News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by thefifthsetpin on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:37PM (#19730253)
I suppose I'm happy that the fourth amendment was upheld, but from a privacy perspective I'm disheartened.

A chalked tire was ephemeral. I doubt that whatever replaces it will be.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by jen729w on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:30PM (#19732518)
> A chalked tire was ephemeral. I doubt that whatever replaces it will be.

My girlfriend tells me of a homeless guy that used to roam the streets of Bondi, Australia – as in the famous beach – rubbing the chalk off the tyres. This guy never said a word, just shuffled about rubbing off chalk. Suffice to say he was a local hero.

Now he’s gonna have to learn how to DROP TABLE.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Sendotsh on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @08:16PM (#19734358)
It was a thing all over Sydney throughout the 90s. We used to do it too (and I'm pretty sure I saw the guy your girlfriend is referring to, or another like him). We'd skate down at Bondi and throughout the city and if we saw the inspector chalking a street, we'd come down later and wipe them off. Same as topping up parking meters. If you found money on the ground you'd just stick it in the next expired parking meter you saw. No one liked having coins rattling around in your pocket while skating.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by perl4ever on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @09:47PM (#19734854)
The emotion/motivation behind this seems kind of peculiar to me. Sure, it's a nice thing for the person who is parked, but not for the person who isn't parked, at any given moment. Would it be a worthwhile good deed to find people who have just been to an ATM and give them some more money?

I don't go around ranting about inequality much in general; I'm just bemused by the implication that increasing it is obviously good karma.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ImprovedSilence on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:14PM (#19734986)
na, it's more anti-authority us v. them than it is "how can I be most effective at helping others". cops can sometimes be a pain to skaters, and cops can sometimes be a pain to illegally parked cars. The less times the cops win, the better.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Sendotsh on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:22PM (#19735281)
Yup pretty much this. Any benefit to the car owners was purely a happy coincidence. I'd say the homeless guy mentioned above (and know for a fact others who did it in the same area/era) were doing it for the same reason.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by perl4ever on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:48PM (#19735401)
I remember seeing a homeless guy feeding a large amount of bread to pigeons on the sidewalk, if you get my drift.

I thought it was amusing, but I didn't park on the street.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ALittleLight on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:32AM (#19736059)
Ideally the authorities are working to achieve efficient use of parking space and funding for local government. I suspect such "anti-authority" protestors are not really informed enough to make a reasonable guess as to whether their interventions will be a net benefit. As is, to me, it just seems like people messing with the system because they can't compare the abstract benefits of increased parking efficiency, to the more obvious costs of someone experiencing the displeasure of a parking ticket.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by darkerside on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:22PM (#19735024)
If you treat the populace as a closed system, and the government as an external actor, then these actions increase total utility by preventing larger losses to the external actor.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by perl4ever on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:37PM (#19735347)
"closed system...external actor"

Hmm...a _closed_ system sort of implies there are no external actors doesn't it?

Your statement appears superficially dispassionate and hypothetical, but I don't think it makes any sense unless it is unpacked as a lot of normative statements that would be very controversial if explicitly stated.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by darkerside on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @10:47PM (#19744598)
Please default to trust. Just because you didn't understand my statement doesn't mean it's nonsense. I'll try again.

Everything depends on how you frame it. When making decisions, you can maximize utility for just yourself, or perhaps for friends and family, or maybe for everyone in your small town. How you choose to frame who you care about will determine the decisions you make. If you include "the government" in this frame of reference, there is no overall change in net utility when a ticket is given. Someone pays a large sum of money (negative utility) and it goes into government coffers (positive utility).

People who put change in meters likely do not include "the government" in their system of utility. In that frame of reference, a ticket being written is a net decrease in utility because the positive utility of government revenue doesn't matter.

My point is, actions that seem irrational to you may actually be understood as rational when viewed from a different frame of reference.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by perl4ever on Thursday April 25, 2019 @06:45PM (#19753204)
"People who put change in meters likely do not include "the government" in their system of utility. In that frame of reference, a ticket being written is a net decrease in utility because the positive utility of government revenue doesn't matter."

I think I get what you are saying...for instance, arresting a serial killer would be a net decrease in utility, because the positive utility enjoyed by government workers being paid to prosecute, etc. doesn't matter when you don't consider the government as part of your logical system.

Are you sure you are using an orthodox style of reasoning?

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by darkerside on Thursday April 25, 2019 @09:16PM (#19754038)
If the "closed ayatem" is the serial killer, then yes, of course. And many criminals do indeed think the system is stacked against them and is unfair, because they haven't internalized that their wrongdoings impact other people.

I'm not using orthodox reasoning. I'm just explaining a perspective you don't seem to understand. And you don't have to agree with it to understand.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ohbleek on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @04:11PM (#19742148)
The statement makes perfect sense. A closed system does not mean there cannot be an external actor. Your statement however, is intentionally superficially dispassionate.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by perl4ever on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @08:12PM (#19743789)
The idea that "external actors" by definition cause losses to a system no matter what they do makes no sense to me. If Darth Vader gives me a cookie, there is no contradiction between the cookie having utility and him being Darth Vader.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by stjohnswarts on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:06PM (#19775010)
A little civil disobedience is good for the soul
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by cialowicz on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:10PM (#19732895)
> ...roam the streets of Bondi, Australia

This ruling applies to the US, not Australia.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by avh02 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:40PM (#19733192)
It was a highly relevant but non-local anecdote - who cares where it is? I happened to find it a cute random act of kindness (or rebellion).
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by chrisseaton on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:41PM (#19733205)
Not cute or kind for people who want a fair shot at parking like everyone else and can't because people are abusing the system for their own selfish reasons, enabled by someone rubbing the chalk off.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by avh02 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:59PM (#19733368)
I agree, which is why I put the "or rebellion" bit, at the same time, it's not like the people parking are paying someone to go around rubbing chalk off so I can't say they're "abusing the system" as they have no expectation of getting away with it.

Regardless, it's story a friend of a friend told somebody, who knows how true

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by rsync on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:05PM (#19731764)
"A chalked tire was ephemeral. I doubt that whatever replaces it will be."

I suspect you are right and share your foreboding...

However, a very easy solution would be to just mark the asphalt around the tires ... maybe write "blue chevy" between the marks.

So easy.

