News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by ObsoleteNerd on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:38PM (#17821401)
Doesn't Valve take 30% from games on Steam? But they're complaining Apple taking 30% is too much?

I also don't really think the Apple/Google fee is that unreasonable. Considering the resources, tools, marketplaces, tutorials, payment processing, all the other All dev stuff they provide in general. Yes if your app goes big, they make a lot of money. But for every big app there's something like 9 that fail completely (it's murky due to how many apps aren't intended to profit in the first place, and are just made to attract customers to a brand).

I don't know the numbers though. Maybe they could charge lots less. But just from my single viewpoint, it doesn't "feel" unreasonable.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by cgriswald on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:55PM (#17821572)
Steam does not sell me a locked down hardware platform preventing me from buying the software directly from the publisher. Nor does Steam force me to buy DLC through Steam, I am free to buy the DLC directly from the publisher. Steam gets a cut of what I buy from Steam and I am not locked into buying from Steam in order to make my PC useful.

Apple sells me a locked down hardware platform that requires me to go through them for all software purchases and all data purchases made with that software.

> But just from my single viewpoint, it doesn't "feel" unreasonable.

It seems unreasonable to me that Apple should get a cut of my Amazon Video purchases. Apple adds no value there; they just get in the way and try to take a cut. I already have a relationship with Amazon and when I download a video from Amazon, it costs Apple nothing.

The entire thing where I have to make a purchase through the Amazon website rather than the Amazon or Amazon Video app and then download it with Amazon Video app is just stupid.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by madrox on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:01PM (#17822157)
Steam is also adding a lot of value for that rev-share. A social network...kickstart-esque backing of projects...cloud saves...great search and discoverability. There is a reason why developers choose Steam even though they operate on platforms that don't require it.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by UncleMeat on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:12PM (#17822238)
And mobile stores offer search, promotion, distribution, and analytics.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by cgriswald on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:41PM (#17822448)
In the absence of any alternative methods of developers getting their apps into users hands, it is difficult to say whether "search, promotion, distribution, and analytics" offered by Apple are really valued at what Apple is charging for them. It is also difficult to separate these things from things Apple is doing for its own sake, since they increase sales which benefits Apple directly.

I strongly suspect that, given enough time to compensate for the existing momentum of the App Store, if an alternative App Store was an option, Apple would either improve its offerings, lower what it charges, or see a mass migration of publishers away from the App Store.

Edit: Clarity of meaning.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dkonofalski on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:59PM (#17822604)
You're completely ignoring the hit to both the brand and experience that something like that would cause. There's a big reason why iOS users tend to spend more money on the platform than Android users do on the Google platform and a huge part of that is the trust built by Apple with their users.

You can go into the Google Play store (which most people would think was the "official" and "safe" method of getting apps) and still get malware and/or a virus on your Android phone. Now imagine that Google offered both an official Play store and an alternative open Play store. Which do you think the majority of users would use and have a positive opinion of?

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by cgriswald on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:28PM (#17822810)
You seem to be suggesting the only alternative to the App Store is a janky Apple-run Open App Store. All Apple has to do to offer an alternative is let people install Apps on their phones outside the App Store just like they can do on their Macs. People will still trust the App Store, but maybe a competitor comes along and maybe Netflix/Amazon etc use them or maybe they don’t.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dkonofalski on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:48PM (#17822941)
I didn't suggest that at all. I suggested that it was a possible alternative simply because that's the only way something like that would be considered "official" still while allowing for any apps to be published.

There's no reason for Apple to offer that on their phones since it dilutes the customer experience. Anyone that would care about doing that can still do that via XCode by side-loading the apps.

Case in point - where's the competitor for the Mac App Store on macOS? There's not. Users have to do all the legwork themselves. That's literally no different than side-loading your own apps.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by throwaway917100 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:57PM (#17823653)
Wait What. Steam is a "competitor" to Mac App Store. Homebrew is a sort of competitor to app store. Heck any website which has more that 1 Mac OS "app" is a sort of an "app store ".
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kyle-rb on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:48PM (#17831584)
>Case in point - where's the competitor for the Mac App Store on macOS? There's not. Users have to do all the legwork themselves.

Yeah, double-clicking that DMG and dragging the .app 30 pixels to the Applications shortcut is a lot of work.

>That's literally no different than side-loading your own apps.

Yup, clicking and dragging is the same as configuring a different machine to properly build and provision.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dkonofalski on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:02PM (#17854524)
Stop being obtuse. People have to find the software they want first and then download the DMG from somewhere which usually involves ignoring a billion fake "DOWNLOAD NOW" buttons. The App Store is a trusted platform with literally one click find an app and one click to install.

You're being purposely disingenuous.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kyle-rb on Monday September 03, 2018 @09:18PM (#17905928)
What? First of all my main argument was that installing outside the App Store is much easier on MacOS than it is on iOS.

Second: many, many sites host their own DMG downloads, with zero fake download buttons. I don't think searching for an app's website on Google is significantly harder than searching for an app in the App Store (also I'm not sure typing in search terms is "one click", but whatever). I'll admit that using the App Store is slightly less work to install stuff, and somewhat more secure.

But from a user standpoint (I use a Mac with one or two App Store apps and dozens of DMG-installer-based apps) it's not a huge difference. And from a developer standpoint, that's not worth 30% of my revenue.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jsjohnst on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:41PM (#17823573)
> All Apple has to do to offer an alternative is let people install Apps on their phones outside the App Store

This exists now and is free. I’m not saying it’s a good user experience (especially the one week limitation), but it’s definitely possible and legit / legal / free.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jjeaff on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:44AM (#17824646)
Sideloading on iOS is a bad enough user experience to be effectively useless.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jsjohnst on Thursday August 23, 2018 @08:44AM (#17826741)
Depends on the use case. For the intended purpose it’s not useless, but far from great either.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by paulddraper on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @10:03PM (#17823951)
> not saying it’s a good user experience

Why do you think that is?

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jsjohnst on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @11:38PM (#17824371)
I apologize, but I don’t understand your question. Can you clarify?
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by WA on Thursday August 23, 2018 @02:48AM (#17825115)
Search: yes, but to counter that: the App Store shows ads of your competitors ABOVE your own app, even if someone searches for your app by name.

Promotion: only the ones that seem to be successful anyways. Mostly no niche apps

Distribution: yes

Analytics: Not everybody needs this and they're pretty basic, too.

They also introduce hurdles: Rating system (can be easily abused), or in the case of the App Store: review process (sometimes somewhat arbitrary), no insight into payments (you can't even issue a refund).

One service that is indeed quite useful: They handle all payment processing and country's tax. You just get a single payment wired to your bank account. Makes your own taxes a lot easier. This and distribution are probably the biggest benefit for most apps (especially niche apps), but does this justify a 30% cut?

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jimbokun on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:05PM (#17821661)
As I understand it, if you already have a subscription for Amazon Video through the web, then download the Amazon Video app and login to your existing account, Apple doesn't get anything.

