News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by drewrv on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:47PM (#15827293)
I've been spending a lot of time lately wondering if people who treat colleges and universities as though their job is worker training are confused, or if I'm naive in believing colleges and universities exist to expand human knowledge through research and education.

I suspect the answer is that our culture is confused, we want people who are smart and well rounded to also be useful. And the ugly side of it is, we want clear class divisions. One would never refer to law school or medical school as "vocational".

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by codingdave on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:04PM (#15827465)
> One would never refer to law school or medical school as "vocational".

Sure you would. They are 100% vocational schools. Their cost, acceptance rates, time commitment, and difficulty level may be higher than other vocational schools, but that doesn't change what they are -- 100% focused on giving you the knowledge and skills to do a specific job.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by kod on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:07PM (#15829642)
Law schools (or at least the top 20 school that I went to) are definitely not 100% focused on teaching you the vocation of being an attorney.

Hell, they aren't even focused on teaching you to pass the bar, which is why most people pay for separate cram schools.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by acoard on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:02PM (#15846469)
Yet, going to law school is a pre-requisite for becoming the vocation of a lawyer.

Arguably, "a school one must go to in order to practice a vocation" can be referred to as a "vocational school." I understand that vocational schools are often thought to be purely practical and not theoretical, but I think this definition does a disservice to the reality of entering certain vocations.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by kod on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:57PM (#15854568)
No, it is not a pre-requisite. At least in the U.S., several states still allow you to pass the bar and become a licensed attorney without going to law school.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by icebraining on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:35PM (#15827754)
That's the point - they are, but are not referred as such.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by cvwright on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:09PM (#15828994)
They are in fact called "professional schools" -- this captures what both of you are saying.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by hammock on Saturday December 02, 2017 @11:46AM (#15832692)
They are actually called "professional" schools, but yeah it's a euphemism that means the same thing.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Danihan on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:32PM (#15827722)
Well then where are all the "vocational" CS programs at universities?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by AYBABTME on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:55PM (#15827949)
Canada has ‘software engineering’ degrees which are essentially vocational CS degrees.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by kat on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:05PM (#15828964)
To add to this, Canadian Universities also have co-op programs.

You don't have to have an engineering degree to get a co-op job. The student gets paid well over minimum wage (and learns on the job) and the employers get financial incentives from the gov't to hire students. Its win-win for both the student and the employer.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by dharness on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:48AM (#15830417)
Software Engineering at Canadian universities does not contain a dramatically different level of vocational training (with the exception of Waterloo).

Co-op programs are optional, and take place in the summer or in a gap year. The affiliation of companies hosting co-ops is loose, and the schools charge large fees for participating in these programs (with the exception of Waterloo).

Speaking from personal experience, results may vary.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jholman on Saturday December 02, 2017 @05:42AM (#15831332)
Which Canadian schools have software engineering degrees which are vocational?

Note that my degree is from a well-reputed Canadian school that has a "software engineering specialization", and as far as I can tell (though I did not take it) that specialization is indistinguishable from the main CS curriculum, and is not valid vocational training.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by rhizome on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:55PM (#15827959)
Medical and Law schools are postgraduate.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by maccard on Saturday December 02, 2017 @11:46AM (#15832696)
In some places. In Ireland, law is a normal undergraduate degree with some extra vocational training after you graduate. Medicine is an undergraduate (5 year) programme, during which quite a lot is vocational - students spend multiple months in hospitals during that period, and when they graduate they are still considered as training.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by kingkawn on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:40PM (#15827794)
Coding Boot camps
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by AnimalMuppet on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:41PM (#15827811)
... which are not at universities.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by inopinatus on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:53PM (#15827924)
And will also not prepare you for a job in computer science.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by enraged_camel on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:06PM (#15828566)
They might prepare you for an intro-level job in software development though, if you actually continue learning things and honing your skills after completing them.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by djellybeans on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:30PM (#15829131)
For what it's worth, these bootcamps are the current "trade schools" for software jobs where the barrier to entry is lower. They're accelerated programs that use job placement as a strong selling point.

