News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by Barrin92 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @05:48PM (#28066837)
> if you are fully vaccinated, you are at essentially no risk of serious illness from SARS-CoV2.

Terrible first order logic. The threat from the virus is not only immediate risk to the individual, it is also further transmissions increasing the risk of creating new breakthrough variants. Every infected person is a gamble that risks nullifying the effectiveness of vaccines, so the goal must be to bring down infections as strongly as possible.

>We have never before justified such intrusive government policies based on the risks faced by these individuals

we should have. Tolerating disease spread and threats to vulnerable populations when vaccines are available that are practically risk-free (or the risk being magnitudes smaller than the payoff) is ridiculous. Maybe this finally shakes people awake and puts public health and safety to the top of the agenda rather than people throwing tantrums like children about government incursion.

edit: and another point I forgot, with such a significant unvaccinated population we will very likely see surges in admissions in winter again. Public health resources are limited. Unnecessary Covid hospitalizations cause immense opportunity cost in the form of crowding out care and driving costs. Which in many cases other sick people and the public will have to carry.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by timr on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:08PM (#28067594)
> we should have. Tolerating disease spread and threats to vulnerable populations when vaccines are available that are practically risk-free (or the risk being magnitudes smaller than the payoff) is ridiculous. Maybe this finally shakes people awake and puts public health and safety to the top of the agenda rather than people throwing tantrums like children about government incursion.

You can certainly go down this path, and dismiss everyone who disagrees with you as "children", but what you value is not the same as what everyone else values.

I am willing to balance the risk of never having a normal life again with an overall risk of illness and death that is on par with every other year I have been alive.

Eventually, I too will become old and frail, and become vulnerable to some virus or another. If I ever become so afraid of death that I demand that other people give up their basic human rights to "keep me safe", then I hope that illness takes me quickly after that. I don't want to live in the world you propose.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by wwweston on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:58PM (#28068003)
> an overall risk of illness and death that is on par with every other year I have been alive.

The excess death statistics would like to have a word with you, but more importantly:

> If I ever become so afraid of death that I demand that other people give up their basic human rights

Are basic human rights really what we're talking about here?

If so, they've always had limits when it came to impacts on others. The freedom to swing your fist ends at the tip of someone's nose; the freedom to spread certain pathogens might end there as well.

Of course, the article here is talking about vaccination as a condition for participation in venues where density and proximity is a concern. "Basic human rights" may well not quite reach into unqualified access to "indoor dining, in indoor fitness facilities, indoor entertainment facilities." Hell, it's hard to actually make an totally unqualified case for bodily autonomy itself, even though that's a good principle to start from, it isn't the only one.

Basic human rights were not lost from the world by smallpox or other vaccination mandates. They wouldn't be destroyed even if there were going to be a federal mandate for covid vaccination, which doesn't even seem to be on the horizon. They are certainly not going to be destroyed by proof of vaccination being required for entry to restaurants and gymns.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by acituan on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:32PM (#28069537)
> The excess death statistics would like to have a word with you

Independent of the rest of your argument, this one is not a good one to hinge on.

"Excess death" is a pragmatic term, not a normative term. The baseline death statistics doesn't mean those deaths were OK, or natural and acceptable to endure. They include many peer to peer (e.g traffic accidents) or institution to peer (many "lifestyle" diseases') deaths too, which in themselves are also excess deaths in comparison to another baseline (e.g. obesity related deaths in comparison to 1960s).

These feeds back to the arguments of risk tolerance and freedoms; there is a mutually tolerated, implicit risk of peer-to-peer death in driving too. I am not saying this is comparable to the risk of death by covid (it is obviously not), but we can't make principled arguments of absolute safety nor absolute freedom without keeping things proportional to the risks and freedoms we're already been balancing.

> Basic human rights were not lost from the world by smallpox or other vaccination mandates.

If we're being anal about it, it is not entirely true. People have a right to keep the functional and structural integrity of their bodies; and even enhancing immunization would be a change in that, and that has an element of intrusiveness to it. Again, being a transmitter of the virus and harming other people's bodies is also a threat to the functional and structural organization of those bodies, and that is (very) intrusive too, but two things can be true at the same time, and therefore this is not the principle to argue from.

The honest argument would be accepting the need for striking a balance, accepting the sense of anxiety from both sides, and not pushing conclusions into people. We have to have people participate in the rationality of the decision making, from a place of empathy and growth.

I hope this is a moment we can also realize that just like public health is a shared resource and lack thereof is a shared liability, public rationality and sound decision making capability is also a shared resource and lack thereof is a shared liability. We've been turning a blind eye to all sorts of media training people to be more and more polarized, using shaming as a short-term compliance tool that has long-term stupefying consequences. Now we depend on all of us coming to our senses to survive this thing; we need a herd immunity against irrational self-deception just as much.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by wwweston on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:36AM (#28069917)
> "Excess death" is a pragmatic term, not a normative term

Fully aware of that. The reason I invoked them is to make the pragmatic point that those statistics alone and the correlated rise with covid should tell an analyst that risks associated with the virus aren't the same as "every other year they've been alive." That's a descriptive observation.

Of course, it also invites a normative judgment...

> If we're being anal about it, it is not entirely true.

It's essentially true, and this is important. There have been genuinely compulsory vaccinations in modern free societies... and these compulsions turned out not to be slippery slopes into totalitarian oppression, but the corner case that you'd expect from societies that, as you say, realize this isn't about "absolute safety nor absolute freedom," that both risks and rights can be qualified (and in fact, for rights to be meaningful at all, they must be qualified, since there are always cases where a right reaches a point of tension with another right).

And NY isn't even talking about genuine compulsory vaccination, it's proposing vaccination as a condition of participating in things that people can opt out of. It's not even as compulsory as a fine or paying your taxes or any number of other carrots/sticks that states regularly use to "push conclusions into people" because if you're going to have a society, you're going to blow past the limits of voluntarism at some point, as lovely as it is to try and maximize it within those limits.

> People have a right to keep the functional and structural integrity of their bodies

Yes, I anticipated that and you can see it in my comment where I refer to bodily autonomy. It's a good place to start, but like every other right it isn't unqualified.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by canoebuilder on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:28AM (#28070195)
and in fact, for rights to be meaningful at all, they must be qualified, since there are always cases where a right reaches a point of tension with another right

What? I have never heard anything like that at all. Rights are absolute.

That sounds like it is coming from the "Sure free speech is fine, so long as it doesn't offend me," crowd.

it's proposing vaccination as a condition of participating in things that people can opt out of.

People here are generally highly attuned to one of the big surveillance ad corps trying to massage people into accepting some invasion of their personal sovereignty, how is this different? You think if something like this is accepted there won't be pushes to go further?

If this infrastructure is put in place, it will be abused, and it will coopted for other things.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by wwweston on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:44AM (#28070271)
> What? I have never heard anything like that at all.

Sure you have. It's embedded in the common phrase (invoked earlier) about the right to swing a fist ending at the edge of people's noses. Or in the oft-invoked expression about yelling "Fire!" in a crowded theater. Or the frequent refrain about rights being paired with responsibilities.

> You think if something like this is accepted there won't be pushes to go further?

We don't have to "think" it, we can point to historic and present examples where like compulsory actions existed without devolving into totalitarianism because we have a society shaped by people who understood it's possible to have both substantial general protections and specific exceptions.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by forcry on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:31AM (#28071225)
>We don't have to "think" it, we can point to historic and present examples where like compulsory actions existed without devolving into totalitarianism...

If there are, that should be the exceptions, rather than the norm.

Also, the parent asked if there won't be "pushes". So the implication is that there will be an overwhelming push in that direction, and very weak countering "pull" in the opposite direction.

And it is clear what direction it will ultimately go. So that is the danger in setting a precedent. So that further pushes in a "bad" direction will require much less effort, and only matter of time it is accepted to be the "new normal"..

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by wwweston on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:09PM (#28077378)
The precedents you're invoking as fearsome are scattered over a century old, some older. Past vaccination requirements have been examined and upheld -- all without leading to an overwhelming push to eliminate general autonomy.

So the idea that "it is clear what direction it will ultimately go" is... kinda correct, actually. It is clear that general autonomy can remain a valued principle with specific exceptions. It is clear that they are the exceptions rather than the norm. And that the pull in the other direction isn't weak.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by forcry on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:47PM (#28078630)
> It is clear that general autonomy can remain a valued principle with specific exceptions.

Sure. It is the ever increasing number of "specific exceptions" that people should be worried about.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by modriano on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:04AM (#28070728)
> What? I have never heard anything like that at all. Rights are absolute.

1A text: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances." [0]

So is the right to the freedom of speech absolute? Not according to the body authorized to definitively interpret the law, the Supreme Court, which ruled that laws abridging the freedom to defame people through speech or press are constitutional.

Thus the right to the freedom of speech has limits and is not absolute.

"In United States constitutional law, false statements of fact are statements of fact (as opposed to points of law) that are false. Such statements are not always protected by the First Amendment. This is usually due to laws against defamation, that is making statements that harm the reputation of another." [1]

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amendment_to_the_Unite...

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_statements_of_fact

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by DiggyJohnson on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:27AM (#28070871)
There is a rich literature about the origins/generation/properties of “human rights.”

As an easy example: how do you reconcile that rights are absolute with the over-used “can’t shout fire in a theatre” case that curtails freedom of speech. Many would argue that rights must be qualified, or exist in relationship with each other. All of these are humanist arguments, mind you. Nobody is trying to throw human rights out with the humans.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:55AM (#28070327)
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by DiggyJohnson on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:23AM (#28070844)
Really excellent comment. I liked the line about your different values from GP. I cannot prove this, but I feel as if it is becoming more “normalized” to not be able to reconcile this fact.

What are the odds that anyone is right about everything? We ought to be confident in our reasoned decisions, yes, but then not be surprised that someone else’s reasoned decisions disagree with our own.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by canoebuilder on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:33AM (#28070222)
Now we depend on all of us coming to our senses to survive this thing

Am I missing something? It seems to be clear for well over a year that "this thing" is not some existential threat that threatens our very survival. Why are people talking as if it is, and seeking to craft policy as if it is?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:33AM (#28072793)
Perhaps not my survival, or your survival, but a bunch of countries' health systems have collapsed as part of this pandemic, which has definitely lead to excess deaths.

Personally, I believe that the global excess deaths figures will be bigger this year than last, due to all the developing world where vaccines are not available.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by lmm on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:31PM (#28068678)
> The excess death statistics would like to have a word with you

What do excess deaths of vaccinated people look like?

> "Basic human rights" may well not quite reach into unqualified access to "indoor dining, in indoor fitness facilities, indoor entertainment facilities."

This is disingenuous. Freedom of peaceful assembly is widely recognised as a basic right.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by yibg on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:48AM (#28069978)
Is this an absolute or relative thing? If I have Ebola and actively contagious, would I still have to right to peacefully assemble in a crowded venue? Or is there some cut off of potential harm where this is true?
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by lmm on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:59AM (#28070041)
No basic human right is absolute. Nowhere has completely unrestricted speech, everywhere puts some restrictions on voting rights, all regimes have cases in which your property rights are forfeit. But it should be a very high bar.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by randerson on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:55PM (#28069268)
Peaceful assembly without being killed by your neighbors seems like an even more basic subset of that right.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:01PM (#28068896)
Peaceful assembly is protected in the constitution for people "to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

Who's doing this in a movie theater? It's clearly meant to protect public protests.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by smhost on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:18PM (#28069002)
they're saying it's a sit-in

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sit-in

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by walterbell on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:59PM (#28068887)
> What do excess deaths of vaccinated people look like?

VAERS currently reports 11,000 deaths (50% in USA mainland) after Covid vaccines. VAERS only has a subset of data on vaccine adverse events, so the true number when private/HMO databases are included will be some multiple (5x to 100x) of the VAERS total, https://openvaers.com/. A German pathologist has estimated that 30% of post-vaccine deaths were caused by vaccination. We need more autopsies in other countries, along with earlier post-vaccine clinical observation, https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https...