Which is why the article emphasized Netflix trying to get customers to sign up through their web site, and not the app.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by giovannibajo1 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:18PM (#17821789)
Correct. Apple gets a cut if a customer subscribes through the in-app one-click subscription, which is extremely convenient for any iPhone user (and thus app publishers) because it’s a single click rather than having to insert credit cards, 3D secure and whatnot. In this case the cut is 30% on the first year and 10% afterwards. If the user subscribes through the website, Apple gets nothing. I find this fair.

What is more unfair is that Apple forbids apps to open/link websites where subscriptions can be done to “workaround” the iTunes subscription. If you take Spotify for instance and login as free user, there are absolutely zero mentions that you can upgrade to premium, because they decided to lose those potential customers and rather let them know through other channels of their purchasing options (eg: emails).

On the other hand, this creates a very safe and simple environment for iPhone users. Absolutely NO app asks for a credit card, ever. You either pay one-click safely through iTunes, or nothing. There is no phishing, no mismanaged credit card handling, no credit cards “stolen by hackers from the app I installed into my iPhone”. I’m not saying this fully justifies the above unfair rule, but it’s at least a partial positive side effect.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by biztos on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:57AM (#17824709)
I would also note that being able to painlessly cancel a subscription at any time is a big incentive for users to buy subscriptions through the iOS App Store.

Having recently jumped through the series of hoops necessary to cancel an NYTimes subscription, I am strongly biased towards App Store and Amazon-Prime-based subscriptions, even though they are arguably unfair to the providers.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by scarface74 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @07:27PM (#17823165)
What is more unfair is that Apple forbids apps to open/link websites where subscriptions can be done to “workaround” the iTunes subscription.

Slight anecdote, because of that policy, Amazon doesn't support links to Amazon from Kindle Books. Which is fine 99.999% of the time. Until you buy a book about AWS and you can't click on any of the links to documentation on Amazon's websites....

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dkonofalski on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:35PM (#17822858)
This is 100% what I'm saying. I think that it does fully justify the rule that people are saying is "unfair". I have yet to hear a good argument that doesn't amount to something totally incorrect like "Apple doesn't provide any value and is just a middleman" or just an opinion like "Apple shouldn't take part of the purchase just because they own the platform" because while it may be a valid opinion, it looks at the situation from only the perspective of the 2 companies in question (Apple and whoever) and not the end-user.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by clarky07 on Thursday August 30, 2018 @06:59PM (#17881554)
it's 15% in future years, not 10%.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by cgriswald on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:32PM (#17822389)
You are correct in that if I subscribe through Apple, that Apple gets a cut, and if I subscribe via the web they do not get a cut. This makes sense, since Apple is providing a subscription service. I don't have any problem with this model. It's convenient and I've used it in the past.

However, Apple also wants a cut if I were to purchase a movie through the Amazon Video app. Amazon has disallowed such purchases for this reason. Instead, I have to go back to the web, make the purchase, and then I can view it with the app.

Some may argue that this is a fair price for having your app hosted on the app store. However, since Apple prevents any other means of me getting apps on my phone, I find it unfair rent-seeking.

Worse, Apple very clearly wants subscriptions to work just like in-app purchases.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by wlesieutre on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:10PM (#17821714)
IIRC this is how the Kindle app works for iOS. You can't buy books, but if you own books on your account you can read them.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by fpoling on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:19PM (#17821800)
One can even download free samples of the books which makes it very convenient to pay on kindle or the website later. But it is sad that Apple decided that apps cannot even mention that purchase has to be done at the website.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by wilc0 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:15PM (#17821755)
You can wishlist and download samples from the app on iOS, but any purchases have to be done from the website. On android, you can buy/download full books directly from the app.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by rlanday on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:03PM (#17821642)
> Apple adds no value there

Other than inventing the modern phone, writing the operating system and developer tools, running the store, manufacturing the phones people are consuming Amazon's product on and convincing people to buy them...you can argue about what's "fair," but Apple's certainly adding value.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by earenndil on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:19PM (#17821795)
All of those except 'running the store' are value paid for in the purchase of the phone, not the software on it.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by bovine3dom on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:55PM (#17822108)
Money is fungible. I would be very surprised if Apple didn't regard revenue from the App Store as partially due to their investment in the iPhone.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Buge on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:45AM (#17824653)
Why? Is it wrong to sell a phone at low cost and charge more for apps? Video game consoles sometimes are sold at a loss in order to make money from games.

It's similar to Fortnite's model: sell the game at a low cost (free actually), and then make money from inessential addons (skins).

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by earenndil on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:54AM (#17824693)
It's fine for a company to sell hardware/os at a loss and recoup the costs with apps, if they predict that they'll make more money that way. However, it's not reasonable for them to, say, refuse me service on the os because all I bought was a hardware+os, not any apps. Nor is it reasonable for them to make me, an app-maker, bear the brunt of the os, since I have nothing to do with the os, just the app store.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Buge on Thursday August 23, 2018 @01:03AM (#17824737)
If I buy a smart fridge, even though it has a computer in it, I don't expect to be able to install arbitrary software on it in a supported manner. Apple doesn't advertise as a computing platform for everything, they advertise as having a whitelist of apps, and that's what they provide. I don't want a phone with a whitelist, so I don't buy iOS phones. But some people do want that type of product, and do buy them.

You do have something to do with the os. Your app is running on the os.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jjeaff on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:51AM (#17824681)
If that were the case, no, nothing wrong... But apple is making a huge markup on their $1200 phones. They aren't making up a loss with their app store. They're just piling on the cash.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Buge on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:54AM (#17824692)
Would it be wrong of apple to make the app store fee 5% and then increase the phone price whatever percent is necessary to make up that loss? Would that be considered piling on the cash?
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jjeaff on Thursday August 23, 2018 @03:09PM (#17829801)
At least then, buyers get a more realistic view of total cost of ownership up front, rather than hiding the rest of the profits in the pricing of other people's apps.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by FireBeyond on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:27PM (#17822340)
> Other than inventing the modern phone

Come on now.

> writing the operating system

Which OS, iOS, that the phone purchaser inherently paid for? Or macOS, that the computer purchaser inherently paid for?

> developer tools

Which you need to purchase a developer license for to be useful.

Apple is adding value, AND double dipping. Most of your examples are things they've already been compensated for.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Buge on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:48AM (#17824671)
Just because they've already been compensated to some degree doesn't mean they've been fully compensated. Video game consoles are sometimes sold at a loss in order to make money on games.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by FireBeyond on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:40AM (#17828138)
The richest company in the world, with the largest cash reserves in the world, is not being fully compensated for their efforts?
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Buge on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:44PM (#17832624)
I mean they might not be fully compensated if they remove the app store fees.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by CamperBob2 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:44PM (#17822467)
Come on now.

They invented the app ecosystem, which is far more important than just inventing a phone. Without Apple, the application market would still be controlled by Sprint and AT&T and Verizon.

Not defending Apple or attacking it, just pointing out the facts.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by rohit2412 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:39PM (#17822878)
And how is Apple's walled app store any better than the alternative of at&t controlled app store?

They can keep their 30% cut if they allow me to sideload apps from external sources.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by orbitur on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @11:07PM (#17824224)
> And how is Apple's walled app store any better than the alternative of at&t controlled app store?

