this particular stupid thing a bit too often. Have the offices of Fox News or Breitbart or the Creation Science Museum been raided by police? No? Then this is not even close to parallel.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by inopinatus on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:26PM (#28475385)
There’s a seam of individuals cutting across the political spectrum that is confused about their right to speak freely. They think it translates to a right to force everyone to listen to them. Then they become shirty when told to fuck off.

It’s naturally correlated to extremities of viewpoint, both due to the absence of critical thinking on the part of the complainant and the elevated likelihood their views fall outside a certain window of acceptability.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by alentist on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:22PM (#28475333)
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by systemvoltage on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:18PM (#28476706)
One side has to show tolerance, convince others and be kind. Instead, we are throwing people under the bus, enranging them further and permanently affecting their mental health - they'll never to ever listen to any progressive voice.

This is an absolute disaster. People forget that the point of debates and exercise in politics is to convince the other side and get their vote. May be I am crazy to think this way.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by president on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:18PM (#28476316)
There are plenty of examples but you won't hear about those things if all your information comes from the corporate press.

Someone else in the comments posted a twitter app with many examples but when someone finally posts the receipts, nobody follows up. What does that tell me? People are not interested in the truth but defending their tribe.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by throwawaylolx on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:28PM (#28474878)
>Thank you for proving me right fellow HNer.

Well, who do you think does the censoring in the West? Companies that employ people browsing this very forum.

[dead]
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by GekkePrutser on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:47PM (#28475048)
The Nazis were totally right-wing. Their purges shocked the world. It's not just a left-wing thing, it's a common theme across all forms of extremism. Left, right, religion-based (look at the Taliban now, they don't really fit in the left or right category at all)... It always comes down to the same thing. Not listening to the other person but choosing to silence them with violence instead. The flag they wave is different but the extremism remains the same.

What we need is balance. Left and right together. Agreeing to disagree and finding a way to work together anyway. That's democracy. It's hard but it's the only way.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by another_story on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:10PM (#28475237)
Define what you mean by left.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by wizzwizz4 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:55PM (#28475653)
It's the correct side of the road to drive on, in the northern hemisphere! Roundabouts should be the same direction as sundials.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by mthoms on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:37PM (#28476009)
Please keep it to politics. We don't want a flame war! :-/
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by analognoise on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:52PM (#28475089)
Whose voice is getting quashed in the US? Everyone has a Facebook, Twitter, email, phones, a magazine, protests, their own news channels, subReddits.

What group doesn't have all those things? Whose voice is being quashed - exactly? Even straight up Nazis have websites, newsletters, gatherings, organized protest marches and Facebook pages. The fucking Taliban is on Twitter.

So...who is being quashed because of their beliefs, exactly?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by cabalamat on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:25PM (#28475380)
> Everyone has a Facebook, Twitter [...] subReddits

You appear to be arguing that no-one has ever been kicked off Facebook or Twitter, and that no subreddits have ever been banned. Is that your position?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by analognoise on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:20PM (#28476333)
So "Silencing" is just getting kicked from Twitter and FB?

Such a privileged and weak notion of silencing. China will send people to camps and the police will break down a memorial museum - that's silencing.

Getting kicked from FB/Twitter because for being a twat doesn't mean your group is persecuted.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by alentist on Friday September 10, 2021 @04:38PM (#28486607)
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by analognoise on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:30PM (#28487113)
That's not "moving the goal posts".

The ACTUAL complaint is that people demand an AUDIENCE - they want to be able to broadcast their views to the largest number of people possible.

Nobody in the US is being "quashed" - you can run your own website, print your own newsletter, and nobody is going to kick down your door or send you to a re-education camp. Like I said, Nazis run their own websites, and the Taliban is on Twitter. Nobody here is being "silenced" because they can't grab the microphone - nobody's owed a microphone in the first place.

It's not even "relative privation" - nobody has a God given right to...Facebook. People serious about their causes run their own websites - they don't immediately start whinging because they've been booted from Reddit.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by alentist on Sunday September 12, 2021 @11:59PM (#28507735)
> That's not "moving the goal posts".

