News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by wnoise on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:31PM (#15827108)
> CS programs have, in the main, not decided that the primary path to becoming a programmer should involve doing material actual programming.

Well, that's because CS programs are designed to teach CS, not to be a vocational school for programmers.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by drewrv on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:47PM (#15827293)
I've been spending a lot of time lately wondering if people who treat colleges and universities as though their job is worker training are confused, or if I'm naive in believing colleges and universities exist to expand human knowledge through research and education.

I suspect the answer is that our culture is confused, we want people who are smart and well rounded to also be useful. And the ugly side of it is, we want clear class divisions. One would never refer to law school or medical school as "vocational".

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by codingdave on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:04PM (#15827465)
> One would never refer to law school or medical school as "vocational".

Sure you would. They are 100% vocational schools. Their cost, acceptance rates, time commitment, and difficulty level may be higher than other vocational schools, but that doesn't change what they are -- 100% focused on giving you the knowledge and skills to do a specific job.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by kod on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:07PM (#15829642)
Law schools (or at least the top 20 school that I went to) are definitely not 100% focused on teaching you the vocation of being an attorney.

Hell, they aren't even focused on teaching you to pass the bar, which is why most people pay for separate cram schools.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by acoard on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:02PM (#15846469)
Yet, going to law school is a pre-requisite for becoming the vocation of a lawyer.

Arguably, "a school one must go to in order to practice a vocation" can be referred to as a "vocational school." I understand that vocational schools are often thought to be purely practical and not theoretical, but I think this definition does a disservice to the reality of entering certain vocations.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by kod on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:57PM (#15854568)
No, it is not a pre-requisite. At least in the U.S., several states still allow you to pass the bar and become a licensed attorney without going to law school.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by icebraining on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:35PM (#15827754)
That's the point - they are, but are not referred as such.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by cvwright on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:09PM (#15828994)
They are in fact called "professional schools" -- this captures what both of you are saying.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by hammock on Saturday December 02, 2017 @11:46AM (#15832692)
They are actually called "professional" schools, but yeah it's a euphemism that means the same thing.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Danihan on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:32PM (#15827722)
Well then where are all the "vocational" CS programs at universities?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by AYBABTME on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:55PM (#15827949)
Canada has ‘software engineering’ degrees which are essentially vocational CS degrees.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by kat on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:05PM (#15828964)
To add to this, Canadian Universities also have co-op programs.

You don't have to have an engineering degree to get a co-op job. The student gets paid well over minimum wage (and learns on the job) and the employers get financial incentives from the gov't to hire students. Its win-win for both the student and the employer.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by dharness on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:48AM (#15830417)
Software Engineering at Canadian universities does not contain a dramatically different level of vocational training (with the exception of Waterloo).

Co-op programs are optional, and take place in the summer or in a gap year. The affiliation of companies hosting co-ops is loose, and the schools charge large fees for participating in these programs (with the exception of Waterloo).

Speaking from personal experience, results may vary.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jholman on Saturday December 02, 2017 @05:42AM (#15831332)
Which Canadian schools have software engineering degrees which are vocational?

Note that my degree is from a well-reputed Canadian school that has a "software engineering specialization", and as far as I can tell (though I did not take it) that specialization is indistinguishable from the main CS curriculum, and is not valid vocational training.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by rhizome on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:55PM (#15827959)
Medical and Law schools are postgraduate.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by maccard on Saturday December 02, 2017 @11:46AM (#15832696)
In some places. In Ireland, law is a normal undergraduate degree with some extra vocational training after you graduate. Medicine is an undergraduate (5 year) programme, during which quite a lot is vocational - students spend multiple months in hospitals during that period, and when they graduate they are still considered as training.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by kingkawn on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:40PM (#15827794)
Coding Boot camps
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by AnimalMuppet on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:41PM (#15827811)
... which are not at universities.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by inopinatus on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:53PM (#15827924)
And will also not prepare you for a job in computer science.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by enraged_camel on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:06PM (#15828566)
They might prepare you for an intro-level job in software development though, if you actually continue learning things and honing your skills after completing them.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by djellybeans on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:30PM (#15829131)
For what it's worth, these bootcamps are the current "trade schools" for software jobs where the barrier to entry is lower. They're accelerated programs that use job placement as a strong selling point.

It's almost like they rose from the death of many for-profit technical schools (DeVry, WestWood et al.) and took their ecological niche. But in contrast to bootcamps, these for-profit schools were too big, slow, and ineffective.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by sharemywin on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:54PM (#15827943)
in the business college.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:06PM (#15827482)
Higher education is used as a proxy for intelligence by companies who are hiring because they are not allowed to use IQ tests. So I think it kind of makes sense that our society is confused about the purpose of higher education.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by valuearb on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:48PM (#15827873)
It's not just an IQ test, it's a test of ability, which is different. Your college record shows that you

a) Whether you were able to get the work done. b) Whether you were smart enough to do the work well.

It's the combination that's important, not either single one. Employers want people who show up on time, actually care enough to try, and are smart enough to figure it out.

The college degree has a better than zero correlation to that. After you get the job it's mainly about performance and output, once you've been promoted a few times your college degree mostly doesn't matter.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:18PM (#15829057)
I agree with all of that, though spending 4 years to make that determination seems crazy to me. A competent employer can figure out which hires are worthwhile in about a month or so.

There’s another issue with using educational attainment as a proxy of intelligence: it doesn’t really help you distinguish among candidates who all have a bachelors degree. All you know is that they’re above some threshold, but not how far above. You can use the prestige of the school as a proxy for this, but it all seems like a hell of a lot of hassle when you can figure this all out in a half hour with an IQ test.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by fjsolwmv on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:46PM (#15829812)
IQ test tell you how good someone is at pattern recognition, which is a major factor in abilo to learn. It doesn't tell you what they have learned, or if they have the criticality important skill of perseverance/grit. In fact, high IQ can reduce grit, since clever pattern matchers use their cleverness to avoid working hard on the toy problems of childhood.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by johnnyhillbilly on Sunday December 03, 2017 @07:05AM (#15837237)
My personal take on this is that high IQ quickly turns into a liability in childhood. Particularly when entering the school system.

I believe the words "bored to tears" summarize the experience quite well.

While the majority of pupils get a standardized curriculum designed to keep their interest at a steady pace, pupils with a high learning capacity get no such thing. If they try to learn faster, it doesn't fit with the governance and management model within which the teacher must operate. Therefore, most teachers are at a loss when faced with these statistical outliers.

Also, other pupils may experience emotions of inadequacy and unfairness when a fellow pupil just blasts through the material in minutes that would take them all week. This may lead to the high capacity pupil being a target of some unfortunate group dynamics.

