News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by rlanday on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:03PM (#17821642)
> Apple adds no value there

Other than inventing the modern phone, writing the operating system and developer tools, running the store, manufacturing the phones people are consuming Amazon's product on and convincing people to buy them...you can argue about what's "fair," but Apple's certainly adding value.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by earenndil on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:19PM (#17821795)
All of those except 'running the store' are value paid for in the purchase of the phone, not the software on it.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by bovine3dom on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:55PM (#17822108)
Money is fungible. I would be very surprised if Apple didn't regard revenue from the App Store as partially due to their investment in the iPhone.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Buge on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:45AM (#17824653)
Why? Is it wrong to sell a phone at low cost and charge more for apps? Video game consoles sometimes are sold at a loss in order to make money from games.

It's similar to Fortnite's model: sell the game at a low cost (free actually), and then make money from inessential addons (skins).

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by earenndil on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:54AM (#17824693)
It's fine for a company to sell hardware/os at a loss and recoup the costs with apps, if they predict that they'll make more money that way. However, it's not reasonable for them to, say, refuse me service on the os because all I bought was a hardware+os, not any apps. Nor is it reasonable for them to make me, an app-maker, bear the brunt of the os, since I have nothing to do with the os, just the app store.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Buge on Thursday August 23, 2018 @01:03AM (#17824737)
If I buy a smart fridge, even though it has a computer in it, I don't expect to be able to install arbitrary software on it in a supported manner. Apple doesn't advertise as a computing platform for everything, they advertise as having a whitelist of apps, and that's what they provide. I don't want a phone with a whitelist, so I don't buy iOS phones. But some people do want that type of product, and do buy them.

You do have something to do with the os. Your app is running on the os.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jjeaff on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:51AM (#17824681)
If that were the case, no, nothing wrong... But apple is making a huge markup on their $1200 phones. They aren't making up a loss with their app store. They're just piling on the cash.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Buge on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:54AM (#17824692)
Would it be wrong of apple to make the app store fee 5% and then increase the phone price whatever percent is necessary to make up that loss? Would that be considered piling on the cash?
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by jjeaff on Thursday August 23, 2018 @03:09PM (#17829801)
At least then, buyers get a more realistic view of total cost of ownership up front, rather than hiding the rest of the profits in the pricing of other people's apps.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by FireBeyond on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:27PM (#17822340)
> Other than inventing the modern phone

Come on now.

> writing the operating system

Which OS, iOS, that the phone purchaser inherently paid for? Or macOS, that the computer purchaser inherently paid for?

> developer tools

Which you need to purchase a developer license for to be useful.

Apple is adding value, AND double dipping. Most of your examples are things they've already been compensated for.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Buge on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:48AM (#17824671)
Just because they've already been compensated to some degree doesn't mean they've been fully compensated. Video game consoles are sometimes sold at a loss in order to make money on games.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by FireBeyond on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:40AM (#17828138)
The richest company in the world, with the largest cash reserves in the world, is not being fully compensated for their efforts?
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Buge on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:44PM (#17832624)
I mean they might not be fully compensated if they remove the app store fees.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by CamperBob2 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:44PM (#17822467)
Come on now.

They invented the app ecosystem, which is far more important than just inventing a phone. Without Apple, the application market would still be controlled by Sprint and AT&T and Verizon.

Not defending Apple or attacking it, just pointing out the facts.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by rohit2412 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:39PM (#17822878)
And how is Apple's walled app store any better than the alternative of at&t controlled app store?

They can keep their 30% cut if they allow me to sideload apps from external sources.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by orbitur on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @11:07PM (#17824224)
> And how is Apple's walled app store any better than the alternative of at&t controlled app store?

I don't know if you've used an iPhone, but do you really think AT&T's walled garden would have anything approaching the quality of the best apps on the App Store?

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by CamperBob2 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:20PM (#17830376)
He or she is probably just young. No one who was there would ask a question like that, even rhetorically.

Sadly, people have forgotten how much life sucked for mobile developers before the iPhone. Apple's contribution is reflected in various peoples' prejudices and agendas, but not in history books. Only Nixon could go to China, and only Jobs could have stared down AT&T from a position of weakness.

I'm not an Apple partisan, and I'm definitely not going to defend the concept of locking a general-purpose computing platform away from its own users, but I'll always give him credit for that.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kartan on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:35PM (#17822413)
> but Apple's certainly adding value.

Do roads add value? Should trucks pay a 30% of their cargo retail price in road tolls?

I agree with your point that Apple adds value. I just do not see that as a justification to take a 30% share of all apps that run on their devices.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by greedo on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:28PM (#17822812)
Trucks pay fees based on the load they're carrying...
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by fjsolwmv on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @10:07PM (#17823968)
The weight, not the price.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by Steltek on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:42AM (#17826370)
As trucks account for a high (90%ish) amount of road wear, they actually probably should pay a high fee. Accurate costs might also make the rail freight industry more cost competitive, leading to better market diversity.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by 1123581321 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:50PM (#17822954)
Comparing distribution of physical goods is a poor analogy as the variable costs are high, and low or zero for App Store developers. We know from tariffs that a 30% fee on mining or manufacturing increases costs and reduces trade, but despite Apple’s 30%, the cost of an app has been driven down. This suggests that a high revenue share of a software sale is viable in a way that a high revenue share of a truck load is not.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kartan on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:59AM (#17828334)
> This suggests that a high revenue share of a software sale is viable in a way that a high revenue share of a truck load is not.

This is a good point. But I would rather see this apps more highly taxed than to allow monopolistic empires to grow.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by 1123581321 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:21PM (#17828523)
Sorry, are you saying you’d like App Store software taxed enough that sales are low and it’s not viable for Apple to make money, forcing them to allow an unregulated open market if they want a meaningful number of apps on their phones? It’s an interesting idea, but I think the opportunity cost early on would have been that entire software market. And the opportunity cost now would be killing a large percentage of businesses that sell software to that market that can’t afford to handle distribution themselves. This quickly gets into the debate about whether it’s better to have large and many small companies or no large and few small companies.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by kartan on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:02PM (#17830274)
> Sorry, are you saying you’d like App Store software taxed enough that sales are low and it’s not viable for Apple to make money, forcing them to allow an unregulated open market if they want a meaningful number of apps on their phones?

No. :)

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by 1123581321 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:06PM (#17830294)
:)

Well, what are you saying? I seriously don’t understand what you meant.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dingaling on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:00PM (#17822145)
> Other than inventing the modern phone

IBM Simon, 1992.

Applr popularised, they didn't invent. Ironically given the target of their 1984 ad.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by binomialxenon on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:07PM (#17822673)
The ridiculously tall screen was certainly ahead of its time.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by gameswithgo on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:04PM (#17821650)
Anything is fair, but I don't like things that only allow app stores as a first class way to get software on my machine.

I have voted with my wallet. But it is getting harder to do so, soon only linux will be left.

Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by dkonofalski on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:39PM (#17822881)
That's fine but you're not really the intended market for the App Stores. App Stores are for the people that click "Yes" to everything and end up with Internet Explorer as a strip of their screen because they have 42 toolbars installed. Those people undoubtedly like app stores precisely for being the only way to get software on their machines.
Re:Apple and Google Face Growing Revolt Over App Store ‘Tax’ by voltagex_ on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:05PM (#17823384)
I dunno - I much prefer the Microsoft app store on Windows for simple applications that I don't need to customise much. It's quicker than finding the right exe and keeping it up to date myself.