> pathologists therefore worked with public prosecutors, the police and resident doctors, reports Schirmacher. More than 40 people have already been autopsied who died within two weeks of being vaccinated. Schirmacher estimates that 30 to 40 percent of them died from the vaccination. In his opinion, the frequency of fatal consequences of vaccinations is underestimated

Existing Covid vaccines are non-sterilizing, i.e. they do not prevent infection or transmission. In fact, because a non-sterilizing vaccine suppresses symptoms, an infected vaccinated person doesn't know to isolate (unless they get tested after exposure, as recommended by CDC) and can infect others. A non-vaccinated person would show symptoms and can self-isolate, ending the transmission chain.

Natural immunity is sterilizing, i.e. NYC essential workers who have already recovered from Covid are much better for public health than anyone vaccinated with a non-sterilizing Covid vaccine, https://thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/558757-the-ill-advise...

> During the pandemic, the professional laptop class protected themselves by working from home while exposing the working class that brought them food and other goods. It is now the height of hypocrisy to recognize immunity from vaccinations but not immunity from those exposed while serving the laptop class.

US Covid deaths peaked in early January, three months before US daily vaccines peaked in mid-April (https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/us-daily-covid-vaccine-do...), and VAERS deaths peaked in March-April, https://www.medalerts.org/vaersdb/findfield.php?GRAPH=ON&GRO...

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by greycol on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:15PM (#28069412)
Just to clarify for those worried about what looks like legitimate numbers. The 6000 (unverified though there are legitimate reports) deaths on VAERS (down from the 11,000 when those that were posted from overseas sources were removed) means that the death rate for the vaccine using this number is 0.0018%.

To put that number into context, you are 944 times more likely to die if you catch covid than if you get a vacine in the US. That's right the anti-vaxer take on the VAERS numbers say getting a vaccine is 1000 times better than not getting a covid vaccine. Even in the country with the lowest reported (0.1% which is not necessarily the actual) death rate per covid case you are 100x better off getting the vaccine.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by walterbell on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:20PM (#28069456)
A more local statistic is the list of adverse events by age group, for the specific lot number on a vaccine card. One vaccine lot number can be distributed across multiple geographical regions. To run the query, replace 123456 at the end of the URL below, with the lot number from a vaccine card. More granular results can be found via the query wizard.

https://medalerts.org/vaersdb/findfield.php?TABLE=ON&GROUP1=...

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by canoebuilder on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:56AM (#28070022)
People dying from covid are old, to very old, and/or in poor to very poor health. People dying from and having adverse reactions to the "vaccines" are young to not that old, and in good health.

Big piece of the puzzle you are ommiting there.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by wwweston on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:12AM (#28070426)
Let's put those puzzle pieces together:

In the US, over 300 million doses of covid-19 vaccines have been administered so far. Reported deaths of any cause (regardless of any established connection with the vaccine) among this group was on the order of 6000 people as of the end of July. [0]

US covid-19 cases are around 35 million and 600k deaths. How many of those were "young to not that old"? Well, one count[1] would put us at about 28k under 50, 10k under 40.

Let's be generous to the "vaccines are a threat to the young" position and assume for the sake of argument that ALL of the 6000 VAERS reported deaths were in fact caused by the vaccine and were ALL people under 40. Even making those assumptions, the order-of-magnitude difference in vaccination events vs infection events makes it utterly clear that covid itself is at least 10x more dangerous to people under 40 than receiving a vaccination is.

And if you dig into the adverse vaccine event specifics, my bet is that you find a pretty similar distribution of adverse effects -- sure, some of them are young people, just like some covid deaths are young people, but not most of them.

[0] https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/safety/ad...

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1191568/reported-deaths-...

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by Zababa on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:22PM (#28077533)
Shouldn't we take into account that someone dying earlier is worse than someone dying old? Not sure if that would flip the balance, it may for people around 20-25 maybe, or at least balance things.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by wwweston on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:38PM (#28081915)
If we've established that the vaccine is 1/10th the risk of covid itself to younger people (which I think I did in my comment), as far as I can tell any extra weight that might be assigned to preserving young life just falls out of the problem.

People do work with numbers like "Years of Life Lost," and FWIW I think that can inform some conversations even though I don't think it helps much with this one. It is not the end-all-be-all, though. You could, for example, look at the social costs of losing the accumulated experience/wisdom/social capital of people over a certain age, which may be why some societies emphasize respect for the elderly.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by Zababa on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:36PM (#28082321)
You did for people under 40, and I agree with your point, but I'm wondering if the results are the same for people that are between 20 and 30 for example. I find that 75% of the people that died of COVID under 40 were under 30 and 40 with https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm. So the risk would be more around 1/3rd (give or take) of the risk of covid itself, following your calculations. So you're betting that less than a third of people between 20 and 30 will get covid (again, give or take and highly in "my" favor, as you yourself pushed the data on this side already).

Considering that we still don't know the long terms effect of the vaccine, I can understand that someone between 20 and 30 without comorbidities would think that it's reasonable to wait and see, especially if he's less at risk (lives in the countryside for example, remote work, things like that).

> You could, for example, look at the social costs of losing the accumulated experience/wisdom/social capital of people over a certain age, which may be why some societies emphasize respect for the elderly.

That's a good point. You could also add a different value for years depending on the age, as people often value their youth more. 1.5 years lost when you're in college or starting your first job is not the same as when you're in your 70s and retired.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by timdev2 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:07PM (#28069360)
If you're going to use VAERS data to support your argument, you really must take extra care to demonstrate that you understand what those data actually are, and explain why your conclusions should be taken seriously.

Otherwise, you risk being lumped in with the multitude of bad takes made by people who misunderstand what VAERS is, and don't understand statistics.

> US Covid deaths peaked in early January, three months before US daily vaccines peaked in mid-April, and VAERS deaths peaked in March-April.

I find an April peak in VAERS deaths entirely unsurprising, since that's exactly when the rate of vaccination was highest.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by walterbell on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:14PM (#28069408)
If you know of non-VAERS public sources of vaccine adverse event data, references would be appreciated. A link was provided to one pathologist autopsy study, more are needed. CDC VSD (Vaccine Safety Datalink) is not public, sometimes we get data snapshots when CDC is investigating specific adverse events, like blood clots, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27464528
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by timdev2 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:29PM (#28069508)
Perhaps I wasn't clear. I wasn't complaining that VAERS was a bad source of data. I was pointing out that your post is hard to distinguish from the large body of bad posts that misinterpret those data because their authors fundamentally misconstrue what the data actually represent.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by walterbell on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:31PM (#28069532)
Ah, thanks for clarifying.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by canoebuilder on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:52AM (#28069994)
Are basic human rights really what we're talking about here?

If so, they've always had limits when it came to impacts on others. The freedom to swing your fist ends at the tip of someone's nose

Whoa, you've got that horridly twisted.

It's not a human right to demand that others undergo a medical procedure for your own perceived interest. It's not a human right to demand others undergo a medical procedure, or be injected with something, because you've been told it will benefit you in some way. Every individual has complete choice and autonomy as to the medical procedures they undergo. That is the human right.

>Article 6 – Consent

1. Any preventive, diagnostic and therapeutic medical intervention is only to be carried out with the prior, free and informed consent of the person concerned, based on adequate information. The consent should, where appropriate, be express and may be withdrawn by the person concerned at any time and for any reason without disadvantage or prejudice.

http://portal.unesco.org/en/ev.php-URL_ID=31058&URL_DO=DO_TO...

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:58AM (#28070038)
This isn't a medical procedure. You are certainly not allowed to make someone go through a medical procedure, since, you know, it doesn't affect you. Not being vaccinated affects everyone, so your choice of whether you get it or not is now going to have consequences on what you can do publicly. I've still not heard a single good argument for not vaccinating despite reading most anti-vax comments on this post.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:47PM (#28082379)
>I've still not heard a single good argument for not vaccinating despite reading most anti-vax comments on this post.

The obvious good reason is you have one of the many pre-existing conditions that prevent you from getting the vaccine without causing yourself further risk of long term organ damage/failure caused by you previously taking other mandatory vaccines on a regular basis (healthcare workers, vasculitis is one such group of diseases common among the RN population - but what do they know, those front line workers with their anti-vaxx mumbo-jumbo).

The other obvious reason is another simple one - it seems its completely unnecessary for any relatively "healthy" person such as myself to worry about this virus. Our immune systems are designed for this battle, and based on the death rates, it seems despite the US population being very obese and largely unhealthy with a fairly high diabetes rate, we're somehow not dying in droves.

Third reason, vaccinations against every single little virus that comes along is effectively practicing negative selection. I think we all can assume where that leads especially with a leaky vaccine like this one - large scale true extinction event. We're breeding superbugs by vaccinating large scale populations, instead of small targeted vaccine administration.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by desine on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:14AM (#28070135)
>I've still not heard a single good argument for not vaccinating despite reading most anti-vax comments on this post.

Because if I put something in my body only because my master tells me to, I am a slave. Through and through. Bodily autonomy is absolute. It's different than the Modern American definition of slavery, which is mostly based on the New World forms of slavery, which are related to but different than the Old World forms of slavery. But they are all slavery. Either you have control of your corpus or you do not.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by katbyte on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:05AM (#28070736)
You have the choice to be vaccinated or not - businesses and have the choice to refuse to provide service to the unvaccinated, private property and all. And society has the right to insist on vaccines to participate. We all have rights and yours don’t cancel out others.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by desine on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:48PM (#28077098)
TLA is about a local government mandating that businesses check for vaccination status. That's infringing on rights of the businesses, "private property and all."
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:24AM (#28070180)
You were vaccinated as a child and you're presumably perfectly fine. And it's not about you. It's about not being selfish to end a pandemic that affects other people a lot worse than it does you.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by desine on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:32AM (#28070210)
We allow parents to make decisions for children up to a certain age. I'm definitely not arguing that.

It is about me. A population is made up of individual people. Those individual people have rights. Given a choice of a population of X size who surrender the rights to govern their body, vs a population of free willed humans of (X - (00.03 * X)), I would gladly take the latter, including as a casualty. Humanity under authoritarianism is never morally acceptable, regardless of how benevolent my dictator appears to be.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by nl on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:22AM (#28070489)
This is an argument against tyranny, but it isn't an argument against vaccination.

From your comment:

> Because if I put something in my body only because my master tells me to, I am a slave.

So don't do it for that reason. Do it because it will save your (and other people's) life.

That's an entirely reasonable position to take.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by grepfru_it on Friday August 06, 2021 @08:55AM (#28086470)
>save your life

How do you know he wasn't already infected and thus has natural immunity? So how is this saving her or his life?

Why aren't we testing for those who actually need this vaccine or not (because antibody tests don't work very well and no one wants to improve that metric because thats not where the money is)

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by desine on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:33AM (#28070559)
Sure, but it's not the only reasonable position to take.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:10AM (#28073220)
What are your concerns if you were to do it? Is it purely to take a stance?
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by desine on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:15PM (#28079096)
Concern over long term effects of mRNA therapy, of which I've found little evidence

Concern over long term effects of the spike protein presented by COVID-19, both attached to the virus and free-floating within my body as a result of mRNA therapy.

Concern over long term ability for my cells to accurately recreate the spike protein. From what I've read, this is actually low concern on my scale, the capping seems pretty thorough.

Concern over my body creating an immunoresponse to organs/nearby cells/systems where the spike protein has accumulated

Concern over my immune system being able to form a strong defense in the future over different coronaviruses when it's been trained to work outside it's normal operational parameters.

Concern over the hubris of mankind and the house of cards that is our trust in the peer review system.

Concern over the lack of experiment replication done in the modern medical fields

Concern over the fact that some of these companies have shady history, including knowingly selling me asbestos to keep my testicle dry during the summer heat.

