News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by PascLeRasc on Monday April 26, 2021 @07:48PM (#26949806)
I really, really wish I could opt out of having accounts with the big 3 credit bureaus. Freezes don’t appear to work - they usually say that I don’t have an active freeze whenever I go to lift one. Or their website is down entirely. Or they won’t let me get to the freeze section without clicking no on their paid monitoring services 8 times. For Transunion all I needed to lift a freeze was the last 4 of my SSN, so how does that help?

I don’t want to have my information with these companies. Please let me not participate. It’s like every American was given a Chase Bank account at birth that we can’t close, it’s weird.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by anyfoo on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:04PM (#26950460)
As someone who grew up in Europe and lives in the US now, the whole "credit" thing is still weird to me anyway. In Germany at least, credit cards are mostly only a thing because they are convenient to pay with online, and then often behave like debit cards (paying directly from your bank account) anyway.

Everyday shopping happens with debit cards, bills are paid by wiring money.

When I came here, I "built credit" by paying everything by credit card and making sure to pay off the entire bill immediately to not incur any interest penalty, but when I read stuff like "always pay off the credit card with the highest APR first", my head's still spinning.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by paxys on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:45PM (#26951765)
Credit cards in the USA are backed by very strong consumer protection laws. That is why you can mindlessly give one to wait staff at a restaurant who will disappear with it for an extended amount of time, while in any other country that would be unimaginable. I have also never once cared about credit card skimmers at gas stations or anything of the sort. It's the bank's responsibility to protect the card, not my own.

Consumer culture in general means that it is very profitable for banks and payment processors to hand out credit cards like candy (with huge spending incentives), despite knowing that a ton of people are going to rack up debt that they will never be able to pay.

The overall credit system is also a lot larger than just credit cards. The country runs on cheap debt. Everything from houses, education, cars all the way to TVs and dresses is financed with long-term payments and low single digit interest rates. Most of what people earn goes towards paying for stuff they bought in the past rather than saving for something they might buy later.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ryandrake on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:49AM (#26952119)
If you want to understand the USA or figure out why something here is the way it is, the answer is usually "because it lets corporations extract the most money out of regular people." Everything, from seemingly odd little cultural quirks to enormous institutions like how we do health care, systems that were deliberately designed and things that emerged organically: everything is the way it is because it optimizes wealth transfer from ordinary people to corporations. That's usually the most straightforward explanation.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by unityByFreedom on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:41AM (#26952783)
Giving loans is a good thing. With them, as the comment above yours points out, people finance education, cars, and homes that they can afford to pay off later due to having a higher salary than before.

Predatory loans are bad and governments do try to crack down on those. Going from "it's easy to get credit in the US" to "the US lets corporations steal from regular people" is a bit much.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by yrro on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:22AM (#26954101)
On the other hand, the abundance of credit has driven up the prices of education, cars, homes, etc.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Caprinicus on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:51AM (#26954270)
Car prices in America are among the lowest in the developed world though. It’s difficult to compare education as you’re getting a wildly different product depending on what specific university you go to.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ntwalker on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:08AM (#26954369)
They pretty much have to be. The infrastructure of the US is such that if cars cost what they do in Europe then a massive section of the population would be entirely locked out of the economy unable to hold a job.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by TapWaterBandit on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:26PM (#26964761)
You've got this backwards.

1. The average American is considerably wealthier than the average European.

2. Cars are so expensive in Europe relative to America due to regulations/taxes/etc which are applied by governments (the alleged protectors of the people's welfare).

3. You've got causation backwards in regards to infrastructure, the US infrastructure is the way it is BECAUSE cars are cheaper, cars aren't cheap due to the needs of infrastructure.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by klmadfejno on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:25AM (#26956270)
When people need something, prices tend to go up, not down.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dmos62 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:33AM (#26953468)
I somewhat agree with what you said, but I think you sidestepped the intriguing question of why so many people in US seem to use credit.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by unityByFreedom on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:53AM (#26954698)
I don't think I sidestepped it. People use credit to better themselves because they can. Maybe you are asking why more capital is available to lend and I think that's a good question.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by leetcrew on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:02AM (#26954341)
time value of money and capital gains tax make it less efficient to pay cash for large purchases. why don't people in the rest of the world use credit?
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by xwdv on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:14AM (#26954415)
Money now is worth more than money later, why is that a hard concept to understand?
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dmos62 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:02AM (#26955272)
For one, I've never felt that way. If I were a business, that might be different.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by leetcrew on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:36AM (#26956447)
would you be indifferent to whether your employer paid you at the end of a pay period versus six months later?
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dmos62 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @11:03AM (#26956866)
Fair point.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by xwdv on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:52PM (#26958463)
That’s why you’ve never felt that way.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dmos62 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:43PM (#26960536)
I don't know what you mean.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by watwut on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:22AM (#26966675)
There is something wrong about punishing people who don't want loans, however. And making it necessary to have or use credit card, so that you build up your credit score in a maze of rule, despite you consistently being able to pay with debit card or cash is exactly that.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @11:26AM (#26970459)
They aren't being punished by not using credit cards, they're just choosing not to avail themselves of the benefits of using credit cards.

If you pay your bill every month, then a credit card is like a debit card plus benefits like up to 20% of the purchase value in points, not to mention benefiting from the time value of money.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by watwut on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:03PM (#26971642)
Credit score matters for whole host of things like when you want to buy a house. So yes, you are penalized for not having it.

> benefiting from the time value of money

This is just nonsense. There is no additional gain from waiting till end of month till you pay.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ImPostingOnHN on Monday May 03, 2021 @02:12AM (#27022139)
I'm sorry, my post must have given the impression that I was talking about credit scores instead of credit cards, which is what I was talking about.

As for your other point, if there were no benefit from floating money for 2 months, then there'd be no benefit from doing that an indefinite number of times, which conflicts with the time value of money, an established, mathematically basic concept.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by frockington1 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @08:28AM (#26954962)
Id rather take a 30 year mortgage out at 4.5% and invest it elsewhere as 4.5% is less than my expected return.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by patentatt on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @08:41AM (#26955081)
And mortgage rates are much lower than that now too, <3% is quite realistic
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by frockington1 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:24AM (#26955477)
I recently heard Denmark has negative mortgage rates for natural born citizens. Losing money if you don't take it.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by gher-shyu3i on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:22AM (#26954104)
Giving loans with 0 interest is a good thing, however, giving loans with anything above 0% interest ins a terrible thing. We've known this for literally thousands of years.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by unityByFreedom on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:58AM (#26954738)
If you're willing to give me an interest-free loan then I will take it and invest it in an index. Generally speaking, discounted loans are only available from governments or friends for specific purposes like education or health when they want to invest in people. Even then you still have people taking advantage because money is fungible. It's hard to do this in a sustainable manner.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by gher-shyu3i on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:13AM (#26955382)
The premise is that the economy must not be based on loans, it's not sustainable as we are seeing today (not to mention it's parasitic). Loans are given out for charity purposes. If you want to invest your money, there are many moral ways.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ycuser2 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:34AM (#26952740)
A little bit off-topic: If you want an explanation in Germany what things are the way they are, it's often because "otherwise the insurance wouldn't pay in worst case".
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by kilroy123 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:12AM (#26952601)
I wish more people realized this.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by refurb on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:45AM (#26956598)
That’s a very cynical view and not accurate.

Having lived in other countries, I actually missed the benefits that robust competition drives. Consumers in some countries are paying fees that went away 20+ years ago in the US.

And as grandparent says, the robust protections offered in the US are a huge plus to consumers. In other countries they aren’t so generous as to forgive fraud and the like.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jwr on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:46AM (#26952815)
> Credit cards in the USA are backed by very strong consumer protection laws. That is why you can mindlessly give one to wait staff at a restaurant who will disappear with it for an extended amount of time, while in any other country that would be unimaginable.

But how is this specific to "credit" cards? Don't debit cards get the same protection? The point here is that in the US one needs to have "credit history" in order to do things like rent an apartment, which is not a thing in the EU.

As to security, the EU has largely gotten around the problem by implementing modern payment systems. In Poland no waiter will "disappear" with your card, they will bring a mobile terminal to the table, so that you can use your (contactless) card.

In fact, living in Poland currently, I can't remember the last time I used a physical card anywhere. For the last two years or so I've only been carrying my phone with me, no wallet at all.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by herbstein on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @08:04AM (#26954782)
> In fact, living in Poland currently, I can't remember the last time I used a physical card anywhere. For the last two years or so I've only been carrying my phone with me, no wallet at all.

Here in Denmark we recently got an official digital drivers license. You verify your identity with the government issued 2FA system, scan the NFC chip in your (non-expired) passport, and you're golden. The digital license is as valid as the physical license.

