Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by leobelle on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:03AM
(#7333093)
So where are all the tablet apps, because there are like zero tablet apps.
I am on my third Android tablet (a Kindle Fire HDX). My first Android tablet was the first Samsung 7" tablet that came out with Gingerbread on it, back in like 2010. I got a free iPad from my job a few years ago and gave that to my daughter and have upgraded her iPad since. She has a ton of children apps for her, that she has grown up with, and learned from. There are near no apps for my Android tablet this many years in. Personally I never want an iOS device, I just don't like the operating system, but I would really like at least some apps for Android. These marketshare numbers don't seem to have helped at all.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by higherpurpose on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:14AM
(#7333501)
I still blame Google for that. They made an absolutely terrible strategic error early on by saying developers don't need to make tablet apps" - because phone apps can just "scale up". At the time they were using the same flawed Microsoft philosophy of "one app everywhere".
That put off developers from making tablet apps, for a long, long time. And because of that it also had the side effect of affecting Android tablet sales, which in turn gave Android developers even fewer reasons to make tablet apps for Android.
I mean, can you believe it that only late last year Google decided to show users "tablet apps" by default when using a tablet? They finally did something to encourage developers to optimize their apps for tablets.
But I don't think it's enough. Normally, I don't think Google should've done this, but they are so late in the tablet app game now, that I think they should start forcing developers to optimize their apps for tablets, too, or have their apps kicked out of the store within a year.
I think it's a very reasonable time-frame, and it's not like they have to rewrite their apps from scratch to do it. If they did that, I think within 6 months we'd see Android tablet apps for everything.
Something else that I'd like them to do: kick out apps from the "Featured" or "Editor's Choice" that don't adhere to the Android style guidelines. You'd think that Google would want at least the hand-picked apps to be "made for Android", no? Do that, and watch how the top popular apps scramble to adhere to Google's standards.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by myko on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:52AM
(#7334369)
> because phone apps can just "scale up"
This wasn't the reason, though. The reason is and was because on Android it is really quite easy to adapt to multiple screen sizes, and show different views based on screen size.
> Something else that I'd like them to do: kick out apps from the "Featured" or "Editor's Choice" that don't adhere to the Android style guidelines.
Totally agree. Google hasn't done enough to strongly encourage companies to make quality apps. Though these days when I see an application I consider to be poor in quality on Android I tend to find a similarly poor in quality app on iOS from the same company.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by bane on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:48AM
(#7333952)
Because in general, you don't write tablet vs. phone apps for Android. Google is finding a better way that's not consumer unfriendly with adaptable layout engines that operate differently on a tablet vs. on a phone.
Specific distributions for various sized screens is an artifact of iOS, not a design idiom on Android.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by bananas on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:22AM
(#7333152)
There are millions of shit apps for reference...
However there's this big one that comes with them all called a browser. It does all sorts.
The only apps that have an advantage over this app are the ones that have at least partially disconnected model i.e email, offline navigation, authoring or creative stuff and to a degree games.
Then again I'd rather have a real keyboard to write emails, a smaller device for my offline navigation and a bigger screen for authoring and creative stuff.
So basically, it's a browsing, email and games machine. And a crap one at that.
For reference I own a laptop and a smartphone. The mid ground seems pointless to me. Tablets are relegated to children's entertainment and they'd rather use the Xbox for that to be fair as Minecraft is better with real controls and it doesn't spam the hell out of you by trying to install apps via adtrack.king.com every two minutes.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by nicholassmith on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:10AM
(#7333484)
"So basically, it's a browsing, email and games machine. And a crap one at that."
For you. Important distinction, just because you specifically haven't found a use doesn't mean others haven't. I know people who code on them, or do some spreadsheet twiddling, or (yes, slowly) write documents on them. For them a tablet is the right amount of compromises.
A 30 second search on YouTube reveals a plethora of digital artists, another might reveal a similar amount of digital musicians. Your use case isn't their use case.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by w1ntermute on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:54AM
(#7333981)
Maybe you use your tablet differently, but all I really need is:
* Web (Chrome)
* Email (Gmail)
* Movies/TV shows (YouTube & Netflix)
* Reading (Kindle & Pocket)
* Music (Spotify & YouTube)
Edit: I forgot about Mango[0], a manga reader. This is one I have to sideload, since Mango essentially provides a native frontend to websites that host fan translations (Japanese to English) of copyrighted content. I can imagine that such an app can't be obtained on iOS without jailbreaking.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by akumen on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:48AM
(#7333390)
Because they are cheaper and there more OEMs pushing them out. However, Android tablet ecosystem sucks. Simple as that.