It's almost like they rose from the death of many for-profit technical schools (DeVry, WestWood et al.) and took their ecological niche. But in contrast to bootcamps, these for-profit schools were too big, slow, and ineffective.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by sharemywin on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:54PM (#15827943)
in the business college.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:06PM (#15827482)
Higher education is used as a proxy for intelligence by companies who are hiring because they are not allowed to use IQ tests. So I think it kind of makes sense that our society is confused about the purpose of higher education.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by valuearb on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:48PM (#15827873)
It's not just an IQ test, it's a test of ability, which is different. Your college record shows that you

a) Whether you were able to get the work done. b) Whether you were smart enough to do the work well.

It's the combination that's important, not either single one. Employers want people who show up on time, actually care enough to try, and are smart enough to figure it out.

The college degree has a better than zero correlation to that. After you get the job it's mainly about performance and output, once you've been promoted a few times your college degree mostly doesn't matter.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:18PM (#15829057)
I agree with all of that, though spending 4 years to make that determination seems crazy to me. A competent employer can figure out which hires are worthwhile in about a month or so.

There’s another issue with using educational attainment as a proxy of intelligence: it doesn’t really help you distinguish among candidates who all have a bachelors degree. All you know is that they’re above some threshold, but not how far above. You can use the prestige of the school as a proxy for this, but it all seems like a hell of a lot of hassle when you can figure this all out in a half hour with an IQ test.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by fjsolwmv on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:46PM (#15829812)
IQ test tell you how good someone is at pattern recognition, which is a major factor in abilo to learn. It doesn't tell you what they have learned, or if they have the criticality important skill of perseverance/grit. In fact, high IQ can reduce grit, since clever pattern matchers use their cleverness to avoid working hard on the toy problems of childhood.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by johnnyhillbilly on Sunday December 03, 2017 @07:05AM (#15837237)
My personal take on this is that high IQ quickly turns into a liability in childhood. Particularly when entering the school system.

I believe the words "bored to tears" summarize the experience quite well.

While the majority of pupils get a standardized curriculum designed to keep their interest at a steady pace, pupils with a high learning capacity get no such thing. If they try to learn faster, it doesn't fit with the governance and management model within which the teacher must operate. Therefore, most teachers are at a loss when faced with these statistical outliers.

Also, other pupils may experience emotions of inadequacy and unfairness when a fellow pupil just blasts through the material in minutes that would take them all week. This may lead to the high capacity pupil being a target of some unfortunate group dynamics.

Since schools have no governance model for this, the high learning capacity pupil's school experience is essentially unmanaged. At a loss, society almost invariably resorts to platitudes like "No need to feel sorry for them, because they are so fortunate to be smart. We must focus on the pupils that struggle."

A few years down the line, the pupil's inner motivation may be completely replaced by depression, self-blaming or worse. Then the platitudes take a turn for the worse with blaming the pupil's willingness to work: "In fact, high IQ can reduce grit, since clever pattern matchers use their cleverness to avoid working hard on the toy problems of childhood."

Fortunately, my own school days are long since gone. Without blaming any person in the system, I can say: "Good riddance!" to this whole pitiful affair of how society treated me as a child.

Instead, I can draw attention to this problem by saying clearly that these are children that never asked for these gifts in the first place. Let's as a society realize that what we are doing to them is absolutely wrong and woefully irresponsible.

Fortunately, at least one western country has political attention on this right now. I will work hard and with "grit" to make sure that my experience and observations can help in creating new policies. In particular I wish to address how to practically leverage the pupils' own drive to learn without incurring social/peer stigma or ridiculous costs.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Sunday December 03, 2017 @01:01PM (#15838626)
This is a huge problem.

We are perfectly happy to identify athletic talent and enact systems so that the athletically talented are matched up with peers who share their gifts, but we mostly refuse to do this for intellectual talent.

I was fortunate enough to attend a program that handled this pretty well. Basically it was 120 kids from 11-18 who skipped high school and attended university together instead. It’s called the Early Entrance Program and it’s at Cal State Los Angeles:

http://www.calstatela.edu/academic/eep

The issue I face is that I am raising my children in Portland, Oregon, so this program will not be an option for them. Our personal approach is to home school instead. And I’ll probably investigate starting something like the Early Entrance Program at the state university in Portland here.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by rogerbinns on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:59PM (#15827997)
It also shows that you could do that for several years, following the rules set by someone else, and passing.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by bittercynic on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:41PM (#15828385)
Nice double meaning with 'passing' also meaning something like: "able to appear to be what those in power want me to be."
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by mwfunk on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:24PM (#15828688)
I would not interpret it that way at all. Being able to understand requirements and implement stuff based on those requirements, or work as part of a team, or maintain dedication to a task for weeks or months at a time, has nothing to do with teenage notions of the world being populated by conformists vs. nonconformists (which ironically is usually based on very conformist notions of what it means to be a nonconformist).