Couple this with NFC payment being a requirement anywhere that takes payment, the banks having developed a way of transferring money between accounts in different banks instantly based on just a phone number, and the digital drivers license, there's never a need to have my wallet on me. At the moment I'm not even sure where it is -- it's somewhere in the apartment.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jwr on Thursday April 29, 2021 @06:46AM (#26979507)
Yes, the same thing exists here. My national id as well as driver's licence are stored on my phone. Forgot to mention it.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by naniwaduni on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:02AM (#26952927)
There is a very strong, very simple alignment of incentives that you'd think shouldn't really matter, but makes a huge difference: with credit, the burden is on the bank to collect money from you.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by luma on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:13AM (#26954404)
In the US debit cards work completely differently than CCs. In the event of fraud, the debit card holder is technically responsible for any losses. Your bank might step in to deal with that, or they might not.

With a credit card company it's always the card issuing company's problem to address.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by sofixa on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:14AM (#26955394)
> In the US debit cards work completely differently than CCs. In the event of fraud, the debit card holder is technically responsible for any losses

That seems very backward. And as you might suppose, really isn't the case in the EU. Fraud is fraud, and it might take time, but you'll get your money back.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by diggernet on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:45PM (#26962082)
> it might take time, but you'll get your money back.

And that's really the key difference between credit and debit.

With a debit card, if there is fraud, the money is gone from your checking account. You will get it back, but it will take time, and in the meantime you may be suffering from all kinds of unpleasant effects of having a suddenly and unexpectedly empty checking account.

With a credit card, if there is fraud, you have a debt on the books. You will get it removed, but it will take time, and in the meantime you still have all your money.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by sofixa on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:27AM (#26966702)
> You will get it back, but it will take time, and in the meantime you may be suffering from all kinds of unpleasant effects of having a suddenly and unexpectedly empty checking account.

That's what card limits are for. Even on my high-level Visa Premier card, the limit is 1k per day, and there are also per-transaction and per month limits. I can increase it via my bank's app if i plan on making a big purchase with the card, so IMHO it's a good solution for that problem.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @11:30AM (#26970501)
The current solution obviates the additional work requirement of changing credit limits before purchase, so IMHO it's a better solution for that problem.

If you're protected from your credit card being used on a $5,000 purchase, why would you lower the credit limit below that?

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Frost1x on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:43AM (#26955698)
The US is all about risk, money, and power transfer. Maybe everywhere is but I've only lived in the US.

In the case of of CCs, there is an assumption that a certain portion of people will take high interest credit offered by the cards and that they will incur interest and have to pay that. The rates are often incredibly high, something like 20%+. To encourage more people to use these cards to increase the population and likihood people will be forced to pay these interests, CC companies offer incentives like cash back, no-interest periods to encourage borrowing behavior or misunderstanding of the boundary time for payments for at least one hefty interest payment, etc. They also offer an alternative to people who have difficulty receiving a loan for some item any other way.

Debit cards on the other hand are offered by traditional banks. Many of these are free and associated with free or nearly free accounts (usually requiring your regular income deposited or a minimum balance they can invest elsewhere while you let it sit idle). Banks are not incentivized for you to spend money. It's in their interest for your money to sit in your account theyre investing elsewhere or for them to charge you various service fees. They're less inclined to give you incentives and protections to use these cards.

If consumers get to a point of using credit cards in a responsible manner (essentially more people exploiting their benefits than CC providers exploiting them), you'll see these features and protections slowly peeled away. Many cards used to even offer price protection where if an item changed prices than the price point you purchased at, the CC company would refund you the difference. Obviously enough people took advantage of this vs the pool of people paying high interest that these features slowly peeled away. Time and value limits were introduced and tightened, card providers began to remove these, and now few if any cards provide this. This is one consumer feature/perk that used to exist that no longer exists because the normalized increasingly responsible use of cards by consumers. There are several more (rental protection, road side protection, flight delay protections, and a host of perks). Now you often have to pay a fee for a card that has such perks and need to be sure your spending rates are high enough to warrant the fee.

Payment systems aren't about payment systems and detecting fraud, they're about building complex systems people want to participate in under the assumption the complex system will at large extract wealth from the people using the system, not the other way around. Even something as trivial as just paying for exchange of services/good would be straightforward but it's not, it's gamed to pass risks, extract money, and transfer power.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by anaerobicover on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:02PM (#26957742)
> It's in their interest for your money to sit in your account theyre investing elsewhere or for them to charge you various service fees.

Generally true, but I have suspected that banks have begun getting payments from the payment processors, however (Mastercard/Visa). Most recent time I created my checking account the bank nearly insisted that I have a debit card although I strongly preferred to have only ATM access with it. Additionally the largest banks have most certainly figured out squeezing fees from people for use of the debit cards.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jdofaz on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:46AM (#26956607)
I don't use my debit card because I don't want to fight to get my money back, but that doesn't mean you are liable for fraud.

https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0213-lost-or-stolen-cr...

"If someone makes unauthorized transactions with your debit card number, but your card is not lost, you are not liable for those transactions if you report them within 60 days of your statement being sent to you."

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jjav on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:46AM (#26965701)
> But how is this specific to "credit" cards? Don't debit cards get the same protection?

No, they don't. It gets confusing because many banks do offer protections against debit card fraud, but that's entirely up to the bank and its terms of service (which of course they can change at any moment).

The credit card protections are by regulation, so you can count on them regardless of bank and the banks can't change them.

A debit card is a straight siphon into your bank account. The bank may or may not help in the case of fraud, depending how much they feel like retaining your business.

A credit card is a strong firewall between expenses and your money, both in implementation (it's a separate account after all) and regulation (you're not liable for fraudulent use).

So, in the USA always use credit cards. Avoid debit cards. I try to not have any debit cards (it can't be exploited if it doesn't exist) although lately it has been more difficult since banks insist on sending me debit cards I don't want. So I store them away, will never carry or use them.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by teachingassist on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:52AM (#26955816)
Credit cards also have stronger consumer protections than debit cards in several European countries.

e.g.

https://www.moneyadviceservice.org.uk/en/articles/how-youre-...

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by op00to on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:26AM (#26954500)
No. Debit cards do not get the same protection.

I have never had my credit checked for an apartment.

I too only use my phone for most credit card transactions.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by matsemann on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:30AM (#26952715)
> I have also never once cared about credit card skimmers at gas stations or anything of the sort.

As a European I haven't as well. But that's because it's been the safe chip part of the card that's been used all my adult life and not the easily spoofed magnet stripe.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by rsj_hn on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:31AM (#26953457)
You are confusing a few things here. First, the chip cards are still vulnerable to man-in-the-middle attacks, which is what the modern intermediate devices now do, even though many still call them "skimmers" out of habit (some are advocating for the similar-sounding "shimmer" to describe these devices).

They are quite effective at stealing from Europeans just as well as they can steal from Americans, except Americans are not on the hook for the stolen funds whereas Europeans are.

Here's a Krebs on Security article that has pics of a shimmer found in Europe in 2015: https://krebsonsecurity.com/2017/01/atm-shimmers-target-chip...

There was 1.8 Billion in chip card fraud for cards issued in Europe in 2018, with the highest rates of fraud in France and the UK in Europe in 2018, although only 20% is at Point of Sale and 80% is online.

But the real difference vis-a-vis the US and Europe is not chips in cards but the massive epidemic of wholesale identify theft in the U.S. The vast majority (in terms of dollar amounts) of credit fraud in the US is part of identity theft, something the US suffers from due to lack of consistent ID cards and ID card enforcement - and very little todo with chip and pin technology.

The US has 24 B in credit fraud, the majority of which is identity theft, and the largest amounts related to entire bank accounts and fraudulent loans being taken out, lines of credit being issued in someone else's name, etc, and not some illegal transactions stolen at gas stations with intermediate devices.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by sixbrx on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:34AM (#26954555)
Chip cards are vastly safer. From the article you linked about shimmer attacks:

“The only way for this attack to be successful is if a [bank card] issuer neglects to check the CVV when authorizing a transaction,”

I'm betting the European cc fraud is mostly from residual magnetic stripes or online forms being used, not the chip usages. Do you have a specific breakdown?

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by rsj_hn on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @11:37AM (#26957395)
I think you are misreading the article, so let me be clear:

If you enter your card in a compromised device, then you lose control over

1) how many transactions are being made

2) who you are paying

3) how much

Because the chip has no way of asking you for confirmation about the identity and amount of the transaction. There is no secure keypad entry connected to the chip or secure bus going out.