Your first comment:

> Whose voice is getting quashed in the US? Everyone has a Facebook, Twitter, email, phones, a magazine, protests, their own news channels, subReddits.

Your second comment:

> So "Silencing" is just getting kicked from Twitter and FB?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by analognoise on Monday September 13, 2021 @11:00AM (#28512340)
The first indicates that there are multiple services to "be heard" - but I've said repeatedly that the ultimate fallback is running your own website.

Sorry I was responding to the notion that people took being banned from FB/Reddit/whatever as being quashed. Those people are free to print their own newsletters or run their own websites.

It seems like two separate points, which is why I don't see it. Maybe I should have made it more cohesive.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by alentist on Thursday September 16, 2021 @11:39AM (#28553194)
Of course they're being quashed.

Censorship is the suppression of speech, public communication, or other information, on the basis that such material is considered objectionable, harmful, sensitive, or "inconvenient." Censorship can be conducted by governments, private institutions, and other controlling bodies.

Amazon, Apple, Google, Twitter, Facebook, etc. are multibillion-dollar corporations that control a colossal share of online communications.

You approve of said quashing because it aligns with your political ideology.

> Those people are free to print their own newsletters or run their own websites.

And if the registrars and payment processors do the same, as has already happened? You'll move the goalposts again.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by alentist on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:12PM (#28475260)
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Dah00n on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:59AM (#28479847)
Having a voice doesn't not equal being heard. Especially not if you define A Voice as writing on Facebook or Twitter. You might as well stand on a box in the dead parts of Detroit and talk politics. Being heard in a democratic country means your vote matters.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by analognoise on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:54AM (#28480821)
Nobody has the right to "be heard"! That's the thing. You have the right to scream it out loud, but nobody is forced to stand there and listen.

No - you can't falsely equate "being heard" by being on FB and Twitter to voting.

If my neighbor starts screaming Nazi talking points, I have the right to walk away. They still have the right to scream them.

Buy Facebook isn't "forced" to carry their views, either! And the Nazi believes what they're saying, so to ensure they're heard, they launch their OWN websites, print their own newsletters, and show up at protests.

No. Just No. Nobody is forced to carry anyone else's speech, and only people so weak in their beliefs as to "give up" when banned by FB and Twitter are complaining.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by fouric on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:45PM (#28488446)
This is completely wrong. "Being heard" is being on FB and Twitter, as these platforms (1) are effectively public forums by nature of their massive, near-monopolistic reach, (2) claim protections of public forums, such as immunity from liability due to user-posted content, and (3) implicitly and explicitly portray themselves as public squares/forums[1].

The online equivalent to "having the right to walk away" is blocking someone on a platform. It's that simple.

Once a company has reached a monopolistic size, which describes FB and Twitter, then it either needs to be broken up, or treated like a utility/government service - this is exactly the argument that you see all the time about e.g. ISPs and Alphabet/Google - because there's no other morally excusable way to act. The first amendment was written to only apply to the government because that's the entity that's the most likely to (and most dangerous in) silence speech and discourse, not the only one.

You definitely would not be making these arguments if it were your ideological tribe that were being censored.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28456794

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by analognoise on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:29PM (#28488686)
Bullshit. If I was a serious <whatever> I'd go run my own website.

People whinge about being censored but don't care enough to run a website? Nazis run their own websites. It's easier than ever to run a website.

Nobody is owed being on a private platform, and it's total bullshit to say that we should force companies to. It's not a "de facto public square" - it's an advertising platform, first and foremost.

So @Jack said it was a public square - in the context of the ideal. Did he make that statement to a court? Because I'll bet being deposed, he'd say that was flowery talk.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by fouric on Saturday September 11, 2021 @09:35PM (#28497815)
> People whinge about being censored but don't care enough to run a website?

People talking about "whinging" usually do so because they can't come up with a logical counter-argument. That pattern holds true here.

> Nobody is owed being on a private platform, and it's total bullshit to say that we should force companies to.

