News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by calinet6 on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:54PM (#19287452)
> To preface the article, I primarily work on, and prefer, back-end code. I've been involved in both web and software development for over 4 years now

Cool, cool. To preface this comment, I'm a user experience designer, and I've been doing web software development and design for over 20 years.

In reality, your conjecture turns out to be largely untrue. Visual design quality does have an impact.

Main principle you want to look up: the Aesthetic Usability Effect. Basically, users perceive your product to be more usable if it's aesthetically pleasing.

> Summary: Users are more tolerant of minor usability issues when they find an interface visually appealing. This aesthetic-usability effect can mask UI problems and can prevent issue discovery during usability testing. Identify instances of the aesthetic-usability effect in your user research by watching what your users do, as well as listening to what they say.

From https://www.nngroup.com/articles/aesthetic-usability-effect/

See also: https://www.nngroup.com/articles/perceived-value/ (other ways users perceive value based on the UI)

Of course, this has limits. A rebrand or redesign that, all other things equal, is mostly the same quality as before probably won't get much benefit. I've seen many redesigns and that tends not to be something people do—there's usually a good bump in visual quality in the process.

So, regardless of whether you, personally notice the different functionality, many redesigns are actually a success at improving the perceived value, perceived usability, and overall evaluation of the brand, company, and product.

People aren't idiots. They don't do this work for no reason. Try to understand and respect the work outside your own department and specialty. Building respect across those boundaries is a rare and valuable thing.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by inertiatic on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:10PM (#19287510)
>People aren't idiots. They don't do this work for no reason.

Citation absolutely needed. In my experience people are frequently idiots, and work gets done for no reason after someone with authority is convinced that it's a good idea by someone aching to do that sort of work.

If it happens in so many other cases, it does happen in UI/UX as well.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by dsego on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:28AM (#19288766)
Job security, designers can only design, so that's what they do. And if there is nothing new to design, they will keep redesigning. Gotta keep up with the trends.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by pembrook on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:02AM (#19288853)
Coders can only code, so that's what they do. Even if there's no new features needed or the old software is working fine as is, they will keep refactoring. Gotta keep up with the trends.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by oftenwrong on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:50AM (#19289015)
I'd agree. Given the opportunity, programmers will often work without regard to business needs. For example, rewriting an old codebase using their favourite new stack.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by brobdingnagians on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:00AM (#19289707)
Totally agree, and for managers who have programmers on staff they will keep making up features without thinking about whether it is a good idea. You start getting "features" crammed in because they have to pay the programmers to do _something_.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by calinet6 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:28PM (#19290405)
This is such a real thing that happens, yep.

It's really hard to get people together to make good software. I think that's something everyone can agree on.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mgkimsal on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:05AM (#19289726)
> For example, rewriting an old codebase using their favourite new stack.

Sometimes that is a business need, but the rest of the business doesn't recognize it (or won't until it's too late). Yes, having your website running on coldfusion 5 isn't actually a problem - data comes in, data goes out, orders are filled (ecommerce, for example). If the actual business needs didn't change ever... there would not be a need to ever refactor/rebuild.

And yes, I've seen "needless" refactoring, without regard for business needs. But there are folks who do understand some of the needs of the business before the other business units may realize it themselves.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by gnagatomo on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:24PM (#19291986)
>Sometimes that _is_ a business need, but the rest of the business doesn't recognize it (or won't until it's too late).

This. I work for a big payment system company. They had to buy another Exadata, reaching the maximum plan offered by Oracle. The refactor was delayed so much that now we have little more than one year to rewrite everything. If we don't make it in due time no more transactions will be processed. Some devs who pointed the need for a refactor left the company in the last two years and said it feels like a time bomb ticking with every git commit.

Meanwhile the UI/UX guys are trying to create a design system whilst redesigning the internet banking system and app, backed by the CPO and CTO (!?). I mean, I'm not the one calling the shots, but neither a deisgn system nor redesign should be a priority for a least two years.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mgkimsal on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:25PM (#19292342)
Yep. I can't say I've worked on data at that scale, but the 'every commit is a time bomb' - had that feeling on things.

What has bugged me in the past (and why I don't like being just a 'coder') is that... hey - people in my position have a perspective few others have. Sometimes we can see things that others can't, and generally we're smart enough to understand the business impact. If you're being asked to implement 'business logic' all day, for months or years, at some point, whether you want it or not, you can see how a business is being impacted by things that you can see. Raising a flag like "hey, xyz should probably be a priority..." and being dismissed because you're just a coder and don't understand the business - besides being insulting, sort of doesn't really jive with reality. In many cases, the software team are the only people that actually have a strong understanding of 'the business' - how many of the pieces fit together, etc.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by gnagatomo on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:16PM (#19292478)
>you can see how a business is being impacted by things that you can see

Strongly agree. The biggest barrier between devs and refactors with zero interface impact is AGILE mentality of always aiming to deliver value to the end user with every deploy. Business people just don't understand how much of an impact crappy implementations and error handling does have on the end user. We see 5~6% error rate, which represents hundreds of thousand of people daily, but shipping a new "feature" (that within months will be used by a few hundred people with a very high bounce rate) is always the top priority.

From time to time there is a meeting with the following subject: "why are users not using the basic features", and the business people's answer is always "the ui is outdated" or "the menu is confusing the user". Those answers are gathered by talking to some random users on the streets close to the company building (I'm not making this up).

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mgkimsal on Sunday March 03, 2019 @08:54AM (#19294422)
> We see 5~6% error rate, which represents hundreds of thousand of people daily, but shipping a new "feature" (that within months will be used by a few hundred people with a very high bounce rate) is always the top priority.

seems to get back to "what gets measured" mantra. And, reminds me cell phone company churn. There's loads of things that could be done to improve service for existing customers, but companies spend budget chasing 'new' customers to 'switch' with low rates for X months, then jack up the price. "Loyal" customers get ignored.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by bobblywobbles on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:28AM (#19292924)
And then you end up with brittle applications to support. Not fun for devs. Not happy times with management.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Hendrikto on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:11AM (#19288885)
That does actually happen. Just look at the JS ecosystem.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by austincheney on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:14AM (#19289096)
As a JavaScript developer I can say that does happen, but its usually due to bad decisions from insecurity coupled with chasing trends rather than any overt act to justify thy existence.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by dsego on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:58AM (#19289956)
I actually agree. In my experience though, since the design is more visible to business people, it's easier to convince them it's needed. Tech debt gets attention when development grinds to a halt and productivity takes a toll. The other thing in my experience is that usually the dev is last in line when it comes to decision making, unless you have a strong tech person who can take control of the product vision and push back. But those people are rare since they have to wear multiple hats. Usually I see that designers make the design first based on some use case or story and the devs then get to code it.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by jgaa on Sunday March 03, 2019 @07:01AM (#19294062)
That's the beauty of free Open Source projects. Code is written when it's required. When the project does it's job, coders move on to other useful projects.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by AJ007 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:00AM (#19289269)
This is true for everyone from janitors to CEOs. The big question is, what jobs are harmless, which cause improvements being “over-worked”, and which have the greatest odds of causing substantial destruction?