Concern over the lack of transparency in the bridges between pharma lobbyists and government, politicians and media, and media and pharma corps.

Concern over the lack of transparency in more broader sense.

Concern over the obvious astroturfing on social media, of multiple "influencers" posting the same copy and pasted messages, the bot responses, the general fiscal funding behind this debate.

Concern over the future implications of us accepting, as a society, the weaponization of fear, and the saving graces of corporations.

Concern over our willingness to change our lives in drastic manners because of the justification that it may save a life, which I see as an endless justification opportunity for future world leaders.

Concern over turning fear into a virtue.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:36PM (#28081459)
This is why the pandemic is nowhere near over. People who don't read data taking a political stance just because it's their right.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:01PM (#28082471)
I read data. A friend is working on the vaccine for Novavax - him and his family will not be vaccinated anytime within this decade. This is very quickly turning into an endemic virus cycle like most others throughout history. We've been trying to eradicate the coronavirus family for at least 70 years with 0 results. This is a leaky vaccine, and breakthrough case numbers reported by Pfizer to the FDA don't paint a rosy picture (somewhere between 14-24%; they don't know, they didn't really test those people in their initial trials, they just assumed they had Covid based on symptoms, which is why they keep stressing that even though you've had your vaccinations, you're still at risk of infection and spreading the disease). Look at the numbers of fully vaccinated people in Israel currently hospitalized. I'd rather NYC enforced high quality diet and mandatory exercise than a newfangled vaccine. But I know, people just want the magic pill....every year...for the rest of their lives.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by nl on Friday August 06, 2021 @12:20AM (#28083290)
> Look at the numbers of fully vaccinated people in Israel currently hospitalized.

The country’s Health Ministry reported last week that the two-dose vaccine is now just 39% effective in Israel where the highly transmissible delta variant is the dominant strain. The shot still works very well in preventing people from getting seriously sick, Israeli officials said, demonstrating 88% effectiveness against hospitalization and 91% effectiveness against severe illness.[1]

So 88% effective against Delta-strain COVID causing hospitalization. That seems pretty good!

I think many people saying "look at Israel" are looking at the decreased effectiveness in stopping any symptoms against Delta-COVID and think that - disappointing - headline figure (39%) is the protection against hospitalisation rate. It's not, fortunately.

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/29/delta-variant-israel-to-give...

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Friday August 06, 2021 @04:38PM (#28092467)
I mean that's fantastic. My immune system is also highly effective against corona viruses, fungal infections, and other pathogenic microbes. To each his own.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by nl on Friday August 06, 2021 @10:34PM (#28095171)
> My immune system is also highly effective against corona viruses, fungal infections, and other pathogenic microbes.

It sure is! Once it has had a look at the virus to know to act against it.

That is literally what a vaccine is - a way to give your immune system an early look at a pathogen so it knows to act next time it sees it.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Monday August 09, 2021 @09:19PM (#28124255)
Thanks for the lesson. This is exactly how your immune system already functions. No need to set yourself up for risks with jabs if you've got a genetic precondition for various diseases related to routine vaccinations. I'm glad we agree.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by grepfru_it on Friday August 06, 2021 @09:02AM (#28086559)
> him and his family will not be vaccinated anytime within this decade.

because of the nanoparticle adjuvant that enacpsulates the subunit? yeah that's been on the top of my mind too, but covaxin is a traditional inactivated virus and it confers 70+% efficacy. my question is, if a vaccine that is the same genetic material (maybe a little less, but not heavily modified like mrna or run through the moth/tree approach like novavax) then why are we ignoring those who were actually infected?

food for thought: long covid is H O R R I B L E, and that should be everyones reason to take a vaccine.. but if you don't want to, just be prepared to sit on the sidelines for a year or maybe more. once the pandemic, as defined by the government, ends then you are on your own. there is already less patience for those who need to take extended time from work for a covid positive result

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Friday August 06, 2021 @04:29PM (#28092361)
Long covid is highly debated as the evidence for such a disease is currently very weak, but we will see it crystallize in the next few years I suppose. Many in the health field see it as another psychologically-induced disease. Who knows? Let us not forget that every single viral infection that attacks the body, is likely to leave at least some long term damage or change (no matter how slight), and certainly the unlucky few have severe long term damage even from the flu.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:53PM (#28082784)
https://apnews.com/article/fact-checking-644288348135

Your anecdotal evidence from a friend isn't data.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Friday August 06, 2021 @07:43AM (#28085789)
Not just my friend, my friend. Everybody who worked on encapsulating the mRNA vaccine knows why the compound was not allowed for human use previously, and why they've all had to show the same diligence (because it caused clots which lead to stroke-outs and heart attacks in animal trials).

Your link shows what exactly? That yes, the majority of people with Covid currently, and majority of hospitalized (severely ill other words) are fully vaccinated.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Friday August 06, 2021 @09:14AM (#28086695)
Read the article, then respond. #1 you don't know everyone who worked on it, and #2 the entire point of the article is this is WAY lower than their prevaccinated days in January.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Friday August 06, 2021 @04:36PM (#28092456)
I'm not arguing wether the vaccine keeps some people out of the hospital, I've read the article broski. The article points out what some Israeli doctors are seeing; to quote one "80-90% of my covid cases are 100% vaccinated". This vaccine is coming up short and is probably causing more harm than good in the long run; we're heading into an endemic cycle. Everyone (each company) that has worked on mRNA vaccines in the last 10 years+ are facing the same ethical dilemma, as all of the compounds have not been approved for human use. Just saying what the virologist tells me. Go nuts with your vaccine ingestion (I don't care what you do one way or the other), but I would stay with Sputnik or the Sino vaccines especially if you have a history of blood clots or genetic predisposition to heart conditions.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by nl on Friday August 06, 2021 @10:45PM (#28095234)
> The article points out what some Israeli doctors are seeing; to quote one "80-90% of my covid cases are 100% vaccinated".

You seem to think this is bad or something? As the vaccine rate increases of course more patients will be vaccinated. If the vaccine rate was 100% then 100% of people seen would be vaccinated!

The number of people being hospitalised has decreased hugely though.

> Everyone (each company) that has worked on mRNA vaccines in the last 10 years+ are facing the same ethical dilemma, as all of the compounds have not been approved for human use.

Well this isn't true at all.

> I would stay with Sputnik or the Sino vaccines especially if you have a history of blood clots or genetic predisposition to heart conditions.

I don't know much about the Sino vaccine, but Sputnik is a adenovirus-based vaccine (the same as AstraZeneca). It probably has the same blood clotting issues as AZ, but the places it has been deployed have much less robust post vaccine medical surveillance.

But it's good you'd take it! I'd encourage you to do so ASAP.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Monday August 09, 2021 @09:25PM (#28124283)
It is bad. When 80% of your hospitalizations (serious conditions) have gotten two jabs of the mRNA vaccine. Hospitalizations in my state are only increasing, and its not the un-vaccinated, it's those that believe being vaccinated means you no longer hold any risk with relation to spreading the virus.

The blood clots from AstraZeneca have not been thoroughly investigated - we don't know the pathways involved. By the way, the mRNA vaccines are producing many more blood clot calls into triage lines and offices than AZ (prolly because of slow rollout here).

>I'd encourage you to do so ASAP.

Why would you encourage me to do something my body doesn't need?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by desine on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:54PM (#28081586)
definitely not the issue of people handwaving away concerns as being unfounded or uneducated. thanks for showing me the truth.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by amanaplanacanal on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:31AM (#28072268)
In the US, you most certainly do not. Are you unaware of drug laws, for example? By your logic, you are now and always have been a slave, and so is everyone else. What was once a useful word is now meaningless.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by canoebuilder on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:41AM (#28070256)
What? Vaccination absolutely is a medical procedure. How could you say otherwise?

It's now clear that these injections do not have the efficacy of what has traditionally been termed a "vaccination," but they're definitely being marketed as a preventative, or therapeutic medical intervention.

Weird comment this one...

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:20AM (#28073345)
Getting a shot is not a medical procedure and more than going to the dentist is. The efficacy is still much, much higher than not being vaccinated. I'm not sure I see what you're getting at.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by claytongulick on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:43PM (#28068765)
It depends on whether you consider liberty, self ownership and free contracts between consenting adults to be basic human rights.

Eroding liberty by restricting free association would have certainly been considered a violation of rights by the folks that listed them in the Constitution.

In fact, they put it first.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:35AM (#28072819)
And yet, quarantine of infected people/places has a long, long history in the US. Weird.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by claytongulick on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:49AM (#28073696)
Great point!

Like when we put barbed wire up in Chinatown, San Francisco in 1900 after allowing all the white people to leave? [1]

Or when we incarcerated 30,000 women in WWI because they may be "unclean" and held them even after their mandatory STD tests came back negative? [1]

Or what we did to immigrant Russian Jews in 1892? [2]

Did you know that up until 2009 we banned HIV positive people from entering the U.S.? [2]

Yes, of course the U.S. has a long history of quarantine. We also have a long history of abusing those powers for racist and political reasons.

The PA Supreme Court, at least, agrees. [3]

[1] https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2014/10/30/3601204...

[2] https://www.historytoday.com/history-matters/cure-worse-dise...

[3] https://www.alston.com/en/insights/publications/2020/09/cons...

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by wutbrodo on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:33AM (#28069907)
> The excess death statistics would like to have a word with you,

I think you're misunderstanding the conversation. The thread is talking about the risk _to vaccinated people_. What excess death statistics are you thinking of that show a categorical increase in risk for those vaccinated?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by forcry on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:32AM (#28070896)
>the freedom to spread certain pathogens might end there as well.

There is a false equivalence here that freedom to opt-out of a commercial product, is excising one's freedom to "spread diseases".

To make it clear, would you want to pass a law that prevents someone with a genetic defect from marrying and having children? Because they would be "spreading" generic disorders, and by having offspring, they are "exercising their freedom to spread a genetic disorder", right?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by hibernator149 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:18AM (#28071798)
Comparing vacination to forced sterilisation is pretty extreme. What makes you think that these are on the same level?
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by forcry on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:55AM (#28073026)
Basically, it is the same reasoning. But it does not have to be force sterilisation.

You can say that any one that is not breathing through a mask is exercising their freedom to spread diseases, and so everyone should wear a mask all the time..

Basically, the point is there is a line where your right to be safe and the right of the rest of the world to exist in freedom is in balance. And arguments like the one that is being made is pushing that line to reduce the latter, and if we are not careful, the latter will be reasoned out, in the name of increasing the "protection" of the 0.01% of people from 95.02 to 95.03% (Just made up numbers to illustrate the point).

And it is not hard to imagine who benefits from it.

May be we need a "Citizen freedom index" for every country so that we will know when we are draining it.

Because if it is hard to improve what that cannot be measured, its hard to know when you are draining it as well..

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mlang23 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:17PM (#28068158)
Thanks for having the courage to write this. I couldnt agree more. I find the risk assessment argument of the thread parent really twisted. Younger people effectively have no risk of dying from covid. Elderly have. And now, the left is trying to force everyone to vaccinate, no matter how good or bad their immune system might be. This world has become a place I actually really dont want to live in. If this trend really wins and people accept a world of forced vaccination and masks and restrictions of public areas, I prefer to contract covid and die.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:01AM (#28070050)
> Younger people effectively have no risk of dying from covid. Elderly have

Not true. Delta is showing increasingly worse numbers for younger people. Some children's hospitals are full from it. If you have another argument besides that one let's discuss.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mlang23 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:15AM (#28071457)
I think you are spreading FUD. So no need to argue with you.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:18AM (#28073322)
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by timr on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:35PM (#28082306)
So, yet another article about "cases" that are "surging"...however:

"The study does note that “it appears that severe illness due to COVID-19 is uncommon among children.”

"Among the 23 states and New York City reviewed by AAP, children’s hospitalizations made up 1.3 – 3.5 percent of all COVID-19 hospitalizations for the week ending July 29."