Since schools have no governance model for this, the high learning capacity pupil's school experience is essentially unmanaged. At a loss, society almost invariably resorts to platitudes like "No need to feel sorry for them, because they are so fortunate to be smart. We must focus on the pupils that struggle."

A few years down the line, the pupil's inner motivation may be completely replaced by depression, self-blaming or worse. Then the platitudes take a turn for the worse with blaming the pupil's willingness to work: "In fact, high IQ can reduce grit, since clever pattern matchers use their cleverness to avoid working hard on the toy problems of childhood."

Fortunately, my own school days are long since gone. Without blaming any person in the system, I can say: "Good riddance!" to this whole pitiful affair of how society treated me as a child.

Instead, I can draw attention to this problem by saying clearly that these are children that never asked for these gifts in the first place. Let's as a society realize that what we are doing to them is absolutely wrong and woefully irresponsible.

Fortunately, at least one western country has political attention on this right now. I will work hard and with "grit" to make sure that my experience and observations can help in creating new policies. In particular I wish to address how to practically leverage the pupils' own drive to learn without incurring social/peer stigma or ridiculous costs.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Sunday December 03, 2017 @01:01PM (#15838626)
This is a huge problem.

We are perfectly happy to identify athletic talent and enact systems so that the athletically talented are matched up with peers who share their gifts, but we mostly refuse to do this for intellectual talent.

I was fortunate enough to attend a program that handled this pretty well. Basically it was 120 kids from 11-18 who skipped high school and attended university together instead. It’s called the Early Entrance Program and it’s at Cal State Los Angeles:

http://www.calstatela.edu/academic/eep

The issue I face is that I am raising my children in Portland, Oregon, so this program will not be an option for them. Our personal approach is to home school instead. And I’ll probably investigate starting something like the Early Entrance Program at the state university in Portland here.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by rogerbinns on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:59PM (#15827997)
It also shows that you could do that for several years, following the rules set by someone else, and passing.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by bittercynic on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:41PM (#15828385)
Nice double meaning with 'passing' also meaning something like: "able to appear to be what those in power want me to be."
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by mwfunk on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:24PM (#15828688)
I would not interpret it that way at all. Being able to understand requirements and implement stuff based on those requirements, or work as part of a team, or maintain dedication to a task for weeks or months at a time, has nothing to do with teenage notions of the world being populated by conformists vs. nonconformists (which ironically is usually based on very conformist notions of what it means to be a nonconformist).

On the other hand, I have known a number of people who used their self-identification as a nonconformist as an excuse for why they couldn't cut it someplace, whether it's school or a job or some interpersonal situation. It's a bad excuse because it gives the person an easy out for not reflecting on how they could have handled the situation better, or avoided getting into the situation in the first place. It also pushes all of the blame on other people, which is comforting but very rarely 100% true. We should all be our own worst critics, lest someone else beats us to it.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by cloverich on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:23PM (#15832894)
For better or worse, it _is_ a proxy for many things. But one that i think is most relevant to a typical job is the ability to see something that is sometimes fun, sometimes boring, and sometimes challenging through to the end. Typically staying put in one place while doing so. Its not intended to be vocational training, but in a sense it matches very well with what's expect of the typical employee: Show up consistently, deal with stress and various people and tasks with an ability to see it all through, without quitting or pissing too many people off. If you can cope well and make it through undergrad, you can likely handle a vast array of jobs.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jogjayr on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:46PM (#15827854)
> because they are not allowed to use IQ tests

There's actual employment law that prohibits using IQ tests? I'd never heard that before

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Phlarp on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:58PM (#15828513)
An IQ test can be used during the hiring process but the employer has to be able to defend its use as directly relevant to the work at hand. So most employers aren't willing to spend the legal fees related to defending the use of a direct IQ test... Possibly because the college degree is a good enough litmus test for IQ to satisfy their needs.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by vilmosi on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:13PM (#15829027)
If it's difficult to prove that IQ is relevant to the job... Maybe it's not. Also, I doubt that's the reason.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:31PM (#15829135)
It’s not difficult to demonstrate that IQ is relevant to job performance (its the best predictor of performance for most jobs). The problem is to demonstrate that it doesn’t have a discriminatory effect (there are large, persistent differences in IQ between races).
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by vilmosi on Sunday December 03, 2017 @07:14PM (#15840485)
There's already an imbalance when it comes to different genders and races, I don't get what they would lose.

The real reason companies don't do it is because Fizz Buzz is a better test than IQ tests.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Wh1zz on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:48AM (#15830418)
Source on that first claim?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by rvern on Saturday December 02, 2017 @08:34AM (#15831792)
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by ramses0 on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:28PM (#15828281)
It's related to anti-discrimination / "psychology-test" laws. If there is any sort of "test" given as a condition of employment, it must be relevant, standardized, non-biased, reviewed by specialists and approved, etc.

http://cdn8.openculture.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/Test1...

The value and definition of "IQ" is widely disputed and generally seen as of limited relevance to the actual work and performance of that work (uncorrelated). Look it up and do some research if you're interested, this is just a quick showing of _why_ tests may be considered bad.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by majormajor on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:54PM (#15828481)
One day I wonder if some lawyer will strike it big by making an argument that looking at universities is discrimination because e.g. family connections and wealth give you a big leg up in getting into certain elite schools...
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:22PM (#15829073)
Yeah, but most universities engage in affirmative action, which theoretically negates this.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jogjayr on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:57PM (#15828505)
The linked image you shared is one I've seen before that was a Louisiana state voter literacy test used for voter suppression. It was disproportionately administered to black voters[1]

I'm not saying that IQ tests are useful measures of ability to do a job. I just wasn't aware there was actual law or precedent forbidding their use.

> If there is any sort of "test" given as a condition of employment, it must be relevant, standardized, non-biased, reviewed by specialists and approved, etc.

Wouldn't this disqualify a lot of whiteboard interviews too? Most startups don't have a standard question bank reviewed by experts or grade on a standard rubric.

1. http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_vault/2013/06/28/voting_right...