UI / UX redesigns should be tested with small amounts of users, with all key metrics measured, and see what happens to those metrics and user retention after a few months. Otherwise, UI redesigns has a chance of causing a lot of destruction both by loss of users and bugs. Fortunately for software this isn’t that difficult to do. Other tasks, less so or impossible.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by sizzle on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:49PM (#19292063)
Absolutely, and testing with a diverse population with a sufficiently large sample size will yield the highest quality signal for measuring redesign success e.g. time on task, task completion, discoverability/usability, etc.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by birksherty on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:04AM (#19289061)
That's what happens in most of website redesigns.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by eswat on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:42AM (#19288800)
Maybe I’m reading too much into this. But I think you’re conflating your contempt for negative workplace politics and the aftermath of decisions you’ve experienced, with the intentions of these companies that do these redesigns.

Some of these redesigns that don’t work out well could have been worked on by brilliant people that were very cautious about what kind of work they take on. But you don’t always hit it out of the park.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by kd5bjo on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:15AM (#19288409)
I’ll agree that people never do anything without a reason, with the caveat that “It’s my boss’s pet project and he signs my paycheck” is often a good enough reason to do something.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by speedplane on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:01AM (#19288534)
If it's your boss's pet project, then your boss probably has a reason for doing it, even if it isn't a good one.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by birksherty on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:02AM (#19289058)
That reason is often promotion and putting things in the resume.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by PedroBatista on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:02AM (#19289278)
Well, that’s a pretty good reason, for him.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by TelmoMenezes on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:45AM (#19289221)
"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it." -- Upton Sinclair
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by j45 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:09AM (#19289746)
Very applicable in leadership and management in this time of disruption everywhere.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by calinet6 on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:21PM (#19287551)
I'll concede "most people are of average idiocy" and cite core principles of statistics and the meanings of average and most.

But yes, you're right, happens all the time. Less so with most of the large scale more popular redesigns people tend to think of when writing articles like this about tools they actually use; the team at Atlassian, for example, is not made of idiots, neither at Slack, Google, Twitter, or other large companies with mostly significant design experience.

Smaller operations where we all likely work—yep, hit or miss.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by camhart on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:56AM (#19287982)
I and almost everyone from my team loathes the new jira released a year+ ago. The menu drives me nuts still and makes no sense.

It's my understanding the use of the word "idiot" in this context implies someone who is primarily responsible for a significant amount of rework on anything that bears no real fruit, ui redesigns being one potential example. Pretty sure big companies make those mistakes just as much as small. Though I don't think its fair to call someone an idiot for this reason--I think its very challenging to do well.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by spease on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:54AM (#19288511)
Yeah, I specifically avoid using Atlassian as much as I can because of how tedious it is to wait ~6 seconds for every UI action to complete.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by groestl on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:54AM (#19288672)
An idiot, in the original sense of the word, is someone who focuses on themselves, showing no interest in the common cause/politics. It's a bit heavy, but reapplied here it could mean someone who focuses completely on visual quality, while not putting their time into other important aspects of the product (almost all of which are more important that visual quality, at least according to OP).
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by atoav on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:02AM (#19288696)
This is how I would describe the noun of idiotic design if it existed.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by marcosdumay on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:09PM (#19290005)
Well, if it didn't exist before, you just created it.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by groestl on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:59AM (#19288526)
Well, after the Google Cloud Console redesign of the Datastore UI, visual quality is great, but "Open in new Tab" is broken, the result tables abbreviate dates at the Month field, and in entity edits a timestamp can only be given with Minute resolution. So what should I make of that?
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by speedplane on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:08AM (#19288554)
I loved the old app engine console, it was super fast, and dumped tons of the information you needed to analyze. The new one is slower, and has plenty of UI bugs like the one you mentioned (my pet peave is CTRL+click on many links no longer opens a new tab). On the other hand, look at all the stuff they added! There must be 30 dashboards you can jump into, and yet the new UI makes navigating all of them relatively easy. The old one was great for just app engine, but it would never be able to scale to all the services they currently offer.

Also, they are relatively responsive to developer demands, at least as far as the dashboard is concerned. Not that long ago, if you wanted to export a few seconds of logs, you had to setup a Cloud SQL sink that could suck in gigabytes of logs. Not too helpful if you want to analyze just a few hundred lines. People complained, and now you can export the current view to excel/csv. They've also speeded up load times significantly (it's still not snappy though).

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by ascar on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:23AM (#19288929)
I have the feeling they force some UI and especially icon redesign with every new Android version. Not because it's necessarily or actually looks better, but just to make it different. It's mildly annoying to me. Especially since some app icons now have ugly white boarders (galaxy s9 with android 8 and even worse in 9/oneui).
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by hopler on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:04AM (#19289288)
The white borders was a gimmick to support some new transparency feature, but since Android half-does everything, it doesn't quite work. Android's openness saves the day, you can install 3rd party launcher with icon pack plugins
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by btschaegg on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:15PM (#19290325)
I absolutely love your comment on statistics.

But on the notion that large companies specifically don't have hit or miss design or redesigns: I'd argue there's more than enough evidence to the contrary. And, personally, I find Atlassian products to be a very good example of that.

Note: In this regard, I focus mainly on Don Norman's view on "design", which is largely orthogonal to aesthetics. It's cool for software to look nice. But if it's laid out in a non-intuitive way or doesn't prevent (or even provokes) user errors, it's not good design, period.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by sizzle on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:35PM (#19292553)
Absolutely, despite the best intentions of UX designers/researchers the PMs/POs (depending on org), directors and above get final say on business/technology/ final (re)design decisions, which is then broken down into the backlog for developers.

Proper (re)design initiatives need to born out of the intersection of "viability, (user) desirability, and feasibility."