All you have is physical presence. The chip can prove to the input device that it is present, and the input device cam forward that proof to the bank. That is all the chip does. It does not prevent you from paying the wrong person, and it does not prevent you from paying the wrong amount. This is why compromised input devices are created, so that you can be charged the wrong amount and to the wrong party when you think you are buying gas.

The chip only guarantees physical presence. Checking the CVV is only when there is no presence and you are trying to milk the attack into an offline attack rather in addition to the MITM attack. Why are offline attacks also possible? Because vendors want to support online purchases, where there is no physical presence. But that' not the MITM attack I was describing.

Offline (card not present) transactions are a second issue, and indeed they are much larger (80-20) not present:present in terms of card fraud, but you don't need shimmers to conduct card not present fraud, although you can certainly use them for that.

Finally, not verifying CVV is not an abuse of the protocol, it's how you do a card not present transaction, which is also supported in the same payment protocol. It's not some weird form of protocol violation vendors are all mysteriously doing. It is not "doing it wrong".

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Nebasuke on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:55AM (#26955841)
There's also a reason it's much higher in the UK (I don't know about France) and it's the online component. The UK has long card numbers for debit cards, often usable online with just your credit card number + CVV, similar to how US credit cards work. This is not the case for debit cards in a good number of other European countries.

For example, my Dutch card can only be used physically at an ATM using your PIN, or online by using a payment system like iDEAL for which you need bank login details + password (which is not stored on the card). It does not have a long card number like most US debit/credit cards.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by rsj_hn on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @11:31AM (#26957298)
In both the US and EU, credit card fraud is 20% POS and 80% online.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dmos62 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:36AM (#26953488)
As a European neither have I. Couldn't I just have the bank do a chargeback in case of a bad charge?
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by maccard on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:24AM (#26953742)
Yes. I've made claims with 2 card providers in two different banks in the UK (one was a transaction for a macbook pro in India, the other was a merchant who refused to cancel a recurring payment despite me making multiple attempts to resolve with them). Both cases required a verbal confirmation, and a letter to claim it was fraud and a refund within 5 working days.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by phlo on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:39AM (#26953831)
> The country runs on cheap debt. Everything from houses, education, cars all the way to TVs and dresses is financed with long-term payments and low single digit interest rates.

Can you point to a few examples of TVs or dresses being financed in the low single digits? I'm genuinely curious -- as an outsider, my impression of US credit was always one of a system that charged predatory interest. That impression is mostly based on seeing credit cards advertised at 15-25% APR, and hearing stories of student loans with interest rates that approached the double digits (for debt that's not dis-chargeable in bankruptcy, no less).

My point of reference are Switzerland and Germany, which have legal caps on interest rates around 10-13%. Credit agreements with higher interest rates are nullified, voiding all interest claims. As a result, the growing rate for unsecured debt is somewhere in the 8-10% region. (And, of course, significantly lower for secured debt, like mortgages or car leases.)

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by naturalauction on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:58AM (#26954736)
This exists in the EU and Switzerland too, look at Klarna. They take 3% of a transaction from the merchant (depends on the country) and charge no interest fees at all for the end user. Even a financially responsible buyer might find it worth paying off later since there is no interest.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by phlo on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:47AM (#26955748)
Oh, I have no doubt that there are situations where it may make sense to buy things on credit. Houses and cars can often be financed at good conditions. I've yet to see an example where this applies to small purchases.

Klarna offers a variety of payment methods. The 30-day factoring looks fine (3% charged to the merchant, no interest to buyers). But as far as I can tell, any financing they offer beyond 30 days comes with significant interest. Their product page for Ratenkauf [1] says "Es fallen Zinsen an." ("Interest is charged"). When I look at their demo store [2], they indicate a 10.43% APR for a €400 purchase paid over 12 months. This, of course, falls on the right side of the law and has a pretty small risk of ruining people -- still, I don't think there are many scenarios where you'll end up better off after paying 10% interest on anything.

[1] https://www.klarna.com/de/verkaeufer/produkte/ratenkauf/ [2] https://www.klarna.com/demo/de/de-DE/kp/p-sunglasses-de/. You'll have to add the sunglasses to your cart and proceed to checkout.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by xwdv on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:17AM (#26954436)
Certainly. There’s many cards that provide promotional 0% interest rates for 12 months. The idea is every 12 months you sign up for one of these cards and you can make minimum payments with no interest, when the card is reaching the end of its promotional period you just pay it off in full and don’t use it anymore unless there’s good rewards.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by phlo on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:50AM (#26956668)
Ah. I hadn't considered credit card churning. Thanks!

(I do have some reservations -- I'm guessing that only a small minority of cardholders attempt to churn their balance from card to card or pay it off before the end of the promotional period. 12-month lines of credit don't come for free, and if the expected average payoff wasn't worth it, credit card companies would probably stop running these promotions.)

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by xwdv on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:51PM (#26958452)
It is 100% free money. The catch is you will be charged all the interest in some cases if you reach the end of the promotional period and haven’t paid off the card in full, or something like that.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Svip on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:18AM (#26952307)
> very strong consumer protection laws

What if you go bankrupt as a consumer in the US? Credit cards are scarily easy to come by in the US, which suggests to me that credit card issuers aren't worried about consumers potentially unable to pay them off. Which further suggests to me that it's not really the consumers being protected, but rather the credit card companies.

How does consumer bankruptcy work in the US? Raking in a lot of credit card debt, that you cannot afford, could make one liable for life.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by throwawayboise on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:23AM (#26952346)
> What if you go bankrupt as a consumer in the US

You will have difficulty getting credit for 5-7 years. You may think "fine, I'll just pay as I go" but credit checks are often part of the approval process for an apartment lease, or applying for a job.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by malka on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:45AM (#26953171)
> credit checks are often part of the approval process for an apartment lease, or applying for a job.

And then, your country tries to shame China for its "social score".

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Karunamon on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:24AM (#26956260)
There's a pretty broad difference between a system that determines "does this person honor their payment agreements according to the objective metrics of their payment history and credit usage" and a system that determines "is this person a 'good citizen' according to an opaque set of random metrics, many of which are non-financial and defined by the state".

Comparing them directly in this way is not only disingenuous, it indirectly handwaves the objectively oppressive system China runs.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Clewza313 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:49AM (#26953200)
Which, contrary to popular perception, is not even a monolithic government scheme but a bunch of mostly unrelated initiatives, the best known of which is Alibaba's Sesame.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhima_Credit

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by KSteffensen on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:54AM (#26953602)
Why are credit checks part of applying for a job? Isn't the employer supposed to pay you?
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by IncRnd on Thursday May 06, 2021 @12:38PM (#27065825)
An employer may not want to hire someone to be responsible for company money, when they are not responsible with their own money.

A poor credit file can show you are not organized or responsible.

Actually using much available credit is an indicator of someone in financial hardship who may be more likely to commit fraud or theft.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by frockington1 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @08:31AM (#26954981)
If you are in mountains of debt you would be more vulnerable to embezzlement and bribery. Generally only relevant for security and financial industries
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by fredophile on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:45AM (#26954238)
It may be included as part of a background check. If you need to apply for a security clearance then any debt you have is relevant to that process.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by matttb on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:49AM (#26952468)
I had a property management company tell me they wouldn't rent to me if my credit wasn't good enough even if I paid the entire lease up front
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by verall on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:41AM (#26952784)
Yes, because you could do more than the value of the lease in damage to the property, and then be so insolvent that there is no way to recover any of the money from you.

I'm not saying I agree with this. Landlords are ridiculously abusive, as a renter you will frequently be asked to pay a $300+ nonrefundable "application fee" before they will show you the lease document. They then can put whatever terms they want into the lease, understanding that many renters would not be able to afford another application fee.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by cpwright on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @06:29AM (#26967792)
Even if the landlord was willing to rent to you by mitigating the risk in this way; at least in NY state that would not be legal anymore.

The state recently limited security deposits to a single month, and do not permit taking more than one months rent up front. This was meant to help tenants avoid having to come up with more money, but of course landlords will simply mitigate the risk by not renting to some people at all or only for a higher monthly amount.

https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/changes-in-nys-rent-la... "Capping Security Deposits • Landlords can only charge up to one month of rent for a security deposit or “advance payment.” This applies to all residential rentals, with a few exceptions, whether you have a lease or not. › This means that if you are moving into an apartment where the rent is $1500 a month, the most your landlord can charge for a security deposit is $1500. › This also means that your landlord may not charge you in advance for the last month’s rent if you are also paying a security deposit."

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by toomanybeersies on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:00AM (#26968351)
> credit checks are often part of the approval process for ... applying for a job

Surely that can't be legal?