"According to the study, children were 0.00 – 0.26 percent of all COVID-19 deaths, and seven states reported zero child deaths among data from 43 states, New York City, Puerto Rico and Guam, with 0.00 – 0.03 percent of all child COVID-19 cases resulted in death in those areas."

If you're trying to provide evidence that Covid does not present a serious threat to children, it'd be hard to do a better job.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by cobbzilla on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:34PM (#28068711)
What you are describing could be called geritocracy, which is a bit of a pejorative, implying negative outcomes, particularly for the young. But then consider Florida, with the most old folks per capita, and what their policies and outcomes have been.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:42AM (#28072868)
> the left is trying to force everyone to vaccinate

If you believe that the left is pretty much every public health organisation in every country in the world, then yes.

Otherwise, your statement is false.

If Trump had won, and he had encouraged vaccination, would you be blaming the right?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by salamandersauce on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:20AM (#28072207)
Jesus christ. Did you go to public school? In most cases vaccinations for common diseases is required to attend. Vaccines save lives, is very little burden to you especially if you "have a good immune system". The faster we get everyone vaccinated the faster we get rid of the need of masks and restrictions. It's morons like you elongating things.

If you get on that ventilatior you won't be thinking you made the right choice. You'll be wishing you took the vaccine like so many stories we see today. What an idiotic hill to die on.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mlang23 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:40AM (#28074367)
Keep your FUD to yourself and to your family. I am young and healthy enough that I will not need a hospital if I get a covid infection. Your FUD does not change my attitude.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by salamandersauce on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:08AM (#28074805)
Will everyone you know with that attitude be so lucky? Or those that actually can't get the vaccine. You sound like a selfish jerk. Did you ever stop and think that maybe your family and friends won't be so lucky as to not need a hospital? It's not just for you!!!

Even if your young and healthy there's still a non-zero chance something could happen to you.

Why not just get it on the off chance?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mlang23 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:38PM (#28076093)
Yet another FUD-spreader.

> there's still a non-zero chance something somethin could happen to you.

That was true before the pandemic, and it is still true today. If I die, I die. No need to restrict the lives of everyone else just because you are afraid of death.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by salamandersauce on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:09PM (#28076543)
Just because you don't like the message it's not FUD. Do you not wear a seatbelt in the car too? If you die, you die. Why bother wearing a bike helmet? If you die, you die. Unprotected sex with strangers? Sure, why not. If you die, you die. Why bother mitigating any risk that you can? I mean if you die, you die. Live your life free am I right? No need for silly restrictions like seatbelts, helmets or condoms.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:06PM (#28082502)
Now you're finally getting it. I don't do any of those things you describe....and I don't particularly value or even like life. You stick to your value system and live however the fuck you want, and let everybody else value what they value and live however they want. If you're afraid of a virus potentially killing random people, I am not sure how you've made it this far without sheltering in place your whole life (hint, we have much scarier superbugs spread in hospitals that are almost immediately deadly to the immunocompromised).
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by salamandersauce on Friday August 06, 2021 @05:57AM (#28085126)
Wow. So you're a moron. Doesn't even have to be random people. I don't want any of my friends or family dying from a currently preventable cause.

The problem with you "living however you want" is that it can impact other people...living. Every person the virus infects is a new chance for it to mutate and potentially get worse. We've already seen that happen once with the delta variant. You have an easy way to prevent deaths and you won't because?

Would you let someone "live their life" running around stabbing people? Some people might just get a nick, some could die, what does it matter?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Friday August 06, 2021 @07:46AM (#28085814)
So you call me a moron, and then you go on to compare stabbing people to not getting a vaccine...hmmmm.

People are largely unvaccinated in New York city (70% unvax), and yet, somehow, we don't see people lying in the streets (at least not from Covid). Hmmmm. Could it be that people's immune systems are functioning despite the human hubris and hysteria?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by salamandersauce on Friday August 06, 2021 @07:57AM (#28085903)
If you don't wear a seatbelt you absolutely are.

Where did you see that 70% of NYC is unvaxed? Over 50% of people in NYC are fully vaccinated against COVID and those under 12 are still not eligible.

https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data-vaccines.p...

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Friday August 06, 2021 @04:23PM (#28092316)
Your obsession with death avoidance is clearly anxiety inducing. Embrace life, embrace death, embrace (bad) luck and embrace decay are my personal keys to a stress-less life. I grew up in a country and in a household, where the car we owned had no seat belts. We also rode our bikes without helmets (shock! horror!). It was not a big deal. Never got into a car accident and I've personally been driving for over 30 years. For about a decade I drank and drove without incident. I jump out of airplanes with suspect and haphazard inspections on a regular basis. Had some close calls, but I'm still here (broken bones mend). My grandmother died at 99 (by choice mind you), her husband died at 30 of cancer. Life is a roll of a dice, you cannot escape your genetic lottery, a vaccine (especially this one) is highly unlikely to save much of your life if you're a person with 2.8 comorbidities.

I got the 70% unvaxed from a nytimes.com article; apparently it was dated. Looks like only 40% are unvaxed now according to your link. What's the Covid death rate in that highly congested and dense city? In my state, it is .13%, and that's counting many many deaths that have nothing to do with Covid as a "Covid death" (according to my wife [RN] and her friends who work in local ERs and ICUs as well as a head administrator of our largest public state health network).

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by salamandersauce on Friday August 06, 2021 @06:49PM (#28093656)
Survivorship bias. Look it up. Congrats. You didn't die or kill any one drinking and driving or not wearing any seatbelts. Lucky you.

But guess what? They do save lives. That's why it's against the law to not wear a seat belt or bike helmet in most places or to not drink and drive. The vaccine can save lives too but it works best if as many people as possible to protect those who can't, to prevent breakthrough infections etc.

I'm not "obsessed" with death avoidance. I'm just not such a selfish asshat that I can give an hour of my time to go get vaccinated, reduce spread and maybe save some lives.

It's not like those people with comorbidities were going to die tomorrow without COVID anyways, they were going to live 5, 10, 20 extra years. Time to see children and grandchildren grow up, spend with friends etc.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Monday August 09, 2021 @09:16PM (#28124236)
I know, its all survivorship bias, none of it has anything to do with my OCD genes or the thousands of little mitigations to risks I take every day.

>The vaccine can save lives too but it works best if as many people as possible to protect those who can't, to prevent breakthrough infections etc.

What works best is for sick people to stay the fuck home until they're not sick anymore. Healthy people's immune systems, won't allow a large viral load to allow for transmission. This is not a magic virus, there is nothing new here.

>I'm just not such a selfish asshat that I can give an hour of my time to go get vaccinated, reduce spread and maybe save some lives.

Homie, if you believe you're saving some lives by getting vaccinated...I don't know what kind of propaganda you've been feeding on along with those cheetos you were complaining about the other day.

The vaccine will not stop you from transmitting the virus to other immunocompromised people. Don't take my word for it, take Pfizer's.

[dead]
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by Rapzid on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:59PM (#28069302)
I'm honestly surprised DUI laws are not brought up more as an analogy when discussing mask mandates and other public health measures.

An argument for driving drunk that sounds a lot like more than a few no-mask and no-vax arguments; "I drive drunk all the time and have never hurt anyone; I will probably never kill anyone. If you can't accept the risk of driving on the roads with me then stay home!".

And also, in both cases of course it's the potential harm to others that tends to make the laws acceptable. In the case of SCOTUS, it's settled that the government can take EXTREME measures in the name of public health.. Likely far beyond anything we have had to deal with so far.

But the courts acceptance (which is the source of truth of what is legal) is contextual. So the slippery slope arguments are off base IMHO because something upheld in the context of the pandemic could be struck down outside the pandemic..

We live by rule of law and it's a glorious thing. As much as I enjoy being cynical, getting together to agree on rules we wouldn't otherwise hold ourselves to(game theory?) is an amazing thing.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mdorazio on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:45PM (#28068360)
This is effectively a "think of the children argument". People with health complications will always be at higher risk of bad disease outcomes than the rest of the population. That includes the regular flu, too, and is pretty much guaranteed to include some form of COVID forever at this point. You don't get to use that as some kind of moral high ground to force your personal stance on everyone else.

Educate people about the low risk and high benefit of getting vaccinated. Encourage them to do so as a generally good thing for society. But framing it the way you are right now is not just unhelpful, it actively makes unvaccinated people think you hate freedom and don't give a damn about anyone's personal opinions.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by FactolSarin on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:03PM (#28068488)
1) I didn't mention children at all. I'm certainly not making a "think of the children" argument. That implies you think COVID is overblown and not a serious threat. But it is, and it's killed millions.

2) I don't give a damn about dumb opinions, and it's not my job to "educate" people that, let's be honest, don't really want to learn. The solution to stop deaths by DUIs isn't to try and convince people that they're wrong for driving drunk. The solution to stop deaths by lead poisoning isn't to try and educate consumers about the danger of lead in food.

Framing that as "hating freedom" is disengenuous. It would be nice if people did the bare minimum to not endanger lives, without requiring the force of law. Sadly, that's not always the case.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mdorazio on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:45PM (#28068785)
1) Replace "children" with "immunocompromised people". It is the exact same argument. Don't be pedantic. And yes, I do believe COVID is overblown in how it is presented. The risk factors are very clear now and nowhere near as bad as they were originally presented, or as bad as people still seem to think they are.

2) You just did it again - stating other people's opinions are "dumb" because they don't adhere to your personal mantra is exactly how you make other people completely disengage. Just like I'm going to do now.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by FactolSarin on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:27PM (#28069068)
To be clear, there's nothing wrong with thinking of children (or the immunocompromised or handicapped or any other group). "Think of the children" is an argument where you use children to justify an absurd, overblown, or bad faith argument.

You seem to think it means "I shouldn't have to think about other people's well-being because freedom." I think that's pretty callous.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mlang23 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:06AM (#28071407)
As a person with a disability, I request respectfully that you leave disability out of your flawed "everyone needs to comply with my opinion" nonsense. I dont want to see disability abused by people like you. Understood? Keep your patronising to yourself and your family.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:05AM (#28070066)
Yes vaccinated people can pass it on, but not as easily (study released today). Yes getting vaccinated will end the pandemic sooner because A) it won't be transmitted as much, and B) hospitals won't be at capacity for milder cases. Just get vaccinated
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:09PM (#28082520)
>It would be nice if people did the bare minimum to not endanger lives, without requiring the force of law. Sadly, that's not always the case.

I completely agree, we need to somehow get rid of all cell phones, so that people can stop with all of the distracted driving for one. Then we can make sure we force folks to eat right, exercise, and get 7-9 hours of sleep a night. No sleep, no car.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by curmudgeon22 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:43AM (#28069950)
I think if the vaccines offered sterilizing immunity, you'd have a much stronger argument. As it is, vaccinated are able to transmit the disease, also putting immunocompromised at risk. That the vaccines appear to lack durable protection is a problem as well IMO. What are the compound impacts of the vaccines if booster shots are required on an annual basis?
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mlang23 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:12AM (#28071440)
> if booster shots are required on an annual basis

Even worse, where I live the current story is a bi-annual renewal!

I will fight this as long as I can. I dont want a dependency like that. Its a socially enforced drug abuse.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by XorNot on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:52PM (#28068839)
So are you vaccinated? I feel like this is the entry question to this argument. And if not, why not?
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mlang23 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:00AM (#28071375)
While we are at it. I also don't care if your bosses mother died or not. Since she is your bosses mother, she likely had an age where death is lurking around the corner anyway.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by FactolSarin on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:51PM (#28077909)
She wasn't retired, so I'd guess in her early 60s and didn't have any other major health issues from what I understand. But I'm glad you laid your cards on the table about not caring. I mean, it was already pretty clear.