I've had two Android tablets (Asus Transofrmer TF101 and then a Nexus 7) ... Nexus admittedly a much better experience but I use my iPad mini so much more than both of those tablets put together. Higher quality apps and better accessory/device ecosystem provide for a superior overall experience.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by aroch on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:29AM
(#7333846)
I don't know, I had a first gen Nexus 7 and the experiences was pretty disappointing. Google cheaped out on the NAND and using more than 40% of the storage would cause it to stall, lag and generally behave like a pile of poop. It's somewhat mitigated by TRIM in Kitkat but not totally. On top of that, I had to RMA my N7 3 times to get one that was physically functional to begin with.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by ce4 on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:03AM
(#7334028)
That's been fixed [1] by enabling TRIM for the eMMC as of Android 4.3 already. I wouldn't call the Kingston eMMC chips cheap, most of the time it's a buggy FTL (flash translation layer) that causes problems. Other manufacturers had more serious bugs that even caused data loss for the user (e.g. Samsung Galaxy S2 i9100/i777, Note n7000, etc. Cf. [2]).
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by aroch on Monday March 03, 2014 @11:25AM
(#7334596)
Yeah, I know...I even mentioned that TRIM fixes it. Still doesn't mean it wasn't a shitty experience for the many months before proper TRIM support landed
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by brador on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:49AM
(#7333226)
Money. Many Android tablets are full of pirate apps (you just need an APK file). Plus, IOS users are, on average, more willing to pay. It's why some apps are $0.99 on IOS and free with ads on Android.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by GFischer on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:53AM
(#7333237)
Here in Uruguay, I don't see people pirating much. I do see a lot of free apps on Android though :) , and nobody is able to pay for an app... mostly because Apple doesn't understand or care that nobody has an international credit card.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by leobelle on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:36AM
(#7333588)
I run the Amazon App Store and Humble Bundle on my Galaxy S4, both of which are APK files I side installed and I have many apps from both installed. I don't think I'm a minority in that regard, since these are businesses. As such I have lots of apps not from the Google Play Store. My Kindle HDX doesn't even have access to Google Play, so all the apps on it are from Amazon/Humble Bundle. They're just blown up phone apps for the most part.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by devcpp on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:53AM
(#7333978)
The only occurrences of the the word "Android" are in that paragraph:
>More apps than Android: Apple's App Store has more than 425,000 apps. The Android Market has 200,000. In May, Google (GOOG) announced its 4.5 billionth app download, compared with Apple's 15 billion as of July 7.
Where do you read that iOS users were paying more than Android users in that article?
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by gress on Monday March 03, 2014 @11:19AM
(#7334549)
The vast majority of these devices are not being bought for apps, or even the browser. They are being sold as TV replacements for watching streaming video in Asia.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by bookwormAT on Friday March 07, 2014 @06:43PM
(#7363489)
I'm surprised people find this still an issue. Almost all of the popular apps in the store seem to scale great on large displays these days. Notable exceptions are the official apps from Facebook & Twitter.
I just checked my tablet: Pocket Casts, Flipboard,Kindle, Pocket, Cal, Timely, Expedia, Skype, Imdb, Hacker News 2, Pinterest, Flow,... All have special layouts for large screens.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by habosa on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:54AM
(#7334381)
I think the lack of compelling tablet-only apps has contributed to the popularity of the 7" tablet form factor. Since we mostly use our tablets like oversized phones without voice capacity, they might as well be comfortable to use in portrait and have a phone-like experience.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by k-mcgrady on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:55AM
(#7333065)
Surprised this hadn't already happened as I'm sure Android tablets are much more popular in a lot of markets where price is the most important consideration. Apple really doesn't cater to that at all.
What's the usage numbers like though. That seems to be the one Apple always bring out when discussing the iPhone (fewer sales but much more web browsing than Android). I know a family member who had an iPad and used it all the time. For his next tablet he got an Android tablet and he doesn't use it at all. Why? No good apps. Android still lacks massively in quality tablet apps.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by Touche on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:43AM
(#7333370)
> What's the usage numbers like though. That seems to be the one Apple always bring out when discussing the iPhone
They use whatever number is to their advantage. First it was marketshare, then it was app count, "usage" is simply the newest number they use. Suffice to say, they're going to lose that one too. But I'm sure iOS will always have some advantage so they'll always have some number that's the one true indicator of value.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by k-mcgrady on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:32AM
(#7333186)
The stats I'm referring to are ones the Apple always mention at events. Although there are many more Android phones sold than iPhones when you look at browser usage share iPhone is higher than Android. Their point seems to be that a lot of Android phones are used solely as phones and not as smartphones.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by Touche on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:51AM
(#7333401)
Marketshare measures devices sold. So while Android has overtaken iPad in sales, there are still more total iPads in the world. Browser usage is always going to lag behind sales for years. Go look at browser marketshare charts and notice Safari on the slow decline.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by rikkus on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:02AM
(#7333091)
I like good apps, and would consider using something with iOS, but I haven't seen anything on iOS that is missing or not-as-good on Android. Could you give some example apps? It would be great to hear about some I/we are missing out on. I'm not just asking so I can say 'Hey Android has this already' - I'm genuinely interested in good apps!