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:20PM (#15829069)
Whiteboard tests are directly relevant to the position being hired for and, thus, okay to use.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by sgustard on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:51PM (#15829270)
The classic "how many gas stations are there in the USA?" type of interview question seem exactly like an IQ test and not at all relevant to job requirements.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by benji-york on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:22PM (#15828237)
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by pavlov on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:34PM (#15827745)
If IQ tests were a reliable measure of any job capability, surely the brilliant minds at Mensa would already have made a mint by selling recruitment services.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:49PM (#15829260)
See this commment elsewhere in the thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15828513
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by chefandy on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:47PM (#15827865)
Well, part of the problem is that mensa is a total crock of shit.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by pessimizer on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:21PM (#15828225)
Whatever it is, it's a group filled with people who score very high on iq tests.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by git_rancher on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:29PM (#15828290)
You may not know this but a primary purpose of Mensa is to help "smart" people find other "smart" people to socialize with. In that sense it succeeds (I'm a member).
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by astura on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:47PM (#15829580)
Define "crock of shit?" It's just an organization with membership requirements, by that logic organizations such as the VFW are a "crock of shit."
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Danihan on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:32PM (#15827732)
For fuck's sake, cut out the middle man and just request SAT / ACT scores.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by auxym on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:43PM (#15827825)
I'm canadian so have never taken these tests, but I was under the impression that a large component of scoring well on them is cramming?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by losvedir on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:04PM (#15828057)
Not really. I think of the SAT as a great equalizer since a brilliant kid in rural Nebraska will do well and be able to go to an elite college, while a silver spoon heir will spend thousands and maybe improve their score but certainly not max it out.

Not to toot my own horn but I got a perfect score on the math part of the SAT with little prep, and I've tutored others on the same and only managed to eke out a little improvement. (In contrast, I've tutored math course work and had more success there.)

The math isn't very advanced, it's just a matter of doing it quickly and accurately.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 02, 2017 @09:21AM (#15831923)
> I think of the SAT as a great equalizer

The truth is more nuanced [1].

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/03/05/these...

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by thaumasiotes on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:11PM (#15829408)
From a psychometric perspective, they are IQ tests, in that they show the same correlation with IQ tests that IQ tests show with each other.

From a research-into-today's-hot-button-issues perspective, they are routinely slammed for being about cramming, but the effect of test preparation on test scores tends to be very close to zero when you look into it.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by akgerber on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:34PM (#15828332)
I did very well on both tests in high school without much cramming (I skimmed one study book from the library), and scored something like 90th percentile when I took the ACT in middle school.

Whether this is correlated to anything important in real life is an entirely separate question.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by trentmb on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:36PM (#15828346)
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jx2zhou on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:53PM (#15827929)
You're correct.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Joof on Saturday December 02, 2017 @03:55AM (#15831025)
I did well, but I also took it with a severe migraine. Can I take it again now?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by danjoc on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:20PM (#15828219)
>Higher education is used as a proxy for intelligence by companies who are hiring because they are not allowed to use IQ tests.

I think you're wrong about that,

http://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/sto...

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:39PM (#15829195)
Your link is to a story about an employer who uses a test which is a proxy for intelligence (they even give the rough equivalency between the test they use and IQ). I think that supports my point that intelligence is one of the more important things employers are looking for. Most employers don’t have the resources to develop a hiring screening test and then certify that it is not discriminatory, so they use educational attainment instead.

Another way to approach this is to ask yourself: if not as a proxy for intelligence, then why do some jobs require a college degree?

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by danjoc on Sunday December 03, 2017 @01:42PM (#15838809)
Still wrong.

https://www.hiresuccess.com/blog/is-employment-testing-legal

>I think that supports my point

I didn't say it invalidated your point. I'm trying to draw your attention to a specific area in your statement that is wrong. You can simply say,

>Higher education is used as a proxy for intelligence by companies

That's enough. Nobody will argue with you about that.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by astura on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:37PM (#15829531)
IQ tests used for hiring do exist in the US - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wonderlic_test
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by fjsolwmv on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:55PM (#15829855)
Yes, and that exact test was the one that is legally fraught: https://www.wonderlic.com/resources/publications/white-paper...
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by crdoconnor on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:20PM (#15828670)
Higher education seems like more of a "class marker" to me.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:47PM (#15829252)
Or maybe the causal factor for both class and higher education is intelligence. The Bell Curve makes a compelling case that the transition away from agriculture toward knowledge work over the last 100 years has created a society in which intelligence is funneled into higher education and from there into high paying professions.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by fjsolwmv on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:04PM (#15829895)
The Bell Curve is a famous case of quasi-science. You are putting statistical speculation up against centuries of well-documented explicit discrimination policies.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:09PM (#15830094)
Have you read The Bell Curve?

You may disagree with some of its conclusions (I personally am skeptical of its conclusions about racial differences in IQ), but to call it pseudo science is, I think, unfair. FWIW, Steven Pinker, who is about as thoughtful and level headed as they come, agrees:

https://mobile.twitter.com/sapinker/status/84691284703672320...

And, anyway, the point I was making had nothing to do with racial IQ differences. It was referring to what the rest of The Bell Curve is about (discussion of racial IQ differences makes up only about 25% of the book): how the US society’s transition away from most people working in agriculture toward most people working at desks has created a class structure stratified by intelligence.

It’s actually a shame that the book discusses racial IQ differences at all, because everyone got hung up on that and totally missed what is, IMO, a much more important point. And I think it explains a lot about current politics in the US.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by holbrad on Saturday December 02, 2017 @02:31PM (#15833554)
You seem to be rather confused about the Bell Curve.

It's my understanding that the main data presented hasn't been overturned or disproved (In-fact quite the opposite)

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by vilmosi on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:03PM (#15828041)
Meh, IQ is potential, not capability, to do a job. I don't find this argument convincing. What about all the literal geniuses who have no interest and never studied CS?

At least the graduate can show that he/she can commit to a multi-year long, sometimes boring, project successfully. A high IQ person could just leave your company after 6 months because "they're bored".

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:16PM (#15829440)
I’m not saying employers would hire solely based on IQ. That would be crazy. It’s just a screening measure. But so is educational attainment. Nobody gets hired because they have a college degree, but plenty of people don’t get hired because they lack a college degree.

Also, agree that educational attainment gives you more information about a candidate, but in terms of assessing intelligence, it is a coarser measure than IQ. I’ve hired a few people in my day, and there is huge divergence in intelligence among college grads. For lots of jobs it is useful to be able to distinguish between not-stupid, bright, and ridiculously smart. Educational attainment doesn’t really help with that, but IQ tests would.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by mrkurt on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:01PM (#15827427)
People aren't confused. Colleges do many things.

They're also very expensive to attend, and the most immediate value they offer is to get people jobs

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by rch on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:55PM (#15827374)
I've heard doctors speak of themselves as having a trade skill... albeit one that pays well.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by yesenadam on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:05PM (#15829374)
Fascinating point. Is "training vs education" a useful pair of terms? Universities used to be for education, now often its assumed they are for training only. (Bachelor of Science in Hotel Management I come across nowadays - in what?!)