I don't know if you've used an iPhone, but do you really think AT&T's walled garden would have anything approaching the quality of the best apps on the App Store?

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by CamperBob2 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:20PM (#17830376)
He or she is probably just young. No one who was there would ask a question like that, even rhetorically.

Sadly, people have forgotten how much life sucked for mobile developers before the iPhone. Apple's contribution is reflected in various peoples' prejudices and agendas, but not in history books. Only Nixon could go to China, and only Jobs could have stared down AT&T from a position of weakness.

I'm not an Apple partisan, and I'm definitely not going to defend the concept of locking a general-purpose computing platform away from its own users, but I'll always give him credit for that.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kartan on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:35PM (#17822413)
> but Apple's certainly adding value.

Do roads add value? Should trucks pay a 30% of their cargo retail price in road tolls?

I agree with your point that Apple adds value. I just do not see that as a justification to take a 30% share of all apps that run on their devices.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by greedo on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:28PM (#17822812)
Trucks pay fees based on the load they're carrying...
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by fjsolwmv on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @10:07PM (#17823968)
The weight, not the price.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Steltek on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:42AM (#17826370)
As trucks account for a high (90%ish) amount of road wear, they actually probably should pay a high fee. Accurate costs might also make the rail freight industry more cost competitive, leading to better market diversity.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by 1123581321 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:50PM (#17822954)
Comparing distribution of physical goods is a poor analogy as the variable costs are high, and low or zero for App Store developers. We know from tariffs that a 30% fee on mining or manufacturing increases costs and reduces trade, but despite Apple’s 30%, the cost of an app has been driven down. This suggests that a high revenue share of a software sale is viable in a way that a high revenue share of a truck load is not.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kartan on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:59AM (#17828334)
> This suggests that a high revenue share of a software sale is viable in a way that a high revenue share of a truck load is not.

This is a good point. But I would rather see this apps more highly taxed than to allow monopolistic empires to grow.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by 1123581321 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:21PM (#17828523)
Sorry, are you saying you’d like App Store software taxed enough that sales are low and it’s not viable for Apple to make money, forcing them to allow an unregulated open market if they want a meaningful number of apps on their phones? It’s an interesting idea, but I think the opportunity cost early on would have been that entire software market. And the opportunity cost now would be killing a large percentage of businesses that sell software to that market that can’t afford to handle distribution themselves. This quickly gets into the debate about whether it’s better to have large and many small companies or no large and few small companies.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kartan on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:02PM (#17830274)
> Sorry, are you saying you’d like App Store software taxed enough that sales are low and it’s not viable for Apple to make money, forcing them to allow an unregulated open market if they want a meaningful number of apps on their phones?

No. :)

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by 1123581321 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:06PM (#17830294)
:)

Well, what are you saying? I seriously don’t understand what you meant.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dingaling on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:00PM (#17822145)
> Other than inventing the modern phone

IBM Simon, 1992.

Applr popularised, they didn't invent. Ironically given the target of their 1984 ad.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by binomialxenon on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:07PM (#17822673)
The ridiculously tall screen was certainly ahead of its time.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by gameswithgo on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:04PM (#17821650)
Anything is fair, but I don't like things that only allow app stores as a first class way to get software on my machine.

I have voted with my wallet. But it is getting harder to do so, soon only linux will be left.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dkonofalski on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:39PM (#17822881)
That's fine but you're not really the intended market for the App Stores. App Stores are for the people that click "Yes" to everything and end up with Internet Explorer as a strip of their screen because they have 42 toolbars installed. Those people undoubtedly like app stores precisely for being the only way to get software on their machines.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by voltagex_ on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:05PM (#17823384)
I dunno - I much prefer the Microsoft app store on Windows for simple applications that I don't need to customise much. It's quicker than finding the right exe and keeping it up to date myself.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dkonofalski on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:56PM (#17822581)
That's not really a fair comparison since Apple has to curate the App Store and is 100% responsible for the service as well. It's not like you're buying an iPhone or iPad without knowing that all your apps come from the App Store and that's part of the value - unlike Android, you know exactly where the app is coming from, what it is and isn't allowed to do, and have an expectation that the app has been reasonably reviewed so it's not a danger to you or the device.

Steam is almost exactly the same way because it's not like you can take your Steam purchase and use it without Steam. Yes, you can buy DLC and other add-ons directly from the publisher if you wanted to but that's moreso because of how the publishers have created their products rather than how Steam works as a platform.

As for your Amazon example, Apple does absolutely add value there. They manage and keep track of all your purchases and payments so that there's a single, unified method for both paying and resolving issues. Additionally, since Apple functions as the payment processor, you're also paying for the security functionality. The only reason you have to make a purchase from the Amazon website is because Amazon wants to control the purchasing and doesn't want to pay Apple for their payment processing.

It's just a difference of whether you prefer the consistency of the experience that Apple prefers at the expense of other companies or whether you prefer to deal with several different experiences that could potentially open everything up for fraud and problems. People who aren't as tech savvy or who don't want to have to wade through a bunch of BS just to make a purchase may prefer Apple's method. Others may prefer digging through and doing all that in order to have a broader pool to choose from.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by ApostleMatthew on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:59PM (#17823012)
I think your first paragraph is a result of you viewing this from the perspective of someone knowledgeable about technology. The vast majority of people using Android phones get their apps exclusively from the Play Store and assume Android is exactly the same as iOS in that way.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by scentedmeat on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @07:52PM (#17823306)
> Apple adds no value there

I like having all my subscriptions in the same place so I can easily see what I'm paying and cancel.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by scarface74 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @07:24PM (#17823154)
Apple sells me a locked down hardware platform that requires me to go through them for all software purchases and all data purchases made with that software.

A. You can choose to buy an Android phone like 80%+ of the smart phone world.

B. You can buy content outside of the Apple store and use it within the app (Amazon, Udemy, Spotify, Google Play Music, every video streaming service, etc.)

It seems unreasonable to me that Apple should get a cut of my Amazon Video purchases.

They don't, in fact you can't buy Amazon content within the app.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by mrep on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @07:46PM (#17823279)
Amazon does not offer you the option because the only way they could offer it is if they gave Apple their 30% cut. Same super annoying reason you cannot buy books in the kindle app.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by baxtr on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:44PM (#17822476)
I don’t think Apple sells you anything. You buy stuff from them. You are free as a bird to buy any other products you desire
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by clay_the_ripper on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:06PM (#17821674)
They add value by creating a product that has massive scale, reach, usability and quality. They add value by having branded stores that fix the device for you. They add value by developing stable software that gets updated regularly. If you don’t like the product, don’t buy one, it’s that simple. Go buy a cheap Chinese knockoff that doesn’t have developer support for millions of apps, has lousy quality control, if it breaks you’re shit out of luck. It costs 1/10 the price of an iphone, but the experience is lousy. I value my iphone because it adds more value to my life than it costs to buy, and the company that makes it is entitled to charge whatever they want for it. Apple makes money because they add value and I see no reason why a company that adds value to the marketplace should not turn a profit.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by cgriswald on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:15PM (#17822256)
> They add value by creating a product that has massive scale, reach, usability and quality. They add value by having branded stores that fix the device for you. They add value by developing stable software that gets updated regularly.

