News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta... by lubos on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:01AM (#7333088)
So if open ecosystem is always going to beat a closed one, why didn't Discourse beat Facebook? Why didn't App.net beat Twitter? Why didn't Linux beat Windows on desktops?

I'm happy for Android but saying that Android is winning only because it's "more" open is just non-sense.

Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta... by josteink on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:15AM (#7333507)
> Why didn't App.net beat Twitter?

Because App.net cost money ($50 per head/year iirc) and twitter despite being a closed service was free (as in beer).

App.net didn't have a chance.

Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta... by quarterto on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:04AM (#7333099)
> why didn't Discourse beat Facebook?

a) they're aiming more for phpBB et al b) they launched a year ago

Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta... by veeti on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:33AM (#7333194)
He probably meant Diaspora.
Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta... by josteink on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:27AM (#7333554)
In that case they lost because their conceptual model was so complex that even a reasonably technical user trying to sign up would give up trying to get an account, trying to figure out what a "hub" was and how you would get one.

And I mean that on top of network effect. And the fact that it was mismanaged. And that it was mostly vapour-ware.

It hardly had a chance.

Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta... by nl on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:22AM (#7333154)
why didn't Discourse beat Facebook? Why didn't App.net beat Twitter? Why didn't Linux beat Windows on desktops?

I've never heard of Discourse.

App.net didn't beat Twitter because of network effects. And it costs more.

Windows has a very open ecosystem. It's not open source.

Arguably the parent has missed the difference between open source and open ecosystem. The iPad has a moderately open ecosystem too - though less open than Android (which in some ways is less open than Windows since it has a centralised distribution method).

Re:Android Grabs Top Spot From iPad With 62% Share of the Ta... by Grue3 on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:46AM (#7333633)
>why didn't Discourse beat Facebook

Did you mean Diaspora? Also, those are not "ecosystems".