Laws exist to protect innocents from people like you.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mlang23 on Friday August 06, 2021 @02:30AM (#28083945)
I am still not impressed. My father died with 39, my aunt with 42, and both my grannies didnt go beyond 70. This was way before corona. Life isnt guaranteed to last for 100 years. Stop fucking over the whole world just because you can not accept that it is finite.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by chaps on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:29PM (#28067775)
Okay, so then you die. Nihilism is your choice, so that's cool I guess. But your post is about you, and only you, fullstop. There are other people out there, despite whatever solipsistic beliefs you have.

With an R0 value of 6, you're statistically likely to infect 6 other people. Why is that acceptable to you?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by timr on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:43PM (#28067885)
> With an R0 value of 6, you're statistically likely to infect 6 other people. Why is that acceptable to you?

Because I have been "statistically likely" to infect N other people every time I had a cold, a flu, or any number of other viruses, most of which are fatal to at least some segment of the population.

Moreover, those N other people can get vaccinated if they're worried about this particular risk. It's a great vaccine. It essentially prevents death from SARS-CoV2. If they don't, that's their choice.

Being alive is risky. You can try to eliminate all of that risk, but you will be dead long before anyone puts you in the grave.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:52PM (#28069249)
Many unvaccinated people don't have a lot of faith in the medical establishment. And if they stayed in when they got sick, then died quietly in their homes, it would be different. But they don't. Once they're sick, they suddenly believe in the miracle of modern medicine again. They fill up the hospitals and drain their community's limited medical resources, leading to excess non-covid deaths. This behavior is widely perceived as selfish and hypocritical, because it is.

Some of their "freedom" is now being stripped away by their vaccinated counterparts, who are growing increasingly impatient and frustrated, and who outnumber them.

This may also be selfish, but at least it's democratic.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by RHSeeger on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:19AM (#28069820)
> Moreover, those N other people can get vaccinated if they're worried about this particular risk. It's a great vaccine. It essentially prevents death from SARS-CoV2. If they don't, that's their choice.

Except for the people that are unable to get it due to a medical condition. Or unable to get it because they're too young. Or able to get it but it didn't work for them.

And then the fact that, as it spreads, it has a chance to mutate, so the more it spreads, the more we have to worry about dangerous variants.

Anyone who chooses not to get the vaccine just because "they don't want to" is putting the rest of society at risk... purely because they're selfish. As far as a lot of us are concerned, that's a pretty horrible type of person to be.

Of course, such people are welcome to not interact with the rest of society (nobody, not even other unvaccinated folks, per risk of mutation); live on farm and grow your own resources, etc. At that point, you're not putting anyone else at risk, so it's no longer selfish. However, I very much doubt many of such people, claiming "it's my body, so I can do what I want" are willing to actually follow through what's required to avoid putting _other people's bodies_ at risk.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by alex_munroe on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:04AM (#28070385)
> Except for the people that are unable to get it due to a medical condition. Or unable to get it because they're too young. Or able to get it but it didn't work for them.

> Of course, such people are welcome to not interact with the rest of society.

People who's bodies are at risk are free to avoid participating in society. Being sick sucks, but doesn't give you the right to force others to do medical procedures in order to protect you.

Yes, in our world, participating in society is often mandatory, and not a choice that you can make. That equally applies to people who are sick, and to the people who don't want to be forced to have things done to their body against their will.

There are many communicable diseases, and many things healthy people can be forced to do in order to protect the sick. The choice whether or not to force them is a tradeoff - safety for the society versus freedom for the individual.

People who value individual freedom more than they value safety are simply making a different tradeoff than you do. At some point, a society designed to minimize the risk at the expense of human freedoms becomes a nightmare to live in.

For example, we could significantly reduce the risk of rapes and murders (especially of vulnerable people) by forcing everyone to wear a bodycam and an ankle bracelet. We don't do that because we have decided that this is not a tradeoff worth making.

On the other hand, we did decide to reduce the risk of people dying from drunk driving, we have sacrificed our freedom to drink and drive for the sake of the safety of the other people on the road.

My point is, where you draw the line is a question of your values. Neither side is being "dumb" or "selfish". Some people value social prosperity and safety and are willing to sacrifice their (and other people's) freedoms to increase it. Others value individual rights and freedoms, and are willing to accept some risks and sacrifice some safety in order to not have these rights taken away.

Society without freedoms is better able to protect the vulnerable, and also the life in such society is less worth living.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by katbyte on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:08AM (#28070757)
“People who are not willing to be vaccinated are free to not participate in society” - argument goes both ways
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by defaultprimate on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:11AM (#28072583)
False equivalence. Actively requiring someone to take an action to participate in society is not the same as someone making a personal risk assessment for themselves and deciding whether or not to participate in society based on that.

Besides, if we go with your standards, those that can't take the vaccine would not be allowed to participate in a mandatory vaccine society anyway. So either they're forced to avoid participating, or they at least have the option to based on a personal assessment.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by RHSeeger on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:21AM (#28072678)
Alternatively, you can look at it as

1. We all go a little out of our way to help those who need help (the sick, those the vaccine doesn't work for, those who cannot get the vaccine for other reasons), OR

2. Some people are selfish and only care about their own self gratification, so are unwilling to sacrifice a tiny bit to help everyone else.

I'll take the society with more 1 and push back on 2.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by defaultprimate on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:02AM (#28073106)
No one knows what the level of sacrifice is, that's the problem. The long term effects of both the virus and the vaccines are unknown.

You're weighing guaranteed exposure to potentially unknown effects vs a non guaranteed risk of contracting the virus.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by RHSeeger on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:54AM (#28074570)
Yes, and I'm weighing it based on various well educated professional (scientists, doctors, etc) putting forth the opinion that it is well worth the risk given the benefit to society as a whole.

Versus a bunch of people that refuse to get the vaccine because ... they feel like they are better able to analyze the facts than those well educated people.

There was literally an interview with a woman on NPR recently who said, "I have grand children, so I'm not getting the vaccine". Like... she thought that having grand children was a reason _not_ to get the vaccine. And she followed it up with "they don't think we're smart enough to make good decisions for our families". Here's the thing; "they" are clearly correct.

I just get so frustrated by this stance of "Science and facts are propaganda; _I_ know better, because I trust my gut. The welfare of society be damned".

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by defaultprimate on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:37PM (#28076085)
The food pyramid, demonization of fats, antibacterial soaps, and countless other examples were touted as "factually beneficial for society" by well educated professionals until there was sufficient data to definitively prove them wrong, and those that challenged them based on the insufficiency of the data were considered "crazy" until they were proved correct.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by RHSeeger on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:28PM (#28077620)
> until there was sufficient data to definitively prove them wrong

Yes, and that's precisely how good analysis and decision making is supposed to work. You're supposed to change your mind when the information you based your decision on changes. That's a _good_ thing.

For any given discussion, given enough people, there will always be a set of people that believe each of the possible things that _can_ be believed. We have people that believe the world is flat. However, the fact that _some_ of those people happened to believe what turned out to be true when the set of input information changed... doesn't make them smarted than everyone else. Unless they were basing their conclusions on a known and defensible set of arguments... it just makes them randomly lucky. You can have a watch to tell time... then ignore it and say it's always 12pm. When it happens to get to 12pm, you'll be right. But you'll still be stupid.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by defaultprimate on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:12PM (#28080684)
lol no, the burden of proof for efficacy and safety is on those pushing the idea. It's perfectly reasonable to reject something based on a lack of, or questionable, empirical evidence.

There's nothing stupid about rejecting "expert consensus" when the data backing the experts doesn't exist.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by katbyte on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:09AM (#28074822)
We know what the efforts of Covid are. I personally know people who have lost their sense of taste, one for over a year and no sign of it coming back and hates cooking/food now - I’ll vaccinate up just to avoid that.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by daddylongstroke on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:14PM (#28082545)
Hope you understand how ridiculous this statement is: "However, I very much doubt many of such people, claiming "it's my body, so I can do what I want" are willing to actually follow through what's required to avoid putting _other people's bodies_ at risk. "

Most people are healthy enough to beat flu, coronaviruses, strep infections, etc. etc. etc. Most people are "good enough" immune-system wise, and are not at all a risk to anybody.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by chaps on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:04PM (#28068059)
You're (intentionally?) leaving out the part where we don't know how the vaccine will pan out as more resistant variants get spread. This great vaccine might not hold, and getting a vaccine now helps prevent that from happening. You talk about choice of vaccine, as if those who get the vaccine have a choice against death.. but as the virus gets resistant, it becomes less and less of a choice.

With your argument standing on the foundation of choice of vaccine+no death vs no vaccine+death, why are you accepting of the fact that lower vaccination rates has a non-trivial chance to strip away the individual choice of life or death of themselves and their loved ones?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by timr on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:17PM (#28068162)
> You're (intentionally?) leaving out the part where we don't know how the vaccine will pan out as more resistant variants get spread. This great vaccine might not hold, and getting a vaccine now helps prevent that from happening.

I don't know a lot of things.

I don't know that I won't die in my sleep. I don't know if I won't walk out the door tomorrow morning and get hit by a taxi. I don't know that I won't get botulism and die from a bad pickle. I don't that I won't choke on that pickle. I don't know if the next SARS variant isn't festering in some pile of bat poop in a Cave in Kunming right now. I don't know that I won't end 2021 in a hospital, dying from some cancer that hasn't yet been diagnosed.

Life is risky. On the spectrum of "things I don't know but worry about", the third-order effects of someone else's personal decisions is pretty far down the list.

...in fact, this risk is way below the risk that other people seem to be actively trying to take away my freedoms on a daily basis, because they're scared of what "might" happen, and want everyone else to live according to their rules.

But yeah, I'm pretty comfortable with my level of protection from SARS-CoV2.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by throwaway675309 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:46PM (#28068370)
I've never heard the willingness to host and incubate a virus to develop further and possibly more infectious variants described as a "freedom".

Just because you're the one smoking, doesn't mean that second hand smoke is harmless.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by technothrasher on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:08PM (#28068521)
> I don't know that I won't get botulism and die from a bad pickle.

Well let me at least put your mind at ease here. The high vinegar content means getting botulism from a pickle is extremely unlikely.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by CamperBob2 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:16PM (#28068560)
The problem is, there are other possible outcomes for a COVID case besides death, hospitalization, and recovery. There is absolutely no reason to think that we understand 100% of what this bug can do. For every uncertainty one might perceive about the "unapproved," "experimental," "insufficiently-tested," or "novel" vaccine, that goes double for the virus itself.

Allowing the virus to propagate freely is asking for trouble in the form of mutations as well. If it had been possible to inoculate the majority of the population in India, for example, we probably wouldn't be dealing with the delta variant right now.

Edit: if a single assertion above is wrong, please reply with citations, and we'll all be that much better-informed for it. Downvoting something that's objectively correct just because it disagrees with your political agenda is the weakest of weak sauce.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by throwawayboise on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:38PM (#28069586)
> There is absolutely no reason to think that we understand 100% of what this bug can do.

If that's true, there's no reason to think that we understand 100% of the long term effects of the novel vaccines for this bug.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by CamperBob2 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:01AM (#28069734)
Well, I (literally) can't argue with that, having just failed spectacularly at attempting to do so.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by 6510 on Friday August 06, 2021 @02:13AM (#28083865)
But you did make a great case for banning unhealthy food and enforcing mandatory exercise. Fewer shorter work days - we have viruses to fight!
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by CamperBob2 on Friday August 06, 2021 @04:47PM (#28092563)
And if the effects of poor diet and exercise were contagious, maybe you'd have a point.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by 6510 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @08:39AM (#28098160)
The eco system is really one giant life form. In a way we are all part of the same organism.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by CamperBob2 on Monday August 09, 2021 @12:08AM (#28112664)
I saw that Star Trek episode too. Seemed like kind of a bummer to be assimilated, although I suppose it wasn't so bad once you got used to the idea.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by guscost on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:25PM (#28069047)
You’re being downvoted for flagrant abuse of the precautionary principle.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by CamperBob2 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:31PM (#28069099)
Interesting... some good food for thought there, because I'm usually vehemently opposed to the precautionary principle. It's good to see HN'ers agreeing with me on that for once.