Your rant is misplaced and you've missed the point entirely. I never said Apple adds no value. I think they add quite a bit of value, which is why I've bought a number of their products. I am talking about a specific case for which Apple thinks it is due 30%.

Apple does not add value by inserting itself into a transaction I am trying to conduct with Amazon. I've already paid for all the value. First to Apple for the device, and then to Amazon for the data. Am I or Amazon supposed to pay Apple for my use of the device as well? And if so... where is the value added?

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by valuearb on Thursday August 23, 2018 @01:40AM (#17824854)
It’s really hard to feel sorry for Amazon, or you, given your whine is you have to go to a web browser to complete your transaction.

In truth, The App Store is far more than a mere payment processor, though it might be best in the world at that. The costs of hosting, distributing and updating two million apps across hundreds of localized stores, and also vetting every release and update for those millions of apps, is immense.

All their work makes the App Store easy and safe to use anywhere in the world and that helps developers sell more apps.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by cbhl on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:12PM (#17821731)
I would bet that Apple would probably rather you not have a relationship with Amazon Video at all, getting your TV and Movies from iTunes instead.

But Apple doesn't have a majority of market share (by number of devices), so, in my opinion, antitrust regulators have completely discounted their behavior.

On the other hand, the experience of using Apple Pay is miles beyond Google Checkout/Wallet/Pay/Android Pay/whatever marketing's new name-of-the-week-is, and only allowing One Blessed Way of taking payment on Apple devices is a big component of that. Having one consistent flow that I can execute in three seconds from muscle memory really does make buying-from-random-apps-and-retailers experience much nicer and more predictable than it is on the web and on other mobile platforms.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by YurtleTheTurtle on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:44PM (#17822002)
Apple Pay and app store/itunes payments are completely separate. I had apple pay set-up for awhile and when I went to purchase an app, itunes wouldn't accept apple pay and I had to re-enter all my CC information into itunes.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by lightwin on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:15PM (#17821759)
Apple does not sell to us, we buy from Apple :)
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by javagram on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:43PM (#17821439)
Valve takes 30% of direct sales through steam but allows developers to generate and sell separately steam keys where they get a 0% cut, as I understand it. For instance when you buy a game on humble bundle and get a steam key for it, valve makes nothing off that transaction.

Unless Apple and google start allowing sales outside their stores I don’t think steam is comparable.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by pitaj on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:46PM (#17821470)
Google Play and the Apple App Store are completely different beasts. Unless you jailbreak your iOS device, there is no way to install apps outside the App Store. On Android, you can install entirely separate stores, like the Amazon one, and several OSS-focused stores.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by DINKDINK on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:07PM (#17821691)
>Unless you jailbreak your iOS device, there is no way to install apps outside the App Store

Technically this is not correct. Practically it is. You can install Apps on iOS devices without the app store (called sideloading, and it's a PITA): https://beebom.com/how-to-sideload-apps-iphone-ios-10-withou...

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by DerDangDerDang on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:16PM (#17821762)
That’s not completely true, as I understand it. You can (or could a couple of years ago) get an ‘enterprise’ developer account that allows you to sign and provision apps to be sideloaded via a web link. Though iirc it’s more hassle for the end user as they have to explicitly allow it on their device.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jsjohnst on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:50PM (#17823619)
DINKDINK’s reply above is more relevant. If you try using an enterprise cert to allow general public users to install your app you’ll quickly lose your enterprise cert. The enterprise cert is only to be used for internal company apps.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kevingadd on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @10:21PM (#17824024)
This is accurate but they've started getting antsy about free steam keys. I think it's due to pay-what-you-want bundles but they haven't really given any official statements, it's just second-hand from various developers. I suspect the policy on free keys may change now that literally anyone can toss a game up on the store and we've started seeing people maliciously manipulate the system (games that mine bitcoins and have in-app purchases designed to defraud users). They already made changes to filter out reviews from people who got game keys "for free" because of that sort of manipulation.

I suspect they'll either put a limit on # of free keys or start charging per key, something like 5% of your listed retail price.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by e_proxus on Thursday August 23, 2018 @03:26AM (#17825268)
There's a bigger difference: Steam competes on "open" platforms (i.e. the major OSes), where "open" means anyone could launch a competing service (and I fully expect another one to challenge Steam in the near future considering the way Steam is heading).

No one can launch a competing app service on iOS. Apparently you can on Android, but I'm not sure why no one succeeded yet. Maybe the same reason as no one succeeded yet replacing Steam either, you need some kind of critical mass and that takes time to build.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Steko on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:06PM (#17821677)
People keep saying Apple adds no value but bringing millions of paying customers and a trusted storefront does in fact have lots of value for most apps. This is exactly the value Steam brings on PC. Being locked down or not is a red herring to the value argument, people sell on Steam because of simple math: the millions of additional paying customers outweighs the commission Valve demands.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by pascalxus on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:33PM (#17821906)
Yes, but there comes a point when it just becomes rent seeking. It's digital nature for there to be one portal that leads you to everything.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by binomialxenon on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:10PM (#17822690)
Valve has competitors in the PC games storefront market. On iOS, there is (for all practical reasons) no other storefront. People would be stuck on the App Store even if they were to charge something ridiculous like 50%, because there's no where else to go.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by bigmit37 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @09:07PM (#17823701)
I’m surprised there is no backlash from independent iOS developers. Not only do they have 30% taken away, they have the yearly $100 fee,they need expensive Apple products to make the app, apps have be priced low because consumers expect low priced amazing apps. Then you have to market the app to stand out.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Steko on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:45PM (#17822923)
> Valve has competitors in the PC games storefront market. On iOS, there is (for all practical reasons) no other storefront.

Predictably, this is where the goalposts have moved[1] but it's really orthogonal to whether there's value or not. Also as pointed out elsewhere, Steam is in a competitive market and charges the same commission. Also in Apple's favor is the well attested to value of the App Store vs Google Play and others in terms of raw revenue.

[1] 'Predictably' as in "Being locked down or not is a red herring to the value argument" in grandparent

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dkonofalski on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:40PM (#17822896)
Yes, but if that were the case, there would be no apps on the App Store.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by DmenshunlAnlsis on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @07:16PM (#17823117)
Being locked down is the source of the value on many cases. Being locked down and curated means that when someone looks for an app they find that app, and not that app and a dozen lookalikes with similar names, half of which are outright malware. Being locked down and curated means that stuff just works and does so predictably, and will continue to work.

That’s the value add IMO, not the aluminum case, the Apple logo, or anything else. A locked garden isn’t perfect, but it’s better than an open sewer.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jasonlotito on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @11:21PM (#17824296)
> Being locked down is the source of the value on many cases. ... Being locked down and curated means that stuff just works and does so predictably, and will continue to work.

The Apple App Store does not fill all those conditions. In fact, I can safely say it does not do some of things you say, including the part about stuff just working.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by valuearb on Thursday August 23, 2018 @01:43AM (#17824867)
The Apple App store isn’t perfect, it just works better and has less malware than any App Store in the history of the world.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by stefan_ on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:50PM (#17821517)
The modern marvel that are credit cards or debit cards run at low single digit percentages. And they are getting a ton of margin out of those; so much that in the EU, they capped fees at 0.3%.

