I loved it, it's do much easier to find stuff if you already don't know where it is.
Great design for the casual Wordster.
1) You can absolutely botch it. A good example of that is Sibelius: Their Ribbon does not make any sense at all (and is in multiple instances literally a waste of space). Personally, I find the ribbon design on MS Office to be much better, though; MS has clearly put much thought and experimentation (i.e. many studies) into the concept.
2) What I find to be extremely interesting: For MS Office, the ribbon introduced better shortcuts. Since Office products are totally overloaded with functionality, the parts you don't use often were usually left behind in terms of useful shortcuts. With the Ribbon, these functionalities are usually accessible via a Spacemacs-Style mnemonic keypresses. If you use a specific functionality over and over, it's now much easier to remember a not-so-bad way to trigger it from the keyboard.
On another note:
I also find the "new" formatting context menu that pops up in MS Word whenever you select some text to be a very clever idea. It remembers me much of an old Xerox demo[1][2] that was done with a mouse and a trackball simultaneously (featuring a palette you could place around where you were currently making changes with the mouse). I'm convinced that to this day, there's a lot of ignored potential in that concept.
[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VpTFcItyE9w [2]: https://www.billbuxton.com/TGtaxonomy.html
It doesn't mean you can't add new features (or code), but doing so leads to trade-offs.
The real difference with the ribbon is that computing shifted from professionals and workers to everyone. The audience that cares about old style windows menus is vocal and tiny. Users struggled to discover, locate and remember items in the old menus. Many users struggled to find the menu.
That said, the Mac menu system is the best implementation of that type of menu delivery.
I thought I'd eventually get used to it. Nope. It's still significantly less productive than a standard menu.
If you think menu's promote discovery better, you haven't looked at the Visual Studio menus in a while.
The MS ribbon was a classic redesign. It broke the standard menu metaphor and crashed productivity for no good reason.
Flat design was in a similar league, but not quite as bad. Is that a button or a text element? How can anyone tell?
Refinement is a much harder challenge. Improving the aesthetics of something while making it subtly easier to use is a really difficult thing to do.