If a private platform holds a near-monopoly on speech online, and actively uses anti-competitive behavior to hold people on their platform (as Facebook does, at least) - yes, individuals are owed the right to be present on that platform, because (as stated repeatedly before) it's a monopoly. Facebook is one of the largest sites in the world and enjoys the network effects of being the largest social media site in the world, as well as the lens through which millions of people perceive the world around them, and does its best to keep people there through a variety of anti-competitive strategies - if, at that scale, they decide that they want to ban people for non-illegal content, then the only sane thing to do is to break them up so that they no longer have a monopoly position, which is clearly not happening.

> It's not a "de facto public square"

It is. It has the properties of a public square, namely public visibility, generally available access to the population, a design that allows for and encourages conversation between individuals, and a design meant to emulate a public forum for discussion. Even though it's not legally a public square, it's a de-facto one because it has all of the properties of one and is treated as one - that's what "de-facto" means.

> it's an advertising platform, first and foremost.

Those two things aren't mutually exclusive. Ultra-scale social media platforms have the properties of both advertising platforms and public fora. You don't like the classification of the latter? Well, it's going to remain one until it's broken up or changes its behavior or suddenly loses users.

> So @Jack said it was a public square - in the context of the ideal. Did he make that statement to a court? Because I'll bet being deposed, he'd say that was flowery talk.

You're intentionally being obtuse. Of course the CEO of Twitter wouldn't stand behind his claim in court - but only because that'd be disadvantageous to him (in any court case likely to come up in the next several years), not because he didn't mean it. Nothing you said has any bearing on the fact that he said that it was a public square and meant it. You can't explain this away - it literally came from the CEO, the strategic lead for the company. If he says that Twitter is like a public square, that means that he's directing the company to that effect.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by chasd00 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:00PM (#28475153)
For one, it's well known in tech that you're putting your job/livelihood at risk by speaking contrary to the political groupthink. Many people who didn't vote for Clinton or Biden are effectively in career hiding. Threatening someone's job over their beliefs/opinions is very effective censorship.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by gautamdivgi on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:27PM (#28475401)
The right of free speech protects against government retribution. It does not protect private individual / corporation retaliation. This is why you have secret ballot - so no one can retaliate against you for someone you’ve voted for.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by refenestrator on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:32PM (#28476801)
Yes, that's why we have the secret ballot and should keep it, but let's try to trend away from why it's necessary?
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by sergiomattei on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:13PM (#28475273)
When in history hasn't this been the case?
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by analognoise on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:07AM (#28480978)
Never.

People are demanding access to an audience like it's a right, and saying their votes don't matter if they can't reach an audience. It's the dumbest shit I've ever heard.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by wallacoloo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:16PM (#28475844)
> it's well known in tech that you're putting your job/livelihood at risk by speaking contrary to the political groupthink.

Have you ever tried it?

FWIW, coworkers in my org pushed for a blacklist of words we’re not allowed to check into the codebase within the last year. I raised my counter opinion. I did so respectfully. Today, there’s no blacklist, and I still have my job.

Btw my presidential vote was a write-in for Bernie Sanders as president with Yang as running mate. Laugh if you like. I’m vaccinated; I wear a mask wherever the property owner of whatever establishment I’m in requests it (e.g. signs posted on the door), and omit the mask where not. I think my governor’s recent mask mandate is a mistake because we could already navigate the problem organically with the above approach, and anyone who wasn’t previously respecting an establishment’s masking policy isn’t going to respect a top-down legislative one given there’s no intent of enforcement.

People will disagree with my political opinions. And if they want, they’ll downvote me to communicate that. But I’m confident I won’t get banned from HN for stating these in the unusual event that it’s relevant to the discussion, much less that any future employer of importance is going to comb through here and decide against hiring me because I respectfully put forth an opposing political viewpoint.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ekianjo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:35PM (#28476000)
> Btw my presidential vote was a write-in for Bernie Sanders as president with Yang as running mate

the comment before was probably not aimed at those who vote or support the left.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by wallacoloo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:20PM (#28476330)
Eh, the anti-PC example is anti-progressive though. I didn't want to elaborate my comment with lengthier political views since HN usually isn't the place.