Usability is only scratching the surface of how to quantify the impact of a redesign and the author doesn't acknowledge the convoluted nature of how design decisions actually get made in non design-led tech organizations. The best companies (i.e. FAANG) have data and are measuring the outcomes of design decisions before developers even get assigned the work.

From the author's vantage point and how they get assigned work, they are missing the forest for the trees.

Thoughts?

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by james_s_tayler on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:23AM (#19287727)
Yeah. It's a bit of column A and a bit of column B.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by speedplane on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:01AM (#19288529)
> In my experience people are frequently idiots, and work gets done for no reason after someone with authority is convinced that it's a good idea by someone aching to do that sort of work.

You're contradicting yourself here. If someone with authority is convinced that something is a good idea, then they have a reason for doing it. It might be a misguided reason, but it's not just randomness.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by paulryanrogers on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:59AM (#19289265)
Distinguishing between badly chosen ideas and randomly chosen ones may be impossible if the authority figure provides no context.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by calinet6 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:23AM (#19289358)
I think you’ve identified one of the root causes here. :)
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by naasking on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:29AM (#19289579)
> In reality, your conjecture turns out to be largely untrue. Visual design quality does have an impact.

Did you read the article? The author specifically says, "Before all of the UI designers that read this go out and riot and champion against me for saying UI redesigns are a waste of time, let me say that I do value design. I think at the bare minimum, a product or website needs to be usable, and if you possess a good eye and steady hand, you should feel compelled to create something that looks pleasing."

He then goes on to say, "Just stop redesigning the UI all the time. UI redesigns, in my opinion, are a waste of time 95% of the time. Let me explain further."

That's not so contentious IMO. Redesigns can be too frequent and the purported purpose of redesigns is typically nebulous, and can be driven more by politics than any of the objective metrics that you describe.

> People aren't idiots. They don't do this work for no reason. Try to understand and respect the work outside your own department and specialty.

Of course they have reasons. That doesn't make those reasons objectively correct. Maybe you should try to understand and respect the point the article is trying to convey, that perhaps the pendulum on UI redesign has swung a little too far one way.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mgkimsal on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:01AM (#19289710)
> That doesn't make those reasons objectively correct.

You don't even need to appeal to some 'objective correct' standard. You can just look more basically at "what is the purpose?" Usually, it's "increase sales". So... determine baseline metrics, perhaps implement some testing to see what changes have what effect, and then push forward a larger redesign effort if the tests moved towards the goal/purpose.

Perhaps the goal is 'reduce number of clicks'. Is that really important? Or is it 'reduce user frustration'? How will you measure that?

"Reduce page load time" - should be pretty easy to measure, but will it have an impact on other things (sales, support, etc)?

People may have 'good reasons' for a redesign. Without a measurable goal, they're a waste of time, imo, and I've often seen them do more harm than good (measurable harm, like reduced sales, customer drop off, etc). But hey - those front page pictures looked really nice in the photoshop mockups sent over...

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by js2 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:57AM (#19289955)
> Did you read the article?

Please don’t do this.

> Maybe you should try to understand

Or this. Reminder: be civil, don’t be snarky.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by naasking on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:12PM (#19290310)
Come on, literally the second paragraph of the article addresses exactly the OP's point. I also wasn't being snarky, I was applying the OP's exact argument to his own critique of the article. I'm fine with sensible moderation, but holding up a mirror on a bad comment isn't an uncivil or snarky reply.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by js2 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:48PM (#19290498)
HN guidelines specifically say:

> Please don't insinuate that someone hasn't read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that."

Your first paragraph is just as strong with its opening sentence (“Did you read the article?”) removed.

The guidelines also say:

> Don't say things you wouldn't say face-to-face.

The final sentence of your last paragraph could have been phrased: “The point the article is trying to convey is that perhaps the pendulum on UI redesign has swung a little too far one way.”

I get that you were mocking the “try to understand” from the parent comment, but your comment would have been stronger by not doing so.

> holding up a mirror on a bad comment isn't an uncivil or snarky reply.

The bulk of your comment is polite and civil, but the opening and concluding sentences are attacking the the commenter, not the comment.

($0.02. Just trying to keep things polite around here.)

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by naasking on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:05PM (#19290581)
Edit: I've erased this because I'm not going to debate rhetorical methods since this is all pointless.

HN's guidelines also suggest avoiding unrelated tangents, so this will be my last post debating rhetoric and HN guidelines.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by sekh60 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:21PM (#19290665)
I really wish Gmail would stop changing so frequently. It probably objectively isn't that bad, but having to teach older, not so tech competent relatives where things moved to is a real pain.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by pembrook on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:50PM (#19290814)
You don’t think Google is running tests on the effects of every little UI change?

Remember, their goals aren’t the same as your goals. Your goal is to get the best email tool possible. Google’s goal is to extract as much money as possible from you and your data...while still being the best alternative to competitors.

Those goals are very very different. Most of these comments are so naive. It’s almost as if most people have never seen the amount of actionable data the average digital product throws off.

A smart default assumption, especially when it comes to the big guys like google/Facebook; the UI changed because it makes the company more money.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Fins on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:47PM (#19291356)
But that assumes that the new design does make more money. I, honestly, fail to see how, e.g., moving the account switch button in the new Gmail app from left to right increases ad views. On the other hand, from all we hear about Google's promotion process, it seems quite likely that the redesign happened "just because" and somebody gets to add a checkbox to the promotion list.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by blunte on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:02AM (#19288535)
As a user, 9/10 if I notice the UI has changed, it's because I'm unhappy and feeling encumbered or lost.

It's very rare that a redesign had me saying, "Oh wow, that's so much better!"

So many UI fads have set usability back but get repeated with most redesigns... hamburger menus, login forms that hide password fields until you've entered the username, ultra minimal forms that leave the user guessing what is interactive, text fields with labels only approximated by gray text within that field, and on and on.

Many old UIs were uglier but more usable.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by calinet6 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:24AM (#19289366)
A lot of that isn’t the redesign itself, but the fact that almost no one designs for the change event itself. It’s a whole different problem to solve, and it’s usually just dropping you into something totally different without context.

Could write a whole blog post on designing for UX change. I think I’ll do that...

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by btschaegg on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:31PM (#19290418)
Note that there sadly also is a very strong effect that also can "ruin" (in principle) good redesigns for existing users: When all else fails (i.e. you are not able to guide your design by existing metaphors etc.), humans learn by repetition. That's why consistency with other products is usually not a bad idea: Search bars are usually to the top right, so when you put yours there, a new user will know where to look.