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dkarp on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:39AM (#26953828)
I cannot understand how this works at restaurants in the US.

Last time I visited it went like this:

1. I get a bill ($50 for example) and give the server my card

2. A card payment notification appears on my phone for the $50 payment with my bank

3. The receipt comes back with a tip field where I write $10 and sign

4. The server now updates the payment and a few days later when the payment clears, the amount has changed to $60

But what if the server chose to enter $20 instead of the $10 I specified? Do I have to keep the receipt and remember to go check that the cleared payment matches a few days later? How else would that be caught?

In the UK, you enter the tip on the card machine when you put your card in, so the payment is immediately taken and everything is clear. I really want to know why I shouldn't worry about the above scenario next time I cross the pond!

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jjav on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:58AM (#26965763)
> But what if the server chose to enter $20 instead of the $10 I specified?

Sure, they could. As long as you kept the receipt just show it to the credit card company and they'll reverse it. More importantly, I'd imagine the store would be heavily penalized, up to possibly losing their credit card contract which would leave them unable to accept payments if it's a recurring problem.

So, it doesn't really happen. In decades of eating out a lot, never seen it (and I'm the type who checks every line item in the credit card statement so I'd notice if anything is even a penny off). So no reason to worry about it.

> you enter the tip on the card machine when you put your card in

Personally I hate this so much, because I want to compute the tip and it's really uncomfortable to do so with the waiter staring at me. I want them to go away and give me time and peace to do the calculation.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dkarp on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @06:12AM (#26967692)
Yea, it seems to come down to the penalties being high enough that this fraud isn't worth it.

As a software engineer, the idea of writing in my bad handwriting the tip and total and then someone who is probably in a hurry typing it in seems like a way to introduce more human error.

That's much less likely to happen with a terminal and, since most banks here send you instant payment notifications, you're likely to catch it immediately.

Obviously this system is working for billions of payments a year over there so it can't be too much of an issue! Next time I'm there, I'll not worry about it.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by danielecook on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:06AM (#26953996)
It does seem weird. All I can say is that changing the tip amount is rare. I’ve never seen it happen, or perhaps I’ve never noticed.

Additionally, I don’t worry about it thou because my past experience suggests I can reverse the charges if I call the credit card company fairly easily.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by xwdv on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:20AM (#26954448)
One call to your credit card company about the fraudulent charge and it’s resolved. They will do an investigation and the price of the original transaction before the tip will be discovered. Also, the employee who changed the tip amount will likely be fired.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by naturalauction on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:50AM (#26954672)
Additionally the whole charge is likely to be reversed (or it has been for me in similar situations) and the business will have to pay a pretty big ($20+) fee. Of course the employee could be a bad actor but it's in the businesses best interest to try to ensure that isn't the case. I think if there are too many chargebacks, the business gets designated as high-risk and will also have to pay more processing fees.

One thing to note about the US is that card processing fees are more than double what they are in the UK/EU. It allows CC companies to eat the costs of fraud more without passing it onto the consumer/business.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dkarp on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:59AM (#26954744)
Right, so you're saying it up to me to notice and call the credit card company?

In that case, I need to go through my statement and remember that the $70 charge was supposed to be $60, or have the receipts and check it. That isn't something I have to do here, because it all happens at the same time.

Or are you saying that the penalty for the restaurant/server is high enough that this sort of thing just doesn't really happen much?

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by chrisdhal on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:46AM (#26955742)
I've never seen it happen and I use credit cards for everything. I can't remember the last meal in a restaurant that I didn't use a credit card. I've never heard of it happening from any friends or family either. It just isn't a thing.

Same with stealing number. Yes it's kind of strange that most of the time the server just takes your card and disappears for a while, but I've never heard of a number being stolen from anybody I know. Of course, it does happen, but it's very rare.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by xwdv on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:48PM (#26958401)
Here’s the thing man, until you personally see it happen at least once, don’t bother worrying about it. The odds are super slim and the incentives to commit tip fraud on one meal are high risk for little gain. I’ve never seen it happen or heard of it happening.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by anaerobicover on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:10PM (#26957877)
> But what if the server chose to enter $20 instead of the $10 I specified?

Unless they have complicity with management, the risk over reward is too great to try this. If they kept the skim small to be unnoticed -- $3-5 on each check, perhaps -- it may still not add up to being worthwhile. Most people in the world are not criminal masterminds; I think sometimes engineers like us forget that others are not constantly looking for loopholes in everything. :)

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by petters on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:35AM (#26952403)
It's the same in Sweden. The laws are very beneficial for cc holders.

If you buy something with a cc and the company for snow reason later does not fulfill it's obligations, the bank is liable. If you paid with cash or a debit card, you're on your own.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by distances on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:35AM (#26953480)
From what I've seen, it's still different in the US. If you dispute a payment, in the US the bank apparently sides with you most of the time. In Europe bank sides with you only if it was a clear case of not receiving the service/goods, otherwise it's usually considered a valid transaction.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by faster on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:13AM (#26956110)
I once had a conversation with a couple friends of friends who did targeting for the credit card industry, figuring out which demographics to send cards to. Their goal was to find people who paid responsibly and spent irresponsibly. If people who pay well weren't irresponsible enough in their spending, incentives would be provided. I'm sure this is even worse now with all the data and data-driven tools available.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by rtpg on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:19AM (#26953719)
> That is why you can mindlessly give one to wait staff at a restaurant who will disappear with it for an extended amount of time, while in any other country that would be unimaginable

What are you talking about? You do realize that credit cards exist everywhere at this point? You think that when someone pays by card in other parts of the world they maintain constant eye contact with their card, lest the person... skim the largely visible number?

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by edent on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:26AM (#26953754)
Err... yes. That's exactly how they work in the UK - and most other countries I've visited.

The waiter comes to your table, presents you with the EPOS or tablet. You take it and either tap your card, or insert it and type your PIN. Then you hand the terminal back to the waiter.

The card never leaves your hand.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by intellirogue on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:17AM (#26954069)
Exactly. I can't even imagine how the US system is meant to work with something like Apple Pay. I don't carry my physical card, there's no need to when it is in my phone.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by bsoft16385 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:11PM (#26964187)
The take away your card system doesn't work with phone payments. That's one reason why they haven't really taken off in the USA.

A lot of chain restaurants now use tablets to let you pay right at the table, and usually they support contactless payments.

Fast food restaurants have also started accepting contactless payments by and large, although it can be quite awkward in the drive thru.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by efdee on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:39AM (#26954197)
Not sure why you think that is particular to the USA. Credit cards in every country I know work this way.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by zacharycohn on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:41PM (#26951325)
You don't have to pay immediately to avoid interest. They aggregate all your bills within a given 30-day billing period, then you have 30 days from that date to pay. Interest only begins to get accrued after that last deadline.

If you wanted to, you could have the credit card companies float you a purchase for almost 60 days without interest if you timed your charge and the payment right.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by anyfoo on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:51PM (#26951388)
Thanks, I understand that. Paying "immediately" was partly hyperbole, partly that I wouldn't forget about it when I started out. I've gotten accustomed to it now.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dataflow on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:04PM (#26951487)
Btw, for people who aren't living paycheck-to-paycheck, the interest accrual isn't the real issue to worry about. Imagine: if you spend $300 in a month, and miss your payment by a whole month once in a while, even at a crazy 20% APR, you'll have to pay $5. Unless you only have a few dollars to your name, it's probably not going to suddenly break you.

The real issue, I think, is the impact on your credit history for missing a payment entirely, i.e. not paying the minimum amount due. Even if it's $1, you need to pay all of it. That's the real penalty to worry about.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by conductr on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:15PM (#26951573)
The not paycheck to paycheck people I know, myself included, charge everything they can and put the credit card on auto pay for full balance. So in my case at least, your $300 is more like $10,000 monthly. I’d be pretty mad if something happened and I owed $100+ of interest but like you said, not as mad as having the late payment show up on my credit history

Should mention I make ~$300 a month in cash back by doing this and that’s my main motivation. I actually hate the idea of cash back as I realize it just adds cost to the system but I’m just one dude and the world has spoken on the matter so I may as well get what I can out of it.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by bena on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:55PM (#26951833)
It's kind of messed up because it's like a permanent discount at every store you shop at because you have enough money to not be paycheck to paycheck.

It costs more to be poor.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by CaptainZapp on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:04AM (#26952208)
> It costs more to be poor.

That's definitely true. Time to reintroduce Scalzi's take on the subject:

https://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Macha on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:21AM (#26954455)
See also the Sam Vimes boots theory of socioeconomic unfairness (from Men at Arms, 1993):

> The reason that the rich were so rich, Vimes reasoned, was because they managed to spend less money.