But here's a right-leaning hot take to drive the point home: 18 months into this pandemic and I've never once had any input into the policy response. I thought the agreement was "I get the vaccine, I get to live my life as normal". Now that policy changes (mostly state-level) are flipping that, I regret getting the vaccine: I'm in a low-risk demographic and I just gave up my most powerful tool in influencing policy decision. I won't make that same mistake with the booster shots Biden discussed earlier today: I won't be getting those until my policy leaders actually serve me as a constituent.

> it's well known in tech that you're putting your job/livelihood at risk by speaking contrary to the political groupthink.

Still confident that GP is wrong about that and I won't lose my job or livelihood by posting this.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by krapp on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:05PM (#28475201)
>Many people who didn't vote for Clinton or Biden are effectively in career hiding.

Are they? Where? In the American South, where I live, Republicans, Conservatives and Trumpists are still loud and proud, and gainfully employed.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by pedrosorio on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:03PM (#28475726)
Recent case of a CEO losing their job in the American South (HQ: Roswell, Georgia) for supporting the recent Texas abortion law: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-09-07/video-gam...

EDIT: To be clear, this not evidence in favor of the comment you were responding to: "There is a trend of certain dominant power in all of these countries that is quashing all opposing voices". As far as I can tell, supporting things the majority of society disagrees with has always been ground for career repercussions in the "land of the free" (as it is in the rest of the world).

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by selectodude on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:30PM (#28475967)
For the same reason I wouldn't put a Biden/Harris sign on my gun store in rural Missouri, I would probably keep my mouth shut on abortion if I'm the CEO of a video game developer.

Your job is to make other people money. If you become a liability you're not going to have a job much longer.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by _carbyau_ on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:57PM (#28477269)
Context and the multiple roles of a person, is why people get upset over this.

I agree with you. As a CEO, estranging any significant section of the market is not a good career move!

But amongst their friends, family, [insert other social circle here] their comments may not be a big deal.

As a non-public persona, I say expletives at work(as an employee) that I wouldn't want my child hearing(as a father). I can get away with it because the two worlds don't collide.

But once you have a public persona - like being a CEO - your worlds are merged into one. You don't get to have a "personal opinion" because your public persona cuts across all boundaries and your comments will be judged in the context of a public majority opinion.

Having a "public" persona is no joke. Take it seriously and expect that non-majority opinions will get public blowback so there better be a good reason for them!

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by treeman79 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:49PM (#28475599)
Depend on the company’s Most companies I keep my mouth shut.

And I mostly just want a balanced budget. This has become harder as more places are requiring active participation in woke mentality.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by temp8964 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:58PM (#28475141)
I have a quick example: the former president.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by jjoonathan on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:11PM (#28475254)
...and what did he do to get banned?

(Hint: it wasn't "having ideas.")

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ssully on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:05PM (#28475197)
Are people using the downvote button incorrectly here?
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:19PM (#28474795)
You're welcome.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by telllersid on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:13PM (#28475271)
The US republic was basically founded on pamphlets, newspapers, books..then incredibly long debates and respectful discussion.

Look at the structure of the Lincoln–Douglas debates. One candidate spoke for 60 minutes, followed by a 90-minute response and a final 30-minute rejoinder by the first candidate.

That doesn't work anymore. None of this works. Yes, all opposing voices will be silenced until there is 1 party basically everywhere. That is what people want and so that is what you will get in a democracy. There is no evidence to the contrary.

I am just glad I am old enough to have lived most my life already.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Monday September 13, 2021 @12:59AM (#28508004)
> The Chinese Government is speeding up their efforts to swallow Hong Kong and Macau into the Mainland.

What do you expect them to do?

Put them into a reserve area, like Indian reserve? How about Xinjiang or Tibet?

What do you mean by swallowing anyway?

You mean HK and Macau people are not living the same life as before? All I know is that most people are better off than before.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by asdff on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:25PM (#28475378)
If Beijing ever martyrs the protestors like tianeman again I don't think the world will take kindly to that at all. I even think russia would join an american coalition. China has no strong allies that wouldn't prefer to spare themselves in the event of worldwide intervention and they can't fight off the entire developed world alone no matter how far they came in recent decades.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by labster on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:33PM (#28475453)
Yes, the US and its allies will send very strongly worded letters to China if that happens, along with its order for ten million more iPhones.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by mc32 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:32PM (#28475448)
You are too optimistic.