Instead, a politically connected services firm will capture local mayors / council members (very, very cheaply - shockingly cheaply) and build it into their unnecessary speed/redlight camera systems.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by burkaman on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:06PM (#19732320)
That's error-prone (what if another blue chevy replaces it?), and takes 10 times as long as a simple mark, and doesn't work when the road is sandy or wet, and you need some quick way to erase the last marks, etc.

I can't think of anything nearly as quick and cheap and effective as a chalk mark on the tire.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by tom_ on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:18PM (#19733541)
What about a notebook and pen? Note car number plate and/or description of car and location. If you've got somebody going wrong chalking tyres, you can have that person take notes instead.

(This might also take a bit longer than making a chalk mark, but time is not exactly of the essence here.)

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by learnstats2 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:58PM (#19733843)
I searched for "number plate" because I am pretty sure this is what is done in UK/Europe and I have no idea why you would consider doing anything else?

But nobody saying "license plate" is suggesting this - is there some reason why not?

Chalking seems 100% unreliable and very open to legal challenge.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by opless on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @04:36AM (#19736568)
In the UK equipment varies.

I've seen smartphone based license scanners, Psion-based data entry terminals (they punch in each and every offenders license plate), but parking meters tend to have a paper receipt you place on the dashboard or stick to the window. But now they have a pay-using-an-app option ... They take your licence plate details always and check it against an online db, and if not then they look for a paper ticket.

Pretty much, if you park in a time limited street zone or a metered zone or a municipal car park ... You can be assured your car number plate is captured along with entry and exit times.

The data is likely sold on too

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ThePadawan on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:02AM (#19735926)
I assume it's just harder to write down license plate "numbers" in the US since they are both less strictly formatted and less unique than any national plates in Europe (that I am aware of).

From a short search, it seems that license plate numbers aren't even unique across state borders in the US, for example.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by mcv on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @09:48AM (#19738257)
I find all of these solutions wonderfully low-tech. In Amsterdam, they slowly drive google streetview-style car which autotmatically records number plates, looks them up, and issues fines where necessary. The only thing needed is someone to drive the car, and I'm sure that's also going to replaced eventually.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by stale2002 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:43PM (#19732634)
I can think of a way.

Police could walk around with a hand held license plate scanner, that electronically tracks the general location of the parking space, and the car.

I bet this could be done with a phone app, actually.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by coderintherye on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:55PM (#19732761)
In urban areas the city could even work with local property owners to place video cameras that have enough angle to be able to have a constant view of all the cars that park. Could automate ticketing car owners who overstay.

*Not that I wish for this, but it's theoretically possible to implement.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by pfooti on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @08:36PM (#19734473)
incentivize this by passing 20% of the ticket price back to the property owner
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dondawest on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:28AM (#19735797)
How do we de-incentivize doing cop’s jobs for them on HN? This is a great idea with one problem: fuck the police.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by lazyasciiart on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:44AM (#19735854)
Ban parking cars on public property. Then nobody needs to be tracking how long it's there for.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dondawest on Monday April 29, 2019 @11:49AM (#19779449)
Fully agreed.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by stan_rogers on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @08:49PM (#19734553)
They're not exactly equivalent. Tire-chalking essentially proves that the vehicle didn't move (or that the driver was ridiculously unlucky in that the mark showed up at about the same location). The number/license plate merely shows that the same car is in the same parking spot, so the (legal, if arguably too "letter of the law") approach of vacating the space and parking there again is indistinguishable from overstaying the limit.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by foota on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @08:59PM (#19734605)
I believe most jurisdictions require you to leave a space for some time before the parking "resets"
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by _archon_ on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @10:33AM (#19738714)
How would they know that hadn't happened?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by foota on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @07:57PM (#19743715)
If you require vehicles to be gone from a certain street for 24 hours, say, before parking there again for a 2 hour spot, and you check it at 1 pm then later at 4 pm, you can conclude the vehicle wasn't gone for 24 hours.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by burkaman on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:19PM (#19732990)
I know, but that's a little slower, way more expensive, and fails if the battery runs out or the GPS can't connect, or the license plate is too dirty to read.

Obviously the chalk method isn't perfect either, but it's close.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ricardobeat on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:30PM (#19733093)
That is how parking enforcement works here in the Netherlands. Someone just drives a camera-equipped car around and everything happens automatically - you enter your license plate on the meter so times are known to the minute.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by perl4ever on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @09:50PM (#19734865)
There are parking meters in the US city I live in, where you enter your license plate and you don't have to fill an individual meter or display a tag on your dash.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by djmobley on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:56AM (#19735904)
If the license plate is too dirty to read, give them a ticket for that instead.

Penalty should be greater than for the parking infraction anyway, otherwise people would dirty their plates deliberately.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by daveFNbuck on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:27PM (#19733067)
There are also a lot of advantages once you automate this via a camera. Now you can put cheap cameras near spots and/or mount the cameras on cars to automate ticketing as police are driving around on other business.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by rlander on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @08:11PM (#19734331)
My city does this (Florianopolis, Brazil). I can use a smart phone app to start the clock or just let an officer pass by and tag my car. Chalking seems very... rudimentary.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by nitrogen on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:06PM (#19733904)
I think Salt Lake City for one does enforce parking this way.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by SllX on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:47PM (#19734186)
San Francisco already does. Hell, it might actually be built into the enforcement vehicle (the Interceptors!), but don’t quote me on that part.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by amluto on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:00PM (#19732804)
Palo Alto does something like this.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by tokai on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:23PM (#19734010)
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by n8henry on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @04:20AM (#19736498)
A photo
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by acdha on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @09:31PM (#19734790)
> So easy. Instead, a politically connected services firm will capture local mayors / council members (very, very cheaply - shockingly cheaply) and build it into their unnecessary speed/redlight camera systems.

I agree that there’s a history of questionable business practices in that industry but those systems are far from unnecessary. Motor vehicles being driven irresponsibly kill something like 40k Americans per year and cause all sorts of injuries and quality of life reductions. Cameras are a good way to discourage that without using tons of police time or dragging in questions of fairness — the call should be punishing corruption, not giving up a valuable tool.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Stratoscope on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:28PM (#19735047)
Cities all around the SF Bay Area have been removing their red light cameras. Here in Menlo Park the city just dropped ours. And about time! They were widely hated for mailing people fake tickets for minor infractions that were not a safety hazard at all, like slowly rolling through a right turn with no other traffic in the vicinity.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Declanomous on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:17PM (#19735262)
I used to be annoyed by red light cameras because they triggered on "safe" infractions, like right turns on red. Over the past few years I've changed my mind, because I've almost been hit as a pedestrian and on my bike by people sliding through intersections, to the point where I've physically prevented myself from being hit by pushing off the car a couple times.