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by jkaljundi on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:24AM
(#7333166)
Many aviation, flight planning and aviation navigation maps are much better on iOS and there is much better choice for iOS. The same for many magazines.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by k-mcgrady on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:00AM
(#7333248)
If you're a musician Garageband and Amplitube are both killer and there is now comparison on Android (one of the main things preventing me from switching to Android). It's a niche but a pretty large one. iMovie is something that isn't niche - a lot of people are going to find that very useful for putting together quick videos and photo montages to email to friends.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by k-mcgrady on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:05AM
(#7333463)
>> "Windows shipped a movie maker for years that no one used"
Because it was terrible. Also there was no easy way to share videos. Look at how many videos are uploaded to YouTube everyday. A lot of people will get value form iMovie.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by simonh on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:39AM
(#7333604)
Oh boy was that bad. It couldn't write DVDs back when that was THE thing you wanted a video editor to do, and it only supported windows-only codecs. You couldn't even upload the videos to Youtube, when that became The thing you wanted to do with video, due to the proprietary-only codec support. This is one of the three main reasons I switched to Mac back in 2007. One was viruses, another was Time machine and the third was video as I had recently had kids. The closest thing to iMove on a PC back then cost IIRC about $1,000.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by IBM on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:03AM
(#7333261)
Android is gaining market share because of extremely low-end devices that are inexpensive. So far that hasn't been enough to convince developers to stop being iOS first, and especially not for tablets.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by MrScruff on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:51AM
(#7333403)
Everyone has their own niche though. This is what Apple suffered from in the 90s - the long tail. Whatever you wanted to do, there was a Windows application that did it.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by corresation on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:45AM
(#7333378)
I know a family member who had an iPad and used it all the time. For his next tablet he got an Android tablet and he doesn't use it at all.
In my household we have two Nexus 7s and an iPad. The iPad is absolutely loaded with apps.
My children argue over who has to take the iPad, as they all prefer the Nexus 7s. The games are identical to their iPad counterparts, YouTube is, apparently, a superior experience (not surprising given Google), Netflix is largely the same, and it has search and a web browser. That encompasses all of their computing world.
Oh and it has a couple of gaming system emulators. Those aren't even possible on iOS.
It isn't just children. To many adults, a tablet is a web, email and media device. I read the news on news websites, not by using apps for each provider. I use the web browser. etc.
The long tail isn't as big of a difference as it is so often held out to be. Paper is a neat app....but I haven't touched it in probably a year. The same for Garageband -- a week of lots of use, then forgotten. I've never made a movie on a tablet. Those all faded away.
Personally I still prefer the iPad when I grab something for browsing, and given that it has the TMNGo app that isn't available for Android yet, but it just isn't that huge of a chasm.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by RyanZAG on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:52AM
(#7333057)
So the Apple fans who were telling us how poor the Android tablet experience is and that Android only beats iOS on phones because of carrier bundling appear to have been incorrect yet again. Makes for very good proof that an open ecosystem is always going to beat out a closed one in the long run.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by anon1385 on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:07AM
(#7333106)
I wonder how many of those tablets will ever get updates to fix the remote vulnerabilities that have have been out in the wild for nearly 100 weeks now[1]. Do people buying new tablets today realise that they are remotely exploitable because they come with ancient versions of Android and will probably never be patched?[2]
This kind of thing just shows how utterly empty and useless marketing buzzwords like 'open' are.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by lubos on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:01AM
(#7333088)
So if open ecosystem is always going to beat a closed one, why didn't Discourse beat Facebook? Why didn't App.net beat Twitter? Why didn't Linux beat Windows on desktops?
I'm happy for Android but saying that Android is winning only because it's "more" open is just non-sense.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by josteink on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:27AM
(#7333554)
In that case they lost because their conceptual model was so complex that even a reasonably technical user trying to sign up would give up trying to get an account, trying to figure out what a "hub" was and how you would get one.
And I mean that on top of network effect. And the fact that it was mismanaged. And that it was mostly vapour-ware.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by nl on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:22AM
(#7333154)
why didn't Discourse beat Facebook? Why didn't App.net beat Twitter? Why didn't Linux beat Windows on desktops?
I've never heard of Discourse.
App.net didn't beat Twitter because of network effects. And it costs more.
Windows has a very open ecosystem. It's not open source.
Arguably the parent has missed the difference between open source and open ecosystem. The iPad has a moderately open ecosystem too - though less open than Android (which in some ways is less open than Windows since it has a centralised distribution method).
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by k-mcgrady on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:56AM
(#7333072)
From my comment on this thread:
"I know a family member who had an iPad and used it all the time. For his next tablet he got an Android tablet and he doesn't use it at all. Why? No good apps."
Android tablets are good when cost is a major consideration but if you can afford to spend an extra $100/200 I believe you'll get more value from an iPad still.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by RyanZAG on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:02AM
(#7333090)
So the millions of people buying Android tablets just throw their money away and never use them? Seems a bit of a stretch. Generally if a product isn't useful then people don't buy it, regardless of the price. Why doesn't your family member return the tablet if it's useless?
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by k-mcgrady on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:29AM
(#7333179)
>> So the millions of people buying Android tablets just throw their money away and never use them? Seems a bit of a stretch.
I didn't say that at all. From my personal experience it seems they get less value from them. They are certainly useful devices but I think the extra money an iPad costs provides more value than the added expense.
>> Why doesn't your family member return the tablet if it's useless?