The US got too involved in too many wars for the wrong reasons and we got weary of them. China sees this as a weakness (admittedly).

If the US does not flinch, no one else will and we won’t and no one else will.

We know terrible things are happening en masse in Xinjiang, Iran does terrible things to dissidents, north Korea does terrible things.

China and N Korea have nukes. Iran is close. In the and no one will do anything if they decide to fully bare their teeth.

Economically it’s a “commons” no one is willingly going to leave because it’s leaving too much money on the table. In a globalized world, companies really heavily influence foreign policy. These companies want the printer to stay on.

They may do themselves in, but that’s on them.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by asdff on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:37PM (#28475493)
US has sophisticated missile defense systems and enough nukes to send the entire continent of asia back to the stone age. A nuclear war started by any other nation than the U.S. is literally suicide, and these world leaders know it which is why all there has been since WWII in terms of nuclear warfare is saber rattling.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by mc32 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:00PM (#28475696)
No sane person would initiate a first strike --it's uncertain whether someone would be able to launch a full retaliatory strike. Only insane people like Castro and LeMay would give orders to launch. Today's nukes are near-civilization ending. They are not the equivalent of a month's worth of carpet bombing executed in one sortie.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by asdff on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:33PM (#28485447)
Nukes have been civilization ending since the 1960s. You should see the plans made by American planners at the time. They joked about having to turn the nation of Albania into nothing. US has enough sensors to track when launches occur that a retaliatory strike would be launched almost immediately. Even if missiles somehow got through to the continent, we have many of them in discrete locations on submarines, waiting to launch. We are even using our navy more for missile defense since there are advantages to being mobile and ephemeral than having a fixed defensive battery that everyone can see on google earth satellite imagery.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tkojames on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:24PM (#28476363)
The problem is if a country leader/government thinks that is worth ending civilization because there is something kind of afterlife that is better.. you hear the argument made about Iran. Not sure if I agree. But MAD breaks down if on side does not care about surving. Which makes nukes really scary..
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by teawrecks on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:21PM (#28475879)
The ability to "nuke an entire continent" isn't saber rattling, it's holding a dead man's switch. All major powers have been holding them for decades, and piling more nukes on doesn't make any difference at this point. All mutually assured destruction does is prevent attacks in the physical domain from happening*. So instead the fights continue in the political, economic, and digital domains. If anyone makes a physical attack in response to a nonphysical one, they have already lost.

* against other major powers, of course. Major powers themselves continue to test what they can get away with. Russia moving into Crimea. China saying "What? These guys have always been part of China. Do something, I dare you."

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by yodsanklai on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:54PM (#28475641)
>US has sophisticated missile defense systems and enough nukes to send the entire continent of asia back to the stone age

So does China with the US.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by asdff on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:04PM (#28475734)
China's arsenal is almost a full order of magnitude smaller than just what the US has currently deployed and ready for launch (not counting the rest of the stockpile which is like 4x the size). We have enough weaponry to completely overwhelm their defenses. China does not.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by mthoms on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:28PM (#28475944)
So China will only nuke 60% of the US population instead of the 90% casualties we will inflict on them? Huzzah! That will show 'em!
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by systemvoltage on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:15PM (#28476296)
There is also the US National Missile Defense: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_national_missile...
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by slapfrog on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:13PM (#28477015)
I suggest you read the article you linked carefully. Follow the links to the articles of each of the constituent programs, and read those articles carefully with a critical eye. Pay particular attention to the number of interceptors those programs actually have, the type of missile those systems are designed to intercept, and the locations of the installations. You can use the "measure distance" tool on google maps to plot out great arcs to get an idea of what sort of threat those installations are meant to counter.

I'll sum it up for you: The US has some defense against countries like North Korea. Not against Russia, nor even China. But don't take my word for it, read those articles carefully, paying attention to the details.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by quickthrowman on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:38PM (#28476017)
“ Mr. President, I'm not saying we wouldn't get our hair mussed. But I do say no more than ten to twenty million killed, tops. Uh, depending on the breaks.”