When it costs us virtually nothing to do the right thing, though, I don't see how the precautionary principle applies. Usually we see that principle come up in arguments over nuclear power, large-scale environmental projects, major technological paradigm shifts, or medical therapies with a real potential for harm. It just doesn't seem to be in play here. Wear a mask in public, exercise reasonable social distancing practices when possible, and get vaccinated with something that has already been used successfully over a billion times. Is that really asking so much?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by guscost on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:35PM (#28069130)
Yes. The harm is mostly psychological, but it is an existential threat to society. You might not agree, but that is my take, and I would bet it is shared by the others who are downvoting you.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by CamperBob2 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:37PM (#28069150)
Yes. The harm is mostly psychological, but it is an existential threat to society. You might not agree, but that is my take.

OK, understood. It's good to see where people are coming from on this subject, even when disagreeing.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by guscost on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:53PM (#28069252)
Thanks for taking the time to read and reply sincerely.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by zapstar on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:50PM (#28067948)
My children are in those “N other people”. They are not yet able to be vaccinated. It is not their choice.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by timr on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:59PM (#28068018)
> My children are in those “N other people”. They are not yet able to be vaccinated. It is not their choice.

The good news is (assuming that they're not immune compromised in a way that would make them vulnerable to a panoply of other viruses) they're at essentially no risk from Covid. The data on this is unassailable:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28041775

The far bigger risk to children, at this point, is panicky parents doing things that negatively impact their psychological well-being.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by fomine3 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:45PM (#28068363)
The article seems to not considering delta variant.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by onecommentman on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:44PM (#28068775)
My understanding is the manufacturers of the “great vaccine” are still immune from liability, at least in the US.

https://www.phe.gov/emergency/events/COVID19/COVIDvaccinator...

“Following the money”, it would seem neither the industry nor the Government share your sanguine view on the vaccines. It would be easy enough to revoke the legal immunity now…it’s been nearly a year and a half since COVID was introduced into US, it’s not the emergency it was in the beginning. Yet I think it is still in place.

If the COVID vaccines are so good, why the failure to accept the typical financial liability that comes with every other medical intervention? There’s a difference between being an anti-vaxxer and an anti-inject-stuff-in-my-arm-without-professional-liability-er. Those who “follow the money” in such things would have reason to be skeptical.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by 360walk on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:32PM (#28068687)
R0 of an infection is the expected number of cases directly generated by one case in a population where all individuals are susceptible to infection.

We are nowhere near all people in a population being susceptible to infection with the vaccine rollout (and the people that are susceptible, it's their choice.)

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by nitrogen on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:45PM (#28067910)
With an R0 value of 6

What is effective R with the mRNA vaccines?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by XorNot on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:46PM (#28068791)
Irrelevant so long as vaccination levels are as low as they are: there's no population where infection starts in a vaccinated person and spreads amongst the vaccinated only that we can reasonably track.

What we do know is that vaccinated people seem to be getting COVID Delta and spreading it to close contacts: but that's a self-selecting the sample too - people who are getting vaccinated are also vastly more likely to take adequate precautions if they get infected.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by guscost on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:49PM (#28067936)
I don’t get “nihilism” from any of that. It is just a healthy attitude about life and death, an attitude that is apparently not even close to universal in our culture.

I can try to understand the other side, but please do the same. Pretty much everyone has been disappointed by humanity this year, and we’re all feeling roughly the same emotions even though we have radically different worldviews.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by chaps on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:22PM (#28068191)
I reread what he wrote and.. yeah, pretty nihilistic still. More-nihilistic-than-not? Hmm. Nah, that's too wordy.

And to point your point back at you, please re-read my post as someone who is trying to understand them. I honestly have no freaking clue why you think otherwise, other than the fact that I disagree with them. I literally asked them a question so that I can understand them better!

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by guscost on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:00PM (#28068890)
> please re-read my post as someone who is trying to understand them.

You may have convinced yourself that this is true, but I don’t believe it. Your comment was mostly passive-aggressive rhetorical sniping:

> Okay, so then you die. Nihilism is your choice, so that's cool I guess. But your post is about you, and only you, fullstop. There are other people out there, despite whatever solipsistic beliefs you have.

And the “question” you ask at the end reads like just another attack:

> Why is that acceptable to you?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by chaps on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:16PM (#28069421)
I'll admit that the first paragraph was passive aggressive. The question, though, was genuine whether you want to believe it or not. This thread's ancestor posters were only sharing rebuttals and not really trying to understand each others' reasoning. My question was in-mind that the OP was only talking about themselves, despite the issue at hand being about other people. The question I asked was written to attempt to get a genuine answer that took into account their own loved ones instead of themselves. I was hoping for a genuine answer, and I believe that they responded genuinely, even though I disagree with them.

You gotta understand, friend.. what I think is at stake here are the lives of the people that I love. With that in mind, the seemingly callous disregard of even their own loved ones is... a difficult thing to parse. So again, please try to read my words from the perspective of someone who's desperately frustrated, and at least attempting to figure out why someone is explicitly okay with knowing that their actions will get others killed.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by nradov on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:49PM (#28067934)
What is the specific acceptable level of risk to expose others to? Please quantify, and show your work. If you're criticizing others on that basis then there must be a quantitative limit.

And note that the limit can't be 0. Real life always involves some risk.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by noduerme on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:26PM (#28068214)
We just need to look at what society and the law have determined is acceptable risk for one individual to put others at. Driving a car puts others in danger, but not as much as driving drunk or recklessly. Being both unvaxed and unmasked is unnecessarily reckless toward others, simply because one such spreader can put exponentially more people in danger than any single drunk driver.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by jedmeyers on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:37AM (#28070579)
> Being both unvaxed and unmasked is unnecessarily reckless toward others

Mandating an unapproved novel 'vaccine' while removing all responsibility from the manufacturers for the side effects is extremely reckless toward others.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by noduerme on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:59AM (#28071064)
Really, if you look at the history of this vaccine, it's the complete opposite of reckless. It was a great technology that had been in progress for years and was essentially held back by too much government regulation. Solving a vaccine for this virus within days was an incredible outcome of American soft power capitalism, and letting the free market pursue a profit. That's why the Bernie/communist crowd are so desperately eager to force Moderna and Pfizer to hand over the patents. How dare we invest in and make something so successful and lifesaving for some reason as ugly as profit. Remember, loosening responsibility is the norm and the ethos for a capitalist society. And the only people asking to see a vax card are private enterprises. It's good news all around, good for the economy. It's only bad for the mentally crippled who are so mired in conspiratorial thought that they can't see what's obviously good for themselves. But no one's ever going to make you get it. I just think we should turn the wilfully unvaxed away from the hospital when you get covid. Why should we pay for your mistakes?
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by guscost on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:12PM (#28068973)
I’m a member of society, and I (along with many others) believe that we are way across the acceptable boundary between my individual rights and the risk everyone else should bear.

What do we do now? Do we need to fight a war to decide who gets things their way? There won’t be any real winners in such an event.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by lmm on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:33PM (#28068696)
> Being both unvaxed and unmasked is unnecessarily reckless toward others, simply because one such spreader can put exponentially more people in danger than any single drunk driver.

Worst possible case regardless of likelihood is not a good metric. I'll bet the average drunk driver, and indeed the average sober driver, causes many more deaths than the average unvaxed unmasked person in a post-vaccination world.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by greycol on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:02AM (#28069738)
You'd bet wrong 1.3 million traffic deaths in a year. double it to 2.6 m for 2 years.

In the 2 years of covid we have had 4.25 million deaths with still 90% us and 97% of the rest of the world left to catch it.

You only need a unmasked person to have an R value 1.64 times higher than a vaxed/masked for the proportional deaths to not reach parity even with 90% people vacinated.

That's completely ignoring the fact that driving is actually a productive activity with a goal. Where as most of the reasons people give for not wearing a mask are either easily debunked or work just as well as a retort to someone asking you "why are you continuously punching yourself?".

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by nradov on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:05AM (#28069755)
Where are you getting 90%? The CDC estimates that 36% of Americans have been infected.

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burd...

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by greycol on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:46AM (#28069963)
WHO confirmed cases so using your numbers that does change it to just another 1.2 million dead americans assuming no change in death rate due to other strains the vaccine rather than another 5.5 million.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by zekica on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:54AM (#28070322)
And you are assuming that the next variants will be more deadly.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by noduerme on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:05AM (#28071090)
>> That's completely ignoring the fact that driving is actually a productive activity with a goal

And most antivaxers and the unmasked are welfare cases with nothing to do but look at reddit, and so are a burden on the state and a direct cost to me as a taxpayer even when there isn't a pandemic. Hey, maybe this will work out great in the end.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by lmm on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:41AM (#28069939)
> In the 2 years of covid we have had 4.25 million deaths

And how many of those were of fully vaccinated people?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by greycol on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:50AM (#28069985)
If we have 100 people responsible for a bad thing happening to 10 people in that group that is proportionally the same as 10 people being responsible for a bad thing happening to 1 person in that group and having 90 unrelated people to the side when we are divvying up blame.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by lmm on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:56AM (#28070018)
Yes and no; if you're accusing unvaccinated-by-choice people of recklessly endangering others, then it's quite different whether they're endangering random other people or only other unvaccinated-by-choice people. (Similarly I have no problem with drivers on private car-only roads, only those who endanger pedestrians and cyclists on the public roads).

Also the dynamics of how far any given infection would spread are very different in a post-vaccination world.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by greycol on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:07AM (#28070082)
Sure now your only recklessly endangering those who can't get vaccinated and those who opt in. So maybe at steady state the numbers do work out in favour of it being less dangerous than driving proportionally(excluding the people who opt in to this danger). But you realise we're talking about driving, an activity that actually accomplishes something, as opposed to not getting vaccinated which accomplishes at most nothing. If driving accomplished nothing you can bet you wouldn't be able to do it in the city were you are involving others it'd be relegated to tracks.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by noduerme on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:09AM (#28071114)
Technically, I was talking about drunk driving, which kills a lot fewer people than (productive) driving. That's why I selected the limited case of people who innocently die because of a driver's wilful negligence, which is exponentially fewer than those who die because of antivaxers' wilful negligence. Probably even when there isn't a pandemic with an R6 replication rate.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by noduerme on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:40PM (#28069601)
In a post-vaccination world, you'd be exactly correct. And no one is advocating for a permanent mask mandate. But in the present world, where large sectors of the population are not vaxed, the likelihood of an unvaxed spreader killing someone versus a drunk driver, for any individual on any given night, is probably equal or greater.

I'll admit something. I happen to love driving twice the speed limit after a few drinks. Feels great. And I indulge that sometimes on country roads when there's no one around. I know I'm a better driver after a few beers than most people are sober. If it were up to me, there would be a test, and a rating on my license that let me drive with a higher BAC than other people. But you know what? My personal pleasure isn't worth the damage of taking someone's life, or of entitling everyone else in society to do the same. So, on the whole, it's obviously better that it's illegal. Even though it infringes on my personal freedom and pursuit of happiness.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by nradov on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:52PM (#28069677)
In the US, all of the at-risk population who wants to be vaccinated has been. The only people who can't get vaccinated are children under 12, and they are at virtually zero risk.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by noduerme on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:58PM (#28069710)
Yes, but the at-risk who don't want to be vaccinated are soaking up enormous resources, including hospital beds and doctors and nurses that should be attending people with other health emergencies. Moreover they're a breeding ground for variants that can evade the vaccine. And beyond that, even if they only kill each other, how is that okay?
[dead]
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by desine on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:26PM (#28068215)
There's risks outside of infectious disease modeling. I'm not sure you understand the counterpoint they were making.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by chaps on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:36PM (#28068291)
Because their question is a strawman towards something I wasn't attempting to understand. I can see where they're coming from with their question, but that's a whole different discussion. Like, if you want to have a discussion about why me riding a motorcycle is dangerous to myself and others, let's do that. But it's a different question and not relevant to a pandemic.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by 2muchcoffeeman on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:13AM (#28069794)
I am willing to balance the risk of never having a normal life again with an overall risk of illness and death that is on par with every other year I have been alive.

