Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time
by hopler on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:26AM
(#19289379)
Round rects are better. Apple established that 30 years ago. Sharp corners are a fad that Microsoft(!) started with Windows Phone/10 just to be different from Apple (their chronic problem of trying to compete by doing randomly different things) and the Googlee going for it with cards, before they realized rounded rects are preferred for a reason. (And cards, what an innovation, copying the original desktop application GUI language from cascading/tiling window systems and HyperCard
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time
by speedplane on Sunday March 03, 2019 @04:24AM
(#19293573)
> Round rects are better. Apple established that 30 years ago.
They did? Their iPhones went from rounded corners, to sharp corners, back to rounded corners again. Apple design is impressive, but I don't see any timeless consistency.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time
by user5994461 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:19AM
(#19289549)
Why is it better? What is the reason it's preferred?
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time
by Spooky23 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:35AM
(#19289600)
It’s less visually jarring and doesn’t feel malleable.
Find another human interface that consists of sharp edged shapes. That design aesthetic is like brutalist UI. Pretty for the architect, but few others are moved.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time
by speedplane on Sunday March 03, 2019 @05:52AM
(#19293832)
It's not at all obvious that rounded rectangles are superior to sharp edges.
Sharp edges convey precision, rounded edges convey approximation. Many mechanical knobs and buttons have clear notches and clicks to make clear to the user they are in control of the machine.
Uh? The reasons you're giving don't feel very convincing..
(I have no opinion on what is better)
For example, just a few months ago, Google used square rectangles for the search bar, and advocated "cards" with sharp corners in their material design standards. However, just recently, they updated gmail and google search to use rounded rectangles in the search bar instead of rectangles. Are rectangles better or worse than rounded rectangles? Yes? No? The answer is, it doesn't matter for usability. But because Google is so big and has such influence, now, if your site uses a rectangular search bar with sharp corners users will perceive it as "dated".
There are many similar examples of this. Microsoft's metro UI was cool and popular for maybe a full 6 months. Clean Helvetica font was everyone's aspiration, then Google pushed Lato, and now it's Robato, until they change their mind again. Small 11pt font used to be the norm, then very large readable 14pt font was the norm, and now we're back to something like 12pt. Single page applications a while ago were avoided, then became so popular they were effectively a pre-requisite, and now they should only be used "where appropriate".
I think Google make these changes not to make their site look good and refreshing, but to make everyone else's look old and dated.