> Take boots, for example. He earned thirty-eight dollars a month plus allowances. A really good pair of leather boots cost fifty dollars. But an affordable pair of boots, which were sort of OK for a season or two and then leaked like hell when the cardboard gave out, cost about ten dollars. Those were the kind of boots Vimes always bought, and wore until the soles were so thin that he could tell where he was in Ankh-Morpork on a foggy night by the feel of the cobbles.

> But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that’d still be keeping his feet dry in ten years’ time, while the poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by fshbbdssbbgdd on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:13AM (#26951934)
This is true, it’s a good system for engineers and travel hackers but bad for the common person. The credit card processors are raking in fees, though. It also provides lots of opportunities for what is essentially legal low-level embezzlement for anyone who can expense things to their employer (especially folks who travel on their dime). Way too comfortable a system for anyone to change it.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by conductr on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:10AM (#26952246)
Speaking of that. I like to look for loopholes / arbitrage opportunities within.

Once upon a time, when cash back ran benefits were in the 6% range. I bought prepaid visas from a retail store. And ran them through some merchant account. About $50K went in a circle every day and I kept the spread of almost 4% if I recall. I had to pull some other accounting tricks to make sure it did not accrue tax liability in the process but it was actually fairly impressive once I hit a certain volume I knew I tripped the alarm with the credit card issuer. They changed their entire card benefits in a way that was obviously related to blocking the activity I was doing.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by lozaning on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:57AM (#26952512)
The best manufactured spend used to just be buying money at face value and with free shipping from the US Mint. Too bad the mint got wise to that and now there's a premium + shipping.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by nopzor on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @06:19AM (#26967732)
it’s against the terms of all merchant accounts to use them as a cash advance for yourself, even if there is zero percent cash back. also, what sort of prepaid visa ever offered 6% cash back?
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by cyberlurker on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:30AM (#26952026)
I think about this all the time with so many things in life. Same with employer tax incentives, like a free metro pass/tax deductible contributions towards commuting. I’m actually paying less to take the subway than someone making minimum wage. It doesn’t seem right.

I take full advantage of all the credit card benefits though, as I think everyone should if they can.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by conductr on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:59PM (#26959259)
It’s absolutely true. In many ways. Although in this case, a poor person could reap the same benefits. The only requirement would be good credit and payments/financial discipline. I know those things are generally inversely correlated but just wanted to point out you don’t have to be wealthy to get a cash back credit card.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jjav on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:12AM (#26965824)
> if you spend $300 in a month, and miss your payment by a whole month once in a while, even at a crazy 20% APR, you'll have to pay $5

Careful with this though. The interest rules are very complex. One would think you pay the interest + penalty + balance in full and that's that, but no. Once the account goes into "charging interest" mode, it keeps charging interest on subsequent months even if you pay in full as long as there is a balance on the day of the cycle close (which if you're using the card, there always will be!)

The way out of that trap is, if you ever have a late payment, stop using that card entirely and pre-pay the entire balance (including charges not billed yet) before the close of the cycle. The goal is to get a statement with $0 balance. That will reset the account state to normal.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dataflow on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:27AM (#26965924)
Wow. I knew that balance transfers had similarly terrible rules, but I hadn't realized that normal usage can end up like this too. That's so... predatory. How is this even legal? If you pay everything in full such that your balance is $0 on a given day, what are they even charging interest on at the end of the billing cycle? The grace period just goes away for the whole billing period?
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jjav on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:16AM (#26966992)
> such that your balance is $0 on a given day

I'm not sure about that one. Maybe getting the balance to zero on any given day (not just cycle closing day) is enough to reset the account? I don't know.

But I know they'll keep charging interest every month even if you pay in full every month, once the account goes into that state due to a single delayed payment.

Looks like it's called residual interest? https://www.thepennyhoarder.com/debt/residual-interest/

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by zacharycohn on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @11:48AM (#26957551)
I have met many people who actually don't understand it and think interest starts accruing the moment you swipe! Important to be accurate.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jjav on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:04AM (#26965787)
> float you a purchase for almost 60 days

Indeed! For very large payments I try to time them for the day after the close of the cycle, so I get those ~60 days of free deferral.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by thayne on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:34PM (#26951694)
As someone who lives in the US, and travelled to europe, one of the toughest things was that many more places only took cash than in the states. Which meant I had to carry around a lot more cash than I was used to, knowing that as a tourist I was a target for theft (and I have been stolen from multiple times while abroad). With a credit card, if it was stolen, I could cancel it immediately, and I wouldn't be responsible for purchases the thief made with it. If cash was stolen, it would just be gone.

Also, I got a better exchange rate with my credit card than with cash from a bank or ATM.

On the other hand, I really liked that I payed for meals at the table instead of giving the card to the waiter, and that listed prices included tax.

That's not to say the US system doesn't have problems, it definetely does. But I wouldn't want a cash-only system either.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by KSteffensen on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:48AM (#26953892)
This is not a general Europe thing. I live in Denmark and I only use cash to try and teach my kids about money. I can't remember the last time I paid cash for anything. I'm tempted to say it has been a decade or so.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by blntechie on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @08:04AM (#26954786)
Very good point about using cash to teach kids about money.

I just began teaching my kindergarten going son about money and some of the things he has learned watching us is very insightful. For all purposes, money for him is our phone. He has seen countless places where we pay with phone to buy things (using QR codes) and that has given him an impression that a phone can get anything from a store.

For me, in my own childhood days, money as in cash was easily understandable as a finite resource because once it’s given to someone, it cannot be taken back. So I learned just by watching that money carries a value and is limited. But just scanning a phone or card with no concept of finiteness will carry some repercussions I think in future.

Will be interesting to watch the future generation who might grow without concept of cash money.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Haemm0r on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:51PM (#26951797)
I always withdraw cash money using the debit card when I'm abroad. It has acceptable exchange rates(always better than the money exchange rates at the destination country) and much lower fees(mostly just a fixed amount of €) than the credit card (quite high percentage + fixed fee).
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by nicolas_t on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:15AM (#26951950)
This really depends on the credit card and bank. My old French credit card that was supposed to be great for traveling had 2.5% conversion rate plus 0.30 euros fixed fee.

My US amex is usually only 0.1% more than current market rate and so better than any debit card I have by far.

In my experience, European countries are by far the worst when it comes to exchange rate and added fees. One hypothesis is that interchange fees are capped so credit card companies can't make as much from the merchants but even before that happened, I remember the fees being very high.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Xylakant on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:29AM (#26953084)
The problem with exchange rates is usually that the institution managing the ATM/Payment Terminal tries to trick you into using their exchange instead of just charging your card in the local currency and have your bank do the exchange. And the ATMs exchange rate are a ripoff. You’re not a returning customer, so they milk you as much as they can. This holds true for both credit and debit cards. Check with your bank, they’ll give you the proper advice and it’s usually “charge in the local currency and let us handle the exchange.”
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Nextgrid on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:02AM (#26955273)
Modern banks in the UK such as Monzo, Starling, Revolut and others have no FX fees.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by JCM9 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:45AM (#26954637)
Many people in the US use credit cards like “charge cards” and pay them off each month. I’ve never carried a balance on a CC but still use them for nearly all purchases. If something goes wrong a CC give the consumer a lot more leverage than say a debit card. I once had a bad experience with a merchant where they overcharged me and refused to fix it. One phone call to the credit card company had their payment revoked and that was the end of it. Now they have to deal with the CC company on why they are treating CC company’s consumers poorly vs me random consumer that’s not happy with them.

I get that the flip side is the above can suck for businesses if consumers file bogus complaints but as a consumer I’m going to take advantage of every tool at my disposal. If I had paid with a debit card it would have been a big mess to fix.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by cyberpunk on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:19AM (#26953032)
Schufa scores are definitely a thing in Germany; I mean, same thing different name..
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ruph123 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:55AM (#26953604)
Its not. Schufa collects negative entries. If you did not pay back loans in time you will have a bad Schufa. To the contrary in the US you have to have “good credit” meaning you have to have participated in the “credit system” and behaved well.

If you don’t have any record: Great for Schufa, bad in the US.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by cyberpunk on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:36AM (#26953811)
Oh I thought no debt history would equal clean credit. That’s bananas, surely it’s safer to lend to someone who has never been in debt? I don’t get the logic..
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by SturgeonsLaw on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:12AM (#26954033)
Depending on the lender, they might actually be after people who are always in debt, and who pay their credit cards bills each month but never entirely pay them off.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by elyobo on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:24AM (#26954116)
No, it's safer to lend to someone who has handled credit well (i.e. by paying it back) than someone who has no track record.

