Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings
by wwweston on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:09PM
(#28077378)
The precedents you're invoking as fearsome are scattered over a century old, some older. Past vaccination requirements have been examined and upheld -- all without leading to an overwhelming push to eliminate general autonomy.
So the idea that "it is clear what direction it will ultimately go" is... kinda correct, actually. It is clear that general autonomy can remain a valued principle with specific exceptions. It is clear that they are the exceptions rather than the norm. And that the pull in the other direction isn't weak.
Re:NYC to mandate proof of vaccination for many indoor settings
by forcry on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:47PM
(#28078630)
> It is clear that general autonomy can remain a valued principle with specific exceptions.
Sure. It is the ever increasing number of "specific exceptions" that people should be worried about.
If there are, that should be the exceptions, rather than the norm.
Also, the parent asked if there won't be "pushes". So the implication is that there will be an overwhelming push in that direction, and very weak countering "pull" in the opposite direction.
And it is clear what direction it will ultimately go. So that is the danger in setting a precedent. So that further pushes in a "bad" direction will require much less effort, and only matter of time it is accepted to be the "new normal"..