I often hear people talk as if education was something that happened to them, then it finished. (Like learning is something you just do in an institution.) I guess training is more like that, teaching knowledge and skills for some particular task/role/job.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by fjsolwmv on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:06PM (#15829903)
How is learning how to run a hotel not an education? Are all the Agriculture and Mechanical universities not education?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by yesenadam on Saturday December 02, 2017 @02:58PM (#15833706)
Well, that's the point - those things, training to do a particular job, are now thought of as 'education'.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by dvdhnt on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:05PM (#15827469)
> And the ugly side of it is, we want clear class divisions.

What? I suspect that it's typically, if not exclusively, those in the upper classes that want this. The ugly side of it is human nature is selfish.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by aeorgnoieang on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:00PM (#15828013)
Actually, I suspect that it's the middle class (or middle classes for cultures with more than three classes) that are most anxious about being mistaken as lower class. Actual upper class members don't usually care – they're not relying on university attendance to protect their positions.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by santoshalper on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:32PM (#15827730)
I definitely would refer to law and medical schools as vocational, much more so than many other educational programs.

I have known several people who went to medical or law school and every single one them went only because it is a per-requisite to becoming a doctor or lawyer. What is your explanation, that people attend these schools to expand their mind, and then entirely coincidentally, manage to end up in the corresponding career as though by accident?

Get real.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by patientplatypus on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:08PM (#15828588)
Ugh...I hear this sort of thing all the time and I find it sooo obnoxious.

Look, the reason that all the students go to university is to make money. Like 90%+ of undergrads go there to make money so whether it "technically" should be a monastery of cloistered academics pondering the universe (based on some high minded notion of what learning "ought" to be for) is besides the point. University costs a shit ton of money and people (the vast majority) pay it so they can have a decent life.

And the fact that universities are, on the whole, teaching skills that do not help their students accomplish this means either A) they are actively misleading their students B) university is a class indicator more than a place to learn (I can spend huge amounts of money so I'm probably not poor and black - which sucks for all sorts of reasons) or C) they don't understand that teaching academic CS, as opposed to programming, is not what industry demands (so they suck at what they're selling).

These are the people who, quite literally, are billing themselves as the "smartest guys in the room". If that's the case they can well stop sucking at their bloody job!

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jknoepfler on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:34PM (#15828763)
There are two things wrong with this perspective.

First, if you walk out of a four year degree in computer science without a strong foundation in discrete mathematics, algorithms, data structures, and at least one of distributed systems theory, stochastic systems theory, control, statistics/machine learning, AI, data visualization, or design, you've stunted your horizons for growth as an engineer pretty badly. I use three of those every day at work. I wouldn't be able to read the research, do the math, or write the software to implement what I work on without a very strong education in fundamentals. The only CSE course I took in University that I haven't made active use of was an advanced matrix computation course. I mean, if you're just shitting out web services and REST APIs or converting COBOL to Java, fine, but that's something you can train a monkey (and in very short order, a computer) to do.

Secondly, we invest in Universities as a public good. You should come out of a four year program able to write well, critically analyze difficult material (not "Catcher in the Rye"), articulate complex ideas persuasively, and understand the world you live in and how to live in it substantially better than when you went in. You might be surprised to learn that with the benefit of hindsight, many people find the time they spent reading and learning to be incredibly useful later in life, as it provided a foundation for dealing with conflict and complexity. If that's wasted on you, then it's wasted on you, but understand that you have shot yourself in the foot in terms of your ability to mature as a human being. I personally think public University education should be substantially more rigorous and should fail people aggressively, and should also be free. I wish we separated the whole "whoo look at me I'm 18-22 let's party" thing from the thought of University. If that's where you are in life at 18, there's nothing wrong with that... go work as a code monkey or a barista and get it out of your system, and when you're ready to level up as a human being give University a try, go. That's more or less what worked for me, anyway.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by mangodrunk on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:54PM (#15829293)
>You should come out of a four year program able to write well, critically analyze difficult material (not "Catcher in the Rye"), articulate complex ideas persuasively, and understand the world you live in and how to live in it substantially better than when you went in.

What a great comment. I think that's also missed by schools where the focus is on memorization and/or trivia. It would be great if they focused on the areas you talked about, not necessarily directly, but at least that is the goal.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by patientplatypus on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:04PM (#15830075)
Well, not that it matters to my argument, but I did go to university, and did well (in the academic sense - much of my time would probably have been better spent drinking and networking rather than getting good grades). Personally I think it was an incredible waste of time. Even though I worked incredibly hard in many diverse subject areas, most of what I learned was taught at such an abstract level as to be completely unusable in any practical sense. Almost all of what I needed I later learned on the job as needed. Of all the things you've listed, why can't you just look them up on the internet or hire a tutor at worst?

As far as "leveling up as a human being", books are free - go sit in a library. Hell, grab a kindle; most of the cool stuff that I learned about the human experience I learned from talking with others, staring at the sky, hiking in mountains, and reading free books that people on the internet recommend. None of this requires taking out the equivalent of a mortgage or listening to someone lecture on it. If you want a lecture, those are free online too!

I just get the sense that university is used as a filter to differentiate yourself from people who are "below you" - not as smart, not as hard working, not as "mature as a human being". But the main barrier to get into a university seems to be connections and money, neither of which I have a huge amount of respect for. Many of the wealthiest and well connected people in the world are huge assholes, and many of the poorest and least connected are incredibly wise and kind (and intelligent and hard working). It feels like a way to separate yourself from the unwashed hoi polloi and put a barrier to entry between yourself and other people who could do your job. In that sense university encourages laziness!

Overall, I just get this sense that university is this bullshit thing we all just agree to participate in because, for those who go they get a monetary benefit, even though everyone knows its just this bullshit thing. That monetary benefit comes from being a class filter, a networking tool for like minded rich people to find other like minded rich people, and probably a few other class effects I don't really understand. I thought when I was younger that as I got older that maybe I would get more jaded and just accept bullshit things. It would certainly make my life easier to do what other people do and not fight against the tide. But if anything I've become more altruistic and romantic, I want the world to be more honest and people to do the right thing.

I don't know. I've probably benefitted from it even though I wished people judged me based on other qualities that are more important.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by noneedtoask on Saturday December 02, 2017 @06:06AM (#15831397)
First, you should know that the "barrier of connections and money" you talk about does not apply everywhere. Actually, a lot of universities are free so long as you prove you are smart enough through entry exams. So while it still is used as a class filter everywhere, realize that there is equal chance in a lot of countries to get into any university.

Secondly, universities are not meant to prepare you for a better salary or job. They are meant to give you a particular set of skills and knowledge from a field of work. Finishing means that you usually get access to a certain community with the same specialty. This is useful if you want to keep up to date with your field or publish new findings.

Software companies that require computer scientists usually are just full of it and they forget that there are other universities that prepare people for software engineering or even just programming. You could argue that a course or bootcamp is enough. But we already know they ask for too much when you look at the requirements they have. They aim for the best and then take what they are given.