There's a catch-22 if rules are so strict so that you can't get credit because you haven't had credit before, but in general "positive" credit reporting seems pretty beneficial.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by avh02 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:49AM (#26953561)
haven't been to the US, but you can get a clean schufa if you just move to the country. I've _heard_ that in the US you'd need to get and pay off debt in order to have a good standing, a lack of any record is considered suspicious.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by SilasX on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:29AM (#26956332)
That is absolutely true. I was treated as subprime despite having no debts and a high credit score (on annualcreditreport.com) merely because I had never taken on debt. I would get rejected even for $500 department store credit cards! It’s ridiculous.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by xeromal on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:05AM (#26952212)
If you're middle class or higher, a credit card is a no-brainer in the US. I pay for 1 international trip a year + a few domestic trips just using my card for every day purchases. I rack up points, pay everything off, and benefit tremendously.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jjoonathan on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:19AM (#26952313)
I know that getting a very visible 2% back from an invisible 4% fee is psychologically fun in a way that a European-style 0.5% fee isn't, but the net effect of the American style is still to transfer more money from you to the credit card company.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by throwawayboise on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:25AM (#26952356)
The fact of the matter is that retail goods and services cost the same whether I pay cash or use a credit card. So might as well take the benefits the card offers.

Every great once in a while I will run into a small business that doesn't take credit cards, or offers a discount for cash. But it's quite rare.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jjoonathan on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:29AM (#26952373)
Yeah, which the CC oligopoly has conveniently arranged through merchant contracts. The Europeans negotiated around this with legislation and won a better deal.

In the US, I'm sure people would scream and cry if the evil government tried to take their 2% rewards, even if it meant 3.5% lower prices. We don't like math very much over here -- as this thread is proving.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by fredophile on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:52AM (#26954278)
I doubt prices on most common purchases would change at all. That extra money would just go to the retailers instead.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Tempest1981 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:56AM (#26952508)
Or resigned to the massive power of lobbyists.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by bogomipz on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:58AM (#26956791)
>"The fact of the matter is that retail goods and services cost the same whether I pay cash or use a credit card. So might as well take the benefits the card offers"

The merchant costs for processing the purchase of those products is baked into price though. The net effect is that the fees the merchant pays push your retail price up. You're not really getting a benefit if you get 2% back and the retail price is 2% higher to account for the merchants processing fees.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by xeromal on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:32AM (#26952391)
This was exactly my point. The amount of cash discount places are dwindling so you're actively losing money if you pay cash.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by btilly on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:57AM (#26952517)
The invisible fee is paid by the merchant, not the consumer. And fees aren't 4%, they are generally 1.3% to 3.5%. With higher fees for American Express, and merchant types with higher fraud rates. (American Express also offers greater rewards to consumers...)

In the end, aside from the complicated consumer reward part, the amount that the credit card companies get isn't that different from the European system.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jstanley on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:36AM (#26953489)
> The invisible fee is paid by the merchant, not the consumer.

But the customer pays the merchant. It's all paid by the customer.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by btilly on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:08PM (#26960092)
The customer is paying whether or not they use a credit card.

However actual businesses have overhead for dealing with physical cash as well. It is slower at the teller, needs to be manually counted and recounted, transported (sometimes with security) and so on. It is not clear whether real costs of handling money are greater or less than merchant fees.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by watermelon0 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:15AM (#26952285)
Doesn't the money have to come from somewhere? I assume merchants need to pay fees to credit card companies, and in turn this results in higher product/service prices?
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by kj4ips on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:21AM (#26952332)
That's where most of it comes from in the US, interchange rates on credit cards are not regulated, so they're generally somewhere around 2%.

Which, coincidentally, is the benchmark for "decent" credit card rewards.

Some cards will offer rewards on certain kinds of purchases, often up to 5%, but offering only 1%, or nothing for other purposes.

Since the average person only has a single credit card, the majority of cardholders produce more in interchange fees than they collect in rewards.

There's also some complicated accounting voodoo that I don't truly understand, that effectively means that banks can treat extended credit as a pseudo asset, plus, whenever alone is outstanding, it's value is added to the virtual money supply.

It is possible for an individual customer to get significantly more in rewards than interchange, but as this is a relatively small portion of customers, most issuers do not seem to care.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by gnopgnip on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:35AM (#26953481)
Technically no, no one has to explicitly lose money or pay for these rewards. The economy is not a zero sum game. There are direct costs with handling cash for merchants, for smaller businesses these are often higher than credit card interchangge/merchant fees. There are also indirect costs like lower sales and consumers losing cash due to theft.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by xeromal on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:20AM (#26952324)
Indeed that's the truth but they charge that for every customer including cash customers except specific places like arco. So if everyone is getting charged, best get some benefit from it!
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jjoonathan on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:25AM (#26952358)
...which is a state of affairs the CC companies have arranged through anticompetitive terms in merchant contracts. Cash never had a chance to compete. The moment people realize they could get effectively twice the rewards points by squeezing out the fat cut taken by the CC companies, they absolutely will. CC companies will fight tooth and nail to make sure the fees stay invisible and unavoidable via cash.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @11:44AM (#26970678)
Totally -- if the government passes some law that says, for example, credit card companies can't give out 5% rewards, but only if the prices of goods drops 5%, I would be 100% in support of that.

Until that happens, I'll take the 5% cash back, since it is preferable to 0% cash back while paying the same price.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by continuational on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:12AM (#26952257)
It's a no-brainer, because whether you have a credit card or not, you're paying for those trips every time you purchase something.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by xeromal on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:19AM (#26952315)
That's true in a macro sense but so is everyone else, even people paying cash sometimes.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by thepasswordis on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:12PM (#26950539)
Do you only pay for things like a car or a house using cash? Or what about if you are applying for a loan to start a business? Is it all just a 100% cash based society?
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by anyfoo on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:16PM (#26950580)
No, cars and houses are still common to finance, but those are obviously usually much rarer events and of some great magnitude. And given the usual lack of much of a "credit history", banks rather look at your income, assets, and other things.

Business credits exist too of course, but I'd guess that the proportion of the population doing that is even less (and Germans are already much less likely to buy houses or apartments than people in the US).

Of course if you did have a credit somewhere, and you defaulted/didn't pay, it's bad, and there is a credit bureau tracking that and more ("SchuFa").

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by thepasswordis on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:31PM (#26950699)
I think there might be some confusion happening here.

Nearly every “basic” transaction (like buying coffee) is done with what might appear as a “credit card”, but it is actually a debit card. Some people use “credit” for these daily sorts of purchase, but at least among the people I know, this is extremely rare.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by vngzs on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:38PM (#26950789)
If I buy coffee, I buy it on a credit card. Every daily purchase uses a credit card. Why? I want a buffer between me and the purchaser. I don't want them to be able to take money from my bank.

https://youtu.be/vsMydMDi3rI?t=2595

Now, if I shop online, I used to put it on a credit card. Now I generate a virtual debit card using an online service and pay with that. The logic is the same.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by anyfoo on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:42PM (#26950816)
That is actually the one thing I grant credit cards to be superior in. Back before I moved here, I was traveling with friends to the US. We knew credit cards were prevalent in the US, so I got a "normal" credit card from my bank, and one of my friends got a debit type credit card.

We later got some fraudulent charges on it, which got resolved for either of us, but for me the money was never gone (I had not paid the bill yet), while for my friend it took a while to get the money back on their account.

Another fun difference: When during our trip, waiters and cashiers would not just take the credit card, but walk away with it, we were horrified. In Germany, you never give your card away to anyone. You stick it in a terminal and type in your PIN.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by setr on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:02PM (#26950996)
> That is actually the one thing I grant credit cards to be superior in

I mean, it’s basically their only purpose in life (if you use it for the other purpose to purchase things ahead of your paycheck, that you don’t have the cash for already, you’re going to get yourself in trouble — 20% interest _hurts_)

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Semaphor on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:28AM (#26952013)
> I mean, it’s basically their only purpose in life

Cash back/miles is another one.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by skeletal88 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:17AM (#26953376)
Does not exist in europe, because they come from insane fees charged from merchants and the fees are regulated here to be lower than in the us.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by maccard on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:37AM (#26953819)
Amex offers 1.25% cashback, and they also have rewards cards that provide "points" which are redeemable on most major airline/hotel rewards programs. In practice Amex is almost universally accepted (I make 1-2 transactions a month that aren't on my Amex, but almost never a big ticket purchase).