And those transaction fees actually pay for something, like customer protection, SLAs (not a shitty status site) and no, the credit card company doesn't add unskippable ads on top of the checkout process or advertise a scam clone version of what you are trying to buy to you.

You tell me if the app store fees provide 100x as much.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by toasterlovin on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:07PM (#17822207)
In your analogy, the App Store is the store, not the credit card terminal. As somebody who sells on Amazon, I can tell you that they take more than 30% of what the customer pays.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by mywittyname on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:46PM (#17821477)
Valve has several big competitors in the PC market. Several hugely successful games are not available on Steam.

I'm not sure it's possible to create a hugely successful iPhone app that isn't on the App Store. Apple has a monopoly and is using it to squeeze excessive fees from developers.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by colechristensen on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:55PM (#17821574)
Using a monopoly to squeeze excessive fees that happen to be exactly the same as the fees for a competitive market? There seems to be a logic breakdown there.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:13PM (#17821736)
> Using a monopoly to squeeze excessive fees that happen to be exactly the same as the fees for a competitive market? There seems to be a logic breakdown there.

Valve gets 30% of apps distributed using Steam. In other words, only companies that value Steam at the 30% premium will use it -- and many of them don't. Meanwhile Steam has to be responsive to customers because it has competition, so it's forced to be a better product than monopoly app stores.

It's like saying that $25 is "the market price" for eight ounces of tuna fish because there are restaurants that charge that price and some people patronize them, so a monopoly that charges $50/pound in all cases is not charging unreasonable prices.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by fenwick67 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:48PM (#17822512)
The critical differences here is that computers don't come with Steam games pre-installed with the Steam Store being the only way to install new ones

Whereas most Android phones come with Google apps and the Play Store as the only ways to get new apps.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by mrep on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @07:53PM (#17823312)
You can install new apps onto android from other stores like amazon or download straight from the web. Fortnite just did the latter by avoiding the play store and selling their app direct from their website.

For IOS though, fortnite launched it in the IOS store because there is no real practical way to get users to install their app outside of Apples app store.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by mywittyname on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:04PM (#17821646)
There's no logic breakdown at all: publishers can get better terms by going with an competitor to Steam, such as GMG, GoG, Origin, Microsoft Store, or just release the app on their own website/platform.

It's functionally impossible to release an app on iOS without paying Apple.

Compared to the 0% of self-publishing, Apple's fees are excessive.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dkonofalski on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:44PM (#17822919)
Sure, they can get better terms going through a competitor but then they don't get any of the value or services that Steam offers. They're paying a percentage to make use of all the benefits you get through Steam both as a company and for the end-users.

Apple's fees aren't excessive because they offer their services and provide their value to every app published through their store. Yes, they could offer a way to publish the app without those features and not charge the fee but that would further complicate the experience for users. I mean, technically, companies are absolutely allowed to host apps for users to side load themselves. It's just that no one wants to do that because it's not worth it when the costs Apple are taking are actually reasonable.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kemitche on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:01PM (#17821632)
A business making an app has one choice for delivering that app to iPhone users. The iPhone owners could choose to switch to Android, but that's not a choice the business can make for the consumer.

The business could choose to launch on Android only, and hope that convinces consumers to switch, but that's about it for options.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by DmenshunlAnlsis on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:15PM (#17821752)
Apple has a “monopoly” on their own products, not smartphones or apps, or anything else. It’s like complaining that Ford has a monopoly on cars made by Ford. There are other phones, other ecosystems, other cars. A monopoly isn’t “I want an Apple product on my own terms, and if I can’t get that, it’s a monopoly.” This trend of claiming Apple is a monopoly or Facebook is because you don’t like the alternatives is puerile and incorrect. You have a right to competition, not the premium product. You have a right to the marketplace of for example, cars, not a right to a Mercedes.

I’m getting very tired of the phrase “de facto” bandied about in front of monopoly as a way to use the latter word in a way that has no legal or technical merit. Words have meanings. Apple has a walled garden which competes with similar products, it’s just that Apple’s is better in many ways. They have a valuable audience, they don’t suffe from the security issues of their competitors, and that may make you want to use them. So use them, or don’t, and accept the trade-offs.

Don’t like Apple? Try android, their competition in the same space.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by imh on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:39PM (#17822435)
Apple does have a monopoly on their own products. No need for scare quotes. They also have a monopoly on iOS app distribution. One of those bothers more market participants than the other, and for the same reasons monopolies can (but don't always) cause trouble for the markets in which they exist.

As per usual, competition is a good answer. Competition in making iPhones is nonsensical. Competition in distributing and selling iOS apps isn't, and would be good for the market. Or at least it might be good for the market. That's the whole premise of this discussion, and for most discussions about monopolistic tendencies.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:20PM (#17821801)
The monopoly they have isn't phones, it's iOS app distribution. It's a different market -- and the market isn't combined with apps for other systems because they have disjoint sets of customers. You can't use Android apps when you don't have an Android device.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by DmenshunlAnlsis on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:24PM (#17821849)
Right, and WalMart has a “monopoly” on WalMarts, but that’s not actually a monopoly. If they had a monopoly on supermarket, that would be a legal issue. Apps is the space for competition, and Apple doesn’t have a monopoly on apps, or phones. In fact you can almost always get the same apps on multiple platforms.

People just want something they can’t have, so they play word games to make themselves sound righteous rather than selfish or petulant. No amount of talking around the issue or downvotes changes it, and it’s why an AG will laugh in your face if you claim Apple is violating antitrust regulations with their system.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:47PM (#17822036)
> Right, and WalMart has a “monopoly” on WalMarts, but that’s not actually a monopoly. If they had a monopoly on supermarket, that would be a legal issue.

Which is likewise why Apple doesn't have a monopoly on phones.

> Apps is the space for competition, and Apple doesn’t have a monopoly on apps, or phones. In fact you can almost always get the same apps on multiple platforms.

The market isn't the app market itself, it's not that there aren't a hundred flashlight apps, it's the distribution market. All the flashlight apps have to come through Apple.

It's as if Walmart is the only retailer in California. That there are arbitrarily many manufacturers or that other retailers exist in Florida doesn't mean they don't have a retail monopoly in California.

And the fact is you can't get an app for your iPhone from the Play Store. They aren't the same market because they can't be substituted for each other.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by mrep on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:05PM (#17823381)
This is why I think we need a new way of identifying market abuse because you can make anyone a/not a monopoly based on what definition you use.

IOS device software distribution -> apple has a monopoly

High end phones -> apple probably has a monopoly

Total revenue of phones sold -> apple probably has a monopoly

Number of phones (in use?) by OS -> android has a monopoly

Number of computers by OS -> nobody has a monopoly http://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:34PM (#17823537)
> This is why I think we need a new way of identifying market abuse because you can make anyone a/not a monopoly based on what definition you use.

Which is why it matters if there are close substitutes or not.

> IOS device software distribution -> apple has a monopoly

There are no good substitutes for this. There is no viable alternative for distributing apps to the people with iOS devices. Distributing apps to people with Android devices isn't a substitute because they're different people, in the same way that distribution in the Northeast is not a substitute for distribution in the Southwest.