-General Buck Turgidson, Dr Strangelove

Here it is in video form, watch it so you can see how ridiculous your idea is: https://youtube.com/watch?v=HgyjlqhiTV8

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tkojames on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:26PM (#28476381)
The blueray 4k they released for Dr Strangelove looks amazing. Highly recommend watching it.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by asdff on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:36PM (#28485482)
More chilling quotes happened in real life:

"SIOP-62 included the virtual obliteration of the tiny country of Albania because within its borders sat huge Soviet air-defense radar, which had to be taken out with high assurance. Power smiled at Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara and said with a mock straight face: "Well, Mr. Secretary, I hope you don't have any friends or relations in Albania, because we are just going to have to wipe it out.""

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Integrated_Operational_...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by IX-103 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:22PM (#28475887)
Not to mention that the US deployed strategic arms in more diverse locations (other countries), making a first strike against them that takes out most of their response capability difficult to pull off successfully.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by teawrecks on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:37PM (#28476003)
Wtf? Why are people in this thread acting like the nuclear option is an actual option. This isn't StarCraft where you trade into the enemy forces, and as long as you cripple their economy you win. You just killed billions of innocent people. Everyone lost.

Y'all need to go watch War Games again. The only winning move is not to play.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Yeroc on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:32PM (#28475447)
Ah, but China holds all the financial levers to keep everyone in their place. If there were a war there'd be no "Made in China" goods being exported. Take a look around you and think about that for a few minutes. They can get away with almost anything. The only thing they fear is an internal uprising.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by bawolff on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:18PM (#28475854)
> If there were a war there'd be no "Made in China" goods being exported.

Who are you kidding? If there was a full scale china vs usa war, there would be nobody left to import the goods either.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by teawrecks on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:42PM (#28476056)
> The only thing they fear is an internal uprising.

Unfortunately, they're so good at propaganda and fear that they seem to have the civil unrest front on lock. Any real protests are erased and no one is allowed to mention it ever happened.

I have to assume this practice won't last forever. Historically, it never does. But it could last a while.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by hker on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:56PM (#28475664)
> They can get away with almost anything.

Not if factories move to Vietnam, Thailand, Laos, Bangladesh, India, etc., as the current trend continues.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by pempem on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:00PM (#28475706)
In most of the countries you've identified China has a strong toehold already.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ekianjo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:31PM (#28475974)
not really. those neighbors have absolutely no trust in China. There is history too between these countries in Asia.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by pempem on Monday September 13, 2021 @04:25PM (#28516401)
Fully agree that there is endless history inter and intra asia. As a 1st gen asian american let me assure you I am familiar with that reality.

This is 2019 Thailand:

According to a BoI report, investment applications from Chinese projects in the first nine months of this year amounted to 45 billion baht, up 100% from the same period last year, mainly from the rubber industry and tyre manufacturing.

Thailand advanced six notches to 21st out of 190 countries in the World Bank's 2020 Ease of Doing Business (EODB) rankings. - https://www.bangkokpost.com/business/1782899/chinese-factory...

This is Malaysia in 2016: China is pouring huge money into Malaysia and most people have yet to bat an eye on the significance of this huge impact. In times of trouble, who is it that comes to support Malaysia? It is the Chinese. “This has led to Malaysia’s foreign bond holdings going back up to over 50% and also gave our ringgit some form of stability,” says Astramina Advisory Sdn Bhd managing director Wong Muh Rong. - https://archive.is/Ipbnu#selection-2839.0-2839.191

The reason for pulling old quotes is to show that this is a trend that has continued forward. I'd be happy to be wrong.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by teawrecks on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:02PM (#28476194)
Politics isn't that simple. Not everyone in those countries feels the same way or is being paid by the same people. Even in HK where citizens regularly fill the streets to openly protest Chinese influence, the HK govt has many Chinese sympathizers who are trying to ensure the situation shakes out in China's favor.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by kayxspre on Friday September 10, 2021 @07:52AM (#28480240)
This mirrors what happened in Thailand as well. While the younger generations (90s or after) want to see a better and fair politics, many people involving in politics nowadays are more likely to support Chinese influence (infrastructure, pandemic response, among others). In fact, when its embassy published an op-ed bashing Thai people for diminishing the efficiency of COVID-19 vaccine it supplied to Thailand, there are some Thai people who actually gave apology on behalf of the fellow Thais, despite their series implying that face masks from Thailand have a low quality.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by TimTheTinker on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:00PM (#28475703)
> If there were a war there'd be no "Made in China" goods being exported.