For the cases that amex isn't accepted, all the major airline groups have a rewards card too (although BA's is an Amex), and most of the supermarkets have cashback cards in the 0.75-1% range.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Semaphor on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:07AM (#26954004)
Yup. I’m in Germany and I get cash back points on my Amex. Same experience that it’s very rare not being able to use it, I carry a Mastercard for that case.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by throwawayboise on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:34AM (#26952395)
Yes, the European/Canadian way to do credit cards at a restaurant is nice. The card never leaves your posession. I wish that would get adopted here, but restaurants will resist having to buy the handheld devices. I like restaurants where you get the bill at the table but pay at a desk near the front door, avoiding the problem of handing your card to the waiter.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by drdec on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:02AM (#26955274)
Many "family" restaurants in the in my area of the US have tablets at the table which allows you to pay your bill when you are ready to leave with a credit/debit card with no interaction with the server required.

Family restaurant means a chain like Applebees for those unfamiliar with the term.

The tablets are also a revenue-generating device as you can play games on them for a fee. They also have surveys so you can give feedback on the service, this has become somewhat controversial (see https://www.eater.com/2018/6/22/17492528/tablets-restaurants...).

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by wholinator2 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:08AM (#26956024)
Yes, I believe ive seen those terminals at applebees and chili's
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dexterdog on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:37PM (#26950760)
You and I don't know the same people. I use a credit card for everything and pay it off at the end of the month. I know nobody who uses a debit card like that unless their credit cards are maxed out.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by devin on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:25PM (#26951186)
Same. Debit cards carry a lot of risk that I can offload by using a credit card. If someone gets ahold of your debit card info, there is very little recourse once the money has left your bank. Not so with credit cards. In addition, credit cards carry a whole bunch of rewards (earning points you can redeem for travel or gift cards, cash back, upgraded status with airlines and hotels, no foreign transaction fees, and the list goes on) you can’t get with debit cards.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by viraptor on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:33AM (#26952043)
> If someone gets ahold of your debit card info, there is very little recourse once the money has left your bank.

This gets repeated, but it's not true everywhere. Some banks may not care or maybe it's harder in some countries. But for example in the UK I could easily revert a few £k the same day without issues. I'd love to read more about where the differences come from, but the blanket statement is not 100% correct.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by devin on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:31AM (#26953096)
Once upon a time you didn't see co-branded Visa/Mastercard/etc. debit cards for local banks. In many cases you still don't. If you have access to a co-branded debit card you're often afforded many of the same protections as credit card users. However, you still miss out on other, additional benefits, like building your credit and getting access to rewards.

It always depends, so do your own research, but as far as I understand, it is still considered decent general advice to tell people to prefer credit cards over debit cards. They will build credit, earn rewards, have excellent consumer protection from fraud, increase the distance between their purchases and the cash in their bank account, and so on.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by allset_ on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:45AM (#26952094)
It's true in the US. If someone manages to steal your debit card data and your PIN, all the banks say "well your PIN was used, so it must have been you" and you're SOL.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by karakot on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:11AM (#26952250)
It probably depends, my debit card got skimmed and they got $500 from it (max daily cash limit). The bank returned my money no question asked.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by devin on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:22AM (#26953049)
Yes, the limit is often the difference. Multiply your $500 by 10 and I'm curious how a small to mid-size credit union treats it. If it's a cobranded card, it's one thing. If it's a "Friendly Bank of Central Virginia" debit card, you may have less luck.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by craftinator on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:01AM (#26951864)
> credit cards carry a whole bunch of rewards

This sentence is the epitome of marketing brainwashing in the US. Not trying to single you out, as we all suffer it to different degrees here, but this sentence kind of puts it in such a nice little box.

What's a reward? What actions warrant such gifts? Why don't they just give you money instead of "points"? At any point, does the gameification of debt strike any of us as one of the most abhorrent MBA ideas in history? It's right up there on the list, sitting below indentured servitude and for-profit prisons.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by cyberlurker on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:36AM (#26952053)
They mostly do cash back as an option these days. The sinister part is we pay more to cover the transaction cost. But if you aren’t using a credit card to get points you’re only hurting yourself. (Unless the biz has a cash deal)
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by dexterdog on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @11:35AM (#26957350)
My card has always had cash back. I always pay it off so I don't care what the interest rate is. If somebody steals my debit card I can bounce checks. If somebody steals my credit card I might hit my limit, but they'll give it all back.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by tharkun__ on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:09PM (#26951047)
Then 'it worked'. That's the whole point of credit cards. They're trying to dissociate the buying and the paying such that it's easily possible to 'overbuy' and slip into the credit card hell of perpetually trying to pay it off.

The closer you are to 'living pay check to pay check' the easier it is to get you into this. And I suppose for some people it takes multiple larger purchases to get you into it. Popular culture, TV shows, Twitter nowadays etc. don't help and 'legitimatize' it (everyone's talking about it that way, so everyone must be doing it that way, so it's OK to do it that way).

You might be good at "paying it off at the end of the month". A lot of people easily slip into credit card hell that way, because they _can't_ pay it off at the end of the month, because they didn't realize how much of their credit they should really be using. Credit card says you have $2000? Let's spend $2000. At the end of the month I only have $1500 left in my account? Oh crap!

Personally I pay it off in sort of regular intervals, since it's all right there in my online banking. I've never waited for a "credit card bill", even when they still sent them to me in actual dead tree form.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Ayesh on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:18AM (#26952308)
It's just being financially responsible.

I use my credit card for the purchase buffer the other mentioned, and I've set it to the exact amount is taken from my bank account on the due date.

I also track my expenses and categorize it, so I have a clear idea what's happening in the budget.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by elyobo on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:38AM (#26954192)
I pay it off in full when it's due, and have done almost without fail for years. In two cases I stuffed up (paid the previous month's bill instead on one, can't recall the other), in both cases I hit them up and they ended up refunding my interest anyway.

The points for regular spend, the sign up bonuses, and the interest savings (the average balance on my card ends up saving me interest on my mortgage) put me well ahead.

Credit cards are a solid because many (most?) people use them poorly, but it's certainly possible to use them wisely.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by throwawayboise on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:37AM (#26952407)
Young people with no credit history can get debit cards if they open bank accounts. I'm not really sure it helps their credit score but it's convenient. The first real credit card a young person gets will have a very low limit, maybe only a few hundred dollars, so they are not all that useful at first other than to start establishing a credit history.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by matttb on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:55AM (#26952494)
Debit cards do not help credit score. If your score is too low or non-existent you often have to get a 'secured' credit card which means you have a limit (often it's still a low limit which I don't understand), and that limit is how much cash you let the company hold for you. It doesn't seem any different to me than having a bank account + debit card. When you're done using a 'secured' card you get your initial money back
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by anyfoo on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:37PM (#26950768)
That does not match my experience at all, even before coming here. Credit cards, as far as I could see, are actually credit cards most of the time, and I have been explicitly told that I should start "building credit" by paying as much with a "real" credit card as possible.

"Credit card bills" also seem to be a regular part of everyday conversation here, in sitcoms, on Twitter...

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by astura on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:32AM (#26952035)
>I have been explicitly told that I should start "building credit" by paying as much with a "real" credit card as possible.

You've been somewhat misinformed. You build credit by obtaining the credit line and just having it available for a long time, not by using it "as much as possible." Actually purchasing items with your credit card is not required.[1]

In fact, "maxing out" your credit cards (when your bill closes using 85%+ of your limit) actually can reduce your score (but only for the month(s) your cards are "maxed out.")

FICO scores aren't a black box, they publish exactly what they take into account - https://www.myfico.com/credit-education/whats-in-your-credit...

[1] with the caveat that some credit card issuers will close dormant accounts after a couple years.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Nextgrid on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:12AM (#26955364)
In the UK, there is no such thing as FICO. The "score" the credit bureaus tell you is completely made up and is designed to encourage you to check back regularly so you can see and "engage" with the "offers" (aka ads/spam) next to it. It will vary by a dozen points every month or so.

Lenders get a raw copy of your report when you apply for credit, which contains things like credit account history (max limit, % of limit used, late payments if any, etc) and then run their own scoring algorithm on it. Those are black boxes.

In the UK, getting a credit card and using it regularly seems to be the common advice for building credit, which makes sense considering the scoring algorithms themselves aren't public (and differ by lender).

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by jbeam on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @11:50AM (#26970760)
>Actually purchasing items with your credit card is not required.

Pretty sure you need to make at least a $0.01 purchase for the purpose of having a payment, otherwise you won't have a payment history.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by astura on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:45AM (#26952096)
>Some people use “credit” for these daily sorts of purchase, but at least among the people I know, this is extremely rare.

Really depends.

If you know mostly college students, and younger, lower income people, yeah, most are paying with debit.

If your circle is high income and older, then it's mostly credit. Especially people who do frequent business travel.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ticviking on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:16PM (#26950581)
The US is abnormally obsessed about credit and creditworthiness.