> High end phones -> apple probably has a monopoly

There are high end Android phones that are probably adequate substitutes. But if there weren't (or you think they aren't adequate substitutes) then sure.

> Total revenue of phones sold -> apple probably has a monopoly

The market you've specified is "phones" which is obviously not something Apple has a monopoly on. Whole Foods doesn't have a monopoly on food just because they have high margins. There are tons of non-Apple phones if all you need to satisfy to be part of the market is to be a phone.

It may even be a weak market definition because it's too broad -- a feature phone isn't a very good substitute for an iPhone. A better market definition might be smartphones, but even then they still don't have a monopoly. It's not about revenue or margins, it's a question of whether the consumer has a reasonable alternative supplier of something sufficiently equivalent.

> Number of phones (in use?) by OS -> android has a monopoly

The market in that case is would be "phone OS" but then Android has the obvious competition from iOS. Also, Android isn't a company, it's a product. It's nearly impossible for a piece of open source software to have "a monopoly" when literally everyone is allowed to supply it and anyone can do so at trivial cost. All the Android phone manufacturers are each independent suppliers of it.

> Number of computers by OS -> nobody has a monopoly

The market in that case is "computer OS" which is a poor market definition because desktop and phone operating systems are poor substitutes for each other.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by mrep on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:49PM (#17823612)
I agree that there are substitutes for everything except the IOS distribution one. I also agree that most of these metrics are not true monopolies. However, I'm using the term "monopoly" in the way the EU sees it when enacting antitrust fines to curtail this type of behavior because what they basically use is >50% in some arbitrarily chosen metric (percent of of smartphones running an OS used for the EUs recent 5 billion dollar android fine on google) as that is what the EU is currently using to fine companies into "behaving" despite IOS being a much more abusive platform IMO.

This is why I think we need a new way of identifying market abuse.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @09:09PM (#17823707)
The problem with what the EU is doing is that they aren't interested in applying a rigorous standard. It's perfectly possible to define markets or abuse in various ways, but if all they're really doing is to backfill reasoning to justify enormous fines on American businesses there is no point in arguing about what is in practice a rationalization, and the response if they continue to use such ambiguous rules probably ought to be something like lobbying the US government to negotiate a truce (or retaliate in kind against EU businesses).
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by mrep on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @09:56PM (#17823927)
Wow, I cannot upvote you enough.

> The problem with what the EU is doing is that they aren't interested in applying a rigorous standard.

Yeah, this is what I and a lot of other people have a problem with these EU antitrust laws and even GDPR . In the google case, they literally had the android play clauses set from day 1 when they had 0% market share and instead of telling google that they could no longer bundle chrome/search to the play store now that they reached 50% market share in mobile OS (their magic antitrust metric), they waited 7 years and then threw a ridiculous fine at them. If the laws were clear, this wouldn't be a problem.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jpetso on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:48PM (#17822041)
Agreed. Instead of rectifying this via monopoly abuse laws, there should be regulations applicable to all hardware providers for allowing alternative software distribution mechanisms.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by zaroth on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @09:40PM (#17823861)
You want to make it illegal for someone to make a piece of hardware that can only run binaries signed by the manufacturer?

I can’t understand this at all. If I go through the trouble to create a product and I want to control the user experience for that product, that’s my right and privilege. The market will decide if they want to purchase my product or not.

Consumers have spoken, and spoken extremely loudly, that they like Apple’s approach. Why would you want to deny the right for this product to exist?

It’s an amazing product, and what Apple has accomplished with their App Store is nothing short of incredible. I love their approach and I think they are 100% entitled to charge what they want on their own marketplace.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by AnthonyMouse on Thursday August 23, 2018 @01:49AM (#17824889)
> You want to make it illegal for someone to make a piece of hardware that can only run binaries signed by the manufacturer?

I'm not sure why this is supposed to be controversial. It's not a prohibition on checking signatures, it's just a requirement to give the user the option of doing something else.

Once you sell something it's not yours anymore. Companies shouldn't be allowed to stick up everyone in an ancillary market just because they have more market power.

> I can’t understand this at all. If I go through the trouble to create a product and I want to control the user experience for that product, that’s my right and privilege. The market will decide if they want to purchase my product or not.

That's assuming that markets are perfect. What you're saying would be true if there were two versions of the iPhone, one that could only run signed apps and one that was exactly the same but can also run unsigned apps and the customer chose the first one. But that isn't the case, and because that isn't the case you end up forcing someone who wants an iPhone for a reason other than mandatory signing to accept mandatory signing (and the consequent app store monopoly) even though they don't want it. That isn't the market deciding, it's the manufacturer deciding for the market.

> Consumers have spoken, and spoken extremely loudly, that they like Apple’s approach.

This is not really supported by the evidence. The large majority of phone customers chose Android and even among iPhone customers there are multiple other reasons (hardware, UI, status signaling) to choose an iPhone even if you don't want or don't care about app gatekeeping.

The fact that customers don't want it is the whole issue. The first time most users are given a choice between installing an app they want that isn't approved or not having the app, they're going to install it. And given a choice between a distribution method that restricts apps and then charges 30% more and one that doesn't and has lower prices, they're going to pick the lower prices. Otherwise Apple wouldn't have to lock all the doors and windows from the outside -- you could just choose to never install anything outside Apple's store, even if you had the option to do otherwise.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by zaroth on Thursday August 23, 2018 @10:05AM (#17827327)
>> Consumers have spoken, and spoken extremely loudly, that they like Apple’s approach.

> This is not really supported by the evidence...

This isn’t about Apple vs Android or market share. The success of iOS speaks for itself, and in particular the success of the App Store speaks for itself. It is self-evident from the billions of dollars that apps have earned (is it tens of billions now?) that the model is successful and widely used both by developers and consumers. Apple users are much more prolific spenders on the Apple App Store than users of the Android market as well, the majority of that money going directly to developers. This is partly demographics, but also partly the security, reliability, and trust provided by the walled garden.

> And given a choice between a distribution method that restricts apps and then charges 30% more and one that doesn't and has lower prices

As long as apps that are not sold through the Apple Store do not use any Apple APIs to operate, that would be fair.

But if you want to use the massive infrastructure that Apple has built [1] then I think you have to play by Apple’s rules.

The iPhone is a device which you own, yes, but it is also a massive collection of services which Apple spends 10s of billions of dollars developing and supporting in order to deliver the overall experience.

As an app developer, the APIs, services, documentation, training, support, and marketing combine to justify the 30%. The “App Store” application itself, and all the search, discovery, reviews, auto-updates, billing, services, and support is just one piece of the massive infra that Apple provides to all the apps running on its platform.

[1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17823937

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by AnthonyMouse on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:50PM (#17828726)
> The success of iOS speaks for itself, and in particular the success of the App Store speaks for itself. It is self-evident from the billions of dollars that apps have earned (is it tens of billions now?) that the model is successful and widely used both by developers and consumers.

Requiring everyone to use something and then claiming that everyone wants to use it because everyone uses it is a bit circular, isn't it?

> This is partly demographics, but also partly the security, reliability, and trust provided by the walled garden.