I think universities are too easy nowadays to let people in. During my father's time, there were around 10 slots for the arts university in my country each year. All of them ended being praised artists. Actually, national news are made when each one of them pass away.

Now, universities just take everyone, especially if they pay for a slot. This caused a shift into perspective. You are no longer hard-working or lucky to get into a university, you are now expected to get into one to prove you are not a complete moron.

This is the actual problem, and it is reflected in your arguments. I agree, you probably didn't need to go to university. Hell, I know that I didn't need to go through mine. However, we were both expected to, and for no good reason.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by slfnflctd on Saturday December 02, 2017 @08:09AM (#15831718)
> universities are not meant to prepare you for a better salary or job

Regardless of what any individual may think a university is or isn't meant for, this is how they are used.

As a high school dropout, I was directly told by managers in more than one situation that all I needed was a Bachelor's and I would be eligible for better positions. There was zero discussion of skills, as it was already understood that my skill level in many areas was much higher than that of the degreed people I worked with (who also weren't using their educations for anything other than as a "door pass" to be considered for better jobs).

The system is broken.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by bordercases on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:32PM (#15829146)
Where the heck do you work? How long did it take for you to get to that position? What was your role as a junior?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by extra88 on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:31PM (#15828725)
> the reason that all the students go to university is to make money. Like 90%+ of undergrads go there to make money

Which is it, "all" or "90%?" I went to a private liberal arts college so maybe that automatically puts me and my classmates in the 10% but I did not think the overwhelming majority of us were there to make money. The fact that lots of students still major in subjects that can be very worthwhile and valuable but lack obvious paths to financial success (e.g. most of Humanities and a lot of Social Sciences) indicates "making money" is not why they're there.

You think universities should basically be trade schools. They're not and they shouldn't be. Trade schools should be trade schools but the U.S. has a dearth of them and many that fit the description aren't good enough.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by bordercases on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:31PM (#15829133)
I really hope we see greater specialization of mid-line universities that don't know whether they want to be an academic school or a trade school. Programming-as-inquiry is extremely difficult due to the amount of effort and math required to produce novelty, and programming-as-trade is much less difficult in comparison as a lot of the systems you're composing together already have their principles worked out. You can work from the manual in the latter case, while you're defining the manual in the former.

Meanwhile a university not knowing whether it wants to be a trade school or a research school has mixed incentives that results in an inconsistent quality of education. You get professors who don't know how to teach and teachers who don't know how to go in depth. By requiring both you've made your staffing requirements that much harder to fulfill if you don't want to trade off education quality.

On that note how have bootcamps been doing lately?

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by orangecat on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:52PM (#15833050)
The fact that lots of students still major in subjects that can be very worthwhile and valuable but lack obvious paths to financial success (e.g. most of Humanities and a lot of Social Sciences) indicates "making money" is not why they're there.

"Financial success" doesn't necessarily mean optimizing the total number of dollars in your income; it can also mean being able to do work that you enjoy while having a decent standard of living. If a college degree had no impact on your employment opportunities, how many students would still go?

Trade schools should be trade schools but the U.S. has a dearth of them and many that fit the description aren't good enough.

Which is the point. It's not that universities shouldn't exist, it's that they shouldn't be trying to serve both roles.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by patientplatypus on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:07PM (#15830086)
> the reason that all the students go to university is to make money. Like 90%+ of undergrads go there to make money Which is it, "all" or "90%?"

Ok come on man. I said 90%+. Don't quibble just to be a prick.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by dang on Monday December 04, 2017 @04:26PM (#15847660)
If you can't stick to posting civil, substantive comments, we're going to have to ban you. Nitpicking is annoying but it doesn't give license to damage the site in your own right.

Would you mind reading https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html and abiding by the desired spirit when posting here?

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by abvdasker on Saturday December 02, 2017 @01:39AM (#15830595)
The name-calling seems a little uncalled for.

I also went to a good liberal arts college and had a similar experience. People studying subjects that probably wouldn't lead to financially lucrative careers were in the majority.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Al-Khwarizmi on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:34PM (#15828764)
> University costs a shit ton of money and people (the vast majority) pay it so they can have a decent life.

First of all, no one is forced to go to university, so if people pay that much money, it's probably because they feel it's worth it, regardless of its supposed "cloistered academicism".

Secondly, maybe the main problem is that something that is needed (or at least very convenient) to have a decent life shouldn't cost a shit ton of money at all. As is the case in countries like Germany, etc. (if your parent post is from one of those, your reply doesn't even make sense).

Finally, I would rather hire a coder with a strong CS background that one from vocational school. The former may not know the language du jour and the framework fad of the day, but can pick them up easily because they know the fundamentals. The latter will likely adapt much slower.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by tikhonj on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:32PM (#15827723)
To be fair, they do a pretty bad job teaching CS too. Your average undergrad program is almost entirely learning about CS, not learning CS. A non-trivial of students get through a CS degree never doing anything novel in CS—a real shame because, unlike math, research-level CS problems are eminently accessible to undergrads.

It doesn't even have to be "real" research: I just expect more than classes which have you regurgitate what you learned to pass. And yet that's all you need to get a CS degree. It's a bit like learning to write by filling in blanks.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by dsp1234 on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:02PM (#15828035)
Your average undergrad program... CS degree never doing anything novel in CS

Is this different than any other field? I was under the impression that most BS programs do not require novel research. That doesn't come until post graduate courses.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by tikhonj on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:50PM (#15828449)
I don't necessarily mean publishable—that's doable but difficult in CS—but novel in the sense of requiring non-trivial creativity and insight within the field rather than replaying things you were taught directly.

An example might be writing a compiler for a language you design with features not covered in the book. It's probably not publishable, but it is doing CS in a way that just following instructions in a book or from lectures to write a compiler isn't.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by maksimum on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:15PM (#15829034)
So personal projects that extend the material you learn in courses and take 1-2 semesters to complete? I think plenty of schools already do that as part of a BA/BS graduation requirement.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by astura on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:23PM (#15829719)
You just must have had a bad CS program, my undergraduate degree involved plenty of those types of projects.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by edanm on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:11PM (#15828127)
I think it doesn't come until a second degree, or sometimes a graduate degree. Not post graduate.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by umanwizard on Saturday December 02, 2017 @08:31PM (#15835485)
Something was lost in translation here. Graduate degree and postgraduate degree mean the same thing, at least in the US.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Y7ZCQtNo39 on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:31PM (#15828726)
I don't think industry needs every CS graduate to produce something novel. The work of many is just building upon the work of others.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by 0xCMP on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:49PM (#15828866)
"novel = of value" in this case.