On the other hand, I have known a number of people who used their self-identification as a nonconformist as an excuse for why they couldn't cut it someplace, whether it's school or a job or some interpersonal situation. It's a bad excuse because it gives the person an easy out for not reflecting on how they could have handled the situation better, or avoided getting into the situation in the first place. It also pushes all of the blame on other people, which is comforting but very rarely 100% true. We should all be our own worst critics, lest someone else beats us to it.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by cloverich on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:23PM (#15832894)
For better or worse, it _is_ a proxy for many things. But one that i think is most relevant to a typical job is the ability to see something that is sometimes fun, sometimes boring, and sometimes challenging through to the end. Typically staying put in one place while doing so. Its not intended to be vocational training, but in a sense it matches very well with what's expect of the typical employee: Show up consistently, deal with stress and various people and tasks with an ability to see it all through, without quitting or pissing too many people off. If you can cope well and make it through undergrad, you can likely handle a vast array of jobs.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jogjayr on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:46PM (#15827854)
> because they are not allowed to use IQ tests

There's actual employment law that prohibits using IQ tests? I'd never heard that before

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Phlarp on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:58PM (#15828513)
An IQ test can be used during the hiring process but the employer has to be able to defend its use as directly relevant to the work at hand. So most employers aren't willing to spend the legal fees related to defending the use of a direct IQ test... Possibly because the college degree is a good enough litmus test for IQ to satisfy their needs.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by vilmosi on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:13PM (#15829027)
If it's difficult to prove that IQ is relevant to the job... Maybe it's not. Also, I doubt that's the reason.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:31PM (#15829135)
It’s not difficult to demonstrate that IQ is relevant to job performance (its the best predictor of performance for most jobs). The problem is to demonstrate that it doesn’t have a discriminatory effect (there are large, persistent differences in IQ between races).
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by vilmosi on Sunday December 03, 2017 @07:14PM (#15840485)
There's already an imbalance when it comes to different genders and races, I don't get what they would lose.

The real reason companies don't do it is because Fizz Buzz is a better test than IQ tests.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Wh1zz on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:48AM (#15830418)
Source on that first claim?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by rvern on Saturday December 02, 2017 @08:34AM (#15831792)
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by ramses0 on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:28PM (#15828281)
It's related to anti-discrimination / "psychology-test" laws. If there is any sort of "test" given as a condition of employment, it must be relevant, standardized, non-biased, reviewed by specialists and approved, etc.

http://cdn8.openculture.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/Test1...

The value and definition of "IQ" is widely disputed and generally seen as of limited relevance to the actual work and performance of that work (uncorrelated). Look it up and do some research if you're interested, this is just a quick showing of _why_ tests may be considered bad.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by majormajor on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:54PM (#15828481)
One day I wonder if some lawyer will strike it big by making an argument that looking at universities is discrimination because e.g. family connections and wealth give you a big leg up in getting into certain elite schools...
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:22PM (#15829073)
Yeah, but most universities engage in affirmative action, which theoretically negates this.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jogjayr on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:57PM (#15828505)
The linked image you shared is one I've seen before that was a Louisiana state voter literacy test used for voter suppression. It was disproportionately administered to black voters[1]

I'm not saying that IQ tests are useful measures of ability to do a job. I just wasn't aware there was actual law or precedent forbidding their use.

> If there is any sort of "test" given as a condition of employment, it must be relevant, standardized, non-biased, reviewed by specialists and approved, etc.

Wouldn't this disqualify a lot of whiteboard interviews too? Most startups don't have a standard question bank reviewed by experts or grade on a standard rubric.

1. http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_vault/2013/06/28/voting_right...