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by Touche on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:26AM
(#7333549)
I get the opposite impression. Because the iPad doesn't have access to the harddrive it's hard to use it outside of silo-ed app experiences. I have a catalog of cbr/cbz comic books and it's simple too much work to get them on the iPad. On the Nexus 7 I simple copy them over the network using File Explorer.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by evilduck on Monday March 03, 2014 @11:17AM
(#7334529)
iOS apps that have file management needs work fundamentally the same as a regular file explorer: connect to iTunes, select your device, click the 'Apps' tab, scroll down to 'File Sharing', select your destination app, drag and drop files, sync. You can even do this over wifi. I guess the Android advantage is you can initiate this transfer from the device instead of the computer, but that's not really "too much work" IMO.
Apps that register for opening certain file types will also be available in 'Open in' dialogs of other apps (if the developers of both apps added the same file extension) so it's easy to move files between apps. Silos for app files only exist if the developer is lazy or ignorant, the platform itself has supported file sharing between apps for years.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by Touche on Monday March 03, 2014 @01:43PM
(#7335503)
> iOS apps that have file management needs work fundamentally the same as a regular file explorer: connect to iTunes,
Wait, what? Connecting to iTunes is not part of any regular file explorer workflow.
> I guess the Android advantage is you can initiate this transfer from the device instead of the computer, but that's not really "too much work" IMO.
Wow, can't disagree more. That's an enormous difference. one is a computer and one is a periphery. Peripheries are fine, some people can live with just a periphery, but if you have real file management needs like the one I pointed to above, a periphery won't cut it. It's entirely too inconvenient to have to dig out the computer that has iTunes installed (for me it's 1 of 4 laptops in my house), get the files onto that computer (probably over the network) and then transfer them onto the device.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by evilduck on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:16PM
(#7336534)
What's the tangible difference between opening iTunes and opening a file explorer app? Nothing. Both scenarios of file management require opening a program and moving files around. The name of the program is rather irrelevant. Even navigating to the device/app is maybe one more click than finding your phone's storage over a network share or when physically connected.
And you've only got to physically connect to iTunes once, after that you can just upload files over local wifi. You've constructed yourself a scenario where iOS is the loser for you, but for anyone with a Windows or Mac computer (what, 97% of the world?), "finding the iTunes computer" is not a difficult task.
How about we call a molehill a molehill instead of a mountain?
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by Touche on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:25PM
(#7336597)
If I have to copy a large file (movies can be 10gb) to a computer first and then copy to it to the iPad, that is not a molehill, that's an major inconvenience, and a major time-sink. Of course, I fundamentally disagree that having to use a computer to get data onto another computer is a small inconvenience.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by Touche on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @06:36PM
(#7344052)
I said from the beginning that transferring data to a computer before you transfer it to another computer is wasteful and inconvenient. Apparently when I use an example that you can't dispute you call this "moving the goalposts".
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by GFischer on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:52AM
(#7333230)
I have an iPad, and my gf has a Google Nexus 7. We live in Uruguay, and at least for us, it makes way more sense to have an Android tablet than an Apple tablet, moastly because a lot more things are paid on the iPad, and most developers target Android first in my country because it has 90% market share. So YMMV. We also have Android phones. I think the user experience is good enough on both OS, and I'll probably buy Android for my next tablet (I got really frustrated by the iPad's limitations). Apple does have the everything-integrated experience if you buy only Apple (iMac, iPhone and iPad), but only affluent people can afford that, and I wouldn't want it even if I could afford it (which I can't).
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by NicoJuicy on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:43PM
(#7335943)
I'm from Belgium and we're not willing to buy everything on Apple.
Come on, the newest Apple computer costs like 3000 $ . Anyone who wants it, is willing to throw out cash.
Even a friend of mine (who is a serieus Apple fan), is going to buy a Windows pc (but he'll keep his iPhone). I suspect that he is going to get frustrated by the frustrating experience that Apple brings on other platforms.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by DCKing on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:31AM
(#7333184)
A platform wins because of bandwagon effect. This is why Windows won on the desktop, Facebook won and now Android has won. Releasing an open system at the right time (as Google did) can cause major bandwagon effect, but is a contributing factor and not a true necessity.
I think if Google sold Android like Microsoft does Windows it still would have won (albeit somewhat more slowly). Apple always limits its bandwagon effect by limiting the availability of its platform to a rather small collection of devices. There's simply much more, and much cheaper choice of Android devices than there is with iOS. That defines what platforms wins, not the source code license or the details of their application policy.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by hrktb on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:46AM
(#7333634)
Not really caring about what the fans are saying, but the OP is about market share, and you match it with an opinion about user experience.
That doesn't make much sense as the two concepts are not directly correlated. Good user experience doesn't guarantee market share nor does market share point at good experience.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by cclogg on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:55AM
(#7333068)
Darn, the article didn't say anything about which countries caused the growth. It makes it hard to read into what this actually means depending on where you are. Eg http://www.zdnet.com/windows-phone-makes-gains-in-europe-but... shows that certain countries like China can skew total market share towards Android vs Japan skewing towards iOS (and US about 50-50).
