News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by JackeJR on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:35AM (#28477848)
Some think that if the US extended their protection to Taiwan, Beijing would not attempt to take Taiwan.

Let's just assume for a moment that the US will fight off attacks by China to take Taiwan. And that US successfully ward off an attack. What next? What is there to prevent China from trying again and again and again? Will the US be prepared to ward off attacks after attacks after attacks? This is unlikely to happen.

With this, lets again assume that China eventually successfully takes Taiwan. What next? They would have taken over an island with a large number of people who resents their rule. There will be a persistent resistance group as long as Beijing continues her ways and Beijing is aware of this and is trying to shape the education of the younger generations so that the resentment does not cross generations.

Even if all these were to take place and all hope seems to be lost. There is a glimmer of hope. A totalitarian state has one major fault. There is no effective feedback mechanism and to assume that this one man can make the right call, the right decision all the time is a stretch. At some point, be it internal infighting, or a policy misstep creating intense misery amongst the people, there will be discontent and if the history of China is any indication, the discontent can trigger uprisings and eventually a change of regime.

The only way the regime can be changed is from the inside.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by hker on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:47AM (#28478205)
> Some think that if the US extended their protection to Taiwan, Beijing would not attempt to take Taiwan.

> What next? What is there to prevent China from trying again and again and again?

> The only way the regime can be changed is from the inside.

Worth noting that the Chinese Army “may not be willing to fight” (‘pay the bill’ for the aggressive stance of the Foreign Ministry). [1]

If the Chinese Army did not score decisive victories early on, they may be the one to give up, pushing back pressure from the top, instead of trying again and again.

[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/geopolitics/comments/p0nqla/chinese...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by blagie on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:47AM (#28479454)
I predict:

1) China won't attack Taiwan until it can be assured a swift victory.

2) China will reach that state within our lifetimes.

WWII was won, in part, by US manufacturing prowess. China has that advantage. It's military is currently behind in equipment, but if it chose to, it could build a blue water navy or whatever else it wants in record time. It also has the political ability to engage in major projects like these (see respective COVID19 responses).

I suspect Chinese military leadership is far more competent than US or EU. The cream of the crop in the West doesn't go into the military (see Afghanistan for an good example of how US armed forces are managed).

I also think we will see major disruptions in military from autonomous and semi-autonomous machines which will really reduce the US lead. DJI is headquartered in China, as are many of the other players here. If heave machines like carriers are obsoleted, the US advantage might turn into an expensive liability.

The Chinese military also has more manpower.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dTal on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:33AM (#28479692)
Carriers are already obsolete in a superpower war. Both sides possess weapons that can destroy them utterly from a great distance, and their location cannot be kept secret. Carriers won't last a day.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:54AM (#28480829)
China's hypersonic missiles have shorter range than an F35 launched from a carrier with midair refuel drone.

The only issue is that we'd want our carriers closer in practice. Close to the action means faster response times. If we are willing to destroy Chinese satellites, then China's kill chain becomes much harder.

I'm not convinced that a drone or spyplane can reliably penetrate the defensive line of destroyers + cruisers + E2 Hawkeyes.

And satellites aren't even that reliable either, it may be possible to hide a carrier between satellite flyovers in practice.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by blagie on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:05PM (#28483483)
A drone could not penetrate a defensive line of destroyers, cruisers, and E2 Hawkeyes.

However, a destroyer costs $870 million. I can build a drone for around $870 which has decent range, and sufficient firepower to do real damage if attacking with sufficient precision (e.g. placing a small explosive charge directly within a barrel).

That means I can launch a million drones for the cost of one destroyer. I'm pretty sure that a line of destroyers, cruisers, and E2 Hawkeyes wouldn't be able to destroy a fleet of a million drones. If they could, the cost of destroying each drone would likely be greater than the cost of the drone.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by imtringued on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:46PM (#28485575)
You can also launch 870 cruise missiles for the cost of one destroyer from a greater range with greater destruction.

Actually, this is wrong. That is the cost of the missiles, not the cost of the launch platform, nor the cost of the personnel, nor the cost of the logistics.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Friday September 10, 2021 @12:08PM (#28483528)
CRAM bullets cost cheaper than your drone, and those CRAMs are on each Destroyer. I think our cruisers have 2 CRAMs on them (but I forget exactly)

These CRAMs can aim-bot and destroy subsonic cruise missiles (500mph), and even supersonic cruise missiles (1000mph). That's why China has spent billions developing hypersonic missiles (2500+mph) to dodge our CRAMs and missile defenses.