Right on red is awesome as a driver, but it makes roads really dangerous for other road users. I think bad intersection design is partly to blame for perceived "frivolous" red light tickets, but at the same time I think that drivers really should come to a complete stop before the line (and before the crosswalk if there is one) before deciding if a right turn on red is safe or practicable. If people can't even be bothered to stop for a right turn on red then it's probably better to ban them outright.

Also, I've seen enough people run red lights 2-3 seconds after the light changes that I want red light cameras at every intersection anyways. It might be 1 in every 250 people who gets dinged for the right turn on red ticket, but that's stupidly dangerous.

If a fix is needed, increase the fine for blowing the light, scale it based on the time the light had been red (so you don't excessively punish people who got caught in the zone of indecision), and reduce the fine for rolling through a right on red.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by mtviewdave on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @12:41AM (#19735620)
Do you always look both ways before entering the street? I always try to do that, both because that's what I was taught to do as a child, and because it seems like the best way to ensure my safety when walking. The only times as a pedestrian when I've been nearly hit by a car is when I've failed to do that.

If you don't look both ways, why not?

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by mikekchar on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @12:59AM (#19735702)
Here are 2 scenarios that might explain OP's point of view.

You are walking up to an intersection and the crosswalk sign is green. You look right and across the intersection all the traffic is stopped. You look left and there is a car coming, but it is clearly slowing down for the red light. You step into the intersection, but the car doesn't actually stop. They turn right at the intersection. You have to jump away. The problem here is not that you didn't look, but that you misinterpreted what the car was doing. It would be best to wait until all approaching cars are actually stopped before entering the intersection, but next time you are crossing a street I challenge you to see if you always do that. It's surprisingly uncommon because the car is "obviously" stopping.

The second is more of a clear cut problem. Bicycles often travel at speeds much faster than people expect. It's not unusual for a road bike to be going over 30 km/h (just under 20 mph). Cars should wait for you to clear the intersection, but often they aren't looking for bikes and will make a right hand turn, cutting off the cyclist. It happened to me many times in Canada. I'm very happy that the turn-on-red rule is not allowed in Japan where I live now.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Stratoscope on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:42AM (#19735846)
California has a little-known law that tries to protect bicyclists from the "right hook" accident you mention. If there is a bike lane, drivers are required to merge into the bike lane before turning right, instead of turning from the car lane and cutting across the bike lane.

This is why bike lane stripes have a dotted section when approaching an intersection, to give drivers a hint about what they are supposed to do. Unfortunately, only a minority of drivers understand and follow the hint.

https://sfbike.org/news/bike-lanes-and-right-turns/

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by acdha on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:59PM (#19741101)
> They were widely hated for mailing people fake tickets for minor infractions that were not a safety hazard at all, like slowly rolling through a right turn with no other traffic in the vicinity.

You meant to say “real tickets”, right, since you described someone actually breaking the law — and I've seen many, many times where “no other traffic” meant “no other traffic which the driver saw, correctly understood, and respected”. I've had a few close calls in crosswalks and there's nothing fake about it.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by sandos on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:22AM (#19736018)
Afaik, here in Sweden they use something called "digital cameras". They take a picture of said car and placement on street and just compare it later on.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by chrisbrandow on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:09PM (#19735218)
Not as easy at tapping a tire with a long stick as you drive by
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by NotAnEconomist on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:00PM (#19732274)
Cops with license plate scanners that also check for warrants and cross reference your movements over time is my guess.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by sathackr on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:03PM (#19733417)
And then the police departments sell the information to 3rd party advertising companies to make up for shortfalls in their budget.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by cjensen on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:48PM (#19730383)
For what it's worth: Palo Alto already tracks parking electronically. The good part of this is that you can't just repark in a different space to avoid a ticket; this encourages people to have a real plan for the entire time they need parking.

Perhaps the US government or the states should enact data retention laws to ensure stuff gets purged in order to avoid the downsides of a surveillance state.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by pmiller2 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:03PM (#19730558)
Palo Alto’s system is very successful at keeping me out of Palo Alto, and I think that’s actually the point. There’s nothing I can think of that in Palo Alto that’s worth dealing with their parking situation.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by aidos on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:52PM (#19730427)
This stuff can be a pain though. I drop my daughter off at a club on Saturday mornings. I need to pay for parking for an hour, even though I only need 10 minutes but then I can’t return for 2 hours. So actually, I need to pay for 2 hours upfront so I can come back to collect later.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ThrustVectoring on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:40PM (#19732607)
You might not need to pay for parking because you might not be parking per se. The california definition of parking:

http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection...

>“Park or parking” shall mean the standing of a vehicle, whether occupied or not, otherwise than temporarily for the purpose of and while actually engaged in loading or unloading merchandise or passengers.

As long as you're physically engaged in loading or unloading merchandise or passengers, your car is standing but not parking. If you only need to drop off your child and don't need to escort her inside, you shouldn't be forced to pay for parking.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by village-idiot on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:54PM (#19730445)
You're in the minority where it affects you negatively.

The main purpose of street front parking meters, aside from revenue, is to encourage people to get in and get out. Parking is a limited resource designed to support local businesses, whose revenue scales with the number of visits, not their duration.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by closeparen on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:02PM (#19730552)
This assumes that the purpose of a visit is retail shopping, which is in decline. Downtown use is shifting towards experiences (restaurants, coffee shops, etc) where lingering a while is an essential feature.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by WorldMaker on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:25PM (#19730809)
Even this idea of optimizing for visits over duration is flawed for retail shopping: not everyone has a specific item in mind and only that specific item in mind for a direct in/out purchase decision. So much of marketing is about impulse buys, and so much of consumer decision models are about wrestling with a wall of near but distinct variations of a product for that "perfect" one for a particular shopping. That's before you even get into the social models of retail where people shop together. Retail shopping benefits financially from time/lingering/"experiences" just as well as everything else and optimizing for "visits" maybe optimizing for the wrong things for even retail.