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:20PM (#15829069)
Whiteboard tests are directly relevant to the position being hired for and, thus, okay to use.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by sgustard on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:51PM (#15829270)
The classic "how many gas stations are there in the USA?" type of interview question seem exactly like an IQ test and not at all relevant to job requirements.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by benji-york on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:22PM (#15828237)
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by pavlov on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:34PM (#15827745)
If IQ tests were a reliable measure of any job capability, surely the brilliant minds at Mensa would already have made a mint by selling recruitment services.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:49PM (#15829260)
See this commment elsewhere in the thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15828513
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by chefandy on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:47PM (#15827865)
Well, part of the problem is that mensa is a total crock of shit.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by pessimizer on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:21PM (#15828225)
Whatever it is, it's a group filled with people who score very high on iq tests.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by git_rancher on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:29PM (#15828290)
You may not know this but a primary purpose of Mensa is to help "smart" people find other "smart" people to socialize with. In that sense it succeeds (I'm a member).
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by astura on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:47PM (#15829580)
Define "crock of shit?" It's just an organization with membership requirements, by that logic organizations such as the VFW are a "crock of shit."
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Danihan on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:32PM (#15827732)
For fuck's sake, cut out the middle man and just request SAT / ACT scores.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by auxym on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:43PM (#15827825)
I'm canadian so have never taken these tests, but I was under the impression that a large component of scoring well on them is cramming?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by losvedir on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:04PM (#15828057)
Not really. I think of the SAT as a great equalizer since a brilliant kid in rural Nebraska will do well and be able to go to an elite college, while a silver spoon heir will spend thousands and maybe improve their score but certainly not max it out.

Not to toot my own horn but I got a perfect score on the math part of the SAT with little prep, and I've tutored others on the same and only managed to eke out a little improvement. (In contrast, I've tutored math course work and had more success there.)

The math isn't very advanced, it's just a matter of doing it quickly and accurately.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 02, 2017 @09:21AM (#15831923)
> I think of the SAT as a great equalizer

The truth is more nuanced [1].

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/03/05/these...

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by thaumasiotes on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:11PM (#15829408)
From a psychometric perspective, they are IQ tests, in that they show the same correlation with IQ tests that IQ tests show with each other.

From a research-into-today's-hot-button-issues perspective, they are routinely slammed for being about cramming, but the effect of test preparation on test scores tends to be very close to zero when you look into it.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by akgerber on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:34PM (#15828332)
I did very well on both tests in high school without much cramming (I skimmed one study book from the library), and scored something like 90th percentile when I took the ACT in middle school.

Whether this is correlated to anything important in real life is an entirely separate question.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by trentmb on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:36PM (#15828346)
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by jx2zhou on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:53PM (#15827929)
You're correct.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by Joof on Saturday December 02, 2017 @03:55AM (#15831025)
I did well, but I also took it with a severe migraine. Can I take it again now?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by danjoc on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:20PM (#15828219)
>Higher education is used as a proxy for intelligence by companies who are hiring because they are not allowed to use IQ tests.

I think you're wrong about that,

http://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/sto...

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:39PM (#15829195)
Your link is to a story about an employer who uses a test which is a proxy for intelligence (they even give the rough equivalency between the test they use and IQ). I think that supports my point that intelligence is one of the more important things employers are looking for. Most employers don’t have the resources to develop a hiring screening test and then certify that it is not discriminatory, so they use educational attainment instead.

Another way to approach this is to ask yourself: if not as a proxy for intelligence, then why do some jobs require a college degree?

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by danjoc on Sunday December 03, 2017 @01:42PM (#15838809)
Still wrong.

https://www.hiresuccess.com/blog/is-employment-testing-legal

>I think that supports my point

I didn't say it invalidated your point. I'm trying to draw your attention to a specific area in your statement that is wrong. You can simply say,

>Higher education is used as a proxy for intelligence by companies

That's enough. Nobody will argue with you about that.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by astura on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:37PM (#15829531)
IQ tests used for hiring do exist in the US - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wonderlic_test
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by fjsolwmv on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:55PM (#15829855)
Yes, and that exact test was the one that is legally fraught: https://www.wonderlic.com/resources/publications/white-paper...
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by crdoconnor on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:20PM (#15828670)
Higher education seems like more of a "class marker" to me.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:47PM (#15829252)
Or maybe the causal factor for both class and higher education is intelligence. The Bell Curve makes a compelling case that the transition away from agriculture toward knowledge work over the last 100 years has created a society in which intelligence is funneled into higher education and from there into high paying professions.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by fjsolwmv on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:04PM (#15829895)
The Bell Curve is a famous case of quasi-science. You are putting statistical speculation up against centuries of well-documented explicit discrimination policies.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:09PM (#15830094)
Have you read The Bell Curve?