OTOH, this also means that for a user who has used your product for ten years, the fact that your search bar is, in fact, not in the top right, doesn't matter -- because they have learned where it is. If you move it, they will be upset, even if the new design might objectively be more intuitive (as in: new users have less trouble with it).

This effect can make it rather hard at times to judge if a redesign of a product you've used for a long time is in fact as bad as you believe it to be.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by marcosdumay on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:12PM (#19290023)
On phone apps, if I noticed the UI 9/10 of the times I notice a UI change it's because I opened it do do something, but all I can see is a tutorial on how to use the new UI.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by vosper on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:04PM (#19290577)
> login forms that hide password fields until you've entered the username

I've been lead to believe that this is for websites that support authentication by multiple methods. If you submit your email address first they can look it up and see that you auth with SAML, or log you in through Google, or if you login with a password they can then render that form for you.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by edoceo on Saturday March 02, 2019 @03:21PM (#19290989)
We do this with a single form, not necessary to have two steps
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by hopler on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:06AM (#19289296)
Explain why the hamburger menu is bad but the floppy disk icon is good.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Scarblac on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:23AM (#19289364)
The floppy disk icon does one thing: "Save". Everybody knows it does, because that's been its job for ages now. What it looks like is irrelevant.

The hamburger menu _replaced_ the style of menu we used to have, where all the options were under their own menus with titles ("File", and so on). That was lost. The only reason they were left behind was to make it work well on tiny screens. If you don't have a tiny screen, you just lost functionality that you were familiar with and that worked, for no reason.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by ftio on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:18AM (#19289113)
I come bearing anecdata!

At my previous company, we did a minor visual design refresh of our ancient software because our sales data showed that one of the top objections cited by prospects was that the software looked old.

Although the visual design refresh did nothing for usability, it completely eliminated that objection and enabled our sales team to focus on how our software could improve our customers’ businesses and why it was better than our competitors’. The redesign improved conversion rates.

The redesign caused a bit of consternation among existing customers, but they got over it quickly. It had no observable effect on retention/churn.

If you were a PM on my team unable to substantiate why the work you’re scheduling helps the business (by making life better for customers or by reducing purchasing friction), you wouldn’t be on my team for long. These pointless redesigns are amateur-hour stuff.

Of course, there are other legitimate reasons to do a redesign, like maintainability and developer retention/happiness, but those are much riskier and even more difficult to justify.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by wvenable on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:28PM (#19287572)
What's the difference between a re-design and constant refinement of a design?

I believe in making products aesthetically pleasing. I spend a lot of time ensuring my products look good because I know that this is the first impression of any product. I'm constantly improving the design of my products in subtle (and sometimes not subtle) ways.

Full redesigns are the design equivalent of full software rewrites. They suffer from all the same issues: second system affect, loss of functionality, loss of knowledge, etc. And like software re-writes, sometimes they are necessary but often they are not.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday March 02, 2019 @03:42AM (#19288309)
Redesigns tend to happen because someone in management decides they want to remake the UI in a way that appeals to them, whether or not it makes sense to anyone else.

The MS ribbon was a classic redesign. It broke the standard menu metaphor and crashed productivity for no good reason.

Flat design was in a similar league, but not quite as bad. Is that a button or a text element? How can anyone tell?

Refinement is a much harder challenge. Improving the aesthetics of something while making it subtly easier to use is a really difficult thing to do.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by d0100 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:30AM (#19288604)
I am guessing that only Office power users hated the MS ribbon.

I loved it, it's do much easier to find stuff if you already don't know where it is.

Great design for the casual Wordster.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by btschaegg on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:51PM (#19290515)
There are two interesting factors to the Office Ribbon and its clones.

1) You can absolutely botch it. A good example of that is Sibelius: Their Ribbon does not make any sense at all (and is in multiple instances literally a waste of space). Personally, I find the ribbon design on MS Office to be much better, though; MS has clearly put much thought and experimentation (i.e. many studies) into the concept.

2) What I find to be extremely interesting: For MS Office, the ribbon introduced better shortcuts. Since Office products are totally overloaded with functionality, the parts you don't use often were usually left behind in terms of useful shortcuts. With the Ribbon, these functionalities are usually accessible via a Spacemacs-Style mnemonic keypresses. If you use a specific functionality over and over, it's now much easier to remember a not-so-bad way to trigger it from the keyboard.

On another note:

I also find the "new" formatting context menu that pops up in MS Word whenever you select some text to be a very clever idea. It remembers me much of an old Xerox demo[1][2] that was done with a mouse and a trackball simultaneously (featuring a palette you could place around where you were currently making changes with the mouse). I'm convinced that to this day, there's a lot of ignored potential in that concept.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VpTFcItyE9w [2]: https://www.billbuxton.com/TGtaxonomy.html

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by atoav on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:03AM (#19288700)
yeah but it is software: ehy not serve both?
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by duckmysick on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:37AM (#19288790)
Because it's software. Additional options mean additional code, which leads to increased complexity and burden on maintenance. And it's not a linear increase.

It doesn't mean you can't add new features (or code), but doing so leads to trade-offs.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Spooky23 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:30AM (#19289584)
Only a specific set of grumpy people of a specific age give any shits about it.

The real difference with the ribbon is that computing shifted from professionals and workers to everyone. The audience that cares about old style windows menus is vocal and tiny. Users struggled to discover, locate and remember items in the old menus. Many users struggled to find the menu.

That said, the Mac menu system is the best implementation of that type of menu delivery.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by icelancer on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:40AM (#19288630)
> The MS ribbon was a classic redesign. It broke the standard menu metaphor and crashed productivity for no good reason.

I thought I'd eventually get used to it. Nope. It's still significantly less productive than a standard menu.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by hawaiianbrah on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:15AM (#19289099)
Why’s that? Aren’t there shortcuts for about everything?
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by vbezhenar on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:36AM (#19289418)
I have office installed, but I'm not using it often, so I have no idea about its shortcuts and I'm not going to learn them. Menu allows discovery. If you're smart enough, usually you can find your way to required feature via discovery. Ribbons have less items than menu and they are not very well organized (there's only one level of hierarchy), so I'm often stuck not able to find something.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by wvenable on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:28PM (#19290098)
Everything is on the ribbon. Once you understand that, it actually becomes a lot easier to use.