Arguably this is exactly part of why retail disappeared from many urban environments because suburban and exurban Malls were better at optimizing for lingering, social experiences in the 70s/80s.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:18PM (#19730736)
The statement you are responding to does not assume the purpose of a visit is retail shopping. It doesn't matter what kind of business it is, it needs to make sufficient revenue, and unless the businesses start charging for lingering, they need to ensure enough customers are able to patronize the business to keep it going.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by WorldMaker on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:28PM (#19730845)
The point is a quantity over quality thing. People that linger/feel free to take their time are more likely to spend more in a lot of business classes. Optimizing for quantity of people spending money may be suboptimal for total revenue if each individual person spends less because they feel time pressured / aren't allowed to "window shop" / etc.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by village-idiot on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:41PM (#19731497)
Quality over quantity is a nice theory, but a bad idea when allocating public spending.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by WorldMaker on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:15PM (#19731872)
I'm not sure I even understand what your point is now.

Public spending tries to account for quality all the time. Quality "metrics" of various sorts exist in lots of places and can always be evaluated (or found, then evaluated, as may often need to be the case) when making trade-offs.

In the case of public parking, there are ways to improve "quality" by reducing overall parking pressure at specific locations by "moving" it to other areas, such as park-and-ride combinations with public transportation, improving access to site-to-site ground transportation (bicycles, scooters, wheelchairs, segways, what have you), and just improved public transportation in general.

Quantity is often an easier metric to optimize for because it's always a number, but that's all the more reason for public spending to find ways to do the hard thing and optimize for quality. That's why we elect people to work on hard problems and care so much about public spending.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by village-idiot on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:54PM (#19732223)
Define quality. It's all great to say that quality matters, but you're using an abstract definition of quality while letting everyone fill in their own mental definition of quality. That feels good, but is is a terrible way to actually make the concrete decisions about how the public purse will be used.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by WorldMaker on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:41PM (#19732618)
There was nothing abstract in my definition of quality. I defined quality directly in terms of things that matter to net revenue of local businesses several times in the above posts and gave several examples (such as perceived time pressure versus ability to window shop or impulse buy).

I don't see how that is a terrible way to make concrete decisions about public spending, and I'm very not sure why you are arguing that it is. Quality can certainly be defined and optimized for, and that's precisely what I've said, and provided specific examples for. I even admitted that optimizing for quality is hard, but just because something is hard doesn't make it impossible to make concrete decisions about.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by village-idiot on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:31PM (#19733103)
So you’re not optimizing for quality, you’re optimizing for revenue, and you just disagree with my recommendations for optimization. Got it.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by closeparen on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:13PM (#19731855)
The point of going to a restaurant or coffee shop is the atmosphere / venue for socialization; you would not do it if too tight a timeline were imposed.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by village-idiot on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:23PM (#19732445)
... which is why they usually pay for their own lots and don't use publicly funded metered parking.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by perl4ever on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:02PM (#19734913)
Not at a lot of places I go to. I guess a place like Starbucks or McDonald's or Dunkin Donuts almost always (not always!) has a lot, but random restaurants and coffee shops that I go to generally don't.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:18PM (#19730731)
> The main purpose of street front parking meters, aside from revenue, is to encourage people to get in and get out

That's not a purpose aside from revenue, that's a mechanism for increasing sales, property, and/or income tax revenue, depending on the particular tax regime in the locality.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by cjensen on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:26PM (#19730814)
If you want a walkable downtown, you need to keep the stores alive, which means they need revenue. Especially true in a place like Palo Alto with its crazy rent prices.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by bluGill on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:44PM (#19731001)
IF you want a walkable downtown you need people to have a reason to walk. Once someone is in their car it isn't a big deal to get back in my car to drive to the next place - you see this all the time in strip malls where people drive to the next store. Keeping people from getting into the car in the first place is key. That means you need to focus downtown first on the people who live there. Outsiders who don't live downtown are welcome to come too, but if you make their needs the focus you kill downtown.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by village-idiot on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:39PM (#19731483)
Car shoppers are the least valuable shoppers by far. They spend less and they demand more public spending in their support.

You can downvote all you want, but it's been researched.

https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/12/cyclists-and-...

https://www.treehugger.com/urban-design/study-shows-people-w...

https://www.bishopstonsociety.org.uk/bishopston/amenities/11...

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by perl4ever on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:03PM (#19734922)
"Car shoppers are the least valuable shoppers by far. They spend less"

Hmm...sounds like a good justification for owning a car - I can't give it up, otherwise I would spend too much on other stuff!

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by cjensen on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:23PM (#19731959)
I won't disagree with your ideas in general because I just don't know.

But in the case of Palo Alto, this isn't true. Parking is just hard enough to find that people generally do walk once parked. And there aren't enough people in downtown to keep it alive without the outsiders.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by bluGill on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:47PM (#19732680)
I've never been to Palo Alto, but I'm going to guess that it is another town that goes to bed early. Busy during business hours and sporting events (and other large venus that bring in people), dead otherwise. People already downtown for work stay downtown for lunch, but they do all their non-lunch activities elsewhere if possible. (using the court house is only possible downtown...)
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by cjensen on Monday April 29, 2019 @07:45PM (#19783719)
There's a lot of places like you describe :-)

Palo Alto is oddly not one of them. I don't know why PA is so unusual, but it is. Might be the safety. Might be the disposable income. Might be the lack of mainstream-style shopping and dining areas.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by bradknowles on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:35PM (#19733678)
Palo Alto is a town where Millionaires complain about being treated like undesirables, because they don't make as much money as the vast numbers of people who have hundreds of millions of dollars, or billions.

And so the "just millionaires" become the new downtrodden and homeless. At least, in their own minds.

You wanna talk about "Reality Distortion Effect"?

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ryanmonroe on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:58PM (#19730495)
The idea that parking exists primarily to increase the revenue of business owners seems pretty bleak.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ghaff on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:46PM (#19731564)
What other function would it serve in a retail area? I suppose you could argue that its direct purpose is to allow people who do not live within walking distance to visit and spend time. But unless local businesses profit from that visiting, they're not going to be in business for long and there won't be any reason for people to go there.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by rrix2 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:40PM (#19733196)
30 years ago we could say the purpose is simply to "exist in the public space of my community", but the demand for constantly increasing revenue from any and all space has effectively destroyed that.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by village-idiot on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:46PM (#19734178)
You’re joking right? We’ve never had parking just because. It’s always been there to serve the needs of whatever it’s next to. In the case of retail, it’s to support the shops, period.