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by jebus989 on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:08AM
(#7333470)
This is kinda like comparing coke with "carbonated orange drinks". The fact that the latter outsell the former seems obvious but unimpressive, as a fairer comparison (Coke vs. Fanta / product line vs. product line rather than OS) reveals its continued market dominance.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by 6thSigma on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:35AM
(#7334252)
There isn't an iPad equivelant for Android though. All of the Android tablets share an ecosystem and all of the iOS tablets share an ecosystem; that's where the link is. Perhaps only counting tablets with Android 4.0 and above would be a better comparison.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by antimagic on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:51AM
(#7334355)
Sure, maybe. Perhaps you'd like to show us a "snapshot" of where you think the goalposts were before they started moving. You know, something along the lines of multiple pro-Apple pundits saying "The iPad will win the tablet wars, maintaining majority marketshare into the indefinate future".
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by chrisBob on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:11AM
(#7333488)
I think a more telling number is where the money is. How much does Apple make from iPad sales vs all of the Android tablet profits. How much is spent in the app stores?
As a developer I will stick with iOS until the profits flip.
I couldn't find updated numbers, but in 2012 Apple sold slightly fewer phones, but people still spent 4x as much in the iOS app store.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by habosa on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:58AM
(#7334412)
I'd like to know how many "good" Android tablets are selling, and how much of this is the fact that Android has total dominance on the low end (< $99) market. Specifically, I'd like to see market share for Android devices with Android 4.0+, 1GB RAM, and a decent multicore processor. I'm a happy Nexus 7 owner myself, but there are a lot of people with Android tablets that are total garbage.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by ef47d35620c1 on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:37AM
(#7333338)
Watching Android versus iWhatever is like watching Windows versus Macintosh all over again. How soon will they have 97% of the market is now the question.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by simonh on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:43AM
(#7333622)
That's all very well, except that Windows doesn't have 97% of the market. In fact for consumer PCs over $1,000 the Mac actually dominates, as it does for profits in the PC industry overall and has done for quite some time.
If iOS ever does end up in the same position against Android as the Mac does against the PC, Apple will be doing very nicely thank you very much.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by akulbe on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:26AM
(#7334184)
Yes, this is subjective... I realize that, so here's my opinionated response.
More market share != winning.
Applications for Android tablets largely still suck.
Applications for iPad, are better quality in my experience - and that by a WIDE margin.
Now, here's the bias disclaimer. I have been an avid Mac user in the past, and there are many things I prefer about that platform, in terms of development and productivity (i.e. just getting stuff DONE)
HOWEVER - I am currently all-Linux, except for the iPad Air.
I use the following devices:
iPad Air
Nexus 5 (this is my primary "phone" now, having switched from an iPhone 5)
Nexus 7 2013 wifi.
Yes, that's some extra info... I just wanted to convey the fact that I'm giving Android a fair shake. If you want to ask me what I think of the N5, I'd be happy to share, but that's off-topic here. :)
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by akulbe on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:29AM
(#7334216)
And the "more market share != winning" comment...
let's add an example of that... Microsoft.
Yes, they rule in the desktop space. So what? They haven't done anything to innovate in a LONG time.
They lost the mobile market.
They seem to be grasping for straws, and largely trying to gain revenue by strong-arm bully tactics with patent licensing agreements that are likely almost all FUD.
CAN they innovate? Perhaps. It's been a long time since they have.
For all you MS-lovers who will tout the dominant market share, and stock market profits... let me ask you this.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by gte910h on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:46AM
(#7333941)
The devices without cell equipment are certainly NOT included in the phones comparisons. Aka, iPod Touches and Samsung 5" non-Phone tablets
Why would you assume they're also excluded by tablets?
None of the sites are showing any real breakdowns to verify this, but the Apple tablet numbers are iPad numbers, not iPad + iPod Touch which it should be if small form factor, non cell tablets are considered in this.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by BugBrother on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:32AM
(#7333325)
I'm an iPad user in Romania, right now.
The salaries are really low here, most sales seem to be 100-200 Euro cheap Androids.
The Androids are often used for specific applications/niches (e.g. in taxis and by poor students). If buyers had money, they'd at least get Androids with better screens.
I believe the market for paid Android apps here is more or less nil.
(I hope the cheap Androids aren't used for banking etc, considering the lack of security updates.)
In short -- these cheap Androids aren't really competing with iPads. People just can't afford better (or they are used for a specific application 20 minutes a day).
All that said, I still would consider to switch from iOS if I could get better Emacs support with external keyboard than a terminal (which work on iOS now).
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by higherpurpose on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:04AM
(#7333453)
That's like saying cheap Windows PC's didn't really compete with $2000 Macs. Cheap PCs is what helped Microsoft gain its monopoly power, and what put Apple in a niche position.
This is a strength of Android - that it can be on inexpensive devices for the billions of potential users out there.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by interpol_p on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:42AM
(#7333914)
I don't think Apple minds being in a niche position.
Remember their original goal for the iPhone? Capture one percent of the market. Their products have always catered to a niche, only with the iPod did they ever start seeing mainstream popularity.