How fast is your drone flying? Does it pull enough lateral Gs to dodge CRAM shots or avoid the Patriot defense missiles?

--------

https://youtu.be/0bmSCC823tM?t=205

The "city-version" has shorter range, because we need the bullets to self-destroy themselves before they land on someone's property. So the Israeli "Iron Dome" is in fact, inferior, to the defense system on these Destroyers / Cruisers that surround the Carrier.

Tel Aviv's Iron Dome also has a much more difficult job: defending a population center rather than just a few ships. There will naturally be "holes" in the Iron Dome (just areas of the city that aren't as well defended).

In contrast: we can position our ships to maximize the chance of interception, and minimize the chance of our CRAM's failing.

-----------------

The worry about China's drones is their stealth spydrones which will try to triangulate the position of the carrier strike group. The drone then sends the coordinates to a hypersonic missile.

I'm not convinced that the stealth systems on those drones are sufficient to "hide" from radar, probably only good enough to prevent things like CRAM/Patriots from locking on. Without the ability to lock on, we don't have an ability to kill those drones from Destroyers / Cruisers.

That's where the Carrier comes in. The E2 Hawkeye has an aerial radar system and can get "eyes in the sky", making our targeting superior (maybe then our Patriots can hit). We can also launch fighters (F22 is probably sufficient) to close the distance and lock on / destroy the target... or even engage in a dogfight (radar-drones wouldn't have much dogfighting ability).

--------

How is China launching a million drones anyway? Their carriers aren't like ours. We have 4x catapults and 2x runways per carrier, I'm pretty sure China's carriers are only 1x runway. How many minutes does it take per launch?

If its an air battle you want, the 4x catapults + 2x runways the Supercarriers push will get more planes into the air than anything in the Chinese Navy... and we have something like 10 carriers fielded right now.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by blagie on Saturday September 11, 2021 @11:55AM (#28492975)
We're talking about Taiwan. China sets them up in the fields in a few of the rural communities near Xiamen. They simultaneously lift off from the fields. They fly at ~25mph. They take perhaps three hours to clear the water between Taiwan and China. There's a million of them. They're slow, but fairly agile.

Looking at the video, it looks like the C-RAM system is shooting perhaps dozens of rounds per second. Shooting down a million drones would take many hours of continuous shooting, assuming every bullet hit, which it wouldn't.

And a Patriot missile is $2-3 million.

I think the future of warfare is likely to be cheap, small, but smart and precision.

* A small drone flies into a gun barrel and explodes.

* A small drone flies into a jet air intake, and explodes, spraying material designed to damage the engine as it passes through

* A small drone deposits a chemical weapon in a ship's HVAC intake

* A small drone sprays corrosive paint on a camera, on a jet window, other surface we look through

* A small drone launches a single bullet to kill a mechanic

... and so on.

I think a lot of this goes like rock-paper-scissors, where a million $1000 drones overwhelms a $1 billion ship. On the other hand, a hundred thousand $10,000 drones could probably make quick work of a million $1000 drones. And so on.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Saturday September 11, 2021 @01:38PM (#28493945)
> They fly at ~25mph.

You know that US Warships run at 35mph to 50mph over water, right? You literally can't hit a warship at that speed.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dTal on Saturday September 11, 2021 @07:24PM (#28497053)
Only if the warship is at flanking speed directly away from the battle, commonly referred to as "running away". In which case, you've won.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Saturday September 11, 2021 @09:04PM (#28497646)
CRAMs have an effective range of like, 10km.

As long as the ship is traveling 25mph away from a 25mph drone, its shooting them down with machine guns (and bullets are very, very cheap). A flock of drones flying at 25mph isn't a weapon, they're sitting ducks. Fully and completely ineffective at ever dealing damage to these warships.

Like, 25mph means that these drones are going to be within effective range of the machine guns for 10 minutes when the ship is standing still. And these AEGIS systems on these destroyers have 300km+ effective radar range.