We’ve had mechanically metered parking since the 1940s, and manually paid for parking before that. Something has to pay for all that concrete.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by village-idiot on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:59PM (#19731133)
It’s not like parking is this beautiful stuff you’d like to have around, eh? Of course parking serves the purpose of whatever it’s next to.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by larkeith on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:53PM (#19730432)
> The good part of this is that you can't just repark in a different space to avoid a ticket

This is weird to me. Is parking time a per day thing instead of per instance - e.g. if I park for two hours in the morning and two hours in the evening, would it violate a 3-hour parking space? If not, what's the criteria for being "not parked", if getting in and driving your vehicle to another spot isn't it - would around the block count?

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by cjensen on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:57PM (#19730473)
Palo Alto uses a clearly marked zone system. So the two hours per day is per zone.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:49PM (#19733292)
In my city it is per block face. So you can go around the corner and park again. Except that you can't because we have no meters so all the parking is full all the time.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by larkeith on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:01PM (#19730551)
Huh. I guess that makes sense, it's just quite unfamiliar to me.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:15PM (#19730703)
> Is parking time a per day thing instead of per instance - e.g.

In many cities, it's a certain time limit in a certain geographic zone within a particular time window (e.g., 1 hour in a 2 hour window in a set of adhat blocks) that either hits a hard limit or (where tiered pricing is used) a higher price/time tier.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by kd5bjo on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:04PM (#19730575)
Given this ruling, the 2012 ruling about GPS trackers, and the ubiquity of number plate scanners, it’s possible someone could challenge the constitutionality of requiring license plates on vehicles — they’re not all black model Ts anymore, so there’s less need for the registration number to be visible a mile away.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:12PM (#19730655)
Both the GPS and the chalking cases involved a government officer committing a physical trespass. Requiring you to affix a registration plate isn't remotely similar. So, while there might be a challenge available, the GPS and chalking cases don't really pace the way for it in any substantive new way.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by kd5bjo on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:34PM (#19730893)
I’m not a lawyer, so this is just idle speculation, but the relationships I see are:

* Like the GPS trackers, license plates are devices designed to aid in identifying and locating a vehicle from a distance by technological means.

* Like the chalk marks, the government is using these devices indiscriminately, without probable cause.

* For bonus points, license plates are compelled speech, like requiring you to introduce yourself with your real name to everyone you meet.

It’S certainly not a guaranteed win, but it’s not so far fetched that I’d be surprised to see a competent lawyer try it.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by LeifCarrotson on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:31PM (#19732526)
> Like the GPS trackers, license plates are devices designed to aid in identifying and locating a vehicle from a distance by technological means.

License plates originated in the early 1900s, long before color film cameras were a thing, and more than a century before inexpensive, at-scale license plate readers were a thing.

License plates were devices designed to aid police officers in identifying a vehicle from up close by requesting a license plate check.

It was remarkable in 2002's Bourne Identity when the highly-trained agent remarked that he knew the license plate numbers of every vehicle in the lot, and the implication that he'd recall them if they happened across the same cars again was scary.

The fact that it costs almost nothing to outfit every meter reader with a license plate scanner and log the motion of people and cars in a central database is an accident caused by the progress of technology, not a design goal of the license plate.

Preventing abuse of technologies as they become possible is a hard problem.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by kd5bjo on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:49AM (#19736144)
> is an accident caused by the progress of technology, not a design goal of the license plate

It certainly wasn’t a design goal for 1910-era license plates, but it probably is for 2010-era license plates. The only way to really know would be to subpoena the records relating to the most recent redesign process.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by jrockway on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:48PM (#19731030)
Driving is a privilege, not a right. You can drive without license plates on private property all you want.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by sergiosgc on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:56PM (#19731106)
Not everything is binary. Driving is a privilege, yes, but making use of the privilege does not imply forfeiture of civil rights. A balance has to be struck.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by kelnos on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:57PM (#19732257)
And many, many people are perfectly ok with the balance of "if you want to drive on public roads, you have to display a somewhat-opaque identifier on your vehicle so you can be held accountable if you screw up".
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by perl4ever on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @09:53PM (#19734875)
As people point out, the opacity has lessened over time, and it's reasonable to question if we should re-evaluate how it's being used. Kind of like how social security numbers have changed their role in society.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by mjevans on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:21PM (#19733003)
Being required to identify yourself and related property in relation to suspected crimes (with probable cause) is acceptable. E.G. "License and Registration please, you are suspected of committing X and possibly other crimes."

Being required to wear a real-name badge in a public place is much more unsettling.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by rossenberg79 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:26PM (#19732474)
License plates not being required will lead to abuse of driving privileges, an imbalance.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by rootusrootus on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:14PM (#19732931)
FWIW, that is not exactly true (in the US). Driving is not an explicitly enumerated right, but it cannot be taken away without due process, so it's more than a privilege.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by SkyBelow on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:37PM (#19733158)
>Driving is a privilege, not a right.

Given it's impact on day to day life, perhaps it is time to change that.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Zak on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:12PM (#19731844)
In a great many cities, this right is actually restricted. City codes often prohibit parking unregistered/expired vehicles on private property if they're visible.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by astura on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:40PM (#19732111)
Yeah... that's to prevent blight, having a neighbor who has a de facto junk yard in their front yard is really bad for property values.

If your unregistered car is not in disrepair and you aren't storing multiple cars in your front yard, you're very unlikely to be cited.

I just looked up my town ordinance and it only applies to "junk motor vehicles."

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Zak on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @08:16AM (#19737601)
To put that another way, middle-class and wealthy people don't like to see poor people.

The way most places I'm aware of structure it is vehicles that don't have current registration or that can't move under their own power. That's potentially more broad than "junk" but also a more objective standard.

This sort of law can have a severe impact on poor people. Imagine you're barely getting by, then your car breaks down. This is not unlikely because as you're barely getting by, you have an older car and you're not having it maintained professionally on a rigorous schedule. It's going to be a while before you can afford the parts - let's say a "new" transmission from a junkyard. It sure would help if you didn't have to pay $100/month to keep insurance on it though. Of course, that means you have to turn in the license plate, or they'll suspend your driver's license (in certain jurisdictions).

A lot of people have to sell their car for scrap in this situation, which does not give them anywhere near enough to replace it with something reliable.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by crankylinuxuser on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:55PM (#19732235)
> I just looked up my town ordinance and it only applies to "junk motor vehicles."

And just exactly who determines this "junk" status?