Fill in the blank programs ("Here's the skeleton, make it display a list") and 3 projects with < 200 lines that aren't doing something CS specific are not novel, but all too common and wide spread.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Y7ZCQtNo39 on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:21PM (#15832875)
A lot of things of business value go like this, for example: go build this UI in React, etc. You don't need the ability to significantly return something back to academia to do that. You just need good coding mechanics.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by 0xCMP on Saturday December 02, 2017 @05:51PM (#15834676)
Not the point: college is for CS. Not for "building on the work of others." You learn the basics that everyone needs to do the advanced work. If that isn't needed/useful then you need a vocational school instead of a CS program.

Making people do continual simple demos and nonsense programs instead of teaching them actual CS is BS. They can be simple programs, they don't need to build huge things, but what they build should reveal and teach them things beyond how to shift text around the screen.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Y7ZCQtNo39 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @04:46PM (#15839793)
Are there vocational programs beyond those 20-week'ish coding schools? Because those don't seem to equip people with quite enough skill.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by ninkendo on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:55PM (#15827946)
> classes which have you regurgitate what you learned to pass

I think that's what school is, no?

I'm not trying to be glib, I think this is just a reality of how education works in pretty much all subjects (typical US academia, YMMV etc.) Can you name a major that doesn't work this way?

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by aeorgnoieang on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:02PM (#15828029)
I had to write real proofs (tho I didn't fail completely if it wasn't free of errors) for my U.S. math undergrad degree.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by dsp1234 on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:04PM (#15828049)
Did those proofs have to be novel, or were the proofs of already known concepts?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by vecter on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:53PM (#15829837)
I'm sure those proofs at the time were novel to the student but obviously not the professor who assigned the problem. That's how the student learns.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by mcphage on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:39PM (#15829995)
Novel to the student up to a point—math students are taught a variety of proof techniques in each of their subjects, theorems that students are required to prove generally fall to very similar techniques.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by umanwizard on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:21PM (#15830133)
They have to be novel in my experience.

I have a BS in Mathematics from a mediocre school (University of Arizona) and exams were always "prove this fact (which you have never heard of before)", never "what is the proof of XYZ theorem (which we studied)"

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by posterboy on Saturday December 02, 2017 @08:41AM (#15831812)
there is so much room for questions, it's quicker to write the proof than to search an answer. And a readily found answer would, for undergrad, less likely be in proof form, or too distinct for specific topics later on. And the instructor might become suspicious and interogate you, in which case, if the material helped you to understand, that's the point.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by lukego on Saturday December 02, 2017 @06:57AM (#15831528)
Nostalgia: I really love the 60s definition of CS at Stanford, which seems more inclusive of practical aspects than the theoretical bent of today:

"I consider computer science to be the art and science of exploiting automatic digital computers, and of creating the technology necessary to understand their use. It deals with such related problems as the design of better machines using known components, the design and implementation of adequate software systems for communication between man and machine, and the design and analysis of methods of representing information by abstract symbols and of processes for manipulating these symbols. Computer science must also concern itself with such theoretical subjects supporting this technology as information theory, the logic of the finitely constructable, numerical mathematical analysis, and the psychology of problem solving. Naturally, these theoretical subjects are shared by computer science with such disciplines as philosophy, mathematics, and psychology."

http://i.stanford.edu/pub/cstr/reports/cs/tr/65/26/CS-TR-65-...

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Cyberdog on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:35PM (#15827147)
And yet many job listings for programmers demand you have a CS degree…
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by hamstercat on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:55PM (#15827373)
My first boss once told me that when he looks at hiring, having a CS degree means that you know how to find solution to problems. Being able to code can be learned on the job if needed. Most junior jobs in bigcos are usually code monkey type of work anyway.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by throwawayjava on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:43PM (#15827237)
Because for many employers "ability to program" is a minimum requirement, not the full job description.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by alexbecker on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:08PM (#15827507)
For far more employers, "ability to program" is something they have no idea how to filter for in a pile of resumes, but "CS degree" seems like it might be a usable proxy.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by BeetleB on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:18PM (#15827587)
>Because for many employers "ability to program" is a minimum requirement, not the full job description

I think this was the author's point. You state it is a minimum requirement, implying a CS degree is a more challenging requirement. Yet it's not hard to find people with CS degrees who do not have the minimum requirement.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by SadWebDeveloper on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:42PM (#15827221)
That's because CS grads always want to be pair with their own and put heavy work on "planning" how to do things well rather than starting working on it.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by macintux on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:46PM (#15827274)
...yet that's not obvious to everyone, hence the inclusion.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by macintux on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:55PM (#15827371)
Forgot I just had this argument a couple of months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15502022
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by allenz on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:28PM (#15827679)
It's not about that fact. The author argues that programming schools should be vocational schools (while ostensibly presenting a list of objective facts).
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by compiler-guy on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:55PM (#15827954)
The author doesn't seem to be making a normative argument here. Rather he is observing that something many people believe (someone with a CS degree will be a trained programmer) isn't true.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by allenz on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:19PM (#15828210)
I replied to your sibling comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15827977
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jack9 on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:32PM (#15827734)
> The author argues that programming schools should be vocational schools

I dont see where. The implication is that they are assumed to be contrary to reality. It's supposed to be a list of obvious facts.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by allenz on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:57PM (#15827977)
The full tweet, from the link: "CS programs have, in the main, not decided that the primary path to becoming a programmer should involve doing material actual programming. There are some exceptions: Waterloo, for example. This is the point where I joke "That's an exhaustive list" but not sure that a joke."

This reads to me that Patrick wishes that the joke were not true, which is corroborated by other comments of his, such as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7761134#7762383

The fact that you think that the article is in any way objective is why it is so dangerous. Ideology is like water. Patrick's assumptions and biases shape how he presents his "facts" and which facts are left out. It's not objective! What he is really doing is presenting a specific market-based worldview, which has certain insights and major deficiencies.

Consider for example "There is no hidden reserve of smart people". It sounds like an actionable insight, but is it true? Is it even falsifiable? What does it mean? And what actions would it lead you to take?

My answer: it reinforces the perspective that smart people are the only people worth considering, that there are few smart people, and (in context) that these people are mostly "generalists" and entrepreneurs. It values "intelligence", probably measured in terms of short-term ability to make money, and leaves out values and self-reflection. It leaves out the possibility that you can learn from anyone (c.f. the story of the $20 fan[1]). It leaves out the possibility that your hiring process could be discriminatory or unwelcoming. And so on.

This, I argue, is a good demonstration of why programmers need liberal arts; technical decisions are never just technical decisions. We must remember to ask who wins, who loses, is that desirable, is that just?

[1] http://cs.txstate.edu/~br02/cs1428/ShortStoryForEngineers.ht...