Unless you have very expensive equipment on those drones: they'll be flying in blind and getting sniped. Either stealth (which prevents the CRAM from locking on), or superior radar (to see the ships before the ships see it), or a combination thereof.

And again: if they're not standing still: the ships can basically run around in circles and the drones would never catch up.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by blagie on Sunday September 12, 2021 @06:04AM (#28499851)
I think that depends on the mission.

1) China doesn't need to destroy US ships; it merely needs to keep them distracted long enough to take control of Taiwan. If China moves quickly, the Taiwanese leadership are deported to Beijing, and there are boots on the ground, it's a done deal. Once that's done, it will be like Crimea. There's no way the US is getting drawn into a land war in Asia.

2) Ten minutes, at a dozen shots a minute, means a gun firing at 10 RPS can take out 6,000 drones. That's 0.6% of a flock.

3) You can't run circles around a flock of millions of drones, no matter how fast you go. A flock can cover a lot of space. The best you can do is run away, which would take US forces out-of-commission.

4) The Taiwan Straight is simply not that large. It's not hard for China to be aware of everything that happens there, even with a fleet of small, cheap AUVs. Heck, they could drop a few hundred thousand of these as well, if they wanted to.

5) It's equally not hard for China to communicate with a flock of drones. A directional spread spectrum link isn't easy to jam. At that range, even an optical link is practical, and not something where we have countermeasures.

6) A million drones can effectively blanket the whole Taiwan straight.

7) In terms of stealth, I'm not sure how technology will progress, but I'm pretty sure that building drones indistinguishable from birds on radar just wouldn't be that hard. I'm also pretty sure a flock of drones could be made to emulate other forms of craft, on radar.

8) I'm also pretty sure China wouldn't telegraph what they're doing. It's not like we can prepare countermeasures. I gave one example of a disruptive technology; there are dozens of others. To be honest, I have no idea how AEGIS would deal with a million targets, nor what having that many targets would do to its ability to track things like Chinese landing craft, unless the US were explicitly prepared for this particular threat.

Also, the C-RAM price-per-round is about $30. With a $1000 drone, things are cost-neutral if about 3% of rounds hit. At 10 kilometers, it would take rounds a little under 10 seconds to arrive. Even modestly chaotic trajectories would dodge most rounds.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Sunday September 12, 2021 @12:50PM (#28502734)
Frankly: the discussion point of "suicide drones" is pretty ignorant.

25mph drones will not hold back a warship. They can't effectively close range at 10km out, let alone at 5km, 1km, or shorter. As I stated earlier: warships are literally faster than that.

The "meta" under discussion, by serious people (including Chinese investments / Chinese saber rattling) is the missile. 500mph cruise missiles, 1000mph supersonic missiles, and 3000mph hypersonic missiles.

If you're going to "suicide drone", you do it at 3000mph to impress people. You don't do it at 25mph. Even at 500mph and 1000mph, the methodology is so clearly ineffective that China has spent billions making 3000mph missiles instead.

The minute you start thinking about how these drones are going to take off, refuel, get their payloads (etc. etc.), is the minute you realize how impractical the whole proposal is. What kind of launch platform will these drones take off in? What's the effective range of a drone?

US Destroyers have tomahawk cruise missiles that can reliably hit targets 2000km away, and these missiles fly at 500mph+. How long does it take for your 25mph drone to cover the 2000km range that these Destroyers are at defending Taiwan?

By the time your drones get there, the Destroyers have already launched all their missiles and have gone home.

------

How do you even find the warships in the first place? You keep saying "hundreds of drones", but drones flying at 10km high can only see 300km out.

Secondly: if you fly "like a bird" at say 1000meters, you can only see 100km out before the horizon blocks you. It'd be impossible to track down the warships firing from 2000km away.

At these ranges, the E2 Hawkeye of the Carrier will see your drones, and an appropriate response will be dispatched. Most likely, the warships will just avoid the drones. Hiding behind the horizon.

What kind of drone are you using to even try to tavel 2000km over water? I'm pretty sure that your typical $1000 drone simply don't have the range or speed to even get to the warships.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragonwriter on Sunday September 12, 2021 @06:20AM (#28499915)
> There's no way the US is getting drawn into a land war in Asia.