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by 14 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:28PM (#19732502)
We have bylaw officers in my town. They would be the ones to decide what a junk vehicle is and obviously they are not experts in every area possible so they just use their judgement and make a call. Some other person who applied for a job in my city that my taxes pay gets to determine if my stuff is crap or not. Of course you can always take the city to court if they are acting inappropriately. What criteria do they use? I am going to guess the does the car look like crap test. If so get ride of it. Or how about when did you insure or drive the car last? Not for years well get rid of it. The fact of the matter is, like others have said, no one wants a neighbor that collects a bunch of cars that just rot and look like crap. No one is asking people to get working vehicles and get rid of them. Also, the city gives you plenty of warning. You could show them look the car drives or your intent to fix it. No different then if they determine your yard isn't clean enought....I personally like long grass and bugs, the city not so much. Some person gets to decide is the answer.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Karunamon on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:04PM (#19732306)
Humans, naturally. Usually a subclass of humans we call "judges" whose job it is to decide on these matters.

Snark aside, law isn't code and the "reasonable person" test works well in most cases.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by astura on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:25PM (#19732463)
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:43PM (#19733231)
I believe in my city a car parked on the streets has to be moved at least once every three days.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by learc83 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:13PM (#19732923)
In my county junk is defined as incapable of moving under it's own power.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by novok on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:39PM (#19733704)
That plus a leeway of 1 week is a fairly objective standard.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:49PM (#19731038)
Law does work by similarity, but to the features cited in the decision rationale (here and in the GPS case, physical trespass without probable cause), not similarities unrelated to the decision rationale.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by tomohawk on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:05PM (#19732855)
It's practically required to carry a transponder in your car on the east coast as there are many toll roads and they are in the process of phasing out cash.

There are companies that want to turn your cell phone into that transponder so that you can just use your phone as a universal transponder.

This seems likely to happen. Once it does, will having a smart phone with this feature enabled be required to drive on a road? If so, it is seems likely that this requirement will be challenged in court, but what's the difference between being required to have a plate on your car or an app on your phone?

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by crankylinuxuser on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:53PM (#19732215)
> * For bonus points, license plates are compelled speech, like requiring you to introduce yourself with your real name to everyone you meet.

That's why I won't get a amateur radio plate any more. Anybody can look up my callsign and figure out who I am. And I'm legally required to show it.

At least a license plate has some obfuscation between plate# and human who registered it.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by alexis_fr on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:11PM (#19731248)
Sorry, is it a requirement to introduce oneself with his real name to everyone they meet?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by mental1896 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:24PM (#19730794)
So all they'd need to do is compel the driver to chalk his own car?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:46PM (#19731016)
> So all they'd need to do is compel the driver to chalk his own car?

The typical method along those lines is paying at a machine, getting a receipt, and posting the receipt visibly inside the windshield or the street side window, but, yes. This was about physical trespass for information without sufficient cause, not a right not to have parking time tracked.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by stormbrew on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:22PM (#19731953)
Is looking in a window not itself a 'search'? Like, a police officer dragging a street by looking in every window for pot or guns would presumably be indiscriminately searching without probably cause, why would it be different with tickets in windows legally?

My experience though is this particular style of parking pass is usually on private property where the people checking are not part of a branch of police though, and thus I think are not bound against unreasonable search in the same way?

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:42PM (#19732127)
> Is looking in a window not itself a 'search'?

No, by the plain view doctrine information gathered at least by normal human senses without a physical trespass is not a search.

> Like, a police officer dragging a street by looking in every window for pot or guns would presumably be indiscriminately searching without probably cause

No, they wouldn't, just like a police officer indiscriminately looking through your car window for violations of cellphone use while driving laws without any particular cause isn't.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by stormbrew on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:09PM (#19735222)
Fair enough. Today I learned.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by wil421 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:35PM (#19732070)
I know for searches you need to have a reasonable expectation of privacy for the search to be illegal.

For example, I saw an article a few years ago where a cop was literally walking a drug dog around a house. The dog detected drugs so they busted the door down. The courts threw the case out, there was no reason for a drug dog to be searching around his house.

I’d expect if you had a drugs or a dead body in plain view of a window then your expectation of privacy is gone.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by roywiggins on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:38PM (#19730939)
You could just require a permit to park, and permits are issued by a ticket machine, and are valid for 2 hours (or whatever). Cars without prominently displayed tickets are fined, and cars with expired tickets also.

Without the physical intrusion, I don't think this ruling would apply at all.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by joncp on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:36PM (#19730917)
They already require you to affix a sticker inside the window in many places. That's the same thing.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by tuukkah on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:16PM (#19731300)
Or to buy a 2-hour parking license for your license plate online.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by amalcon on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:36PM (#19732087)
In a sense, yes. The argument would be that they're not really compelling you, because you don't need to park there. The city is allowed to make all kinds of crazy rules about who may park where and when on public roads.

In another sense, no, because what the chalk does is establish that this car has not moved since the last time the officer went by. If you chalk the tire yourself, the officer cannot know when you did so.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ScottFree on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:08PM (#19730611)
If it goes that route, even the legality of using of drug sniffing dogs comes into question.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by sgustard on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:19PM (#19731917)
I'd imagine drug dogs sniffing you while you walk down a public street to be unconstitutional. At airports, concert venues, and so on, it seems like you've already consented to being searched.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by stestagg on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @03:42AM (#19736355)
If the dog had a collar that sprayed you with chalk to indicate you’d been sniffed...
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by chrisdhoover on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:43PM (#19732139)
They should be unconstitutional.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ScottFree on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:45PM (#19732159)
According to whom?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by DINKDINK on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:07PM (#19733439)
If the state hasn't shown that an accused has committed a crime before the state trespassed but needs to trespass first to then dig up an ex-post justification for trespassing witch hunts develop.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ScottFree on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:45PM (#19733753)
And yet, the supreme court has upheld the use of drug sniffing dogs for traffic stops.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by MertsA on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:32AM (#19735815)
And yet, their accuracy is poor to say the least and no objective, informed, reasonable person would conclude that a drug dog scratching someone's paint would be considered probable cause. But here we are.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by DINKDINK on Saturday April 27, 2019 @06:40PM (#19768075)
The rationale is probably that smelling the air around a car is not trespass.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ScottFree on Saturday April 27, 2019 @07:11PM (#19768213)
Drug sniffing dogs aren't accurate. You might as well allow the cop to flip a coin and if it comes up heads he has probable cause to search the vehicle. Combine that with civil asset forfeiture laws and you have a nasty incentive. Cops have been caught giving their dogs signals to bark so they can seize the car.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by anbop on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:51PM (#19731622)
The Constitution isn’t code, so new behaviors can’t be stumbled into like a buffer overflow. There is no national outrage over license plates and everyone seems pretty OK with them so the Court is not going to throw a massive wrench into society for no reason by making them unconstitutional.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by colejohnson66 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:55PM (#19733822)
A huge chunk of the population is fine with Trump blocking people he doesn’t like, and a court ruled that unconstitutional. Just because a huge chunk of people support it doesn’t mean it should be legal and upheld in court.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by anbop on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @11:01AM (#19739009)
But that’s a new behavior. How can license plates suddenly become illegal after 100 years, unless there is an “evolving standard of decency” in this regard?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by beverlyhills on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:10PM (#19731232)
In Beverly Hills, a shocking percentage of people drive without license plates. Most are dealer advertisement plates. The cops rarely pull people over for this.