You may disagree with some of its conclusions (I personally am skeptical of its conclusions about racial differences in IQ), but to call it pseudo science is, I think, unfair. FWIW, Steven Pinker, who is about as thoughtful and level headed as they come, agrees:

https://mobile.twitter.com/sapinker/status/84691284703672320...

And, anyway, the point I was making had nothing to do with racial IQ differences. It was referring to what the rest of The Bell Curve is about (discussion of racial IQ differences makes up only about 25% of the book): how the US society’s transition away from most people working in agriculture toward most people working at desks has created a class structure stratified by intelligence.

It’s actually a shame that the book discusses racial IQ differences at all, because everyone got hung up on that and totally missed what is, IMO, a much more important point. And I think it explains a lot about current politics in the US.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by holbrad on Saturday December 02, 2017 @02:31PM (#15833554)
You seem to be rather confused about the Bell Curve.

It's my understanding that the main data presented hasn't been overturned or disproved (In-fact quite the opposite)

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by vilmosi on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:03PM (#15828041)
Meh, IQ is potential, not capability, to do a job. I don't find this argument convincing. What about all the literal geniuses who have no interest and never studied CS?

At least the graduate can show that he/she can commit to a multi-year long, sometimes boring, project successfully. A high IQ person could just leave your company after 6 months because "they're bored".

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by toasterlovin on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:16PM (#15829440)
I’m not saying employers would hire solely based on IQ. That would be crazy. It’s just a screening measure. But so is educational attainment. Nobody gets hired because they have a college degree, but plenty of people don’t get hired because they lack a college degree.

Also, agree that educational attainment gives you more information about a candidate, but in terms of assessing intelligence, it is a coarser measure than IQ. I’ve hired a few people in my day, and there is huge divergence in intelligence among college grads. For lots of jobs it is useful to be able to distinguish between not-stupid, bright, and ridiculously smart. Educational attainment doesn’t really help with that, but IQ tests would.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by mrkurt on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:01PM (#15827427)
People aren't confused. Colleges do many things.

They're also very expensive to attend, and the most immediate value they offer is to get people jobs

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by rch on Friday December 01, 2017 @03:55PM (#15827374)
I've heard doctors speak of themselves as having a trade skill... albeit one that pays well.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by yesenadam on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:05PM (#15829374)
Fascinating point. Is "training vs education" a useful pair of terms? Universities used to be for education, now often its assumed they are for training only. (Bachelor of Science in Hotel Management I come across nowadays - in what?!)

I often hear people talk as if education was something that happened to them, then it finished. (Like learning is something you just do in an institution.) I guess training is more like that, teaching knowledge and skills for some particular task/role/job.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by fjsolwmv on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:06PM (#15829903)
How is learning how to run a hotel not an education? Are all the Agriculture and Mechanical universities not education?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by yesenadam on Saturday December 02, 2017 @02:58PM (#15833706)
Well, that's the point - those things, training to do a particular job, are now thought of as 'education'.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by dvdhnt on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:05PM (#15827469)
> And the ugly side of it is, we want clear class divisions.

What? I suspect that it's typically, if not exclusively, those in the upper classes that want this. The ugly side of it is human nature is selfish.

Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by aeorgnoieang on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:00PM (#15828013)
Actually, I suspect that it's the middle class (or middle classes for cultures with more than three classes) that are most anxious about being mistaken as lower class. Actual upper class members don't usually care – they're not relying on university attendance to protect their positions.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already by santoshalper on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:32PM (#15827730)
I definitely would refer to law and medical schools as vocational, much more so than many other educational programs.

I have known several people who went to medical or law school and every single one them went only because it is a per-requisite to becoming a doctor or lawyer. What is your explanation, that people attend these schools to expand their mind, and then entirely coincidentally, manage to end up in the corresponding career as though by accident?

Get real.