News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by inertiatic on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:10PM (#19287510)
>People aren't idiots. They don't do this work for no reason.

Citation absolutely needed. In my experience people are frequently idiots, and work gets done for no reason after someone with authority is convinced that it's a good idea by someone aching to do that sort of work.

If it happens in so many other cases, it does happen in UI/UX as well.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by dsego on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:28AM (#19288766)
Job security, designers can only design, so that's what they do. And if there is nothing new to design, they will keep redesigning. Gotta keep up with the trends.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by pembrook on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:02AM (#19288853)
Coders can only code, so that's what they do. Even if there's no new features needed or the old software is working fine as is, they will keep refactoring. Gotta keep up with the trends.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by oftenwrong on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:50AM (#19289015)
I'd agree. Given the opportunity, programmers will often work without regard to business needs. For example, rewriting an old codebase using their favourite new stack.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by brobdingnagians on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:00AM (#19289707)
Totally agree, and for managers who have programmers on staff they will keep making up features without thinking about whether it is a good idea. You start getting "features" crammed in because they have to pay the programmers to do _something_.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by calinet6 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:28PM (#19290405)
This is such a real thing that happens, yep.

It's really hard to get people together to make good software. I think that's something everyone can agree on.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mgkimsal on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:05AM (#19289726)
> For example, rewriting an old codebase using their favourite new stack.

Sometimes that is a business need, but the rest of the business doesn't recognize it (or won't until it's too late). Yes, having your website running on coldfusion 5 isn't actually a problem - data comes in, data goes out, orders are filled (ecommerce, for example). If the actual business needs didn't change ever... there would not be a need to ever refactor/rebuild.

And yes, I've seen "needless" refactoring, without regard for business needs. But there are folks who do understand some of the needs of the business before the other business units may realize it themselves.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by gnagatomo on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:24PM (#19291986)
>Sometimes that _is_ a business need, but the rest of the business doesn't recognize it (or won't until it's too late).

This. I work for a big payment system company. They had to buy another Exadata, reaching the maximum plan offered by Oracle. The refactor was delayed so much that now we have little more than one year to rewrite everything. If we don't make it in due time no more transactions will be processed. Some devs who pointed the need for a refactor left the company in the last two years and said it feels like a time bomb ticking with every git commit.

Meanwhile the UI/UX guys are trying to create a design system whilst redesigning the internet banking system and app, backed by the CPO and CTO (!?). I mean, I'm not the one calling the shots, but neither a deisgn system nor redesign should be a priority for a least two years.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mgkimsal on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:25PM (#19292342)
Yep. I can't say I've worked on data at that scale, but the 'every commit is a time bomb' - had that feeling on things.

What has bugged me in the past (and why I don't like being just a 'coder') is that... hey - people in my position have a perspective few others have. Sometimes we can see things that others can't, and generally we're smart enough to understand the business impact. If you're being asked to implement 'business logic' all day, for months or years, at some point, whether you want it or not, you can see how a business is being impacted by things that you can see. Raising a flag like "hey, xyz should probably be a priority..." and being dismissed because you're just a coder and don't understand the business - besides being insulting, sort of doesn't really jive with reality. In many cases, the software team are the only people that actually have a strong understanding of 'the business' - how many of the pieces fit together, etc.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by gnagatomo on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:16PM (#19292478)
>you can see how a business is being impacted by things that you can see

Strongly agree. The biggest barrier between devs and refactors with zero interface impact is AGILE mentality of always aiming to deliver value to the end user with every deploy. Business people just don't understand how much of an impact crappy implementations and error handling does have on the end user. We see 5~6% error rate, which represents hundreds of thousand of people daily, but shipping a new "feature" (that within months will be used by a few hundred people with a very high bounce rate) is always the top priority.

From time to time there is a meeting with the following subject: "why are users not using the basic features", and the business people's answer is always "the ui is outdated" or "the menu is confusing the user". Those answers are gathered by talking to some random users on the streets close to the company building (I'm not making this up).