It’s not about you. It’s never about you. There are plenty of people who cannot legitimately get vaccinated. Since these people have no choice to get the vaccine, then your rights to choose for yourself are rightly curtailed.

I’m always curious about these arguments. Why do you think your rights are superior to the rights of others?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by tekromancr on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:57PM (#28069277)
That's a bit dramatic, no? The proposal is wear masks and get a needle in your sholder, we aren't putting people in concentration camps here.

I see it as on par with indoor smoking bans and seatbelts. You are giving up a relatively small degree of freedom in order to stop a highly contagious, highly mutable virus; and yes, to protect people who aren't you.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by yezr on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:28PM (#28069081)
You're not being asked to give up your basic human rights though. What you are being asked to do is to get a free, readily available vaccine that will protect you and others from current and future harm.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by logicchains on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:07AM (#28070074)
>What you are being asked to do is to get a free, readily available vaccine that will protect you and others from current and future harm.

A vaccine that also has a known chance of causing current harm, and an unknown chance of causing future harm.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by natchy on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:19AM (#28070464)
> a free, readily available vaccine

Nothing is free. How much did pharma companies make from the vaccine? I don’t know the answer.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by res0nat0r on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:48AM (#28073679)
Everyone here has never been able to go to school in the usa since they were kids unless they proved they were vaccinated against the standard diseases we've been giving out shots against for decades. Same goes for most high education too.

It's just become "a thing" now thanks to the rightwing using it as another way to aggravate their base, and thanks to "experts" who have an internet connection and think they know more than epidemiologists.

Unless these steps are taken this will never end and the daily hassles will be worse and go on longer for everyone.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by fumar on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:21PM (#28069019)
Sure, self preservation or self preference first. I get that. What about empathy to frail or at risk people? What about people on cancer treatments that diminish their immune systems? Those people even vaccinated may be at higher risk.

Are you saying that the greater good in overall societal health is less valuable than your individual preferred method of existence? Genuinely curious.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by maxerickson on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:34PM (#28068707)
You don't have a basic human right to go into buildings that other people own.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by fredros on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:55AM (#28070679)
But you have the right to invite people into buildings you own, right ?
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by maxerickson on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:07AM (#28072107)
Certainly not an absolute one. For example, fire codes typically have occupancy limits that prioritize public safety over the desires of owners and patrons.

(There's a stronger argument for refusing a vaccine being an absolute right)

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by prepend on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:44PM (#28068777)
You do if they are open to the public. We once lived in a country where people were banned from entering buildings based on the color of their skin.

If I run a private public space I shouldn’t (and can’t) discriminate arbitrarily on who can enter.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by maxerickson on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:07PM (#28068934)
Places open to the public can almost arbitrarily ask people to leave (at which point their presence becomes trespassing), they just can't ask people to leave for being members of protected classes.

So if I don't like what your t-shirt says, that's all it takes.

And for instance, Walmart doesn't have to open to the public tomorrow just because they opened to the public today.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by filoeleven on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:22PM (#28069023)
> private public space

Please explain further what that means.

Also please explain how setting restrictions on use of the space based on conduct, such as being vaccinated or not, is more arbitrary than, say, a dress code.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by albedoa on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:19PM (#28069010)
> If I run a private public space I shouldn’t (and can’t) discriminate arbitrarily on who can enter.

You actually can. It might help the discussion for you to tell us where you picked up this idea.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by timdev2 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:17PM (#28069427)
Discrimination is largely legal. You absolutely can discriminate on any characteristic you like, with several well defined exceptions (such as race or sex).
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by acituan on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @06:26PM (#28067249)
> The threat from the virus is not only immediate risk to the individual, it is also further transmissions increasing the risk of creating new breakthrough variants

> Tolerating disease spread and threats to vulnerable populations when vaccines are available that are practically risk-free (or the risk being magnitudes smaller than the payoff) is ridiculous

Those are very different justifications with very different policy implications, it is best not to conflate the two.

If breakthrough variants was the major concern (and it should have been) vaccine rollout should have been fast in addition to very high percentages, and vaccinated/unvaccinated population mix should have been minimized with policy. Anything less gives the perfect arena for evolutionary algorithm to learn its way around the vaccine immunity.

Second issue is the fading immunity of current vaccines in comparison to natural immunity. Vaccines got disproportionate attention and funding at the expense of covid treatment bets, which would have helped with developing higher natural immunity levels. To what degree conflicts of interests due to EUA play in this, we don’t know. But once booster shots enter the “mandatory” territory, that will cause an additional drop in compliance. How many boosters can we really mandate, for how many years?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by freeone3000 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:39PM (#28067865)
How in the world could vaccine rollout have been any faster? This is the fastest a vaccination program has ever been run, for anything, ever. We're at 60% population vaccination after SIX MONTHS, which is absolutely insane -- polio was slower, and they were allowed jet injectors! Vaccination is going as fast as possible, and policy was implemented to minimize all mixing of people, not just Vax/unvax.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by acituan on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:57PM (#28068876)
You misunderstand the problem.

We’re not talking about the total vaccination rate; it is a matter of how diffuse or concentrated it had to be for a particular locale to minimize variant training. Obviously it brings up questions of fairness thus was avoided by politicians.

> Vaccination is going as fast as possible, and policy was implemented to minimize all mixing of people, not just Vax/unvax.

It was a lofty aspiration but wasn’t/hasn’t been good enough. We could have had different levels of strictness from the beginning when lifting lockdowns, instead of going a full open and betting on a no variant scenario, instead of now with too late of an attempt, which will anger people and won’t be likely to work well.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:11AM (#28070110)
Please cite a recent source that natural immunity is better/longer lasting.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by zekica on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:12AM (#28070424)
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:48AM (#28072940)
That study (at least the abstract) does not support your contention.

It makes the case that previously infected individuals do not need to be prioritised for vaccination, not that natural immunity is better than vaccine driven immunity.

Perhaps you shared the wrong paper?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by spirodonfl on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:42PM (#28077023)
Perhaps you misread the paper? You cherry picked a portion of the abstract and made it seem like that conclusion was made. Here, let me help you:

"Conclusions: Individuals who have had SARS-CoV-2 infection are unlikely to benefit from COVID-19 vaccination, and vaccines can be safely prioritized to those who have not been infected before."

You can prioritize those who have not been infected before BECAUSE those who HAVE been infected are unlikely to see a benefit in vaccinating to begin with.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by disgruntledphd2 on Friday August 06, 2021 @03:11AM (#28084161)
Your point was that natural immunity was better than vaccine induced immunity. The paper does not support this contention.

Like, I'm academically interested in this, and I know how easy it is to share the wrong paper, hence my final comment.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by bingohbangoh on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @06:12PM (#28067104)
Won’t there always be a variant popping up somewhere in some part of the world though?

The idea that “if we all got vaccinated, we could have zero variants” reeks of “zero COVID” thinking

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by datameta on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @06:29PM (#28067276)
More unvaccinated people -> more people getting covid -> more chances for mutation into variants

It's really that simple. We want as few active infections as possible globally so that existing vaccinations can work for the variants they were made in mind with. Otherwise we will be at the disadvantage in a perpetual arms race trying to quickly stamp out the global "fires" of new variants.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by zarzavat on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:32PM (#28067799)
If you actually want that, then you need some kind of megaproject to build vaccine factories to supply the entire world and to distribute them to the whole world's population. This virus doesn't respect borders.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by monocasa on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:44PM (#28067894)
Yes in fact, that's the core of what a lot of people have been wanting by trying to get an IP waiver from the WTO. You don't even need new factories, as there's tons of factories out there that are itching to make the various vaccines.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by vimy on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:29PM (#28068230)
It was my understanding that the developing world doesn’t have the required infrastructure nor qualified workers to manufacture the complex covid vaccines. So the whole patent point is moot.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by monocasa on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:32PM (#28068258)
Your understanding is incorrect, hence the ongoing process for the WTO waiver. Even the mRNA vaccines aren't that crazy, it's a culture of e. coli that's been genetically engineered to produce the vaccines; the manufacturing steps themselves are pretty run of the mill bio reactor stuff with slightly more stringent temperature controls on the tail end. The non mRNA vaccines are pretty much equivalent to any other standard vaccine.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by hcurtiss on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:26PM (#28069487)
With an IP waiver, you make it less likely you'll have a vaccine for the next one, defeating the entire purpose.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by monocasa on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:32PM (#28069539)
No you don't; the vaccines were funded almost entirely with public money anyway.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by hcurtiss on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:36AM (#28069918)
Their manufacture was. The mRNA research was a huge private bet (after some companies had given up).
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by monocasa on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:25PM (#28076792)
The largest source of Moderna's R&D funding was nearly $1B in grants from the US Government.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by shaklee3 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:07AM (#28070080)
This has already happened. There's a world organization distributing millions of vaccines, and soon billions.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by AuryGlenz on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:28PM (#28067765)
In a world where the delta variant can infect fully vaccinated people fairly easily, aren’t the vaccinated the real problem? The unvaccinated aren’t putting any particular pressure on the virus when it comes to evolving around the vaccines, but the vaccinated are.

Unless we could magically get the cases to zero this problem isn’t going away. Mask mandates will slow things, but eventually you’ll need enough people to actually get infected to drop the replication rate.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by XorNot on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:59PM (#28068882)
This is incredibly wrong.

Evolution is incremental. To become vaccine evading, the virus has to have a host it can replicate it, and a host that is a resistant target.

In fact it needs a big pool of them, since once infected develop immunity they no longer produce trial mutations.

So you need a pool of the unvaccinated, coming into frequently, regular contact with the vaccinated in order for any specific vaccine escape to evolve.

This is because, any incremental improvement needs to become a population dominant strain within the unvaccinated population: that you survived in a vaccinated person for a little bit is irrelevant if at the end of the day every virus with that trait dies without spreading.

Even if you successfully do spread from a vaccinated host, you need to either land in another vaccinated host (who then spreads you around: so isolation measures are effective), and while you're doing this you need to develop a better escape system: not guaranteed, because if overall viral loading or time to immunity is shorter, that's less time to generate variants.

But...a good way to optimize this, is to just spread to a pool of unvaccinated people. With luck you retain the vaccine-escape mutations, become dominant within the unvaccinated pool, and then get lots of opportunities to try and infect vaccinated people and get a little further.

This, incidentally, why viral evolution tends to consist of "the virus jumped between species several times" - because crossing a species barrier requires ongoing persistent contact between a host you can replicate it, and one you're trying to cross over into.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by AuryGlenz on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:46PM (#28076221)
Right, but aren't you assuming that the delta variant can't go from vaccinated to vaccinated effectively? I don't think we really have solid data on this yet but it seems possible, at the very least.

If that is happening, and the R0 from vaccinated to vaccinated is above 1, aren't we creating immense evolutionary pressure to defeat the current vaccines?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by foolinaround on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:17PM (#28068993)
> To become vaccine evading, the virus has to have a host it can replicate it, and a host that is a resistant target.

Can you please explain more?

Why can't both hosts A and B both be vaccinated folks?

Is'nt there a 3rd category - those who have immunity via past infection? How do it work in that case?

---

If what you say above is correct, then why do we see new strains in flu?

Has'nt pretty much every person on earth been exposed to flu or vaccinated against it?

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by XorNot on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:35AM (#28072809)
If host A and B are both vaccinated, then either the virus has achieved vaccine escape (it is spreading amongst the vaccinated population effectively), or if it hasn't then it still dies out.

If 1 vaccinated person infects another say 3, but then those people fail to infect anyone else - then it doesn't actually matter what selective advantages that viral strain had - 100% of the virus has died out.