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jack9 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @04:26PM (#15839676)
> The author argues that programming schools should be vocational schools

I still don't see this argument being made in ANYTHING you posted now.

> The fact that you think that the article is in any way objective is why it is so dangerous.

How does this relate? I asked for how you came to a conclusion and have gone off into other topics that you're using to characterize a perspective or ideology. I don't care about what you think or what the author thinks. I care about finding how you jumped to a conclusion based on the article's text.

The handwaving to make your own intellectual assertions (right or wrong) have nothing to do with my issue, in the content of what you originally stated. Good luck with whatever.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jasonlfunk on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:34PM (#15827141)
Yes. I often explained that CS was more like a math degree than an engineering degree.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by lordnacho on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:54PM (#15827359)
An engineering degree won't teach you how to do things, either. I have one. Grads aren't able to build bridges, silicon chips, airplanes, or whatever else engineers are supposed to do. (Ok, I built a radio in my first term. But it was a very simple one.) They just have some intellectual tools that are useful precursors to gaining such knowledge.

You can liken CS to something like Chemistry. Is Chemistry about test tubes and HPLC devices? No. Will you learn how test tubes work when you do a chemistry degree? Probably.

It just happens that the practical skill practiced by CS majors is coding. And coding has this unusually large applicability that wet lab work doesn't. Does that mean CS is about coding? No. But you'll probably learn more about coding doing CS than most other things.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by WalterBright on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:52PM (#15827917)
Mechanical engineering, fluid mechanics, electronics, all have a common core of mathematical modeling techniques. An engineering degree is fairly flexible, and one can even pivot into CS. But CS has no commonality with engineering, and a CS degree cannot pivot into engineering.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jghn on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:46PM (#15828838)
It wasn't that many years ago that most colleges didn't offer a true CS degree, but rather a math degree in CS. When I was applying to colleges in the early 90s I remember it being roughly 50/50.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by hugs on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:56PM (#15827379)
Ironically, an engineering degree is also like a math degree.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by auxym on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:49PM (#15827889)
Meh, at least my (mechanical engineering) degree wasn't.

Sure, you learn some mathematical tools that can help you solve some very practical problems, but it stops about there. I was not taught anything close to creative mathematical thinking. I was never taught the fundamentals of things: the axioms and the theorems on which the tools we "learn" are based on. I can guarantee you no one in my graduating class could read a proof of even modest complexity, let alone write one.

Granted, I did go to a school with a good reputation, but one of a very practical/applied program. Still, I'm pretty convinced that math and engineering are very, very different fields, even if all engineering programs include a handful of math classes.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by WalterBright on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:54PM (#15827942)
My engineering classes (Caltech) were nearly all applied math classes.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by umanwizard on Saturday December 02, 2017 @08:28PM (#15835472)
“Applied math” isn’t very similar to what you learn in a reputable math degree, so the point stands.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by umanwizard on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:22PM (#15830136)
No it is not. I studied math and the engineers only went as far as differential equations, basic (non proof based) complex analysis, and so on. There were zero engineers in theoretical classes.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Bromskloss on Saturday December 02, 2017 @01:46AM (#15830615)
> non proof based

What's that about? Does the lecturer just state theorems without proving them, or does it mean that the students aren't required to be able to prove them?

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by closeparen on Saturday December 02, 2017 @11:03PM (#15835897)
It means the activity of the class (lectures, homework, exams) is to compute numeric and algebraic solutions according to the methods and procedures you're taught. The outcome of a class is generally that you're able to solve a new kind of equation.

This describes 99% of the math that most Americans (including engineering students) who are not math majors will ever encounter. Proofs may be presented as curiosities, and students may even be quizzed on them, but students would not be expected to come up with proofs they haven't seen before.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by NTDF9 on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:22PM (#15827623)
Electrical engineering surely is.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by fjsolwmv on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:40PM (#15829787)
An applied math degree
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by guyzero on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:00PM (#15827423)
Having attended Waterloo, this isn't very surprising at all. The CS department is part of the Math Faculty.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by fsloth on Saturday December 02, 2017 @06:32AM (#15831465)
I would claim there is a significant portion of population for whom empirical teaching of CS would be far more kind and efficient than going through the Djisktraist pure theory route. Even Djisktra began with writing actual programs until he grogged how to think about it and then moved to pure theory.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by BeetleB on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:30PM (#15827703)
>Well, that's because CS programs are designed to teach CS, not to be a vocational school for programmers.

And which is why they should be moved out of the College of Engineering and placed into the college that has mathematics. Curiously enough, the only school he mentions where he can reliably know their grads have programming experience actually does place CS under mathematics.

I think being able to program basic tasks should be a requirement for all engineering programs. They all require a course in CS - mostly not because they want ME's to know CS, but they want them to be able to program basic things.

Yet, many/most engineering grads are really poor at it. I feel for any given engineering degree program, we should make all seniors who have declared they will graduate that semester to take a basic exam on very basic concepts that all grads of that program should know (strong emphasis on the word "basic"). If it's acceptable for them not to know basic material in an introductory class, then remove the class from the curriculum!

Example: I was in a top 5 school helping an grad student in CS do basic probability homework. We were disagreeing on the correct answer, so I suggested he write a simple program to simulate it and compare with his calculated answer.

This is the simplest program possible: A for loop, and a random number generator.

He had no idea how to do it.

I'm not picking on him because he's a CS student. I think it's a valid question for people in all engineering programs that involve introductory programming courses. What's the point of making such a course a mandatory requirement if they can literally do nothing based on that knowledge?

Similarly, an electrical engineer who does not know, say, Kirchoff's laws should not be allowed to graduate.

Yes, I do think universities are for education, but if they cannot apply what they learned, they are not educated.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by khedoros1 on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:48PM (#15827876)
I went to a polytechnic university (i.e. one with a "learn by doing" focus). Our engineering students definitely had to have some programming classes, but they were taught separately from the CS ones. Most engineering students considered them an annoying roadblock in the way of getting back to their "real" work, and I (a CS student) spent a fair amount of time tutoring friends. I'll have to ask some of them if they use any form of programming now, in their day jobs. I suspect I'd get a mix of answers.

As for the CS students, lectures were often on the theory, and homework was usually focused on implementing demonstrations of the theory. A grad student who wasn't a decent programmer was either a cheater in undergrad, or didn't come from our school.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by BeetleB on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:57PM (#15827980)
>A grad student who wasn't a decent programmer was either a cheater in undergrad, or didn't come from our school.

This particular student came from a different engineering background. Yet, he still got admitted into a top 5 CS program.

And whether he did CS or not in his undergrad is beside the point. I think this is a task any engineering grad should be able to do. If not, the university should not be listing programming as a core skill they teach their engineering students.