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by mgkimsal on Sunday March 03, 2019 @08:54AM (#19294422)
> We see 5~6% error rate, which represents hundreds of thousand of people daily, but shipping a new "feature" (that within months will be used by a few hundred people with a very high bounce rate) is always the top priority.

seems to get back to "what gets measured" mantra. And, reminds me cell phone company churn. There's loads of things that could be done to improve service for existing customers, but companies spend budget chasing 'new' customers to 'switch' with low rates for X months, then jack up the price. "Loyal" customers get ignored.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by bobblywobbles on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:28AM (#19292924)
And then you end up with brittle applications to support. Not fun for devs. Not happy times with management.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by Hendrikto on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:11AM (#19288885)
That does actually happen. Just look at the JS ecosystem.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by austincheney on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:14AM (#19289096)
As a JavaScript developer I can say that does happen, but its usually due to bad decisions from insecurity coupled with chasing trends rather than any overt act to justify thy existence.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by dsego on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:58AM (#19289956)
I actually agree. In my experience though, since the design is more visible to business people, it's easier to convince them it's needed. Tech debt gets attention when development grinds to a halt and productivity takes a toll. The other thing in my experience is that usually the dev is last in line when it comes to decision making, unless you have a strong tech person who can take control of the product vision and push back. But those people are rare since they have to wear multiple hats. Usually I see that designers make the design first based on some use case or story and the devs then get to code it.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by jgaa on Sunday March 03, 2019 @07:01AM (#19294062)
That's the beauty of free Open Source projects. Code is written when it's required. When the project does it's job, coders move on to other useful projects.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by AJ007 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:00AM (#19289269)
This is true for everyone from janitors to CEOs. The big question is, what jobs are harmless, which cause improvements being “over-worked”, and which have the greatest odds of causing substantial destruction?

UI / UX redesigns should be tested with small amounts of users, with all key metrics measured, and see what happens to those metrics and user retention after a few months. Otherwise, UI redesigns has a chance of causing a lot of destruction both by loss of users and bugs. Fortunately for software this isn’t that difficult to do. Other tasks, less so or impossible.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by sizzle on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:49PM (#19292063)
Absolutely, and testing with a diverse population with a sufficiently large sample size will yield the highest quality signal for measuring redesign success e.g. time on task, task completion, discoverability/usability, etc.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by birksherty on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:04AM (#19289061)
That's what happens in most of website redesigns.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by eswat on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:42AM (#19288800)
Maybe I’m reading too much into this. But I think you’re conflating your contempt for negative workplace politics and the aftermath of decisions you’ve experienced, with the intentions of these companies that do these redesigns.

Some of these redesigns that don’t work out well could have been worked on by brilliant people that were very cautious about what kind of work they take on. But you don’t always hit it out of the park.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by kd5bjo on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:15AM (#19288409)
I’ll agree that people never do anything without a reason, with the caveat that “It’s my boss’s pet project and he signs my paycheck” is often a good enough reason to do something.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by speedplane on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:01AM (#19288534)
If it's your boss's pet project, then your boss probably has a reason for doing it, even if it isn't a good one.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by birksherty on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:02AM (#19289058)
That reason is often promotion and putting things in the resume.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by PedroBatista on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:02AM (#19289278)
Well, that’s a pretty good reason, for him.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by TelmoMenezes on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:45AM (#19289221)
"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it." -- Upton Sinclair
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by j45 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:09AM (#19289746)
Very applicable in leadership and management in this time of disruption everywhere.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by calinet6 on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:21PM (#19287551)
I'll concede "most people are of average idiocy" and cite core principles of statistics and the meanings of average and most.

But yes, you're right, happens all the time. Less so with most of the large scale more popular redesigns people tend to think of when writing articles like this about tools they actually use; the team at Atlassian, for example, is not made of idiots, neither at Slack, Google, Twitter, or other large companies with mostly significant design experience.

Smaller operations where we all likely work—yep, hit or miss.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by camhart on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:56AM (#19287982)
I and almost everyone from my team loathes the new jira released a year+ ago. The menu drives me nuts still and makes no sense.