I like the idea of reverse regulations. Like I shouldn’t have to display my license plate unless I’ve been cited as a dangerous driver.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by gwillen on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:28PM (#19731402)
This only became illegal on January 1, 2019. Before that there was a grace period. So you're going to see a lot less of it.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by colejohnson66 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:56PM (#19733832)
This is actually how Steve Jobs got away with not having a license plate. He just got a new car every 5-6 months (the grace period is 6 months)
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by acct1771 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:12PM (#19731259)
Ohio does similar to this with "party plates".
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by harlanji on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:28PM (#19730841)
Mountain View, CA is already using automated roving photo technology to enforce the 72 hour parking limitation (anti-RV living). Personally I have a coherent position on data retention that could apply to any DB like this and make it ephemeral. Legislation about data retention with room for lossy aggregates like counts.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by blobbers on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:23PM (#19731362)
What do you think the chances are that some city IT department screws that up?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by seattle_spring on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:19PM (#19730740)
Oh good, even less chance to catch hit and runs. Removing license plates would mean a field day for criminals all to appease a few tinfoil hat wearers.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dang on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:30PM (#19740766)
Your comments in this thread broke the site guidelines. Could you please review and follow them when posting here? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Note, in particular, "Don't be snarky" and "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." Also the one against calling names (such as "tinfoil hat wearers").

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by seattle_spring on Friday April 26, 2019 @08:21PM (#19762900)
Understood regarding name calling, but the other guy literally cited a wikipedia article on Nazi Concentration Camps to corroborate what he was talking about. How did I in that case did I respond to a "weaker interpretation that was easier to criticize"?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by yjftsjthsd-h on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:09AM (#19735736)
> all to appease a few tinfoil hat wearers.

Straw manning does not make your position look stronger. Privacy is a valid concern.

[dead]
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dang on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:31PM (#19740783)
Please don't do this here.
[dead]
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by CompanionCuuube on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:46PM (#19734176)
Why not? Our cities are built around widespread use of multi ton "killing machines", where walkability is often sacrificed so that cars become the only realistic option.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:19PM (#19731330)
Criminals already just use stolen cars and/or stolen plates.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by donatj on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:25PM (#19731379)
I doubt most hit-and-runs are committed in stolen cars.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by acct1771 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:14PM (#19731281)
Tinfoil amplifies signals.

That, and "conspiracy theorist", are propaganda terms, and should be rejected.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by seattle_spring on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:00PM (#19732272)
Yeah, no. /r/conspiracy has a 1000 comment thread that witchhunts people at my friend's company because it shared an address in SF with some dating site loosely related to Hillary Clinton. People I cared about were literally threatened with their lives.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by acct1771 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @03:41PM (#19741957)
Everybody that reads about conspiracies, or discusses conspiracy theory, must be just like those people.

...wow.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by chapium on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:16PM (#19731886)
If you have the correct vitamin supplements you can dampen your output.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by thinkloop on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:49PM (#19731046)
Imagine having to plate and infringe upon 300+ million people just to appease some hit-and-run foil pants wearers
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Gibbon1 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:14PM (#19732376)
The government is in it rights to very specifically limit what people/corporations/muni's can do with license plate data.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by DINKDINK on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:01PM (#19733394)
Say a savant in your neighborhood has been able to memorize everyone's license plate, when and where they park. This violates a privacy law on data retention. Do you advocate fining and imprisoning the savant for the facets of her mind? Would you advocate that if this information ended up in a book, that the government should start collecting these books and destroying them? Maybe in a fire? like a book burning?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Gibbon1 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:02PM (#19733876)
> Do you advocate fining and imprisoning the savant for the facets of her mind?

No I advocate not taking you seriously from now on.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by DINKDINK on Thursday April 25, 2019 @11:12AM (#19748999)
>> Do you advocate fining and imprisoning the savant for the facets of her mind?

>No

>The government is in it rights to very specifically limit what people[...] can do with license plate data.

Ok, thanks for retracting your previous position, for a second there you were advocating for people to be imprisoned for things they do with their mind.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Raphmedia on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:10PM (#19731233)
What would stop someone from doing crimes if all car were anonymous?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by acct1771 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:12PM (#19731263)
The same thing that stopped people 50-100 years ago.

Actual police work.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Raphmedia on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:30PM (#19731426)
You would replace photo radars, red light cameras and automatic paying tolls with actual employees? That sound like a waste of manpower.

Does that also mean that petrol is now free since you could just fill up and drive away without ever being recognized? Or are we also putting someone at each pump to make sure nobody drives away?

This would also make actual police investigation harder. How would you call the police on someone driving recklessly without being able to provide the plate? What about when they need to find someone that has a done a crime? Should they close down traffic and search every single cars of the same color and make as the criminal's?

The only way removing plates would work is if you replace it with something more invasive (i.e. facial recognition).