But why do you need the walls instead of just a sign that says "now leaving Apple's garden"? If being in Apple's store means you're trusted and make more money then go be in Apple's store. That still doesn't explain why it should be prohibited for a user to install an app outside of it. And then we would find out which factors actually make the difference, instead of claiming it's this and then taking an action inconsistent with it -- if nobody wanted to install apps outside the store then there would be no reason to prohibit it because no one would be trying to do it.

> As long as apps that are not sold through the Apple Store do not use any Apple APIs to operate, that would be fair.

They don't even allow that. If they did you would soon have alternate APIs from Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Canonical, Mozilla or others. But Apple encouraging that would be like Microsoft encouraging use of Sun Java. Apple gets more from people using their API than the people get from using it instead of an alternative.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jpetso on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:24AM (#17824571)
Whether this is your right and privilege is determined by laws and regulations. At the moment, it is. At the same time, there are clearly different opinions as demonstrated by this thread, and your 100% agreement may or may not reflect how society overall feels about this issue or whether it's a good idea.

Neither does my opinion, of course. And either way, the fact that people like the Apple user experience doesn't mean they like or are even informed about the benefits and drawbacks of the iOS App Store model. They may have spoken for that model, or they may hate that model but still buy iPhones because they communicate with the rest of their Apple devices, or because the hardware is innovative and superior, or because they don't want to be tracked by a much scarier surveillance machinery. Without separating the parts and letting each compete on its own, we'll never know what about it is something consumers want and what about it they'd rather pass on.

I'm not calling for an end to products like Apple's. I think it's great that people have access to devices that follow clear policies and security practices which are guaranteed by a trustworthy party.

I do think, though, that this decision should be made by the user in the end. The opportunity to set defaults is already an extremely strong lever for the first-party vendor, and people such as yourself who like it as is have no reason to change anything about it.

I also think that competition can and should happen on different levels, and that control of e.g. hardware or system APIs should not automatically translate to exclusive control over the third-party ecosystem, unless the user explicitly wants this. One possible approach to regulating this, without preventing actual highly integrated products, could be to require the vendor to allow third-party app stores if the product ships with an app store itself. If the iOS experience is actually better with iOS App Store compared to a third-party app store with e.g. lower fees, better search and less stringent controls, why not let them battle it out and let the consumer decide?

It's important to recognize that Apple has created world-class products. It's also important to recognize that the existing duopoly is an extremely strong detractor against competition. It's like the government inviting bids for a giant construction project - if they require the bidders to do everything and the kitchen sink, then only the largest consortiums will be able to apply, whereas if the project is split into several reasonably-sized parts then smaller companies can compete as well and the end result will be cheaper, better executed and more accountable. I think we all agree that competition is a good thing, the question is how large to draw the boundary of what constitutes an integrated product and what should be considered out of scope, to compete in a different market. I think we owe it to society and to future businesses to ensure that a superior product still has a chance of succeeding in the marketplace.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by stale2002 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:08PM (#17822217)
No, Walmart owns those stores. Phones, on the other hand, are owned by the people who purchase them. And those people who own the phones have the full right to do whatever they want with them.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by binomialxenon on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:16PM (#17822728)
Apple does not support these rights, of course. They'd be happy if you were only leasing the use of an iDevice from them.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by DmenshunlAnlsis on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:28PM (#17822813)
You can do whatever you want with your iPhone too, including rooting it, or throwing out of a moving car. Apple can then choose to support it, or not. In the same way that you can buy a given make and model of car and mod it into a dragster, or a tractor if you want to. Apple sells iPhones, and own their store which you can choose to access from your iPhone, or not if you prefer. In addition you can get all of the benefits of “phone” and “app” from another platform if you prefer.

I can buy a Mercedes, and if I want to I can pay a Merc dealership $1400 parts and labor for an ignition coil when the similar part andlabor for a Toyota would be $200. I can also go to a non-Merc shop and seek repairs (and take some risks) for less money. What I can’t do is buy a Mercedes, then turn around and demand that Mercedes sell their parts at Toyota rates and claim that Mercedes has a monopoly on Mercedes.

I mean I could, but I’d rightly be an object of scorn and ridicule. To go back to the WalMart analogy, they have their own store brands as well, and they’re only sold in WalMarts. Why not force them to sell from other outlets, since they’re a monopoly in your fantastical estimation? It’s legal and frankly ethical to restrict sales that way, and a world of other options exist; it’s not WalMart mayo, or no mayo ever again.

By contrast for a real illegal monopoly see Standard Oil or AT&T. If I wanted to use the phone lines, I could pay whatever they wanted or train carrier pigeons. My access to “phone” was entirely a function of whether I was willing to play their game. It wasn’t a matter of having different choices of providers and platforms and marketplaces, it was have a phone with AT&T, or don’t have a phone.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @07:51PM (#17823299)
> You can do whatever you want with your iPhone too, including rooting it

Not according to Apple.

> Why not force them to sell from other outlets, since they’re a monopoly in your fantastical estimation?

They're not a monopoly because the other stores already have products that are adequate substitutes. People can buy a different brand of laundry detergent from a different store without having to replace their washing machine.

> If I wanted to use the phone lines, I could pay whatever they wanted or train carrier pigeons.

Not true -- if you wanted to use phone line all you would have to do is go to Canada where they have non-AT&T phone lines and use them there.

Obviously it isn't very practical to leave the country every time you want to make a phone call, but how is that any different than needing to buy a new phone every time you want to buy an app?

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jliptzin on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:51PM (#17821524)
The problem is it's clearly a monopoly (or duopoly). How did they settle on 30%? Why did Apple and Google come to the same 30% number - is that a coincidence? They could easily provide the same service for less than 1/3 of the cost, but the percent never budges because it doesn't have to. There's zero competitive pressure. In fact they could move it up to 60% if they want to with nothing stopping them. Some people have managed to build a business on these app stores but in my opinion they should only be leveraged as part of an existing independent business, otherwise you're building a business on quicksand.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jimbokun on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:06PM (#17821676)
"Why did Apple and Google come to the same 30% number - is that a coincidence?"

Google copied Apple?

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by iainmerrick on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:31PM (#17821894)
Right. If this were a competitive market, they'd both be constantly refining their cut to find the optimal value. In practice the 30% was plucked out of the air and has never been changed.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Spivak on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:44PM (#17821441)
Keep in mind that the price they charge doesn't really have anything to do with the actual infrastructure despite the costs. They're not selling infrastructure, they're selling access to an audience no different than really any other publisher.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by apersona on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:09PM (#17821701)
What? They're complaining about Valve too.

Bethesda, for example, recently announced that they're launching Fallout 76 on their own personal launcher (https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2018/08/fallout-76s-pc-versio...).

I've noticed this trend in the game industry. Any game company that is large enough will work on their own launcher (look at Blizzard, Epic Games, EA, etc.)

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by ashelmire on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:36PM (#17821923)
Don't Apple and Google take 30% of all in-app sales as well? It's like your phone and internet company saying, "Well, guess we're gonna take 30% of all business you do over the phone or internet" or your rental company demanding 30% of your income.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:43PM (#17821435)
30% seems a lot when BlueSnap/Avangate/FastSpring provide most of the same services for 6-8%.