If you think menu's promote discovery better, you haven't looked at the Visual Studio menus in a while.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by hopler on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:14AM (#19289323)
Ribbon may have been a bad idea, but MS claimed they did a bunch of UX research around it. Why is the standard menu metaphor better? Hunting through a hundred menu items whose names I don't need is a pain, especially if I don't have years of experience learning the options.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by vbezhenar on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:39AM (#19289429)
But ribbon does not present those hundred items in a better way. It just presents most used items and rest are gone to some dark place. And those most used items already were present on toolbars.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by wvenable on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:31PM (#19290111)
Every option that was on the menu is in the ribbon, there is no dark place. In fact, the ribbon probably surfaces even more options.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by ghaff on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:56AM (#19289947)
I saw a presentation at Mix once where they went through the redesign process in detail. For myself, and many others, the end result wasn’t great—and not only because it was different—but there was study behind it.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by kevingadd on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:45PM (#19287616)
Most redesigns I've dealt with are the result of someone wanting a promotion, which has nothing to do with whether or not they're an idiot. Many of those people ship bad or half-baked redesigns that waste everyone's time but get them a promotion, because you need achievements to point to in order to get promoted at companies like Google.

That aside, your post mostly fails to address the critiques in the OP. Yes, a pleasing UI tends to feel better to use, but most of these pretty redesigns throw away important other traits an old design had, or just simply lack them. It's hard to positively compare (for example) New Gmail with Old Gmail when they managed to make it slower and break the reply button, for example.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by michaelmrose on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:15AM (#19288048)
It is damn near amazing how fast old Gmail is did you know that you can still use it?

It uses like a mb of ram and loads instantly.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by christophilus on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:55AM (#19289254)
How do you use the old Gmail? I hate, hate, hate the new one.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by jazzyjackson on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:30PM (#19290415)
They hide it behind this strange URL

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/h/1pq68r75kzvdr/

You should see a banner with an option to 'set basic HTML as default view' across the top.

It's great. You see all the information - nothing hidden behind icons, and page loads between screens actually take less time than with a SPA.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by WalterSear on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:41PM (#19291577)
Wow.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by magicalhippo on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:39AM (#19288986)
> Main principle you want to look up: the Aesthetic Usability Effect. Basically, users perceive your product to be more usable if it's aesthetically pleasing.

Well that explains a few things. Many a time have I experienced a UI remake looking great but being absolutely horrible to use.

Take for example Google+, where they tried a last ditch effort to make it more popular by doing a UI update. They made it look really slick, but in the process made it much, much worse to actually use. I used to be an active G+ user (yeah, I know) but after they forced me to use the new UI I stopped using it, it was that bad.

Another example is Acronis TrueImage, which completely redid their UI, making it much more visually pleasing and up-to-date. Initially I thought it was great, but then I noticed that certain processes were a lot more tedious to do, and they'd also removed a lot of functionally in the process.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by rarecoil on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:57AM (#19287985)
> I've seen many redesigns and that tends not to be something people do—there's usually a good bump in visual quality in the process.

So really, the important point is that you can gain affordances for usability sins if you have a design that is appealing to people as modern or otherwise trendy.

By the same process: if you have a design that was 100% usable, then redesign and end up making usability mistakes, there's a good chance you'll see net-zero or negative from the prettier UI in your testing.

For the majority of companies that do not have focus groups, usability labs, and a design staff that can spend cycles on R&D, it seems you may be better off doing little more than reskinning existing UI controls to maintain trendiness than full-scale re-wires of your existing product at any time to maximize the aesthetic-usability effect for minimal design work. Examples you cite in a sibling comment have cash to burn on exactly this, however I think that is the exception rather than the norm for businesses at large.

Visual (aesthetic) design change buys goodwill, reinforces and differentiates brand image, but IMO is mostly a marketing tool at the end of the day. I see product design and visual design as sister disciplines that must communicate, similar to two people running a three-legged race, but it is easy to improve one or the other separately from the other in most iterative scenarios. Large-scale redesigns are usually risky, and Snapchat's a great high-profile example of a company that was able to hire talent and let that process go off the rails.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by conanbatt on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:25PM (#19290087)
> People aren't idiots. They don't do this work for no reason. Try to understand and respect the work outside your own department and specialty. Building respect across those boundaries is a rare and valuable thing.

I wouldn't frame it this way, but there are many confounding things in measuring a change in the UI design.

I jumped from web consumer to operations, and the mindset is so different: in web, you have shallow actions that you want things to be easier and look aesthetically pleasing. In operations you want deep actions that require reliability or learning, and that require every or many users to do it, changing the UI is a nightmare for them. It has to be vastly better to compensate the change. And not only that, you need your operations to be more efficient than your competition: a bad ui can cause issues in an entire company.

In consumer-web, pages like reddit changes their entire UI to have posts read in the same page and its use-it or lose-it. Consumer web cruises along the monopolistic positions they have to spend resources without visible consequence. Who cares if reddit's ui is 10% snazzier or 10% snappier? It's not like the reddit user will stop using it because of it. That redesign happened in a company that raised half a billion dollars.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mannykannot on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:01AM (#19287656)
I have used a quite a lot of online retail sites, and for me, the thing that most distinguishes the good from the bad is the quality of their search features, in giving me the tools to focus on relevant results.

The most visible feature of many of the sites I visit are the attempts to get me to do something other than what I went to the site for.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Aegaeus10111 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:01AM (#19288362)
I'd like to point out that the search and how the results are displayed are part of the design - and can be the major bit. UI design isn't only, often not even primarily, about aesthetics.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by TheCoelacanth on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:06PM (#19290285)
UI redesigns frequently are primarily about aesthetics. You don't have to completely redesign your site to redesign your search.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Aegaeus10111 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:52AM (#19295006)
Sometimes, sure. And sometimes aesthetics are vital. That doesn't say anything about UI design in general though, only a subset of cases.

It's possible you may need to redo UI for new search. If I add faceted search or geo search, for example in my search update, I may well need to redo the UI in a way much more fundamental than aesthetics.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mannykannot on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:01PM (#19290248)
Bad UI design might cripple a good search capability, but UI design cannot fix a weak one.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Aegaeus10111 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:49AM (#19294986)
True. But you might as well say the same about an umbrella not keeping mosquitoes away.

UI design doesn't involve BE design in any way. So?