Classic blunder or not, the US gets drawn into land wars in Asia fairly regularly (especially in the 21st century, where we’ve spent most of it involved in two at once.) 1950-1953 Korea, 1955-1973 Vietnam, 1991 Iraq, 2001-2021 Afghanistan, 2003-2011 Iraq II: Elecric Boogaloo, 2014-? Iraq III: Now with Syria, too.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ericmay on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:01AM (#28480893)
I either agree or think your predictions make sense, but I think your premises that lead to them are a little bit suspect.

China doesn't have the same manufacturing prowess that the US did because of its location. In World War II, the US was essentially an untouchable supply chain with access to both oceans. It could fight Japan and supply Russia through the west if necessary, and it could fight Germany and supply England and Russia through the eat too.

In China's case, the main issue is that while the factories are certainly humming right along, they need to import food, oil, and other raw materials. Where do those come from? Certainly Russia, despite its blustering, isn't going to do too much to help China because that gives the U.S. an easy excuse to attack Russia in the east. Expect Russia to sit this one out and maybe screw around in a inconsequential way in Europe at best.

Will China then get resources from neighbors? Sure. Except now they have to transport all of these raw materials to the east coast of China where all the factories are. Lots of lead times here.

Meanwhile, the US can simply purchase the same materials from untouched supply chains in Europe and South America.

> it could build a blue water navy or whatever else it wants in record time.

I very much doubt this. And this has to happen years (decades?) before a war breaks out. China would have to build these ships in docks on the shore, which would be vulnerable to any number of U.S. bombing campaigns from strategic locations (Guam, Japan, carrier fleet, etc.). Not to say why wouldn't the U.S. also build hypersonic missiles?

> It also has the political ability to engage in major projects like these (see respective COVID19 responses).

Sure, that's always the general strength of the authoritarian regime. The ability to issue dictates. But that's also the great weakness, because you can go down a very wrong path and you won't know until its too late. Japan experienced this in World War II.

But the U.S. (and allies) would undoubtedly be united in a response to a Chinese invasion of Taiwan. The center-left, center, and entire right wing of the US for sure would be. So I'm not sure I'd look at the U.S.'s COVID-19 response and generalize from that.

> I suspect Chinese military leadership is far more competent than US or EU. The cream of the crop in the West doesn't go into the military (see Afghanistan for an good example of how US armed forces are managed).

What do you base this on? If nothing else, the United States and European Union (NATO allies) have been engaging in actual joint operations all over the world for the past 20-some years.

And the U.S. fought a different kind of war in Afghanistan than it would the one it might have to fight against China in the Pacific. First, the U.S. occupied the country just fine for 20 years, and then got tired of it. The U.S. also operated with very strict rules of engagement. Like, shoot at US soldiers then throw your Ak-47 in the weeds and say it wasn't you and nobody could do anything since you didn't have your weapon on you. Iraq looks to be a better example but neither should be relied upon as a good case.

> I also think we will see major disruptions in military from autonomous and semi-autonomous machines which will really reduce the US lead. DJI is headquartered in China, as are many of the other players here.

Who cares about DJI?

> If heave machines like carriers are obsoleted, the US advantage might turn into an expensive liability.

Weren't you saying that China would build a blue-water navy in record time? What would they do with this obsolete navy?

But the U.S. doesn't need to keep its carrier groups within range of any Chinese action to cause lots of problems for China. A naval blockade, they can go sink ships in ports that are friendly to China but aren't in China, etc.

> The Chinese military also has more manpower.

True that quantity does have a quality all of its own, but it seems like a bottle neck to me. Are they going to load up boat after boat and sail soldiers to Taiwan? Seems like a pretty expensive offensive and will Chinese moral handle losing soldiers in boats going to attack Taiwan? Lots of uncertainties.

Anyway, my point here was just to provide some counterpoints to some of yours here. Frankly, this is all really stupid.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by dragontamer on Friday September 10, 2021 @10:50AM (#28482363)
> Not to say why wouldn't the U.S. also build hypersonic missiles?

China isn't even building missile-defense cruisers (equivalent to the AEGIS system on US-ships). Our tomahawks (cheaper, subsonic cruise missiles) would obliterate them at much cheaper prices.

Why fly at 3000mph (hypersonic) when 500mph is already too fast for their defenses?