I don't think it would hurt Apple to fall back to being a niche in the current computing landscape — they are just amassing money otherwise — their company does not seem designed to actually grow with the money they earn.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by mcphage on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:03AM
(#7334029)
> This is a strength of Android - that it can be on inexpensive devices
iOS can be on inexpensive devices, too; Apple just chooses not to. Now, maybe that's a good decision, and maybe it's not—but it's a decision that they're making, not a corner they've been backed into.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta...
by BugBrother on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:17AM
(#7333515)
That analogy would work better if the cheap Androids sold software, too. And were nice to use with those apps.
But maybe ads to people without money will be enough to finance software? I think before that happens, good cheap screens (maybe not IPS) and lowering electronic prices will push the prices for usable xPAd down anyway -- what seems to happen for phones now. Then everything in the xPad market changes (just don't ask me how).
I am on my third Android tablet (a Kindle Fire HDX). My first Android tablet was the first Samsung 7" tablet that came out with Gingerbread on it, back in like 2010. I got a free iPad from my job a few years ago and gave that to my daughter and have upgraded her iPad since. She has a ton of children apps for her, that she has grown up with, and learned from. There are near no apps for my Android tablet this many years in. Personally I never want an iOS device, I just don't like the operating system, but I would really like at least some apps for Android. These marketshare numbers don't seem to have helped at all.
That put off developers from making tablet apps, for a long, long time. And because of that it also had the side effect of affecting Android tablet sales, which in turn gave Android developers even fewer reasons to make tablet apps for Android.
I mean, can you believe it that only late last year Google decided to show users "tablet apps" by default when using a tablet? They finally did something to encourage developers to optimize their apps for tablets.
But I don't think it's enough. Normally, I don't think Google should've done this, but they are so late in the tablet app game now, that I think they should start forcing developers to optimize their apps for tablets, too, or have their apps kicked out of the store within a year.
I think it's a very reasonable time-frame, and it's not like they have to rewrite their apps from scratch to do it. If they did that, I think within 6 months we'd see Android tablet apps for everything.
Something else that I'd like them to do: kick out apps from the "Featured" or "Editor's Choice" that don't adhere to the Android style guidelines. You'd think that Google would want at least the hand-picked apps to be "made for Android", no? Do that, and watch how the top popular apps scramble to adhere to Google's standards.
This wasn't the reason, though. The reason is and was because on Android it is really quite easy to adapt to multiple screen sizes, and show different views based on screen size.
> Something else that I'd like them to do: kick out apps from the "Featured" or "Editor's Choice" that don't adhere to the Android style guidelines.
Totally agree. Google hasn't done enough to strongly encourage companies to make quality apps. Though these days when I see an application I consider to be poor in quality on Android I tend to find a similarly poor in quality app on iOS from the same company.
Specific distributions for various sized screens is an artifact of iOS, not a design idiom on Android.
https://developer.android.com/guide/practices/tablets-and-ha...
However there's this big one that comes with them all called a browser. It does all sorts.
The only apps that have an advantage over this app are the ones that have at least partially disconnected model i.e email, offline navigation, authoring or creative stuff and to a degree games.
Then again I'd rather have a real keyboard to write emails, a smaller device for my offline navigation and a bigger screen for authoring and creative stuff.
So basically, it's a browsing, email and games machine. And a crap one at that.
For reference I own a laptop and a smartphone. The mid ground seems pointless to me. Tablets are relegated to children's entertainment and they'd rather use the Xbox for that to be fair as Minecraft is better with real controls and it doesn't spam the hell out of you by trying to install apps via adtrack.king.com every two minutes.
For you. Important distinction, just because you specifically haven't found a use doesn't mean others haven't. I know people who code on them, or do some spreadsheet twiddling, or (yes, slowly) write documents on them. For them a tablet is the right amount of compromises.
A 30 second search on YouTube reveals a plethora of digital artists, another might reveal a similar amount of digital musicians. Your use case isn't their use case.
* Web (Chrome)
* Email (Gmail)
* Movies/TV shows (YouTube & Netflix)
* Reading (Kindle & Pocket)
* Music (Spotify & YouTube)
Edit: I forgot about Mango[0], a manga reader. This is one I have to sideload, since Mango essentially provides a native frontend to websites that host fan translations (Japanese to English) of copyrighted content. I can imagine that such an app can't be obtained on iOS without jailbreaking.
0: http://mango.leetsoft.net/
There's actually a tweet from Zac Bertschy, Executive Editor of Anime News Network that complained about how many are available on iTunes:
https://twitter.com/ANNZac/status/202096701534765056
I've had two Android tablets (Asus Transofrmer TF101 and then a Nexus 7) ... Nexus admittedly a much better experience but I use my iPad mini so much more than both of those tablets put together. Higher quality apps and better accessory/device ecosystem provide for a superior overall experience.
Overall quite disappointing
[1]: http://www.tomshardware.com/news/Nexus-7-eMMC-controller-fst... [2]: https://plus.google.com/+AndrewDodd/posts/2eEd95oN1ZP
Personally, despite you just needing to install an APK, I don't know a single Android-user running anything not installed from the Play store.