BTW, he is not unique. I don't think many (perhaps 20-30%) of my fellow grads (non-CS engineers) could code something that simple either when they were graduating.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by posterboy on Saturday December 02, 2017 @09:13AM (#15831901)
you are being very critical, a part of university education is tolerance, although some opinions differ on if that relates to knowing literally everything. Trade-offs are a part of engineering because optimal solutions don't always exist. I'm saying, programming often is just knowing which functions to pick, which is not an inert skill except for reading comprehension, if there is a good documentation. There's nothing universal to learn there, the interesting bit is writing those functions. But a pseudo random number generator is rather advanced stuff.

I hope you helped out as good as you could to bridge the gap and maybe you were rightfully disappointed if the student hadn't prepared to catch up to undergrad material in spare time.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by BeetleB on Saturday December 02, 2017 @01:55PM (#15833340)
>I'm saying, programming often is just knowing which functions to pick, which is not an inert skill except for reading comprehension, if there is a good documentation. There's nothing universal to learn there, the interesting bit is writing those functions. But a pseudo random number generator is rather advanced stuff.

First of all, I'm not asking them to know "advanced" random number generation theory. As a kid, using random number generators in BASIC was one of the first things we did when we learned programming - it makes writing programs a lot more fun. Granted, it's not usually covered in introductory programming courses. But all that is needed is one API call. I pretty much told him what he needed to do. I showed him the API he needs to generate random numbers. We talked in big picture terms about the algorithm (set up the experiment, run 10000 times, take the ratio of success over number of runs). We talked about the theory on why such an experiment would answer his question. I helped in every way other than the actual coding. Had he written some code, I would have helped debug (some probability experiments are tricky to code correctly - that is acceptable).

He just couldn't translate the problem to code.

>You are being very critical, a part of university education is tolerance, although some opinions differ on if that relates to knowing literally everything. Trade-offs are a part of engineering because optimal solutions don't always exist.

I definitely am being critical. When you graduate, you get a seal from your institution that is supposed to be a guarantee of something. My question is: What is that something? If you start dealing with math graduates from a university and you find they often cannot do basic algebra, you stop valuing the seal the university provides - which damages all math graduates of the university. They are working very hard to get a certificate that is not valued by others.

Would you trust a physics graduate who cannot do basic calculus? You can argue that he may know all the theories (conservation of energy, electromagnetics, etc), and understands the principles behind calculus (area of curves, rates of change, etc). But if they struggle with basic evaluation of integrals, you probably will wonder about what kinds of courses they taught in his university that allowed him to get a degree without actually solving problems with calculus.

This is the problem the author is talking about. If you consistently interview people with computer science degrees, who cannot do a simple fizzbuzz, you stop valuing the degree - and that is the general landscape in the software world. Those who worked hard to gain a lot of knowledge relevant to both theory and practice are right to be upset that because of lax (or at least misguided) standards from their educational institution, they have to go through more hoops to convince people of their skills.

It goes beyond the simple mantra of "Universities teach computer science, not software." I would question the technical ability of anyone who cannot write such a simple program, with as much guidance as I provided - be they a CS major or a math major. I'm not asking for practical knowledge like whether unit testing is useful, or how to architect large software, or the virtues of OO over FP. Just a basic program. Can you write it?

Certainly there is not universal agreement on the curriculum. I'm saying there should be agreement on some basics. Historically, universities handle this by ensuring some introductory course is in the curriculum. My argument is that in the US the education system is a little too modularized, and there should be more coupling. If programming is seen to be a core skill that engineers should know, make writing code an aspect of every engineering course (it's really easy to construct assignments/projects in pretty much any engineering course that could involve writing code).

Don't let someone get an A in the introductory course in his freshman year, and then allow him to forget pretty much everything he learned from it by the time he graduates. If you do, you wasted the student's time, the instructor's time, and the time of all the interviewers who cannot trust your degree and have to check for themselves if this person knows the basics.

Again, it all boils down to: The university is giving you a degree. Is this degree a guarantee of anything? If so, what? I'm all for education for the sake of gaining knowledge. But how many of us would be OK with gaining the knowledge without any kind of certification from the university? Not many, I suspect. I actually did this personally (dropped out of PhD after many years as I felt I gained the knowledge but did not feel a degree would help me), and can assure you from the conversations I had with others who tried to convince me otherwise that pretty much almost everyone wants that paper to have some value.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by ken47 on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:56PM (#15827975)
There is a well known delineation between applied math and pure math. It seems that such a convention has yet to be established for CS.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by nitwit005 on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:45PM (#15828408)
Not sure that's an accurate comparison. We make the English majors do a ton of writing, the art majors produce a lot of art, and no one seems to have any issue assigning a lists of problems to math majors as homework.

I suspect there is just a cultural issue, where the CS faculty doesn't want to do that style of teaching. I had a professor hand out debugging assignments because that was part of the industry feedback they'd gotten, but only the one professor listened to the feedback.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by ynniv on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:59PM (#15828005)
Sometimes* the best way to learn things is to do them, a lot.

- Graduate of the North Avenue Trade School

(* Most times)

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by JepZ on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:29PM (#15828295)
I think there is a thin line here. For example I was taught I to programm Smalltalk. On the one hand that is not a commonly used programming language and on the other hand it teaches Object Oriented Programming like no other language.

So yes, after that you can't start as a Senior Java Developer but I think you have a very good foundation to quickly pick up other Object Oriented languages.

So you do not have to teach the latest hyped language to give students the ability to programm. Instead you can use clean languages to teach CS and let your students excercise them to show you that they understood what you taught them.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by matt_morgan on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:47PM (#15828848)
Reminder that patio11 might be saying all these things without trying to imply value. I.e., he's not necessarily saying any of these things are good and bad; the "obvious" part is just that they are true.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by closeparen on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:59PM (#15828922)
My CS education turned out to be “coding in a few fundamental domains” and I was very happy with it. We implemented some fundamental algorithms and components across operating systems, networks, distributed consensus, compilers/interpreters, visualization, sensing and perception, databases, machine learning, etc.

You were free to construct a degree out of proofs rather than source code if you wanted, but those of us who desired a more practical education could fill our days with systems programming.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Clubber on Saturday December 02, 2017 @01:56AM (#15830649)
What's the point of learning CS if you can't write a complete program? What the hell else are you going to do with it? Try to think of yet another way to write a sort algorithm?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by wvenable on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:48PM (#15828429)
Don't worry most CS programs aren't designed to teach CS either. They teach a random assortment of technical material that is neither terribly difficult nor terribly relevant.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by ptr_void on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:44PM (#15828404)
Yet not having a CS degree makes getting a programming job 10x more difficult.