In most nations the debt to income ratio for these things is also much stricter than in the USA, since they don't expect everyone to have 10k in credit card debt and 50k in student loans.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by klyrs on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:51PM (#26951796)
Consumerism. You wouldn't believe the crap, and the volume of the crap, that Americans buy. Saying that completely red-handedly.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by frockington1 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @08:37AM (#26955038)
Its amazingly easy to not have those debts, and most people I run into do not. The problem is the people who do are very vocal about it and it's impossible to inform them that they may be spending more than they can afford
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ncallaway on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:35PM (#26950745)
Financing has existed as a concept _far far far_ longer than "credit bureaus" have existed as a concept.

Financing can absolutely exist without a centralized credit rating system / data privacy nightmare.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by Nition on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:11PM (#26951058)
The options aren't just cash or credit. Debit cards are commonly used: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debit_card
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by valzam on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:49AM (#26952115)
My bank in Germany actually has a hybrid system: Any charges are on the card, not your account but you have to specifically apply for deferred payment. The default option is that they settle the credit balance with your checking account every month.

Seems like a good system to me. You give people the "buffer" between your account and merchants but make it very hard for people to go into debt.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by BeetleB on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:55AM (#26952156)
Last car I bought - the dealer would allow me to put only $3500 via a CC. The remaining balance was via cash/money order/bank check/whatever.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by gher-shyu3i on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:21AM (#26954098)
This is how the usurious banking system gets you. People continue to cry about the wealth gap, yet they don't want to fix the problems right under their noses.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by drunner on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @08:46AM (#26955125)
Equifax drives me insane. I can't manage my own freeze with them because they can't validate who I am over the phone (none of other bureaus had a problem).

Instead, I have spent 6+ hours on the phone with them over the last 3 months. I have faxed the requested information 3 times and mailed it once and nothing has been resolved. I've given up. I recently had to have my credit checked for home purchase and I simply told the lenders that I would not be working with them if they could not use Experian or Transunion to verify my credit.

The most insanely infuriating thing about all of is was that when Equifax got hacked, I immediately froze my wife's and my own credit with Equifax. At the time, they required you to create a unique 16 digit key to manage your freeze. They have apparently done away with that, so even though I own the key and can give it to them, it means nothing to them. My wifes account has no issues.

My account will be frozen for life at Equifax, I don't care to waste any more time with them and I the credit system in the US with a passion.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by PascLeRasc on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:44AM (#26955716)
I have the same issue, PINs are never recognized. They can't find me when I call in either. I've been able to unfreeze from the iOS app, but that's only because it asks for basically zero information to do so.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by willhinsa on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:01AM (#26951862)
That is one way to be able to solve the problem, but the most direct way to solve the problem of credit scams is to put the onus on the bank who opened up the account incorrectly to assume responsibility for the debt, not on the person whose details were spoofed to create the account.

This is quite humorously illustrated by a "That Mitchell and Webb Sound" skit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by paxys on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:48AM (#26952110)
Completely agree with this. Credit freezes don't work because credit reporting agencies have never been in the business of identity verification or protection. Whoever grants the line of credit should be doing the due diligence on whether the right person is in front of them or not, but they would rather pad their numbers and shift blame to someone else.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by npsimons on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @11:17AM (#26957080)
> but the most direct way to solve the problem of credit scams is to put the onus on the bank who opened up the account incorrectly to assume responsibility for the debt, not on the person whose details were spoofed to create the account.

This. "Identity theft" shouldn't be a term. There's already a term for what's happening, it's called fraud, and it's perpetrated on the banks without involving the person whose identity was "stolen." Consumers shouldn't have to deal with the fallout from banks' fuckups, especially given the resources banks have available to avoid said fuckups.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by AdamHede on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:18AM (#26952637)
I am a part of a small but passionate group in Denmark, who advocates for giving everyone an account in the national bank at birth.

This account would be able to attach a featureless debit card (using our national standard payment system "DanKort"), and have the same interest rate as the national Bank (so for now, slightly negative).

Employees of the national bank is already able to get accounts like this. So there is precedence.

This is obviously not a particular attractive not sophisticated "product", but it is awfully hard to hurt yourself with, and will have all the functionality that allows you to function in a modern society.

Make banking a choice, and force the banks to make sufficiently attractive products to convince me to participate willingly.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by runeks on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:50AM (#26952839)
> Make banking a choice […]

How does “giving everyone an account in the national bank at birth” correspond to making a choice? How about, instead, you give people the option to open an account with the national bank? That sounds more like a choice.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by alephu5 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:27AM (#26952688)
DiEM25 advocate for this and it's a great idea. I hope it happens in Denmark and that the rest of the world follows suit.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by sdoering on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:34AM (#26952742)
No I know were the idea in Yannis Varoufakis' new books "Another Now" originated. Or were he proposed it as he is part of DiEM25.

Actually quite some interesting thoughts within this book.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by mijamo on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:34AM (#26952745)
The ECB is working on something like that actually.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by judge2020 on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:12PM (#26950537)
This all stems from the right to privacy and right to control your data, and the overall lack thereof in the United States. All that the credit beuraus do is collect information from various sources about people.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ikiris on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:43PM (#26951335)
You aren't the customer, you're the product.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by colonelpopcorn on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:37AM (#26956463)
In lieu of an actual identity system, credit reporting is probably a necessary evil. Or at least an evil inevitability.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by tobiasSoftware on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:51AM (#26952129)
What really upset me was when my wife immigrated, she did so just before Trump passed some new immigration laws. Those laws would have required her to submit her credit scores as part of the paperwork for immigration. The idea that in order to immigrate you have to tell the government information from three private companies is just insane in my opinion. This last week has solidified this opinion as a year and a half later she still can't get info from them, I can't imagine what they would say just after moving here.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by closeparen on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:45PM (#26960567)
Reputation is a pretty fundamental component of existence in a human civilization. The specific implementation leaves a lot to be desired, but the underlying structure - people will talk behind your back about your behavior when deciding how much to trust you - is not going anywhere.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by garyrob on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:46AM (#26956618)
" Freezes don’t appear to work - they usually say that I don’t have an active freeze whenever I go to lift one. Or their website is down entirely. Or they won’t let me get to the freeze section without clicking no on their paid monitoring services 8 times. " It might be worth mentioning that I've had to temporarily lift freezes from all 3 bureaus a number of times and nothing like this has ever happened to me. I've never had any trouble or needed to pay anything.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by thepasswordis on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:47PM (#26950317)
You could accomplish this by just never applying for credit of any kind, couldn't you? In this way, these agencies might have a file about somebody with your name, but it won't really be relevant to you in any way.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by AlotOfReading on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:02PM (#26950445)
Even if you never open a line of credit in your life, the contents of that record will still affect your ability to rent apartments, get jobs, and even have utilities in your name.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by teeray on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:00PM (#26951472)
Also the lack of records will also impact those things
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by cheriot on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:54PM (#26950371)
Until someone else applies for credit with your identity.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by cortesoft on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:56PM (#26951835)
But if you never use credit, having your credit hurt by this wouldn’t matter.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by athms on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:36PM (#26962803)
Anytime you open an account at a financial institution for a savings, checking, or retirement account, they will get a credit report. Employers are increasingly requiring a credit report before handing out job offers. Every landlord is going to require a certain credit score before accepting your application.

You don't need worry about your credit if you use cash and store it in a coffee tin, couch surf, and work under the table.

Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by anyfoo on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:07PM (#26950499)
Please tell me that's not actually possible?
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by judge2020 on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:15PM (#26950570)
Assuming someone knows your name, address, and SSN (something which isn't meant to be secret - the SSA even printed 'not for identification' on the cards for a while), they can apply for credit cards in your name as they often require no other form of identification. The U.S. doesn't have a national login system for identity verification or anything so there's not much that could be done here from the security aspect besides creating a federal credit beurau or a federal ID system (or if login.gov allowed third-party companies to use it).
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by ropans808 on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:13PM (#26951078)
That's kind of what identity theft is, and it is distressingly possible.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by mint2 on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:15PM (#26950576)
It is possible and it happens. This what ppl mean when they talk about identity theft.
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by iczero on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:14PM (#26950563)
Identity theft!
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by artificial on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:31PM (#26950702)
Bank fraud. :)
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by magicalhippo on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:45AM (#26956597)
Re:Experian’s credit freeze security is still a joke by athms on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:51PM (#26962982)
Any query with an SSN/ITIN that doesn't exist will create a report for that number. Different names using the same SSN/ITIN are listed as aliases.

Credit reports are queried for many reasons, not only loans.