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mannykannot on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @07:29AM (#19318365)
So you are saying UI is not involved in the most important measure of quality of a retail site - that is the point, and the answer to your "so?" (though, personally, I would not make the distinction as stark as you have, here.)
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Waterluvian on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:14AM (#19289324)
The fundamental challenge I have with UX and UX people is that there's clearly a lot of really important, useful stuff in the discipline, mixed with a lot of nonsense. And I've been burned a few times by those who tell a good story to susceptible executives and utterly waste time and resources to justify their own existence.

I wish there were better resources for non UX people like me to learn how to tell the difference.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by azhenley on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:19AM (#19289346)
What you describe is true in any area, including software developers.

You could just start learning about UX. It’ll make you a better engineer!

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Waterluvian on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:28AM (#19289384)
I think you're partly right that it is true in any area. But I don't think it's equally true in every area, and I think that UX lends itself a bit more to subjective artsyness than software development.

But I generally agree with your sentiment; you can absolutely find "just trust me" in software development. You can also probably smell it out better by learning about it more.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by azhenley on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:31AM (#19289401)
If you do want to stay away from the “artsy” side, search for “usability engineering” and “interaction design”.

You’ll find a lot more about empirically driven methods to evaluate your UI, mostly from a productivity perspective. I personally find it fascinating!

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by madeofpalk on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:34AM (#19289413)
> more to subjective artsyness than software development.

You would think so, but the amount of 'developer superstition' and and 'gut feeling' I've faced in development is quite high.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by werber on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:19AM (#19289345)
When UX veers away from research and data it gets nasty. I think the situation you're describing is something that happens when their isn't full buy in from the stake holders on the value of that research
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by calinet6 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:21AM (#19289352)
I do, too. It’s a growing field, and it’s much more muddy than dev. Give us time.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Aeolun on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:27AM (#19288597)
In my experience, only about 40% of redesigns actually are a visual upgrade. All the others are just a visual change.

Visual changes are irrelevant at best, and actively harmful at worst.

By all means, improve the website and the design, but actually improve it.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by pdonis on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:29AM (#19287749)
> Visual design quality does have an impact.

A negative one, based on what you quote:

"This aesthetic-usability effect can mask UI problems and can prevent issue discovery during usability testing."

Which seems to be saying that the uglier you make your UI, the better your chances of having actual usability issues surface.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Mtinie on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:28AM (#19288764)
This is the reason design isn’t a simple concept. The non-aesthetic portions of the effort (contextual and ethnographic research, information architecture, general usability, workflows, requirement generation, etc.) need to be done just so those warts can be exposed.

After the fundamentals are solid it’s then important to apply appropriate aesthetic and interactive elements to polish the experience.

Simply jumping to visual design after skipping the fundamentals is nearly assuring a failure. It would be akin to worrying about performance and scaling of product’s database and API without first considering if the data schemas and underlying technology stack even meet the operational needs.

Addendum: “Evolutionary design” instead of “revolutionary design” is typically preferred if one would like to keep a connection between how something was done before and the (hopefully) improved version.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by christophilus on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:04AM (#19289287)
I do tend to avoid sites that look too old. But I also avoid sites that are too slow. I'm no longer a Gmail user for this reason, for example, and I'm only a Reddit user because (thank God) there's still old.reddit.com. Can I just advocate for one thing? Make performance the #1 priority of any redesign (or at least a very, very high priority).
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by cousin_it on Sunday March 03, 2019 @08:05AM (#19294260)
When designers try to justify themselves, they commit many sins, but performance problems are usually due to programmers trying to justify themselves.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mrighele on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:09AM (#19288557)
> Basically, users perceive your product to be more usable if it's aesthetically pleasing.

On the other side, it will be less usable while i have to relearn how to use it. This is not an issue if it happens from time to time, you pay upfront a decrease of productivity and will be rewarded greatly later on. But in the era of SaaS we are constantly subject to a stream of redesigns, sometimes small, other times global. You cannot finish adapting to a change that another comes.

I don't know about others, but for me is deeply frustrating.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by speedplane on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:23AM (#19288587)
I don't mind functional UI updates (e.g., adding a search bar, when previously you had to scroll). But design changes are made simply for design purposes by big-tech companies are frustrating because when they do an update, it puts pressure on everyone else to follow their design to avoid looking out of date.

For example, just a few months ago, Google used square rectangles for the search bar, and advocated "cards" with sharp corners in their material design standards. However, just recently, they updated gmail and google search to use rounded rectangles in the search bar instead of rectangles. Are rectangles better or worse than rounded rectangles? Yes? No? The answer is, it doesn't matter for usability. But because Google is so big and has such influence, now, if your site uses a rectangular search bar with sharp corners users will perceive it as "dated".

There are many similar examples of this. Microsoft's metro UI was cool and popular for maybe a full 6 months. Clean Helvetica font was everyone's aspiration, then Google pushed Lato, and now it's Robato, until they change their mind again. Small 11pt font used to be the norm, then very large readable 14pt font was the norm, and now we're back to something like 12pt. Single page applications a while ago were avoided, then became so popular they were effectively a pre-requisite, and now they should only be used "where appropriate".

I think Google make these changes not to make their site look good and refreshing, but to make everyone else's look old and dated.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by hopler on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:26AM (#19289379)
Round rects are better. Apple established that 30 years ago. Sharp corners are a fad that Microsoft(!) started with Windows Phone/10 just to be different from Apple (their chronic problem of trying to compete by doing randomly different things) and the Googlee going for it with cards, before they realized rounded rects are preferred for a reason. (And cards, what an innovation, copying the original desktop application GUI language from cascading/tiling window systems and HyperCard
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by speedplane on Sunday March 03, 2019 @04:24AM (#19293573)
> Round rects are better. Apple established that 30 years ago.

They did? Their iPhones went from rounded corners, to sharp corners, back to rounded corners again. Apple design is impressive, but I don't see any timeless consistency.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by user5994461 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:19AM (#19289549)
Why is it better? What is the reason it's preferred?
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Spooky23 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:35AM (#19289600)
It’s less visually jarring and doesn’t feel malleable.

Find another human interface that consists of sharp edged shapes. That design aesthetic is like brutalist UI. Pretty for the architect, but few others are moved.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by speedplane on Sunday March 03, 2019 @05:52AM (#19293832)
It's not at all obvious that rounded rectangles are superior to sharp edges.