But if the same chain terminates in the vaccinated people then infecting an unvaccinated person...then the new mutation escapes and potentially becomes dominant within the reservoir (unvaccinated people) and a failure to spread through the vaccinated population doesn't lead to the destruction of the mutant strain.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by foolinaround on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:03AM (#28073113)
thank you for explaining this. Is there some literature that provides a reasonably clear explanation ( ELI5) around this.

the next question is what happens to those with acquired immunity, and why are they being forced to be vaccinated?

I see many studies that show that their levels of antibodies seem to be even better than ones from the vaccines.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by geedy on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:09PM (#28068096)
Variants occur in both unvaccinated and the vaccinated.

Given enough time, a virus will tend evolve to become more infectious period.

Somebody else could confirm this, but it seems to me that the current known variants of concern are not responses to vaccination.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by johncearls on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:39PM (#28068743)
Only the vaccinated will preferentially evolve variants that are resistant to the vaccine. The vaccines are leaky, as evidenced by the recent outbreak in the Northeast. A saner strategy with leaky vaccines is to vaccinate the small population that is vulnerable and let the rest of the population of develop a natural herd immunity. Otherwise you are creating a fitness advantage to resistant strains.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by XorNot on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:07PM (#28068937)
This is not how it works, and "natural" herd immunity has never been a real concept in epidemiology - which it is clear you are speculating on without bothering to read about but should also be trivially obvious from the fact that until vaccines none of the vaccine preventable diseases ever went extinct on their own.

Or how the flu hits every single year.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by johncearls on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:36PM (#28069140)
> Herd immunity is a form of indirect protection from infectious disease that can occur with some diseases when a sufficient percentage of a population has become immune to an infection, whether through vaccination or previous infections, thereby reducing the likelihood of infection for individuals who lack immunity.

Right from wikipedia.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by XorNot on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:02AM (#28069737)
Yes, and wikipedia is not the study of epidemiology.

Epidemiology as a field did not publish papers or study the idea of "natural" herd immunity till last year when politicians started throwing the term around and a whole lot of researcher's scrambled to see whether this insanity had any merit.

Of which the answer is what we already knew just spelled out more specifically: no, this doesn't actually happen in the wild without vaccines, because it's literally just spreading the virus. Viruses burn themselves out after infecting basically everyone, provided immunity is long lasting.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by manwe150 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:34PM (#28069552)
It is misleading though, since this definition is merely ‘flattening the curve’ for the rest of human life, and accepting the increased death rate every year. By contrast, a successful vaccination effort also ‘flattens the curve,’ but additionally substantially reduces the rate of deaths. The latter is what we have observed happen with high confidence in the vaccinated population for COVID: deaths of vaccinated individuals is much less common than for unvaccinated (back of napkin math seems to currently be somewhere between 100-1000 to 1 across most age ranges)
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by AuryGlenz on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:41PM (#28076138)
I don't think when people talked about herd immunity they meant that the coronavirus would be wiped out, just that it'd get the replication rate down to a manageable level. Just like those diseases that vaccines wiped out, the young would always be at risk of being infected. In this case though, the young (babies excepted) are also fairly protected from it getting serious.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by Barrin92 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:03PM (#28067565)
the dynamic is a feedback loop in either direction. More vaccinations means slowdown of spread which means slower rate of mutation and in turn easier ways to control the virus. Faster transmission means faster rate of mutations and having a harder time controlling the virus.

'Zero covid' or near-zero covid anyway does not 'reek' because it is perfectly attainable. The virus could be squashed pretty much completely. The fact that we cannot do it is the result of institutionalized failure, resignation and normalization of dysfunction, not actually a matter of fact.

We have in fact eradicated one highly transmittable, airborne virus through a global vaccination effort already, namely smallpox. And that was almost half a century ago.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by sokoloff on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:35PM (#28067819)
Haven’t we seen several recent papers suggesting animal reservoirs for the virus? If those papers are correct, it seems that elimination from the Earth is never going to happen (well, it’ll happen when the sun turns into a red giant).
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by mdorazio on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:54PM (#28068431)
> We have in fact eradicated one highly transmittable, airborne virus through a global vaccination effort already, namely smallpox. And that was almost half a century ago.

Exactly. It was half a century ago when the global population was half what it is today and travel (especially international) was massively lower as well. Also Smallpox had a much lower mutation rate than COVID does, and it's not transmissable until obvious symptoms develop (much different than COVID). Thinking the same strategy would work today is kind of a pipe dream.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by curmudgeon22 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:57AM (#28070027)
A core difference is the smallpox vaccine had/has sterilizing immunity while the covid vaccines do not. I think given non-sterilizing immunity and the rate and scale of global vaccine roll outs, zero covid is virtually impossible.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by lionhead on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:39AM (#28069926)
>The virus could be squashed pretty much completely.

In Korea, we tried, succeeded for a couple of weeks, then failed.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by Taniwha on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:34AM (#28070564)
Think about the end game here - we have evidence of ~4 covid viruses that have adapted to humans, one of which may have been responsible for an epidemic a couple of 100 years ago. Now days they are relatively benign, they make up part of what we call "the common cold".

This is historical evidences that covid viruses in humans evolve to become relatively benign, likely this happens faster if we let it kill more people more quickly, but, well, modern medicine. So what will it take for the current covid variant to reach this state - we'll need it to evolve a benign version that out competes the current covid-delta .

A benign version of a virus that out competes its more lethal cousins is something that we also call a "live vaccine".

So why shouldn't we help it along? if we know it's going to happen naturally why not make it happen faster? past attempts to generate live vaccines have mostly worked but have not always gone well, but they were made with technologies that essentially consisted of whacking them with a mallet and hoping they would stay dead - the mRNA vaccines are much more like engineering. Why not take an existing relatively benign vaccine and fit it out with a protein coat similar enough to C19 and release that?

Obviously this is not something one would do blindly, it would require lots of testing, especially with immunocompromised people. And testing (without releasing it early) would be hard - tested people would need to remain in lockdown.

Of course the crazy anti-vaxxers would scream bloody blue murder - but given that their current propaganda already paints the current vaccines as "live vaccines" and warns people to stay away from the vaccinated that horse would seem to have already bolted

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by foolinaround on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:11PM (#28068964)
This point needs to be stated more loudly.

People here pretend that if only USA was 100% vaccinated, then there will not be another variant.

There will always be another part of the world where a variant will arise, and eventually make its way here to the US.

OTOH, the USA is unique in the freedom it offers compared to any other country in the world, and a key ingredient in my opinion to its success.

One of the most shocking aspects to me is how the US citizens have changed to so nonchalantly willing to give away their freedoms and those of their neighbours.

I would not have believed if someone told me this 2 years ago.

And in the past years, I had often wondered about the 'good' Germans during the time of the Nazis, and why they did'nt first lift a finger when the atrocities against the Jews started, and later, a good number of them actively participated in elimination of the Jews.

the last year has been quite an eye opener. My hope is that more US citizens, regardless of their political persuasions and belief about the vaccines step back and think about the uniqueness of the freedoms they enjoy, and their willingness to throw it all away.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by xxpor on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:23AM (#28069846)
Most people's moral framework isn't deontological, fortunately for everyone.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by logicchains on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:09AM (#28070095)
And that's why governments managed to kill over a hundred million people in the past century, because they convinced people it was for some "Greater good".
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by xxpor on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:52PM (#28076309)
A completely separate problem. If you're not grounded in reality, it doesn't matter if you're operating in a deontological or consequentialist mode. You can justify bad outcomes with either.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by katbyte on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:16AM (#28070803)
Are you comparing vaccines and masks to genocide?
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by foolinaround on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:59AM (#28073068)
Are you intentionally missing the point?

The mindset of fear that is inculcated that pits one group against another is the similarity that starts it off.

1940s Germany: Germans were convinced that Jews were the outer, not deserving of protection

20th century communism, too many examples - China, Russia, Cambodia, etc : Different classes - writers, teachers, scientists were identified as the outer group, and hate was inculcated

Today's scenario: the 'unvaccinated' are made as the other group.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by Anthony-G on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:19AM (#28074073)
That’s not a particularly good analogy. The persecution of the Jews by Nazis was based on immutable characteristics (such as whether or not one’s grandparents were Jewish). Likewise, if you had built a career as an intellectual, teacher or urban professional in Phnom Penh in the 1970s, you couldn’t suddenly turn around and pretend to be a peasant to avoid persecution. Even being short-sighted and wearing glasses was enough to be marked as an enemy of the Khmer Rouge regime.

Choosing not to be vaccinated is not an immutable characteristic. It’s a behavioural choice and a better analogy would be choosing to drink and drive – behaviour that is rightly frowned upon by most of society.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by foolinaround on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:22PM (#28076739)
'Drinking and driving' is not a good analogy either.

There is no one that argues that 'drinking and driving' is good for anyone at all.

OTOH, regarding vaccines, there are so many different human conditions, side effects and issues seen with vaccines that it is fair to be skeptical.

The other big factor is the time that has elapsed, and different folks have different levels of comfort.

All of this being brushed aside - to identify a group of folks to crush -- is the evil being discussed.

---

that they are immutable or not is quibbling, in my opinion.

Using the Khmer Rouge, the system decapitated the intellectuals not because they are learned, but because they had the ability to think and decide for themselves.

Now, in the US, I argue, that people who chose to think differently are being targeted, with the carrot being provided that they can change...

Is this not coercion? There is a line between persuasion and coercion, and very clearly, it has been crossed.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by wppick on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:45PM (#28068358)
> Public health resources are limited. Unnecessary Covid hospitalizations cause immense opportunity cost in the form of crowding out care and driving costs. Which in many cases other sick people and the public will have to carry.

We have already decided as a society that individual choice outranks the cost to the health system. See obesity, smoking cigarettes, drinking alcohol, workaholic culture with very limited vacation days, etc

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by apostacy on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:35AM (#28072813)
Ask yourself if you would be ok submitting your photo ID, proof of citizenship, and phone's unique ID in any of the settings that the mandate will cover.

Do you honestly think they will dismantle it one day? Especially if Apple is making it so easy for them.

For the record, no I don't think I should have to present my ID to get a Metrocard or ride a train. I do think that is oppressive. Because by that point they will have intruded into our lives way too much.

NY state has been encroaching for years. They have been fantasizing about a "no ride" list for Amtrak.

And many officials have invited the TSA and ICE to set up surprise mobile checkpoints for commuters at bus terminals.

All under the justification of protecting us from terrorism.

This is just the thin edge of a wedge to expand their control over us. And yes, most of them do want more power and money, and our civil liberties stand in the way of that.

[1]: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/train-security-is-a-no-ride-lis... [2]: https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2011/06/tsa-swarms-8000...

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by swayvil on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @06:13PM (#28067118)
He says : It's irrational. It's intrusive. It's over-reach.

You reply : But the threat is so great that such is justified.

I have heard this dialog before.

Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by colordrops on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:24PM (#28067741)
The flu virus can and has mutated in the past to become extremely deadly (see 1918). Why is it different this time? Why should it be treated differently than the flu, when it comes to variants? I think everyone should get vaccinated, but I want to fill in all logical holes to help this debate.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by pklausler on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:36PM (#28067826)
This time, we've got effective vaccines.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by colordrops on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:04PM (#28068490)
I don't follow - are you saying that the flu vaccine shouldn't be mandated because it's not effective, and if there was an effective one, it should be mandated?
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by pklausler on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:43PM (#28079497)
I'm saying that we have effective vaccines in 2021 against COVID-19 but we did not have effective vaccines in 1918 against influenza.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings by colordrops on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:27PM (#28080117)
You misunderstood what I was saying. I'm not talking about 1918. Covid vaccines are being pushed to tamp down breakthrough variants. There is also as much risk of a deadly breakthrough variant of the flu right now. My point of bringing up 1918 is to show that deadly flu breakthrough variants are possible. Considering that this is still the case in 2021, should we mandate flu vaccines as well, right now? If not, the argument for mandating covid vaccines is inconsistent.