That would be the best thing that ever happened to the rest of the world, and to Chinese citizens as well.

China has long abused its citizens to undercut global prices on manufactured goods. Their political and religious prisoners are very often put to work in factories (if not sent to work camps or tortured in prison); and wages for factory work are very low compared to the rest of the world.

In the early 1930s, the USSR survived by shipping so much grain out of Ukraine that by 1933, 25% of the Ukrainian populace had died. Dictatorships and authoritarian regimes always abuse people one way or another to survive.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by hker on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:08PM (#28475778)
> In the early 1930s, the USSR survived by shipping so much grain out of Ukraine that by 1933, 25% of the Ukrainian populace had died. Dictatorships and authoritarian regimes always abuse people one way or another to survive.

During the Great Leap Forward around 1958-1962, an estimated 15 to 55 millions died in China due to famine, while China was still a net exporter of grain (to Cuba and Africa).

Another data point to support your point.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by cma on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:26PM (#28476372)
Ireland was a net exporter of food during the potato famine, from appeals to laissez-faire capitalism.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by TimTheTinker on Thursday September 09, 2021 @09:39PM (#28476836)
That was due to abusive behavior on England's part.

Every country and every political leader is capable of committing atrocities. But overall, rule-of-law democracy is much better at mitigating that than other forms of government.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by yunohn on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:57AM (#28478262)
> rule-of-law democracy is much better at mitigating that than other forms of government

I believe that both are exploitative, just that developed democracy is better at hiding it - either internally through low wage labor or by exporting to developing countries.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Aunche on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:52PM (#28476132)
We wouldn't be trading with China if it didn't benefit us. A sanction damages the participants as much as its target. This doesn't matter if your target is a smaller country like Iran or even Russia, but China is way to big an exporter to sanction.

>Their political and religious prisoners are very often put to work in factories (if not sent to work camps or tortured in prison)

So you want them to shut down the factories, in which case they'll be sent to be sent to labor camps or rot in prison instead?

>wages for factory work are very low compared to the rest of the world.

China's average wage more than doubled over the past 10 years. Do you expect wages to increase by an order of magnitude overnight? Also, why would you blame China for this instead of the importers demanding razor thin margins or manufactured goods?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by TimTheTinker on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:21PM (#28476342)
> We wouldn't be trading with China if it didn't benefit us.

The ends don't justify the means when those means are morally wrong. Morally wrong means create collateral damage that I believe will haunt us for generations to come. (I'm sure you can think of various 20th century dictators whose actions still haunt the world.)

> China's average wage more than doubled over the past 10 years.

That's good, but it's more a result of Jintao's relaxed policy than the current president's policy. Not that I approve of Jintao - he was as much an authoritarian leader as those that preceded him.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by yunohn on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:55AM (#28478254)
> So you want them to shut down the factories, in which case they'll be sent to be sent to labor camps or rot in prison instead

What do you think a labor camp is, actually? It’s forced manual labor, done for the benefit of the non-imprisoned populace.

I don’t believe there’s much of a difference between being forced to manufacture goods versus rotting in a prison - both are horrible.

Mass shutdown of factories might actually spur some protest from the general populace and shed light on the plight of the imprisoned.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Aunche on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:34AM (#28478429)
>It’s forced manual labor, done for the benefit of the non-imprisoned populace.

From what I understand, when the media talks about an Apple supplier exploiting Uighurs for example, they're talking about a factory that employs willing people and others who are forced to find a job or else they'll be sent back to a detention camp. This is terrible, but it's not comparable to being sent off to a laogai camp.

>Mass shutdown of factories might actually spur some protest from the general populace and shed light on the plight of the imprisoned.