Sharp edges convey precision, rounded edges convey approximation. Many mechanical knobs and buttons have clear notches and clicks to make clear to the user they are in control of the machine.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by renox on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:52PM (#19291623)
Uh? The reasons you're giving don't feel very convincing.. (I have no opinion on what is better)
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by ferongr on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:48PM (#19290802)
Please provide proof.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by bobblywobbles on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:18AM (#19292886)
You sparked a lot of comments in this post.

Thank you for explaining these concepts to me, I have not heard of the aesthetic usability effect. I will read into this as I am curious what it is now.

To be clear, I do value design. I think design is important and I write that out in the article that I value design. What I struggle to value are redesigns, that is, complete redesigns of a UI - instead preferring incremental updates of the UX that is necessary to use the product or application.

Thank you for the work that you've done, as I'm sure you have had a great impact on the customers you've directly and indirectly served. Continue to do design, because if it were up to me, nothing would look good at all.

Cheers.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:44AM (#19289438)
> Basically, users perceive your product to be more usable if it's aesthetically pleasing.

Of course perception and reality are different things. And I imagine that effect is only really true for, at best, some slight statistical majority. Certainly I know a lot of people who've stuck with older versions of software because it looks and works like they've come to expect, and I myself tend to judge the usability of new software by how much it looks like a Win95 application.

The thing I love most about only developing software for in-house use (because my company doesn't sell software) is that nobody really cares what it looks like.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by maxhallinan on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:46AM (#19289003)
How does the Aesthetic Usability Effect account for the success of websites like Amazon, Wikipedia, Craigslist, Hacker News, classic Reddit, and LinkedIn, to name a few? There seems to be no correlation between aesthetic quality and use of these sites. I'm not sure what that indicates about the "usability" of these sites. If the goal is to maximize the number of users, it would seem that there is some evidence that a sense of usability determined by aesthetic quality is not that important.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by username223 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:20AM (#19289554)
I know this will never happen, but it would be interesting to see the percentage of Reddit users who took the time to opt out of the new "improved" interface. I suspect that number is small, because most people have learned to just quietly sigh and accept random UI changes, but larger than the Reddit UI team would care to admit.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by gwern on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:45AM (#19289639)
If you are a moderator of a reasonably popular subreddit, you can find out by checking the traffic statistics which breaks out old vs new! For example, for my little link-sharing subreddit (https://www.reddit.com/r/gwern/) : https://imgur.com/a/sUcEQeQ

You can see a large fraction of the users have taken the time to optout, perhaps as much as a third (!) of those who can. Considering how passive most users are, this tells me that the new & expensive Reddit design is indeed loathed.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by plorkyeran on Saturday March 02, 2019 @03:08PM (#19290912)
Reddit tries pretty hard to force you back onto the new design, too. When not using old.reddit.com it "forgets" that I opted out of the redesign on a regular basis, and even old.reddit.com occasionally redirects to the new design.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by gwern on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:55PM (#19292266)
I think that might be a bug. That was happening to me on a daily or more frequent basis for a while, but I don't think I've had to redo the opt-out in like a week.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by username223 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:09PM (#19290007)
Thanks! 1/3 opting out is indeed damning. I'm surprised they made those stats public. Hopefully a moderator of /r/programming, /r/news, /r/politics, or some other mega-popular subreddit will post their stats.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Retra on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:49AM (#19289013)
People aren't using those sites because of their UIs, but because of the content they offer. UI isn't the only factor, but it is a necessary factor.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by logifail on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:15AM (#19289100)
> UI isn't the only factor, but it is a necessary factor.

Necessary for what (or for whom)?

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Retra on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:22PM (#19291755)
A UI is necessary for users to use your product. That doesn't mean the UI is your product.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by ThomPete on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:45AM (#19289218)
Ive done this for more than 20 years too and i dont think the article is as wrong as you seem to think. In general designers seem to think that design is a much more important aapect than it actually is. Sucessful redesigns arent about improving the percieved value or respect the work outside your own department. They are about solving specific problems that hinder business to be optimal. When you start asking people to respect your work as a blanket statement, you lose mine.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Spooky23 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:23AM (#19289564)
People aren’t idiots, but reinventing the front end is like starting over and needs to be done in one fell swoop.

Usually that means redesign on the quick which always equals missed features. The classic example is when everyone jumped on responsive web design. Many applications and sites ended up including 80% of the elements of the desktop page and dropping other elements. Like my bank, who eliminated the ability to see your routing number and account number.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by werber on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:01AM (#19289272)
UI !== UX, without the research side it is kinda pointless. I'm not sure if the point of the article was to say that but it's what I read
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Theodores on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:04AM (#19289504)
Thank goodness someone has chimed in with this. The original article has no mention of UX.

UI developers are getting marched out the door at a well known publisher right now, their services no longer needed. UX is a different story with this mystery publisher, they now get to call a lot of the shots.

There is a bigger discussion to be had regarding the whole visual design process. In 2006 when you could have your navigation in any corner of the screen with any design for the search icon it made sense to have UI designers add their special flourishes. Now we know where the navigation goes and what the icon is for search, that has all been settled. User experience still needs some people to take care of it as we can't leave that up to the programmers, can we?

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by sh87 on Monday March 04, 2019 @12:35AM (#19299026)
As a user I have not come across any good 'visual' redesign. On the contrary, it annoys me. Immensely; when the fking redesign replaces my known problems for unknown ones.

As an example, as contractors, we fill up timesheets very often. Our company decided to move to another 'aesthetically pleasing' platform which to me as a user is same as a redesign. Now the click - tab - 8 - tab - space - cmd+w ritual is taken away. It now goes like this : load page - login - click link - click a drop down - wait for it to timeout (dont even ask me why) - click again and wait for the dropdown to populate and close itself - click again - select - click - 8 - click save - find the mini'x' - click - select another dropdown - click submit (no, space no longer works on this form).

This new platform has more options, more whitespace, more corporate colors. Agreed. No colors, whitespace your redesign could add will soothe the agony of poor usability.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by doodpants on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:15AM (#19289537)
> Cool, cool. To preface this comment, I'm a user experience designer, and I've been doing web software development and design for over 20 years.

Cool, cool. To preface this comment, I'm a guy who owns a computer and uses software.

Most GUI redesigns I've seen in the past 10 years make the interface prettier, but LESS usable. The new design usually incoroporates three categories of changes:

1. Lists of items are rendered in a larger font with more spacing between items, leading to lower information density, thus requiring more scrolling. (For bonus points, often a window that has a scrollable area isn't resizable, so you're stuck with whatever arbitrary viewport size the designer decided was large enough.)