In short, you could do any crimes you currently do with a stolen car or fake plates without any effort.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by tempestn on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:38PM (#19731471)
Re petrol, you could do what's done everywhere in Canada as far as I know, which is simply have people pay at the pump before filling. (And yes, it works for filling the tank too, since you can authorize a larger amount than is spent.)
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ilovetux on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:02PM (#19732290)
I think all gas stations in the areas I frequent in the US (New Jersey, Pennsylvania, New York and Virginia) are prepay only. I haven't seen a gas station that you could pump first since I was a teenager in the 90s.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by eric_h on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:47PM (#19732679)
> New Jersey

Nitpick, but last I checked, New Jersey still doesn't let you pump your own gas.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by ilovetux on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @08:37PM (#19734479)
Very true, but by definition that means that you need to establish payment before they will pump. I thought it would unnecessarily complicate my comment to mention this so I'm actually glad you made this comment so I could make this reply.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Raphmedia on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:56PM (#19731673)
I can't talk about all of Canada but I know that those pump before paying stations are still quite common in the eastern provinces during daytime hours.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by perl4ever on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @09:59PM (#19734897)
It's strange, now that I think of it, to consider that getting gas before paying has died out in a lot of places, such as where I live, but getting (and consuming) food before paying has not.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by tempestn on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:27AM (#19735794)
Along with the social norm, there's probably a financial incentive behind that. If you make people pre-pay, they're much less likely to stick around and spend more. But obviously the norm is huge too; you'd be associated with fast food.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by tempestn on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:58PM (#19732784)
Ah, ok, I think the furthest east I've pumped gas is Quebec, but most of my knowledge comes from BC, Alberta and Ontario.

Anyway, pre-paying for gas is a thing that's pretty straightforward, is my main point.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by xfitm3 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:39PM (#19730957)
In my area parking enforcement has ALPR. The computer tells them when to stop and issue a citation. Pole mounted ALPRs are popping up in major intersections, and along two lane roads in wealthy areas.

All of the mobile "Your speed is" trailers also have ALPR. You can leave your phone at home, but law enforcement still knows where you're at.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by tclancy on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:15PM (#19731295)
"Automatic number plate recognition" for the curious.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by Cd00d on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:56PM (#19733347)
Ah, the 'L' is for 'number'!
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by all2 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:46PM (#19730361)
Many cities have vehicles that are covered with cameras, read your license plate, and make a database entry.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by kleiba on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:47PM (#19732171)
And chalk on tires is unconstitutional?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by cardiffspaceman on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:20PM (#19732994)
I guess you're thinking of privacy while the court was thinking of trespass in terms of property and property damage. The chalk affects the tire, so property damage. The camera doesn't affect the tire, so no property damage. Both affect privacy: the chalk mark signifies that you parked somewhere where they mark tires and the camera records that you were in some spot.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by jrochkind1 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @08:37AM (#19737730)
I'm pretty sure where I live they already don't use chalk, but instead use cars/gocarts with license plate scanners, driven by parking enforcement officers, that drive up and down the streets, recording what cars were where when. The system will flag em to stop and ticket where required.

I think this is quite common now in the US?

Googling, I'm not sure if it's not quite common yet (yet!), or there just hasn't been a lot of attention to it?

https://www.govtech.com/public-safety/License-Plate-Scanning...

https://ops-com.com/parking-security-platform/license-plate-...

https://www.genetec.com/solutions/industries/parking-enforce...

https://www.pressdemocrat.com/news/7186110-181/crimebeat-wha...

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by threatofrain on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:16PM (#19731302)
I think if we allow cameras in the many public space then in a sense can always be geographically tracked. Also if we assume that dropping things in public means we forfeited any privacy concerns, like our DNA from skin cells, or our fingerprints from cups, in a way we already have the line of privacy drawn very far back.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by sbuttgereit on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:10AM (#19735737)
My hunch is that the sort of tracking you dread is on its way regardless of what happened in this case. Over time, the only likely difference of this court result is that parking enforcement agents will have some software that tells them about the license plates with expired time... license plates they may have already been bulk collecting for broader purposes. Speculation... but... we'll see....
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by cryptonector on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:48PM (#19731581)
Exactly. The traffic cop can just write down the license plates, take pictures, whatever is convenient. The city could use cameras and automate a great deal of the process. All without ever touching the car except for placing the ticket on the windshield when it's issued (and why is that not trespassing?! probably because by then the officer has evidence of a violation, thus curing the trespass).
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by esturk on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:01PM (#19731723)
If you read the article, the 4th amendment has 2 parts. Is it a search and is it reasonable. Chalking is not reasonable because at the moment of chalking, the car is in a legal position. Placing a ticket is reasonable because at the time of placement, it is no longer in a legal position.

Otherwise no one can place parking tickets no more.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by cryptonector on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:12PM (#19732365)
Isn't that what I wrote?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by legohead on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:38PM (#19730941)
kind of funny this came about after someone broke the law 15 times, not for any real invasion of privacy or property.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by hammock on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:22PM (#19732442)
The article mentions a likely candidate for replacement: "parking enforcement officers could sidestep the constitutional issue altogether by simply taking a photo of the car rather than using chalk"
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by rocqua on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:18PM (#19732978)
Its scary that they equated chalking to GPS trackers. Pervasiveness is exactly the difference between the two. It seems that the courts did not recognize that.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by foolfoolz on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:26PM (#19730816)
it's ridiculous how much cars are ephemeral today. you have to read a physical license plate to know which car it is, possibly even a vin number. registration is tracked on your car by a 2 inch sticker

soon enough (realistically 15-20 years) license plates may still be around but no one is going to use them. the car is going to identify itself electronically. and i am a huge personal freedoms and privacy supporter but i am all for this.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by roywiggins on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:39PM (#19730961)
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by notJim on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:48PM (#19731029)
> the devices are also able to show ads

Ahh of course. Heaven forbid anyone ever not be looking at an ad.

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by thinkingemote on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:06PM (#19741188)
>i am a huge personal freedoms and privacy supporter but i am all for this.

Not that huge

Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by stordoff on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:23PM (#19734013)
Why? I'm not seeing the benefit of this.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by tempestn on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:35PM (#19731457)
Yep, my thought was that it was only a matter of time (probably not much) before chalking was replaced with cameras connected to computers anyway.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by jiveturkey on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:58PM (#19731691)
spray the time notation between the front and back tires. (with chalk). the tool will be 600x the cost of chalk-on-a-stick but at least it's a durable 1x capex.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by chapium on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:21PM (#19731928)
what if the chalk is from the previous car?
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by vokep on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:02PM (#19732836)
if you've got a device to spray time notation with chalk, you probably can also spray some notation of the car model or license plate
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by rrix2 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:43PM (#19733224)
One requires a text entry interface and one requires a battery and a quartz crystal
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by megaremote on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:20PM (#19735275)
Every single car should be constantly tracked, they are killing machines. 2 million die a year due to the cars.
Re:Court Says Using Chalk on Tires for Parking Enforcement V... by nextlevelwizard on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:53AM (#19735888)
100% of murders and homicides are comited by people. Every single person should be constantly tracked, they are killing machines.