Obviously the XDA crowd is different, but they are a clear minority, and I know almost nobody IRL who goes that route.
>More apps than Android: Apple's App Store has more than 425,000 apps. The Android Market has 200,000. In May, Google (GOOG) announced its 4.5 billionth app download, compared with Apple's 15 billion as of July 7.
Where do you read that iOS users were paying more than Android users in that article?
Also, Android devices that are are not tablets are counted in the statistics: http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/11/18/android-based-tv-s...
I just checked my tablet: Pocket Casts, Flipboard,Kindle, Pocket, Cal, Timely, Expedia, Skype, Imdb, Hacker News 2, Pinterest, Flow,... All have special layouts for large screens.
What's the usage numbers like though. That seems to be the one Apple always bring out when discussing the iPhone (fewer sales but much more web browsing than Android). I know a family member who had an iPad and used it all the time. For his next tablet he got an Android tablet and he doesn't use it at all. Why? No good apps. Android still lacks massively in quality tablet apps.
They use whatever number is to their advantage. First it was marketshare, then it was app count, "usage" is simply the newest number they use. Suffice to say, they're going to lose that one too. But I'm sure iOS will always have some advantage so they'll always have some number that's the one true indicator of value.
Weird... The browsing experience is very good on Android.
But then again, my mom uses an Android tablet all the time and my aunt doesn't use her iPad.
Whats your conclusion about that? :-)
But we have a saying in Dutch: "Wij van Wc-eend adviseren... Wc-eend"
Translation: "We from ToiletDuck advice... ToiletDuck" (it was a known commercial for a toilet cleaning product)
I'm sure i can find a statistic that says that Employees with an iPad are less productive then those with an Android tablet :)
Statistics are like bikinis. What they reveal is suggestive, but what they conceal is vital. ~Aaron Levenstein
- Garageband
- Amplitube
- Paper by FiftyThree
- iMovie
- Penultimate
- Sky Guide
Because it was terrible. Also there was no easy way to share videos. Look at how many videos are uploaded to YouTube everyday. A lot of people will get value form iMovie.
In my household we have two Nexus 7s and an iPad. The iPad is absolutely loaded with apps.
My children argue over who has to take the iPad, as they all prefer the Nexus 7s. The games are identical to their iPad counterparts, YouTube is, apparently, a superior experience (not surprising given Google), Netflix is largely the same, and it has search and a web browser. That encompasses all of their computing world.
Oh and it has a couple of gaming system emulators. Those aren't even possible on iOS.
It isn't just children. To many adults, a tablet is a web, email and media device. I read the news on news websites, not by using apps for each provider. I use the web browser. etc.
The long tail isn't as big of a difference as it is so often held out to be. Paper is a neat app....but I haven't touched it in probably a year. The same for Garageband -- a week of lots of use, then forgotten. I've never made a movie on a tablet. Those all faded away.
Personally I still prefer the iPad when I grab something for browsing, and given that it has the TMNGo app that isn't available for Android yet, but it just isn't that huge of a chasm.
This kind of thing just shows how utterly empty and useless marketing buzzwords like 'open' are.
[1] http://arstechnica.com/security/2014/02/e-z-2-use-attack-cod...
[2] http://www.walmart.com/search/search-ng.do?search_query=andr...
I'm happy for Android but saying that Android is winning only because it's "more" open is just non-sense.
Because App.net cost money ($50 per head/year iirc) and twitter despite being a closed service was free (as in beer).
App.net didn't have a chance.
a) they're aiming more for phpBB et al b) they launched a year ago
And I mean that on top of network effect. And the fact that it was mismanaged. And that it was mostly vapour-ware.
It hardly had a chance.
I've never heard of Discourse.
App.net didn't beat Twitter because of network effects. And it costs more.
Windows has a very open ecosystem. It's not open source.
Arguably the parent has missed the difference between open source and open ecosystem. The iPad has a moderately open ecosystem too - though less open than Android (which in some ways is less open than Windows since it has a centralised distribution method).
Did you mean Diaspora? Also, those are not "ecosystems".
"I know a family member who had an iPad and used it all the time. For his next tablet he got an Android tablet and he doesn't use it at all. Why? No good apps."
Android tablets are good when cost is a major consideration but if you can afford to spend an extra $100/200 I believe you'll get more value from an iPad still.
I didn't say that at all. From my personal experience it seems they get less value from them. They are certainly useful devices but I think the extra money an iPad costs provides more value than the added expense.
>> Why doesn't your family member return the tablet if it's useless?
He's trying to sell it.
Apps that register for opening certain file types will also be available in 'Open in' dialogs of other apps (if the developers of both apps added the same file extension) so it's easy to move files between apps. Silos for app files only exist if the developer is lazy or ignorant, the platform itself has supported file sharing between apps for years.
Wait, what? Connecting to iTunes is not part of any regular file explorer workflow.
> I guess the Android advantage is you can initiate this transfer from the device instead of the computer, but that's not really "too much work" IMO.