Someone desperate for work won't give a damn about the plight of others. This goes for the Chinese who will angry at what they perceive as western hegemony, and the people who would lose their jobs at home.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by yunohn on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:49AM (#28478491)
> they're talking about a factory that employs willing people

Prisoners forced to choose between harsh detention or menial factory work, are not “willing”.

This is the same argument made by people against minimum wage increases - “why do low wage workers do such jobs, they have a choice”.

The USA also has the same kind of prison labor, and inmates are forced to work for the profit of companies and the state, while receiving barely any wages in return. In fact, most of them cannot get any real work after release either.

> Someone desperate for work

I’m talking about the general global populace waking up to the fact that their goods are made by (essentially) slaves, as a result of labor shutdowns. This would be really beneficial to the worker class, and harm the ruling class.

And from the previous comment:

> importers demanding razor thin margins

Western companies that “believe” in human rights could just as well manufacture goods with a conscience and demand fair-trade supply chains; instead of just profit. But obviously, reality shows us otherwise.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Aunche on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:22AM (#28478671)
>Prisoners forced to choose between harsh detention or menial factory work, are not “willing”

I mean that the factories employ regular employees as well as those threatened to be sent back to detention. I don't see why both groups of people should be punished so that people thousands of miles away can feel a better conscience.

>I’m talking about the general global populace waking up to the fact that their goods are made by (essentially) slaves, as a result of labor shutdowns.

Has anything like that has ever happened in history? I don't see how people in economic distress are less likely to care about the plight of others. Meanwhile, if people cared enough to cut all trade with China, I don't see what more awareness would get us.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by yunohn on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:04AM (#28480928)
> I don't see why both groups of people should be punished so that people thousands of miles away can feel a better conscience.

What do you mean? This thread is about how China is violently dealing with dissenters within Asia (HK is not China). We’re talking about how a ban on slave labor Chinese goods could solve things.

> Has anything like that has ever happened in history?

Never before in history has the global manufacturing industry concentrated into one region (China).

> I don't see what more awareness would get us.

Awareness would instigate change, and China would be forced to stop utilizing prisoner-slave labor.

> people thousands of miles away can feel a better conscience

I’m really concerned by the level of dismissiveness you’re showing. Not sure if this discussion is leading anywhere.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by yodsanklai on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:53PM (#28475633)
I really think nobody cares. Even if China were to military invade Taiwan tonight, I'm not sure there would be any form of retaliation from western countries.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Ansil849 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:06PM (#28476226)
This. Frankly, I'm surprised with the restraint China is showing. They can more or less do whatever they want to Taiwan with no real repercussions.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by vimy on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:49PM (#28477224)
Except China would control TSMC after an invasion. And since the whole world runs on chips this would be unacceptable to the West.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by abacadaba on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:07PM (#28475770)
You realize they have millions of their citizens in reeducation camps right now as we speak that may or may not be harvesting their organs, right?
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by vmception on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:15PM (#28475832)
Imagine believing that

I'm not here to only disagree, like everyone else, I'm genuinely curious what influences you have to believe this

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by kingkawn on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:44PM (#28475030)
The only reason Hong Kong has had this period of independence is a side effect of western power subjugating the Chinese mainland. As the Chinese mainland grows in global power and the west decays into internal squabbles there should be no expectation that the pretenses of western power will remain intact.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by kingkawn on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:50PM (#28487294)
I think I'm being downvoted out of some sense of political duty to Hong Kong from westerners, but really there has been nothing holding the mainland back other than the threat of western power. If there is no threat, there is nothing that will hold them back, whether we find it tasteful or not.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Thursday September 09, 2021 @08:14PM (#28476293)
I am disappointed by the naivete displayed by Hong Kong and their Western supporters (plus some mainlanders who privately admitted so). They are just replaying the tiananmen square riot, and had been setup from the beginning to be walking into the trap that happened before, and many times over the course of human history...

They had a very good chance of inducing meaningful change into Chinese people's mindset, and plant the seed for much bigger scale of change in China. Imagine a free and solidified China, with Taiwan finally joining the whole under a free nation. That would be the real junvanation of the nation.

They squandered, they lack the discipline, showing stutling naive approach to serious politics, they are put down like weak fire in the winter days...

What a pity...