There's no reason to build hypersonic missiles until China (or Russia) demonstrates missile-defense capabilities. Even then: the methodology of "launch 20 missiles simultaneously to overwhelm their defense system" seems a lot cheaper than using developing or using hypersonic missiles.

Cheap subsonic cruise missiles are all you need unless your opponent can shoot them down. China needs Hypersonic because of AEGIS (ie: we've reliably demonstrated that we can shoot down missiles flying at 500mph). China hasn't done that, and doesn't seem to have any plans to obtain this technology yet.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ALittleLight on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:37PM (#28487182)
"The center-left, center, and entire right wing of the US for sure would be."

I doubt that. I am an American and wouldn't support war with China over Taiwan. I don't know a single person who has ever said anything suggesting they think we should commit the country to war to protect Taiwan.

Coming off the failed Afghanistan war I expect war would be extremely unpopular. Especially with an enemy so much more capable than assorted Afghan militia.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by AnimalMuppet on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:53PM (#28487321)
I really don't want another war. At the same time, I don't want the world that would result from China taking Taiwan, either.

What's wrong with that world? 1) We didn't keep our promises. 2) Another 23 million people oppressed by force against their will. Even if it isn't our job to defend them, it still doesn't sit well to see it happen. 3) We can't get chips (much less important than the other two).

Where does that leave me? Not wanting war, but not wanting the alternative? There are a fair number of people with that perspective. If it comes to it, what will we decide? I don't know, even for myself.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by PakG1 on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:33AM (#28478426)
War is tough and horrible. Any person can see that. There are many complex reasons why the larger Afghan army could not stand up to the Taliban, and while the situation is not comparable at all to the Chinese military, my point is that around the world, there are military units that aren't prepared or willing to fight the wars that their politicians wage.

I do wager that China's PLA would win a war that involves Taiwan, just due to sheer numbers and resources, but that the experience would be so bitter that the PLA would lose morale in various respects. This is partly because they don't actually have real war experience in the modern era.

Even armies with real war experience can get bitter. Armies without real war experience that suddenly get thrown into the fire, I'd wager that they would get even more bitter. PTSD and suicides would only be par for the course, the real issue would be inexperienced soldiers starting to question "what are we really doing and why am I killing people, do I really believe in what I'm doing?" I wager it would create cracks in what is currently a fairly unified country in China.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by belter on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:03AM (#28480913)
You are seeing too much from a modern occidental perspective although I dont know where you are from.

No PTSD in the divisions that were driving over their own citizens in this event: https://imgur.com/bGP9oKf

Also no hesitation, dissent of any kind is known, from the internal departments implementing it in Hong Kong, Tibet, or Xinjiang.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by tasogare on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:55AM (#28478255)
The local big player is Japan. It would be hard to intervene because of its current constitution but I don't see them letting PRC push its border so close. Moreover Okinawa was historically a vassal state of both Chinese empires and Japan, so it's possible China greed could extend there as well.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by rackjack on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:08AM (#28478005)
> Let's just assume for a moment that the US will fight off attacks by China to take Taiwan. And that US successfully ward off an attack. What next? What is there to prevent China from trying again and again and again? Will the US be prepared to ward off attacks after attacks after attacks? This is unlikely to happen.

America did this in Korea and it split the country in half.

> With this, lets again assume that China eventually successfully takes Taiwan. What next? They would have taken over an island with a large number of people who resents their rule. There will be a persistent resistance group as long as Beijing continues her ways and Beijing is aware of this and is trying to shape the education of the younger generations so that the resentment does not cross generations.

Also, brainwashing via complete control of the media, disappearing dissidents... They're doing it to the Falun Gong and the Muslims and others and they'll have no problem doing it to more.

> Even if all these were to take place and all hope seems to be lost. There is a glimmer of hope. A totalitarian state has one major fault. There is no effective feedback mechanism and to assume that this one man can make the right call, the right decision all the time is a stretch. At some point, be it internal infighting, or a policy misstep creating intense misery amongst the people, there will be discontent and if the history of China is any indication, the discontent can trigger uprisings and eventually a change of regime.

Also possible for there to be enough bureaucratic momentum that those within it have enough skin in the game to want to install a new head. But once China's growth starts to slow down I wouldn't be surprised at the CCP losing the Mandate of Heaven and the Ouroboros eating its tail again.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by klodolph on Friday September 10, 2021 @02:11AM (#28478333)
> America did this in Korea and it split the country in half.