Wow, can't disagree more. That's an enormous difference. one is a computer and one is a periphery. Peripheries are fine, some people can live with just a periphery, but if you have real file management needs like the one I pointed to above, a periphery won't cut it. It's entirely too inconvenient to have to dig out the computer that has iTunes installed (for me it's 1 of 4 laptops in my house), get the files onto that computer (probably over the network) and then transfer them onto the device.
And you've only got to physically connect to iTunes once, after that you can just upload files over local wifi. You've constructed yourself a scenario where iOS is the loser for you, but for anyone with a Windows or Mac computer (what, 97% of the world?), "finding the iTunes computer" is not a difficult task.
How about we call a molehill a molehill instead of a mountain?
Come on, the newest Apple computer costs like 3000 $ . Anyone who wants it, is willing to throw out cash.
Even a friend of mine (who is a serieus Apple fan), is going to buy a Windows pc (but he'll keep his iPhone). I suspect that he is going to get frustrated by the frustrating experience that Apple brings on other platforms.
I think if Google sold Android like Microsoft does Windows it still would have won (albeit somewhat more slowly). Apple always limits its bandwagon effect by limiting the availability of its platform to a rather small collection of devices. There's simply much more, and much cheaper choice of Android devices than there is with iOS. That defines what platforms wins, not the source code license or the details of their application policy.
That doesn't make much sense as the two concepts are not directly correlated. Good user experience doesn't guarantee market share nor does market share point at good experience.
Maybe it'll encourage better tablet apps for Android, which is still obviously lagging in this area.
edit already two replies providing nice examples.
Also, because android is open, the numbers are inflated: http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/11/18/android-based-tv-s...
I'm thinking the quote probably doen't exist.
As a developer I will stick with iOS until the profits flip.
I couldn't find updated numbers, but in 2012 Apple sold slightly fewer phones, but people still spent 4x as much in the iOS app store.
http://techland.time.com/2013/04/16/ios-vs-android/
Why should anyone apart from Apple care about this?
Unless ofcourse you're merely interested in finding out if you're getting ripped of and by how much?
If iOS ever does end up in the same position against Android as the Mac does against the PC, Apple will be doing very nicely thank you very much.
More market share != winning.
Applications for Android tablets largely still suck. Applications for iPad, are better quality in my experience - and that by a WIDE margin.
Now, here's the bias disclaimer. I have been an avid Mac user in the past, and there are many things I prefer about that platform, in terms of development and productivity (i.e. just getting stuff DONE)
HOWEVER - I am currently all-Linux, except for the iPad Air.
I use the following devices:
iPad Air Nexus 5 (this is my primary "phone" now, having switched from an iPhone 5) Nexus 7 2013 wifi.
Yes, that's some extra info... I just wanted to convey the fact that I'm giving Android a fair shake. If you want to ask me what I think of the N5, I'd be happy to share, but that's off-topic here. :)
let's add an example of that... Microsoft.
Yes, they rule in the desktop space. So what? They haven't done anything to innovate in a LONG time.
They lost the mobile market.
They seem to be grasping for straws, and largely trying to gain revenue by strong-arm bully tactics with patent licensing agreements that are likely almost all FUD.
CAN they innovate? Perhaps. It's been a long time since they have.
For all you MS-lovers who will tout the dominant market share, and stock market profits... let me ask you this.
If MS was doing SO good... why is Ballmer out? :)
</opinion>
I'd love to see this confirmed or disproved.
Why would you assume they're also excluded by tablets?
None of the sites are showing any real breakdowns to verify this, but the Apple tablet numbers are iPad numbers, not iPad + iPod Touch which it should be if small form factor, non cell tablets are considered in this.
The salaries are really low here, most sales seem to be 100-200 Euro cheap Androids.
The Androids are often used for specific applications/niches (e.g. in taxis and by poor students). If buyers had money, they'd at least get Androids with better screens.
I believe the market for paid Android apps here is more or less nil.
(I hope the cheap Androids aren't used for banking etc, considering the lack of security updates.)
In short -- these cheap Androids aren't really competing with iPads. People just can't afford better (or they are used for a specific application 20 minutes a day).
All that said, I still would consider to switch from iOS if I could get better Emacs support with external keyboard than a terminal (which work on iOS now).
This is a strength of Android - that it can be on inexpensive devices for the billions of potential users out there.
Remember their original goal for the iPhone? Capture one percent of the market. Their products have always catered to a niche, only with the iPod did they ever start seeing mainstream popularity.
I don't think it would hurt Apple to fall back to being a niche in the current computing landscape — they are just amassing money otherwise — their company does not seem designed to actually grow with the money they earn.
iOS can be on inexpensive devices, too; Apple just chooses not to. Now, maybe that's a good decision, and maybe it's not—but it's a decision that they're making, not a corner they've been backed into.
But maybe ads to people without money will be enough to finance software? I think before that happens, good cheap screens (maybe not IPS) and lowering electronic prices will push the prices for usable xPAd down anyway -- what seems to happen for phones now. Then everything in the xPad market changes (just don't ask me how).