2. Controls that used to always be visible are now hidden until you hover or click the right spot. This is done to reduce "clutter", as though controls are somehow graffiti.

3. A bunch of convenient shortcuts enjoyed by long-time power users weren't reimplimented in the new design, because the designer didn't know about them, or simply didn't think they mattered.

I have a WordPress blog. WordPress recently overhauled their entire editing UI, and I hate it. When I started the blog several years ago, I was able to figure out how to use WordPress by exploring the UI. The new UI is an extreme example of #2; when you go to write a new post, the page is entirely blank. You have to click somewhere to get a text cursor, and there isn't even a visually delineated text area before you do so. There are a couple of features I had to hunt around for, and I wouldn't have even known those features existed if I hadn't learned them from the old UI, which presented them front and center.

My company uses JIRA for bug tracking. They switched to a new GUI a while back, and I hate it. It's harder to find things that used to be presented front and center. And as an example of #3: It used to be possible to just type an issue number like "392" in the search box, hit Enter, and be brought immediately to that issue page. Not anymore; if you do that quickly, you get a "no results found" page. If you type the number and then wait a couple of seconds, you get a list of search results, which you can then click on. Pressing Enter then takes you to the first one, but often that is NOT issue #392, it's just some issue that happens to have the text "392" somewhere in it. So you have to eyeball the search results, and then click the right one. The old way was more convenient. Fortunately, I eventually found the preference to switch back to the old GUI, which they helpfully give you because they apparently realize that the new GUI sucks. (I don't know offhand if it reverts the search behavior, because I've already changed my habits to not use it anymore.)

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by tootie on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:33AM (#19289851)
Last place I worked did a skunkworks redesign project in their primary e-commerce site and A/B tested it against the existing site (which was perfectly decent) and recorded a consistently higher conversion rate. They could easily put an 8-figure value on the redesign which cost in the high 6-figures to design and implement.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by zzzcpan on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:23AM (#19289133)
> Users are more tolerant of __minor__ usability issues

Let's be honest, aesthetic-usability effect is too insignificant to ever prioritize aesthetics over usability and pretty much no company in the world can benefit from it. It's just a justification for producing pretty looking interfaces with awful UX, because UX is hard, a typical designer on the market likely can't even do it and eye candy is more easily sellable in hierarchical organizations, where everyone can impress their bosses all the way to the top.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by sonnyblarney on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:24PM (#19287559)
"users perceive your product to be more usable if it's aesthetically pleasing."

Of course, in the first 10 seconds or few minutes, but I suspect strongly this effect fades over time.

Most UI redesigns are bad because they focus on the wrong things and throw out a lot of good things, or change for the sake of change.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by pfranz on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:35PM (#19287589)
At a previous job I would see the process of films getting made. After a year of keeping the same joke they'd swap it out with a less funny joke. It's not because the new joke is better, the old joke got tired to them and the new joke was fresh.

I see the same thing happen all over the place--branding and UI are very common victims.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by sonnyblarney on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:10AM (#19287687)
That's a very interesting insight.

Music editing has the same issues as well. Even in the short term - over the course of a day your ears can get tired of a specific set of sounds and you don't hear with 'fresh ears'.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by eswat on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:48AM (#19288824)
That’s a cool example. In terms of UI redesigns though, changing things up is definitely more costly in this realm.

I probably don’t mind a new skit because I’m just looking to be entertained. But I’m mostly looking to get shit done with something that had an actual UI to it, so freshness can be more hit-or-miss.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by thaumasiotes on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:48AM (#19287958)
> Of course, in the first 10 seconds or few minutes, but I suspect strongly this effect fades over time.

This is part of the general phenomenon of looking for your keys under the lamppost.

It's easy to do an experiment that tests how people feel about your new design after looking at it for a minute and a half. Want to compare how people feel about the old and new designs after six months of getting used to them? That will take at least six months.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by ProxCoques on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:46AM (#19288129)
You are confusing aesthetics with usability. Useful tests are not designed to find out how people feel about a design, but whether those people can complete task(s) they need to do with the design. The latter is usually apparent within an hour, and most of the problems surface once you have tested about 5-6 people.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by thaumasiotes on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:20AM (#19289555)
I'm not confusing anything. Whether people can complete tasks they need to perform is a major influence on how they feel about a design. And where they prefer an approach that makes the task harder rather than easier, that is still valuable information, and the appropriate response can easily be to give them the approach they prefer.

But I'm going to disagree that an hour is enough to reveal any advantages and disadvantages that may be present.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by WalterSear on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:43PM (#19291584)
You are confusing the first time experience with usability.

And unless the software is quite simplistic, 5-6 people is just enough to falsely validate the preconceptions of the UX designer.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Jack000 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @03:16AM (#19288237)
if your product is a website, the average time on page is 4.6 seconds [1] (a lot of people bounce immediately, lowering the average)

the first 10 seconds of ux is extremely important, since it's basically the top of your funnel.

[1] https://www.weidert.com/whole_brain_marketing_blog/bid/11696...

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by sonnyblarney on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:09AM (#19288395)
Yes, fully agree.

However, as people start to actually use the site, I think they care a lot less about a lot of cosmetic things.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by badfrog on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:00AM (#19289270)
> as people start to actually use the site, I think they care a lot less about a lot of cosmetic things

That's definitely true, _if_ they start to actually use the site. You need something to hook them in the first few seconds.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by deepstream on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:28AM (#19288598)
Funny thing about AUE is that it hides usability issues. People get dazzled by the look, and feel it's better than it is.

This means the OP is correct. New paint doesn't make it more useful. To really help users, optimize for usable design, not just aesthetics.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by aclissold on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:53AM (#19288667)
Why not both?
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by bloomer on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:39AM (#19288797)
Limited time and resources
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by calinet6 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:27AM (#19289383)
There is a balance. If aesthetics are a limiting factor, as determined by research, then they’re worth improving.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by gjs278 on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:37PM (#19287596)
I bet you have ruined several designs that were perfectly fine
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by AsyncAwait on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:07AM (#19289737)
> Cool, cool. To preface this comment, I'm a user experience designer, and I've been doing web software development and design for over 20 years.

This seems like a call to seniority. Just because you've been there for X more years doesn't make your input automatically more valid. I get his disclaimer i.e. 'I am not a designer', but yours just feels a bit like bragging.