That is not even close to what happened. Korea was divided at the end of WWII into Soviet and US occupation zones after the Japanese surrender. Prior to that, it had been occupied by Japan.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by JackeJR on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:05AM (#28482599)
I agree that once the growth slows China will start to see cracks in its society. This, I submit, is the reason why Beijing is doubling down on the nationalist path. Cast the West as the enemy and China as the victim of oppression to drum up nationalist sentiments.

The social compact I believe that exists in China is that the people put up with the curbs either out of ignorance of the lacks of curbs or because of the promise of a better life which comes along with increased job wages as long as they toe the party line.

The moment the bargain is not held up for the increased wages, the compact starts to get eroded. Turmoil in China if it happens will have a widespread and largely unknown consequences. Unknown because too many pieces are intricately linked to the stable functioning of China.

For one, I hope to be able to witness this one day.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by justicezyx on Monday September 13, 2021 @12:54AM (#28507981)
> Cast the West as the enemy and China as the victim of oppression to drum up nationalist sentiments.

Well, no, this is what US is doing, paint China as the source of all evil.

Yourself is the product of that ploy.

Think about Afghanistan, after so many years of wasted money life and time, one still think war is the answer.

How effective the propaganda has been...

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by belter on Friday September 10, 2021 @07:53AM (#28480258)
From a tactical point a view it looks a minor issue, except of course for the people of Taiwan. I cannot imagine what somebody in Taiwan, born and raised in a democracy, might be thinking when looking at what is happening in Hong Kong

From the Strategic point of view, you have to look at a map to see what that would mean. China would take over Taiwan, and immediately expand its sea island building around its borders. Cut off the Philippines and Japan across the South China Sea. From Taiwan a fighter jet can be over Japan in 10 min. Australia with its rich mineral resources and empty spaces would be next...

That the US, Australia, Japan together not make it clear to China invading Taiwan would mean a price not worth paying, will prove to be the Strategic blunder of this Century.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by nmfisher on Friday September 10, 2021 @11:37AM (#28483041)
I don't know where this absurd idea came from that "China invading Taiwan" means "Australia/Japan would be next!".

As far as the PRC is concerned, Taiwan is a part of China. They wouldn't be invading another nations, they would simply be reclaiming sovereignty over a renegade province.

That is something entirely different from invading a Western ally. One thing has absolutely no bearing on the other.

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by belter on Friday September 10, 2021 @01:53PM (#28484986)
Well historically Taiwan could argue China is the renegade province. See other comments in this thread for the context.

I think you are missing the main point. Despite an arbitration court ruling against it, China decided all of the China Sea is theirs: https://im-media.voltron.voanews.com/Drupal/01live-166/style...

"The South China Sea Arbitration (The Republic of Philippines v. The People's Republic of China)" https://pca-cpa.org/en/cases/7/

Started making artificial islands in the middle of nowhere, and now says all foreign vessels need to report in their ‘territorial waters’.

"China to require foreign vessels to report in ‘territorial waters’" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28395358

Have a look at a map, and see the distance from Yonaguni ( Japan ) to Taiwan and the distance Yonaguni to mainland Japan. You think China will do what they are doing in Hong Kong, Xinjiang, South China Sea and suddenly...Come to their senses and stop, specially if unchallenged for previous actions?

If they do this in the other side of the world: "Hundreds of fishing vessels vanishing along Argentina’s waters" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27412691

What will they do at their door?

Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by greyhair on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:58AM (#28481658)
Are you in the diplomatic corps? Are you certain that US, Australia, and Japan are not communicating to China? Not all diplomatic exchanges are made public. For example, it is clear that the US is currently talking with the Taliban leadership. What are they saying? We have no idea, but it is taking place. I suspect the same is true for the above.
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by Rd6n6 on Saturday September 11, 2021 @07:04PM (#28496926)
Huge thread about a war between the USA and China without serious mention of nuclear weapons and nuclear winter
Re:Hong Kong: Police Raid Tiananmen Square Museum by ukoki on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:01AM (#28478559)
There will be political unrest as soon as the populace realise that the easy victory they were promised is not materialising and in fact tens of thousands of sons -- only-children who represent the future, pride and prosperity of their parents -- will not be returning home.