Of course Apple would argue that they are connecting you to their customers. When there are a million apps in the store I'm not sure how true that is.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Spivak on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:45PM (#17821462)
But Apple's customer base is more valuable, which is why people still publish there despite the cost. Apple and Google aren't selling infrastructure, they're selling an audience.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by tonyedgecombe on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:31AM (#17825553)
That's fine, it makes sense to me that you would develop for Apple before Android because those customers are more affluent and willing to spend on software.

However I question whether the App Store is connecting you to those customers in any meaningful way when there is so much competition in there. Sure if you are lucky enough to get to the front page then you can do OK but most don't.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by chipotle_coyote on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:40PM (#17821952)
Apple also has a large and growing editorial staff writing articles and highlights for their App Store; it's virtually becoming a house magazine. So being in their store potentially offers exposure and marketing for free that's immensely valuable. (Whether it's 30% valuable is debatable, of course. Personally I think they should drop it from 15%/30% to 10%/20%, but "Apple: always more expensive than you think they should be" has worked for them for a long time.)
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by tonyedgecombe on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:24AM (#17825524)
potentially is the key word here.

If you are basing your business on getting exposure in the App Store then you are building it on shaky foundations.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by chipotle_coyote on Thursday August 23, 2018 @06:55PM (#17831285)
There's a reason I put it in italics, to be sure. :)
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by VikingCoder on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:12PM (#17821728)
BlueSnap/Avangate/FastSpring develop a free OS that's used by 85% of the smartphones in the world?

The fee is paying towards the development of Android. Your comparison of "same services" isn't remotely valid.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by tonyedgecombe on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:33AM (#17825561)
Is it? I though Android was subsidised by advertising.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by valuearb on Thursday August 23, 2018 @01:48AM (#17824885)
Payment processing is the smallest part of what the Google and Apple App stores provide, your comparison is ludicrous.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by tonyedgecombe on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:34AM (#17825563)
What other function do you think they are providing for the average developer?
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by valuearb on Friday August 24, 2018 @12:12AM (#17832751)
Distribution is the biggest part.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by OSTN on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:59PM (#17822602)
>Doesn't Valve take 30% from games on Steam? But they're complaining Apple taking 30% is too much?

Nobody is locked to valve on PC. Large game publishers have their own PC stores precisely to avoid getting ripped off by Valve. EA has Origin, Ubisoft has Uplay, Blizzard/Activision has Battle.net. MS has the Microsoft Store. There are many little indie stores with their own handling of profits, like itch.io :

>itch.io costs nothing to use. You are free to create pages and upload your content without ever having to pay anything. Advertisements will never be placed on any of your pages.

>You get to decide how much you want to support itch.io by choosing what percentage of your sales should go towards our operational costs and continued development of the platform. We call that open revenue sharing.

Subscription MMORPGs also all have their own payment schemes and external launchers that bypass Valve's little greedy hands.

Being locked to a single app store on any platform is a mistake. PCs are great because we don't suffer this, for now. Until MS decides to make Windows S the default and lock people from freely switching to a normal version of Windows.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by tw04 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:58PM (#17822126)
If every app I downloaded were several to several 10s of gigabytes of data, I might be more inclined to cut them some slack. 30% on a 5MB download is pretty tough to justify. The cost of storing and transferring that file is a rounding error.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by zaroth on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @10:00PM (#17823937)
What makes you think the 30% cut is to pay for the bandwidth of the file transfer?

The entire platform the app runs on was created by Apple. The hardware, the OS, the programming language, the SDKs.

Thousands of APIs used to build the apps, maybe a million pages of documentation on those APIs.

All the toolchain to develop, build, test, and deploy apps for purchase in hundreds of countries including customer profiles, billing, and support.

Billions of dollars of iCloud infrastructure for backend services to support everything from push notifications, data sync, backup, automatic updates, etc.

Then you get into the actual app store and you have all the work that went into the UX there for discovering, installing, buying and reviewing apps. In-app purchases and subscription services to support different business models. Family sharing, parental controls, parental approval requirements for kids’ phones.

I could go on for hours and probably still miss huge swaths of functionality that Apple invested millions of dollars into, just so that you could pull up chair and with a few lines of code start writing an app that can reach billions of devices.

Not to mention all the marketing and training and support Apple does to prime their customers to be big users of the App Store.

Yeah, and the bandwidth to download the app as well.

Personally I think 30% is a steal for what you get in return.

Oh, and I’ll just add one more thing; you can distribute your app for free and you pay Apple nothing (or nearly nothing) for the benefit of all their hard work and infrastructure and support.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by akshat_h on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:53PM (#17821550)
Does Steam take a cut for in game purchases? I think the major issue here is with companies having app stores inside app store. All the companies mentioned i.e Amazon, Steam seem to allow in-app purchases at a scale quite different than normal apps. It does seem weird that if I am purchasing an item through Steam's app store, Steam has to pay Apple.

I mean it would be like Amazon paying Apple a cut, if I buy a TV from amazon. AFAIK, it is only for digital goods that Apple charges, but I am not sure how the demarcation works.

On the flip side, if Apple/Google allow any app to use in-app purchases without a commission, then all apps will use in-app purchases for everything.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by cma on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:38AM (#17824620)
> Does Steam take a cut for in game purchases?

Yes. That's why they cut out remote control purchasing feature from their iOS app, to avoid hypocrisy charges and to avoid the sticky situation where a steam app tried the same (letting you make microtransaction purchases by remoting in to your phone or something).

Same as why Epic dropped their marketplace cut down from 30% something like one week before their "30% is unfair" press campaign which in turn was used to take the spotlight off criticism of Fortnite's release on Android as a timed exclusive with Samsung's new flagship.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by radley on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:27PM (#17822344)
> But for every big app there's something like 9 that fail completely

Actually the ratio is more like 1 to 500k. There are millions of apps in both stores, but I'd bet less than 1000 make significant income exclusively from the app stores.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dkonofalski on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:48PM (#17822508)
I agree. There's a lot that people take for granted with these App Stores, especially with Apple's. The alternative is to pass this cost onto the consumer instead and I think that's a terrible idea.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by halo on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:56PM (#17822575)
Many major PC games publishers and developers have chosen either to not to use Steam or have reduced their support including EA, Epic, Microsoft (including Mojang), Riot, Activision Blizzard and Bethesda.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by forrestthewoods on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:11PM (#17823413)
Steam’s 30% is also too high.

There’s a reason the new Fallout 76 is skipping Steam and will be sold through a Bethesda launcher.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by ben_jones on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:41PM (#17821420)
I don't know if you have a "fair" argument here. Who needs that 30% more Apple or an independent app developer? Though the same could be said for Valve, at least it's the purpose of Valve where apple sells computing devices not software as their core enterprise.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kodablah on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:54PM (#17821555)
> Doesn't Valve take 30% from games on Steam? But they're complaining Apple taking 30% is too much?

They're complaining Apple is taking too much without alternative. If the app store provided 30% worth of value, it would be voluntarily chosen like Steam is. Why derail with such a ridiculous equivalence?