Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already
by aeorgnoieang on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:02PM
(#15828029)
I had to write real proofs (tho I didn't fail completely if it wasn't free of errors) for my U.S. math undergrad degree.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already
by dsp1234 on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:04PM
(#15828049)
Did those proofs have to be novel, or were the proofs of already known concepts?
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already
by vecter on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:53PM
(#15829837)
I'm sure those proofs at the time were novel to the student but obviously not the professor who assigned the problem. That's how the student learns.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already
by mcphage on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:39PM
(#15829995)
Novel to the student up to a point—math students are taught a variety of proof techniques in each of their subjects, theorems that students are required to prove generally fall to very similar techniques.
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already
by umanwizard on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:21PM
(#15830133)
They have to be novel in my experience.
I have a BS in Mathematics from a mediocre school (University of Arizona) and exams were always "prove this fact (which you have never heard of before)", never "what is the proof of XYZ theorem (which we studied)"
Re:Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already
by posterboy on Saturday December 02, 2017 @08:41AM
(#15831812)
there is so much room for questions, it's quicker to write the proof than to search an answer. And a readily found answer would, for undergrad, less likely be in proof form, or too distinct for specific topics later on. And the instructor might become suspicious and interogate you, in which case, if the material helped you to understand, that's the point.
I think that's what school is, no?
I'm not trying to be glib, I think this is just a reality of how education works in pretty much all subjects (typical US academia, YMMV etc.) Can you name a major that doesn't work this way?