It's my understanding the use of the word "idiot" in this context implies someone who is primarily responsible for a significant amount of rework on anything that bears no real fruit, ui redesigns being one potential example. Pretty sure big companies make those mistakes just as much as small. Though I don't think its fair to call someone an idiot for this reason--I think its very challenging to do well.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by spease on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:54AM (#19288511)
Yeah, I specifically avoid using Atlassian as much as I can because of how tedious it is to wait ~6 seconds for every UI action to complete.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by groestl on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:54AM (#19288672)
An idiot, in the original sense of the word, is someone who focuses on themselves, showing no interest in the common cause/politics. It's a bit heavy, but reapplied here it could mean someone who focuses completely on visual quality, while not putting their time into other important aspects of the product (almost all of which are more important that visual quality, at least according to OP).
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by atoav on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:02AM (#19288696)
This is how I would describe the noun of idiotic design if it existed.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by marcosdumay on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:09PM (#19290005)
Well, if it didn't exist before, you just created it.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by groestl on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:59AM (#19288526)
Well, after the Google Cloud Console redesign of the Datastore UI, visual quality is great, but "Open in new Tab" is broken, the result tables abbreviate dates at the Month field, and in entity edits a timestamp can only be given with Minute resolution. So what should I make of that?
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by speedplane on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:08AM (#19288554)
I loved the old app engine console, it was super fast, and dumped tons of the information you needed to analyze. The new one is slower, and has plenty of UI bugs like the one you mentioned (my pet peave is CTRL+click on many links no longer opens a new tab). On the other hand, look at all the stuff they added! There must be 30 dashboards you can jump into, and yet the new UI makes navigating all of them relatively easy. The old one was great for just app engine, but it would never be able to scale to all the services they currently offer.

Also, they are relatively responsive to developer demands, at least as far as the dashboard is concerned. Not that long ago, if you wanted to export a few seconds of logs, you had to setup a Cloud SQL sink that could suck in gigabytes of logs. Not too helpful if you want to analyze just a few hundred lines. People complained, and now you can export the current view to excel/csv. They've also speeded up load times significantly (it's still not snappy though).

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by ascar on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:23AM (#19288929)
I have the feeling they force some UI and especially icon redesign with every new Android version. Not because it's necessarily or actually looks better, but just to make it different. It's mildly annoying to me. Especially since some app icons now have ugly white boarders (galaxy s9 with android 8 and even worse in 9/oneui).
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by hopler on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:04AM (#19289288)
The white borders was a gimmick to support some new transparency feature, but since Android half-does everything, it doesn't quite work. Android's openness saves the day, you can install 3rd party launcher with icon pack plugins
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by btschaegg on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:15PM (#19290325)
I absolutely love your comment on statistics.

But on the notion that large companies specifically don't have hit or miss design or redesigns: I'd argue there's more than enough evidence to the contrary. And, personally, I find Atlassian products to be a very good example of that.

Note: In this regard, I focus mainly on Don Norman's view on "design", which is largely orthogonal to aesthetics. It's cool for software to look nice. But if it's laid out in a non-intuitive way or doesn't prevent (or even provokes) user errors, it's not good design, period.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by sizzle on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:35PM (#19292553)
Absolutely, despite the best intentions of UX designers/researchers the PMs/POs (depending on org), directors and above get final say on business/technology/ final (re)design decisions, which is then broken down into the backlog for developers.

Proper (re)design initiatives need to born out of the intersection of "viability, (user) desirability, and feasibility."

Usability is only scratching the surface of how to quantify the impact of a redesign and the author doesn't acknowledge the convoluted nature of how design decisions actually get made in non design-led tech organizations. The best companies (i.e. FAANG) have data and are measuring the outcomes of design decisions before developers even get assigned the work.

From the author's vantage point and how they get assigned work, they are missing the forest for the trees.

Thoughts?

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by james_s_tayler on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:23AM (#19287727)
Yeah. It's a bit of column A and a bit of column B.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by speedplane on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:01AM (#19288529)
> In my experience people are frequently idiots, and work gets done for no reason after someone with authority is convinced that it's a good idea by someone aching to do that sort of work.

You're contradicting yourself here. If someone with authority is convinced that something is a good idea, then they have a reason for doing it. It might be a misguided reason, but it's not just randomness.

Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by paulryanrogers on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:59AM (#19289265)
Distinguishing between badly chosen ideas and randomly chosen ones may be impossible if the authority figure provides no context.
Re:UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time by calinet6 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:23AM (#19289358)
I think you’ve identified one of the root causes here. :)